r/religion • • Jan 04 '22

Being atheist because you "believe in science" is a ridiculous argument

0 Upvotes

I always thought that people who claim that they are atheist because they "believe in science", lack the most basic understanding of what science is.

Science by definition is "knowledge about or study of the natural world based on facts learned through experiments and observation". Science is ultimately limited by both the senses we possess and the tools we have.

Our eyes are very limited in the spectrum they can see, our noses are extremely limited in the scents they can pick, our ears limited to the waves they can hear. We try to compensate for our limited senses by making tools that can expand our capabilities, but at the end of the day, those very tools are limited by our current knowledge and very limited natural resources.

We try to formulate theories that make the most sense to us at that moment of time, using the tools and accumulated knowledge we have. These theories are not "scientific facts", they are just us trying our best to make sense of what we can observe of our natural surroundings. Theories come and go, they get replaced by newer, better theories.

There is no absolute truths to be found in the sciences, so to argue that science can answer the fundamental questions about our existence and purpose in life is a pretty ridiculous claim.


r/religion • • Apr 14 '22

Why do so many Christians lately seem to have a problem with transgender people, considering the prominent transgender figures in the bible and lack of biblical commentary about transgenderism otherwise?

1 Upvotes

First off, I've hunted through the bible. There's nothing calling out transgenderism in it as some kind of sin. ( On the contrary, the gnostic gospels specifically call out a woman becoming a man as being a blessing.) And there's not really any history of it, it seems new.

Further, there's three prominent transgender people in the bible:

Eve - Literally made from a male's rib (meaning male genetics), god makes her female, meaning she's MTF.

Jesus - Literally a virgin birth (meaning only X chromosomes), god makes him male, meaning he's FTM.

God - identifies as male, despite creating life (biologically, a decidedly female trait, also some of the psalms allude to him having female parts), meaning he's FTM or non-binary.

So you'd think trans men & trans women would be seen as a sign of God's favor and blessing if anything, why do so many Christians (especially in the U.S. & UK) seem insistent on ignoring the the bible and spreading bigotry about trans people?

I've asked this question to some before, and they mumbled something about sodomy, but I actually looked it up, and sodomy means specifically "acting like people from Sodom" (as in Sodom & Gommorrah), and I looked up what they did, and what they did was attempt to rape young women and angels.

So, if anything, all the hate they're giving should be directed at rapists. Yet, all this hatred is directed towards trans people.

I'm an ex-christian, but I left Christianity before this wave of anti-transness began. And now, it's about all I hear in the news.

So what gives?

Edit:

As a commenter u/hightidesoldgods pointed out, Matthew 19:12 basically calls out a variant of transgenderism that DID exist back in biblical eras (eunuch-ism basically being the antiquity equivalent to transgender surgery), and that they are specifically blessed by god.

Additionally, as UnlikelySpinach518 pointed out, my description of trangenderism in this post is very archaic and simple. I do understand that transgenderism is much more complex identity topic, involving genetics, epigenetics, culture, presentation, identity, and more. But the full complexity would not be known to the people who wrote the bible; this post was more meeting the bible linguistics where they were, so male -> female and female -> male, for the writing authors of the bible, is enough to qualify for the sake of its text in its time period, but would be considered rude and inadequate by modern standards.


r/religion • • Oct 08 '25

For the Islamophobes

0 Upvotes

Salam everyone, idk if it’s just me but recently I’ve been seeing a growing number of Islamophobia around the world like when something bad happens somewhere everyone assumes it was a Muslim or at least someone with an Islamic background, they act like one Muslim defines the rest of us but when it’s any other religion it’s just a bad egg??? The hypocrisy is crazy

My question is if you don’t like Islam or you don’t like Muslims as a whole why???? You’ve never met all the Muslims in the world it’s like me saying the kkk represents all Christian’s or the idf represents all Jews it makes absolutely zero sense to me why you put yourselves on a pedestal and then throw rocks at us


r/religion • • Oct 11 '21

I'd rather believe in my religion and live with tranquility than disbelieve and live in fear and uncertainty forever...

0 Upvotes

I am a believer and just noticed that religion debates go nowhere.. it's been like that for a long time and maybe will continue forever.

That is my idea. What do you think.

Edit: Thank you. For people advising to use reason and accept conclusions even if they feel uncomfortable... Well that's the point of my assertion : it's better to believe and live comfortably. After all, religions neither can be proved by science nor 100% disproved.


r/religion • • Mar 19 '22

Why do atheists want scientific proof?

0 Upvotes

Like, it’s nonsensical. Scientific proof relies on empirical epistemology and evidence. The ‘spiritual’ is literally defined as: “relating to or affecting the human spirit or soul as opposed to material or physical things”.

That’s the key to the whole thing - it’s not material or physical. Therefore how can anyone give empirical evidence of something that is not physical? It doesn’t make sense

Religious people have all sorts of other proofs, but you couldn’t really call any scientific, other than maybeee a psychological study about religion improving mental health, but that’s a stretch.

There are all sorts of epistemologies (ways of knowing) and types of evidence aside from science/empirical which we use for many other things like art/language/love, so there are many other ways theists may evidence their beliefs. But they’re not empirical.

The essential ‘divide’ comes down to a hunch about this question: ‘is there more than the material world?’ Theists answer yes, atheists answer no. Crucially, as we are material physical beings, we will never know either way (until after we die, maybe). Religions etc spout out from there.

So to atheists on here: please stop asking for material evidence for the immaterial. There is none. Do with that what you will. Make your bet.


r/religion • • Dec 06 '25

Jesus definitely Existed

17 Upvotes

Look if you genuinely think he never existed then you haven’t been Paying attention. Jesus existed and was a real person, personally I worship him and say he’s god but many others believe he’s a prophet/Enlightened Person. There’s genuinely no way that he’s not real because why is there so much documentation about him and also the fact that Many others religions say he existed.


r/religion • • Mar 27 '22

The atheist argument that even if God exist that doesn't suddenly mean their worth worships, does not make sense to me

1 Upvotes

I've heard this argument lately from atheist that even if God were to exist that does not suddenly mean they are worth worshiping and only what the deity claims and demands from them is the leading decision of if they are worth being worship.

what confuses me is that even though this argument is about morality it does not seem to understand it. If a God were to exist wouldn't that make morality objective? So how can you even decide what they're doing is incorrect when only THEY can logically come up with what is wrong or right?

Secondly, even if you decide that you disagree with them, what are you gonna do, fight them? like you just have to recite a couple of important words and try to gain their definition of internal peace or whatever then get sent to a magical world where you're happy forever, why you would let your personal feelings get in the middle of that?

in conclusion, to me this just seems like a dumb argument, if something as powerful as a deity exist then it just makes sense to listen to them.


r/religion • • Feb 04 '24

Why are ex-Muslims so adament on spreading misinformation and false narratives of Islam?

2 Upvotes

I am an ex-Muslim; atheist. I may not be a follower of Islam now, but that doesn't give me the right to belittle and propagate false stuff about the religion. It is just disgusting when people say false stuff with the intention of making the religion and prophet look in a bad light.

No one in their right mind should be like this no matter what religion it is. Unless it's some kind of cult like the Church of the Last Testament, led by Vissarion.

The subreddits, Quora spaces(Ex-Muslims Assemble) and the usual spam-like YouTube comments are so toxic and have no respect for other people as human beings. Just let people believe whatever they want as long as they aren't actively harming others.

All the mainstream religions teach basically the same things: Be kind, respectful and all that good stuff. If someone's behaving inhumanely, blame the person and not the religion. It is so weird to me that these ex-Muslims are not behaving like Islam taught them to be like when they were a part of the religion.

I'm not a Muslim anymore and I will defend Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism or any such religion from getting a bad rep due to the acts of misguided and terrible people. I don't understand why people have to be so toxic with other religions like they're waging some kind of holy war. Let's be real, pretty much every single holy war in history that harms innocents is due to the selfishness and greed of the leader who used religion as an excuse.

So my question is, why can't the ex-Muslims let others believe whatever they want?

I won't have an issue if they argue with actual quotes and verses instead of having to twist them.

Seriously, this subreddit is something else! Since religion is an extremely controversial and touchy subject, I really believed that everything would be chaos and insults would fly everywhere. It's amazing that everyone's so civil. Respect!


r/religion • • Dec 21 '22

Having anger towards Christians is not okay.

5 Upvotes

I see a lot of contempt here, in particular for Catholics. I realize in the Western world that most of you come from Christianity; I myself did. I am empathetic to the pain some of you experienced, but that doesn't make it okay to take that out in others who in most cases have nothing to do with your situation.

Everyone forms their own conclusions about religion, and it's not okay to go after people, especially in bad faith. Hatemongering towards Christians does not solve your problem, and to attack people who in most cases do not hate you. Yes, it's hard to believe but most of these people on the internet are not out to get you.

Of course this won't dissuade some of you, but as a Non-Christian who sees this and is sickened by it, I am going to call it out. Process your insecurities with Christianity and get over it. People are people, humans are humans, and most of us here are not interested in seeing your blood red hatred.


r/religion • • Jan 03 '26

Why do Christians seem to hate Jewish people so much?

0 Upvotes

This may be an incredibly stupid question and forgive me if it is, I myself am an atheist and am not well versed in religion. Why do Christians seem to hate Jewish people so much? I've never understood why Jewish people get so much hate in general. From my understanding, it is an abrahamic religion similar to Christianity (in the essence that they believe in god and some form of prophet). Since they seem so similar, why do Christians hate them so much? I just don't understand why they get so much hate. Forgive me if this seems like a dumb question.


r/religion • • Nov 02 '25

This is how high level of modesty look like in different Religions, But why always Islam is criticized?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/religion • • Aug 22 '21

How can it be the case that there is no evidence for the existence of God or gods when atheists often appeal to polytheistic gods to resist apologetic arguments?

8 Upvotes

If your counter to “God caused the universe” is “What about the Greek Pantheon, or the Flying Spaghetti Monster?”, that’s not saying that the universe isn’t evidence for a deity. That’s saying it doesn’t tell you which deity. It can still be evidence for a deity.

It’s like, you can have evidence that a thief stole something, without it also telling you who the thief is.


r/religion • • Jun 06 '24

Why is YHWH so evil?

0 Upvotes

The obvious answer is that Hashem is from the semitic pantheon which is all kinds of fucked up, but I'd like to get a theologian perspective on this. He himself is cruel, jealous, merciless and downright psychotic but he would condemn any creation of his who would act that way.

How do theologists explain the most depraved acts YHWH has committed in the bible? Do Judaeo-Christian religions worship him out of fear? Is it in a similar way people worship Genghis Khan, like yeah he raped, pillaged and killed 10s of millions but he did it for a greater good?

I mean no disrespect, but YHWH cruelty has always bothered me.


r/religion • • Mar 08 '24

AMA I am a Male Satanic witch, AMA!

0 Upvotes

I began to study the art of grey witchcraft a little over a year ago and since then my life has been powerful. Feel free to ask any questions you want about the witchcraft or satanic beliefs and I’ll answer to the best of my abilities!


r/religion • • Feb 10 '25

Why do many see Christianity as so unappealing? I would love all points of view!

0 Upvotes

I have heard so many people make Christianity sound so horrible! I am a Christian and rejected it for many years, and then came to Jesus about 8 years ago, and it has absolutely changed my life for the better. I just want to know the different perceptions that are out there. It seems that many people do not want eternal salvation and peace with God to be true! I would love to hear everyone's thoughts from all backgrounds, beliefs, or other religions! No judgment on you from me! Thank you!


r/religion • • Jan 13 '22

Jesus existed, and the evidence is overwhelming. No credible historian doubts it.

0 Upvotes

I see a lot of people, particularly atheists claiming Jesus never existed. This should be mocked like being a flat Earther. It flies in the face of the overwhelming concesus of academics and experts, and it ignores the overwhelming evidence.

If you deny Jesus ever existed, you are no different from a flat earther or anti-vaxxer.


r/religion • • Jun 23 '10

Atheists always ask me for "evidence" of God, yet the standard model of cosmology today consists of a universe where 74% of the total mass-energy is comprised of a hypothetical substance that has yet to be observed.

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
4 Upvotes

r/religion • • Sep 20 '21

Why don't you guys take Pastafarianism seriously?

7 Upvotes

I don't get it. I truly believe even though some don't. And when I tell people I'm Pastafarian they don't take me seriously and ask me my 'real' religion. Why??


r/religion • • Apr 25 '11

An Israeli television show starring a scantily-clad woman and a monkey puppet has mocked the Crucifixion of Our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ on Easter Sunday.

Thumbnail
therightperspective.org
1 Upvotes

r/religion • • Jun 01 '22

Since it's the start of Pride Month, what are some examples of religions that are not homophobic, or support LGBT outright? 🏳️‍🌈

8 Upvotes

Alternatively, what are some other interpretations of homophobic religions that remove said hate?

Also, mods, please don't delete because of rule 1. I'm specifically asking for non-bigoted responses, looking for respect and positivity. <3


r/religion • • Oct 07 '21

Anyone else tired of the childish" God is mean" narrative?

0 Upvotes

r/religion • • Oct 17 '25

The Bible does have examples of paedophilia in it

0 Upvotes

One of them being the fact that Rebecca got married to a grown man when she was just 3


r/religion • • May 19 '25

The "Religion is About "Social Control" Delusion

0 Upvotes

The assertion that "religion is about social control," and that it's believers are "the blind leading the blind," is fundamentally false, and ignorant, to put it politely.

Not surprisingly, one who says that is about guaranteed to have heard it from people, and probably adopted the belief without unbiased examination.

This belief not only reflects a malevolent prejudice against religious people, but textbook double-thinking, and sheep mentality. Not to mention it's delusional narcissistic, and hypocritical.

Being non-religious does not make one immune from the human condition, no matter how logical you think you are. You are just as likely to be a sheep as anyone else.

I don't know about many of you, but as a 33 year old American, when I was in school, the religious kids weren't "the cool kids," and the vast majority of students would have told you some minor variations of the exact same thing: "religion is stupid. They're just trying to control you."

Could have been rehearsed.

Does willfully following rules make you a sheep? Are you socially controlled by your athletic team, or chess club? How about your employer, when they tell you who you can and cannot date for all of $15 an hour?

I love the, "the Romans created Christianity" lie. They canonized their version of the Bible after 200 years of persecuting Christians. They did not write the Bible. And I'm just going to block anyone that says otherwise, because theres no time for falsehoods.

One could assert of course that Romans have used the Bible for social control, in that they knew people did genuinely believe in it, but the belief that Romans wrote the Bible is false. So is the belief that religion is about social control.

Tell me, doesnt disagreement imply a lack of control? Are you in control of people who disagree with you? Well you see, in a dumbed down sense, that's why there are many different religions, because people disagree.

I'm sure many people are aware there are three, if not more Abrahamic religions (many more, truly).

Over the last 4,000 years, since the founding of Judaism, Christianity, Islam, Sufism, Sikhism, Bahai, and others, there have been many, many sub-sects, and billions of different, very published beliefs about God.

Here are some very basic Jesus and Islamic teachings that stand contrary to the false notion that religion is about social control...

"The Kingdom of God is in your heart."

"Give it all (currency) to the Romans, it doesn't belong here."

And the Islamic declaration of faith: "There is no god but God."

Speaking of Islam, how many revolts and coups does one have to witness to think maybe religious people aren't willing to be controlled?

Yes, there are always those who attempt to control others, and just as many non-religious who attempt to do so as well. Such as those who try to ban religion and steer people away.

For the out-of-context, scripture literalist haters, and article hunters, spare yourselves. Not everyone has the same opinion or interpretation of how poetic parables are to be applied in modern life.

People exaggerate and speak symbolically now, and they did several thousand years ago. So did F. Scott Fitzgerald, and you don't go around saying he didn't exist. Thank you, we're aware.

Have a good day.

P.S. I appreciate the mods allowing this to stay, and have made further edits, so that the post is more respectful to all readers, including those who unkindly, and kindly (still very annoying) treat believers like braindead sheep.

P.S.S.

To all the commenters that missed this part, reread paragraph 9 and 18. I conceded that religion CAN be used for control closely enough.

Go ahead and keep saying things though and trying to make the points you can. Those were part of the original, very sparsely edited post.

Did you draw a different conclusion? I don't care. That's what was meant by those passages.

People should be aware they're just making themselves look like they can't read because it's clear as day to the other 3,000 people who read it, except the handful of (still altogether respectful posts) commenters who didnt.


r/religion • • Dec 11 '23

I'm really tired of people telling me my religion is a cult every time I mention it

0 Upvotes

I'm Mormon and every time I mention it on the Internet tons of people show up and tell me about how terrible my religion is. Many of those same people would find it rude if I critiqued every little thing about their beliefs. I know I could just not mention it ever but it frustrates me that this is the only option. I hope someday people will be more respectful to us and others going through similar things.


r/religion • • Aug 06 '22

I believe I died and was in hell

1 Upvotes

I am a 39 year old white male living in California. All of my life I have been an athiest even describing myself as a militant athiest. Many times Ive told others how much I hated the whole idea of christianity and still to this day most of the ideas and narritive of christianity make no since to me and I feel historically it has had a negative impact. I also feel that it is immoral to indoctrinate children into a religion before they are old enough to decide for themselves.

On three seperate dates, the most recent being today 08AUG2022, I know without question I have literally experienced being in hell. I would never wish this on anyone, the second experience was by far the most deeply horrific jarring experience that I have no words for.

It was approx 2 weeks ago, i was setting on the left side of my couch, legs crossed, the roku remote in my hand. I had been watching youtube, to be honest I was checking out some track star in her revealing shorts. Instantly something changed. The tv looked different, the picture showed what looked like something out of the 80s. I tried to change the channel, i realized Something was changing but there was no information being delivered. There was no information I could experience that came from outside of myself. There was no change, everything froze, there was no communicating with anything.
I wondered if something had happened to reality, if something had changed, if all the life i knew just happened to be in some kind of bubble of perfect for experiencing and the bubble had popped.
I thought to myself is this death? No no way. Im dreaming.
Wait, things arent changing. Thibgs arent going back to normal. Oh my god. Im dead. This is death.
This isnt so bad.

My body felt heavy like sacks of wet sand with nothing alive within it. My hands and fingers stubby bloated and rounder. My skin purplish looking like what youd expect of a waterlogged corpse. Okay things should be shutting off any second. why isnt everything turning off. I was waiting for the screen to go black for life to flash off and my experiences stop.

I realized a moment later i was stuck here in my dark apartment, alone, the tv on but the screen showing people but no faces the picture still old.

I thought to myself, is this how theyll find me, my poor mom, my poor family.
Will i rot here like my neighbor when he died no one knowing until the smell became evident from outside. I felt so alone. I was so desperate to see and hear my mom again. The thought of never seeing her or my brother or neice or nephews and all my other family. There was a horrible smell, the smell of human excrement not over powering but there. theres no way to describe the deepeth of aloneness.

Knowing that this was was afterlife, that this was how things would be forever.
The thought, forever. Realizing there was no suicide to escape, no one i could cry to, nothing that could change anythjng. No iformation, no food, no books, no tv, no one else, absolutely nothing. Void of all except my horror.

And then i thought to myself, they were right. my stepfather and uncle who i had questioned how could they believe in god. It made absolutely no since and there was no proof of whatsoever.

And opened my mouth and the words "my god" came out and i saw a spark of light. A little ball of electricity out of the corner of my eye. I said it again. I started to repeat it out loud. "My god" "my god" as i was repeating my god i saw my skin start to look alive a little bit more each time i spoke.
I felt the words "my god" taking away dark emotions i cant explain. I kept repeating "my god" and each time i could see and feel something horrible left more and more. I leaned my head back on the couch and kept repeating "my god" thinking how amazing god was and how i would never forget.
How i would tell this story to others. How this would be my life and how happy i would be. How this would completely me and how extreme the change from devout athiest with absolute belief that nothing could ever happen to make me believe would be a testament to others. With my head tilted back against the couch i opened my mouth and took a deep breath. As i breathed in i felt something enter back into my body. I felt its weight and the way it thumped as it dropped back into my body.

I assume this was my soul.
After that breath i realized i hadnt been breathing. I felt my heart beat and realized it hadnt been beating. I felt my pulse with my fingers in my throat. It was there. I just kept repeating "my god" over and over again for what must have been ten minutes.

Then i saw youtube on my tv screen and i searched for "god" The first video played and the message was as if it was meant for me and that the person on the video knew what had just happened.

I remeber it saying that from now on i was to be known as isreal and that the experience i had had was part of my relationship with god. It said that there was no reason to go tell everyone and that some things were to be a secret between myself and god. it spoke to me.

This was the second of three experiences.

Tomorrow i will try and describe the first of by far the scariest and most violent experience.

I realize theres probably alot of grammatical and spelling errors. I havent reread this or spellchecked it or anything

This is my honest experience. I havent really used reddit before and im not sure if this is going to show my email or be anonymous. I really hope it will be anonymous but if its not every word of this is true and actually took place to me.

If anyone else has experinced something similar please contact me on here. Or if someone reads this please let me know what you think. I wasnt raised in church and theres alot i dont know or understand

FIRST EXPERINCE

That'd be cool. It really upset me that all the people on this reddit app comment just to mock me.
What happened to me wasn't just one experience it was three. After the first I found the the sign that I was told I would find during the "religious experience" I guess I'd call it.
I still have the coin. It was minted in 313ad and has Constantine on one side and Jupiter on the other. I'm not sure if you know the significance of Constantine to Christianity.
The night after the second experience in the morning I went to the store and it was setting on top of the ATM. I haven't told anyone but the first experience was a full night of being killed over and over again. While it was happening I was terrified but I had a strong belief that it was nessasary and that the men, demons, whatever that were doing this needed to. That I was being like a scapegoat and that it served some purpose.

Through all of my childhood I was badly abused in every way you could think of. During all of it I felt bad for each abuser. Especially the ones that were part of my family. It used to hurt me just as bad to know that they had to feel so much anger and be so unhappy. I think this played into the first experience.

However after the first experience every time after word my body felt dead. Which is the most horrible terrifying experience ever. Especially when you feel that way while trapped in some horrible place with no time, no information, and no other life.
This was my first and second experience of three.

I'll swear in any way I can to help you accept that I'm not making this up and it's it's all been absolutely real and how I describe for me.

ID LIKE TO POST PICTURES OF THE COIN HERE BUT I DONT KNOW HOW. IF ANYONE CAN TELL ME ILL POST THEM