r/redsox • • Aug 01 '25

Trading Devers did not “revitalize” the team

0 Upvotes

So I’ve seen a lot of people (most of them fiercely defending Breslow) talking about how he traded Devers and suddenly we had “good vibes” and the team took off…

So I just want to remind everyone how things actually went.

The 10 games PRIOR to trading Devers is when the team turned things around.

We went 8-2 and took 5 of 6 from the Yankees and 2 of 3 from the rays to jump back into the playoff hunt.

Devers also had an OPS of 904 when traded…

Devers was then traded immediately after we swept the Yankees.

Did having the Devers clubhouse “cancer” trigger the “good vibes”?

No,

We lost 7 of the next 10 games.

That 10 game stretch was our BEST stretch of the year as we crushed a division leader and a (at the time) wild card team, far more impressive than our 10 game win streak where most of our wins were vs bottom feeders.

I’m not even going to bother arguing here whether the trade was good or bad.

I just want to kill the narrative that this team was in shambles and magically got better by trading our best hitter.

The team was on a roll and playing its best stretch of the season BEFORE the trade, immediately slumped after the trade and then got back on a roll after that.

The team had already turned a corner before the Devers deal and those claiming getting rid of him is what got the team going are just being dishonest


r/redsox • • Jun 23 '26

IMAGE This year is a mess but Bres got this one right

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/redsox • • Jan 23 '24

Don’t Sign Montgomery or Snell: They’re Not That Good (Anti Panic-Signing Rant)

1 Upvotes

The impatience of panic-signs is 1,000% not how you turn a last place team into a first place team. You could fill libraries with what I don’t know about front office baseball economics, but I have seen enough Miguel Texiara, Jason Giambi, JA Happ, Kenny Rodgers, Jacoby Ellsbury, or Aj Burnett signings to know dumbly overpaying for top market talent that isn’t even good is a terrible way to “improve” your team.

Signing Jordan Montgomery / Blake Snell is a shallow move. It shuts fans up for 15 minutes but it screws our team over long-term for way longer. Ohtani would have been great. Yamamoto would have been great. But was David Ortiz a hugely sought-after free agent? Bill Mueller? Kevin Youkilis (pre-sox)? It’s gotta be a combo of big moves and savvy moves. Not just chase the shiniest toy still on the shelf.

What we should be doing is raiding the Marlins and Tigers and KC Royals and all the other small/market teams chalk full of post-hype sleepers. Screw Jordan Montgomery. I want Tarik Skubal, Matt Manning, & Casey Mize. I want Jesus Luzardo, Eury Perez, Max Meyer, & Edward Cabrera. I want Scott Barlow. The freaking Marlins signed freaking AJ Puk last year for a bucket of baseballs and we signed Kenley Jansen. Who was very solid, dont get me wrong. But whatre we doing paying up for a premier closer when we could take a guy like Puk and turn him into a lefty papelbon. Better yet, a guy like Puk and Nate Pearson for about a tenth of what Kenley cost, and see which is the better closer.

Last year we failed to commit to the rebuild and it felt stupid literally the whole time.

Either (1) we stink and we are not “just 1 big sign away” from being relevant or (2) we are actually pretty damn good and just a big piece away from major success, which would be evidenced by us being competitive 1/2 way thru the season (and then probably kicking ourselves for not getting a guy like snell or Montgomery).

I think we’re probably a lot closer to (1). It could be (2)! But one thing is for sure - it can’t be both. And frankly i think if it ends up being (2), then you just go sign the biggest arm on the market at the deadline and go for broke. But we’re either close or we arent. It’s not the NBA, you don’t just sign Kevin Durant and la la la your team is competitive now.


r/redsox • • Dec 08 '23

If the Jays get Ohtani and Yankees get Yamomoto, it's basically over

0 Upvotes

I'm being super doomer right now and yeah maybe the Red Sox could still compete for the WC spots, but the Jays would be stacked, the Yankees would be better than last season (even though they didn't make the playoffs and disappointed, they still finished with a better record than Boston) and Tampa will still find a way to be good. Maybe Baltimore will go back to not being good but they look to be the real deal.

At least the Red Sox will be below the luxury tax again...

EDIT: ​Ok so either I did a poor job explaining myself, or some of you lack reading comprehension. This isn't strictly about Ohtani. Obviously if the Red Sox got him he wouldn't magically make their team a superteam and there would still be plenty of holes. Same with Yamamoto. The point was that the Blue Jays and Yankees are ​​already ​better teams ​than the Red Sox​, and​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​ they have a very realistic chance of getting much better (with the Yankees already getting better with the Soto trade), whereas the Red Sox have so far made moves that have, for now, made them at best stand pat and maybe worse. I know the offseason isn't close to over, but if the two moves in the title happen, it would be very very difficult for the Red Sox to be competitive in the AL East.​​​


r/redsox • • May 15 '25

Ok Fire Cora

0 Upvotes

Not running Rafaela to take away the force and then bringing in Wong...clutching another defeat from the jaws of victory.


r/redsox • • Dec 22 '23

Obviously this team is incomplete, but we're actually in great shape for 2024

0 Upvotes

Look, we need pitching, but even without Yamamoto (which is still in play!) we're gonna be okay. It makes me sad to see the fanbase pitching a fit like this. We're the goddamn Red Sox. We're the most successful MLB team of the 21st century. Whining is so... unbecoming.

In any case, yes... SP is a problem. We are going to need a Montgomery or even Snell or one of the guys on the trade market. We have the horses to do it. Chris Sale is healthy, but basically anything we get from him is a bonus. He's gone next year and so is $25.6 mil off the books. Bello flashed ace level stuff. Crawford is better than you remember (and as a popular Red Sox twitter personality said, if he was on Seattle most of us would be talking about trading for him like we talk about the rest of their young staff.) Piv was dominant in the second half. Whitlock and Houck are healthy. We already had an elite pen with a Hall of Fame closer and the best RH set up man in the game. We added to that this offseason with some intriguing guys like Slaten, Campbell, and Weissert.

On offense we have a Silver Slugger winning 3B who will be 27 when the season starts. On the other side of the diamond there's a 1B who outhit the AL Silver Slugger winning 1B in the second half. Trevor Story is healthy and is one of the best defensive infielders in the AL. He's also fast and an excellent baserunner. Wong and McGuire are an excellent catching tandem who compliment each other well. They're both great on defense.

Masataka Yoshida is one of the best hitters in baseball. Was a rookie last season after a grueling preseason and had a top 10 BA. Tyler O'Neill has great wheels, power and is a two time Gold Glover. Duran is back. Amazing wheels, and his defense is improving. He was so good last year. Wilyer Abreu is a guy who could see a lot of time at RF. He was red hot to finish the year. In CF, it could still be up in the air, but Rafaela is allegedly GG quality in CF and at SS. Is his bat ready? Maybe!

So the Red Sox clearly need some more pitching and they need to fill out their bench... but they have tons of cash to spend to get it... and all at positions that won't be blocked when the cavalry gets here.

Team speed is maybe the best they've ever had. They've got two home grown power hitters that are a threat to hit 40 (hasn't happened since Mo Vaughn!) and their up the middle defense is pretty promising. This team is going to be damn good next season, and if the media and their opponents underestimate them, so be it!

Last season I said the Mets and Padres would miss the playoffs. I grew up a Redskins fan so I know what happens when you "win" the offseason. The Red Sox are, to paraphrase Breslow, running their own race.


r/redsox • • Sep 03 '23

Cora - suuuuper geeeeenius

0 Upvotes

Really glad to see Cora bringing Winckowski in with a 6-run lead and Pivetta in with a 5-run lead. I mean, you gotta hold back guys like Barraclough and Llovera so they're available for high leverage situations. </s>


r/redsox • • May 12 '26

IMAGE Download your Will Flemming bingo card for tonight’s game.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/redsox • • Sep 16 '23

[Red Sox] Casas down and Dalbec up

Thumbnail
x.com
0 Upvotes

r/redsox • • Jun 29 '23

Chaim Haters Are Exhausting...

0 Upvotes

When you look at the MLB standings, anyone should be able to see that the Red Sox have been making the right moves since Chaim Bloom took over. Very few, if any mistakes.

People wanted us to sign X for a billion dollars? Or go after all these high priced free agents that would cripple us? It's clear now, as it was clear to so many people at the time, that we were doing the right thing to build long term success.

Whitlock, Bello, Houck, Casas, Wong, Duran, along with a stacked farm system with the core being built, staying under the tax... Raffy signed long term, Dugie primed for an extension... How could anyone not see that this is the correct way to set the franchise up for long term sustained success? How could anyone think we should fire Chaim Bloom or stupider yet, think that John Henry suddenly stopped caring about winning and decided to run the franchise as if we were a small market team to maximize profits?

When Theo was general manager he inherited a VERY good team with Damon, and Varitek, and Pedro, and Manny, and Nomar, and Lowe... and he was able to build a winner right away. And in those days you could stockpile picks as a big market team by trading for pending free agents at the deadline. He was able to let guys go and get maximum value for them leading to a mid to late 2000's core that was amazing. And it came together quickly.

When Cherington took over he could do some of the same things but also outspend in international amateur free agency. You could flex your muscles there and build a young core. He did and it led to a period of sustained success for the team.

Dombrowski took over and gutted the farm. Gave out bad extensions and completely killed the franchise. He got fired for his mismanagement of the team (check out the Phillies!) and then Bloom took over.

With Bloom, he was WAY over the tax and he couldn't stockpile picks like Theo or spend in IAFA like Ben. That had been legislated out of the game. So the only option is to get under the tax and start a slow build. He had to trade Mookie. Full stop. Remember what was being talked about for a return back then? Very few teams were even interested! For a huge star! Because only a few teams would be able to pay him! Cristian Pache from the Braves was possibly a centerpiece (and he sucks!), Brusdar Graterol was almost the total compensation... We got Downs (great prospect who was possibly derailed by Covid), Vergudo (similar production to Mookie this season) and Connor Wong (still in arb and having an amazing season while playing better than advertised defense). He got rid of Price and saved a bundle in the deal too. He sold high on Renfroe, he added Reese McGuire for practically nothing, massive value FA's like Story and Yoshida, he got rid of a bunch of bad culture guys last offseason... We're rolling into 2024 with money to spend under the tax and we'll probably trade Paxton for useful pieces...

Things are lining up so well for the Red Sox but all casuals want is to spend big money to finish in 3rd place just out of the WC. Ridiculous.


r/redsox • • Jul 07 '26

Unpopular Opinion : Breslow is good at his job

5 Upvotes

Breslow brought in Contreras, Gray, Durbin, Siegler, Monasterio, Bennett and Suarez this year. That's a pretty good group.

Last year it was Crochet, Slaten, Narvaez, Chapman.

The hold overs from the previous administration (except for Abreu) are the ones who suck or are perpetually injured and useless.


r/redsox • • Jun 04 '25

Alex Cora just made an awful decision.

0 Upvotes

Tied up bottom 9. No outs. Hamilton on 2nd, Duran up and he doesn’t bunt down the 3B line. Instead lets him hit and flies out. Hamilton doesn’t advance.

This is basic shit! What a fucking jackass!

You put pressure on the Angels to make a play on the fastest man in baseball, with a man in scoring position - anything can happen!

Oh my GOD!!! The Angels just DID THIS!


r/redsox • • Aug 24 '26

I'm pro Trevor Story

7 Upvotes

Initially, I was against it but this is a proven vet. As long as he's not hurt- you put this guy in.

Mazz being anti Story coming back now..really sealed my thinking.


r/redsox • • Jan 07 '23

[Passan] The Los Angeles Dodgers are designating right-hander Trevor Bauer for assignment, sources tell ESPN. The Dodgers will eat $22.5 million. Bauer can sign with any major league team for the $720,000 minimum and can play immediately after completing a record-long suspension.

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/redsox • • Jul 04 '24

I miss Bobby Dalbec and I don’t care what anyone says

0 Upvotes

5 ribbies last night for his beloved Woo Sox. Look, I know that’s where he belongs but I miss him alright?


r/redsox • • Aug 09 '14

Hey guys. Just stopped by to say

0 Upvotes

Fuck Derek Jeter


r/redsox • • May 14 '25

Cora needs to go

0 Upvotes

r/redsox • • Jun 21 '25

IMAGE Still Have My Devers Jersey

Post image
0 Upvotes

Go Red Sox!


r/redsox • • Jun 28 '25

1-6 since we sent KC down

0 Upvotes

Bring him back!!!!!! Why not??

And while we are at it bring up Blaze and Password just so we can have enjoy the kiddies!


r/redsox • • Apr 04 '26

IMAGE Trevor Story is sinking the Red Sox, by himself

Post image
0 Upvotes

That obp is unplayable for a 2 hitter. You will not score runs with this. Even Duran is getting on base at a respectable clip. He can not be the 2 hitter this is fucking insane


r/redsox • • Aug 24 '23

Cora to separate after this year?

3 Upvotes

NESN featured a pregame story about the high amount of errors that Rafael Devers has committed this season. In this pregame piece, Cora is quoted as saying he doesn’t know how long he’s gonna be here but for as long as he’s here, he wants Devers to be his third baseman.

It sounds to me, like Cora believes he’s likely to be fired ? Maybe this is the reason why he was ejected two times in three games? I can’t remember that happening during his tenure with the Red Sox. I don’t consider myself an Alex Cora fan, but I think that this team has beaten expectations.

Meaningful end of season baseball. Late summer. That’s what we’ve had. This team wasn’t constructed to make a deep run. If anything I think they should have traded some players at the deadline like Paxton and possibly Verdugo. Verdugo has had a drop in production and shown that he isn’t focused on baseball. Verdugo may be a non-tender candidate this off-season. Is it fair for Cora to get the axe? What do you think?


r/redsox • • Dec 27 '22

Why are we not boycotting this team?

0 Upvotes

Serious: as consumers, why continue to pay for tickets, concessions, merch, etc. for this poorly run organization?


r/redsox • • Jan 05 '23

Is it time to give Chaim Bloom some credit?

16 Upvotes

If we look at his résumé, I don’t think Chaim Bloom has done a bad job

  1. He was hired with the intent of trading Mookie Betts- we cannot hold that against him, the decision to move Mookie was decided before he was ever hired

  2. Xander Bogearts got a lucrative deal that will ultimately end up being a bad deal. While I can blame him for not trading Bogearts while he could, or resigning him while he could, I can’t blame him for not matching that contract. Having said that, I don’t think anybody saw the SS market playing out the way it did. If everybody had perfect foresight then the free agent market would be nonexistent, I don’t think we can blame him for that- shit happens

  3. He extended our one young guy that it makes sense to give a longterm contract to. Outside of Mookie, who was already getting traded before Bloom’s signing, which one of our players was worth giving a long term contract to? I feel like he’s batting 1000 as far as that’s concerned

  4. Our farm system is significantly better now than at the time Bloom was hired. Not only that, but he’s hired a lot of great stop gap players- Kike Hernandez, Justin Turner, Hunter Renfroe, Corey Kluber, Kenley Jensen, etc.

Not saying my option is the end all be all, but I think that we’ve been giving him a lot more flack than he deserves. At the end of the day, I think he’s the scapegoat for poor ownership. The point of this post is I’m interested in seeing what the rest of our fanbase thinks


r/redsox • • Aug 06 '23

Red Sox fans thank you for the weekend from a Blue Jays fan

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

No, this is not a troll post or a gloat. I as well managed to make it down for the Saturday game here from Toronto and was so happy to finally get to take in Fenway Park. I spent today at Fan Expo Boston (my other passion). But I just want to say I feel Boston gets a bad rap and that the Red Sox fans were actually some of the nicest I’ve met (probably hurts not to be a Yankees fan) you were all very helpful to this fish out of water and didn’t give me too hard a time for my Blue Jays fandom. Was surprised how many of my fellow Canadians and jays fans made it down to Fenway but it was an experience I’m never going to forget! It was a great game. That play at the end of it on Saturday was absolutely bizarre and one of the wildest things I’ve seen in a game. I will say that I loved when you guys started a Yankees suck chant and the entire ballpark joined in because one thing we can agree on is our mutual hatred of the New York Yankees. Your city is absolutely gorgeous and I’ve loved getting to spend some time in it. So pat yourselves on the back. I’m sorry the games didn’t turn out the way you want but it was an absolutely fun weekend!