When you look at the MLB standings, anyone should be able to see that the Red Sox have been making the right moves since Chaim Bloom took over. Very few, if any mistakes.
People wanted us to sign X for a billion dollars? Or go after all these high priced free agents that would cripple us? It's clear now, as it was clear to so many people at the time, that we were doing the right thing to build long term success.
Whitlock, Bello, Houck, Casas, Wong, Duran, along with a stacked farm system with the core being built, staying under the tax... Raffy signed long term, Dugie primed for an extension... How could anyone not see that this is the correct way to set the franchise up for long term sustained success? How could anyone think we should fire Chaim Bloom or stupider yet, think that John Henry suddenly stopped caring about winning and decided to run the franchise as if we were a small market team to maximize profits?
When Theo was general manager he inherited a VERY good team with Damon, and Varitek, and Pedro, and Manny, and Nomar, and Lowe... and he was able to build a winner right away. And in those days you could stockpile picks as a big market team by trading for pending free agents at the deadline. He was able to let guys go and get maximum value for them leading to a mid to late 2000's core that was amazing. And it came together quickly.
When Cherington took over he could do some of the same things but also outspend in international amateur free agency. You could flex your muscles there and build a young core. He did and it led to a period of sustained success for the team.
Dombrowski took over and gutted the farm. Gave out bad extensions and completely killed the franchise. He got fired for his mismanagement of the team (check out the Phillies!) and then Bloom took over.
With Bloom, he was WAY over the tax and he couldn't stockpile picks like Theo or spend in IAFA like Ben. That had been legislated out of the game. So the only option is to get under the tax and start a slow build. He had to trade Mookie. Full stop. Remember what was being talked about for a return back then? Very few teams were even interested! For a huge star! Because only a few teams would be able to pay him! Cristian Pache from the Braves was possibly a centerpiece (and he sucks!), Brusdar Graterol was almost the total compensation... We got Downs (great prospect who was possibly derailed by Covid), Vergudo (similar production to Mookie this season) and Connor Wong (still in arb and having an amazing season while playing better than advertised defense). He got rid of Price and saved a bundle in the deal too. He sold high on Renfroe, he added Reese McGuire for practically nothing, massive value FA's like Story and Yoshida, he got rid of a bunch of bad culture guys last offseason... We're rolling into 2024 with money to spend under the tax and we'll probably trade Paxton for useful pieces...
Things are lining up so well for the Red Sox but all casuals want is to spend big money to finish in 3rd place just out of the WC. Ridiculous.