r/redditrequest • u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin • Jun 05 '25
New changes for the Reddit request process
Hi there!
Reddit request was launched to ensure we can facilitate the fair transition of inactive communities to new moderators. Recently, we have seen an increase in low quality and spam requests. In order to protect this process and our communities, we are making some changes. Check out the details below:
New account requirements
To submit a request, your account now must be at least 90 days old and have at least 100 comment karma and 100 post karma. These karma requirements do not include any karma gained in free karma subs.
Two-Factor authentication (2FA) is now required
All requesters must have 2fa enabled on their Reddit account.
For more information about Two-Factor Authentication, please check out this Reddit Help Center article.
Enabling 2FA:
Required post format
All requests made in r/redditrequest must follow this format:
Post title: The title of your post should ONLY contain the name of the community you’re requesting.
Post flair: You will also need to add flair to your post indicating what type of subreddit you’re requesting.
New flairs include:
NSFW - Public
NSFW - Private
NSFW - Banned
NSFW - Restricted
SFW - Public
SFW - Private
SFW - Banned
SFW - Restricted
An example request would look like:
[SFW - Public]
Mod mail changes
One more thing! Previously, we asked you to send a mod mail message at the time of submitting your request. Now, you must send a mod mail message five days before posting your request. This will help us to process requests faster - ideally within 2 days. If the subreddit has no moderators, you can skip this step.
After posting, u/request_bot will comment on your request asking for your reasons for wanting to moderate the community, as well as asking for a link to the mod mail message that you sent. Please reply to this comment to prevent your request from being denied.
To make these changes run smoothly, the community will be temporarily restricted for approximately 20 minutes. All requests will resume after this time.
TL;DR
Accounts must be at least 90+ days old and have at least 100 comment and 100 post karma
All requesters must have 2fa enabled on their account
The title of your post should only be the name of the community you’re requesting
You must apply flair to your post
You must send a mod mail message 5 days before creating your post (unless no moderators exist).
Please note: All requests before this announcement will be processed with the old rules in mind, so don’t worry if your account does not meet these requirements and you’ve already submitted a request.
Thanks for helping keep r/redditrequest run smoothly!
9
Jun 05 '25
How to get banned sub when i post it on r/redditrequest i got reject it from request bot how this process actually work do anyone have an idea when you request a banned sub most of the time request get denied why how reddit proceed with those request why it difficult to get a sub reopen from a ban state but when it not a banned sub most of the time you got granted access how reddit request work? And i have a question what if someone don’t want to enable 2fa for privacy reason you can rethink this will all respect to the team
8
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 05 '25
Hey u/whitechocobear,
Communities that have been banned for violating Reddit rules are generally not eligible to be handed over, as the goal is to prevent further policy violations. In some cases, even if a subreddit was banned for being unmoderated, it may still be considered unsuitable for reopening which is why those requests are often declined. That said, we have handed over banned communities in the past when they were deemed appropriate, and we’ll continue to do so if the situation fits.
Regarding 2FA: While some may have privacy concerns, 2FA is generally considered a best practice to protect accounts. It doesn’t collect extra personal information it just adds a layer of protection for you and the communities you moderate.
4
Jun 05 '25
if a subreddit was banned for being unmoderated, it may still be considered unsuitable for reopening which is why those requests are often declined. That said, we have handed over banned communities in the past when they were deemed appropriate, and we’ll continue to do so if the situation fits.
this is my main question it confusing why it difficult to reopen because it already banned so maybe someone want to take over and make great job moderate the community
4
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 05 '25
I get where you're coming from. Wanting to revive a banned community with better moderation is a good intention. But the reason it’s difficult is that when a community is banned, it’s usually due to violations of Reddit’s rules. Allowing someone to take over and reuse that same space could risk the same issues coming back, even with new moderation.
If there’s a topic you care about and the original space is banned, you’re often better off starting a new community.→ More replies (4)2
u/Freshionpoop Jun 05 '25
I click on my View Profile for my account, but I can't see what my "100 comment karma and 100 post karma" are.
2
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 05 '25
Hey u/Freshionpoop if you go to your profile and hover over your karma total you will see a breakdown of post and comment.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Freshionpoop Jun 05 '25
Thanks for the reply. I think that only works for desktop computers. Also, I'm on the phone using Brave browser, not the reddit app.
→ More replies (3)
4
u/late_to_redd1t Jun 12 '25
So, I just requested one before I had 2fa set up and it got removed. Then I tried to post again and it says I have to wait 15 days. That doesn't seem fair.
2
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 16 '25
Hey! Looks like you were able to post again. I've added you to that community.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/JaydyGaga88 Jul 01 '25
My account is 163 days old, I have 289 post karma and 115 comment karma. I have 2fa enabled. I sent a mod mail message over 5 days before I created a post. So I meet the "new account requirements"
Yet I got this bot response:
"Hey there,
Thanks for taking the time to submit this request. Unfortunately, we have decided not to approve it at this time. There are other factors, beyond moderator activity, that we consider when reviewing requests. These are at the discretion of admins and may include, but are not limited to:
Insufficient moderator experience for managing a large, active community
Lack of previous moderator experience
Lack of NSFW (Not Safe for Work) moderation experience
Inactive moderation in a community you are already a moderator for
Being on the mod team of an excessive number of communities
Recent account suspensions
Excessive community bans
Violation of Reddit policies, including copyright infringement takedowns
Low activity on Reddit.
We appreciate you taking the time to request this community.
Thanks!"
Although specific requirements have been met by my account, actually there's all these other requirements that weren't mentioned!
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 09 '25
Hey, thanks for flagging this, I handed that subreddit over to you.
→ More replies (2)2
3
u/EK_NOX Jun 05 '25
If I were to request for a subreddit banned due to lack of moderation, how would I check if it had moderators in the first place? Would I still need to send modmail regardless before I post a request?
4
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 05 '25
Hey u/EK_NOX no need to send a mod mail if the community is banned as there is technically no moderators.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Fantastic-Positive86 Jun 12 '25
Is 5 days the minimum?, like can I request a subreddit 10 or 15 days after sending the Modmail? Or do I have to request the sub immediately after 5 days?
4
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 15 '25
Hey, you can request whenever you’d like! It just has to be at least 5 days before submitting a request. Thanks!
1
u/Matzolorian Aug 19 '25
This is blatantly untrue in my experience recently. Users are submitting requests the same day the mod mail is sent, and their requests are being granted prior to the 5 days having passed.
I can supply the proof as well.
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Aug 19 '25
If the moderator is completely inactive across the site, the bot may hand over the subreddit soon after it's requested. It's not able to check when a message was sent.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/TexacoGas Jun 14 '25
To get a subreddit with a u/automoderator would I still have to send a modmail?
4
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 16 '25
You don't need to send a mod mail to a community that only has u/automoderator as the listed mod.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/RealJoshUniverse Jun 15 '25
If moderator does not respond to a mod mail after the five days, does that mean the subreddit is always requestable(assuming karma and activity requirements by the requestor are met)? If not what would the other circumstances be?
Thank you!
2
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 16 '25
If the moderator doesn't respond to the mod mail within 5 days, the community is eligible for request at that time. However, this doesn't guarantee eligibility, as the moderator might be on a short break. If your initial request is denied and you try again after, say, 30 days, it's a good idea to send another message to check if the moderator has returned.
4
u/jaxspider Jul 22 '25
Why is 2fa mandatory? I have been on reddit for almost 2 decades. I do not want that annoying "feature" just to voluntary as a mod. A verified email should be more than enough.
3
u/jaxspider Jul 22 '25
/u/Goldennuggets-3000 please respond to this question.
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 23 '25
Hey u/jaxspider, as mentioned in the post, we've implemented the 2FA requirement to address a rise in low quality and spam requests. These steps add an extra layer of security to accounts, helping us filter out spam and prioritize genuine requests.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/AdCertain49 Jun 06 '25
I want to be a mod for a group that was banned because of inactive moderators. Is that possible to do?
2
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 06 '25
Hey u/AdCertain49, you're more than welcome to submit a request for a banned community and we will review it in the queue. Thanks!
→ More replies (1)
2
u/MrJezza- Jun 19 '25
I tried to request a community, but it said, 'Sorry, this post was removed by Reddit’s filters.' I meet all the requirements, including karma and 2FA.
Not sure if this is something Admins look into r/reddirequest
Thanks for the replies over the questions on this thread, quite helpful.
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 20 '25
Hey, it looks like the subreddit that you have requested has been associated with some spam in the past whenever it's been handed over by the bot so is not eligible for handover at this time.
2
u/SnooObjections217 Jul 06 '25
My requests get deleted instantly. I'm doing it from an Android.
I have 2FA.
I messaged the mod a month ago. Twice.
I put the sub name in the title.
I add the appropriate flair.
It is required to put a link, so I enter the link to the sub.
I then list why I want to take over the sub in the form of a comment.
Thank you in advance!
3
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 09 '25
Hey! I just took a look at some of your requests and it looks like you're not linking to the subreddit that you'd like to moderate correctly. In the URL of the post you're submitting you must enter www.reddit.com/r/SUBREDDITNAME. If the community no longer exists, your post will also be filtered out. Let me know if you're still having issues.
→ More replies (1)2
u/SnooObjections217 Jul 10 '25
In case you did not see my other reply, thank you!
Unfortunately, this is not working either. Should I try it from a computer?
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 10 '25
Hey it looks like your request went through!
→ More replies (1)2
u/Original_Capital4532 Jul 06 '25
I’m having the same issue getting rejected instantly I have the requirements as you mentioned above
→ More replies (1)
2
u/fakeusername0223 Jul 12 '25
if someone else sent modmail 5+ days ago and got no can i use that as an example? i sent yesterday but the person is clearly not active and the only mod/owner of the sub
→ More replies (2)1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 14 '25
Hey! No, you will have to send your own message to the mods.
2
u/ChocolateWi-Fi Jul 14 '25
If I enable 2FA after submitting a request, would my request be considered or would i have to submit another one?
2
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 16 '25
You will need to submit another but you don't have to wait 15 days, you can submit it immediately after enabling 2FA. Thanks!
1
u/ChocolateWi-Fi Jul 16 '25
I tried to submit another request (within 15 days) after enabling my 2FA and it got removed. Do I have to wait another 15 days or is there some other issue?
2
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 16 '25
It looks like the community you're trying to request is not currently eligible because there has been an increase in spam attempt takeovers there.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/maemaecat Jul 28 '25
Hi u/Goldennuggets-3000 apologies for tagging you directly but I’m not getting any answers elsewhere. My post keeps getting removed by Reddit filters. My account is 3 years old, I’ve verified my email and enabled 2FA, I have 100+ post and comment karma, and I am prepared with the unanswered mod mail for the subreddit I want to apply for. I’ve also disconnected my Google account sign in to ensure the verified email and 2FA works correctly.
Can you help please? I would be grateful 💜
→ More replies (3)1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 31 '25
Hey I've gone ahead and approved your post but please note you will still have to wait for manual review which can take up to 1 week. Thanks!
1
u/maemaecat Jul 31 '25
Hi!! Thank you so much!!
So for whatever reason I guess my account updated itself somehow and I was able to post successfully yesterday morning. RequestBot commented and I replied. Should I remove the older post or does it matter?
Thank you so much again! 💜
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 31 '25
Oh nice, thanks for letting me know! No need to remove the older one, we'll review this as soon as we can. Thanks!
→ More replies (2)
23
u/bertraja Jun 12 '25
2FA is too much. Taking over an abandoned subreddit has nothing to do with my individual account safety. Verified E-Mail (paired with an appropriate account age) should be enough
9
u/y--a--s--h Jun 22 '25
i just enabled it and so regretting it,they logged me out from phone and im not able to login again even after entering that stupid code again and again
→ More replies (4)
19
16
16
u/ActiveCommittee8202 Jun 14 '25
How are you expecting us to enable 2-factor-authentication when you don't even let us have 2FA on Android app? When are we getting it on Android?
15
u/lazydictionary Jun 15 '25
Requiring 2FA is steep. Never had 2FA in 16+ years using the site, and successfully requested subs before. I get it probably reduces bots/spam, but that's very annoying. The account and karma requirements should be much steeper - 100 of each is nothing, and only 90 days? That's stupidly easy to work around. (Also, users with that few karma and account age probably shouldn't be moderating anything)
15
u/Earthling_Aprill Jul 08 '25
At this point, because of this nonsense, requesting subs through r/redditrequest should just be completely discontinued and Reddit should just officially switch over to having subs that get reported for being unmoderated or other various Moderator Code of Conduct violations be offered up exclusively by u/ModCodeofConduct instead.
14
u/xEternal-Blue Jun 14 '25
Like others I think the need for 2FA is unnecessary and overkill. I hope this is reverted at some point.
9
u/Bassfaceapollo Jun 19 '25
Agreed. I mostly take over niche subreddits to prevent them from dying out. 2FA is quite a hassle.
I can understand it being a requirement for 'fresh' mods but moderators of other subs looking to take over other subs to prevent them from dying out should get some leeway.
14
u/Inevitable-While-577 Jul 09 '25 edited Jul 09 '25
Please remove the requirement of two factor authentication.
11
7
u/magikarpcatcher Jul 22 '25 edited Jul 22 '25
This is so stupid. I was gonna request to mod a sub for a show I watch but having 2FA is just not worth the hassle. Guess that sub can remain dead/restricted 🤷
4
6
u/Humdrum_Blues Jun 12 '25
Despite meeting all of the requirements, my post was auto removed by "Reddit's Filters". Am I missing something, or is it a glitch?
5
u/KaidudePlays Jun 05 '25
To make sure that I read the post correctly, I have to send a modmail message 5 days before and it will speed up the process by 2 days?
3
→ More replies (1)3
u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin Jun 05 '25
Hi! Yes, send the mod mail message and then five days later, create your post to request the sub. That will reduce the waiting time after the post.
→ More replies (4)
5
u/Shrinkify Jun 11 '25
Hey there! It seems that despite adhering to these rules and my account meeting all requirements, my request this morning was automatically rejected and removed.
I did just activate 2FA right before posting. Is there by chance a delay between enabling 2FA and being able to make requests? Thanks!
5
u/quackfeathers Aug 16 '25
u/Goldennuggets-3000 u/TheOpusCroakus u/AsteriskRX I apologize to tag you all, but there are many of us here trying to reach out to you guys through the modmail and receiving no response. I've been trying to reach out for the past 20 days.
The problem many of us are faced with is our request got removed because of "Reddit's filters". Personally, my account fits the criteria and has 2FA activated. Could you please help us out here?
4
u/ohwowwhatsgood Jun 13 '25
Hi u/goldennuggets-3000 I made a request today it got removed immediately by u/request_bot. I tried the same thing 2 other times over the span of 45 days and it still happened again.
I tried messaging the mods about this, and I have not gotten a response. I keep getting automated responses from bots. Is there any way I can know what I am doing wrong? I am so confused. I really would like to properly request a sub.
Thank you for your patience and help.
4
u/mpark2453 Jul 11 '25
Ive been following the rules but my requests have been removed by reddit filters so the request bot doesnt even see my request. I'm not quite sure how to fix this and im following the rule of not deleting my requests
4
u/quackfeathers Aug 01 '25 edited Aug 03 '25
Hey, I've submitted a request 5 days ago which immediately got rmeoved because of "Reddit's filters"? My account is nearly 4 years old and has just under 400 cumulated karma points, so Im not sure what im doing wrong? I've tried to contact the modmail, but havn't had a response, Im not sure my messages are going through? Any help would be appreciated
Edit: sorry to tag you too u/Goldennuggets-3000 but what happens to cases like mine when "Reddit's filters" removes our redditrequest post?
1
u/Zendicate_ Jun 05 '25
what about requests we made prior to this change
5
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 05 '25
Hey u/Zendicate_
All requests before this announcement will be processed with the old rules in mind, so don’t worry if your account does not meet these requirements and you’ve already submitted a request.
Hope this helps!
→ More replies (1)
1
u/mohhhz Jun 05 '25
Is my post still good when I saw this? I immediately put a post flair on my post and pending to enable 2FA.
2
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 05 '25
Hey u/mohhhz as long as you posted before this post you should be all good!
1
u/Tarnisher Jun 10 '25
This will help us to process requests faster - ideally within 2 days.
And yet, you still show a 6 - 8 day time on the sidebar, same as before.
???
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 16 '25
We're still catching up on the previous requests. We hope to be able to reduce the manual time soon. Thanks.
1
u/The_DarkKnight- Jun 10 '25
Hello,
I made a request for a subreddit that was "granted" by the old rules around a month ago. But I never received mod access for some reason.
I've been trying to get support, but my comments & posts just keep getting auto removed by bots because I'm not a mod at r/modhelp and when I post here it's because of a 15 days cooldown rule and now it's because my 2 and half month account is too young.
This is the link to the "granted" request. Please tell me what the issue is and whether or not I failed under the old rules because I believe I followed them all completely.
3
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 16 '25
Hey, sorry about that! Sometimes the bot misses it. I've handed that over to you now.
2
u/Tarnisher Jun 10 '25
Send a message here: https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=/r/redditrequest
1
u/Gellzer Jun 11 '25
Is the 5 day modmail requirement EXACTLY 5 days before requesting? Or is it at least 5 days before requesting?
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 16 '25
At least 5 days before requesting.
1
u/Successful_Star_2004 Jun 16 '25
Also another small doubt. If the earlier request was denied, can we re use the same modmail for new request of the same subreddit or new modmail for each time we request that sub?
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 16 '25
You should try to send a new mod mail on each request as the moderator might simply be taking a break so it's good to notify them again that you're interested in moderating. Hope this helps!
→ More replies (1)
1
u/proudcyber Jun 17 '25 edited Jun 17 '25
If a post was removed cause it didn't follow the correct format we have to wait 15 days to try to post again right?
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 18 '25
Hey! If you didn't follow the format you should receive a comment from Automod and you can make the request again.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Doctologist Jun 19 '25
I have a verified email, but my request was automatically rejected stating that I don’t have a verified email
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jun 20 '25
You may not have 2fa set up on your account. You need to have a verified email and two-factor authentication. Hope this helps!
1
u/pedrulho Jun 27 '25
TheOpusCroakus in the FAQ it says the following:
How to get a permalink to the message?
On desktop:
Go to your sent messages.
Right-click permalink at the bottom of the message and copy the link address.
Paste this link into a comment on your request.
But now the modmail messages appear as chat message instead of the usual message page on the notification bell, am I now supposed to get the permalink of the chat message with my request to the community instead?
If so, perhaps this part of the FAQ should be updated to reflect the new changes to Reddit's messaging system.
Thank you.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 09 '25
Hey, thanks for bringing this up! We're in the process of updating the FAQ. In the meantime, if you go to the chat window on desktop and hover over the message that you sent to the mods, you should see a link button. Click this to copy the link and add to your request. On mobile, tap and hold on the sent message, tap the Share option and Copy Link.
1
u/Clean-Look-8346 Jun 29 '25
I recently requested for a subreddit and got this reply instantly & my post was removed automatically by the request_bot (So do I need to wait for more 15 days for now?):
Hey! Thanks for requesting this subreddit. Unfortunately, the community r/HardwareHive is not eligible for request at this time as it was only recently banned. Please allow some time before requesting this community again. Thanks!
The community is asked for moderation was banned due to unmoderated. It's been 18 days now. There is no specific rules for community which are ban due to unmoderated and have completed 15 days or 30 days.
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 09 '25
Hey! You should be able to request another community as soon as you have been denied for this reason without having to wait 15 days. If you're having issues, let me know!
1
u/Iwannahumpalittle Jul 04 '25 edited Jul 04 '25
How can I make a request when I don't have a smartphone with apps? Can I do this "two-factor authentication" with my laptop?
Edit: I'm trying to request r/desperateHousewives, it's overrun by bots and the only moderator isn't acvtive
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 09 '25
Hey! You should be able to set up 2fa on your laptop. Instructions can be found in our Help Center.
1
u/Iwannahumpalittle Jul 09 '25
Nope, tried to set it up through my Google account, but can't get any apps to my Windows laptop there either.
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 09 '25
In order to have 2fa set up, you need to have an authenticator app on your phone in order to receive codes so you can log in.
→ More replies (3)
1
u/_Martosz Jul 04 '25 edited Jul 07 '25
So with the new messaging system, mod mail messages will be sent to the chat feature. But how would I link the chat?
I did some looking around, and I found two types of links that link to the mail:
https://chat.reddit.com/room/![random_code]%3Areddit.com
https://www.reddit.com/c/[chat_id]/s/[message_id]
Which should I use?
→ More replies (3)1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 09 '25
Hey! If you go to the chat window on desktop and hover over the message that you sent to the mods, you should see a link button. Click this to copy the link and add to your request. It should be something like:
1
u/rieferX Jul 06 '25
The automated u/request_bot comment still states the following: "Please do not use chat to message the current mods, use mod mail only."
However due to the recent changes made by Reddit, mod mails are now only allowing to send chat messages. Therefore how should one go about this?
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 09 '25
Hey thanks for flagging this, we are in the process of changing this statement in the comment so please continue to use the message the mods option in a community and copy the link from your chat window. You can also send a messaging using this link by typing in the subreddit name in the send to field.
1
u/JayWil1992 Jul 08 '25
how do you get a link to the modmail message? The messages go into the new chat and there's no way to get a link in the chat system?
2
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 10 '25
Hey I just updated the FAQ with instructions on how to do this. Let me know if you're having issues.
1
u/Inevitable-While-577 Jul 09 '25
Sucks how the mods won't answer questions. I'd like to know this, too.
→ More replies (2)2
u/JayWil1992 Jul 09 '25
Ok this is what I did:
You can open the chat, then go to the individual line item message, hold your finger on this until the menu pops up, Share, then copy the link
However the bot message when requesting specifically states it wants a message, not a chat so a bit confused here.
→ More replies (4)2
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 10 '25
Thanks for replying, I'm working on fixing that comment by the bot! Hope to have it updated soon, sorry for the confusion.
1
u/JayWil1992 Jul 09 '25
How do you send a message to the mods of a private sub? You can't
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 10 '25
If you go to compose a message here, you can type in the subreddit name and then copy the link from your chat window.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/DigmonsDrill Jul 10 '25
If I haven't gotten a response in a month, how can I bump the request?
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 11 '25
Thanks for flagging this u/DigmonsDrill, looks like that wasn't flagged to us. I've gone ahead and added you to the community.
1
u/SHIELD_Agent_47 Jul 16 '25
Almost three months ago, I requested r/Feixiao which has no moderators, but my post in this sub got no bot response at all, and when I tried to send a DM to this sub, the automated prompts gave me no option to describe my problem. May I humbly ask if my old request can be bumped somehow?
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 16 '25
Hey, can you try submitting another request for this please? It may have been lost amongst other requests. Thanks!
→ More replies (1)
1
u/SprintsAC Jul 17 '25
Hey u/GoldenNuggets-3000, sorry to bother you, but just to ask a quick question about the modmail to the subreddit we intend to request:
Is an acceptable modmail something along the lines of: "Hey there, I've noticed this subreddit is restricted & I'm interested in being made the new head moderator of this subreddit."?
I also have an issue where the head mod of said subreddit is camping on the subreddit (for 10+ years of it being restricted) & has blocked my account for whatever reason. What happens if a blocked user replies to the Reddit request? (I have absolutely no intention to work with said user, due to failure to remove pro-pedophilia content in other subreddits they moderate in).
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 17 '25
Hey u/SprintsAc, that mod mail should be good to send. It's mainly just to alert the mod team that you're interested in moderating and if you don't hear back in 5 days you will be submitting a request. If the moderator is genuinely interested in holding onto the subreddit and has intentions to grow it in the future then we won't be able to release it to a new mod, but if the mod team are not doing anything, we will most likely hand it off if we think you're the right fit for it. Hope this helps!
→ More replies (2)
1
u/Artisanalpoppies Jul 24 '25
The chatbot's have told me the sub i would like to moderate has human activity and therefore can't be done.
Can an actual human verify this please?
2
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 28 '25
It looks like this subreddit is actively moderated. I would recommend reaching out to the current mod and asking if they'd like to add you into the mod team. Thanks!
→ More replies (1)
1
u/SnooDonkeys9743 Jul 25 '25
Hi, I made a request for the johnadams subreddit and got no response. Did you receive my request?
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 28 '25
Hey it looks like you didn't link to the subreddit correctly. Please try posting again with the correct link to the community you'd like to moderate. If you have any issues let me know.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Immortan2 Jul 25 '25
Hi u/Goldennuggets-3000: writing here publicly because I am unsure how else to reach a Reddit admin. I filed a request in r/redditrequest. It was auto-denied due to immature account. My account is 3 years old with over 30,000 karma
Please forgive me if this has been asked elsewhere. Is there any remedy for this? Thanks in advance if you’re able to reply!
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 28 '25
Hey u/Immortan2, you need to have 100 comment karma and 100 post karma. It looks like you don't have enough Post karma to request a community.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Immortan2 Jul 28 '25
Good morning and thanks for the speedy reply this Monday morning.
Sorry if that answer was easy; I’m now on Reddit mobile and am unable to tell how much post karma I have. I’ve got a post with over 100 upvotes, but I know karma calculation is formulaic/non-linear. Looks like I’ll have to work on my OC game instead of reply-guy!
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 28 '25
Thanks for the reply! If you're on the mobile app:
Go to your profile and tap the about tab.
This is where you'll see the Post and comment karma breakdown. Hope this helps :)
1
u/Myithspa25 Jul 31 '25
I think you skipped a section, it keeps mentioning modmail links, but it doesn't say what the mail has to say, or who to send it to.
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 31 '25
The mod mail I was referring to in this post is the same as a chat message now. You can message the current mod team through chat and explain that you're interested in moderating the subreddit.
1
u/Myithspa25 Jul 31 '25
I'm not sure the moderators ever come online. I've sent a couple messages to them about posts, but no response after a couple days, and no action on the subreddit. Do I still need to send another message about moderating?
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Jul 31 '25
Yes, they might not be aware that you're interested in helping them moderate the community. They may be willing to add you into the mod team so it's always good to send a message. If they don't respond in 5 days, feel free to submit a request and we will review. Thanks!
→ More replies (2)
1
u/ho_merjpimpson Aug 14 '25
there are tons of instructions for requesting a community that has inactive mods, but there are no instructions for submitting a "top mod removal request"
this post only describes how to do it if you are a mod with everything permissions... but what if the top mod that is inactive is the only one with everything permissions?
do i just do it the normal way? it says numerous times that it will be denied if:
Your request may have been denied for several reasons:
Active Moderators: The community’s moderators are still actively moderating.
well, im an active moderator, trying to boot the inactive top mod, so "the community's moderators are still actively moderating."
im asking because i dont want to mess it up and wait another 15 days.
→ More replies (2)1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Aug 15 '25
If the mod is inactive in your community and across the site, u/request_bot will remove them when you make a request. If the mod is still active across the site, you will need to view this page for instructions on how to use the Self Serve Mod Reorder tool and/or receive admin assistance to help complete your request.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Acrobatic-Desk3266 Aug 15 '25
Are we required to message all the mods or any one of them? Thank you!
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Aug 18 '25
You just need to send a message to the subreddit's mod mail which will reach all mods listed in the community.
1
u/Speedwagon1935 Aug 16 '25
The bot issuing 2FA is bugged, I already have had 2FA set up and a verified email.
Just changed the email and verified yet another to see if that fixes this in the next 15 days.
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Aug 18 '25
If you didn't have 2FA set up or a verified email at the time of your request and the bot removed it, you should be able to request again once you add 2FA and verify your email. No need to wait 15 days.
→ More replies (1)
1
Aug 19 '25
HI, I'm the creator of r/lilsiep. I accidentally removed myself as moderator/admin and now I no longer have access to managing the subreddit. There are no other active moderators and I would like to return to administering the community I created.
I kindly ask the staff to reassign me the role of moderator. Thanks so much for the help!
1
1
u/Ok_Rule8747 Aug 19 '25
It meets all the requirements; however, when the post was sent, it showed up as being removed by Reddit's filter. I’ve tried contacting several mods and customer service, but haven’t received any response.
1
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Aug 19 '25
It looks like you don't have enough karma to request a community and that could explain why your post was removed. You need at least 100 post and 100 comment karma.
1
u/Last_Pay_8447 Aug 19 '25
Hi, I created r/catmemesandgifs a couple days ago and removed myself as the moderator. Is there anyway to get reinstated? I put in a request to take over the sub but I think I should have just asked here first. Thank you
1
1
u/UsualOil1130 Sep 01 '25
I have a quick question! The process bot removed my request because there's been "recent" human moderation, although it was just someone changing the description (there's been no moderation for up to three years before that however, and no comments or posts from the mods before or after). Does this still count as "active moderation"?
2
u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin Sep 02 '25
Hey! It looks like one of the mods is still actively moderating and doing more than just changing the description. I recommend reaching out to them directly to see if they'd be willing to add you to the mod team!
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Catchhawk Jun 05 '25
Do we still have to wait 15 days in between posting?
7
u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin Jun 05 '25
Yes.
4
u/MrJezza- Jun 20 '25
Hi, even though the post was removed by filters?
I meet all the requirements and I'm active, but it still gives me some problems.
3
u/snowlove Jun 06 '25
You omitted a requirement:
Verified E-mail address.
7
u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin Jun 06 '25
From the sidebar:
Your account must also have a verified email address and two-factor authentication enabled to ensure the safety of your account.
3
u/TheAeroGuy_007 Jun 06 '25
Hey mods I had requested a subreddit 3 days back and did a modmail to the one and only inactive mod of that sub...can u tell me what am I missing here?
3
u/Pinaslakan Jun 06 '25
You're not missing anything, the turn around time for manual reviewal of the request is 6 days.
That's why the new process will help lessen the waiting time to 2 days, following that you followed the requirements before.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/DefiantEvidence4027 Jun 17 '25
I sent a message; zero response,
https://old.reddit.com/message/messages/2y2oir6
Trying to figure out the 2fa ... If I understand it correctly, the inference is made I need to download something to a phone!?
3
u/Eggw1 Jul 08 '25
Bug:
It's impossible to request private subs because there's no "message the moderators" button.
You can't message them manually because the messages feature only allows messages to u/
I messaged using chat but can't copy the link.
2
3
u/_Vion_ Jul 18 '25 edited Jul 18 '25
Can anyone help me please?
16 days ago I submitted a request here but it was immediately deleted automatically. Today, after waiting 16 days I submitted another and the same happened. I've followed all the guidelines on the sticky. My post is: https://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/1lp2rc6/rvoge/
I opened a ticket per the mod mail automated response and never received a n answer :-(
3
3
u/quackfeathers Aug 04 '25
hello again, can the mods please address the issue many of us are getting with our requests being "Removed by Reddit’s filters”? It's been 8 days since I reached out through the modmail, to no avail.
3
u/beerion Aug 09 '25
My posts keep getting deleted by reddit filters. Any ideas? I added 2FA after the first post was removed. Do I need to wait 15 days before resubmitting?
3
u/knotty_fay Aug 09 '25
Hellooo u/GoldenNuggets-3000
Ive made several request for a subreddit the past few months with no comment response from the bot. I tried messaging it with no luck. Anything I need to do differently?
3
u/quackfeathers Aug 18 '25 edited Aug 22 '25
Hello again, 22 days ago I sent a redditrequest which got removed because of "Reddit's filters". My account fits the criteria and has 2FA activated. I've persistently been trying to message the modmail, to no avail, and comment here every now and then. Please get back to me
Edit: 23 days now.
- 24 days now.
- 25 days
- 26 days
2
u/WeeklyBanEvasion Jun 06 '25
Every single time I post a request my post is immediately removed by Reddit's filters. I've contacted via modmail a dozen times and even submitted tickets directly to reddit but can't get any human response.
Is there any chance of getting this corrected? Thanks!
2
u/DefiantEvidence4027 Jun 11 '25
If I'm understanding the 2FA process Correctly, I hope I remember my original password; I would like to say, if I disappear in 5 days, it's been fun.
2
u/Sir_Badtard Jun 25 '25
My post keeps getting auto removed by Reddits filters. I have MFA turned on and I think I meet all criteria. Any help?
2
u/ScarcityOk2982 Jun 27 '25
Where are the mods in here to help with requests that can't get past the bot? Mine keep getting removed
→ More replies (1)
2
u/kennyshits Jul 18 '25
Hi! Admin i have a request can you please back r/jollislut account
thank you!
2
u/MiaLilly Jul 20 '25
Hello,
I applied for r/spoink yesterday but the post was removed due to my lack of 2FA. I have now amended this and, based on similar experiences that I've read here, it should be okay to post once more regardless of the usual 15 day wait.
However, the bot has not responded to this newest request. Will this still be taken into consideration or does the bot need to respond to my post? I am aware of the current review time, just rather unsure with the lack of the bot.
2
u/souplover5 Aug 03 '25
How are we supposed to obtain a sub if every post gets “Removed by Reddit’s filters”? I meet all these requirements, have tried contacting the mods here multiple times, and I still can’t get human eyes on my request.
2
u/quackfeathers Aug 03 '25
I'm in the same boat as you, Reddit's been acting extremely iffy lately. They're tightening up their spam detection, to the point where it randomly starts affecting new and old users.
At this point, if you've messaged the mods, the only thing to do is to wait for someone to get back. I've already waited a week :/
→ More replies (1)
2
u/quackfeathers Aug 07 '25
hello again, this is my 11th day trying to get a response on this issue: submitted a request got removed because of "Reddit's filters"? My account fits the criteria and has 2FA activated.
2
u/zooted0321 Aug 27 '25 edited Aug 27 '25
Title: AdoptAPayPig
Flair: NSFW – Public
Hello, I’d like to request r/AdoptAPayPig. The subreddit has been inactive and I want to revive it into a thriving community for financial domination and paypig dynamics. My account is over 90 days old, I have the required karma, and 2FA is enabled. i also have many subreddits of my own .
I have sent modmail to the current moderators, but there has been no response. I would like to take over moderation to ensure the community is active and properly managed. . { i have ss proof of no response from a mod message i sent to both her self and the mod community from 107 days ago & just a few days ago as well . }
2
u/SailorGreySparrow Sep 02 '25
Hi, was going to make a request. But here’s the thing. I’m a totally blind screen reader user, and having to scan/import a passkey from another app is inaccessible. So, I take it that means, since Reddit’s form of two-factor authentification is inaccessible to me, I’m ineligible to request moderator privileges in an abandoned sub?
Please advise, as that seems slightly unfair.
2
u/SailorGreySparrow Sep 04 '25
Tagging u/Goldennuggets-3000 … and hopefully that brings about a mod(s) who has an answer. :)
2
u/FamIsNumber1 Sep 03 '25
Is there something that I missed with this new process? My post is showing that it still never activated & properly posted.
1
u/molive6316 Jun 06 '25
The link to the guide for enabling 2fa on Reddit.com takes me to my homepage.
3
u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin Jun 06 '25
Thanks for the heads up! We'll get that fixed.
2
3
1
u/ohwowwhatsgood Jun 06 '25 edited Jun 06 '25
Hi u/goldennuggets-3000 I made a request 24 days ago and it got removed immediately by u/request_bot. I tried the same thing 8 days ago and it still happened again.
I tried messaging the mods about this and I have not gotten a response. I keep getting automated responses from bots. Is there anyway I can know what I am doing wrong? I am so confused. I really would like to properly request a sub.
Thank you for your patience and help.
→ More replies (2)
1
u/SmallBatBigSpooky Jun 06 '25
These are solid changes
I would like to see better communication from you all on denials though
Like ive been trying to request a sub for months now after being asked to take it over and i always get a bot list of potential reasons, but then i see a month old account get some obscure porn sub in like 3 hours
It be nice to know what issues are actually at hand, as many of us who do request are trying to save dead communities
Besides that though i think the current changes being implemented are pretty solid
→ More replies (3)
1
u/Nkosi868 Jun 06 '25
Do I need to request again if I did a week ago and received no response?
2
u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin Jun 06 '25
Hi! Looks like the Mod Code of Conduct team is doing a public mod call for that subreddit. If you're interested in moderating, please comment on that post. Thanks!
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Nomis-Got-Heat Jun 07 '25
I had requested a sub about a week or so ago, but it looks like right after I posted, my request was deleted. I sent a modmail but no response. I was just trying to understand what was going on.
1
1
u/Papa_Chad Jun 07 '25
Question, if a reddit you are trying to obtain access and send a modmail to is restricted that clearly has been inactive, do I still need to make the attempt to modmail still? They give no option to modmail
→ More replies (2)
1
u/VictoryPurple7039 Jun 08 '25
Hey Admins please i just made a request post and it get removed by reddit filter, please what i have done wrong ?
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Rostingu2 Jun 09 '25
Regarding the reply requirement, what is the window to reply to the bot with the modmail link and the reason?
3
u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin Jun 09 '25
Before we review it.. lol But a user shouldn't be requesting a sub until at least 5 days after they have sent the modmail message. So replying to the bot right away seems like a good course of action?
1
u/Anakin_Kardashian Jun 10 '25
Is there a chance I can get an exception when the subreddit in question hasn't had a post in 3 years, only has 2 moderators, one moderator hasn't posted on reddit in 5 years, and the other moderator's only post in the last 2 years was a response 7 months ago in this subreddit saying "I don't want to hand over the community" when someone else requested the subreddit here? I sent the modmail yesterday, but it's very clear that the moderator(s) are just sitting on the subreddit, and I missed the deadline for the new rules by a couple days.
1
u/violentlycurly Jun 16 '25
My subreddit got banned for being unmoderated, even though I was and still am the moderator there. I don't really understand why it got banned. My request post here gets denied immediately before I get to explain, so I'm not sure what to do.
1
u/gk1400 Jun 17 '25
What is considered “recent human moderation activity”? For example, a sub had their “Wiki” section edited 2 months ago, but no actual moderator comments since 89 days ago. What length of time until the moderation activity is no longer considered recent?
1
u/Difficult-Common9858 Jun 19 '25
Hi! Admin i have a request can you please back r/jollislut account
thank you!
1
u/Iissomeoneelse Jun 20 '25
Hi, I'ld like to know what can be done in case you want to request a community whose moderators, negligent to the point of forcing Reddit to ban the page for lack of moderation and tyrannical towards users, have banned you
And I was actually banned after requesting it believing it wasn't well moderated...
1
u/laeiryn Jun 25 '25
Request post disappeared immediately after posting, as did the modmail I sent, not locatable in my inbox - how do I post the link to the modmail I sent after it vanished and I can't access my own message? Aaaand where's my post to comment it to in the first place? I can't even access it through my own page.
1
u/Secure-Disaster-7149 Jun 25 '25
I still have not heard anything from the Reddit Request Review team regarding my request and it has been about a month. It needs reviewed by the team because the moderator is still inactive and has not given a reason why they want to continue moderating especially since they are not even moderating it.
1
u/cobb_highway Jun 26 '25
If the subreddit has no moderators, you can skip this step.
If a subreddit has multiple moderators listed - but they all have suspended accounts, do I still have to go through the process of sending the modmail message?
Or is this counted as not having moderators?
1
u/Advanced-Bag9544 Jun 28 '25
Ok, so if I don’t have 100 points I cannot submit request that no one is moderating a forum that is supposed to be SFW and all post are mostly boo bs?? So what, you will just let it be as is because I read Reddit and not comment that much??? /this community
→ More replies (1)
1
u/dodriohedron Jun 29 '25
It looks like all messaging has now been replaced by chat. Whenever I message the moderators, all it creates is an entry in chat, instead of an actual sent message.
Will links to chat messages work just as well as links to messages? If not, how can I send an old style message?
1
1
u/Original_Capital4532 Jul 05 '25
I’m confused I’ve submitted 2 requests and they get denied I don’t understand why
1
u/Iissomeoneelse Jul 07 '25
I'ld like to know what can be done in case you want to request a community whose moderators, negligent to the point of forcing Reddit to ban the page for lack of moderation and tyrannical towards users, have banned you
And I was actually banned after requesting it believing it wasn't well moderated...
1
u/Relative-Cricket-543 Jul 09 '25
Hi. I am locked out of my main account and not sure why. I was the only active mod on my sub, but there are two others. My preference is to get back into my old account and get back to modding... Is there a way to do this? I don't know how or why my account is locked. Thanks.
1
u/AppleTreeBlue Jul 09 '25 edited Jul 09 '25
@goldennuggets-3000
Is the automated rejection bot refusing valid requests?
I have 987 post karma, 870 comment karma, I have the 5 year club badge.
I was refused my reddit request to take over r/dearalice which is sorely in need of a moderator, the moderator seems absent. I sent 2 mod mail messages with no response (I linked them in my comment on my reddit request post). Much needs updating in the description, pictures etc and some posters need protecting in case of scams etc
I have recently started a sub, so it isn't that I am not eligible to moderate.
Please let me know if you need anything more to prove my eligibility.
Thank you
Edit: I also have 2FA enabled.
The refusal response I received seemed generic and non-specific
Link to the post on redditrequest so you can see my request, the automated refusal and my comment with reasons for my application and also the links to sent modmail: https://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/s/VafhdXpKYA
2
u/JaydyGaga88 Jul 09 '25
Hey! I've sent you a Chat message, I was made a new moderator for the dearALICE subreddit a few hours ago by Goldennuggets-3000 and the old inactive moderators have been removed. I would be happy to invite you to moderate with me ☺️
→ More replies (1)
31
u/cacille Jun 05 '25
Have you added anything to your processes to suss out mods that are using bots to keep their accounts active but whom are not moderating their communities? I know of three groups run by two different mod that are doing this, one of whom is using the Redact bot to do so.
Both mods are not active/engaged. To me, one is seemingly camping, and one is definitely a marketing spammer.