r/redditguild • u/[deleted] • Sep 26 '11
Code of Conduct
It doesn't really matter what I say or not anymore, because I will no doubt be forever be remembered as "that butthurt scrub who left guild because he wasnt invited to a raid".
I'd just like to say that being told I can't come to a group for vague "badness" after seeing another guild member turned down in a much more polite manner was a clear sign to me that I wasn't wanted in the guild.
Sure, the habitual insults and attacks that occurred beforehand might have been in violation of the code of conduct too, but I guess it's only my own fault for assuming that said prior cruelty was only in jest.
And Alannii, I'm really sorry for abandoning the guild after agreeing to join your raid team, but the unhospitable environment of <reddit> just isn't worth my continued time.
Inb4 further ad hominem attacks in flagrant violation of guild policy.
13
u/honusnuggie Honu, Honu Sep 26 '11
The policy is about guild chat.
If you wipe my 5man group a bunch, I would have no problem telling you in a whisper that you are not receiving an invite for the hardest boss in the game, in a pug, for reasons of badness. Guildy or not, that isn't a violation. That is just real talk.
No one broke the CoC.
For the record: I didn't have anything to do with this fiasco. For once >.>
7
u/willdabeast20 Padrice, Paddeh, Quit WoW to play with his firehose Sep 26 '11
Why not? You should have.
1
u/jba Gdiaf* Sep 27 '11
Also had nothing to do with this fiasco, but the CoC policies (in particular, "don't be a dick") should be extended to all guild communication, external too, and certainly not just /gu. No one should be allowed to be a dick just because it happened in /tells.
/offsoapbox
1
u/honusnuggie Honu, Honu Sep 27 '11
Telling someone they are bad, when they are, is real talk. If said person is too sensitive for reality, then their perception of "being a dick" is skewed and should be regarded thusly.
5
u/jba Gdiaf* Sep 27 '11
/backonsoapbox
ok, but like with any communication, tone matters as much as content. Saying "you suck" is shitty and antisocial versus saying "sorry, we're gonna take someone else, but maybe i can help with your (rotation|survivability|etc) sometime soon".
Especially in a guild as large as ours, it's best to err on the side of helpfulness over (perhaps) brutal honesty.
IMHO, of course.
1
-4
Sep 26 '11 edited Sep 26 '11
The rejection wasn't in violation of the CoC. It was the name-calling, ad hominem attacks, and miscellanious dickery that followed my departure.
So yeah, people did break the CoC. Just not the person who turned me down.
10
u/honusnuggie Honu, Honu Sep 26 '11
and they were all reprimanded. But you wouldn't know that, since you were blathering your self-pity and then /gquitting. Tymo was on they ass.
2
5
u/tide19 Carsyn (RIP) Sep 26 '11
Which raid were you turned down for?
5
1
Sep 26 '11
It doesn't really matter. Being told that I was just bad when another guildie inquiring for the same spot was given a real explanation is why I left, not because of which raid it was or the fact that I was rejected.
6
u/tide19 Carsyn (RIP) Sep 26 '11
Ah, I was just curious. Good luck in your future endeavors and such.
6
u/whitecheddar Vesperya, Kessera Sep 26 '11
tl;dr: http://i.imgur.com/d47iE.png
3
u/tide19 Carsyn (RIP) Sep 26 '11
Why you so mean bro? Don't you have more productive things to do like talk Jeffy outta selling his laptop?
4
u/whitecheddar Vesperya, Kessera Sep 26 '11
Flatha and Jayrun not being here. Let's just take a week off
3
u/whitecheddar Vesperya, Kessera Sep 26 '11
OR you can tank and I can play Jayrun's priest and we just need to pug a dps then.
-5
Sep 26 '11
This kind of immaturity is why I left. It's even in violation of the guild code of conduct, which you ostensibly need to agree to in order to join the guild.
8
Sep 26 '11
Isn't the #1 rule to "Not Be A Dick" and I'm pretty sure every SINGLE time someone asked a question, you responded sarcastically and provided no help whatsoever. You violated the CoC the entire time...?
2
8
u/mystikraven Infestatión, Tigol Sep 26 '11
I have witnessed you "being a dick" in /g on countless occasions, whether by the tone of your conversation, the manner in which you spoke to others, or just general rudeness. I don't think you quite have the right to call people out on CoC violations.
In the long run, of course, it's irrelevant.
7
u/withmymagazines Magazines, Publications Sep 27 '11
The same kind of immaturity you threw around /g every time you were on or a question was brought up? I may have only ever ran 1 pug with you but I still remember the incessant douchebaggery you threw in their direction. You gotta give to get and the whole principle of "karma" should be somewhat underlined as a concept to go by for a REDDIT guild.
This game is social, people are social, if it wasn't for the social group I've found her I wouldn't be playing this game. You kinda brought nothing to that and brought a lot of people down - often. It was noted by many.
I'm not trying to be a dick, and to each his own, but if you wan't an explanation for how you've been received and make a thread about it, there it is. For a LIFE LESSON, if you're going to be a dick to others and joke around you need to be aware of when it's gone too far or it's not being received as a joke.
Because seriously man, you acted like the 13y/o XBLive meme kid. Redbook out.
9
16
u/beeblez Tymoshenko, Will Return, Currently a Slave to life Sep 27 '11
Ok, I feel obligated to weigh in as I was the mod around when most of this went down. Although I missed the initial comment completely.
I agree, some people said some stuff to you that flew in the face of the CoC, and I did try to reign that in. I really did. I don't think you saw a lot of it because you were busy gquitting on all your characters, often with a remark about how much <reddit> is a bunch of jerks before you quit on that char. I should have maybe stepped in sooner, but I was watching TV and leveling herbalism, and wasn't super on top of gchat.
You also need to realize you really provoked it. The initial comment that set you off wasn't super polite, no. But it was hardly CoC shattering. If you had talked to a mod in tells or spoken to me when I offered to get involved, ideally it could have all be resolved there.
You kept on talking about it for almost HALF AN HOUR across several characters. I know this because I was thinking about accepting that Rag invite on my hunter when I saw you volunteer, decided to watch the daily show instead, and had enough time to watch an entire broadcast of that show before I started getting involved with guild chat again and realized how out of hand it was getting.
I repeatedly asked you to take it to tells, and to stop creating drama in gchat. You ignored this. You continued to be very upset in guild chat about what one guild member out of hundreds said. I specifically told you to take it to tells before the peanut gallery chimed in, and you ignored this advice until eventually, the peanut gallery did chime in.
You kept on asking people, again and again, "why I'm bad" and eventually multiple someone gave you a pretty detailed break down of their negative experiences with you in a PVE environment. I don't think I've ever raided with you so I can't confirm the accuracy of their statements. However having your question answered certainly didn't calm the situation down, and why would it? You were literally asking people to say negative things about you, it was only a matter of time until they obliged.
That was where it really started to get messy, and where people in guild chat REPEATEDLY tried to change the subject, to move on, and to stop the discussion. This is also where I started warning people to knock off the impolite language.
The discussion persisted, with no small help from you egging it on and not taking it to tells. By then you were chain quitting on your characters and all I could do was sternly warn people to stop with the rude remarks while you were quitting.
In summation, while I feel like some people were out of line, and told them as much, you very actively encouraged this, long after the person who originally offended you had stopped being involved in the conversation because they wanted to de-escalate the situation
Sometimes part of acting like an adult is knowing when to walk away. Knowing when a battle isn't worth fighting. Maybe I should have been more direct in telling you to drop the matter earlier, and I regret that I wasn't. Some arguments aren't about who is right and who is wrong, they're about who is silent and who is not, I really think this could have been avoided if you just took it to tells!
To use the phrase, "it takes two to tango."
7
u/honusnuggie Honu, Honu Sep 27 '11
Strawberry Rhubarb dude. Strawberry Rhubarb. This should be the new guild "safe-word"
2
u/beeblez Tymoshenko, Will Return, Currently a Slave to life Sep 27 '11
I am all kinds of down with this plan.
1
6
u/jba Gdiaf* Sep 27 '11
but I was watching TV and leveling herbalism
That's a euphemism for something, right?
(ps, while i know little about what happened, this is a spot-on response in tone and content; well done.)
9
Sep 26 '11
I don't know what happened but I am really sorry you found <reddit> to be inhospitable. It's certainly not the vibe we want.
7
u/skarface6 Lonepine, canceled sub Sep 26 '11
Welp! Sorry you found the guild this way. I hope it's all Lurral's fault. Lurral is mean. Almost as mean as James Wilson.
0
10
u/willdabeast20 Padrice, Paddeh, Quit WoW to play with his firehose Sep 26 '11
If your raid leader so deemed you were bad, then you had two options. You could have explained to him why you were not bad. Or you could have butthurt ragequit the guild. You obviously chose the latter.
6
3
u/Kalima Suffyr Sep 27 '11
Thankfully as the harshest raid leader, i have nothing to do with this.
1
u/withmymagazines Magazines, Publications Sep 27 '11
ThankfullyUnfortunately as the harshest raid leader, i have nothing to do with this.FTFY
1
u/Kalima Suffyr Sep 27 '11
no no, if they are not on my team, they are above my criticism. I would never say anything personally hurtful or destructive to the guild in public.
5
Sep 26 '11
Since you started a post-departure drama thread, I'm gonna side with the mockers on this one.
9
5
u/ThatBritishKid Adam Sep 26 '11
"that butthurt scrub"
FTFY
-3
u/Nerdragemoar Amazinghuece,Tektronik, Baggedmilkqt, and King of Timeout Sep 26 '11
He's mad cuz he's bad
3
2
u/gravesend Sep 27 '11
. . . trembel
1
Sep 27 '11
I upvote this so hard, my upvote gave birth to a comment, and that comment shat a second comment.
2
1
0
10
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '11
There is a lot of offensive trolling going on here. Be nice people :D