r/redditguild • • Dec 30 '10

Guild Reputation!

This is not a reflection of our progression, or ability to kite hard mobs. This is only to do with player conduct and attitude.


On the server, generally speaking, ours sucks. I know we've got ourselves a pretty big guild and all, but we still need the rest of the wow community on Sargeras to get along with us. All we have is a big guild. We do not currently have a respectable guild. This is our fault. We need to improve.

I think we all need to go back to the CoC and take a long look at it, instead of just scrolling to the bottom and replying with a signature.

I'm not here with the beatstick or here to point fingers... but I am here to ask everyone in the guild to be more aware of the fact that other players have more negative things to say about <reddit> tagged members than they have positive things to say.

This is not a "haters gonna hate" situation. This is a situation where we've got too many extremely childish members out there doing extremely childish things in-game. Be nice to others who are outside the guild, be respectful of everyone.

  • Carry yourself as though you're proud of yourself and your guildmates...

  • Do well in dungeons and pvp.

  • Don't bot. ever.

  • Stop naming your characters stupid shit like: 'Goodweed', 'CaptnNuggz' and 'Buttz' ... I, for one, will not invite characters that have names designed to be overtly annoying/stupid or sound like you were actually high when you named them. (if you really want screenshots from Goodweed explaining how fucking high he is, I can do that... but for now just let the point stand)

  • Stop Trolling public channels (stop trolling guild chat and /reddit)

I really like the reddit guild, and most of you are good people/players. Please help me show the rest of the server that they get the wrong impression of us as a group from a tiny handful of mouthy retards that we haven't weeded out yet.

Edit, PS: This is not a reflection of our progression, or ability to kite hard mobs. This is only to do with player conduct and attitude.

Edit 2: If you like to get fucking wasted and log into WoW, please try to stay out of guildchat until you've had yourself some coffee. It's for the same reason that you came straight home from the bar: You didn't want to get yourself into trouble by hanging out there/driving around while wasted. We don't mind that people get drunk as hell while playing warcraft, but we do acknowledge it does increase your standing on the 'Don't Give a Fuck' leaderboard.

2 Upvotes

90 comments sorted by

7

u/obrion Dec 30 '10 edited Dec 30 '10

Honestly who cares what people name their toon, it's after all a video game (SHOCK). I know a lot of people in /r/trees that think you are in fact being a "hater." Most people play games to take a break from the stress they deal with all day. So hell they might smoke a bowl and name their toon Lemonhaze or might have a drink a two. But to think that our guild reputation is on the line and "OMG nobody likes us because reddit player X plays wow high" is just lame. If you want a top class guild then gquit and start a recruitment process and only recruit top players.

Guild reputation is what it is. That shouldn't stop you from doing what you want to do. Go slay your dragons or go be successful in pvp, it's not going to matter what you have as your guild tag. With 400 + people and you are going to see all sorts of things you don't like. People are going to suck, people are going to troll, people are going to smoke weed and drink (OMG). Just let it be, enjoy your time in WoW and stop wasting your time.

-5

u/dorklogic Dec 30 '10

I was ready to invite Goodweed to the guild until he started asking every moderator who was currently signed on for the invite because he was 'so high he forgot who he was talking to'

Do you see the difference, there?

There's a huge difference in people talking about and doing shit that I dont neccessarily agree with and people talking about and doing shit that the majority of the players online at the time disagree with.

Do you see there difference there?

I've already addressed the fact that people can come in and be as high or wasted as they want, as long as it doesnt cause any strife for the rest of the guild. Same reason bartenders ask some drunks to leave the bar they've just had drinks at: Causing more disturbance than their presence is worth.

"Guild reputation is what it is. that shouldn't stop you from doing what you want to do." It does stop players from doing what they want to do when the <reddit> tag means we go into every PuG being looked down on, or not invited to the PuG at all because some dickweed talked a bunch of shit to the person running the PuG a few days prior and was in <reddit>.

People can suck, that's fine. People cannot troll... because it leads to drama, and it's compeltely unneccessary. Go to /b/ if you want to get your troll on that badly.

People can smoke weed and drink, just dont let it fuck with your guildmates' experience in the dungeon/battleground/server.

Just letting it be is what has caused the recent Timeouts, guild kicks, gquits and drama mongering. I want to go back to letting it be, but right now we're not in a position to do this.

I do want to be in a top class guild. As I said in OP: "This is not a reflection of progression." I want to be in a Top Guild that is respected for member behavior... regardless of how many times we have or have not killed Cho'Gall.

10

u/obrion Dec 30 '10

I was ready to invite Goodweed to the guild until he started asking every moderator who was currently signed on for the invite because he was 'so high he forgot who he was talking to'

Who cares I do this all the time. And since when does anyone have the right to say who gets in to Reddit and who doesn't. If you see a potential problem how about send a private message saying your concerns.

There's a huge difference in people talking about and doing shit that I dont neccessarily agree with and people talking about and doing shit that the majority of the players online at the time disagree with.

So someone has to agree with the majority of the guild's ways or views to be accepted.. WTF.. lol

People cannot troll

Nowhere in the COC does it say people cannot troll. Being a dick and Trolling are not the same. If you cannot take an occasional troll and just laugh it off, MMO's are probably not for you.

Reddit Guild does not need to be fucking Candy Land.

6

u/RomansRedditAcc Romand Dec 30 '10

And only 3-4 months ago, you could message any mod and say, "Hey you fucker, invite me" and they would invite you

3

u/mystikraven Infestatión, Tigol Dec 31 '10

You are wrong for not inviting someone based on their name or sobriety.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10

I was ready to invite Goodweed to the guild until he started asking every moderator who was currently signed on for the invite because he was 'so high he forgot who he was talking to'

So? That's part of your job.

There's a huge difference in people talking about and doing shit that I dont neccessarily agree with and people talking about and doing shit that the majority of the players online at the time disagree with.

'The majority of players online' and how they feel is extremely subjective and difficult to measure and is insufficient evidence to base any kind of serious argument on.

I've already addressed the fact that people can come in and be as high or wasted as they want, as long as it doesnt cause any strife for the rest of the guild. Same reason bartenders ask some drunks to leave the bar they've just had drinks at: Causing more disturbance than their presence is worth.

Forgetting which moderator they talked to is hardly 'strife.' Calling that 'strife' is probably offensive to those who have experienced real strife in their lives.

It does stop players from doing what they want to do when the <reddit> tag means we go into every PuG being looked down on, or not invited to the PuG at all because some dickweed talked a bunch of shit to the person running the PuG a few days prior and was in <reddit>.

Does reddit exist as a guild to please puggers? I think a better solution would be for the leadership to encourage more reddit only groups and for members to step up and lead them themselves. Worrying about what the rest of the server thinks of one guild versus another based on anectdotal evidence is a losing game.

People can suck, that's fine. People cannot troll... because it leads to drama, and it's compeltely unneccessary. Go to /b/ if you want to get your troll on that badly.

Very true. Trolling can lead to drama - as do consecutive drama posts on the subreddit like we've seen recently.

People can smoke weed and drink, just dont let it fuck with your guildmates' experience in the dungeon/battleground/server.

I agree with the intent here but it's very difficult to define exactly how something "fucks with someone else's experience." That's far too subjective for a group of moderators and leadership to stress over. As Croswell suggested, members also need to take it upon themselves to make use of the ignore function instead of relying solely on moderators to do it for them.

I do want to be in a top class guild. As I said in OP: "This is not a reflection of progression." I want to be in a Top Guild that is respected for member behavior... regardless of how many times we have or have not killed Cho'Gall.

This is an impossible goal as it's conditions for success are impossible to objectively measure in any meaningful way.

The truth is that the greater WoW community is far more likely to consider a guild a "Top Guild" based on raid progress more than anything else.

1

u/elevatedhobo Cayrute, Crayute Dec 30 '10

This is an impossible goal as it's conditions for success are impossible to objectively measure in any meaningful way. The truth is that the greater WoW community is far more likely to consider a guild a "Top Guild" based on raid progress more than anything else.

First, objective measurement of success does not make this goal possible or impossible.

The goal if anything as far as i can tell would be to promote a sense of happiness when you find yourself in a group with a <reddit>. Which i find to be completely desirable as opposed to being pegged as incompetent, obnoxious or otherwise loathsome at first glance because of the actions of other players.

4

u/RomansRedditAcc Romand Dec 30 '10

~400 unique people in Reddit

Fact that 9/10 if you are looking at a guild tag its because they are being a jerk.

even if only 1% is a jerk, that is 4 people spreading the disease.

As a Whole, nobody has ever came to me and said my guild sucked, or were dicks, every time someone mentioned it was a positive situation.

-2

u/dorklogic Dec 30 '10

By your numbers, that's 4 people I would LOVE to remove from the guild if I had a name and Screenshot evidence.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10

Just a couple things. First, I really hope this trend isn't going to end up affecting the previously declared policy regarding world PvP, which is basically that it's completely allowed in all cases. Ganking, etc.

Second,

Stop naming your characters stupid shit...

Really? I'm not an admin, I didn't roll a year ago and know the guild when it was "awesome." But I really think it's going a little bit too far when you start imposing guidelines like this. I would ask you admins to take a step back and maybe consider allowing the guild to grow into something new and positive and different than before, instead of constantly bitching and doing whatever you can to beat it back into the same shape you were so comfortable with before. More bonsai, less topping.

Enforce don't-be-a-dick, both in and out of guild? Sure. Telling people what they can/can't name their characters and that they should consider their speech to be monitored and potentially subject to penalties at all times and in all contexts? Paternalistic. Just my two cents.

0

u/dorklogic Dec 30 '10

First, I really hope this trend isn't going to end up affecting the previously declared policy regarding world PvP, which is basically that it's completely allowed in all cases. Ganking, etc.

Sorry, forgot to address this: PVP IS PVP... you can do whatever the hell you want there as long as you don't spam chat buffers with /spit emotes (sure you can /spit, but don't make a macro that spams it 1000 times per minute)

Camp them. Fuck them over. It's a bloody fucking war and that's what people expect when they engage in player versus player combat.

-2

u/dorklogic Dec 30 '10

Names designed to be trolls in and of themselves should not be allowed. Most of the ones we've recently had to turn away were almost immediately caught by Blizzard's GMs as well.

We're not going to be telling people what to think, we are going to be asking that people consider names that aren't "designed to be overtly annoying/stupid or sound like you were actually high when you named them."

Now don't get me wrong about these silly hippies with their marijuana-based names. I love me some Pot... but I leave it in the smoking room... I don't get in game and start explaining to people how amazingly high I am and I don't let it make me start doing 1200 dps in a heroic, either. That is the essence of what I'm bringing up... it's just the r/trees mentality is to fight for the magical plant first, and not step back and understand that there's a bigger picture here.

3

u/jimmyjango42 Dec 30 '10

Bigger picture?

People brag about drinking all the time in guild chat. There's nothing wrong with it, we all have a good time.

Personally, people who play out the stoner stereotypes strike me as counter-productive, but other than that why is it bad when people like to express their preference for Jane?

It isn't about the bigger picture (if it were, we wouldn't be playing a video game) but more about just not acting like an idiot.

Of course, it's up to the mods to decide what exactly that is, but we need to be considerate of all sides (except trolls).

11

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 30 '10 edited Dec 30 '10

I blame everyone in this guild for our problems. You let this happen <reddit>. Yes, you did. EVERY LAST ONE OF YOU. New members, old members, mods, AND admins.

This is reddit.com. Community policing is the complete and utter essence of this entire damn site. We are a guild based on this site. Start acting like it you damn pansies. If you are a regular member, anytime you see someone being a fucker in gchat. PUT THEM ON IGNORE. I (and all mods / admins) don't have that privilege. We have to keep our eyes on gchat whenever possible because of this rampant BULLSHIT.

If no one responds to their trolls, if they can't get a group because they were a douche, THEY WILL STOP BEING FUCKHEADS. If everyone puts that assclown shit monger on ignore, they will STFU or Gquit eventually. The problem would solve itself. But noooooooo, you lazy fuckers rely on mods and admins to do this shit for you. Why? Take some personal fucking responsibility <reddit>. Pull your heads out of your asses.

It makes me sick just thinking of how awesome this guild used to be. It makes me sad that some people decide their particular version of LAWL TROLLIN is funny. To those "trolls", I want to be perfectly clear.

KNOCK IT OFF YOU FUCKING MORONS.

Otherwise, I swear on baby raptor jesus I will go rogue and start gkicking every last one of you annoying fuckers. You're not following the rules for members, so maybe I won't feel that I need to follow the admin rules either. Wouldn't that be fun? Probably not. So how about you all just knock it the fuck off.

Gaming is how I (and all mods / admins) relax. Stop being shitheads or I'm going to create a new guild and only invite awesome people. (I know, COUP! /stabinface.)

/Pissed off Cros is pissed off and sick of this shit.

edit: In before "needs moar random caps and bolding"

3

u/RomansRedditAcc Romand Dec 30 '10

LB was a pretty big troll in his time.

3

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 30 '10

I used to love a good troll. I would pick a band I knew LB loved and say how I heard this one song and ZOMG it was bad. He would get up in arms, I would call him Emo, and we would laugh after he spent a good 30 seconds listing on why they were awesome and how he wasn't emo.

However, this new form of "trolling" apparently consists of being a complete fucking douche and then saying "LUL TROLLED YOU ALL I AM SO CLEVUR!" It has taken away any chance at a reasonable discussion between guild members.

1

u/spewerOfRandomBS Dec 30 '10

Well now, tell us how you really feel!

3

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 30 '10

I feel great. I've been holding that in for awhile. I typed up a drunken rant last weekend, but I decided against posting it. Now I got to exercise those emotions a bit, and I don't even feel that I said anything worth having remorse over. :)

1

u/spewerOfRandomBS Dec 30 '10

No worries brah. It's good to get it out sometimes.

I feel ya though, I will tell someone (privately) that a comment they made in gchat or elsewhere isn't appreciated or that they need to tone it down.

Ignore really is a last resort, I have a thick skin.

2

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 30 '10

Personally, I think calling them out in public is a better idea. Stir up that mob mentality a bit. Get the hivemind offended, possibly even make someone think "shit, maybe that was out of line."

To each their own though. :)

1

u/ViskoOnkh Dec 30 '10

As a fellow member of reddit and a none <reddit> member my general consensus of <reddit> is negative. I have run across many <reddit> members being douchebags in game.

What was really disheartening to me is when I tried to get a couple of my wow buddies to read reddit.com they were initially turned off because of the bad taste <reddit> gave to them. But they are lurkers now!

0

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10

[deleted]

2

u/dorklogic Dec 30 '10

This guild is too large (relatively speaking) to maintain the extreme hands-off policy the leadership first adopted.

I think we need to review our member base, and clean house where needed... and then I whole-heartedly want us to go back to the hands off approach. Now is simply not the time for it.

3

u/spewerOfRandomBS Dec 30 '10

There needs to be a balance, obvious violations of CoC being ignored would just result in anarchy.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10

he cause of the 'hands off' approach is that there was an idea that we can please everyone best if we let everyone moderate themselves. It's a fairy tale.

The idea that you could ever please everyone is the fairy tale. This applies to those who are trolling too much and for those who need thicker skins.

I realize that people who troll too much can be a disservice to the guild as a whole but so can those who seem to be offended by everything.

0

u/beerisoptional Texun Dec 31 '10

Is it really being "offended" if you're just annoyed? Let me clarify that I'm not easily offended as most people that have talked with me in mumble can attest. I think people use the, "thin skin" defense much too often to justify their outrageous behavior. Just because I'm annoyed at snotfucker that can't stop trolling gchat doesn't mean I have thin skin.

The line does have to be drawn somewhere. No matter what the decision is someone's on the other side of it. The key is to remain consistent and to limit favoritism as best as possible.

6

u/insertnounhere Luna* Dec 30 '10

Being myself, I always try and be friends to everyone. I try and show everyone support and encourage them with a "grats" or some variation there of for every single achievement. If this childish behavior in gchat keeps up... it will make for a very unhappy Luna who is not at all hesitant to put people in time out or even gremove them.

You've all been warned. You don't want to see me pissed off.

Stop your constant "trolling" and negative comments. Think about what you say before you say it, remember the adage "if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all". This not saying anything at all will be enforced with timeout.

Most importantly, remember the number one rule or <reddit> is don't be a dick. Live it, love it, get used to it.

4

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 30 '10 edited Dec 30 '10

If we had more Lunas, this would not even be an issue. Strive to be more like Luna.

Except the whole living with and possibly having adult relations with Faust. That would be weird...

3

u/deebags Dec 30 '10

If there was a redditguild bestof'ed This would be at the top of the list. That should be our guild motto for the next month. WHAT WOULD LUNA DO?!

0

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10

[deleted]

4

u/dorklogic Dec 30 '10

I picture a man named Faust standing in front of the mirror stating this several times before heading out every morning.

3

u/PPSF Para Dec 30 '10

Come on, dude. You're at least supposed to make a fake account!

6

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10

I rejoined WoW with the g/f and specifically went with <reddit> because of the "Don't be a dick." rule. Responsible enforcement of that policy can only be a good thing!

3

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10

Ditto.

3

u/Do_your_homework Dec 30 '10

I'm about to do the same.

We just want people that are fun to play with.

1

u/koreanforrabbit Frandrescher Dec 30 '10

Me three.

2

u/spewerOfRandomBS Dec 30 '10

You are never around to grats me on my achievements!

I got one the other night and it was awesome! I don't remember what it was but I am sure it was awesome!

1

u/insertnounhere Luna* Dec 30 '10

I've been around, but trying to keep tabs on <subreddit> and only one or two people will be my friend in that guild. =(

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10

I got my first Luna "grats". It actually meant quite a bit! So thanks!

1

u/insertnounhere Luna* Dec 31 '10

You're welcome :)

2

u/RomansRedditAcc Romand Dec 30 '10

We all love you Luna. We all got your back.

1

u/deebags Dec 30 '10

We were talking about this earlier. We picture Lunas as the guilds little sister. No one fucks with Luna. Ever. Bad things happen to those who do. Bad... Things...

1

u/spewerOfRandomBS Dec 30 '10

You hold him, I'll go get the torches.

15

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 30 '10 edited Dec 30 '10

Separate reply for a different issue:

Nothing in the CoC regulates naming of toons. I'm not saying CaptnNuggz is a great name. I'm saying that acceptable names are not something that has ever been discussed as a guild rule.

We're not an RP guild. We're not an RP server. I've seen some absolutely ridiculous names on some great people. If you have not invited people for stupid names, that is not cool. Novelty names are a big part of reddit, and people should not be prejudiced for them. Don't let your personal feeling become your personal Code of Conduct rules. Stick to the black and white. Gray areas can be discussed, but until they become officially part of the Code, they're not rules.

2

u/mystikraven Infestatión, Tigol Dec 31 '10

This post needs to be removed or hidden or a new post needs to be made. Arathias is a Moderator, meaning he cleans up the bank and follows the CoC for inviting people. Nothing more. This needs to be squelched.

3

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 31 '10 edited Dec 31 '10

Negative. We don't censor things like that. As long as they post under a main account, and it is related to guild business / affairs, we as admins let it be.

It promotes discussion at the very least.

quick edit: I think the original post is obviously an opinion post. If people disagree, then my above response makes it clear that the naming convention is not official policy.

2

u/mystikraven Infestatión, Tigol Dec 31 '10

You miss my point. You absolutely need to make it clear to new players (to the guild) that their name is not affected by our CoC, just Blizzard's ToS.

2

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 31 '10 edited Dec 31 '10

No, I see your point. I don't think you're considering the admin's point of view though. We get enough ZOMG censorship flak from the basic CoC enforcement we have been doing.

Mod powers / duties are laid out here:Rank Structure. They do not make new policies.

Rather than delete a post and cause a "ZOMG GESTAPO SUBREDDIT ADMIN CENSORSHIP BASTARDS" situation, we let the community discuss, and they policed it themselves. I corrected one misconception that may have been taken by a new member. The post was downvoted like mad, and that should be enough. It will drop off the page in time just like prior "end of the world" style posts have.

Everyone has a right to complain. Even mods and admins. I think most admins are more careful because of the shiny pretty names, but becoming a mod does not mean you don't get to express your opinion anymore.

edit - I did bold-ify and reformat my original reply to make it more clear. Just for your sexy self. ;) /rawr

2

u/mystikraven Infestatión, Tigol Dec 31 '10

Hence why i said "or make a new post."

Arathias is a Moderator. New players could mistakenly see that position as a position of power and authority and will take what they say as "rules." This is not a rule, and it needs to be made fucking clear.

I don't give a shit about opinions, I give a shit about misrepresentation. You guys obviously have a double standard in place.

1

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 31 '10 edited Dec 31 '10

We do not need a new post.

We have a post.

2

u/mystikraven Infestatión, Tigol Dec 31 '10

Again missing my point, lol.

Whenever someone makes a misleading post on the front page of our subreddit, a counter-post reminding people of the truth is almost necessary. The sidebar doesn't get read as much as posts on the front page.

Plus, that CoC doesn't mention anything about player names.

1

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 31 '10

Exactly. It doesn't mention anything about playing drunk, talking about weed, or organizing religious rites via gchat either. If a rule is not present, there are no rules.

Again, I do actually see your point. If admins were required to respond to every post that was made with an erroneous fact with a post of our own, we would be making a re-post directed at half the stuff that was posted. I agree that as a mod, maybe it wasn't the smartest post to make. However, your argument that a new player would be confused is flawed. If they're a new player, they've read the CoC.

I made a reply with my shiny fancy "admin" name to the post, and after listening to what you had to say, I bold-ified my post to make it very clear. More than that is making unnecessary waves. If another admin disagrees, I'd be more than happy to discuss it, but as none have (at least not yet,) I think they agree. We do strive for hands-off, community moderation still. Even if seems to be less and less lately. Not a fact we relish, I guarantee.

Also, as a reminder, the CoC does not regulate the subreddit or mumble. So keep that in mind too.

2

u/mystikraven Infestatión, Tigol Jan 01 '11

Put yourself in a newbie's shoes. They just read the CoC post, nice and formatted, bullet points and all that. They they're reading through another post made by a Moderator. It, too, looks like a rule post, and has reiterating points from the CoC, as well as what appear to be new rules. You, as a newbie, might take these non-rules as rules and then start having very very wrong assumptions about how <reddit> works.

Don't pull your Admin title on me, dude, and give me that BS about community moderation. You already know how I feel about THAT double standard.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10

[deleted]

1

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 31 '10

HOW DARE YOU SAY I AM MISTAKEN! /GKICK

Seriously though, thanks for the feedback. Although damn close, I am not all knowing. :)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10

"You are mistaken!"

1

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 31 '10

Lol, now it looks like I really was yelling at someone instead of funny yelling at you... :,(,,,

1

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10

You must have replied super fast, I re-read my post and figured someone would take it wrong or turn it into some dramatic thing and deleted it (people are so touchy lately). Sorry Cros! :D

1

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 31 '10

Yea, I'm pretty much bored stiff at work today, so I've been camping the reddits. :)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10

[deleted]

2

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 31 '10

I don't care who they are, if they're wrong, they're wrong. I've got no problem pointing it out, and if someone else notices me being wrong, I hope they do the same.

8

u/Kanibis Dec 30 '10

CaptnNuggz is an amazing name, I would like to thank you for naming my next toon.

6

u/ToggleOff Rafamalak, Coindrop, etc Dec 30 '10

LtntNuggz

PrvtNuggz

GenNuggz

5

u/bipolrbear Dec 30 '10

i am never really on at night, because of my weird work schedule, and my play is sporadic. plus, most of the time i'm doing archeology anyways. so i have really never had a problem with anyone, or seen anything so heinous. every toon i come across while doing archeology, horde or alliance, guild or no, i /hug and /wave, even if they attack me. if they do attack me, then i /frown and try to run. i may not be luna-level nice, but i try to always grats folks, and give advice and info when i have it.

but i just want to say, i'm sorry who are you, nancy reagan? i can name my toon whatever i want, for whatever reason i want. it can be a reference to anything. the same goes for everyone else. just because you have a personal hang up with something doesn't mean you get to take it out on the other guildies who disagree with you. it also doesn't mean you can make guild chat, or the guild itself, less inviting.

if you want to say that we all need to be nice to each other, in and out of guild, i am all for that. if you want to, two sentences later, call someone's choices "stupid shit" because you don't like them then that is hypocritical. if you want to go so far as to say that you won't let a guildie's ALT in because you dislike the name is just beyond the pale. all the good you tried to do with the post is negated, in my opinion.

everything you have posted here, in terms of guidelines, has been recently posted in this subreddit, with the one exception of your little personal crusade. i can see that there is a big problem with some things, as seen in cros' rage, but your biggest point has nothing to do with the larger point as a whole.

again, yes:

be nice to EVERYONE ALL THE TIME. NO EXCEPTIONS. seriously, like luna said, don't be a dick. it is wholly uncalled for. consider this one of your families.

no: don't censor your toon choice names, don't think you have to come on sober or else you will be banned or kicked. and, although it's highly evidenced by the post some people will judge you, don't feel like you can't be yourself in guildchat. don't let people making unfounded judgements about you stop you from enjoying the game. most of the players are trying to have a good time, not get down on you because you "smoke the weed" and "want to talk about it". heaven forbid.

1

u/spewerOfRandomBS Dec 30 '10

You might want to add another item to that list.

Stop being elitist jerks around people not from the guild. Sorry, but you don't deserve that, at least as yet.

Your way isn't the only way, it might not even be the right way. And I notice most of you have a problem listening.

Start of pug raid: "Oh god tank is from <reddit>, he's going to suck. They never listen!"

An hour later: "OMG Great job on that tanks!"

-2

u/dorklogic Dec 30 '10

In some cases, the tank is actually very, very bad at World of Warcraft. The tank should seek help from some of the other tanks in <reddit> because we'll definitely lend some advice where it is badly needed... but only when asked for the advice, being that we're too afraid of being pegged as elitists due to the rampant reverse-elitism in the guild.

1

u/spewerOfRandomBS Dec 30 '10

being that we're too afraid of being pegged as elitists due to the rampant reverse-elitism in the guild.

Not really. It's all about how it's phrased.

Lets admit it, most of <reddit> are dicks. When advice is phrased right, you don't come off as an elitist jerk. But, if the other person does not want to listen. If I have done the fight a dozen times when I tank, and you are having trouble with it, you should listen. Well yea, you are a tard who does not deserve the help.

but only when asked for the advice

Why? I don't want to wipe with you a dozen times. DPS shouldn't be taking avoidable damage. That being said, if the tank standing in shit that ticks for 20k and expect someone to dps, you must be stuck in WotLK. Healers can't heal through that for both dps and tank. And you really aren't supposed to be tanking anymore.

-1

u/dorklogic Dec 30 '10

Pick through this subreddit. Offering advice to <reddit> members (or most wow players in general)wtihout them first asking for it results in a player becoming super defensive about why they do what they do and often just lashing out. Regardless of how well it may be phrased.

2

u/spewerOfRandomBS Dec 30 '10

Offering advice to <reddit> members (or most wow players in general)wtihout them first asking for it

I pug a lot. I have noticed this to be true more of <reddit> than on most pugs. Sure there are a few pug runs that want to do something their way and that is when you just go with it, and watch them wipe a couple of times. They are surprisingly more receptive to input after.

That being said, I learnt a lot from pugging as well. They notice things that I or other groups I have run with have not. "That stuff there seems to spawn minions if its under that stuff there!"

2

u/spewerOfRandomBS Dec 30 '10 edited Dec 30 '10

Also, I want to make it clear. I am not considering the progression or individual abilities. I am only commenting on the attitudes.

I wouldn't (and don't) mind wiping a dozen times as long as everyone is getting better and being cordial. It's when people start being dicks and/or not listening about what someone else has noticed. Carry that attitude over to pug runs, and you will really hurt the guild reputation.

EDIT: Arathias, someone does not like where this is going aparently. points at voting

0

u/beerisoptional Texun Dec 31 '10

They're just stalking him to downvote. He's in the barrel atm.

2

u/rprz Dec 30 '10

what if i'm being a d-bag for RP reasons? (karl rove.)

2

u/stoplight Dec 30 '10

And I don't care
And I don't give a shit

I'll break your brother's stereo
And then tell him it was you
You think you're better than me
Well you're fucking wrong

Everybody knows I'm Steve Motherfucking Polychronopolous

Deal with it

-"Steve Polychronopolous" by Adam Sandler

2

u/beerisoptional Texun Dec 31 '10

To be honest this guild caters to the fucking cry babies entirely too much. There are rules, there are standards and there is a reputation that should be cared about. If anyone even comes close to breaking up the circle jerk everyone gets in a fucking tizzy. Grow up, grow a pair and realize it's not all about you.

Cockmunchingweedsmoker is not a good name (at least not for wow). I personally don't want to be associated with a guild full of those name types. It's amateur at best.

Blowing up guild chat just so you can entertain yourself isn't a great thing. There are just too many folks in guild to make that possible or even allow for it on a part time basis. Create your own shit talk channel and invite like minded folks to it. See how fucking popular you are then.

It kills me that the same people hollering for tolerance are the ones that talk shit to other people. OH WAIT BRO I WAS J/K! That totally doesn't count! lawl

You guys want to tolerate the jackholes because, "it's free speech dude!" but you shut down anyone that wants to theory craft or try to progress in the game because they're elitists!! GTFO hypocrites.

TLDR: WoW is a game that some of us actually pay to PLAY. Some of us enjoy getting immersed into the game, the social scene and forgetting about real world issues for a bit. You may not have fun doing that but your fucking actions have consequences for those of us that do. Just be aware of that and try to act accordingly.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10

[deleted]

1

u/beerisoptional Texun Dec 31 '10

You're probably right. The guild in its current form isn't exactly a warm and fuzzy.

-1

u/amazedchili Dec 30 '10

So we should totally write a guild addon that lets us upvote/downvote members

1

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 30 '10

I would push the other admins VERY hard to get a sizable gold bounty on an application of this nature. This would resolve it. Self policing, just like the subreddit. Anyone who gets > XX downvotes over a certain time period gets gkicked.

I know nothing of making mods though, so I have no idea how to go about it, or if that is even feasible.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10

Too easy to game and would just cause more unnecessary drama.

4

u/spewerOfRandomBS Dec 30 '10

Anyone who gets > XX downvotes over a certain time period gets gkicked.

I see so much potential for abuse here, internal factions will ruin the guild.

I would advice you don't go that route.

1

u/keyserbjj Dec 31 '10

Yea this is a horrible idea

3

u/InquisitorKaede Vownus Dec 31 '10

Could work if instead of 'at X Downvotes you get kicked' you were instead put into Timeout and it could be reviewed by a moderator later.

1

u/CRoswell TheMostImportantOne Dec 31 '10

Sorry. Only negative non-constructive comments allowed. OBEY THE MASSES OF NAYSAYERS!

I mean... Yea. Good idea. :)

1

u/amazedchili Dec 31 '10

it wouldnt be hard to make this mod, i dont know about auto gkicking, but it could flag them

0

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10

[deleted]

-3

u/dorklogic Dec 30 '10 edited Dec 30 '10
  1. Plenty of replies so far.

  2. It's time for heavy-handed.

I'm not calling anyone out specifically. Check Cros's reply (upvoted to the top); It's a view that has been slowly rising up in all officer/moderator/member conversations for a few weeks now. Nobody is calling in the gestapo, but we as a guild need to change some things and the 'you kids behave now, ya hear?' tone has led to mouthy dickwads parading around under the guise of 'Free Speech'

6

u/bipolrbear Dec 30 '10

your negative karma makes me think maybe it's not time for heavy handed. it will never be time for heavy handed. if you want a small hardcore raiding guild, you are free to do that. if you want to try to turn <reddit> into your ideal guild, you are barking up the wrong tree. i'm sorry, but there are very few posts in this thread where you don't come across as a dick. please do not take this as me trying to be aggressive, or to troll you, i am saying it because, after i read them, i had a gut reaction of "who the fuck does this guy think he is?"

so, i think what i'm getting at, and what i tried to get at with my original reply post is, while you may have the right idea, you are going about it the wrong way and you are probably taking it way too far. you are making far more people unhappy in the guild with this then were unhappy due to the trolls. i have been an admin in the largest guild on a server before. it gets grating. there are a lot of dicks. but you can't respond like this

3

u/attackoftheisland Dec 31 '10

Listen man, you can be as heavy handed as you want, but that isn't going to change anyone's behavior, least of all the assholes. The mods/admins/great and glorious master are the ones that have to take the initiative to remove people from the guild who do not fit because there is no way to turn an asshole into a nice person.

The more assholes in the guild, the worse our reputation will be; the fewer, the better.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10

[deleted]

-1

u/beerisoptional Texun Dec 31 '10

Sounds to me like you're butt hurt over someone else's opinion. Don't try and belittle the guy because he took a stand. Perhaps you missed the part where he mentioned, "It's a view that has been slowly rising up in all officer/moderator/member conversations for a few weeks now."

Just because a few people wanna down vote him doesn't mean his views aren't supported.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10

[deleted]

-1

u/beerisoptional Texun Dec 31 '10

Oh so because YOU weren't part of the conversation it never happened. Gotcha.

"we clear?" wtf is that? I sincerely hope you'd never use that in an actual conversation with someone. I know you wouldn't get a second shot with me. If you're not part of the solution you're part of the problem. If you'd go back through the threads you'd notice the admins are agreeing with the sentiment even if the delivery was wrong.

Look, I admit the the overall tone of his message could have been delivered in a better way. However, some people obviously need the "heavy handed" message to get through to them. And getting an average of 7 downvotes per post isn't exactly what I'd call an overwhelming show of resentment. The same 7 are probably hammering each post he makes because they believe that's the way it should work.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '11

[deleted]

0

u/beerisoptional Texun Jan 01 '11

One day, the people in charge will realize it's snotty little fucks such as yourself that are harming the guild and not the people with heavy handed posts. Maybe, they'll also realize that the intention of this guild should be a place for Redditors to play WoW and not to play Reddit online.

You have done your duty though dude. You've chased me off and convinced me that although the guild is FULL of really great people... the few fuck heads like you can ruin anyone's good nature. You should ask around.. i'm actually kind of easy to get along with. It takes a bit to get my gander up but after all is said and done I pay to play this game and enjoy it. You ruin that enjoyment with your petty little comments and internet cowardice.

You don't want decorum. You thrive off of drama and you'll make sure that your around anything that has some drama connected to it.

It's a shame that the admins are so scared of the masses that they won't do the right thing most of the time. They play hands off and that's pretty cool... It's a unique leadership style that appears to work when members like you (lol raiders my ass) are busy with ez mode content. Once players similar to yourself become bored than shit starts to hit the fan. Hopefully, the leadership will change hands a couple of times where your hand won't be around their cocks and you'll end up where you deserve to be. Until then, enjoy yourself and mark up your internet victory.

This will be my last post in the subreddit. You won't get any responses or replies so feel free to ignore it. I have a feeling you won't though because your e-peen must be satisfied.

2

u/bipolrbear Jan 01 '11

wow you need to chill the fuck out, homie. i'll call the proctologist and we'll see if we can't get the stick out.

0

u/aa_hil Nbluth Jan 04 '11

Lol at douchy, preachy style. Sounds like you, not Arathias.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10

[deleted]

6

u/mystikraven Infestatión, Tigol Dec 31 '10

Your name is fine. Arathias is new and doesn't know what he's talking about.

You and your name and your weed are more than welcome in <reddit>.