r/redacted • • Jan 13 '19

Explain this.

Post image
232 Upvotes

133 comments sorted by

16

u/zer0fuksg1v3n Jan 13 '19

Democrats ruin everything.

They are a decease.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '19

5/7 is good enough, i guess.

5

u/ThingsMyWifeWouldSay Jan 15 '19

Democrats didn’t ruin your education... that was an inside job. Disease. It’s a simple word really, dis-ease. The English language really isn’t that difficult.

46

u/GeechieSmyche Jan 13 '19

They all need to go.

-6

u/SantaMonsanto Jan 13 '19

Everyone in this thread with the emotional 9/11 outbursts

How come no anger over Trumps epic fucking arms deal with SAUDI ARABIA?

CognitiveDissilusionment.exe

8

u/SarahC Jan 14 '19

SA keeps the petrodollar's worth.

Without them on our side we're fucked.

2

u/SantaMonsanto Jan 14 '19

So you’re cool with a country slaughtering 3,000+ innocent civilians on our soil, in our home, because “something something currency”?

What the fuck is wrong with you?

4

u/Kalyion Jan 15 '19

That’s the way mafia works.

1

u/SarahC Jan 18 '19

Well, it's no just me - it's everyone who doesn't protest it, isn't it?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '19

[deleted]

3

u/SantaMonsanto Jan 14 '19

It’s not whataboutism

I’m pointing out a contradiction.

It’s impossible to be both “angry about 9-11” and “indifferent to Saudi Arabia”

They literally attacked our country

2

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '19

People from within that country attacked, not the government. That was the summary of the 9/11 commission report.

3

u/SantaMonsanto Jan 14 '19

The summary was that they received support and funding from the royal family

Granted “The Royal Family” is a rather large group of people

None the less it’s been concluded and backed by evidence that those governing Saudi Arabia or at the very least people with the favor of those governing Saudi Arabia helped plan, coordinate, and funded the 9/11 attacks

It’s really splitting hairs to try and argue that Saudi Arabia didn’t attack us

Your argument basically sounds like the equivalent of:

”The Japanese didn’t attack America at Pearl Harbor. People acting at the direction of the Japanese Government attacked the US at Pearl Harbor”

Yea you are correct, the people of Saudi Arabia did not attack the US, but then again we aren’t doing Billion Dollar deals with the common person of SA.

My point stands, there is a hypocrisy in this Subreddit. You cannot be both “Angry about 9/11” and “indifferent to Trump’s dealings with Saudi Arabia”

People are willing to overlook any sin, so long as Trump says it’s “MAGA”

3

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '19

The bi-partisan 9/11 commission concluded that there was no evidence that the Saudi government as an institution or Saudi officials individually funded Al-Qaida.

3

u/SantaMonsanto Jan 14 '19

As I said

The effort was supported by the “Saudi Royal Family” which is admittedly a large group of people

However, if you know anything about the royal family, something like that isn’t just executed by some “rogue faction”.

TL;DR The Saudi’s are in one way or another responsible for the worst attack in American History”

3

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '19

They commission said there was no evidence.

2

u/SantaMonsanto Jan 14 '19

Contact information for Saudi Royal Family Members as well as a number of bodyguards and other associates of the family have been found in the possession of high ranking Al Quaeda members who were connected to the 9/11 attacks

I’m sorry that there aren’t any pictures of MBS wearing “Fuck The Twin Towers” T-shirt’s

That’s before any conversation about ongoing funding during the planning phases of the attacks. The 9/11 attackers were all Saudi nationals living here on the Saudi Dime having acquired their visas through connections with the Saudi government

Don’t be ignorant

→ More replies (0)

7

u/MCShoveled Jan 14 '19

I don’t really understand anything about this post. Being a Muslim is not the same as being a Jihadist.

And where’s your love for free speech? Is calling someone a motherf%#ker not allowed? If so, how then is the president’s own use of profanity acceptable?

We lefties didn’t forget anything. We do blame those responsible and hold them accountable. We do not however condemn the 25% of the world (1.8 billion people) who peacefully follow a religion different than our own.

Let us never forget America was founded on freedom. Freedom of press, freedom of speech, freedom of religion.

2

u/fizzixs Jan 18 '19

Conservatives are horrible people who conflate the idea of a person expressing their freedom of speech with something 20 terrorists did 20 years ago while attacking her freedom of religion. They went for a high level of difficulty when they do this in the same breath claiming they MAGA when they don't comprehend what makes America great in the first place.

I apologize for them because they are incapable of self reflection or reason.

7

u/MCShoveled Jan 18 '19

All Muslims are terrorists.

All conservatives are horrible people.

😑

Neither of those statements are even remotely close to the truth. I don’t believe the imagery above is an accurate reflection of most conservatives.

1

u/fizzixs Jan 18 '19

Ahh how clever, now point that brain of yours at OP.

28

u/TexasHunter Jan 13 '19

Good fucking question! How quickly they press us to forget.

4

u/500Rads Jan 14 '19

Don't you have freedom of speech in america

4

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '19

Have I done it? Have I found the most autistic sub ever? .. I wish I had somebody to tell about this discovery

2

u/fizzixs Jan 18 '19

Welcome, yes they came out of their snowglobe and don't seem to be enjoying being challenged by logic. It has been quite entertaining.

5

u/DarthTyekanik Jan 13 '19

We lost, duh

6

u/Fish_Kungfu Jan 13 '19

The Left's hatred for America, and their relentless push of dangerous, illogical and irrational political correctness, to advance their Socialist agenda.

6

u/AmericanAnarchy Jan 13 '19

Progressives who want equality of outcome.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

I'll explain, America has a long history of dumb motherfuckers for presidents, dumb motherfuckers who let this happen and dumb motherfuckers who embolden others to do things like this.

1

u/olivernewton-john Jan 13 '19

Yeah! We need another 9/11 to remind the islams of their place!

1

u/lPFreeIy Jan 13 '19

Congresswoman? That's not a congresswoman, it's Barney Frank in a wig

1

u/TheHancock Jan 13 '19

Is it purge time yet?

-1

u/atf104 Jan 13 '19

You mean how did we go from that to a president supporting the country that supplied all the terrorists for that attack so he can personally profit in real estate deals?

-5

u/darthmowzy Jan 13 '19

What’s wrong with having a Muslim congresswomen?

5

u/TheWalkingBoss Jan 13 '19

Everything, they (all Muslims, every last one) are subverting freedom and it should be absolutely frightening to anyone that doesn't want to live under Shariah Law.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

[deleted]

12

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19

Please elaborate on how this fallacy applies to OP instead of just quoting wikipedia. Let's see if you actually understand what you so proudly post.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

[deleted]

14

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19

Nope, but I don't think that OP was implying that. I think he was speaking to the overall presence of a religion that openly hates America, gaining a foothold in our government and openly calling the President a mother-fucker.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Ah so can you tell me exactly what this muslim congresswoman (elected by a majority of her constituents, mind you) has done that proves she is trying to destroy the USA?

7

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19

Yeah, calling the president a mother-fucker, did you not read that part? You can argue on the degree to which that statement is "destroying America," but it certainly isn't helping to build it.

5

u/NewYorkJewbag Jan 13 '19

This is stupid. Every person that called Obama a motberfucker was trying to destroy America? Is that your position?

6

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19

Every elected official that openly called him a mother-fucker or similar, yes.

4

u/NewYorkJewbag Jan 13 '19

That’s, with all due respect, an exceptionally foolish point of view. This is America. We can say what the fuck we want. Go back to wherever you came from with that stupid shit.

5

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19

I didn't say we couldn't, and I didn't say they couldn't say it. I said it is not an effective opposition strategy, and it does not lure people to your cause. Those it does lure are not worth having. That's my opinion, of course.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Yeah, calling the president a mother-fucker, did you not read that part? You can argue on the degree to which that statement is "destroying America," but it certainly isn't helping to build it.

Do you think Trump's language is helping build America?

10

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19

For those who want to see it built, yes. There is no room for "mother-fucker" in the context of building America, and calling it out doesn't take away from those efforts of rebuilding.

If a group of people are working to rebuild a dilapidated structure and some retard is throwing rocks through the windows, then I would say that calling that person out does not hinder the rebuilding effort.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

So Donald Trump said "we're going to tax those motherfuckers" during a rally talking about China. How is this ok but not what the congresswoman said?

10

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19

Holy shit, you actually are dumb. I knew it, but I thought maybe you were just being that way on purpose. You really think two countries having a spat is the same as a President and his elected official? She isn't China, she represents the "mother-fucker."

I mean seriously, are you even trying?

→ More replies (0)

2

u/NewYorkJewbag Jan 13 '19

Congress and the executive are COEQUAL. One does not rule over the other. Trump called Adam Schiff “little Adam Schitt” on Twitter in writing. Where’s the outrage?

This is unmitigated horseshit and Donald trump is absolutely without question a motherfucker.

1

u/lPFreeIy Jan 13 '19

So you walked in on him with your mom?

Must have been a great day for you

→ More replies (0)

-2

u/Houjix Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19

The country is already being built significantly and recently Obama tried to take credit for it

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Huh?

5

u/AreYouDeaf Jan 13 '19

YES AND OBAMA WANTS TO TAKE CREDIT AND SAY HE BUILT THAT

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Mayor619 Jan 13 '19

Ah so can you tell me exactly what this muslim congresswoman (elected by a majority of her constituents, mind you) has done that proves she is trying to destroy the USA?

Strawman fallacy. The OP nor your responder was saying that.

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Um, ya they were. See my link above for the reason why.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Are you saying 9/11 was a Govt psyops against its own people?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Uh, no. Can you explain how you came to that conclusion from what I quoted?

3

u/hotsoop Jan 13 '19

This is great representation of an Association Fallacy:

An association fallacy is an informal inductive fallacy of the hasty-generalization or red-herring type and which asserts, by irrelevant association and often by appeal to emotion, that qualities of one thing are inherently qualities of another. Two types of association fallacies are sometimes referred to as guilt by association and honor by association.

Guilt by association can sometimes also be a type of ad hominem fallacy, if the argument attacks a person because of the similarity between the views of someone making an argument and other proponents of the argument.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_fallacy

1

u/HelperBot_ Jan 13 '19

Desktop link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_fallacy


/r/HelperBot_ Downvote to remove. Counter: 231544

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Are you confused?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

I believe you are saying "don't associate muslims 911 with muslim congressman's insult to trump"

So my corollary is you are saying "muslims didn't do 911"

You're Welcome!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Are you fearful of Christians in Congress because the KKK is Christian?

4

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

I fear democrats because KKK is democrats.

A lot of bad things happened in the name of Christianity in the past, Islam however does bad things in the present. You can comfortably have this discussion only because a predominantly Christian culture fought for you to have it. Show some respect.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Do you show respect to Islam for building a culture that developed algebra?

3

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

They did not develop algebra, that is way overstated.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

And I'd argue that we built the USA in spite of Christiandom.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '19

Personally, I'm atheist and firmly believe in the secular state. I do not see Christianity interfering in any way. The values of Christianity have filtered down and are the reason western society in general is so good. Compare that with islamic states, where there are no human rights, freespeech and equality. You owe your freedoms to Christianity indirectly.

→ More replies (0)

6

u/fizzixs Jan 13 '19

I commend you for trying, the moretards of redacted may not be capable of learning. I am hoping they have shame but research doesn't look promising.

4

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19

/u/willdho won't elaborate on his fallacy accusations, so maybe you can explain how OP's post relates to the fallacy he is suggesting, since you seem to agree with him. Explain it to a moretard like me.

3

u/active-nihilism Jan 13 '19

I’ll play devils advocate here.

While I see Islam as a very dangerous and vile religion that encourages all infidels to either die or be forced to convert I’ll try to explain to you what’s going on here

Guilt by association is a very bad way to judge (although understandable as everyone does it including me) for example let’s say there is a gun owner in the US who decided to go on a rampage and massacres an entire town, the “guilt by association” here could be that any friends of said gun man are also guilty for merely being his friend or that since a gun owner did this mass shooting now through the logical fallacy of guilt by association, people can assume ALL gun owners are evil and will eventually shoot up a town.

The same is being done by this post by saying that since a woman is Islamic that she is somehow apart of the same group that did 9/11 or that she somehow endorsed it...

Now I’ll be in your side here on out as Islam is a very fiendish religion as the quaran (the Bible of Islam basically) states that all true followers of Islam must lie or do whatever they must in order to kill or convert infidels, so from this standpoint it is reasonable to assume that any true Muslim will do whatever they can do reach the highest levels of power in a foreign nation ( ie Congress of the USA)

So while this post is infact following the “guilt by association” fallacy, there is also very good merit to be wary of any devout Muslim as they are quite literally led to believe that infidels are nothing less than animals and thus any action against them is justified...

And just a note but infidel means nonbeliever in case anyone didn’t know

4

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19

I'd agree with you, but OP didn't really expand on his meme, so his implication is left to interpretation. That fact alone is enough to disregard any accusations of possible fallacies.

In my opinion, OP was simply referencing the presence of Islam in our government, and the open opposition to our President that the officials espouse, which is in the same vein of Islam's general dislike of the American way of life and government. They went from flying planes into skyscrapers, to having a foothold in our government. OP didn't accuse the Muslim congresswoman of flying planes into skyscrapers, and didn't suggest that all Muslims would do that. So to say that that is what OP meant is disingenuous without OP clarifying his position.

I do appreciate your response. Usually it's just fortune-cookie one-liners, so the attempt to have a discussion in this sub is appreciated.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

[deleted]

3

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19

I don't agree with his language either, but calling someone a chickenshit over their voting record is not quite the same as calling someone a motherfucker because you just "don't like him."

Also, fuck John Boehner. Please continue telling me I have selective outrage when you don't even know my position in the first place.

-2

u/fizzixs Jan 13 '19

Disgusted by your bigotry, but impressed with your explanation, fuck it have an upvote.

3

u/TheWackyIraqi Jan 13 '19

Islam is cancer, change my mind.

0

u/fizzixs Jan 13 '19

Alright, I'll bite. Are you interested in having this debate long form? I'm assuming both of us want it to be calm, analytical, and keep ad hominem out of it.

I'm not setting ground rules, but I'd like to suggest a format to keep it moving, each number is basically a post in the thread:

  1. Party A: State a premise/point (you have already)

  2. Party B: Asks 1 or 2 questions about the premise, keeping it direct and to the point. Questions can be asking for clarification, evidence, or why the reasoning of the point. Then Party B: makes a counterpoint based on those questions.

  3. Party A: Answers questions directly using evidence and/or logical argument/reason and addresses the counterpoint. Then Party A gets to ask questions about Party B's counterpoint and then make theirs.

  4. Repeat steps 2/3 until in posts as long as it is productive.

  5. We both should be open to be proven wrong and accept that our minds can be changed about the subject.


Your premise:

Islam is cancer, change my mind.

My questions:

  • I'm assuming that since this is reddit, you were being a bit purposefully extreme in this statement, I've done the same. Are you making the metaphor that religion of Islam is cancer because at its core the beliefs are so strong, and the believers are so committed to toxic ideas that they pose a mortal danger to the world in a short time frame?

My Counterpoint:

  • I will concede that there is a small sect of Islam committed to apocalyptic fantasy and world domination. My counterpoint is that small sect doesn't represent the almost 1B Muslims in the world, and in fact, is mostly maintained by unethical political forces in the Middle East as a mechanism of control over their people. Moreover, creating fear in westerners and Christians so they make statements as you have made is part of their plan to increase tension.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

[deleted]

4

u/TheWackyIraqi Jan 13 '19

Who said anything about Christianity?

ISLAM IS CANCER CHANGE MY MIND.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

[deleted]

5

u/TheWackyIraqi Jan 13 '19

If you agree why are you replying to me?

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

[deleted]

5

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19

Depends what you mean by "intentions." If you mean that the intention is to sow dissent and destabilize America, then yes I do agree with OP, and your fallacy is incorrect in that context.

Like I said, it all depends on what intentions you think the OP was implying. You'd have to ask OP.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

[deleted]

4

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19

What are you even talking about? Openly calling the President a mother-fucker is sowing dissent. I'm not guessing at her intentions, they are pretty clear. She wants to divide America and sow dissent within the population. Sometimes I think you just type words and hope they make sense after you hit Save.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

[deleted]

5

u/open_ur_mind Jan 13 '19

Who's talking about impeachment? I'm talking about using inflammatory language such as mother-fucker when referring to the President of the country you were elected to serve.

You want to change the language to impeachment because you know I'm right. No ones talking about impeachment. The context in which she calls Trump a mother-fucker is irrelevant. That type of language sows dissent, and there is literally nothing you can say to change that.

1

u/felmar Jan 13 '19

president of the country you were elected to serve

You ooze fascism

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (0)