r/recruiting • • Oct 09 '25

Candidate Screening 5 minutes into the interview, I realised my candidate wasn’t human.

15.3k Upvotes

We are hiring for an AI engineering position, and I hop onto the meeting to do my usual warm-up: background, small talk, the normal stuff.

Right away, I notice something is off. This person’s head moves a lot when they talk, like, weirdly repetitive. It is not natural. It is almost looping. Still, I go along with it because maybe it is just a camera lag or something.

Then, at one point, this “candidate” starts talking for about two minutes straight without pausing or even sounding like they took a breath. Perfectly fluent. No stumbles. No filler words. Just continuous, textbook-perfect talking. So I throw a simple question at them: “What is AI?”

And I get this back, word for word, like something from a script:

I ask the same question again, just to be sure, and I get the exact same response. Down to every single word. I try it a third time, still identical. Then the call just drops.

Turns out, I had just spent 40 minutes talking to an AI agent. HR later told me the real candidate had joined briefly at the start to introduce themselves, and then somehow, the bot took over. It even looked almost identical to the person’s LinkedIn photo.

So yeah. Not just fake resumes anymore. Fake candidates are now literally joining interviews.
Recruiting hell has officially entered the uncanny valley.


r/recruiting • • Dec 12 '23

Ask Recruiters How do you tell candidates they’re asking for too much money without coming across as rude?

15 Upvotes

Gen Z I’m looking at you

Edit: To the 809 people who commented saying to post the salary range. Legally it’s required in our state, most people just don’t bother to look.


r/recruiting • • Jul 14 '22

Recruitment Chats I feel like this market has created a bunch of entitled assholes NSFW

8 Upvotes

Since COVID, the job market has exploded as I’m sure you all know. I recruit technical applications, specifically .NET developers. Before COVID a SR. Developer would ask for $120-160k max, now I often get people with 5 years of experience demanding $180k minimum. And if I don’t have a role that can pay that much then they tell me to kick rocks, “there are plenty of other recruiters”. I’m getting so burnt out in this market. If I find a good candidate, but don’t place them within a week then they are off the market.

For context, I am an agency recruiter and have been doing this for 3 years.


r/recruiting • • Jan 15 '25

Candidate Screening The implication is that we should spend at least ONE HOUR considering each resume lol

Post image
57 Upvotes

r/recruiting • • May 20 '22

Off Topic More rude candidates than usual?

0 Upvotes

Has anyone else noticed candidates are extremely rude lately? I had a candidate respond with interest and we email back and forth a few times only for him to say he was just joking and he would never work with me lmao. It’s like they have so much free time working from home and they use it to be pieces of shit.

Edit: If you are not a recruiter, can you get the fuck out of here?


r/recruiting • • Feb 24 '24

Candidate Screening Initial phone screen is such a waste of time

0 Upvotes

I'm spending 30 minutes on the phone with each candidate talking about basic stuff like company overview and candidate experience. 95% of the time, they move on to the next round, so this call is really just a formality. I don't think candidates enjoy it either, yet most of my day is spent calling candidates.

Has anyone found an automated solution? I think there should be a better process with AI these days.


r/recruiting • • Feb 10 '23

Ask Recruiters This person missed our scheduled phone call and 30 min later called me 4 times in a row, 9 times in 20 minutes and is still calling. What would you do?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/recruiting • • Sep 29 '23

Candidate Screening Just thought I should warn recruiters about this person. How do jobs even check? Id hate to think I’m competing with people who shouldn’t even be there

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/recruiting • • Sep 20 '24

Ask Recruiters Fake Candidates - I Think I Finally Got My First One

0 Upvotes

Here's the context in short:

  • Recruiting for a Sr. Eng role - full remote

  • Candidate has a very American name and lives in the South

  • Candidate has lower than average number of LI connections

  • Video call starts and it's a very Asian dude with a strong accent

  • He know his tech stuff and has decent to good answers for behaviorals

Did I just get bamboozled? If so, what's the end goal for the other party? Does someone else show up on Day 1? Because it's fully-remote, does he just work from wherever and split the income with the American person getting paid?


r/recruiting • • Jan 19 '25

Ask Recruiters How are you detecting fake resumes?

0 Upvotes

I realized that we were getting a ton of fake applicants to our software openings because many resumes had the following:

  • Similar summaries

  • 1+ job experiences at notable (but not FAANG or unicorn) startups

  • ~3 projects where each project is just the website link of some actual startup.

  • Location is some not-well-known town in the US

  • No LinkedIn profile link or the link is broken

There are definitely some applicants that slip through because they're better at faking. How are you detecting them?


r/recruiting • • Feb 16 '24

Ask Recruiters Is finding people really this difficult?

0 Upvotes

The title says the main ask, but wondering if this is as bad for everyone as it seems. "People don't want to work" is trending pretty hard, and there are some posts on forums (Reddit included, like this one on r/jobs/) seriously asking why people don't want to work.

Are others in HR and Talent-related fields having this hard a time finding people who want to work / keeping people motivated outside of those few industries where layoffs are still high (tech, media, for example)?


r/recruiting • • Aug 25 '23

Candidate Screening Speaking from a hiring manager side, I’ve noticed a lot of really unprofessional behaviour from candidates in interviews recently. Is this something recruiters are noticing too? I’m shocked by some of the entitlement.

111 Upvotes

I’m a hiring manager and not a recruiter but keen to get peoples general consensus on the market. I’m based in Ireland and working in tech sales just for reference.

We recently returned to some good levels of hiring (big team so generally some promotions or people leaving) and some of the things I’ve seen in interviews recently have been shocking. Including but not limited to:

Taking a phone call during an interview. Vaping during an interview. Getting up and leaving the room, telling us “I’ll be back in a few minutes”.

On top of some general entitled attitudes from people (one person told me “I’ve already answered that question when we went to press them for more info).

I had someone interview recently and while he was good he was a bit junior for the role, so I called him myself to give him feedback and tell him I had spoken to another manager who was interested in his profile at one level below the role he interviewed for.

Before I could get to that he got aggressive and defensive telling me I didn’t know what I was talking about, the role was beneath him and that we wasted him time (it was two interviews and an hour and 45 minutes in total).

This isn’t just related to my market I’ve sat in on some other interviews at panel stage and it’s a mix of all them (in case it seems like I’m the problem).

I’ve chatted with my recruiting team during our meetings and they have said the same, lots of people just not answering the phone after a call scheduled, or ghosting. Same on my side trying to do a LinkedIn reach out and have a chat then nothing.

And look this is fine, things change or you might be interested, I’ve even there too but at minimum is dropping a quick message to say you are withdrawing not the bar for professionalism now?

The thing is our profile is fairly junior (around 2-3 years experience after university) and in turn we get a lot of applications (you can look at my previous posts about what we get over a weekend fora single role), so I foot understand why people act like this or if they just really underestimate how many others are interested and qualified to do the job they apply for.

Our salaries are also a set entry level salary, benchmarked across industry and we are probably on the top 5 in the country for the role. We tell candidates from the first call what it is and that it set at that and then still have people trying to negotiate at offer, which for someone with 1-2 years experience is insane.

Look I get searching for a job is stressful and I’m not expecting people to get down and grovel for a job or bend over backwards, but has anyone noticed a real sense of entitlement mixed with a lack of professionalism really coming through on hiring, especially from people who really have no business doing it?

Edit*** shout out to the loser who reported me to the Reddit care team, sorry you seem to have no life.


r/recruiting • • Feb 20 '23

Interviewing What the hell is going on with recruiters nowadays? - Lack of professionalism or overworked?

3 Upvotes

I’m in the market for an engineering role, more specifically a Quality Engineer with 9 years of experience. Here are some of my interactions with recruiters so far:

  1. Interviewed with hiring manager and everything went smooth, next day I received a call from the recruiter expressing their interest in hiring me for the position. He said “well I don’t see how much you want to get paid, the range is $81k and $120k and median for this role is $92k”. I was surprised how quickly he brought the median. I already did my research and the market dictates around $98k-100k. I told him that I was looking for $98k since the market reflected this and I have interviewed for another position that was also within this range. He said “ok I will see what I can do, will let you know tomorrow”. 4 WEEKS passed and I sent him about 3 emails and called him several times within this time and NO RESPONSE at all. At the 4th week he sent an email not even apologizing for his lateness, telling me that they decided to move forward with another candidate. Not a single word of “I wish you success”…NOTHING.

  2. A recruiter sends me an email saying “thank you for applying for this position, please fill the attached Word file and send back to me”…a Word file with a bunch of questions that ask the exact same thing you would find in my resume…literally like “do you have experience in quality systems?”…and I’m like…I could have never been a Quality Engineer in my last jobs if I wouldn’t have any experience in quality systems. But here I go, responded to all these dumb questions with examples. I’m literally doing her job.

  3. A third party recruiter that forgot to confirm the interview time with his customer but confirmed with me…so here I go for the interview only to get told that I should contact this recruiter since there’s no appointment made.

Last time I was in the market for a job was in 2016…and I did not experience any of this, has something changed across the board? Am I missing something?


r/recruiting • • Sep 09 '22

Business Development The new California-salary rule will reduce the number of companies that need recruiters

0 Upvotes

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-30/california-passes-law-requiring-companies-like-meta-disney-to-post-salary-range?utm_source=website&utm_medium=share&utm_campaign=mobile_web_share

With companies being forced to put a salary range, no doubt they will begin to get more candidates with their own job posts. Objectively, this would have an effect on how badly companies needs recruiters, or at the least, how hard it will be to find business.

Any thoughts from people in states/countries where this is already a rule?

EDIT: Should have clarified, I’m referring to the need for third party recruiters


r/recruiting • • Jun 26 '24

Recruitment Chats I have to admit recruiting is a tough job

8 Upvotes

I have to admit, that recruiting is a tough job. Finding the right skills, assessing cultural fit, and ensuring candidates align with our values can feel like a never-ending challenge.

Is anyone else struggling with this?

What strategies or tools have made your hiring process easier?

Are there any horror stories or success stories you'd like to share?


r/recruiting • • Jan 26 '23

Ask Recruiters Remote work as a free candidate stealing tool

281 Upvotes

A friend of mine just lost two employees after his company moved back to 5 days in the office (formerly 2 days). When he told me this, I assumed that these people quit because of the schedule, but it turns out, they didn't. Apparently within a few weeks of going back in-office, a recruiter called them and stole them away with remote job offers.

Before if you wanted to lure candidates away from another company you had to pay them more or offer pricey perks or both. But now that many companies are going back to the office, are there companies taking advantage of that by offering the cost-free perk that is remote to steal their employees?


r/recruiting • • Feb 05 '25

Recruitment Chats Why does recruiting bring out the anger in people?

15 Upvotes

I am talking about subreddit, not in real life. Anyone will post here about anything to do with recruiting, and youll get alot of angry, clearly non recruiters and they act and sound resentful. Nothing I could say calms them down. Is this due to the job market? I try not to argue too much because I am lucky to work for a great company getting more experience as a recruiter with good benefits and not as many can say the same.


r/recruiting • • Jul 19 '24

Recruitment Chats Recruiter Bashing!!!

3 Upvotes

No strangers to controversy… Recruiters are regularly being slated or bashed on LinkedIn and other platforms. (Often by those with no experience in the role or sector.)

As a Recruiter (Agency or InHouse); when you see these posts, do you take them to heart, respond - or laugh them off?


r/recruiting • • Sep 04 '24

Candidate Screening Do you ever directly tell candidates "Sorry, I can't work with you"?

18 Upvotes

Do you ever tell candidates directly that you don't want to work with them? If so, how do you word it?

I'm talking about job hoppers, people that don't have marketable experience, unrealistic expectations, etc.

Do you ever say "Sorry, it's going to be too hard to market someone who's changed jobs so many times"?

One guy even straight up told me he was laid off from his last job for performance issues. I was just like "okay, thanks, I'll call you if I have any roles that are fit."

My only concern about being direct is reputation.. telling colleagues that I'm "difficult" or something.


r/recruiting • • Oct 03 '24

ATS, CRM & Other Technology HR became just a lazy part of companies bureaucracy

Post image
0 Upvotes

The Human Resources may have to change the name to AI selection, since there's absolutely nothing human on today's process. And even the people that get hired, let's be honest, the offers nowadays are inhumane, the process is inhumane and the rejection? That's beyond cruel, just a bot message, never a feedback. If in the near future HR gets replaced by AI just remember, it was their own fault.


r/recruiting • • Oct 04 '22

Candidate Job Search Advice Accepted two offers- would love recruiters opinion on how to make this right?

0 Upvotes

I shouldn't have done this but was overwhelmed by the choice and ended up accepting 2 offers. I've handled this poorly and suspect my recruiter at company B is getting frustrated. I want to know what motivates recruiters (and maybe what laws you need to work with), hopefully join company B, or at least have the chance of doing so without losing both offers.

Generally both companies are pretty selective if that gives any context. With that being said, company A is in a hiring freeze and probably would love an opportunity to rescind my offer. The timeline looks like this:

  1. Interned at employer A. Signed full-time. They paid me a sign-on bonus, which shows up in online records.

  2. During negotiations with B, lied about my offer deadline with company A, said it was further out (in reality they had only started process with me after an accept)

  3. Accepted employer B full time offer. They initiated a background check with the same background check company, and employer A is on my work history- I expect that between HireRight contacting employer A, and having the sign-on bonus in my paid history, employer B will learn about me taking the other offer (and probably A, if they wonder why they're getting contacted by HireRight for a future full-time employee) .

  4. Got cold feet, reneged company B with an excuse (which was real, but something I'm willing to work around to join B).

  5. A few hours after reneging B, contacted them again and told them it may not be the end of things. This is where my recruiter expressed some frustration.

I'd like to accept an offer from employer B. I could:

  • Come totally clean to my recruiter and risk 1. seeming like an indecisive serial liar and 2. having the recruiter notify company A

  • Tell some half truth that makes me seem more sane

  • Not say anything and somehow verify my employment with HireRight without having them contact A

  • Accept I've fucked up and would jeopardize both by trying to get B, take A, and leave the door open for working at B in the future.

I'd love to hear the opinions of recruiters here. Thanks!


r/recruiting • • Apr 24 '23

Ask Recruiters Do you think working experience as a recruiter is necessary to open a recruiting agency?

0 Upvotes

Do you think it’s essential ? Have you got experience in opening / running agency?

I


r/recruiting • • Mar 19 '26

Diversity & Inclusion Are we putting DEI work on our resumes?

2 Upvotes

I serve as a member and lead of my agency's Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) committee. As I explore new job opportunities, I'm curious about how others showcase their DEI involvement on their resumes.

It’s a priority for me that my next position includes an active DEI program. My work on the committee spans various activities, such as:

-organizing virtual and in-person events

-presenting to C-suite executives

-developing content strategies

-creating written materials for multiple internal channels.

While I am open to roles in recruiting, I’m also considering positions focused on employee experience.

So, should I include this DEI work on my resume? Are there preferred formats with or without it? Do I display it on my LinkedIn profile? Should I adjust my language to optimize for ATS or AI keyword scans?

I’d love to hear your insights and best practices for highlighting DEI experience in the job search process.


r/recruiting • • Apr 21 '25

Career Advice 4 Recruiters Is workday illegally sharing data or blacklisting?

0 Upvotes

I came across an interesting post. A candidate suggested that he applied using Workday to over 100 different employers, and not a single one went through, or that he got a call. For some positions, his resume was a 90% match, and for most of them, he got an instant rejection. When he conducted thorough research, he was advised that Workday might have information about his EEOC complaint from his past employer, which could be subtly disclosed to future employers. I know there is already a lawsuit against Workday for a similar practice.

I am aware that a lawsuit has already been filed. I am very curious to learn more. Recruiters, please share your thoughts. Is there any indicator in Workday that flags candidate or blacklist. In a nutshell, Workday subtly shares negative information about the candidate and indicates it to a recruiter or blacklists a candidate.