r/reactivedogs • • Aug 21 '24

Vent Why you should walk your puppy before the last vax

0 Upvotes

I’m noticing a trend these days with new puppy owners. And I’m blaming the vets because I don’t know who else to blame…. although my vet was a rare exception.

This is about informing new puppy owners to NOT take their puppies out for walks and generally out into the world with all four paws on the ground till after the last vaccination. This is horrible advice. The window of time from eight weeks until the last vaccination is crucial for socialization. And excuse me, but walking around with your puppy in a pack or stroller/shopping cart in a store is not going to properly acclimate them to the world. Dogs learn about their world through scent and physically exploring overall and this is not going to happen from a freaking backpack. These tools are great when you really do need to keep your pup off the ground, like if you are in a heavily trafficked area or a pet store or a place where you wouldn’t want a puppy walking around. But walking about early on, like a normal dog, also teaches leash training and housebreaking much more quickly than dogs that are carried around in a backpack. How in the world are you going to know if they need to go potty? How are they going to get their energy out? How will you even know if they are hesitant or scared of anything if you cannot read their body language? How will they learn to walk on a leash? It drives me crazy when I scroll the puppy Reddit groups and one of the most common complaints is that people don’t know what to do with their puppies during that period of time before the last vaccination, believing they cannot even take their puppy beyond the boundaries of their property unless off the ground. Many of these people describe having severe puppy blues and are even talking about returning the puppy to the breeder or shelter. Not that simply getting your puppy out in the world is going to solve all of that, but it makes a huge difference in my opinion. Had I chosen stay cooped up with my high-energy, shy puppy, I would have been a mental wreck and she would have been totally bored, frustrated, and sheltered from a big world that she was gonna have to get to know eventually.

I even had first-hand comparisons: My puppy came from a litter of 13 puppies and I communicated with the other puppy owners, as we have a Facebook group. Several of them followed the path of not taking their puppies out until after the last vaccination and in nearly all cases, they were having issues with shyness and reactivity towards other dogs and strange places…and many other issues that myself and those who chose to take their puppies out early, were not having. Mine was reactive and shy towards other dogs and certain situations as well early on…but because I got her out right away, even enrolling her in a playgroup with puppies who were not fully vaccinated, made a huge difference in her confidence and behavior overall. But I was careful and only hooked in with a group in which the owners were responsible and had started the vaccination process. I felt totally safe because we were all on the same page in the group. What a huge difference that experience made over the weeks that followed. I can’t even imagine what she’d be like today had I not done that. It was a game-changer. And I’m fortunate that I have a quiet neighborhood with wide sidewalks where she could walk and take potty breaks here and there along random grass. I knew the odds of her catching parvo from this very limited area was very slim and she was totally fine. I have a lot of dogs in my extended family and not one of them ever became ill from doing the exact same thing when they were puppies.

I believe vets need to be very clear about these directions. Are they actually telling people they cannot take their puppies absolutely anywhere beyond their private property (feet on the ground)? Because if so, this is bad advice, imo. I don’t believe you should be taking your puppy to dog parks or any dog-heavy areas, of course, but it’s about common sense. I think vets are doing a huge disservice by encouraging owners to avoid walking their pups in the world…or the owners are simply not understanding the directions?! My vet was, thankfully, encouraging me to get my girl out into the world, explaining how the odds were slim that she’d become ill if I was aware and selective about location. Nothing in life is without risks and you have to weigh the pros and cons and benefits of taking such risks. If you have a puppy in New York City or some highly populated area, then perhaps my recommendations would not work. And for that, I would say get out of the area a few times a week and into a quiet neighborhood for walks. It would be worth the trip.

My goal in sharing this is not to rant. But hopefully help anyone out there who has a puppy who is feeling overwhelmed, as I was even with the things I mentioned I was doing. I see so many dogs being rehomed because of issues from not being properly socialized. Outside of housebreaking, I see socialization early on as being THE most important part of raising a puppy.


r/reactivedogs • • Oct 03 '24

Advice Needed Neighbor complaining about my dogs’ barking

1 Upvotes

I work second shift. When I get home I play with my dogs in my fenced yard around 9 pm. One is reactive and barks at everything, even barks while playing and that sets up the other dog to bark. My neighbor has been complaining that they can’t open their windows for fresh air because the barking was waking their baby. I don’t know how to stop it, they are just loud dogs. They get a walk too but they need their yard run and play time. They are mutts - pit, boxer. ACD, lab mixes. I being them inside around 10 pm and don’t allow them to bark continuously, it’s more in spurts. but apparently that’s not good enough. Any advice?


r/reactivedogs • • Sep 06 '23

Advice Needed Excluded from puppy group.

3 Upvotes

Created this account to get some advice because this really upset me.

My puppy isn't even reactive (just excitable, because puppy) but she is a pittie so her excitement can freak people out. In public, we keep this well-managed and just make sure she's not overstimulated, but recently we joined a puppy class where the pups are allowed to just be themselves and play for a portion of the class.

No problems have arisen, and she's been extremely good during the training portion of class and play time. She can be a little rough, but she always backs off when the other puppy says "no". I was so excited when she made friends with a german shepherd puppy whose play style matched hers. Plus, his owner is smart and funny and I loved chatting with her while our puppies tore up.

Until today. It's coming to the end of this class and I saw the german shepherd owner and a few other gals exchanging information so they can do puppy playdates outside. Some of the other girls in that group really dislike me and my dog due to perceiving my puppy as being "mean" to theirs. There was a size difference so one puppy yelped in the beginning of the class when she got startled by my dog but no damage was done & she still hasn't forgiven me for that

I waited until my so called friend was separated from the two girls who don't like my puppy and asked if we can exchange information too, and maybe have a big puppy playgroup if the others don't want to join and I can still see the face she made at me. Like pity and disgust or something

She just straight up told me no, that she's unwilling to risk her dog's safety as the dogs grow up. I told her it's just puppy playing, that they've been playing this whole time and there's nothing unsafe about my dog but she said it's not a risk she's willing to take and they've been supervised by professionals. When I pointed out that german shepherds also face this type of discrimination she just shrugged and said that pitbulls still make up a "disproportionate number of animal fatalities and human bites". She also said she doesn't believe in it's how you raise them and that some genetic traits you can't train out. No matter WHAT I said she had something to say back and at the end just got short with me and said I wasn't going to change her mind. I felt tears forming in my eyes and that's when I noticed everyone was watching us. Of course it was soooo awkward after that

There's one more class left and I feel like we can't even go back. I'm mortified that everyone saw this interaction and even more devastated that I thought we finally made a friend and then this happens.

I know my girl can't really understand that she'll never see her friend again, and that dogs don't necessarily have "friends", but it's literally the best part of her week and for a while it was mine too. She gets so excited when she sees him and even knowing that everyone is meeting up without us upsets me. This isn't the first time people have rejected her for her breed and I just don't know what to do. My heart is broken for my puppy. Plus, how can we join the next level class and see these people again?

Does anyone have any advice about how to handle this? I'm really hurting right now.


r/reactivedogs • • Dec 22 '23

Help!! Dog snapped at my son

0 Upvotes

Tonight, my dog (3yo rescue pit mix) snapped at my 8mo son. My son was reaching for something near the dog and the dog just barked and snapped. This is the second time he has overreacted to a kid in his space. Normally the dog is very good with the baby, they’ve both been able to lay around next to each other and been perfectly fine, but something weird happened this time. My wife and I came up with these options:

  1. Get rid of dog by giving away to someone w/o kids

  2. Find a good trainer (that we don’t have the money for)

  3. Find a way to train him ourselves

  4. Put him down.

What other options do we have? What even are ways to train dogs that struggle with being over reactive? We feel bad because we don’t want to give up on the dog, but we would be failing as parents if he hurts our son. Please help us.


r/reactivedogs • • Aug 13 '24

Advice Needed Asking someone to not get on elevator with their dog- AITA?

0 Upvotes

I always go through the service entrance with my two dogs: one is a dachshund and the other is a yorkie mix. The doxie is the reactive one towards dogs.

I was waiting for the service elevator tonight with my dogs when this girl came through the service entrance with her dog. He was a small dog, a little larger than my dachshund.

As we were all waiting for the elevator, my dog didn't seem annoyed yet, but three dogs in an elevator is not a good idea. It is common sense. I don't care it is a large service elevator. An enclosed space seems like a recipe for disaster and I have no idea how that stranger dog would react.

So the elevator arrived and I asked her to wait for the next one because my dog does not like other dogs. The girl shook her head and said "sorry I have to go about my day, my dog will be ok."

Then my dog started barking. I got kind of got frustrated as I stepped aside to let the girl go on and the girl told me it is not her job to accommodate my dog.

I can't take the stairs so what are my other options? Was I in the wrong for asking her to wait? I just thought it was common sense like I said to not ride an elevator with multiple dogs. I dread running into this girl again.


r/reactivedogs • • Dec 17 '22

Teaching your kids not to judge dog breeds.

0 Upvotes

I had the best experience today. In May I rescued a 6 month Amstaff, Lab, Pit, Boxer mix. We have a nice backyard with a lot of kids around. Luckily his reactivity is mainly with the cats and bikes in the neighborhood but I always make sure our gates are secure. While I took my dog out today, the kids of our next door neighbors are jumping on the trampoline. “Nice dog!” One of the kids say. I say thank you, he replies “What kinda dog is he?” I simply say he’s a mix of everything. The kid goes “Oh we’ll just letting you know pit bulls are really good dogs. They are actually such big teddy bears. Did you know that 90% of the time it’s bad owners that make them mean? Also, dog fighting doesn’t count!” I say that’s very smart and true , thanks for telling me. Im glad parents out there are educating their kids about not judging our animals based on the way they look and to treat them with kindness!


r/reactivedogs • • Jan 13 '24

Support Shelter recommended BE.

2 Upvotes

They’ve never seen my dog. I sent an email asking about their rehoming services, saying she was dog-reactive. Based on that information alone, they said she should be BE’d.

I am in disbelief.

She said she recommends this to everyone with a dog-reactive dog since they’re all miserable and dangerous (paraphrasing).

I… I am in shambles.


r/reactivedogs • • May 22 '23

People that bring their reactive dog on hikes

5 Upvotes

Ran into a situation today with my 10 month old puppy. I'm not sure how I should handled and am posting to see if I could have handled better.

We encountered two adult dogs on the trail that were aggressive/dog reactive. The first dog I asked as I saw the dog coming down the trail if friendly. Owner said no. He moved his dog to the grass and I proceeded on the far side of the trail. No issues.

The second dog was an entirely different experience. My pup laid down due to overheating at side of the trail. The trail is maybe 8ft wide. This lady comes down with her four young kids and her dog. The lady full stops once sees us and asks if I am going to go ahead. I told her no my dog was overheated but she can pass. She loses her temper and says she can't, huffs, and says her dog is reactive. She then full stops on the trail and stares me down. I'm basically like wtf and tell her I'm not moving my dog is overheated. I then try to get my dog up and at that point she storms around me. She then proceeds to tell her kids that they can't stop because of the dogs. It was awkward because while i kept my distance, we had a good half mile to walk back to the parking lot. That whole time i had be conscious of how far away we were from her lousy dog. She had an attitude the whole time. Such an odd experience.

So this is my first dog in years. My thoughts are any reactive dog does not belong on a trail where other people and pets may be passing by, period. I'm also shocked that she found it acceptable that she couldn't handle her dog and it was my responsibility to curb that. The dog was not in a muzzle nor had a harness on.

This trail is in a ritzy area. I am sure this is bound to happen to me again. How would you have handled? What should I have done?


r/reactivedogs • • Oct 17 '23

Complaints from neighbours about my barking dog destroying the neighbourhood.

0 Upvotes

I've had my rescue gsd for 3months (she's 15month old) and extremely fear reactive to dogs. Her last owners had a dog that bullied her so bad she hid under their car 24/7.

They lied about her behaviour to get me to take her from them and after 3 months we've slowly been figuring out all the things that are difficult about this dog that we were lied to about.

The main issue is the barking. She is extremely dog reactive and will bark when she sees or hears another dog. The barking is excessive and long (lasting 10mins after the dog has left her sight or longer if she's barking because another dog is barking too).

The real issue is that my property backs on to a park frequently visited by off lead dogs and their owners (sometimes wondering dogs too).

There has been 3 incidents where wondering and off lead dogs with owners have been aggressive to her at the back fence (barking and lunging) with once incident resulting in council involvement.

The wondering dogs that occasionally bother her at the back fence plus the regular presence of off dogs walking by with their owners has resulted in my dog being extremely stressed and barking regularly between the hours of 6:30am to 8:30am and 4:30pm to 6:30pm due to being prime dog walking time.

Unfortunately I'm often away during these time as I'm at work so my ability to step in and bring her inside away from her barking triggers has been limited.

As a result I've started receiving some pretty angry text messages from neighbours saying my dog is destroying the peacefulness of our neighboured. I've explained to neighbours about her fear issues and that she's currently on anti-anxiety medication to teat the matter but it takes time to work. They also know I'm in training and regularly work with a dog behaviour specialist to help resolve my dog's issues.

I feel like Im doing everything I can but they are fed up and demanding the barking stop immediately or they will involve council.

I'm pretty upset with the whole situation and I really do feel bad for my neighbours. I guess I'm just wondering how I can address the problem with immediate success?

My trainer has advised against bark collars due to the dog being new and his concerns that it could destroy all the trust I have built with her over the last 3 months. On the other had if council gets involved because the barking isnt stoped I could end up with no dog (council can order barking dogs to be put down in my LGA).

I guess I'm just looking for advice or opinions to stop the barking. Any advice on what worked for you would be extremely appreciated 🙏


r/reactivedogs • • Jan 30 '21

Sometimes I just can't help myself :/

0 Upvotes

My reactive girl and I were actually having a rare nice walk the other morning. She was behaving nicely, and because she was, I was feeling so good about our progress. We even came to a corner with three other dogs converging at once! And she did beautifully. She looked to me for treats when I said "leave it", and we walked by like it was nothing. Are you kidding me?? She got lots of praise and an extra treat. Then it happened. The next street a woman with her dog were walking toward us, on the wrong side of the street, of course, so I decided to go across the street. Her dog starts barking and snarling, and my girl returned in kind. She reared on her hind legs, and I could not get her attention back on me for several seconds. So I did what any sane, rational adult would do and shouted at the lady "You don't start nothin', there won't be nothin'!", a quote from the movie Men in Black. Yes, I know, real mature. But darn it all, I work so hard with my dog to help her get over her issues, and these people just let their dogs be all bossy. Anyway, we spent a few minutes working on calming sits and turns, but the walk was ruined. She was back to her "I'm going to do it my way" self, so all the way home we trained. Oh well, it was awesome for a while.


r/reactivedogs • • Feb 24 '25

Rehoming I’m still not over my dog, I returned him to the shelter 4 months ago after having him for 2.5 years.

3 Upvotes

I loved him so much and he truly was my best friend and nothing can replace him. I miss him so much. I don’t want to forget him but it makes me so sad to think about him.

I KNOW I made the right decision returning him so I could attempt to get my life back on track, it’s just so much harder than any could anticipate.

It’s also hard not knowing what he’s feeling. I keep picturing him in his room at the shelter all alone. I feel I should have done more or possibly chose BE instead.

I worry I will never feel that kind of love again.


r/reactivedogs • • Jun 05 '26

Behavioral Euthanasia My dog mauled the veterinarian today

0 Upvotes

Trigger warning: potential for BE

For context: 5 year old large dog, on Amitriptyline, fluoxetine, gabapentin, methocarbomol, carprofen, and at veterinarian Acepromazine

Medical issues: extreme undiagnosable pain in rear end, chronic pancreatitis, unconfirmed generalized seizures (talked about at veterinarian today, she exhibits all the symptoms fairly continuously, but this diagnosis is not confirmed, but it makes everything make sense to me)

Bite history: before this she has a bite history at the veterinarian that happened when her sensitive rear end was touched, likely a level 1-2. No one was ever physically hurt because she exclusively wears a muzzle at the vet.

My reactive dog was chewing at the air this morning, I sent a video to the veterinarian and uafterwards made an appointment. I gave her the additional acepromazine and when it kicked in she went in.

The veterinarian wanted to look in her mouth (and found no bleeding, the start of gingivitis, no foreign objects in her mouth and she honestly seemed incredibly chill with him. Since she was so chill he said he wanted to listen to her heart rate, I agreed, and she jumped at him and went for his throat. His shirt got ripped open, but since she was wearing a muzzle he was overall not as injured as he could have been.

Since it looked like it could have been a deadly attack, afterwards I asked where on the bite scale it was, and the vet declined the answer but told me that on a reactive scale she went from 0-10 instead.

To me such a large attempt at biting means that I have to consider BE. The vet and vet tech didn’t think that was necessary, but I am extremely uncomfortable.


r/reactivedogs • • Jun 18 '25

Vent I am beyond angry at my dog right now.

0 Upvotes

ETA: So much for this sub being supportive. No, I will not get rid of my dog no matter how many of you tell me I should. No, I do not think my actions were OK. No, I'm not asking for advice. Any time I ask for help I get dragged, and I'm not even asking for help this time. Some of y'all suck.

●

First off, I'll say that I'm sick and grumpy and have a very short fuse, so I know it's not that bad..

But I had my dog out on her long line which she's been doing fantastic on lately. But she saw a fckn rabbit and yanked me right into a damn pole. It hurt, and I'm just so livid at her right now. I don't even want to be around her even though I just got back from an 8 hr shift. I immediately just put her back in her kennel (admittedly I did scream at her for a minute, ik not a good move).

I'm upset that she basically just threw away everything we had worked on and didn't listen to me at all. I'm annoyed that she hurt me again (I also have a connective tissue disorder so she fcked my SI joint as well). I'm frustrated that I'm going to either a) have to wear different clothes for a while or b) show off my scrapes on my chest. I'm upset that it's probably going to impact my tanning this year and maybe indefinitely (yay connective tissue problems). I'm angry that she made me look so stupid in front of people. Like imaging your dog running you into a fckn pole in front of your neighbors. So embarrassing. I don't want to be mad at her, but I'm just livid right now.

Ugh, sometimes I wish I had thrown away the flyer advertising her litter 4 years ago 😭


r/reactivedogs • • Mar 08 '25

Advice Needed My “old man” dog nipped my 10 month old.

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone. New to this community as of today since this happened earlier.

I have a schnauzer/terrier mix (30ish lbs) who is 12 years old. I’ve had him his entire life, got him from a shelter as a puppy. He’s been with me through every significant thing in my life. So needless to say, he means a lot to me and I want to do what’s best for him.

But I have a daughter to think about now too, obviously.

She was crawling on the floor and we always tell my old man dog to move out of the way, go somewhere else, etc. when she gets near him. She crawled towards his bed where he was laying, so I called him over to me and he laid down next to me. And generally speaking when he is near me I know he won’t do anything towards her because he knows I’m right there and will intervene if she gets into his space.

Well, I wasn’t being vigilant enough/paying enough attention, because my daughter crawled back over towards us and then grabbed his front paw (he hates having them touched by anyone) and he nipped her on the face.

——

For more backstory information about my pup. This is the second time he has bitten a child. My niece who is now almost 7 years old, cornered him when she was like 18ish months old, he felt threatened, and nipped her face as well. The difference in that time is that he did draw blood on my niece and she had to go to the urgent care. But everyone was basically saying it wasn’t his fault and they should have been watching my niece, etc.

And thinking about it now, there have been a couple other instances of him snapping at adults in certain situations. All “provoked” for lack of a better term (like he was scared, or in a new situation, etc.)

Anyways. I think I’m just looking for words from other dog owners on what you would do. It doesn’t feel like a super fair life for him to have to be separated from me at all hours of the day because I’m with my daughter 100% of the time when she isn’t sleeping. But considering BE feels unbelievably hard. He is 12, he does have some health concerns, but all in all he could live another good 3-5 years I feel. He is still pretty spunky, has his appetite, his overall personality still intact, etc.

My only ask as other dog owners is to consider how much I love my dog. I know we all love our dogs, but he is my childhood dog and has been one of the only constants in my life… is it fair for me to just be diligent about keeping them separated when my daughter is awake? Should I truly consider BE? We do want more children and I just don’t know what the best move is.

I appreciate all perspectives. Thank you.


r/reactivedogs • • May 28 '25

Significant challenges Pitbull nipped my childs face again

0 Upvotes

I need some advice. I think I know what everyone will say, but I am going to ask for advice anyway. I have 2 step children ages 13 and 16 and one bio child aged 6. I wanted a cat for our family, but my husband is allergic and so he wanted a dog and I agreed. I have never owned a dog as an adult. My husband has owned one before. We sort of agreed to get a bernedoodle because they are allegedly hypoallergenic and good with kids. Before going to look at a breeder, my husband wanted to take a look at the shelter. I agreed because I always felt like shelter animals need homes. Both my husband and I work and so are very busy with jobs and 3 kids. My husband and 13 year old fell in love with this mix that was jumping 6 feet high. I knew immediately that the dog was too much dog for us, but my husband was sure she was the right dog, so we went home with her. She is a pitbull mix (maybe mixed with border Collie) who was brought in as a stray so there was nothing known about her.

She is about 1 year old, and extremely dog reactive, anxious, and has a very high amount of energy. She wasn't fixed when we got her and was in heat, so we had to wait before we could spay her, but she did get spayed a couple of weeks after we got her. She is extremely loving, cuddly, affectionate, and smart. She loves to play. My 6 year old hasn't been raised around animals and so doesn't entirely know how to interact with them. She also isn't a great listener, which i know is a parenting problem that I am working on.

The dog sometimes resource guards. The first negative interaction happened when everyone was in the living room and the dog had a bully stick she was chewing on. My daughter went to pet her and the dog nipped her face. A red mark was left, but skin wasn't broken. The next night my daughter was walking near the dog (not approaching or interacting with the dog) and the dog growled at her. We got a dog trainer immediately, and the dog no longer gets bully sticks and we are working on resource guarding and pretty much everything else as well. The dog enjoys playing with my husband and middle son and sometimes the dog play bites, which we do not encourage. The next face nipping instance I was in the room right next to my daughter and something happened that I am not quite sure about, but my daughter was upset and the nip did break skin with a small amount of blood.

The 3rd face nipping incident happened last night in front of my eyes. My daughter picked up one of the dogs toys and went to throw it, like we all often do because the dog likes chasing toys. The dog lunged and I couldn't tell if she was going for the item in my daughters hand or her face. I was able to immediately say NO and put my hand between them and there was no contact between the dog and my daughter. The dog is about 45 pounds, so not huge, but my daughter is less than 40 pounds.

We have reported the incidents to the vet, who has given us Prozac and trazodone for the dog, which we have been giving daily. The dog seems improved, but she is still super high energy and nippy at times. I think the bites are mostly play bites, but I am obviously not the most dog knowledgeable person. I dont let my daughter alone with the dog, but it's not possible for me to be at her side every moment. And the dog is extremely anxious and does not like to be separated from us. The dog enjoys cuddling my daughter, but sometimes will sort of harass her by followers her around trying to get her to play or engage even when my daughter tells the dog no and I have to long lead tie the dog to the door to get her to stop (next to us, not separated or alone)

I assume I should give the dog back to the shelter but was looking for thoughts anyone had. We have spent a lot of money on this dog to try to make it work, but frankly I am afraid of the dog because of what could happen to my daughter if she does something dumb the dog doesn't like. I am also worried that this is a simple training issue I am blowing way out of proportion.

Please don't come for me. I want to do whats best for my family, but I am also worried that I am overreacting and will potentially destroy this dogs life after not trying hard enough. I know if we return her to the shelter with a "bite" history it might not turn out well for her. I think she would be totally fine in a house with out small kids.

Sorry my thoughts are so jumble. Any insight is appreciated.


r/reactivedogs • • Mar 16 '24

Y’all, don’t use easywalk harnesses!

0 Upvotes

I was walking my puppy to work with my girlfriend in the morning (thankfully we left our adult dog at home) when we see a walker with a dog in a cheap cloth muzzle come out of a treed walkway then quickly backtrack up it and disappear into the trees.

We stopped and waited to give her and her dog a bit of a head start and the dog came running out naked at our dog with only a fraying cloth muzzle.

Luckily we have had a reactive dog in the past so I picked the puppy up straight away and my girlfriend was able to body block the dog and calm it down until the owner could get ahold of it.

I know front clip harnesses are often recommended by trainers so don’t make this mistake, make sure your harness is secure!


r/reactivedogs • • May 08 '24

Support Dog jumped on a runner today

0 Upvotes

We have a very reactive rescue, both to dogs and people (mostly just men) and because of this we walk her on a short lead and she is muzzled with a yellow collar that says nervous on it. We have made huge improvements recently but if someone (person or dog) makes eye contact, or makes her jump, inevitably she still goes nuts. We go to great lengths to be vigilant and keep our distance from people, and most of the people we pass respect this because its so very apparent she is a dog who needs space. I should probably mention she is quite a large dog.

We were about halfway round our walk this morning, husband has the lead and it is locked at about 18in/2ft. Dog is between us both and I have her attention focused on me with eye contact. Out of the corner of my eye I see movement, look back and jump because I see a runner less than 3 feet away from us - before I can even think, our dog jumps on him. No growl or bark, just pounces. He cried out in shock but realised she was muzzled and he wasn't injured so just got up and carried on his way.

Now, in my head, I am thinking "what kind of idiot runs up behind a dog that close without any sound or warning". We regularly check behind us and I hadn't seen him until he was just...there. The whole thing really stressed me out as she did make contact with her front paws and knock the guy down but I really don't know what else we could have done. He came out of nowhere, no warning, and was just there, super close.

I think I just need someone to tell me that we didn't do anything wrong as I really can't think what else we could have done to prevent this one. Or if we did make a mistake, what was it and how can we stop it happening again. Thanks for reading, I appreciate any advice or comments.


r/reactivedogs • • Dec 24 '23

Returning to shelter after 3.5 years together

3 Upvotes

Decided to send dog (4.5 year old pit shepherd mix) back to shelter after 3.5 years together

Wasn’t easy. She’s always been dog reactive and has bit 2 dogs while we’ve had her. She’s become a bit human aggressive and afraid she will bite one soon. Decided to send her back and will drop her off at shelter next week. Am i horrible for doing this? I don’t feel remorse to the point where I’m regretting it because I know we can’t be the right house for her. But it’s been a long time and know she might end up killed.


r/reactivedogs • • Jul 15 '23

Advice Needed Introducing baby to reactive dog

1 Upvotes

Friends, rodents, quadrupeds, lend me your ears. My wife is pregnant with our first child. We have a reactive dog, he is reactive towards dogs, and has a very high prey drive. He has met children aged 4 before, has been near babies in strollers and has given us no reason to believe he will have an issue with the baby. However, we want to do everything possible to make sure it is positive for the dog, and safe for the baby. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.


r/reactivedogs • • Feb 17 '25

Aggressive Dogs 13 yr old ex bait dog who is TERRIBLE on walks

0 Upvotes

First off, I love my dog immensly. So please don't come for me with "maybe you shouldn't have a dog".

I have a 12-13 yr old ex bait dog (pitbull / black mouth cur mix). I've had him for 8 years now and I still find myself getting extremely frustrated and pissed off when we go on walks. I know the saying "he's not giving you a hard time, hes having a hard time." But it certaintly doesn't feel that way...

I've spent $2500 and 16+ weeks of professional 1:1 training AND group training classes every week in the past, and it did absolutely nothing... He doesnt care about treats, toys, or my attention on walks. He just wants to sniff\/explore everything and goes crazy when he sees another dog. He wants to sniff so badly that he will bulldoze my legs out at any given moment to go sniff something at least a dozen times on every walk. He will pull as hard as he can to get where he wants to go. He even pulled my shoulder out of the socket once.

Also I have to make several 90 degree turns through neighborhoods to finally get home because if I made a sudden 180 turn around, he will put on the brakes and yank backwards as hard as he can to avoid going home. And sometimes I don't have time so I just have to pull pretty forcefully until he gives up and starts walking with me. It probably looks like bad to bystanders but I just don't have a choice sometimes. And if another dog runs up without a leash, I have to pick his 60lb ass up into the air to avoid a dog fight.

I try to listen to podcasts on our walks to distract myself from it, but sometimes my blood just boils when he yanks me around and I'm in a terrible mood for an hour or two after we get home.

Please help. I don't want to continue this for another year or two. What do I do?


r/reactivedogs • • Nov 19 '23

We surrendered our dog to a rescue today

3 Upvotes

I don’t know why I am even posting this, I guess I just need to make it make sense.

I would like to hear other’s experience or how to deal with the loss and guilt. Honestly I don’t even mind if you tell me how wrong I am.

We got this 1.5 year old border collie from a bad situation where he wasn’t ever walked, trained or socialized, in addition the breeder gave him away at 5weeks already. We really thought we could help having experience with the breed and training. And initially he wasn’t reactive either, only once we started walking him, something that was completely novel to him.

He was always very sweet in the house when there wasn’t anything triggering him. Super cuddly and gentle.

He was great until he wasn’t.

When he bit a friend the other day, we decided it’s all just too much. It’s was a really nasty bite on the hand. Multiple lacerations. He has bitten me multiple times and broken skin twice. He has tried to bite other people but luckily was wearing a muzzle. He has bitten my other dog. He is resource guarding stolen objects, steals food and tissues and basically anything I don’t want him to have and then eats it. The biggest issue is his reactivity though. He is reactive towards everything. Any person walking, dogs, birds, cars, cows, bikes, the ceiling fan, the roomba, and barking either on TV, my other dog or outside. He lunges and barks and snarls and it’s hard to hold him and he doesn’t calm down. After working with him for about 4 months he has learnt a lot but it hasn’t made a dent in the reactivity.

He once ran away which was the scariest thing, since he may chase cars and get hurt or may bite someone. Luckily he found his way home and miraculously nobody got hurt. He has destroyed the blinds and fly gate and we don’t open our windows anymore so he doesn’t get triggered by outside noises. He is on fluoxetine but I am not sure it made a big difference.

On the other hand he is potty trained now, has learnt to play fetch and learnt a bunch of tricks, he is happy to share toys, takes his treats very gentle, is weirdly enough not food aggressive but most importantly he is the biggest cuddle bug I ever met. He just melted onto our laps and wanted belly rubs. He was always smiling and seemed so happy. He just loved the ball after discovering fetch for the first time.

We are heart broken and I have been crying all day and I miss him so much. We really do love him and wish the best for him but after only 5 months, we are already exhausted and scared about the future. We needed to manage his behaviors pretty much constantly or he got himself in trouble. We worked with a couple trainers, exercised him, did training, worked with crates and treats. We gave the ecollar a shot but honestly kinda don’t get its appeal. I still feel we could have worked more consistently and done more training sessions throughout the day. Idk

We have been trying to find a home for him but needed to be transparent, after having multiple people interested, nobody ever wanted to meet him.

We found a rescue that has experience with reactive dogs and is a no kill rescue. The trainer even heard of it and it has very positive reviews online. It’s called a sanctuary but it certainly doesn’t look like a sanctuary. It looked gruesome to me. My dog was terrified and extremely stressed out. In a kennel between two other dogs. They didn’t know we were coming today, because apparently the owner with whom I communicated didn’t let his staff know, so the kennel wasn’t prepared. We paid a $1000 surrender fee.

My poor boy was freaked out from the start. We could barely put his leash on without him biting us and trying to get past us to bark at people. We got him to the kennel, he barked his head off and we had to walk away. I saw that he stopped barking about 5 minutes after we left and at least he laid down. He has an igloo with his sheep fur blanket there and chew toys but it’s all outside and nobody is going to pet him likely for a while because he looks so scary.

I will call them regularly and check in but otherwise that’s it. We surrendered him and now the house feels empty and quiet and I miss him and feel so guilty for not being able to help him.


r/reactivedogs • • May 14 '24

Vent Why are people so stupid

0 Upvotes

Woke up and took my dog/human reactive boy out to do his business. We live in an apartment and there’s only 2 directions we can go to reach grass. There were kids playing in his normal spot so we went the other direction. We almost got to the grass when a guy, girl, and a big dog pop around the corner so I switched directions again and now me and my poor boy, who just woke up and def needs to poop, are trapped standing in the middle of the parking lot just waiting as these people strolled past taking their time letting their dog sniff, no sense of urgency to walk by. So we’re just standing there awkwardly waiting to use the grass. Then this woman has the audacity to yell “Can I help u??” with an attitude. I said “No, I’m just giving my dog space, he’s not friendly, just tryna see which way u guys are going to let him use the bathroom that’s all” She had no response but I guess that was a good enough answer as they slowly continued walking. We’ve encountered stupider people but it pissed me off cuz I’m half asleep just trying to take my dog out, I’m not just staring at you for fun. Why are people so ignorant?

Edit to clarify Ignorant means uninformed. The “ignorant” I’m referring to is the “Can I help you?” which was said with attitude, not the fact that they were taking a turn or unaware of my dogs reactivity. No previous comments were made by me, nasty looks given, “hurry up”, annoyed body language, nothing of the sort. I am very used to having to wait. I was just standing there with my dog, watching because I have to always watch other dogs around to see which way they’re going. One of my dog’s big triggers is other dogs coming towards him. When socializing a reactive dog, you need to determine their trigger threshold, which is how close they can get to a trigger without reacting. The idea is to keep them within that threshold, if they’re reacting, they need more space from the trigger. I was watching them, along with the people and kids on the other side, to keep him within his threshold as part of his training. This interaction happened from halfway across a parking lot with a pretty decent distance between us. My dog wasn’t reacting at all because I had him under control with enough space from the triggers. The woman just didn’t like that I kept looking at them (because she was ignorant to the fact of why I was) and gave an attitude.


r/reactivedogs • • Feb 18 '26

Discussion What’s the consensus on e collars?

0 Upvotes

I know a lot of people hate them- is there ever a situation in which they’ve worked for reactive dogs?

Background: we have a 5 y/o shepherd mix who we rescued as a puppy. We have new baby and long story short she’s not adjusting well. She’s also generally reactive to everything (barriers, strangers, dogs). We started on meds about 2 months ago (no changes) and our vet recommended a training facility that does a day train program and uses e collars. I went in and they allowed me to feel it and it was similar to electrostim that you use on muscles. I left feeling okay about it and she’s scheduled to start next week but after reading more into e collars now I’m worried. Some people say it makes the reactivity/ aggression worse and obviously that’s the last thing I need


r/reactivedogs • • Feb 28 '24

Advice Needed Today killed my confidence

0 Upvotes

I adopted a female 4yo pit bull blue heeler mix last year and she is severely dog reactive/aggressive. She was severely attacked by a german shepherd in her previous home to the point of hospitalization, so she is pretty traumatized by dogs. Bigger dogs she acts more scared of, but little dogs she acts like she needs to attack them. When I notice a dog I get in front of her and tell her to sit and stay. We have been getting better and I use a martingale collar and it controls her fairly well and she can’t slip out of it.

Today, we were rounding a corner of a building and a few yards away were two puppy wiener dogs. As soon as I saw them, I made her sit and stay, but she was screaming and flipping and she was pulling rly hard towards them (she is 70lbs and all muscle so she is strong af; she is like 1/2 my body weight). She almost slipped out of my hands and it was so embarrassing, bc she went on for at least 30 seconds because the owner was not paying attention. One of his dog’s leash slipped out of his hand and the dog got fairly close to mine and if I wasn’t paying attention something would have happened. I was pulling the collar to try to get her to chill out and listen to me, but it’s like i’m not there when she is in fight or flight mode.

She is on clomicalm/clomprimine HCI, and she was previously on trazodone. The trazodone worked really well so honestly I think I might switch back to that, but I was nervous to give her trazodone everyday.

I need advice. I am at a loss. This situation broke me, I came home and sobbed. I feel so bad for her.