r/raylib • u/FantasticBiscotti672 • 4h ago
Is this game better off with Raylib or Unity?
I'm wanting to make a grid-based, proc-gen RPG that's resembles DOOM or Daggerfall (3d world, 2d sprites) but navigate with grid-based walking like in Eye of the Beholder. It would have modern retro graphics that will require lighting, weather, and shadows (see my four Daggerfall Unity screenshots for my vision in art, which uses the amazing DREAM mod.). I'm familiar with Raylib and did a few 2D games with it in C++. I love it. I found BigFoot76's rlights.h that really helps with lighting and shadows with my simple tests. But I'm just wondering, will I have the best luck in Raylib or Unity with this game? I'm sure you're not biased at all here, and can maybe share how Raylib stacks up with 3D. I think one thing that attracts me to wanting to use Raylib is the proc-gen is done at runtime with grid-based layouts, so the project may be very code-centric. I do enjoy how Raylib lets you focus on code.
I grew up in the days when Unity was just starting and did coding by hand, starting with DirectDraw. So, Raylib brings that sense of joy back to programming. I'm for speed, but I'm also a realist that I won't be taking advantage of Untiy's level editor since most of the proc-gen is done in code for both interiors and exteriors. I don't know what tools I would be benefiting from if I'm not using the level editor.