r/Rational_Liberty • • Jun 04 '20

Spreading Freedom Justin Amash introduces bill to end qualified immunity for police officers

Thumbnail
twitter.com
44 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Apr 15 '22

Well said

Post image
36 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Jan 13 '21

Spreading Freedom "Freedom of Speech" is a libertarian principle. The First Amendment protects freedom of speech from the Government. Corporations and individuals can still violate the principle of "Freedom of Speech" and thereby commit censorship. Censorship is almost always bad. Opposition to censorship is good.

32 Upvotes

You don't have to take my word for this argument. Here are the words of Aaron Schwartz, an instrumental figure in early Reddit history:

So I have my own justification for freedom of speech: because we can. Human freedom is important, so we should try to protect it from encroachment wherever possible. With most freedoms — freedom of motion, freedom of exchange, freedom of action — permitting them in full would cause some problems. People shouldn’t be free to walk into other people’s bedrooms, take all their stuff, and then punch the poor victims in the face. But hurling a bunch of epithets at the guy really isn’t so bad.

Freedom of speech is one place where we can draw the line and say: all of this is acceptable. There’s no further logic to it than that; freedom of speech is not an instrumental value. Like all freedom, it’s fundamental, and the only reason we happen to single it out is because it’s more reasonable than all of the others.

http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/becausewecan

Or the General Manager of Twitter, 9 years ago:

"Generally, we remain neutral as to the content because our general council and CEO like to say that we are the free speech wing of the free speech party."

https://amp.theguardian.com/media/2012/mar/22/twitter-tony-wang-free-speech

Or Jack Dorsey, the man himself, on the platform itself:

Twitter stands for freedom of expression. We stand for speaking truth to power. And we stand for empowering dialogue.

https://twitter.com/jack/status/651003891153108997

They are not talking about first amendment protections. They are invoking the high ideal that communication between willing parties should not be restrained by government, individuals, or any other platform that offers to publish people's speech. It is universal in reach.

The Wikipedia page is 100% clear on this as well:

Freedom of speech is a principle that supports the freedom of an individual or a community to articulate their opinions and ideas without fear of retaliation, censorship, or legal sanction.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech

If you are arguing that Freedom of Speech somehow does not apply to corporate entities, you are wrong. You are of course free to believe otherwise, but you will remain wrong.

It is that simple. If you cannot separate the ideal that is Freedom of Speech from the Constitutional Right which protects freedom of speech, your thinking is, in this way, flawed.

People make this error both ways, but the more egregious one is when people assume that an action which does not infringe on the First Amendment somehow doesn't violate 'freedom of speech.' "It is not censorship because its a private entity and the first amendment doesn't apply."

No. Censorship can occur any time the ideal of freedom of speech is infringed upon. Wikipedia again makes this point clear:

Censorship is the suppression of speech, public communication, or other information, on the basis that such material is considered objectionable, harmful, sensitive, or "inconvenient." Censorship can be conducted by governments, private institutions, and other controlling bodies.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship

When you interfere with the ability of a given speaker to communicate with a willing (key word!) audience, you are censoring that person. You may have the right to commit this censorship, but that does not inherently mean that you are justified in censoring the person, or that it was the right thing to do.

Censorship can be justified, and we are fully allowed, under Freedom of Speech, to discuss what is and is not justifiable censorship. This is a discussion I welcome. Freedom of association means you do not have to welcome people onto your platform, and you can remove them if they violate the terms set down when you agreed to host them.

This does not mean you should do so, and in many cases you can rightly be criticized for your decision to eject someone. Even if we agree that the government should not force you to host certain speakers, we can still take you to task for failing to live up to the ideals of Free Speech. You should not be forced to host someone who wants to use your platform for speech, but you should, I'd say, strive to make your rules reasonable and apply them equally.

I think the simplest rule worth applying is that people calling for the censorship of other groups solely because of what they believe and the content of their speech do not believe in Freedom of Speech, and thus are not entitled to the protection of Freedom of Speech. I am still inclined to defend their Freedom of Speech, but I feel NO obligation to extend them the protections of an ideal they do not believe in.

If you are in favor of unjustifiable censorship, I have no problem censoring you.

Likewise, if you are going to use your Freedom of Speech to argue that Freedom of Speech only applies to governments, especially after reading this, I will use my Freedom of Speech to tell you how stupid your line of thinking is.

And that's the beauty of Free Speech in itself. It gives us the ability to discuss what Free Speech actually is. And removing that ability to discuss what is and is not Free Speech, whether its government or a private platform doing it, is an incredibly dangerous precedent.

I leave you with the words of a minor character from some obscure show nobody's ever heard of:

“When you tear out a man's tongue, you are not proving him a liar, you're only telling the world that you fear what he might say.”

And fear, by itself, is never a good enough justification.


r/Rational_Liberty • • Dec 16 '20

Anti-Tyranny How to (Legally) Make Your Own Off-the-Books Handgun

Thumbnail
reason.com
32 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Sep 08 '20

Anti-Tyranny NSA surveillance exposed by Snowden ruled unlawful

Thumbnail
bbc.com
31 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Aug 14 '20

Political Liberty You Don't Have to Vote for Your Party's Crappy Ticket

Thumbnail
reason.com
29 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Dec 03 '21

Federal Overreach gets reminded about the 2nd Amendment

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Dec 13 '21

Bitcoin & Cryptocurrency Silk Road Founder Ross Ulbricht Sells $6 Million NFT From Prison

Thumbnail
futurism.com
26 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Nov 23 '20

Free State Project Jason Osborne (affiliated with the Free State Project) Will Be New Hampshire House Majority Leader – InsideSources

Thumbnail
insidesources.com
26 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Jul 07 '20

Law & Economics If Housing Affordability Is a National Priority, Then Why Does the Government Tax Almost Everything You Need to Build a Home?

Thumbnail
cato.org
26 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Oct 23 '20

Spreading Freedom Dr. Jo Jorgensen - Please watch and share. If you have the time, please like and comment on the original on YouTube. Thank you!! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Osb4du8riHA&feature

Thumbnail
youtube.com
25 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Oct 20 '20

Jo Jorgensen Libertarian Presidential Candidate Fox Business. Please watch and share. If you have the time, please like and comment on the YouTube original. Thank you!!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
24 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Aug 30 '16

Anti-Tyranny Reverse Voxsplaining: Drugs vs. Chairs (Why epi-pens are pricey and chairs are not)

Thumbnail
slatestarcodex.com
24 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Nov 04 '20

Political Liberty Libertarian Candidate Marshall Burt Wins Wyoming State House Race

Thumbnail
reason.com
23 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Apr 30 '20

Political Liberty Justin Amash Becomes the First Libertarian Member of Congress

Thumbnail
reason.com
23 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Sep 29 '20

The Crazy Ones Jo Jorgensen Spike Cohen 2020 Campaign Ad. Please watch and share. If you have the time please like and comment on the original on YouTube. Thank you!!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
22 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Sep 28 '20

Maintaining Freedom Libertarian Presidential Candidate Jo Jorgensen holds event in Madison. Please watch and share. If you have the time please like and comment on the original on YouTube. Thank you!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
22 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Sep 10 '20

Law & Economics Airlines Are Asking for a Second Bailout. Congress Should Say No.

Thumbnail
reason.com
22 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Aug 26 '20

Jo Jorgensen Campaign Ad - War Is Over Please watch and share. And if you have the time go to YouTube and like this video. Thank you!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
22 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Dec 06 '14

What are We Trying to Do Here?

22 Upvotes

What is this Subreddit meant to achieve?

Put simply, we are trying to figure out the most efficient and effective methods of advancing the cause of liberty for ourselves and the world, and then implementing them.

As such, the discussion here will be slightly 'higher level' than most other libertarian subreddits and so you should have a strong understanding of the ins and outs of libertarian theory (of ALL types, from Rothbard to Friedman to Huemer to Murphy and all in between) in order to contribute effectively. Likewise we welcome libertarians of all 'types,' but even if you are a dyed-in-the-wool deontic Rothbardian, you had better have read and understand David Friedman's 'Machinery of Freedom' and know how polycentric law is expected to operate in theory.

Suffice it to say this is not the place to come for answers to your basic reservations about libertarian theory. Everyone is welcome to read along, however.

There will also be discussion of rationality itself and the methods you can use to improve your own rationality in the face of the biases that plague default humans and societies. Learning these methods will improve your effectiveness in all areas from your love life to your job to board games with friends. If you are succeeding as a rationalist, you will start to win more often.

As it pertains to this subreddit, however, we will consider our unified goal to be the advancement of liberty and so any discussion too far afield for that topic should be placed elsewhere. I myself am but an aspiring rationalist of the Bayesian variety, so this sub will also be used to help me and all participants become better Rationalists, and to discuss any resources which will aid that goal.

The object, then, is to take the tenets of rationality, specifically instrumental rationality, and apply them to the problems that face the liberty movement. Further, we will consider the challenges that are likely to arise once freedom has been achieved (on any scale) and propose the most promising solutions for the eventuality we should need them. Finally, we will be taking in information from any relevant sources to try and figure out how likely certain future events are to occur and the actions we can take that are most likely to bring about a preferable outcome.

However, the particular methods you choose to apply will depend on your particular goals. If your goal is personal liberty then you will be taking slightly different steps than someone trying to liberate a whole country. While we are all interested in advancing human liberty, there are a plethora of goals within that broad category which you can adopt as your own. Find something worth fighting for, even at the cost of your lesser preferences. We're all pulling in the same direction.

Finally, it is vital that you commit to taking the actions that, after examination, appear most likely to achieve your preferred goals. For instance, if your goal is achieving freedom for yourself within your lifetime, and you have determined that this goal is likely to be achieved by joining the Free State Project, then rationality demands that you go ahead and join the Free State Project.

What are we NOT trying to do here?

  1. Argue about the gray areas of libertarian theory.

This is not the place to hash out our mild differences. Nihilists, egoists, consequentialists, and all the rest are all welcome but this subreddit is focused on moving forward with some unity of purpose, and focusing on our minimal but key differences is at best tangential to that goal. LIKEWISE we will not be arguing about who is or isn't a 'true' libertarian. If your goal is minarchy, then you still favor an increase in liberty and thus are welcome.

2) Prove libertarian theory right/'circlejerk.'

At least not directly. To truly operate as a rationalists you must be prepared to discard your ideas and beliefs when they are disproven. If a plan isn't working out and cannot be fixed, scrap it. If an experiment proves some tenet of libertarian thought incorrect, question the experiment but if it holds up then scrap the tenet. Our goal should be to demonstrate the success of libertarian theory through actively applying it. Where it doesn't work out we should admit the failure and move on. We don't need to prove libertarian theory 100% correct in every way in order to act on our beliefs that it is correct, but where a belief comes in conflict with observed reality the belief must die.

3) Take ourselves too seriously.

If we aren't enjoying ourselves at least a little, then there's not much point to it. With this in mind do try and keep morale up and feel free to break up the monotony with levity. I will try out some approaches to keep things light as the community (hopefully) develops.


r/Rational_Liberty • • Jan 23 '25

Spreading Freedom Truly makes you think!

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Jan 28 '21

/r/WallStreetBets is trying something unprecedented in history — and the media’s not reporting it…

Thumbnail
medium.com
21 Upvotes

r/Rational_Liberty • • Sep 04 '20

#LetHerSpeak - Jorgensen Cohen 2020 Full Length Ad _Please watch, and share. If you have time, please go to the original on YouTube and like and comment. Thank you!!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
21 Upvotes