Needed to get this off my chest because this is honestly my favorite video game and one of my favorite pieces of media ever. This is the largest gathering of fans of the game and it's a sad sight.
I don't mind if you ban me for what I'm about to say next just as long as you make it permanent and read this post all the way through. Things started to get bad in June of 2022 because it was pride month and there was an influx of fanart. More posting meant more interaction and more interaction meant the subreddit reached more people. Not all of these people knew about the game, but their interactions with the posts bolstered the subreddit, and some of them joined regardless. I'm not going to name subreddits, but it was pride month posts that inspired growth, so it was vehemently pro-pride subreddit members that joined the community. That much was wonderful. I mean sure, it estranged a few hundred bitter people, but this subreddit grew regardless.
Some of those people were very pissy on their way out, and now we have pride flags in the subreddit icon and some specific callouts in the rules. Fine by me, fine by most people. Except the new members are completely insufferable. Half the subreddit is now fanart for the game - fanart which is oftentimes sloppy (sorry) - and the other half is monitor photos of some pretty typical gameplay happening. You don't enforce the "no roleplaying" rule and everyone knows it but doesn't do anything because most of the 50k people are new. I doubt that many of the most active members actually play Rain World, which is ironic considering how much pandering the developers do now. Nobody is willing to discuss this, but Akupara's PR and even game-development positions were influenced by the subreddit. Notice how Downpour, despite being little more than a revamped fanmod, was teased with exciting gameplay that made up for plot issues, but the new DLC hints at nothing. Nothing is happening in the trailer, the images on the steampage are devoid of any substance, and nobody cares. Nobody discusses this. It's just hype in the relevant discussion threads and theory posts. If you're diffident or show restraint, you're a wet blanket. It breaks my heart. This game mattered a lot to me. I enjoyed discussing it, I enjoyed when the community was funny and knew how to express ideas in methods other than terrible sketches and drawings, I enjoyed posts about skill and in-game mechanics. You are all that Rain World, one of the greatest video games ever made, has left, and you don't seem to care.
If it were up to me, I would absolutely:
-Hamper some - just some - of the artposts, enough so that this subreddit shouldn't have to be renamed to include "art" in the title.
-Encourage posting more gameplay and coherent discussions (I don't know, make a hall of fame or something for the best posts, because I guarantee it most of them are not art).
-Weed out roleplayers and people who do not care about the game. Separate the weed from the chaff, it will not be as hard as you think.
-Enforce spoiler flairs. Nobody cares about this because nobody plays the game, but goddamn is it necessary.
If it's any encouragement, the other largest Rain World community is chock-full of coomers. The first time I tried to post this it got autoremoved because I mentioned it by name. You can do better without even trying.
ETA: Either I hallucinated the modlist, or there are a lot of losers just like me. To those of you who try to be constructive, thank you. To nobody's surprise, the biggest gripe with this post is that I was strongly against all the art. Not every solution has to pertain to banning. As I said:
-Make art days instead of art months. Preferably in the middle of the week so there's a lower chance of me seeing it LOL
-Ban low-quality artists who spam their art. Even if there are only like 3 people who do this, great. Ban them. There is no "journey." They are where they are and that's that.
-Encourage subreddit migration and shill the discord.
-If you post an OC, death by firing squad.
Let me know if you have any other ideas.