We all know that 2025 was Carrol’s draft. Ashton Jeanty has talent but obviously we don’t have the trenches to support him, and thus he wasn’t a wise choice. Bech hasn’t panned out, but we also got Porter(a decent starter who’s still developing, and needs more time given he use to be a receiver). We still gotta Tonka out of this draft, which most likely was more a Spytek pick. 2025 draft hasn’t been the best, and so I understand people’s frustration, but let’s not kid ourselves, that was probably more a Carroll train wreck then anything else. Looking at 2026 it’s a fair bit different.
Now in 2026, we can finally start judging Spytek. We drafted Stukes who is a very solid starter, and who’s still developing. He fills a genuine need on defense and will only get better. After, you then get Crawford who is difficult to judge given his season ending injury. Then we get Zuhn(who is looking good), Jerod Mccoy(who was a risk but will hopefully develop well), Mike Washington who is a decent rb2, then later we get Masses. Many of those picks came in later rounds, which mind you, you usually don’t find decent starters. The fact that we hit multiple times is pretty good. And of course many of these players will be making mistakes, it’s their rookie year. Be we see genuine promise.
That’s not even counting this years FA. We hit on signings with Dean(who is genuinely amazing), Walker who’s played well, and Linderbaum who outside of a couple games has been solid. Plus Kirk Cousins who played amazingly and Taron Johnson who’s been serviceable. Yes Kwitty has sucked but that was in the context of not having Max and having to fill his spot with a body. Not the best choice but also somewhat understandable. Nailor was a swing and a miss, but not every FA signing will workout and I think given the other successes it can be forgiven in the grand scheme of things.
In conclusion, we should write off 2025 as a flop and move on. That’s not on Spytek, or at least not mainly. So far, when he’s had control, we hired an amazing offensive coach who’s elevated our offense to a top 10 offense despite no wr’s, no run game, and a Oline which needs much more work. We build on places we needed, got an anchor center, our linebackers are covered, and we satisfied qb, corner, and safety. Much of our defense is made up of young players who are developing but show promise. We started the rebuild properly this year, and so far we’ve made progress. People are really impatient, which I understand given the dumpster fire this franchise has been for a long time. But genuinely this rebuild will take a couple more years. Our defense needs to make mistakes and our young players need to learn. This is what happens when you let rookies develop, you go through growing pains. I’d rather that then suffer through old washed up veterans. But genuinely, I think Spytek has done a decent job so far, and if we have more years like 2026 in terms of building up the roster, we can start to compete in 2027 or 2028.
P.s. the Rob hire was a late hiring cycle choice, and so I think the defense, even without any roster change, should be much much better with a more competent DC. All in all the team has done what it needed to do, and hopefully will continue to make steps forward.