I may have just posted the below to r/Oasis. Stop by the comments, I’m sure it’ll be a hoot…
So what happened is this: oasis had a great two record run of ripping off 60s hits that indie kids had never heard. The world was at their feet; they could do no wrong. Noel told the world he was a genius and people who’d never really heard The Beatles, T-Rex or The Who believed him.
Then, they went off and made the most horrific cocaine-turd of a record in the entire history of popular music, the (by Noel’s own repeated admission) truly dreadful Be Here Now. It was released to the public in August 1997. Noel knew while making it that it was an uninspired overblown mess, but was hoping hype and swagger would continue to get them through.
Unfortunately in May of that year, OK Computer was released and the entire face of rock music was changed. It was a record that rejected all the hackneyed re-hashing of the past and it single-handedly dragged rock music forwards into the approaching new millennium.
Music journalists who just a couple of years earlier were tripping over themselves to circle jerk over the gallaghers, were suddenly hailing Radiohead as “the saviours of guitar music”.
Into this post-OK-Computer world, the sloppy pile of Be Here Now plopped. Initially the halo effect of the band’s reputation buoyed it along, but very quickly people began to see that the emperor was severely under-dressed. This began the slow, but steady and continual descent of the Burnage Beatles until their eventual demise.
What’s worse - when Noel faced his nemesis and actually sat down to listen to OK Computer, he found that he just couldn’t comprehend it. He wasn’t even jealous - he just plain didn’t get it.
All those journos and kids who’d thought that him filling up old empty Beatles vodka bottles with tap water represented god-like creative genius now agreed that something else entirely was where it was at. He couldn’t even rip it off, because he just couldn’t get his head round it.
So he did the only thing he knew how to do: he got his gob going - and in every single interview he turned the line of questioning into a way of saying “I’ll tell you what we’re not, and that’s….” Before launching a yawn-some tirade against the band who the whole world agreed had made the better record
Meanwhile, Radiohead re-defined popular music each time they released a new record. Each album exploring a fresh new horizon. Every album sounding radically different from the last. Very much the way The Beatles had - every time The Beatles released a record they’d taken huge strides and given the world a new definition of what pop music could be.
Meanwhile, every time oasis released a record…….. it sounded a bit like The Beatles.
Deep deep down inside him, noel knew that he’d been given an opportunity and he’d blown it. He had the world in the palm of his hand, but he just shovelled half of Bolivia up his nose and carried on making formulaic 60s re-tread dullness - and maybe, just maybe the naysayers were right that all his good stuff from the glory days had simply been a parade of well crafted rip-offs. (Standing On The Shoulders Of Giants indeed….)
He will never admit this to himself, of course. He must deny deny deny - and instead he has created a single icon to represent the turning point of his career.
It’s not that he wasted his chance, you see - it’s that the world is wrong for loving Thom Yorke. If he could somehow shove that genie back in the bottle, he could go from being a grumpy washed up old has been to what he was before OK computer came out.
Get over it noel. You had a good run for those few years. You had people fooled and you made a mega lottery win’s worth of money.
You stalled, crashed and burned though - and once you admit it’s your own fault and not because of Thom, maybe you’ll be able to move on.
Or maybe instead: you can just dance like a monkey-boy next year and do a desperate cash-grab re-union nostalgia show, celebrating what was happening 30 years ago.
After all, that’s what you were doing back then……