r/questionablecontent • • Sep 01 '24 Take My Silver

Yay's pronouns are they/them

2 Upvotes

Since the next comic has a good percentage chance of returning to the subject of Yay, I thought I'd point out that their pronouns are they/them since it seems difficult for many here..

"But I look at them and see them as female so use she/her!"

You are wrong. Everyone exclusively refers to Yay with they/them.

Saying that when corrected is transphobic.

Also, presentation does not always equal gender, nor does gender dictate pronoun use.

"They refers to the plurality of Yay bodies, she for the individual Yay we see on pages."

Yay is a singular individual occupying multiple bodies. People who are unaware Yay has multiple bodies still use they/them pronouns.

Referring to The Director and the Morays by a collective they/them and individual Morays as she/her works because the Morays, even with their limited intellect, are discreet individuals. Yay is a singular conciousness in multiple bodies. They have also talked about their bodies being extensions of themselves rather than individuals.

If you told me you use he/him when referring to your legs, she/her when referring to any other body part, and they/them when referring to your whole person, I would. However that is not the case for Yay as far as we have seen.

In a better version of this comic there might be room for discussion about how siloing aspects of one's personality into different, separate bodies can create different people or expressions out of a whole. Or alternatively an actual exploration of how different parts of Yay are treated by how they are perceived (eg masculine or feminine). But we have not heard that from Yay, nor any indication Yay's chassis are in any way separate from each other as the same individual.

"They/them is always plural"

You are wrong. The singular they has been in use since at least the 1300s.

"I never noticed"

I think you might just be dumb sorry ¯_(ツ)_/¯


r/questionablecontent • • Jun 16 '19

Unpopular opinion: The world isn't fiction anymore. All the characters are extension of Jeph's religious and political opinions.

0 Upvotes

Before we begin, fun fact. This is a literal copy/paste posted on the other QC sub, and was removed WITHIN TWO MINUTES. I was then pointed to this sub.

EDIT: I would like to genuinely thank this sub for leaving this open for discussion and debate. I am a person who finds true happiness in a good debate, and some of you are making me think. I'm going out for a few hours and will respond to more when I get home.


I've been reading QC since somewhere in the 800s. Now I know in the last 10 years I've changed myself, and I'm sure Jeph has as well, but in general fictional worlds shouldn't start blurring the fourth wall the way QC has.

  • Almost every character out of nowhere is now gay.

  • Roko quit her CAREER out of nowhere because cops = bad.

  • Roko is now campaigning for May to get a new body paid for by the government because Bernie Sanders logic.

I can probably think of more, but the downvotes are already gonna rain down on me so I'll stop here.

Sven is our last hope. In b4 May's new body is male and Sven is now robo gay like robo Faye.


r/questionablecontent • • Jan 09 '23

The Real Reason QC Can Never Recover

2 Upvotes

Count me among those who keep coming back to QC like an abused spouse.

There are a lot of good posts here about why QC is falling in quality, and they all seem to come down to the same thing: There's no more real conflict for the characters, no arguments that aren't resolved in five strips or less, no struggles (look at how many are turning into instant millionaires), and as a result, no drama.

And there CAN'T be. Not with the Tumblratti who are Jeph's primary source of income calling the shots.

The comic has become a smorgasbord of "representation." Every single in-focus character is there to be the face of some minority or supposedly oppressed group. Which means that they can never be seriously in the wrong because they are no longer characters with interesting flaws that can create conflict and drama, but some Tumblrist's idealized representative.

Clinton and Elliot can never break up without it being seen as an attack on homosexual relationships. Ditto Faye and Bubbles. Ditto, well, EVERYBODY because everyone is suddenly pansexual. Can you imagine the outcry if Martin and Claire ever broke up? Or if Claire ever did anything just dead wrong, for that matter? The Tumblr twits would be calling for Jeph to off himself. Again. He'd lose his sweet income overnight as the toxic "fans" canceled him for daring to have a trans person being anything less than a messianic archetype.

If the characters can never disagree, can never be wrong, can never have a moment of selfishness that comes back to bite them, can never even make a crass joke that might rile up the SJWs, you can't have the drama that used to make QC an interesting read.


r/questionablecontent • • Nov 13 '25

Hard take but QC was never "good"

Post image
0 Upvotes

Looking back in nostalgia and the fact that all of us who have been following the comic since 2007 (during the boom of webcomics) and before... I don't think Qc was ever "good." I think we thought it was better than it was because we were younger and our pools were more shallow now as adults we Chase the novelty we felt in high school, in our teens but really looking back its no where to be found. Its like looking back and realizing that 4chan wasnt that great, Charlie the unicorn was funny when we had an undeveloped prefrontal cortex, and that grammar nazi were cringe- when we look back. Even still those squirrel clamp edits are golden and delicious for our current psyche and really help to bring it to where it could have modernly placed if the comic could have just grown up a little and poked a little more fun at itself, so I appreciate it


r/questionablecontent • • Jul 09 '22

If you hate QC so much, why are you still here?

0 Upvotes

Don’t get me wrong, I also think that the comic has been a bit shit for quite a while (not that it was ever the pinnacle of storytelling, tbh).

But this whole subreddit seems to me like a constant circle jerk of how the strip is awful, Jeph is a terrible writer, the art doesn’t make sense, the characters are crap, there are just pastel AIs everywhere, etc.

If QC is so shit why don’t you stop reading it and ranting about it?


r/questionablecontent • • Dec 11 '17

Would people please try to use Tilly's correct pronouns?

18 Upvotes

Look, I understand lots of people don't like them, and I understand exactly why. But they have said specifically that they use they/them/theirs pronouns, so please respect them. I see more comments using she/her/hers for Tilly than they/them/theirs, and it's really not okay.

E: this was well-received initially, then apparently the transphobes came out of the walls. Anyway, you got a fucking problem, post a comment, and debate, don't just go around downvoting everything I say and saying nothing of your own. If you disagree, say why. And if your reason is so stupid you don't want to post it, maybe don't downvote over it.

E2: Seriously literally every comment I've made in here is getting downvoted a ton, without responses. What the fuck people.

E3: Well, apparently someone's "argument" which amounts to a combination of personal insults, playing the victim because I'm "pouncing" on them, and factually incorrect statements is more appealing. Whatever.


r/questionablecontent • • May 06 '16

Why does Faye always get her way?

3 Upvotes

Does Jeph have some kind of motivation in his life to write a character that breaks a basic law of storytelling? I just don't understand. I mean, for christ's sake, she's fat. Is this some kind of pro-fat bias Jeph has?

I mean, I just can't get over it

  • 3/4 of the male characters have fallen in love with her, despite her being both obese and an asshole

  • Bubbles has fallen into a deep friendship with her, despite her being a nagging, meddling jerk

  • She deeply betrayed Dora and, in return, Dora committed insurance fraud for her.

  • She had a consenting, mutually-enjoyed relationship with Sven, and in return Sven ended up destroyed and for-no-reason hated by her sister, but Faye ended up unscathed and self-righteous.

What the hell is with this ultra-PC pro-fat, pro-woman bias in the strip??


r/questionablecontent • • Jul 08 '25

Discussion What are some of the worst takes jeph had over the last 5/7 years?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/questionablecontent • • Sep 05 '16

Brun is honestly awful

4 Upvotes

She is bland as fuck and I haven't enjoyed a single comic involving her. I can't be alone on this!


r/questionablecontent • • Jul 08 '25

Discussion Does Anyone In This Sub Enjoy The Comic?

0 Upvotes

I'm looking back months, and I can find maybe two posts that aren't "Holy shit Jeph is the worst fucking artist and writer in comics history."

Has the quality come down over the years? Yeah. Has his need to make a hundred characters and have them all be the depth of soup spoons caused problems? Definitely. Is it still enjoyable? It is to me.

I guess I wonder why so many people who clearly hate the comic are even here. I've never understood the appeal of posting in a sub that clearly isn't aimed at me.


r/questionablecontent • • Jan 01 '15

Is Claire Male or Female?

0 Upvotes

I don't get it. She says she's trans, and identifies as a female. But she looks like a female. Does that mean she's physically a guy and took hormones to look like a chick? Everything about her says female, including her sexual orientation, but she's transgender. I'm so confused.


r/questionablecontent • • Nov 01 '17

The Jacques School of Responding to Criticism

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/questionablecontent • • Sep 15 '15

Anyone else notice the art quality drop?

0 Upvotes

I thought it was a guest artist but his last two comics have had the most lazily drawn facial expressions.


r/questionablecontent • • Feb 02 '21

Meta Let's all be less mean to Jeph. He's a real person and even if we don't like how the comic is going I know all y'all chunguses would be sad if it stopped.

3 Upvotes

I know I would be sad if it stopped.

He's never going to admit we got to him. He talks a good game on Twitter but the audience is the one with the power. We told him he was a poopy head and now he's actively shitting his pants in revenge. We say "too many new quirky characters who behave super weird about relationships", and he says.... I guess I can't really make up a worse parody than Willow Dragonfang who wanders off from her friends to foster a gay ship between strangers. He showed us, huh!

We won, okay? Baby mad, he's trolling to the point of a character reminding herself out loud not to squeeee over gay men (sigh), and sure, that's shit writing. But we don't need to make him feel like shit too. Wouldn't you feel disgusting if he hurt himself again? I'm sure nobody feels responsible for the consequences of group bullying. And sadly, we have bullied him. I think we can dispense with the fiction that Jeph doesn't check this sub. He's gonna throw the comic down the toilet if this keeps up and maybe even worse.

I spend like 15 seconds reading the comic each day but Jeph spends a lot more than 15 seconds making it every day. It's 15 seconds for us, but a lot of work for him. Even if you hate the new art and direction, be positive. I myself entertain fantasies Renee is going to get her comeupppance.


r/questionablecontent • • Sep 04 '24

Discussion The new low of QC's Quality Control.

4 Upvotes

Last night's comic (and the Bar arc in general) either hints at or reinforces all the things wrong with modern QC.

  • Queer for the sake of it; Roko is panicking because Spooks isn't just her friend, but her unrealized love interest. Because all the robots are predestined to be gay, because Jeph does it to spite us reddit chuds.

  • Babies!: Spooks ran away in a panic and the only thing that will make her feel better is the comforting assurances of a maternal figure. Because Jeph's unresolved mommy abandonment issues.

  • Punching Bag: Sven and Pintsize. Pintsize gets to tag along only to be uncerimonously tossed out of the storyline (and off-panel too). Sven gets to be a wishy-washy AI-curious tourist, mocked for it, then briefly plays strawman for all Jeph's "tell me about Claire's genitals" agitators.

  • X is the worst and I love them: All characters who have negative traits and no redeeming qualities beyond informed ones (Liz currently, previously Ayo, Willow, Purple AI, Millie) must vacillate between comedy and tragedy with their actions and the author demands we applaud both performances equally, or less stand accused of lacking basic human empathy.

I'm tired, boss.


r/questionablecontent • • Nov 30 '17

No Jeph. This is not okay.

15 Upvotes

Edit: I received an apology from Jeph which I deeply appreciate. Hopefully he will make some kind of change in the future to abate my concerns.

The world at large has a problem with the stigmatization of Trans and nonbinary people. They are stereotyped as rapists, as mentally deficient, as socially inept, as ill, and as unwanted members of society.

Tilly being non-binary is one of two things:

  • Either you INTENTIONALLY made a character who is instantly unlikeable, whio doesn't understand "no" or consent, and who is wholly bothersome, and also planned them to be nonbinary (what awful representation of nonbinary people in your diverse comic!) or

  • you have decided to suddenly make Tilly nonbinary in the hope that your readers will "like" your awful character more because of representation.

No. I have read this comic for most of my adult life, Jeph, and I am wholly and genuinely offended by this them of events. I've bought your books and your merchandise. I've stood beside you through controversy after controversy and while I don't like all your characters, I have never seen such an out-of-toich representation of an already demonized community. As a nonbinary person, I am absolutely apalled at how this went down.

Are in a world where nonbinary and transgender individuals are physically attacked, socially excluded, and societally demonized for stereotypes this character embodies.

This is not ok.

I know I'll probably be banned for this post, or at the last downvoted, but I stand by it and know I did the right thing by not staying silent.


r/questionablecontent • • Aug 30 '23

I gotta say, that's some god tier foreshadowing in strip 1300. This is almost 1000 pages before Claire appeared and even more before we knew everything about her

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/questionablecontent • • Jun 02 '21

Low effort Damn, why do you all still read the comic

0 Upvotes

If you hate it so much?


r/questionablecontent • • Apr 20 '26

Discussion does a single visitor of this sub actually like QC ?

1 Upvotes

Been reading the strip for ever.I only joined recently and most posts read like sore fandom.


r/questionablecontent • • Oct 06 '21

Am I the only one who actually likes QC?

0 Upvotes

I've been following the strip for years and I still love it. I hope Jeph keeps going for a long time. I'm blown away by the negativity on this sub. Seriously, doesn't anyone else actually like QC?


r/questionablecontent • • Oct 13 '14

I am prepared to take some flak on this, but... why the hell is Pintsize even a character?

0 Upvotes

I have never enjoyed anything about him, at all. He seems to have come about as an attempt to put QC into the same league as other popular web-comics that had sarcastic robot sidekicks (Penny Arcade, Ctrl-Alt-Delete, etc.), but has nothing much about him that makes him stand out in his own right.

I find him offensive and awful, and totally distracting from the general realism that the strip otherwise sort of manages to maintain.


r/questionablecontent • • Nov 07 '22

Shitpost I literally don't give two shits about twitter or Elon. I just hate knowing Jeph is sitting out there smugly thinking he "got one" on the "man" because his account was banned.

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/questionablecontent • • Jan 08 '26

Why is the fact that Jeph Jacques is a racist not discussed more?

35 Upvotes

I'm not talking about the Ayo discussion, because I don't really agree with a lot going on there. But I'm gonna say this.

Hi, hello, Black woman here. I started reading QC pretty close to when it started because an artist friend of mine said it was interesting. It didn't get interesting to me until Faye told Marten about her dad, but I thought it was cool that a person who obviously was not the best artist in the world was giving it a shot.

And then I started noticing things. Like the lack of Black people. In a supposed college town. And how Jeph seemed to look at Asian women -- particularly East Asian and South Asian -- through the same skeevy whiteguy lens. I didn't mind that he hooked up Asian characters with white guys. Whatever. It was the way in which it was done, and each time -- Meena and Padma -- were the "bad guys" in the situation.

But back to the Black characters -- or lack thereof. I felt ... weird ... when Bailey arrived and she was basically slotted as a nymphomaniac with no interest in Tai (who I despise, so I was okay with that.) And then there was Gabby, who arrived and then just quit the library internship. Not transferred, not had sick relative, just quit, like those lazy negroes do, amirite?

The kicker for me, though, was when a robot shittalked a Black woman about facing prejudice. Bubbles giving Faye's sister's black girlfriend the "you don't know what I go through with prejudice" talk was fucking racist to the extreme. The messageboards existed in that time. I was livid. And then I was banned.

I clocked right away that Ayo and Yemisi were Nigerian. I have Nigerian in-laws and the names are pretty common (much like Padma for an Indian girl and Anh for someone Vietnamese). I actually thought that the inclusion of a black character who was not cast as a whore, a lazy loser, or being robotsplained to about racism might have been Jeph Jacques actually growing as a person and maybe taking some tips from his buddy David Willis. And don't get me wrong -- DoA has become a dumpsterfire, but Willis, who I think is a couple years older than Jeph Jacques, actually -- has always had three-dimensional characters of color, including Black characters. But, alas, I was wrong about Jeph Jacques growing as a person and being anything other than the weirdo anti-black, Asian-woman fetishist fuckboy that he revealed himself to be a decade ago.

And I have to be honest -- I thought that by this time, this would be discussed, much like how people got over their crush on Martin Freeman when it was discovered that he was a racist dick. It took 10 years, but it happened. Yet, I still see people crashing out on Black folks who have issues with how Jeph Jacques portrays us as if it hasn't been evident for ages what he's about.


r/questionablecontent • • Oct 04 '17

I'm over this cotton candy-ass boy, stuff him into an iPhone and let's move on

5 Upvotes

Title says it all. The super earnest cutesy Good Boy is fine when he's a midget, but as an Actual Person he's kind of grating