r/questionablecontent • u/AppendixN Everything is Fine™ • Nov 11 '22
Comic edit Comic: Steve's Back
7
u/yellowvincent Where is Claire? Nov 11 '22
God thank you.i mean marten would be a hack as a luthier but still it would be something
8
u/AppendixN Everything is Fine™ Nov 11 '22
luthier
I had to look up that word!
You never know, Marten might actually be great at it. He was so close to figuring out what he wanted to do with his life.
We've never seen Marten really put his mind to something, because he's never found something that really gets him into that state of flow that comes from being lost in fulfilling work. Maybe repairing musical instruments could be just the thing that does that for him.
4
u/yellowvincent Where is Claire? Nov 11 '22
I thought it was a more common therm sorry .there was a comedian group here called les luthiers they used to make really weird instruments like an harp made with a toilet seat or like a violin with like a spam can I think they even did something with a bidet
3
u/yellowvincent Where is Claire? Nov 11 '22
I think there was a strip when he was with Dora and I think les Paul or someone had died that he was going to do somerhing experimental with his guitar like sound mixing he could do some sound engeniring thing mayyyyyyyyybe?
3
Nov 11 '22
I consider myself somewhat well read/learned, and even I had to look it up when I got my first guitar. Although I guess English being my third language didn't help.
3
u/yellowvincent Where is Claire? Nov 11 '22
It's probably a therm that comes from the French right? I will look it up
4
12
Nov 11 '22
and this is why Jeph abandoned Steve: he'd do exactly that to Marten because, unlike the others, he has the balls to tell him to his face how stupid it is to toss away your plans and attempts to better yourself because you're a pushover for someone giving you a little tail...
12
u/The_Truthkeeper Nov 11 '22
Completely ignoring the fact that Claire was the one who pushed him to make those plans to do something with his life. He had no intent or desire to do anything more than he was already doing
17
u/AppendixN Everything is Fine™ Nov 11 '22
It really bothers me that Claire got him all wound up like that, pushing him to make something of his life to the point that he took it seriously enough to have to go have a long heart to heart with Steve about the idea, looking like she was really going to support him in his decision and even help him take the steps he needed to take…
And then she just kind of… forgot about it. It never comes up again. She's so wrapped up in her own bullshit that Marten's future just went back in the junk drawer, ignored.
Dora, who's supposed to be Marten's close friend, learns about it, but does she ever tell Marten to "prioritize you're needs" (sic)? No.
What is Dora & Claire's relationship? They don't really have a personal connection, they've never chosen to hang out one on one just as friends. To Dora, Claire is "Marty's girlfriend" or "my employee." Dora's telling Claire to prioritize her needs, but when does she say "Marten, what about your dreams?"
Claire pushing Marten to do something with his life was basically a way to distract herself from her own anxieties. She forgot all about it and put him back in the box marked "emotional support pet."
16
u/The_Truthkeeper Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
Strong points I can't disagree with, though I feel like that's placing too much blame on Claire, the fictional character, rather than Jeph, the writer who teed up an interesting story about Marten finally getting his shit together, only to decide he didn't feel like playing ball.
6
u/AppendixN Everything is Fine™ Nov 12 '22
For sure, it's the writer we're talking about. I'm just talking about the way he writes Claire.
2
Nov 20 '22
Well, if I'm to justify it:
Dora knows Marten for years at this point. The most basic characteristic of Marten that was consistent since issue 3 is "I have no idea what I like or want to do, so I sort of content with making my ends in the end". He has a degree, but let's face it - it's rich white boy's degree of "I want to be a rock star, but don't want to work for it" (which is also sorta weird, as it was established that he has grands of debt, but that was sidelined and sort of retconned with his mother paying for that). The only result of speaking with such a person about his dreams and his needs would be annoyance, because he would look at you with this bovine look of his and talking "oh, haha, you right of course, I'll try to think about something". Let's face it, he would be as good as Cubetown as he would be in any other place. This guy has no dreams to pursue, and everybody he's friend with knows it. Still, Dora did confirmed if he's really ok with it (aside from Claire), at least for, you know, for decency sake.
Claire, though, quite consistently is shown as ambitious. She was attending classes because she wanted to work in the field, she is supposingly talented in her field (we don't exactly know, though, but I feel it was implied that the only reason she wasn't stellar in her exam was anxety). For her, Cubetown is literally lifetime opportunity, and, if successful, it's automatically perfect resume for the whole life. Of course everybody who is even a bit sympathetic to her would push her there.
(and, realistically, if/when Claire would feel herself secure, it should be hard times for Marten - but currently she's very much not)
4
u/Kayback2 Nov 12 '22
It was Marten self sabotaging about being responsible for fucking up a Stradivarius that ultimately stopped him going after the repair gig.
I never really got that.
2
u/AppendixN Everything is Fine™ Nov 13 '22
I never read that strip as Marten actually deciding not to try learning instrument repair, more like him just making a self-deprecating joke as a coping mechanism.
If Claire had actually cared about him enough to really push him to try it out, like found a school for him to attend, made him talk to a few professionals in the field, spent some time envisioning it together, he would have at least given it a go.
Maybe he would have dipped his toe in the water and decided it wasn't what he wanted after all, or maybe he would have gotten some momentum going and found a fulfilling purpose.
But we'll never know, because Jeph decided to have Claire just drop the issue entirely. Marten's value to Claire is all about what he can do for her, not what she can do for him.
2
u/Kayback2 Nov 14 '22
No true. I read it as something they had discussed before but I suppose you can't assume off screen events
1
Nov 20 '22
If Claire had actually cared about him enough to really push him to try it out, like found a school for him to attend, made him talk to a few professionals in the field, spent some time envisioning it together, he would have at least given it a go.
It isn't "push him to try it out", it's "doing the whole gig for him when she's in the ending of her own education and have need for her own workspace". I mean, I really can't shit Claire here.
5
Nov 12 '22
In all honesty "Instrument Repair" sounds more like a side hobby that maybe you get very lucky and there's enough business to turn some paychecks from... periodically.
Unless PastelAIBot#11782 is literally a bull in a Guitar Center, smashing all the things. Then he's rolling in the green.
3
u/Kayback2 Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
Oooh ooh is it my turn to play with the monkey paw?
I don't know if there's still a market for it but I've spent far too much time since COVID watching wood turning and "restoration" videos.
He could have a well paying hobby/side gig as a Youtuber who does videos on the repairs/restorations he does. That would even open him up to getting Stradivarius when he's super famous and rich.
1
Nov 13 '22
That was Marten not wanting to work in instrument repair and coming up with a story to justify it. Actually somewhat normal behavior for people who keep getting careers suggested to them.
2
5
Nov 11 '22
True, but IIRC in the early strips it was precisely Steve who pushed Marten to get started with something instead of the dead end job he was doing (which was what, temping at an accounting firm?). He finally got some traction, 'uograded' to the librarian position, while Steve slowly disappeared, and Marten did the same he's been doing since the beginning of the comic - got comfortable with what he had, with the whole "Haha okay" passivity, and in the at least 3 months that's been since Claire suggested him to look for something more fitting, he did nothing.
The guy is in complete apathy, lacks any drive or initiative, and is perfectly fine with everything. That's basically textbook depression, although he hides it well.
6
u/The_Truthkeeper Nov 12 '22
The entirety of Steve trying to push Marten to do something than his dead-end job (not temp, but a permanent bottom rung "office bitch" in an unspecified industry) was telling him that if he hated his job, he should quit. Steve's girlfriend's roommate was the one who suggested the library job after he lost the office bitch gig because their office was liquidated.
And honestly, there's nothing wrong with Marten being comfortable with where he's at. Even though it shouldn't be possible to make ends meet on his salary (library bitch is a minimum wage gig), he was living within his means without issue even before his hush money raise, able to afford food, his share of rent/utilities, and student loan payments. Most people his age are more than happy if they can pull that off.
Of course, now he's entirely comfortable throwing away his comfortable life to follow Claire, so you absolutely have a point about him being too damn passive.
3
Nov 13 '22
Even though it shouldn't be possible to make ends meet on his salary (library bitch is a minimum wage gig)
Actually, what annoys me most about Marten’s job is that “library bitch” at a college library, like most low-skill jobs on college campuses outside of housekeeping, security and maintenance, is a work-study position for financial aid students, not something they just hand out to random people. Claire should have the library bitch job and hate it because even though it’s working in a library, it’s basically something a chimp could be trained to do.
3
u/The_Truthkeeper Nov 13 '22
At least it was made clear when Marten got his job that they were only hiring non-students because the actual students were too pants-on-head stupid to function.
Of course, that was back when Jeph put actual thought into his writing. Nowadays we get "actual librarians with multiple degrees would KILL for Marten's job!".
4
u/CrypticWhale Where is Claire? Nov 12 '22
Still kind of mad about this strip and the next. Marten extremely doesn't actually to want to go into instrument repair. I don't really blame Claire because I'm also not the most socially aware person, and a few years ago, when I was her age, I certainly wouldn't have noticed either.
As for Marten, I don't think being unambitious is the worst thing, but I do think that being so passive that other people push you to do something that you don't want to do is the worst thing.
Why does Jeph write couples so unsuitable for each other.
4
u/The_Truthkeeper Nov 12 '22
On the other hand, Claire ultimately didn't push him to do shit. Nothing ever came of that storyline.
3
u/Corsaka Where is Claire? Dec 21 '22
wait how did you get the font wtf
2
u/AppendixN Everything is Fine™ Dec 22 '22
It’s not exactly the same, but I do use a comic lettering font from Blambot. He makes the best typefaces for comics.
95
u/nevenoe Nov 11 '22
That's why Steve disappeared. Because he would do that.
82
u/Mother_Village9831 CHUD Nov 11 '22
It's also incidentally why having friends outside a set group is a good idea.
Because sometimes they can show you that the group is actually batshit insane and damaging.
30
u/Drakeskulled_Reaper Keeper of the Eternal Burning Hatred of Tai Nov 11 '22
It's what happened to me a good few years back.
The first friend group I got involved in when I moved back here, they were a weird bunch to say the least, I was introduced to them by a friend I had made in the previous town I lived in.
I was a bit of a passive hanger on myself, years of having my self-confidence crushed just made me go along with things.
Then, I met my ACTUAL friends, unlike the first group, these ones lived near to me, whereas it was a train journey just to see the the first group, so I gradually ended up spending more time with the second group.
Seeing a bunch of friends actually act like friends, and not being all weirdly Friendcestual, and all the drama along with that attitude, made me realise that I never really bonded or felt cared about with the first group.
It came to a head when the friend who had initially introduced me was using my place as a crash/party place, and I got fed up and kicked him out, next time I saw some of the first group, they were... pretty hostile to me.
Long story short, most of them only hung out with me out of friendship to my initial friend, and whilst they never overtly HATED me, they probably wouldn't have given me the time of day if I wasn't friends with my initial friend.
After that, I stopped going there, not out of fear, I just felt done with the place.
11
u/Granfallegiance Nov 11 '22
Good on you for getting out of that situation. Doesn't sound like it was doing anything for you.
9
u/Drakeskulled_Reaper Keeper of the Eternal Burning Hatred of Tai Nov 11 '22
It really wasn't.
If I had the confidence and mindset I do now, I'd have peaced out of that group much earlier than I did.
It took meeting my current friend group, who include me, and as they put it "pulled me out my shell" to make me go "what the fuck is wrong with these people?"
9
Nov 11 '22
weirdly Friendcestual
Fuck, I needed this term about 6 years ago, when I was in a similarly shitty group of "friends". Ended up being the pariah because instead of going with their weird "fuck around and stab each other in the back" flow, I actually stood up and did the right thing. Took me a serious change of scenery and friends to realise just how shitty that group was, and just how much they set my anxiety and depression progress back. Nonetheless it was pretty funny how quickly that group tore itself apart when I decided to leave them for good and dumped a bunch of their shit talking out in public.
After that, I stopped going there, not out of fear, I just felt done with the place.
You got to cut out toxic people from your life, even if it means a bit of loneliness. Their presence might help short term, but it's not worth the long term emotional trauma.
6
u/Drakeskulled_Reaper Keeper of the Eternal Burning Hatred of Tai Nov 12 '22
Yeah, last I heard most of them don't hang out anymore, a few grew the fuck up, the rest are 30-odd idiots nobody hangs out with and still go to clubs and hit on girls nearly half their age.
I'm glad I got out. I'm still not 100% but I'm better than what I was and a large part of that is the friends I do have now, I would never be where I am with the initial group.
7
7
9
Nov 11 '22
and why Jeph is afraid to have a normal person in the cast: they'd upset the idiocy balance by daring to face the truth
3
u/Overkillsamurai Nov 11 '22
Gotta write out the over powered hero so the rest of the character have too deal with the plot in a way that makes sense. Classic marvel movie trope.
32
Nov 11 '22
*smack*
"Haha, okay"
10
Nov 11 '22
sadly it'd be his reaction and then lead to the others calling Steve a bully for confronting Marten
9
Nov 11 '22
Nah, he'd actually be okay with the smack, but then accidentally mention it to Dora/Claire who'd go apeshit crazy, launch a crusade against "the bully", and it would end with Yay solving the situation by incriminating him in something so heinous, a super secret government agency rolls into town and takes him away, all in a matter of hours.
Of course this would happen in about 100 strips, every minute of it dragged out.
3
Nov 13 '22
100 strips just for Yay talking about what they did so we don’t have to actually see it, right?
2
Nov 12 '22
So I've seen the "Haha, okay" meme a few times now, when and where did it originate?
6
Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
#4894, where Marten responds to Fayes heartfelt emotions and literal tears with "Haha, okay." as if all of his dialogue was being written by someone who no longer gave a shit about these characters.
22
14
21
10
7
u/arielleassault Nov 12 '22
I really miss the dynamic between Steve and Marten.
I liked their friendship.
7
Nov 12 '22
I really miss when characters had enough depth that you could empathize with them and hear their voices.
4
4
12
u/LordElend Nov 11 '22
That's a really good edit there. I wish the actual comic would still do this.