r/queensthief • u/Tallywanker428 • Jan 10 '25
So, Gen is bi, right?
As a bi person reading his character, idk, it's just the vibe. But it always feels good to have solid representation, Gen is the bees knees
r/queensthief • u/Tallywanker428 • Jan 10 '25
As a bi person reading his character, idk, it's just the vibe. But it always feels good to have solid representation, Gen is the bees knees
r/queensthief • u/Striking-Cow-1227 • Aug 29 '25
Okay firstly, i just finished king if Attolia. This is the first time reading the series.
And I really liked it, but when Gen's plots started unfolding, I got a bit bored. Especially when he sparred a bunch of the guards and won over and over. And apparently everything in the book was manipulated by him. And worked out perfectly. All the faults he seemed to have like being lazy, or not acting like a proper king... were all an act? So he's just plain ol perfect? Anyone else feel that?
r/queensthief • u/WorldSteak • Jan 08 '22
been thinking about reading this series but the thing thats been stopping is the fact the all the books are stand alone. this gives me the feeling there is no big plot storyline. So what about the books make them so standalone?
r/queensthief • u/[deleted] • Feb 23 '25
I think of Gen sometimes when I read about Zelensky. Lately, his response to being called a dictator. He is clever (and facile with language beyond his own) which any comedian should be. He has risen to lead his people in a way he, by his own admission, never wanted to. He refuses to leave his people, his country. He refuses to give his people away to Goliath (the Medes).
So many "leaders" would be sitting in a foreign refuge while men fought and died for the country they "lead".
This man will never be safe.
And he knows that.
r/queensthief • u/[deleted] • Feb 24 '25
The headline this morning was Zelensky refusing to acknowledge a monetary debt to the US to "repay" previously sent aid, after he refused to give away parts of his country in "peace talks" between Russia and US.
I give you >!The Mede demanding his gold, after being refused a country that was never his:
"The gold (US money and arms) was a gift; you said so yourself." "You are a woman (comedian)," Nahuseresh (Trump) said very gently. "You do not understand the world of kings and emperors, you do not understand the nature of their gifts."
"Nahuseresh, if there is one thing a woman understands, it is the nature of gifts. They are bribes when threats will not avail. Your emperor cannot attack this coast unprovoked; the treaties with the greater nations of this Continent prevent him. All he can do is stir up an ugly three-way war and hope to be invited in as an ally, and I did not invite him."
The queen shook her head. "The problem with bribes, Nahuseresh, is that after your money is gone, threats still do not avail." Nahuseresh stared, seeing a queen he hadn't guessed existed!<
r/queensthief • u/Xp365 • Dec 20 '23
So i decided to make an undertale fight for something related to this series. i haven't finished anything but the first book and just started the 2nd so no spoilers for past 1. any ideas?
r/queensthief • u/d3rk99 • Dec 22 '22
I have been looking for this copy for a long time now as a gift for my wife, who is a long time queen thief reader. She really wants the hard back cover from the Joel Tippie cover edition, but I cant find a hard cover anywhere.
Did they even come out with a hard cover of that book?
I did buy a hardcover copy of The Thief, new, that was advertised as the Joel Tippie cover art, but when It came in the mail, it was the original cover art. :(
If anyone knows anything about this subject, or where I could buy one, please, let me know. <3
r/queensthief • u/Polishment • Feb 18 '22
r/queensthief • u/Xp365 • Dec 05 '23
So I picked up the theif. Saw it was like 320 pages or something and was like oh, this will be a quick read. the book is about 8 hours long (that’s the audio book length at least)
r/queensthief • u/[deleted] • Oct 18 '20
That my favorite books -QT , and favorite show - Arrested Development, both feature a man with a hook that is able to skulk about silently and intricately layered plot points and jokes... what does it mean ?
r/queensthief • u/[deleted] • Oct 06 '20
Well I started reading at 1 a.m. and I am finished 5 hours later.
Thank you MWT.
r/queensthief • u/charmaine54321 • Oct 07 '20
I can't help but believe that mwt may intend to continue to write about this world in some way for her next project. She may not continue to write about the characters that we've been introduced to up to now (therefore, no more Queen's Thief per se) "in the present day" of the books we've been introduced to thus far. But I think it's possible that she may write about say, the politics of the Greater Peninsula, and/or the future of Pheris and/or the future generation of the characters that we know and love.
Why do I believe this?
After finishing ROTT, I felt that there was so much more world-building that mwt did in ROTT than was strictly necessary for a last book in a series. And mwt isn't typically one who fills in words for the sake of having words.
For example, I wondered why mwt introduced a new character narrator (Pheris) who was so fleshed out in multiple aspects, that were not strictly necessary for the plot.
- We learnt so much about Pheris' love for math, even though Pheris' primary purpose in ROTT is as a writer/narrator/historian. That only seemed to pay off as a major plot point once with him being uneasy with Pegistus' calculations (and which Pheris didn't even directly intervene in, albeit that Gen perhaps might have watched Pheris' reaction to figure out that there were weird sums going on, assuming Gen was on to Pheris' math abilities - but that was not even hinted at in the narrative). Plot-wise, there was no real reason the magus had to be involved in teaching Pheris math and so on. Everything math-related to Pheris could have been substituted by an interest in writing or his existing interest in nature. So, how will Pheris' math abilities pay off in future?
- Why did people repeatedly tease Pheris and potentially foreshadow that Pheris would be in love someday? Will Pheris have heirs to pass on his share of Erondites' fortune to? Could Pheris fall in love with the future generation of a character we know of, perhaps?
- Why was Relius having Pheris read the History of Savoro i.e. the "history of a family that's held power on the Greater Peninsula for five hundred years"? Further, after so much "training" by Relius and Telius reminding Pheris to watch who's watching him, I would like to know if Pheris will be the next Relius/Orutus/Costis/Kamet in terms of his service to the state. The training for Costis paid off so much more than we got for Pheris in ROTT!
- There are so many other Pheris-related loose ends that I personally am interested in. Including the Erondites/powerful baron theme: How is Pheris going to administer his lands and that of Sejanus? What will Pheris' relationship with Dite be (assuming Dite returns)? How is the house of Erondites going to support Attolia/Attolis with their power in future, or will all of the house's power return to the Crown? I'm assuming most of the barons in Attolia will be greatly reduced in power post-ROTT given their expenditures (both money and lives, including only heirs) on war, so on a broader note, how will the relationship between the ruler, barons/patronoi and okloi evolve? This is especially interesting considering that mwt chose to feature a mix of royalty, and the more dispossessed in society, as main characters in her books.
mwt also named each of the countries of the Greater Peninsula multiple times in ROTT, and bothered to at least record their reactions to the Mede invasion/pledging to support the Little Peninsula's fight one by one, without that necessarily paying off to full satisfaction by the end of ROTT. She could have just said what the Braelings and Pents thought, and used one sentence to say that the rest of the countries agreed that they would help. Rather than having to name the reactions of ambassadors from Gant, Melenze etc, and also draw out those countries' placement in the Thick as Thieves map.
There was also the introducing of the real political tensions felt by the Greater Peninsula powers against a consolidated Little Peninsula, that were not addressed much by the end of the book. It would be interesting to see how a three-way political fight between the Medes, Greater Peninsula and Little Peninsula could be navigated, in future books.
There are also some loose ends leftover from previous books, for example, who is Gitta Kingsdaughter? As introduced in the map in Thick as Thieves. Kingsdaughter could potentially mean daughter of the Annux/Attolis (Gen). But I'm assuming that "Gitta" is not some form of nickname for Eugenia, which I don't believe it's commonly associated with. Kingsdaughter could also mean daughter of Sounis (Sophos) - whose impending child was not satisfactorily born and named by the end of ROTT so that we could feel the loose end tied. Will Gitta Kingsdaughter be a main character of the next series?
Now it's possible, given the reworking of ROTT with the extended publishing date, that some of these details were originally going to lead to plotlines in ROTT that no longer exist. Or, perhaps mwt just wanted us to believe in the fullness of her world-building more, not that anyone doubts that. But, perhaps these details were placed in these books for a reason...
I also think that given how much thought mwt puts into planning her books and world-building, it might take a lot more time/effort before she felt confident to do justice to and roll out a totally different new "world" setting for future books. And it could be so dissatisfying for her personally, to leave this world after ROTT.
Any thoughts about this? Anyone else having hopes and dreams along these lines?
r/queensthief • u/miskyop • Oct 13 '20
I don’t know what to feel. For one the love confession reveal was so completely jarring I had to put down the book and get a cold glass of water. Attolia and Eugenides are by far the most fleshed out and interesting characters so of course I want more of them! But this romance makes me sick not because I dislike it but cause it’s fucked up and too underdeveloped. They dream of each other yes, but the Gods are playing matchmaker lmao. And can you imagine Gen using most of his free time just to stalk her...for years...because he took an infatuation and projected himself as Prince Charming. Ahhhhhhh I don’t know what to feel. Immediate love is a trope I utterly despise but MWT seems very self-aware. Also the romance is wayyy too relevant to Eugenides’ character.
I’d prefer they start on a platform of mutual disdain and gradually build trust within one another, but given the circumstances political marriage would be impossible and OOC.
Edit: I’m taking a brief break from this series. I’ll hop on King of Attolia next week, maybe. Just realized I ate two books within span 6 days. Off to watch a shitty anime or manga to rest my head.
r/queensthief • u/[deleted] • Jan 26 '23
Was anyone else disappointed with how small a role Kamet and Costis had in Return of the Thief? I definitely was expecting them to play a larger part since they were the main characters in Thick as Thieves. Also, although I’m glad that ROTT had confirmed queer characters, I wish that Kamet and Costis were confirmed as well! There was much more subtext in their relationship than the one between Relius and Teleus, imo.
ETA detail
r/queensthief • u/eddis7501 • Mar 31 '24
Kamet: (internally, after Costis fell down the well) All were alive one day and dead the next, as instantly as the Attolian, and yet this feeling was new, this particular loss, as if some part of me had been hollowed out, leaving me at a standstill and directionless.
Costis: I thought we were Immakuk and Ennikar, but we were just Senabid and his master, weren't we?
Gen: The queen lives and will be well. <- I don't know why because this is inherently a reassuring statement, but Gen's gravity in this moment always kills me.
Irene: It was not her time. We will welcome her when she comes again.
Edit: I've also realized that Kamet refers to Costis multiple times as his ("my Attolian," "my Costis") and I just can't 🫠🥰🤗
r/queensthief • u/urlocalbloodychicken • May 11 '21
r/queensthief • u/orphanedhanyou • May 21 '25
I stumbled across this old post recently & the comments: https://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/comments/ghyiqb/help_me_understand_why_the_queens_thief_series_by/
It talks about the issue of a romantic relationship that occurs in the book. I then looked at some other suggested posts and apparently this isn't an isolated opinion.
I thought it was obvious the love on one characters part had grown for YEARS from afar. Not AFTER a defining event at the beginning of the book. It was only reciprocated & HEALED (which I think MWT makes clear is a long term on-going process throughout the series) later in the book & series.
The character didn't FALL in love with the person that hurt them. They were ALREADY in love and that was why the hurt was 1000x worse. To me the struggle was: Can I go on loving them after this? Is deciding to trust again a conscious choice you have to make every morning? Not some magic moment where everything is 'better'?
While not explicit I thought MWT still laid this journey out pretty clearly.
Anyway just wanted to add my two cents to what appears to be a controversial part of the series that turns people away (which feels like they personally needed way more handholding in a series where keeping the reader in the dark is kinda the point & best part).
r/queensthief • u/ThirteenSisters • Feb 12 '20
My apologies for the late chapter. I realized at some point this week that I’m going to be doing this until AUGUST and it suddenly seemed too daunting to even work on. So I didn't get started until Monday, and then I was busy. But if I just keep trucking on and take one week at a time we’ll get there in the end!
“What will you do now?”
“Oh”-- he tried unsuccessfully to keep the tremor out of his voice--”grovel, I suppose.”
“I’ve heard you do that before,” said Attolia, briefly amused in spite of herself.
Eugenides swallowed. “That was begging,” he said with a better effort at lightness. “There wasn’t much opportunity for groveling last...time.” He stumbled, then added evenly, “I am very good at groveling.”
(How is this so funny and so heart-rending at the same time???)
Attolia and Gen climb up the cliff together. Attolia stops and wonders about the cannons -- if her barons didn’t betray her, how DID the Eddisians get the cannons into place? Gen reveals that they were wood, and she calls him bastard, and he smiles again -- the same swift, satisfied smile she’s seen before.
She sets a furious pace for their climb. Gen, trying to get her to slow down, tells her that he thought she’d like the earrings. She snaps at him that she’ll wear the earrings when she is actually willing to marry a stupid goatfoot (the Attolian ephitet for Eddisians), but not to wait for it. (Everybody highlighted that line, for obvious reasons.)
Later in the climb, he steals her knives again just so he can bleat like a goat at her and not get stabbed. Oh, Gen.
At the top of the cliff, Eddis’s ministers are waiting for her. A minister introduces them all as though they were at a court function and not kidnapping her at cliffside, though he stumbles briefly when omitting the introduction of the minister of war, who is there, but somewhat incognito.
The party rides to Pricas spring, where they camp. Before Attolia goes to sleep that night, she asks to see Gen again. When the soldier assigned to guard her hesitates, she just marches off to see him herself, finding him with the physician, who is removing his hook. She is taken aback by how he shudders and slumps with pain -- she had just thought to herself while they were sailing that he was too young to have bones that ached -- and asks him about the battle with Piloxides before returning to her tent.
That night she is awakened by Gen coming into her tent. She thinks he’s coming to kill her and sits up, refusing to cower. He tells her “what luck you have” and kisses her quickly before leaving -- the camp is being attacked by a contingent of Medes. They charge greater numbers and are better equipped, though the Eddisians fight skillfully. They crack the phalanx (which essentially requires your front line of highly trained soldiers to sacrifice themselves -- what a cost!) and Gen and his dad fight in tandem, working a hole deep into the enemy’s lines. Ultimately they are just outnumbered and surrender when the option is given to them.
Nahuseresh greets Attolia, hoping she will excuse that he landed troops in her country in his haste to rescue her. “What alternative do I have?” she asks, like, really looking for alternatives. Sadly, she doesn’t at the moment. Attolia tells Nahuseresh to chain Gen to two officers, informing him that they are surety for his good behavior -- they will be sent back to Eddis after he is safely in her custody in Attolia. She tells him “where there’s life there’s hope” but he doesn’t believe her. He is afraid, and more than being afraid of dying, and of torture, he is afraid that she will be the one to take his sight, his hearing, because she hates him. He needles her about Nahuseresh, and going from shadow queen to shadow puppet, and she hits him. Nahuseresh is approaching, and so she strikes Gen again, hard, to keep his mouth shut and prevent him from “making a bad situation worse.”
Too much going on this chapter to risk titling it after any one event. I’d just call it “Pricas Spring” and leave it at that.
“When he thought I was safely distant from any rescue, her Thief proposed life or death to me and let me choose my fate. I am in my own megaron and have an answer to the Thief’s proposal. Do you know what my answer is?”
“Yes,” the prisoner said.
“Yes,” the queen repeated after him, enunciating the word clearly. “You may tell the queen of Eddis.”
Gen marches, and prays to his God that if he cannot be saved, to at least make him less afraid. The soldiers marching with him offer to jump off the cliff with him, and save him from Attolia’s torture, but he refuses.
While they travel, Nahuseresh tells Attolia how he was informed of Gen’s goal by “a most remarkable woman,” who we of course recognize as Moira. Attolia presses, wondering what he meant by “his goal,” but Nahuseresh has no idea about the proposal -- he was just referring to her location. Clearly by this point Attolia is formulating her plan against Nahuseresh, and needs him kept in the dark about what Gen’s actual goal was. Fortunately, he is an idiot, and completely buys his own fiction that Attolia is lovingly grateful to him for the rescue.
As they make their way to the megaron, Attolia sees three of her barons hanging, dead, above the gate. Two of them were actually loyal to her, but Nahuseresh blithely claims they were traitors and claims “I knew you would not disapprove.” She keeps her disapproval to herself, claiming that she needs a bath to recover from her ordeal, and afterwards she will decide what to do with the prisoners.
Her loyal attendants have concealed Teleus and other loyal members of her guard in her chambers, so she can meet with them before her bath. She informs them that they are not to allow Gen to die. And Teleus tells her that all the royal messengers have mysteriously gone missing or been poisoned. Then she bathes, and when her attendants push a new pair of earrings into her ears, she stops them. Not those earrings!
She returns to the main hall of the megaron, where the Eddisian prisoners have been gathered. She is informed that a soldier (whom we recognize as the minister of war) was trying to sneakily strangle him, but that Teleus noticed and kicked him in the head to stop him before moving him away from his son. She finds Gen and makes him look at her, asking him if he knows what is going to happen to him. He hazily nods.
Attolia announces she needs a message sent to Eddis, and will choose one of the soldiers to deliver it to her. She selects the Minister of War, and tells him that she will not return Eddis’s thief a second time; that Eddis does not understand her attachment to the Medes; that Eddis could save Gen some suffering if she sends a message back with him no later than the 7th hour of the next day. And then she does not even bother to hide her delighted smile, because she IS delighted. And then pleading that she needs rest after her ordeals, she returns to her room, sending and receiving messages through her attendants to plan her army’s engagement the next day.
“A Most Remarkable Woman” would neatly cover Moira and Attolia in this chapter.
“I have said before that the king of Attolia will be my choice, no one else’s.”
“Then you have only to choose me, and we will both be made happy, will we not? And your barons as well. While you were ‘distracted,’ they seemed very agreeable to my rule.”
“They are mice, Nahuseresh, hiding in their mouse-holes, hoping that their own familiar cat will come home to drive you away. At least when I hang people from castle walls, it is because they are traitors, not because they drive hard bargains. You seem willing to hang anyone that displeases you. Hoe kind of you to show my barons that if I am a hard ruler to cross, you are a worse one to serve. I must thank you for that as well as for your emperor’s gold. They will be most mousy and well behaved for months.”
(It was really hard not just to excerpt the entire conversation. SO MANY OWNS.)
Eddis, receiving the message from the minister of war, weighs her decision of what to do next. He gets to the crux of the matter -- either they drive the Medes off these shores now or never, and she decides she must commit her troops, despite her uncertainty.
Attolia waits for dawn, admitting to herself that she has always envied Eddis, who can fight with her troops if she wants to and be there to manage the battle in person. But, at any rate, Eddis won’t have her thief back.
Nahuseresh basically invites himself into Attolia’s room in order to offer to escort her to watch the battle. He claims that Eddis is moving her army to “rescue her lover,” but Attolia disagrees, lacing her disagreement with flattery for Nahuseresh. He suspects nothing. Teleus accompanies them to a location where they can watch and then goes to find a pavilion for her -- and there’s a nice little parallel with some chapters ago, when Eddis met with the Magus in a clearing and her guard insisted on watching and having a good shot. But Eddis trusted the Magus, who had nothing to fear from the guard but was nevertheless aware of him. Nahuseresh is unaware of what Teleus is doing, and ought to be afraid.
They watch the armies line up for battle, and Attolia can see her armies spread in a thin line in front of the Medes army, convenient for them to take the heaviest losses. She reveals to Nahuseresh that the messenger she sent to Eddis was Eddis’s minister of war, and that she knows all about Nahuseresh’s attempts to undermine her throne. It is delicious and brutal as she opens his eyes to how she has been aware of all his schemes, and how smart and wily she actually is. It’s just epic takedown after takedown. He claims his schemes were merely diplomacy, in his emperor’s name. He sputters about how the gold he gave her must be repaid, but she replies that it was a gift -- and gifts are bribes when threats do not avail, but when your gold is gone threats still do not avail. She will not be returning the money. (Did you even get a receipt, bro? No, you did not.) And the next king of Attolia will be her choice, and no one else’s.
Nahuseresh tries to claim that the Medes are still her only defense against Eddis, but she turns his attention to the field, where her army is parting to allow the Eddisians to better attack the Medes. When he claims treachery, she replies that it’s merely diplomacy -- in her own name. And when he rises in anger she draws his attention to Teleus, who is aiming a crossbow at him. He wonders how she will secure her treaty with Eddis, and then realizes before she tells him that she will marry Gen.
I think it must be good for Gen to be on the other side of a risky plan for once. Here in these chapters Attolia commits her own heist worthy of a capital-T Thief -- she steals her sovereignty and Gen back out from under Nahuseresh’s nose. It’s a beautiful thing to see. (And lucky that Gen’s dad decided to hang out incognito -- it would have been much harder without him!)
So here’s my question: When does she change her mind? She’s not willing to marry him on the cliff, but by the time she returns to Ephrata she is. My hunch is that she decides during the skirmish the Attolians fight with the Medes, because it’s then that she has to make the choice -- which side does she want to win?
The choice is the important thing here for Attolia, as it’s mentioned several times that she insists that she will choose the next king of Attolia. “Marry Gen or die” isn’t much of a choice, and neither is “marry Nahuseresh because he’s arranged for your army to be destroyed so you’re dependent on him.” But when the armies meet she has the opportunity to choose between the choices, if that makes sense. And she chooses Gen, because she loooooooves him.
Okay, well, it’s not that easy. I don’t think she actually loves him yet. But she feels for him, she could find a way to admire him, and she would have her sovereignty. And he doesn’t use cheap hair oil and sharpen his beard into points.
I know there’s a million more things to talk about in these chapters, but I’m late enough as it is. Still planning on Monday for the next three, to finish out the book! Whew.
r/queensthief • u/Medical_Comfort7031 • Jun 19 '25
I was doing a lot of rereading around the time when this song was released.
Dancing in the movies, except they’re dancing on the roof!
Now whenever this song comes on, it will always remind me of my favourite fantasy couple.
r/queensthief • u/Xp365 • Jun 17 '25
r/queensthief • u/ThirteenSisters • Feb 04 '20
So I continue to be worried that people don't see these posts when I have the spoiler tag on. So what I'm going to do is just natter on about something unrelated for the first paragraph, hoping that any spoilers will be hidden behind the break.
This is a little late because one of my kids is turning 7 tomorrow and I needed to do some birthday prep during my usual writing time. And after I hit publish on this, it's on to cake-baking!
And now, the post.
“This is the stupidest plan that I have ever in my career participated in,” he said.
“I love stupid plans,” said Eugenides. “How long will it take to get across the dystopia?”
“Twice as long as it would take without those worthless cannon of yours.”
Eugenides laughed.
(I picture a distracted-boyfriend meme where Gen is the guy, sensible plans is the girl in blue, and stupid, risky plans is the girl in red. You know what I'm talking about, right? Anyway.)
The royal engineer (our hero!) watches the Hamiathes reservoir until he can report to the queen that it’s safe to close the gates on the Aracthus. Eddis’s army prepares to march; Attolia prepares to defend against the army she sees massing at the border.
A company of soldiers led by Xenophon (who is in charge; who asked NOT to be in charge of Eugenides; who was overruled) make their way down the river, which has been reduced to a trickle by the closing of the reservoir gates. They climb out of the riverbed and sleep during the day, and then climb back down and march at night. Where the river passes through sheer cliffs they cannot climb, they lodge wooden beams into holes carved into the stone, and string nets between them. Sixteen men are lost when some of the beams are destroyed by three of their cannons coming loose in the flood.
The remainder of the force makes it into Attolia and changes into Attolian uniforms. They load twelves cannon onto one riverboat (the third clue we get in this chapter that these are not iron cannon) and make their way to Ephrata.
Calling this chapter “Worthless Cannon” would be too spoilery, so I’d just call it “Into Attolia” or “Down the Aracthus”.
The Mede ambassador preferred beauty to age. He didn’t say so, but the queen knew it. Perhaps because she was Attolia and it was her megaron, she preferred it to the splendors of the Mede palaces with the glazed tile walls and the gold-topped pillars.
Attolia, in the megaron at Ephrata, makes preparations for war with Eddis’s army -- until she is interrupted by the arrival of Nahuseresh. Some soldiers arrive with a message (to Nahuseresh’s surprise -- he believed he had closed off all the roads to Ephrata and accounted for all messengers) which Attolia reads and then swears. The messages indicates that Baron Efkis has betrayed them, and allowed an army of Eddisians to come land in Ephrata, with cannon.
Quickly realizing that they cannot hold out in the poorly fortified megaron there, Attolia makes plans to surrender the megaron and flee to the Mede and figure it out from there. She tells Teleus to make the arrangements, writes several letters, and then makes her way down to a cave under the megaron that opens to the harbor. There is one boat and a soldier waiting for her. She walks down the dock with him and, lo, the soldier is actually Eugenides.
Teleus arranges the surrender to the Eddisians, and requests to take in the body of the messenger who died on the road. The soldiers who delivered the message go to get him -- and it turns out they are Eddisians and the messenger wasn’t dead and they all run away.
Chapter title “Betrayal” or “The Royal Messenger”
“You’ve brought me to a place rather spare of witnesses if you want me to declare you my heir before I die.”
“I wasn’t proposing to become your heir,” said the Thief.
“Then what?” asked Attolia.
“There’s an easier way for a man to become king,” said Eugenides, and waited for her to realize what he proposed.
Attolia stared at him. “You think I would marry you?” she asked in disbelief.
“If you object to marrying a man with one hand, you’ve only yourself to blame.”
“And when did you grow into a man?” asked Attolia, lifting her eyebrow, her voice tinged with sarcasm.
Attolia is convinced that Eugenides will kill her, but he orders her into the boat and suggests that where there’s life, there’s hope. Soldiers come running, but they’re both in the boat and sailing away before the soldiers arrive. There’s a line here where she looks at him and thinks he’s not going to smile at her again, not even to gloat, that I’m going to come back to later.
Nahuseresh wonders what all the hubbub is about, and Teleus can’t think of a good enough reason not to tell him. (I guess “you’re an oily, untrustworthy jerk” wouldn’t save Teleus’s head if the Mede ended up winning the day). Nahuseresh, in his oily, untrustworthy way, excuses himself to his rooms where he almost certainly goes to write a lot of letters and send a lot of messages to plan the landing of his troops on Attolian soil.
Hours later, Eugenides moves the boat into a tiny harbor surrounded by high cliffs. He tells her she has a choice -- to go into the water, conscious or unconscious, and drown, or make him king of Attolia. She doesn’t understand at first, but eventually realizes it’s a marriage proposal and reacts with derision. (Also, marry me or die -- not very romantic, is it?) She wonders what would happen to Eddis if she chose to die, since Eddis is so dependent on trade and the inevitable conquest of the Mede would put a damper on that. Gen reveals that Eddis has the pirates and they’ve been using that very cove to haul goods up the mountain, and that will keep them from starving.
Hedging further, Attolia wonders about the implications of marriage. Would she still be queen? Would there be tribute? Would Attolia (the country) be bled dry by an uncaring king? Gen answers that she would still be queen and rule with Eddisian advisors, and that there would be peace with Eddis but no tribute.
Attolia reveals that she listened to Gen in his cell after she captured him. The first night he cried; the second night he prayed the invocation of Hephestia, calling her aid to those in need. And then she does agree to marry him (though she warns him never to drink from her wine cup). Then he tells her to paddle them to shore, which she does. Once they are on the dock, she reaches for her knife but it is gone. All three of her knives are gone. Eugenides juggles them one-handed and then hands them back, telling her that she could stab him or push him into the water, but that before she does that she should know that he loves her. He tells the history of her love -- how he watched her as a child -- and she does not believe him. But she chooses not to stab or drown him, because she also believes that his friends are waiting for him at the top of the cliffs, and she has no way out. So they start climbing.
I would love to call this chapter “The Proposal” but that’s also a bit too much of a spoiler. So instead we’ll just call it “Offer me something” or maybe “A Choice”.
So -- perhaps controversial opinion here -- I don’t think the “twist” of the wooden cannons is necessary. It detracts from the more essential reveal that Gen is going to marry Attolia instead of kill her. One little line of saying that the kingdoms woodcarvers made 12 wooden cannons and then you could snicker along with Gen about the cannons on the riverboat and about the Eddisians pretending that it’s so hard to winch the cannons uphill, instead of being mildly surprised when Gen reveals they’re wood (or proud of yourself for figuring it out, if you paid better attention than I did on my first read through.)
So, the real twist -- Gen’s love for Attolia! It’s certainly unexpected, to say the least. One does not normally fall in love with their torturers, with somebody you’ve previously described as a “fiend from hell”. (I’d say in a game of “Marry, F, Kill,” we always knew Attolia could definitely be the kill and could possibly be the F, but the marry is a surprise!) But I think the reader has had a little chance to fall in love with her… her toughness, her tenacity, her sly humor… and so we can believe it. Or at least we can entertain the possibility. But Attolia can’t entertain the possibility, not yet. It’s just too far a leap.
Also, what a terrible proposal. She has the right to hold that over his head for the rest of his life. I mean, she cut off his hand and made war against his country and therefore deserved it … and it was still very much a possibility that she’d go into the water and Gen would be tortured over that forever … but still. Attolia was never expecting any romance, at least. She always knew her marriage would be a political one.
Going back to the line where Attolia doesn’t think Gen’s going to smile again, it’s interesting to see how soon that happens. Look for it in the next set of chapters. It’s also good to notice when he next grins -- remember how Eddis lamented how she missed Gen’s smiles, which were rare, and especially his grins, which were nonexistent? We will see one again, though not for a little while still.
I remember on my first read being a little confused at this point that this is still very much the middle of the book. It FEELS like the beginning of the end, especially remembering how little denouement there was in The Thief. But there’s a lot more left! And we’ll tackle the next 3 chapters next Monday!
ETA the link to Chapters 16-18:
r/queensthief • u/MyNewPhilosophy • Feb 07 '24
I almost missed this… posting in case anyone else is interested
https://www.instagram.com/p/C2SM9MfNJPG/?igsh=MXRhZjFvdTQ2NnZ0ZA==