r/quant • Crypto • 5d ago

Resources Quant map

Post image

Edit: Why I am being downvoted? I just want to be resourceful

185 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

116

u/milchi03 5d ago

„Please generate a map for quant firms mapping our capacity vs holding periods and mark common strategies”

16

u/Remarkable_Log4812 4d ago

Please KINDLY generate a COLORFUL map…

2

u/pdd99 3d ago

*make no mistake

-8

u/Odd-Repair-9330 Crypto 4d ago

Lmao you expect me to draw this in Ms Paint?

4

u/rsha256 4d ago

This is directionally right but you over specified -- if you removed the tick labels on each axis, no one would have issues, but most HFT firms are in the pico/nano range with specialized hardware (FPGA/ASICs) and have lower capacity and stat arb is generally longer hp and higher pot cap

All in all, this is very inaccurate as it stands. That's the issue. Not what you drew it in

48

u/VincentAXM 5d ago

yeah yeah yeah, I wish my stas arb can have that capacity 🤣

-11

u/Odd-Repair-9330 Crypto 5d ago

that capacity axis is “hypothetical” 😂😂

7

u/Defiant-Flamingo2198 5d ago

Is BW really considered trend following? Kinda dubious about MLP and P72 as event driven. They are pod no? GSA same category with Capula?
No idea where this classification is based lol

1

u/matta-leao 2d ago

They have some trend in there most likely

-4

u/Odd-Repair-9330 Crypto 5d ago

BW is risk parity macro quantamental fund lol, not sure fits which bucket but they behave a lot like CTA. Vol premium is probably should be SIG. MLP and P72 have quant pods that don’t neatly sit in statarb category

68

u/Commercial_Insect764 5d ago

Because it is wrong and you include no source

50

u/SprayDiligent9603 5d ago

Lol yes the microsecond holding period lol

10

u/milchi03 5d ago

There is even a minor 100M cap strategy available in ns holding period Hahahah

-8

u/waveforminvest 5d ago

Yeah I remember an interview with someone at Jane Street talking about how a strategy they employed had nanosecond time range, so fast that the hardware cannot even use CPUs.

9

u/milchi03 5d ago

Ofc but that’s not holding period

20

u/OkQuantAtBest 4d ago

What the slop is this.

9

u/Aetius454 HFT 5d ago

I'm quite skeptical of the trillion dollar upper bound capacity you've marked there

6

u/powerexcess 5d ago

The names of funds there are arbitrary

You think aspect does not do trend? Mlp does not do xsectional momentum? 

Almost all these guys do trend in some form. Not the hfts maybe, but the others do it. All the ctas do trend, all the pod shops do trend to some extend, and they both do carry

The y axis is also like finger in the air and looks optimisitc to me

So i would say you are getting downvoted because this is inaccurate. 

  • Take the names out. Replace them with things like CTA MultiManager, HFT, MM, Prop.

  • remove the units from the y axis.

What a super odd choice.. Aspect. Some rando old school cta from london, as the paragon of carry? What?

3

u/Technical_Evening404 5d ago

What makes you think the typical holding period for MM is microseconds to seconds lol?

2

u/Crazy-Accident6808 5d ago

Market making can extend to minutes and hours, sometimes even overnight or after hours

2

u/VIXMasterMike 4d ago

Relative Placement of bubbles reasonable…numbers maybe no

3

u/EmperorOfCanada 5d ago edited 5d ago

I think that the capacity is arguable, but otherwise this is not wildly wrong.

So many people talk about C++ and HFT and seem to ignore that there are a whole host of other strategies for which they need quants of various sorts.

I personally worked on three somewhat separate ones:

  • Watching for triggering events. This was usually an analysis which ran all night, with simpler algos running during the day. The trades didn't need to be all that fast. Faster was better, but a 5 minute delay wasn't the end of the world.

  • Giving tools to help human traders make decisions. They could screw with literal sliders until they had peed in it enough to really like the flavour. As a nearly perfect example would have been the recent nvidia trade. A human would have evaluated how structural that was vs some weird market twitch. That would have been one of the sliders. Maybe in 2026, an AI would have "evaluated" if guy who drives the company forward being potentially removed is long term bad, or long term good.

  • Where does a market run out of something. This was usually logistics. If there is a port strike, land bridges can help, but both take time, and can hit limits. During some huge event such as the olympics, they often run out of concrete capacity during construction. Not enough people with the skill, not enough quarry capacity, not enough cement trucks. There is usually one play at the start, and another, when there is now massive regional overcapacity. This makes logical sense, but you also can calculate it; and these calculations are far harder than you would think, as the fundamental: "Where there's a will, there's a way." kicks in and finds spare capacity where none measurably existed.

Of course, this, like all stock market predictions is tricky, in that I would have thought that Apple's days were over when Jobs left.

9

u/khyth 5d ago

Disagree - this is wildly wrong. The capacity is wildly wrong and the holding periods of the strategies are wrong.

1

u/EmperorOfCanada 4d ago

I was more commenting that quant≠HFT; which is not the takeaway most new people would get from /r/quant

Yes, the capacities are pretty wildly wrong. Holding periods are going to be pretty gray on a good day with a few exceptions where they are pretty much the definition of the strategy.

It is more the further you go right on that graph, the further you get away from HFT. That part was refreshing.

1

u/khyth 4d ago

Well I would take issue with stat arb not including multi day hold as that's the primary PNP strategy that's employed at rentech/shaw/etc.

2

u/Feeling_Map4794 5d ago

good job bro

1

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

This post has the "Resources" flair. Please note that if your post is looking for Career Advice you will be permanently banned for using the wrong flair, as you wouldn't be the first and we're cracking down on it. Delete your post immediately in such a case to avoid the ban.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/ForeverFar1297 5d ago

How do you define holding period for futures trading, as you have to roll your contract every month?

2

u/powerexcess 4d ago

You look at the continuous contract. The artificial instrument you create based in a rolling rule.

But this post in nonsense regardless.

1

u/Old-Sandwich-690 4d ago

The numbers are off. But the ranking of strategies by capacity is accurate

1

u/MysteriousSound125 3d ago

I would not consider Millenium as a quant fund. Their strategy is more like multi stratf so multiple pods doing different things and isolated from each other.