I'm making this post not so much to vent or anything, it's mostly because I have these thoughts on the game, and I wanted to bounce them off of someone.
I played the witness last year, almost 10 years after it's release. Just from there, you could say I'm judging the game too harshly, because I'm looking at it from modern standards, but even then portal is older than that, and outer wilds is not that much more recent... Wildly different games from the Witness, but they have one thing the witness lacks: they don't overstay their welcome.
Honestly, the puzzles are fine, but there are TOO MANY OF THEM. They are not interesting enough that I want to repeat two dozen iterations of each puzzle, slightly more complex each time. The treetop bridges section, for example, felt like playing a cell phone game, just puzzles back to back to back with no end! My eyes were hurting by the end of it. The puzzles would be good if there were just a third of the amount, IMO.
I couldn't stand looking at those grids after a while, but I kept playing because everyone talks about this amazing twist the game has to offer.
What a disappointment of a twist. You get to the top of the mountain, and they present you with the big environmental puzzle as if it were the most groundbreaking thing ever -- I had already been doing them all over the map since the first areas, but they just felt pointless. It's basically pixel hunting the over world, and again - they are so many! I get that it's satisfying to be a completionist, but this felt more like hunting for koroks in Zelda, kind of pointless going for all of them. If there were like 3 per area, it wouldn't feel so overwhelming. Some of them are just a single line, it's lame ASF. They should have just kept the big, cooler ones and ditched the rest
What's even worse is the atmosphere of mystery is just so good, it made me play the whole thing in almost one sitting, wanting to see what it would amount to. If I had played it over one month, maybe it wouldn't feel so repetitive and draining. In the end there was no mystery or anything anyways, it's just for the vibes
And that's not to say anything for the whole pretentious thing the game has going. But that doesn't really retract from the gameplay experience, is more of a matter of taste.
So, any other haters out there? Alternatively, anyone want to tell me how I missed the point of the game, and I'm wrong? Let me hear your thoughts