r/publishing • • Jul 07 '26

Hachette has won their union election!

Post image
697 Upvotes

The vote was 388-130, making it a near 75% supermajority. Congrats Hachette for becoming the biggest union in publishing 🎉


r/publishing • • Oct 09 '26

Book Publishers Are Quietly Using More AI. Staff Are Revolting

Thumbnail
wired.com
541 Upvotes

i hate this!!!!!


r/publishing • • Oct 15 '26

Why We’re Banning AI

Thumbnail
currentaffairs.org
475 Upvotes

r/publishing • • Jan 26 '25

I'm a writer. I suspect my editor has added ChatGPT-generated prose to the book I have in process. How do I bring this up?

438 Upvotes

(update in comments, tl;dr: they did)

This is a throwaway account obviously.

I have a nonfiction book in process with a major publisher right now, and I got the edits back on my first draft earlier this month. The book is running late and the draft was under its target word count -- which is my fault -- so my editor had written some additional content for various sections, leaving notes in the manuscript to make sure the new writing was factual and reflected my tone of voice.

I know this is standard for editors to do, I've done it plenty of times myself. However, reading through the new copy, I began to get suspicious. The writing was very repetitive -- I ended up cutting a lot of it, which I realize is not helping the word count issue but it just kept saying the same thing over and over again -- over-explained things, and was just generally full of received phrasing and cliches. By itself this doesn't indicate anything -- obviously lots of writing is like that -- but the new copy also contained several blatant factual errors, the kind of thing where if you Googled the information you would instantly notice that it was wrong. Not quite at the level of "there are 27 letters in the alphabet," but definitely at the level of "here is a list of the presidents ... Benjamin Franklin" and then describing Benjamin Franklin's inauguration. It's hard to explain but I used to be a fact-checker and have fixed a lot of human factual errors, but these seemed different.

The combination of cliched writing and hallucination-like errors, combined with the instructions to fact-check, gave me a gut feeling, so I threw some passages into ZeroGPT -- "100% AI GPT." Well fuck.

Needless to say I do not want AI slop published under my name. But I don't have any actual proof -- AI detection tools do produce false positives. And more importantly I have absolutely no idea how to bring this up, especially because I am not the person in a position of authority here, and the situation is partly my fault. If it were an editor I had a pre-existing relationship with I could ask up-front "hey, is this ChatGPT," but this is my first time working with this person.

Any advice would be great.


r/publishing • • Nov 04 '25

The Harrowing True Story of a Six-Figure Advance

370 Upvotes

I posted this piece on my blog some years ago. It's all true. Thought some of you might enjoy it.

This is the story of getting my novel published by a major New York publisher. 

It is a story of triumph over adversity.  Followed by defeat at the hands of adversity.   Let’s call it an even split with adversity.      

I will skip quickly through the early rejection letters.  Suffice it to say that, in no time at all, I had accumulated a stack that covered the entire spectrum of conceivable reasons for turning down a manuscript – up to and including that my writing was, somehow, “too sophisticated.”

What does one say to that?  “How dare you!  My writing is not even slightly sophisticated!” Interestingly, another agent referred to the very same work as “too slapstick”.  It would have been interesting to get these agents together for a panel discussion on what was wrong with my manuscript.

For years I worked and reworked a serious novel under the guidance of an agent who expressed an interest in representing it. The novel metamorphosed into a variety of forms: One narrator.  Two narrators.  Six narrators and a chronicler.  Yet with each draft, so my agent told me, there was something undefinable that was not quite right.  Perhaps the issue was not the narration after all.  Perhaps it was the story itself.  Or the protagonist.  Or the font.

I eventually dropped this particular magnum opus and dashed off a little post-modern sex comedy set entirely on the internet.  In a matter of a few months, I had completed it and sent it off.  I soon got a call back from an up-and-coming name in literary representation.  We’ll call him Agent Orange. 

Agent Orange was unlike anyone I had dealt with before:  suave, brimming with confidence, assured in his opinions.  When he declared that a book was, “brilliant”, it seemed he was making a statement not just about the work, but about his own expertise, his authority in conferring the label of brilliance.

“I want to represent this,” he told me.  “I will definitely get you a good deal for it. I’ll call you in a few weeks.”  At first I was unsure whether to really believe him.  Was this just hubris?  A sleazy sales story?  Three weeks later he called again.  “I’m handing your book out today.  I’m telling everyone they have to read it over the weekend.  I’ll be back to you by next Monday to review the offers.”

The anticipation in the following days was almost unbearable.  The following Monday he called again as promised.  His voice was full of excitement.  What was more incredible was what he had to say, which was something out of dream:  He’d generated a bidding war for my novel.  In the end, a publisher we’ll call Entropy House had come up with the best offer, which was well into six figures, and easily one of the largest advances paid to an unpublished novelist that year.  “Get ready for it!” Agent Orange said.  “ You’re going to be famous.”

The next morning I awoke in a sort of euphoric haze.  I made coffee, asked my wife what we should do to celebrate.

“Well,” she said, “the trash definitely needs to get to the dump.”

What the heck?!  Didn’t celebrated writers such as myself have stunt-husbands to do that sort of thing? It would be the first but definitely not the last come-down I would experience in the coming months.

My editor at Entropy House was a hugely enthusiastic advocate for the book, and wanted only a few, small editorial changes.  I remember two in particular.  One was, “Make it even funnier!”  – as though one can simply do this.  I stared despairingly at my pages, wondering how I could squeeze one more droplet of humor out of this or that section.  The other comment I remember was a note across some sex scene that read, “Could a toe really be that dexterous?”  This precipitated a painfully awkward conversation where I explained to my editor that I believed that a toe could be that dexterous, and she expressed the view that it could not, and we bravely discussed angles, positions, anatomical variations.  I remember thinking how I had theoretically reached the pinnacle of the literary world, Entropy House, home of a bevy of Nobel laureates, and this is our erudite discussion!

Alas, it all started to unravel rather quickly.  My book was immediately caught up in politics at Entropy House.  While my editor loved it, her boss evidently disliked it to an almost equal degree, and wondered why my editor had spent so much to acquire it.  The publication date got pushed out.  The printing, the publicity, weren’t going to be that large after all.

Meanwhile, Agent Orange gradually grew more and more remote.  Just when he should have been working to promote the book, or shaking things up at Entropy, or withdrawing it altogether and taking it to another publisher, he flat out disappeared.  Nobody seemed to know what had happened to him.  And then Entropy pushed the publication date back again. And then a third time.

The book came out almost two years after it was first accepted.  As near as I can tell, it was deep-sixed – dumped onto the market by this most prestigious of publishers with zero publicity, zero marketing and zero sales effort.  It was scarcely mentioned to bookstores in Entropy’s list of releases.   My publisher might as well have put a black star on the cover inscribed with the words, “Not an Oprah Choice.”

Why would they do this?  I cannot really be sure.  Perhaps once my editor’s boss had expressed her opposition to the book, she basically wanted it to fail.  Failure vindicated her opinion. Success would have proven her mistaken.  But who knows? 

In any case, the book quickly vanished into obscurity - a little pebble that landed in a pond, made a few ripples, and disappeared into the inky depths.  And I seemed to follow right behind.  The beacon of fame swept right over me, illuminated me for a few delirious seconds, and then moved on – to settle, eventually, on who knows who.  Justin Bieber.  Bristol Palin.  After spending through my advance, I eventually went back into software, making less money than I had before I’d left.   

But there is an interesting coda to this story.  A couple of years later, I was sharing my tale of woe with my new agent, Agent X.  “I’ve heard a lot of horror stories about the publishing industry,” he told me, “but I think yours is the very worst.”

There was something oddly comforting in hearing this.  At least I was noteworthy in some way. “I never heard another word from that agent,” I said. 

“Did you not hear what happened to him?” X asked. 

“No,” I said. “What happened?”

“You know he disappeared from the publishing world completely, right?”

“I didn’t know that. I thought it was just me.”

“Everyone was talking about it.  Nobody knew what had happened to him.  Even if he was still alive.  It turned out, he was off on some huge cocaine bender.”

“That’s horrible!” I said.

“Not as bad as you’d think,” X explained.  “He just resurfaced.  With a memoir about his experience.  Which he just sold for hundreds of thousands of dollars!”

And soon enough, there I am back at my anonymous cubicle in some office tower, and my eye is drawn to a front-page story in The New York Times about Agent Orange and his memoir.  I did not read his book, but I was fascinated – if that is the word – to read in the Times that it included passages where he described how he had screwed over his writers, had left them dangling, unrepresented, in limbo.

So this was the exclamation point to my experience.  I had officially returned to obscurity, while my former agent, who’d once told me I was going to be famous, was on the front page of the New York Times.  And why was he on the front page of The Times?  For screwing over people like me and writing about it!

The theme of Agent Orange’s memoir, so I gathered, was that he’d found redemption.  Oddly, the proof of his redemption was his big advance for his memoir of redemption.

It is an irony that any self-respecting postmodernist has to love.  If he gets a big advance, and lots of media attention, he has returned triumphantly, and there is a story.  If he doesn’t get a big advance, or media coverage, there is no real triumph.  No heartwarming redemption.  The story lies entirely in the fact that the media is covering the story.

There are real tragedies in this world, and my experience certainly not one of them.  Life goes on its petty pace.  I do have a new novel out, albeit with a smaller publisher, and a screenplay in development with an indie producer.  Still…if I were writing this tale I might have tweaked the ending just a bit. 


r/publishing • • May 26 '26

Caught my first ChatGPT book during the proofread.

356 Upvotes

I never thought it would happen to me. Last minute proof before sending to press. It occurs to me a couple chapters in that this book was at least half AI. Not really sure what will become of this title, and I can’t believe it made it past at least 3 editors before I caught it. This is publishing in 2026! I think everyone in acquisitions and editorial has to get a lot more savvy about AI tells, and quickly.


r/publishing • • 29d ago Regret

Why Men Don’t Read: Women Now Run Publishing

Thumbnail
quillette.com
349 Upvotes

Adam Szetela traces how American publishing went from a male-dominated trade to one where more than 70 percent of editors are women, mostly from elite universities, and argues this has narrowed what gets published. Its central claim is that young men don't hate reading, but the books on offer don't speak to them. For example, David Goggins's popular book Can't Hurt Me had to be self-published.

Is the "boys don't read" problem really a supply problem?


r/publishing • • Nov 26 '24

Request: Blanket Ban on A I Evangelists

314 Upvotes

Title. These people have at this point abandoned the rhetoric of even trying to aid writers and now just seek to denigrate marginalized people for their agendas all the time, while claiming we aren’t “smart enough” to write unassisted (with their perhaps most notable contributions to society being dry lakes and Elon Musk).

They’re making this place unpleasant even if they “just ask questions” and spew legitimate misogyny and racism at every turn. Can we just tell them the truth: they are not writers, and won’t be until they listen to real ones? There’s no “paradox of tolerance” they are just always rude at best.


r/publishing • • Nov 04 '25

My 15 year traditional publishing journey (or Hell as some call it)

297 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I've never gone public with this journey but after 15 years I thought I would actually try to connect with others in the community. I was a passionate writer from a young age, a big fan of horror and dark thrillers, and I wrote a horror novel similar to the works of Stephen King when I was 20.

Imagine my shock when I got a literary agent from one of the largest agencies in the nation. She was a young agent at a major agency and was incredibly excited about my work. We pitched it and nearly had a deal with a publisher, who backed out of convos eventually due to similarities in other works they were about to submit. Still, my agent was dedicated, ready to keep pushing my work when...

I learned she was leaving to become an editor. I was devastated. She promised me she was passing me off to good hands. The agency, rather large and one who repped big authors, kind of tossed me around from agent to agent, none of them certain why I was on their plate. Finally, someone who was now "my agent" (who had a big reputation) eventually told me that he believed the agency had fulfilled their end of the bargain and he would not be trying to sell the book any further. I could have their representation but they would not try to sell my book.

I ended representation and published my book through a small indy press. Probably sold 1000 copies and I was elated. Then the press went under.

I wrote another 4 books. Two years later I received literary representation again from a reputable agency. It was a book I was wildly excited about. So was the agent. I actually had multiple offers of rep. I was 23 by now and thought I'd survived the worst of it.

My agent was very helpful and we submitted the book to dozens of places. It was a dark transgressive bit of writing (American Psycho/Chuck Palahniuk esque) and thus while the feedback from editors was highly positive, the response also was: ehhh not sure we can market/sell this.

Back to the drawing board. Over the next few years I wrote a few more novels. My agent pitched a couple and we basically got the same responses. As time went on, my agent became less and less interested, did not return calls or emails. It would take a few months to get a response in some cases. We were at a point where she also did not want to submit work on my behalf.

Dejected, I ended the relationship again. This was around 2017

I pressed on writing. I was working and getting my phd but I still wanted writing to be THE path. From ages 20-35 I wrote 16 novels, although only a handful are really good in my opinion. I kept querying.

I think I have thousands of querying rejections between all the projects, to be honest.

In 2020 I submitted to a small indy publisher for one of my rural/gothic works of horror, again similar to the works of King. They were enthusiastic and offered me a contract. We got a cover designed and were ready for launch.

Then the publisher went under.

Around 2021-2022 I had two conversations with agents for projects of mine. One was over email and then scheduled a phone call with me to talk it over. Another notable agent. He never called at the agreed upon time and never responded to my two emails back to him.

Another agent was highly interested in one of my projects, but upon learning it had been pitched to editors previously withdrew her interest.

I kept writing. I kept submitting. Earned the PhD. Started a family. Earned a living. Still wanted the writing dream. I published some academic texts related to my field, 3 of them, but the sales were small for this niche. Still I was glad to have something out there.

In the present, I submitted more projects in the last couple of years but my lack of a social media presence (not a fan of how it impacts mental health/society/the world) doomed me a couple of times.

So....where did that leave this wild journey? I finally decided to self pub. Put a couple of books out there. Not a marketer so not expecting a lot but just happy to unleash some of the novels from the trunk. It's been a wild and meaningful ride and I've come to realize that writing and my art has value even if it doesn't "make it" like I've wanted.

If you've read this far, thank you, it was cathartic to finally share the tale.


r/publishing • • 14d ago

College student's pay-to-publish press...

Post image
292 Upvotes

I don't know if anyone else has seen this on Instagram, but a college student is trying to launch a pay-to-publish press, looking for people to work for her, and doing fundraising for the venture. The comments are resoundingly positive, which would be wild with the context even if the publishing model wasn't to have authors pay to publish there. Scrolling through the comments feels like drinking crazy juice


r/publishing • • Nov 25 '24

Is anyone surprised?

Post image
269 Upvotes

r/publishing • • Apr 08 '26

Uh...on this Mia Ballard thing.

259 Upvotes

So, I stumbled upon this story from somewhere else, and my first thought was...

Forget the book and whether it was AI generated. Who is the author?

Surprisingly, I could really not find much. A young author who seemed to have a quick rise in the industry and some fame in self-publishing who then got a book deal? I expected interviews and a bunch of social media accounts promoting the books, and could find very little.

The pictures I found, let me say, as a guy who has been on dating apps. All the photos read, "fake person."

So I eventually found this interview: https://bookstr.com/article/mia-ballard-on-her-horrific-feminine-rage-novel/

Now, this thing is COMPLETELY AI written. Much more obvious than the novel. Every answer has the em dash overload common in AI slop.

More surprising was, it had a link to her Instagram account (now deleted), but also a link to a website: miaballard.com

Which seems now to be a a website about AI entirely? Run by a person named Jayne Lytel who has a LinkedIn here: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jaynelytel?trk=article-ssr-frontend-pulse_x-social-details_comments-action_comment_actor-name

Jayne Lytel on her LinkedIn page is described as an "AI Architect" but she seems to also be an author selling a book? And she brags that it was partly AI written?

And her personal webpage leads to this site: runfromsunday.com

What is going on here? Does Mia Ballard even exist? Anyone got proof Mia Ballard is a real person?


r/publishing • • Apr 27 '26

Hachette Is Unionizing!

250 Upvotes

I'm not at Hachette, but I love to see this. Full support to anyone at Hachette in this sub.

Publishers Lunch article (need a subscription to see the full thing): https://lunch.publishersmarketplace.com/2026/04/hachette-book-group-employees-unionize/

Their website: https://hachetteworkers.com/


r/publishing • • Nov 25 '25

My students guilt tripped me into teacher publishing YA and now they're planning a library launch party

243 Upvotes

I teach English to sophomores and juniors and I'm constantly telling them to pursue creative projects, be brave with writing, all that inspirational teacher stuff and for the past year they've watched me work on my YA fantasy novel during lunch and after school.

Last week one student asked when my book was coming out and I did that awkward laugh thing and said oh someday maybe and then THREE different kids called me out for not taking my own advice, one literally said Miss T you tell us to believe in our voices but you won't share yours? Ouch but also they're right?

I've been hiding behind this idea that I need an agent first, that self-publishing would somehow be less legitimate or whatever. but I literally teach a unit on banned books and independent voices and challenging gatekeepers but like how am I going to stand in front of my students talking about the importance of diverse stories getting told while I'm too scared to publish mine?

So I'm doing it... I'm actually going to self-publish this thing, and my students are already planning a launch party in the library which is adorable and terrifying. I've got until June to figure it out because I promised them I'd have copies by the end of the school year.

Has anyone else ever been basically shamed into publishing by teenagers? Just me? Cool cool cool.

For real though if anyone has advice on how to navigate this as a teacher like do I need to tell my principal I'm publishing a book? Is there some ethical thing I'm missing? Help??


r/publishing • • Jul 30 '24

I emailed my editor at Taylor & Francis to find out if they were training AI on my book without my consent.

236 Upvotes

This is their response:

Many thanks for getting in touch and raising your concerns.

 It’s true that we have entered into agreements with two AI companies to provide access to our content for training. This is a fundamental part of our role as a publisher working on behalf of authors to ensure their ideas make the fullest possible contribution, and it’s consistent with our author agreements. Our standard publishing contracts do not enable authors to opt out from a specific use of their content (whether that is for AI or Text and Data Mining (TDM) or other types of licensing opportunity). 

 We are entering into agreements with partners who are aligned with Taylor & Francis on the importance of accurate citation, of author rights, and of improving the impact of scholarly publications. Our role as a publisher is to help authors’ ideas make their fullest contribution to society. The work we are doing with AI will improve research by making it easier to analyse data, generate hypotheses, automate tasks, work across disciplines, and research ideas.

 We have contractual rules that protect authors rights, safeguard their content from unauthorized access or use, and limit the reproduction of verbatim text.

 I should add that royalties will absolutely be paid to authors and other rightsholders in accordance with the licensing terms in their contracts.

 Kind regards,

Editor

I'm furious. Anyone know a good IP lawyer?

Update: They saw my tweet, in which I posted a screenshot and didn't blank the editor names. Here's their response, and mine:

Dear Author

 I am sorry that you are disappointed by our response.

 Just to reiterate that the terms of the contract you signed do authorise Routledge to licence your content in this way. And as I mentioned, we have contractual rules that protect authors' rights, safeguard their content from unauthorized access or use, and limit the reproduction of verbatim text.

I appreciate that you are unhappy with this and you are obviously free to share your concerns with colleagues and others. But I would respectfully request that you remove my and Hannah’s names from the Tweet you posted and if you forward our correspondence to anyone else.

 Kind regards,

Editor

This is my response:

Respect is mutual Editor. You have not given me any.

You didn't reach out to me to ask my consent to exploit my work in this way and you are only getting away with it right now because of what Routledge perceives to be a loophole in a contract written before AI training was considered an issue. I already blanked the email addresses out. If Routledge either confirms that my work is not and never will be used to train AI models, and that authors will be consulted and compensated in future, or alternatively proposes a satisfactory arrangement for myself and other authors affected by this then I'll happily delete the tweet, LinkedIn Post and Reddit post.

This is a complete lack of respect for authors and their work. If you believe the waffle you sent in the first email then you would have talked to authors and let us make our own decisions. The contract makes no mention of AI because it was not an issue in 2019 and you know that. This is an unauthorised use of my work, regardless of how you want to interpret a contract written in a different era.

Regards,

Jay.


r/publishing • • May 14 '21

Does it mean anything that The New Yorker personally responded to my short story submission?

Post image
228 Upvotes

r/publishing • • Mar 18 '21

You post some dumb cartoons online. Next thing you know, your publisher is sending you advance copies of the 5th book in the series. follow your dumb dreams.

Post image
226 Upvotes

r/publishing • • Aug 06 '26

OH MY GOD stop querying by phone!!!

224 Upvotes

I just need to rant because JESUS FUCKING CHRIST people can’t read anymore??? It is 2026 — NO ONE is accepting queries by phone, why are people still trying??

The amount of phone calls I get from people who think email is “just so impersonal” and “I have this incredible story that no one has ever seen” or the presumptuously blunt “can I speak to Founder of the Company?”

NO YOU CANT. DO YOU KNOW THAT EVERYONE THINKS THEY HAVE A REALLY COOL STORY TO TELL THAT NO ONE HAS EVER SEEN?? And do you really think that listing your accomplishments and name dropping important people to me, the person on the phone and NOT someone who cares a single bit about your project, is going to get you somewhere??

I am just at my wits end with the amount of people who feel entitled to a phone query when a company’s website clearly states that they don’t accept them. You are NOT special and you will not be treated as such.

****EDIT — wow, I am pleasantly surprised by how many responses this got, and thank you to all those validating my rant!

For clarity, I want to say that I completely understand how difficult it is to be published. I work in this industry, I’ve seen many talented people who truly had amazing stories to tell who never got a book deal, for various reasons.

My qualm is with people who think they are the exception. People who have done absolutely no research, just googled a list of places and called them all up. The publishing process is difficult but it has rules, and unless you are an actual celebrity, then you are not an exception to these rules. Trust me on this.

In this digital age, there are so many resources that break down the publishing process and offer useful tips. And anyone looking to submit a query should be carefully looking through an agency’s website. It is this part that drives me insane. If a website details how submissions are handled, and explicitly states how submissions are NOT accepted, then doing the thing you’ve been asked NOT to do reads like total disregard for the company’s time.

Also, for those asking about a voicemail or taking the phone number down: unfortunately I have not been allowed to do the latter, even though I’ve pressed the matter. In regard to the former, we do have a voicemail, but are required to answer the phone if someone is in the office.

The point is that if someone calls, it is most likely because they found our phone on the web. And if you’ve found our phone, then you’ve found the website. Any author worth their salt would first and foremost look at submission requirements before attempting to reach out at all, which means they would have had to look at our queries page and seen we do not accept them by phone.


r/publishing • • Oct 21 '25

Is it just me, or are the economics of traditional publishing kind of wild?

223 Upvotes

I was looking into what authors actually make from traditional publishing and honestly, it blew my mind.

From what I’ve seen, most get like a dollar or two per book after everyone else takes their cut. The book might sell for $25, but the author walks away with basically coffee money.

I get that publishers take on risk and cover editing, printing, distribution, all that, but still… how is that even sustainable for writers?

Do most authors see it as a trade for exposure or prestige? Or are there people who actually make a living on those rates?

Just curious what people here think.


r/publishing • • Mar 20 '26

Mia Ballard's Shy Girl canceled by Hachette over purported AI use

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
208 Upvotes

After seeing this controversy (not sure what else to call it at this point!) unfold over the past few months, I'm wondering what this says about the longevity of the current self-pub success to trad-pub pipeline that we're seeing so much at the moment. The editor who acquired this book seems to have acquired it directly from the author, with no agent involvement, and the publisher listed it as a key title for 2026, despite the fact that many of the book's reviews on the self-pub version already flagged it as being AI generated. The author's word that she did not use AI appears to have been sufficient to warrant a huge publicity and marketing campaign, and it's only now that more ARC readers have flagged the AI use, including several distributors refusing to stock the book, and recently surfaced comments from the author about AI having been used in the editing process, that it's been pulled from publication by Hachette.

I'm honestly pretty shocked at the amount of money that will have been poured into this book on the assumption that, because it was a self-pub success, it would be a huge bestseller for the publisher. With its cancellation, I'm also wondering about all the other Hachette authors who won't have seen anywhere close to the marketing and publicity campaigns that this author got, and what the increasing investment in formerly self-published books like this - books which, after acquisition, aren't submitted to the same rigorous editorial process as more conventional acquisitions - might mean for the industry as a whole when they prove not to be the assured financial successes (a la Alchemised, Heated Rivalry) that they're being touted as, but something far riskier.

Interested in others' thoughts, because I think we'll be seeing more stories like this as AI becomes an increasing problem.


r/publishing • • Feb 26 '22

Does anyone else hate how identical these best selling book covers are? It obviously works but it’s so boring and tells you almost nothing about the book. Nothing on this shelf stands out to me.

Post image
186 Upvotes

r/publishing • • 8d ago

HarperCollins staff warned about Walliams' behaviour – but I was sent to his house alone

Thumbnail
inews.co.uk
166 Upvotes

Young women working at David Walliams' former publisher say they were alerted about his conduct roughly a decade ago


r/publishing • • Mar 24 '26

The Shy Girl cancellation raises questions nobody seems to be asking

162 Upvotes

The Shy Girl cancellation raises questions nobody seems to be asking

By now most people in publishing circles have heard about Hachette cancelling Mia Ballard's contract over AI accusations.

A few things about this case that I haven't seen discussed seriously:

The timeline is strange. Hachette described their decision as the result of a thorough and lengthy review. That review concluded one day after the New York Times contacted them with questions. That's not a review. That's a PR response. So what really drove them to make the decision?

The detection tools aren't what people think they are. Pangram returned a 78% AI-generated result that circulated through coverage as though it were a forensic finding. Hachette used Pangram, Originality AI, and ZeroGPT. These are probabilistic pattern matchers, not forensic instruments. They flag patterns that correlate with AI output — patterns that also appear in heavily edited prose, formal writing styles, and neurodivergent writers. The King James Bible has returned AI-positive on tools like these. Three tools with overlapping methodologies aren't three independent data points. The same flaw is repeated three times. Nobody in the mainstream coverage examined this question seriously.

The policy being celebrated doesn't say what people think it says. Hachette requires authors to disclose AI use. It does not prohibit AI-assisted work. Those are different policies. So essentially, what was punished was non-disclosure, not AI use. An author who disclosed upfront wouldn't have broken any rules. Would Hachette have still signed if Mia opened said she used AI assistance? Nobody knows, because the publishing industry hasn't been opening for or against AI.

The contractual gap nobody is addressing. Ballard claims her an editor used AI without her knowledge. We have no way of knowing if that's true. But here's the problem: publishing contracts ask authors to disclose AI use. If a developmental editor, sensitivity reader, or proofreader uses AI without telling the author, the author bears full liability.

That affects every author, not just AI-assisted ones.

The acquisition itself deserves scrutiny. Hachette picked up a self-published novel that had already generated controversy over stolen cover art and AI suspicions before the contract was signed. Did anyone there actually read the manuscript first or did social media metrics do it for them? If average readers flagged the prose as flat and repetitive, what were the editors doing?

I'm not arguing Ballard is innocent. I'm arguing the process used to determine guilt was broken regardless of her guilt. And that process has implications for authors across the board, whatever their position on AI.

Curious what others in this community think, especially anyone who has navigated publishing contracts recently. I'm a writer myself trying to decide between self and traditional publishing.

Is anyone actually addressing the contractual gap on third party AI use?


r/publishing • • Dec 19 '25

David Walliams dropped by publisher over inappropriate behaviour towards junior staff

Thumbnail archive.is
159 Upvotes

Following an investigation by the Telegraph newspaper. Thank christ for that, and may the floodgates of comeuppance for shitty men in publishing finally open.


r/publishing • • 23d ago

LIFE magazine coming back into print wasn't on my 2026 bingo card

158 Upvotes

Have you all seen this? https://new.life.com/

LIFE magazine is relaunching with print. Is this the turn of the tides back into print publishing?