r/publishing • u/verwirrende • 4d ago
Interview tips?
Hi guys,
I have an internship interview (editorial) at a Big 5 publisher in a couple of weeks. It’s the first one I’ve had after months of sending my application into the abyss, so I’m eager to make it count. Does anyone have any tips? Trick questions to expect, answers they’re looking for, things to avoid, etc.?
Thanks!
5
u/Adorable_Watch9085 4d ago
Speaking from experience (I started my career in editorial as an intern at a Big Five imprint, albeit many years ago), you might want to be prepared for them to ask you to list the last handful of books you read. This is where it would be helpful for you to research the imprint in advance so you know what kind of books they publish. If they focus mainly on commercial fiction and the books you mention reading are more highbrow literary books (or vice versa), they might think you’re not the right fit for them. You don’t have to exclusively name books that they published (though familiarity with a few of them would definitely be helpful), but demonstrating that you read the same genres they publish can be a good thing. Also be prepared for them to potentially send you home with a book (or manuscript) and ask you to write a reader’s report summarizing your feedback on the storyline. Good luck, I hope the interview goes well!
2
u/yyt17613 3d ago
Hi this is a small bit of advice from when I was interviewing people at a big 5 publisher!
One time we interviewed this girl who was almost too excited to be there. She said “I can’t believe I’m here” a couple of times in the interview and asked to take a pic on her way out. I know publishing is a big dream for a lot of people, but the higher ups in the interview saw it as immature and didn’t take her seriously. Now when anyone i know is interviewing for their dream role, I tell them to fangirl after they leave.
1
u/FinnegansWeek 3d ago
You’re getting downvotes but as someone who has hired a couple people at a Big 5 in the last year, we had several candidates who were great on paper but during the interview made it clear their goal was working in publishing/for our imprint rather than explaining why the role we were interviewing them for was a good fit. Passion is important but we’re not hiring a full time fan position.
1
u/yyt17613 3d ago
thank you! I certainly didn’t mean to offend anyone, was just trying offer some insight into what I heard some higher ups say in the interview process.
I want to clarify that I think it’s great to be excited for the job interview, but let those emotions out before and after, not during.
1
u/Acrobatic-Poem-3282 4d ago
Research the imprints recent titles and prepare examples of organization, proofreading and teamwork. Practice explaining why editorial interests u beyond simply loving books and bring thoughtful questions
1
u/Reasonable-Rip8065 4d ago
Pick 2 recent books from the imprint and prepare specific observations about their audience and positioning. And also have a clear example of handling detailed work under deadlines
17
u/BugAccomplished1570 4d ago
Pick two books from the imprint’s recent list. For each, practise a 30-second answer about who would buy it, what makes it stand out, and one comparable book. Then try writing a three-sentence reader’s report on a sample chapter: what’s working, one issue, and the first edit you’d suggest. That gives you a concrete example of how you read and give feedback if they ask about your editorial judgment.