r/projecteternity • • Dec 02 '24

Other Avowed is out for preorder -- and reviews are brigaded on Steam!

3 Upvotes

As a POE I-II mega fan I have been looking forward to Avowed for some time, even though it won't scratch the CRPG itch. I went to the preorder page and it has ... LGBTQ+ and "Political" tags, plus tons of hate on the community page, for allowing checks notes pronoun selection???

I want to see POE3. I don't want to see Sawyer crushed again by disappointing initial sales. I don't want this game to be a culture war victim thanks to some angry people on Twitter.

I know it's not in everyone's budget to preorder much less preorder the premium edition, but that's what I'm doing. I was going to wait until the game came out and buy it on sale the way I do 90% of games (since I don't game a ton) but this has made me change my mind.

Edit: look, I'm not telling you to preorder, it's not generally a good idea and certainly don't do it if you don't trust preorders. I'm just choosing to do so because I already know I want this game and I don't personally care if it's just "okay." Apparently it'll be on game pass, so consider that too! I'll take at least 6 months to get thru it tho so game pass isn't worth it to me. I just want to point out that the game's gotten brigaded.


r/projecteternity • • Mar 31 '15

Obsidian, be smart

0 Upvotes

People love you, they really do. Your fans, including me, are some of the most supporting bunch of nerds I've ever seen.
You release a game that breaks itself no matter how careful you are. It's not only the amount of bugs but how stupid and game-breaking they are. Double click to equip gear? Broken character. Loading in a map where you picked up a companion? Broken character. Raedric's Hold crash, tutorial sound bug, int decreasing dot damage, and the list goes on. Even equipping certain gear can break your character! But we are still here, and we are waiting. And we lost characters, restarted the game, tried not to trigger that game-breaking bug only to find there is another one of those how-did-this-went-through-bugs that managed to break our character yet once again.

Even though we waited a long time and we sure can wait a few days more for the first post-release patch to come around, don't you guys think we deserve better? And by better I'm just talking about an update on the situation. The official forum doesn't seem to have a search feature (or maybe I'm not able to find it), but even if there's one, right now we have users reporting the same bug that was already reported three hours ago, yesterday and the day before yesterday.

How about a simple list with the problems you have already acknowledged and their status? Is that really so much to ask? 'Bug A: fixed and included in upcoming patch. Bug B: looking for a fix'. Not even asking for a precise ETA.

With something as simple as that you can:

  • Stop all those repeated posts that make reporting a bug such a dull task.

  • Give the users an easy way to keep track of the currently known bugs, therefore making possible for us to check if we've suffered from it.

  • Give the users something to hold on to while waiting for the patch that is, hopefully, going to solve their problems so they can enjoy the game. Keeping the community in the dark is a bad idea. Plenty of examples for this.

  • Keep the love flowing

Be smart, take care of your loving community.

So pretty please, with sugar on top, give us a heads up.

EDIT: apparently I wasn't clear enough and some of you may think I should give Obsidian a break. Well, I don't see how politely asking for better PR could be a problem, ever. And for those of you playing a bug-free playthrough, I'm sorry to tell you that you are not. Just because you don't notice it, doesn't mean that it doesn't exists. Some of us really care about our spells gaining AoE when they shouldn't or our companion being invincible. If you don't, good for you, but learn to respect what others expect from a game they backed years ago and learn to respect them asking respectfully for better communication.


r/projecteternity • • Mar 29 '26

Discussion Pillars of Eternity II feels like you're a self-insert fanfic character in Edér's story

0 Upvotes

The entire plot feels thematically built for him, the fish out of water (or rather farmer in high seas) trope, his relationship with Eothas, Xoti, his quest and character arc is way more deep compared to the other party members. He builds up the plot and vice versa, the watcher on the other hand feels stappled in, completely redundant


r/projecteternity • • 9d ago

Am I tripping?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Has this always been random, or did they change the default for controller release


r/projecteternity • • Apr 03 '15

Misleading: changed, not removed. "Looks like @Obsidian decided to remove Firedorn's memorial without noting in the patch notes. I'm a bit disappointed"

Thumbnail
twitter.com
47 Upvotes

r/projecteternity • • Feb 22 '25

Discussion So disappointed in Avowed. Looking for a friendly discussion.

54 Upvotes

I do want to have a friendly conversation. Im struggling trying to figure out why im not enjoying it as big of a fan as i am of the Pillars series.

I just feel awkward. Talking animations look uncanny. Playing feels hollow. Companions are trusted upon you with little justification. Their comments and dialog feels forced, and tonally inappropriate right at times; empty. Im not sure what it is. For the first time ever, i notably dont like the character writting. Its so general, but were suppose to be playing a specific character? Not just a random prisoner.

Combat is rudimentary at best. Im just spamming spells and attacks heedlessly. Running around in circles to dodge and wait for health or essence to regen. Theres no depth. Only challenge is meat shields and walls.

Why do we even have all these enchanting materials when i almost never use them. We cant enchant armor, only weapons. But with this sort of game, we are incentivised to specialize. So why have all these items if i cant even put them on my companions. Costs money to respec, and a lot more to make sure its upgraded for your area.

It feels like a simple 2008 action adventure game. Which is totally fine. Nothing wrong with that. Just not for 70-80$. Very much feels like a good budget title. Its overproduced for what it offers at its core.

If i spent 40$ i wouldnt feel as bad as i do. I just dont know what happened. Its a beautiful game, but incredibly shallow. I sadly feel like this game is going to fail.

--‐-----------------------------------‐---------------------------------------

i know that a lot of my points i can say the same for just about every game of this genre. But ive never felt disappointed like this before.


r/projecteternity • • Mar 29 '15

Totalbiscuit - Pillars of Transphobia?

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
2 Upvotes

r/projecteternity • • Feb 14 '24

Discussion Anyone else want to see a fully 3D Pillars of Eternity 3?

1 Upvotes

I don't just mean something that looks like Baldur's Gate 3. I mean, fully 3D, like the way Awowed looks, but only in third person, with the option to have a static isometric camera angle that you can switch to over-the-shoulder view at any time. That would be revolutionary, and I'm sure that if any company could do it...it would actually be Larian. But if Microsoft could give Josh the budget, and tell him to make a 3D world in Pillars of Eternity that would appeal to CRPG players, I think we could see another Game of the Year contender.


r/projecteternity • • Jun 09 '24

Anybody else a little concerned about Avowed?

5 Upvotes

On paper I’m totally down for a third person action rpg in the pillars universe, I mean who doesn’t want an elder scrolls style obsidian game right? But man, the stuff we’ve gotten about Avowed simply doesn’t come off as an obsidian rpg. We’re seeing cartoonish action, which yeah is cool enough I guess and dnd style sword and sorcery is fundamentally kinda cartoonish, but I’m not seeing the tone or story hooks that usually draw me to obsidian RPGs


r/projecteternity • • Mar 29 '25

Discussion Companion Tier List

Post image
0 Upvotes

I included all recruitable followers across all 3 Eora games that I know of.

Included Eder, Aloth, and Pallegina portraits from both games because I rank them separately.

Each individual tier is in no particular order left to right.


r/projecteternity • • Dec 16 '20

Discussion These games subtly destroy hetero normativity and it's incredible.

27 Upvotes

People are just assumed to have the possibility of being gay or bi. The only instance I can think of when a character explicitly has to say they are gay is when Kana gets rejected by Mahena.


r/projecteternity • • Jul 08 '26

Discussion Low effort, honest request

Post image
0 Upvotes

I know it’ll never happen, but let a man dream.


r/projecteternity • • Sep 14 '23

Discussion What happened to the writting in POE2

2 Upvotes

I fucking loved PO1. It was my first crpg (if you don’t count DA:O) and to me it was bafling how it could have characters like Durance, so deep and complex, in par with Hiravais, so funny and straightforward. The way you get the land, get slowly called the Watcher of Caed Nua, and eventually the plot of the gods, filled with philosophical references. I just loved the game.

I jumped to POE2 at the time I couldn’t finished it. I felt bored and burned out. A year after I decided to give it another try, thinking it was just me and too much pillars why I felt uninterested.

One again, I find myself not caring. I LOVE pirates, the pirate theme seems great to me, the power conflict between them and their different views in outlawing is great. After that, everything seems boring.

All companions don’t even get close to the first game, with some great one in the first games like Eder getting pretty stupid by mid game. Maia questline is trash, it doesn’t give you any logical option as a player. Same with Tekehu quest. Xoti is plainly anoying, tho her quest is decent. Serafen is a washed up Hiravais. The main plot goes nowhere. Every single involved party is pretty stupid. The fish people are dumb as fuck. The VTC are the most interesting but still badly presented, and the Rutanian are just straight an evil empire, which would be fine, except that as a player you can only work for them or declare them war. No spying, no betraying, no turning people, no shit. Gameplay is better tho, but I miss the good writing soo much.


r/projecteternity • • Jun 30 '23

Courier's Calling (Maia's personal quest) made me drop the game Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Probably one of the worst and most disappointing endings on a side quest i've ever seen. I was fine with being an errand boy for factions that I couldn't care about, because at least I could do some good through working with them, better my reputation, or maybe better the lives of people. Or I could at least help my companions with their own problems because I actually care about them. So taking Maia to do her personal business and helping her was fine with me.

Maia's quest however was delivering assassin orders and assassinating someone herself, consequences that end up leading to horrible ends to Port Maje and Tikawara (And a Huana tribe). This is all revealed at the end of the side quest....

So i'm sitting there asking the game "How the fuck was I supposed to know that or prevent it in any way?". The only way I could end up with good endings with these towns is to read the wiki and purposely go out of my way to sabotage the assassination orders, which is the exact opposite of roleplaying. Simply helping a companion to the best of my abilities results in bad ends, something that completely negates all progress I made in those towns.

It's crazy how all the work I put into helping Port Mage and Tikawara is all thrown into the trash just by helping a companion, in which case I have no way of knowing that except after the fact.

The game couldn't be bothered to drop hints or some narrative devices to say "Hey you could help Maia, but maybe there's something you could do to figure out what's actually going on. Might be able to talk her down".

Instead the alternative is simply to flop a companion quest. Why would any self-respecting RPG have the best outcome be to purposely fucking over your companion? It makes no sense.

I could stomach the boring factions, the weird pacing of the main story. being an errand boy to a circus of morons, and half the companions being stand ins for the factions, but when simply doing a companion quest to the best of my ability results in a bad ending and I have no way i knowing? Yea i'm done.

I thought POE1 companion stories were a bit weak, but nothing grossly offensive as this nonsense.

All my good will toward the game has been sand blasted off. 52 hours down the drain.


r/projecteternity • • May 04 '24

Discussion Really dissapointed after completing pillars of eternity 2 Spoiler

5 Upvotes

To give some context, I played pillars 1 and after figuring out the combat and stuff, enjoyed it. My only complaints with the game were the classes, combat, and some qol features. A few dungeons also felt too long.

I had heard mixed stuff about the second game, so went in with no expectations. As I started the game, I loved the fact that you could multiclass, the combat is a lot better. The game looks a lot better, npcs have accented english voices, which enhance their dialogues. There are a lot fewer enemies in dungeons, and a lot of things can be done without combat/have alternate solutions. There also much better skill checks. I was excited for the game, and thought it might become one of my top crpgs of all time. Sidekick is a mechanic that more crpgs need to implement.

That was untill I started noticing all the things that were wrong with the game. The first thing I noticed was that the economy made absolutely no sense. This woman just gave me 1000 bucks for bribing this guy 40. The economy of the entire game is purely mechanical, but it really ruins immersion. They probably did it to balance the ship costs. But it got worse.

There is a literal god walking across the ocean who is going to change or destroy the world in a significant way. The stakes are at its peak. Why are these people choosing me for errands and giving me bounties? This was the crux to a larger problem in rpgs if you keep increasing the stakes and add some sort of urgency to it. They probably planned to add some sort of timer to the game, but felt it would be too harsh. Fallout 1 did this pretty well.

Some of the factions are also extremely pointless. Furrante vs aeldys felt like just a personal choice. Why would any good character support illegal slavery. More so, why does any of this matter now? I have a god to stop guys. All the gods in eora asked me to do it.

The problem with the quest design that they went for is that the side quests had huge variations in quality. Some of them were amazing, like fort deadlight was really good, others were literal fetch quests. Oh take crate to port hasongo or some shit.

Lets talk about the companions. I miss durance. Most of the companions from game 1 have already finished the important stuff in their life, so they just go looking for their ex. Aloth's quest was good because it revealed more information on thaos and leden key. The others were kinda dissapointing. Maia is kinda dumb ig, she had to shoot a guy in the head to realise that maybe the deadfire company is bad. Also don't get me started on the romances, xoti was weirdly flirting with both me and eder. I think she was bugged for me because the wiki says she romances after her quest is finished. Maia romance hardly had any content. Im sure aloth or eder romances would have been better but oh well.

The 3 main factions felt like lazy writing to me, as you had no idea you would have to travel to ukaizo, so you never knew you were gonna need a special ship. But that was the main purpose behind having them. Being an errand boy for a faction just didn't make sense to me, but it is a good point that we were seen as a neutral party.

The main story of poe2 is also lackluster. You follow eothas and try to find out about his plan? The lack of fast travel and the amount of loading screens, performance issues also diminishes my enjoyment of the game.

All this is to say, I didn't hate the game, just that it wasn't as good as the first game for me. But an interesting side effect was that I now like pillars 1 even more. Getting to know the gods a lot better and interacting with the world of eora more made me like it more. It was also interesting to see just how much thaos did.

Tl;dr poe2 wasn't as good as I had hoped but made me enjoy poe1 and the world of eora more.


r/projecteternity • • Apr 26 '22

Pale elf - cypher design!

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/projecteternity • • Sep 10 '23

Discussion I really want to love POE but I hate real time pause.

2 Upvotes

I heard there is turn based mode in poe2. Do I need to finish the first game understand the story? Also, how is the turn based mode? Is it like dos2 level of good?


r/projecteternity • • Jul 18 '23

Discussion Why do people dislike Royal Deadfire Company, It's the best faction ! + Why Rauatai is great. [SPOILERS TO PoE2] Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So, sometime ago, i started playing Deadfire, but before that, i did some research to see how each faction presents, and i've seen that many people dislike RDC.

My first Deadfire playthrough was a Magran Priest, and i liked the concept of RDC, so i joined them, and i have no fuckin' idea why people dislike it.

It's: cool, Lawful Neutral/Evil (the two best alignments, and the "Evil" part comes only from their skulduggery military tactics), effective, and it's the best choice for Deadfire Archipelago.

So i decided to make this post explaining why i think it's the best faction, and to see people opinion of RDC. So let's begin.

1. Why people dislike it.

The reasons i've seen people say were:

  1. They're too lawful - In my opinion, this is a huge pro rather than con, Lawfulness is ALWAYS the best, without it, you have anarchy and chaos that slowly destroys everything, and leads to slow decay.

  2. They want to control the Deadfire Archipelago to extract all the resources from it - It's pure bullshit, and ignorance of in game knowledge. Many times we saw the motivation of each faction, and The faction that wants to suck this land dry is VTC, RDC wants just to control it, bring order, settle there, and have the trade routes made between the Archipelago and Rauatai, which even though it's the most prosperous empire in the world, it has poor soil.

  3. They are racist - That's also pure bullshit, they aren't racist at all, they insult Huana, but they're essentially enemies, would you expect kindness between a Nazi and Soviet ? NO, you wouldn't. (and most of the insults against Huana is about them being too passive, disorganized, stupid, and illiterate. BUT ALL OF THESE THINGS ARE TRUE, everyone knows Huana is too passive, disorganized, and even Huana themselves admits to not letting their people learn writing and improving their knowledge, as seen during the conversation with Nairi in Tikawara.)

  4. They don't have the same rights to the Deadfire Archipelago as Huana - Yet again, it's not true, it's true that native people of the Archipelago were Huana, but Rauatai controlled most, if not all of it at some point, which because of the right of conquest, meant that this land was theirs, and it still would be, if not for the natural catastrophes that weaken them to the point of being beaten by the Huana. AND THEY EVEN DID MORE FOR THE ARCHIPELAGO THAN HUANA (They routed away the Naga, while Huana did nothing, and just soured in their own stagnation).

  5. They employ brutal and ruthless tactics/discipline in their army - Yes, they do, that's why they're so effective, and manage to keep everything in order, + tactics like that allow them to minimize the casualties.

2. Why Rauatai/RDC is great.

This point will be mainly about Rauatai, but i think that we should count both RDC/Rauatai as one, same with Old Vailia and VTC.

So, why is it great ?

  1. It's the only Old Empire that avoided the decline, and is still prosperous (not even that, it's THE MOST prosperous out of all the Old Empires).

  2. It's one of the most progressive countries in Eora, both technologically, and socially.

  3. Furthermore, it's a country of Law and order, without being tyrannical.

  4. Regular people from Rauatai are happy (literally, i haven't met a single Rauataian, who wasn't in the army, who said that they didn't enjoy living there, EVERY SINGLE ONE says how great it was).

  5. Contrary to Huana, they are strong, unified, and proactive, which led to them being one of the most, if not THE most, prosperous countries in Eora, EVEN THOUGH THEY HAVE POOR SOIL.

  6. (It's the only subjective point here) They have a really cool drip, and most characters from there have great personality.

3. Why you should choose the RDC instead of other factions, and why is it the best choice for the Deadfire Archipelago.

First, let's quickly talk about the other factions:

- Huana: Stupidly traditionalist people, who lack initiative, and because of that, are too weak to fight anyone, and are too weak to defend themselves.

AND if there is a situation where they don't attack anyone, and have no enemies, because of their lack of initiative and traditionalism, they stagnate, and do nothing, while everyone around them improves, both in militarily, and technologically, WHICH, undoubtedly leads to some time in the future, where other country, way more powerful and advanced, will easily conquer whole Deadfire Archipelago, and exterminate Huana.

- Vailian Trading Company: Smart and progressive, but greedy as fuck. They want to control the Archipelago just so they can suck it dry out of resources, and leave it (probably the worst choice, in long-term, except Principi led by Aeldys).

- Príncipi sen Patrena: Here we have to talk about the divide, between old bloods, and new bloods.

  • Old bloods (led by Furrante): Respectable pirates, that ventured into the Deadfire Archipelago to try to establish their own country, led similarly to Grand Vailia. (In my opinion it's the second-best choice, because it creates a new country, that doesn't excavate the land to the point of breaking, and isn't as stagnate as Huana).

  • New bloods (led by Aeldys): Rowdy children of pirates, no honour, no respect, just pure chaos and levity.

- Royal Deadfire Company, i won't talk about them, because i dedicated most of this post to them.

Then, there are also Endings that say a lot about each faction:

- Vailian Trading Company: It brings short-lived peace (based only on how much profit it brings), and it sucks every possible resource dry for profit. And depending on whom you chose to be the director.

  • If you choose Alvari, she speedruns excavating the resources, builds temporary settlements, and has a plan to dry the land out of resources, and get the fuck away, leaving everyone to fight for the Archipelago again.

  • If you choose Castol, he still excavates all the resources, but he doesn't intend to leave the Archipelago, and he focuses more on animancy. He builds permanent settlements, and an academy at Ukaizo.

- Príncipi sen Patrena: Here it depends if Furrante, or Aeldys is the leader.

If the Furrante is the leader, then he establishes a not-so-bad country of his own and grips most of the Archipelago by its balls. He establishes a formal government around the Consuaglo mes Casitàs, and makes Principi learn to cultivate and trade for the resources they once seized and stole. AND both RDC and VTC

And if the latter is the leader, then she changes the Archipelago into a lawless land of pirates and fucks every other faction (There's also Two-Eyed Pim, who transforms the Principi into a profitable transit company, but if I'm correct, it's only possible to do when not siding with the Principi, but correct me if i'm wrong).

- Huana: They bring relative peace with RDC and VTC, but because of their lack of initiative, they still don't achieve anything, are stuck in tradition, and wouldn't you know, they bring whole Deadfire Archipelago to stagnation.

VTC either leaves the Archipelago, or maintains a small animancy operation.

RDC either leaves the Archipelago, or maintains the trade with Huana.

And Principi either leaves the Archipelago, or is destroyed.

but as i said, because of their lack of initiative, for sure, in some time, some other country will improve both technologically and militarily, while Huana will stay the same, and it will be destroyed by said country with no problem.

-Royal Deadfire Company: Brings peace and order to the Deadfire Archipelago, eliminates crime (including the Principi), isn't a ruthless ruler who evicts every native person from the Archipelago, quite the contrary, it dissolves all the Huana's stupid traditions like caste system, brings them unity as well as prosperity, and it integrates them into society as normal citizens, AND Rauatai doesn't even treat the Archipelago as a colony, they see it as a fully fledged part of their country.

PLUS, unlike VTC, they don't excavate every resource from the Archipelago.

AND IT'S NOT ALL, after they conquered the Deadfire Archipelago, it brought changes into Rauataian culture, they become more self-reliant, and peaceful.

AND THAT'S NOT EVEN THE BEST PART, after it happened, Rauatai becomes dedicated to fixing the cycle of reincarnation.

Picking RDC, is the best for the Eora, not only Rauatai or Deadfire (and personally, i think that it's the canon Ending, mostly because it has the most ending slides, and it gives hope in the form of Rauatai helping to fix the cycle of reincarnation).

I hope i convinced you to change your mind on RDC and Rauatai, and that during your next playthrough, you will choose to support them.


r/projecteternity • • Jan 08 '24

Discussion I kinda realized... We as a community want Avowed to be good... But not too good.

19 Upvotes

What it says on the Tin.
As a community, lovers of Eora and Pillars of eternity...
We want Avowed to be successful.
We want it to be a great game, that holds up in the modern day, gets a lot of attention and people get interested in the setting.
That is what we want.

We want the release announcement (aka when we get a specific date) to result in hundreds of streamers and new players trying out PoE1 and PoE2 to get caught up and understand the setting, we want it to grow.

BUT...
We do not want... Avowed to be too successful, if that make sense?
We want it to make numbers, but not be BG3 sized or win GOTY.

Because, we want Avowed to make Eora a desired setting.
But we don't want Avowed to completely overshadow Pillars of Eternity, and make Microsoft interested in pushing Avowed as the new series.

If Avowed is successful we increase chances for PoE3...
If Avowed is a smash-hit of the year...
We will NEVER see PoE3 period.

Does that make sense?
(I understand that this comes off as me talking for people, but you get my point. If Avowed do well, we might get interest in more Pillars... if Avowed do TOO well, we will never see Pillars again)


r/projecteternity • • Mar 11 '25

5 Things Great about Avowed

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/projecteternity • • Aug 27 '23

I thought this game was boring.

1 Upvotes

Coming from pathfinders, at first i hated this game's graphics and ui so i put it down, poe2.

After giving it more chance cause i was bored, im hooked.

This is what i like

  • gameplay, i like to experiment builds, I also like ship building and fighting.

  • quests, interesting story.

  • lots of rpg elements.

This is what i dont like

  • graphics and animations, but its an indie game so i will give it a pass.

  • companions, they are ugly and boring.

Overall 8/10, good game.


r/projecteternity • • Sep 26 '22

Kickstarter NPCs everywhere. More than actual NPCs

1 Upvotes

I just don't get how people defend it. It's so bad. They out-number real NPCs. I tried desperately to like this game, but every bar, every street, every corner of a populated area, I see nothing but gold plated NPCs that I know have nothing of value to say. If you take into account that so many of the named characters in the game are these kickstarter fanfics it makes this game devoid and barren of actual people to talk to.

It blows me away that people skim over this and consider this a good game. If you'd have replaced all of these NPCs with ACTUAL NPCs I'd agree, the game would be good, but for so many years and changes to have passed, that they left this abomination in the game without an option to toggle them off, just defys my understanding.


r/projecteternity • • May 28 '18

Spoilers POE2: What happened? [BIG SPOILERS] Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I'm going through my second play through of the game here, and I have to ask, What happened? This game says Pillars of Eternity, but it just lacks....soul? Not sure what the word is, but it seems the essence of what made Pillars what it is, is missing.

The game is an improvement on POE1, but I think it was improved in all the wrong places, lacking in the ones that matter. I'm struggling to actually care on this play through, now that I know the story (or lack thereof).

The Good:

- Graphics are pretty. Lighting is great.

- Love the mouse over explaining the Lore, much easier to follow than POE1.

- Explanation of the combat system breakdown is great.

- Music selection is decent.

The Bad:

- Ample Bugs. Won't even go into it here.

- I know it's been mentioned a hundred times, but the difficulty is a joke. This is what is causing me to just not care anymore. On POTD, all levels upscaled, I can literally put the AI on and let the game play itself. The fact the game was released in this state is kind of an insult to the player backers, in my opinion. I had to put on Trial of Iron just to get some kind of thrill battle to battle. I shouldn't be able to kill the end game boss or the sea monster Ondra sent after me by clicking "attack" and sitting back. it's just so bad it makes me wonder if they were afraid of delaying the game's release again. I beat the game at level 15. I should have had to be level 19 or 20 and still have it be a fight.

- Which leads to my next point: the combat system is lacking. In POE1, you had to actually plan your combats and understand the system in order to get through POTD. Here, since all skills are per encounter, you can just fling or do whatever you want against the enemy, don't worry because an injury or a skill will just come back post-battle after an easy rest and eating this egg or whatever. Also, why are spell casters so limited? Why are grimores locked? I can't experience any kind of tactical planning when I'm locked into X spells, so every battle is exactly the same. It's also hard to feel how combat is even going, but I stopped caring about details and just steamroll everything.

- Ship combat is atrocious. To win any battle at sea, it's 1,1,1,1,1,1, then watch AI win auto-battle. Honestly , I avoid other ships as it's a time sink unless I need easy gold.

- Ship Management simply doesn't matter. Just get enough crew, make sure you buy +1 morale food and drink, and get the hull and sails upgrade. There's no other point in upgrading your ship to the better ones. Caed Nua felt more nuanced, more like I had something. Here my ship is meaningless as are my crew.

- The voice acting is much too overdone. On a second play through I'm just trying to get through the scenes now, of which they all talk over each other.

- All the factions are uninteresting and are some kind of weird combination of pirate/italian/noble/islander. There are just too many and all are some kind of evil, so I end up not caring about any of them besides getting XP and then telling them to screw off as I sail off on my own to Ukaizo.

- Companion quests are lacking.

- Entire story is a joke. It actually doesn't matter what I do as a Watcher. Why even have the game in the first place? Why not start the game with Eothas breaking the wheel, and the Watcher is now instrumental in both getting revenge on Eothas for breaking his castle, and liberating all of Eora with the truth about the Gods?

- None of the Gods are likeable or worthy of caring about. You can tell them to fuck off, but then they just kill you outright. So you are locked into doing Berath's pet chores which leads me not to care about the main quest. So I go off and do the side quests for all other dudes who are not really worth of my time either? Very odd choices here.

- Weapons are a mess. Hope you specialize in swords or sabres! Wait, that doesn't matter either because using modals is kinda pointless too. Where are the quests to get a very powerful weapon or item? This is a mainstay in rpgs. There is nothing in this game "building" towards something. In POE1 I was always enchanting and looking to upgrade my gear. Here , it doesn't matter. It all goes back to combat being done poorly.

- Where are the dungeons? I was going to sail island to island exploring the high seas, but once I realized every island was more or less the same (even graphically) I just beelined to the ending quest.

Verdict: To sum it up: Why care ? Your choices don't matter to the big story. Your ship doesn't need to be upgraded. Your party can win fights automatically. All the factions are only out for themselves. Eothas will do whatever he wants. Was the point of the game just to have an RPG as a pirate? To set up for POE3?

I loved this game up until after about 10 hours of playing. Then I went ahead and beat it for the story. Now i'm replaying it, but finding a hard time caring at all. As a huge fan of POE1 (over 500 hours in it), it is disappointing. Maybe I will do a murder hobo run (POTD + Trial of Iron) for fun. I dunno. Everything in this one seems out of place and jarring.


r/projecteternity • • Sep 22 '23

Companion spoilers In a way Grieving Mother is ethically worse than Durance.

7 Upvotes

I guess this post will pretty much all be a spoiler so I will just use the spoiler tag for the whole thing.

Spoiler

I love how both characters have more depth to them than is apparent when you first interact with them.