My kids are 8m, 6f and 4f.
My 6 year old recently joined a girl scout troop after we let her quit karate (2 year in) and soccer (she only lasted a few months. She is also in an Irish dance class now with my 4 year old.
My son does karate 2x-3x a week, soccer 1x-2x a week fall and spring. Karate is year round. He literally wants participate in every sport/event he sees/hears or reads about. Now he sees how much his little sister is having (they went to a fire house today) and wants to do it too. He hears me tell the 4 year old she can join Girl Scouts next year. I told him we can look into Scouting next year for him...he told me he wants one with only boys when I said our local troop is run by 6 years friend's parents...the friend is a girl. Im trying to explain sexism, misogyny etc but...ugh hes 8. I understand where hes coming from, but am having trouble articulating why we need girls spaces 😑. Any suggestions?
Some clarification since this blew up:
He has boys only spaces: soccer. I dont object to single-gender spaces, as I think theyre necessary and foster healthy development if theyre a healthy space. (Ie LGBTQIA allies, everyone has emotions and we need to handle them in a healthy way etc)
We are not putting him in another activity this year, he already partipates in 2.
I wanted to use this as an opportunity to discuss why the BSA no longer is single gender due to some of the troops becoming an unhealthy space, leadership not taking it seriously and the resulting lawsuits bankrupted them and they need to accept everyone now due to finances. Perhaps have another discussion on how long women were excluded from schools and employment.
No, im not trying to give him a whole history lesson, but I like to take opportunities where I can to raise my kids with "progressive" values (why I posted here and not in general parenting groups)
The issue is he sees his sister get to hang out with THEIR 3 mutual friends at girl scouts and hes not allowed. The girls in GSA are also closer in age to him. (9/10 year olds), since we are in a semi-rural area and we dont have enough kids. Shes actually a daisy in a brownie group. He is friends with them too...he's in karate class with one and the other two (sisters) are family friends we've known for years and taught him how to play Mario kart.
He asked to join cub scouts and said he wanted an all boys group but due to living in a rural area, the only local troop here is run by my 6 year olds friend's parents with both girls and boys. Mostly girls. The kids we know in it are my 6 year olds friends, none of his. He wants to be with his friends...who are in soccer which he is in. I dont think any of his friends are in scouts. He just heard "my sister gets to do both groups, with friends, i only have access to one group and their her friends." Not much I can do about it.
I am NOT pulling my daughter out of girl scouts, she is finally enthusiastically participating in a group activity and I am not taking that from her.
Again, I wanted insight on how to help educate my son on why Scouting is the way it is (both genders), why Girls Scouts is for girls and why sometimes adults do their best to help everyone but equity isnt always equality.