r/progressive_islam • • Jul 18 '25

Opinion 🤔 There’s no way the hijabis on the internet actually like wearing hijab

8 Upvotes

I keep seeing all these posts and reels where hijabis are like “my hijab is my crown,” “I feel so empowered wearing it,” etc., and I can’t help but raise an eyebrow.

Like…really? You mean to tell me that in the middle of summer, with your scalp sweating and neck suffocating, you’re genuinely enjoying that? That you don’t ever feel annoyed, restricted, or just wish you could let your hair breathe for once?

I’m not trying to attack anyone’s faith or personal choice—but the way hijab is romanticized online sometimes feels performative. It’s okay to say it’s hard. It’s okay to say it’s a struggle. Not everything has to be polished into some poetic “crown of dignity” metaphor. Because let’s be real: if it were truly that easy and empowering 24/7, we wouldn’t see so many women quietly taking it off.

Anyone else feel this way or am I just being cynical?


r/progressive_islam • • Sep 12 '22

Rant/Vent 🤬 just a little rant about this community

1 Upvotes

I came to r/progressive_islam for comfort from r/Islam that was so harsh and extreme. But you have failed me. Y'all can get extreme as well. Some of you are so "progressive" it's not even progressive Islam anymore it's straight up not Islam. I think some of you didn't like the judgment and strict rules and decided to use the term "progressive" as an excuse not to follow rules and do whatever your heart desires. How did we go from "you won't go to hell if you hold your bfs hand" to "it's ok to have sex before marriage, no one waits for marriage anyway". Y'all can't just ignore major Islam rules. Alcohol is haram, pork is haram, sex before marriage is haram (in any shape or form, even oral or touching), wearing super tight clothes and then putting a scarf on isn't Hijab. Having your hair out with a scarf isn't Hijab. Sinning and then repenting to "have a fresh start" with a plan to sin again isn't repentance. Modern age isn't an excuse for this behaviour, Islam is Islam, we can't not follow rules because "it's 21 century". We shouldn't be extreme in either way.


r/progressive_islam • • Oct 29 '24

Video 🎥 To the people voting for Killer Kamala who told me I’m “wasting my vote” by not falling for the two party trap

0 Upvotes

Hope this enlightens someone today and educates you a little more on how politics work. Just like our government we need to start playing chess not checkers. The girl who reposted is a (married) progressive Muslim influencer so no worries about the name showing.


r/progressive_islam • • Apr 29 '26

Question/Discussion ❔ The war on the hijab and its enduring wisdom

1 Upvotes

Reading through the posts in this sub and the disagreements about hijab, I wanted to share this wisdom someone shared with me.

The wisdom of the hijab is enduring. In today‘s world where capitalism shapes every aspect of our living, the hijab sets a clear boundary. Where attention is increasingly monetised and women’s bodies has been turned into content, branding, and commercial value, the hijab serves as a protection against reducing women to visual commodities.

It helps resist systems that incentivise sexualisation for profit or visibility, and instead redirects worth toward character, intellect, and conduct rather than appearance.


r/progressive_islam • • Nov 06 '23

Rant/Vent 🤬 It deeply saddens me how this war is confirming so many Muslims' biases against the West

0 Upvotes

Nevertheless, I am grateful for all the people voicing their disagreement with the government's stance, and my heart goes out to all the victims.


r/progressive_islam • • May 19 '25

Question/Discussion ❔ I am an exmuslim atheist. AMA

2 Upvotes

Given what I have seen in this sub, many of my views would be considered extremely controversial here. Nonetheless, I hope we can have a civil conversation.


r/progressive_islam • • Apr 07 '23

Question/Discussion ❔ There is a serious problem with some progressive people distorting the Quran severely to push a Liberal agenda

0 Upvotes

I am a Quranist, and I see a lot of this with Quranists and progressive Muslims in general. People promoting LGBT and distorting the Quran to promote Western Liberal values. I think this is a serious problem and gives ammunition to Salafis etc to label us as deviants, because it's sad to say, but in many cases they are right, and then we all get painted with the same brush.

Should we be progressive? Yes. But what should we progress towards? The Quran and the values it teaches us. NOT Western Liberal values. It does not have to be one extreme or the other.

Just because I don't support death penalty for homosexuals does not mean I promote tolerance for deviance.

Just because I believe there is no compulsion in religion and that apostates shouldn't be killed does not mean that people should be able to go around teaching evil values to children in the name of freedom.

Just because I believe that stoning adulterers to death is a corruption promulgated through hadiths does not mean I support open fornication and sex outside marriage.

Just because I don't believe hijab is mandatory does not mean I support women walking around with their breasts and backsides hanging out.

We MUST progress towards the values of the Quran, NOT towards liberalism.

Let me know your opinions in the comments.


r/progressive_islam • • Sep 29 '23

Advice/Help 🥺 Praying is cringe

2 Upvotes

Hello, I really have a problem. I kinda have the feeling of cringe while praying or when others do it, especially praying out loudly. Does someone have this problem too? I feel so awful for feeling this kind of way, but I can‘t help it. It makes me feel uncomfortable when whispering duas.. it‘s embarassing idk. How to get rid of this feeling?


r/progressive_islam • • Feb 17 '24

Question/Discussion ❔ SOMEONE PLEASE RESTORE MY FAITH IN YOU GUYS!

1 Upvotes

First of all i am jordanian and i live in jordan. the palestine issue impacts me deeply.

i Just saw this post (about if what hamas did was right), and i was completely dumb founded to see that only around 5 comments of the 200 said that killing civilians on oct 7th is wrong. half of them avoided the whole topic and talked about the IDF, and the other half denied it when there are literal go-pro footage of hamas throwing grenades into safe houses, shooting indiscriminately into music festivals, standing on trucks shooting at people running away including a person with a child in their arms, and footage of civilan bodies on the street with burned cars. even if you do not believe israel's numbers that most of the casualties are civilians ,including many children, you can not deny the footage. Some even supported hamas wholeheartedly.

Obviously we all know that a bigger blame lies on israel, and the civilian casualties in gaza are much higher and gaza footage haunts me just as much, but why cant you just say october 7th was bad too and move on and talk about the bigger issue. like every sane person would do. like bassam yusuf and Bargouti and many others ,including even hamas leaders abroad saying that civilian attacks were not planned and it was a spur of the moment decision on the part of the troops on the ground.

There was no reason for killing civilians whatsoever. it sent back a solution to palestine for another 100 years. and is a stamp of shame on my whole region that oct 7th has such wide support. i cant stop thinking what if hamas did not target civilians and only attacked IDF, how much closer would we be to peace. i try not to blame gazans for supporting such acts like oct 7th in the polls, since they are not very educated and have been suffering for a long time. and people in my country, jordan, have been brought up to think israelis are devils. but for people like you i just cant rap my head around it. please restore my faith in humanity and in muslims.

honestly i really enjoyed this community for a long time and i like that it prides itself on having civil conversations and sharing different points of view. it is an example that i can point to when i am tempted to fall in the trap of categorizing people based on their faith, despite my surroundings. but apparently group-think doesn't escape even the most progressive. i hope this doesn't get taken down or archived like everywhere else.

btw if you are american please vote for Biden, but keep the pressure on. Trump is way worse.


r/progressive_islam • • Nov 16 '22

Opinion 🤔 The title of the sub is very problematic

0 Upvotes

As the title says. Progressive Islam implies there is a type of Islam that is not progressive. Horrible branding for the religion.

On top of that, using a qualifier before the word Islam is also a great sin in my mind. Islam is beautiful and perfect as Allah created it. We don’t need to add any qualifications to legitimize it or play the role of apologetics.

I am way more in favor of the sub being called Progressive Muslims!! That makes more sense and is respectful of the divinity and sanctity of Islam as bestowed by Allah upon all his creation, while also distinguishing the attitudes of this sub vs some barbarian Muslim attitudes that are rampant nowadays

Would love to hear y’all’s opinions


r/progressive_islam • • Aug 05 '20

This is King Abdullah II with his family, the king of Jordan. He belongs to the Hashemite Dynasty, he is a descendant of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh), shares his bloodline. Did you notice that none of his family members wear hijab? & he doesn’t make them wear hijab? Makes you wounder, huh? Hmm...

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/progressive_islam • • Apr 23 '25

Opinion 🤔 Controversial take: Muslim men should befriend females

0 Upvotes

I am not entering here on the discussion whether it is halal or haram, but let's be honest, it is the lesser of two evils.

I notice many muslims living in muslim countries end up having homo feelings, and I think the cause of this is no contact with women. And many muslim men also end up watching haram, or having very bad view of women, it is not benefitting anyone. I think the best way to solve this problem is by friendship between muslim men and women, as long as it is not khalwa (complete isolation in closed doors) I do not think it is such a problem. The meetings could be in front of family members or in public spaces like coffee shops or libraries. Not talking to females caused more harm than good in practice, we need to acknowledge that.


r/progressive_islam • • Mar 09 '24

Question/Discussion ❔ Keeping Biden out of the White House

2 Upvotes

I think of myself as progressive. I supported and phone-banked for Biden in the previous election. But now I feel betrayed. I am disappointed that he let the massacre in Gaza fold out in daylight despite the overwhelming outcry of progressive Americans. It is even sadder that he is unwilling to accept his mistake and continues to send bombs+free money that will fuel more violence. Over 30K people (most children) have died and this man continues to repeat his words.
I want to contribute to (donate, phone bank, etc) any pro-peace organizations/groups to ensure that Biden (and all the Democrats who supported him) don't get re-elected. Anything you'd recommend?


r/progressive_islam • • Jan 16 '26

Question/Discussion ❔ Regarding Muhammad and Mariyam

0 Upvotes

Muhammad took Mariyam as a gift and made her his concubine. He then proceeded to have sex with her even though he had a wife. I know that sex with a concubine or slave was allowed, but however , it specifically says it is better to free the a slave. My question is this: why did Muhammad continue to have sex with Mariyam knowing how his wife felt about it? What did he have to lose by just abstaining and protecting her? Moreover, why didn’t God take this chance to abolish sex with slaves, as it is morally wrong? You would think that the prophet Muhammad would be wise and emotionally aware enough not to hurt his wife when he could see the pain caused, and blindly submit to desire.


r/progressive_islam • • Jul 12 '25

Question/Discussion ❔ Nikah is not a Marriage nor a legal term!

0 Upvotes

I am sick of seeing marriage having 50 threads on every Muslim social, it's depressing

I like to inform everyone that Nikah is not a legal term (That is aqda nikah not mentioned in quran but fiqh books), nor does it have anything to do with marriage/s-x. Nikah is not a legal term nor marriage, it means contract or to make ties, or commit to someone/something.

>but if Nikah is not marriage why is there mahr?

There is no mahr in the Quran, the idea of mahr does not come from Quran but fiqh books. The word here is sadaqat, which is chartable due for vulnerable people, not to bride women.

Sura 4:4 - "Bring the Nisaa' their Sadaqat..."

Sura 9:60 - "Sadaqat is only for the poor, the needy, workers upon it, reconciled hearts..."

As we can see "sadaqat" in 4:4 got nothing to do with dowry nor mahr not linguistically and not in the context of the Quran. T


r/progressive_islam • • Feb 04 '24

Rant/Vent 🤬 The two reasons I turn away from Islam

6 Upvotes

Ok so two of my major reasons why I stay away from Islam is: 1. Ali Dawah and Mohammad Hijab. These two are the most rude, disrespectful, bigoted, egotistical ,self riches, and hypocritical people I have ever seen, and I know you can’t judge a religion based on its followers. But these 2 are just the worse. They verbally assault people online, spread this message and don’t follow it (only when it supports them), one literally challenged people to boxing because he can’t use words to defend himself when he’s at fault, and when you want to debate them they back down and said your scared of them. They are the Andrew Tate and Kanye West of Islam.

2. Sharia Law. Ok so I am a Christian and I understand that some people want laws that come from holy books, that’s fine. But the way Muslims push this is insane, it’s like they want to overthrow a government, and when countries have it women suffer the most and the men get all the benefits. So to me it seems like Sharia Law is egalitarian at all and divides people base on race, religion, and ethnicity. I also understand that some countries have varying degrees of Sharia Law, but I feel like it would decide us further. As a Christian I don’t want the Bible as law because of the problems above. I want a law that egalitarian and not one that pushes up people of a religion or men.


r/progressive_islam • • Sep 28 '25

Question/Discussion ❔ As an ex-muslim. I think progressive Islam is still better than mainstream one.

1 Upvotes

Disclaimer: This is not a promotion of any sorts. I'm just sharing my personal perspective, I don't appreciate being harrassed.

I've found this sub reddit on my feed, and I'm looking geniunely trying to see the views of progressive muslims as an ex-muslim but, and this might sound offensive I apologize, it just feels PERSONALLY like it's a desperate attempt to make sth that wasn't meant to work work out. It makes no sense. It feels as if it comes from the muslims who want to protect their cultural identity or are scared of the fear-mongering around hell despite the disconnect from their own inner moral compasses, or maybe they retain having this rose-tinted image of Islam in their heads because that's how I felt the more I studied mainstream Islam, shifting into more progressive shoes, but it was still not making any sense fundamentally.

(Edit: honestly, that might've sounded like an insult to all of the effort progressive muslims have been putting towards why and how they believe what they do, I'm really sorry for how this part has come across as, I am in no way smarter than people for leaving Islam, in fact I'm intrigued by how they've come to these views and the effort they've dedicated to examine and study their religion, even if I'm no longer convinced of Islam as a whole. I apologize for how offensive this has come across, I should've made it clear that part was def me projecting from my personal experience as someone who used to be a muslim and my personal experiences with some progressive ones, but it defined doesn't reflect progressive muslims as a whole.)

Of course, that may not speak to all of you, for all I know you could geniunely be seeing something progressive in Islam that makes sense to you which I'm not convinced of and that's okay.

I'll continue to see more of the opinions on this sub, mainly because I'm interested in what progressive muslims think about Islam and how they view it, but it's just reminding me of the cognitive dissonance I had and the hypocrisy I felt when I was trying to be a progressive muslim as a substitute in the past.

My heart goes out to all of you. I don't mean to sound condescending, though this might come across that way but seriously. I feel for all of you because I was there, and it was tough for me deconstructing a life-long indoctrination I've had.

That being said a progressive Muslim is still way better than your typical (not as moderate as you'd think) "moderate" muslims or conservative ones.

One thing I might share in common with a lot of you is my disdain for dogma and the suppression of critical thinking skills (without the fear of questioning that this might be wrong I don't know how critical one can think about something). I hope I'd get to see more and more progressive muslim representation out there, I feel y'all deserve to be heard too, same for my perspective, as ex-muslims rarely get any representation, and if they did it's always rather dismissive.

Throughout my ongoing studies, I've come to hate Islam and organized religions, I view them as dangerous in nature because of how much influence they have over people, and how dangerous interpretation and dogma can be, I believe Islam like all the other organized religions must be held to critique and scrutiny without people coming after you to attack, not to mention how illogical a lot of it is (to me), HOWEVER and I want to make it very clear, that doesn't mean I hate muslims... Etc), I respect their rights to believe what they want as long as it's not taking away freedoms from other people (which sadly I find that to be the case in a lot of conservative communities), and that gives no one the right to harrass them or discriminate against them.

Anyway, I just wanted to say regardless of whether you've left Islam or you've geniunely found that progressive Islam makes sense to you, I'm proud of you for trying to think for yourself, please don't let anyone take that away from you.


r/progressive_islam • • Jul 29 '26

Question/Discussion ❔ The Abdul ballout case

Post image
1 Upvotes

I remember seeing a comment made a few days ago saying he was a mossad plant to aggravate islamophobic attacks, do you think this is legit?


r/progressive_islam • • Apr 22 '24

Question/Discussion ❔ How do I “cope” exactly with the fact that the Prophet Muhammad was most likely a pedophile?

7 Upvotes

It’s constantly brought up for me, online, in person, in my own head. I’ve tried looking for answers but almost everything points to him being a pedophile. Even the ones that say “he might not have been!” Are extremely debatable and not definitive at all. Does this mean Allah doesn’t condone pedophilia? I know people in my life who’ve been victims of child predators, rapists, groomers, etc. Are they gonna spend the afterlife with them? Hell, Islam isn’t exactly the most moral religion, especially by our standards today. How many people who we think are horrible, the worst of the worst, are going to Jannah?


r/progressive_islam • • Nov 04 '23

Research/ Effort Post 📝 I'm an ex-muslim

6 Upvotes

What's up guys, I'm new here, just joined this sub.

I'm a non-hostile, non-hating, non-bigot ex-muslims who likes to talk with any of you 👍🏽

Have any questions regarding me leaving this religion? Feel free to ask. But please, don't be a bigot towards me just because I'm not one of you no more.

In case some of you say this:

  1. I WAS in fact a devout believer.

  2. There are no rak'as in wudhu, rak'as are the amount of times you go up and down during prayer and wudhu is pouring some water to your body before prayer.

  3. There are no rak'as in Suurat Al-Faatiha, a surah has verses but not rak'as

  4. I didn't leave Islam because of "emotional reasons"

  5. I've read the Qur'an and hadiiths, I also read the tafseers

  6. I didn't have "misunderstandings", I just found some logical inconsistencies with the religion and the people trying to justify it


r/progressive_islam • • Jul 03 '25

Question/Discussion ❔ Muslims need to chill on the alcohol taboo

0 Upvotes

Ibn Battuta, the famous medieval Muslim traveller, narrated how he accidentally drank alcoholic beer with fellow Muslims during his travels, when he was in Turkey. This happened because the local people followed the Hanafi school of thought, which allowed grain-based alcohol, while Ibn Battuta's Maliki school forbade all alcoholic beverages. In his own words, "When I went out I made enquiry about it and they said 'It is nabidh [a fermented drink] which they make from dugi grain.' These people are Hanafis and nabidh is permissible according to their doctrine."

The Qur'an uses the word "Khamr" for prohibited alcoholic beverages. According to some early scholars like Abu Hanifa, "Khamr" literally means wine made of grapes or dates, and does not include not all other drinks. According to Abu Hanifa, alcoholic beverages made from honey, figs, wheat, maize or barley are permissible if consumed below the point of intoxication. Later Hanafi scholars eventually abrogated Abu Hanifa's ruling and adopted a general prohibition of all alcoholic beverages, most likely due to pressure from other schools of jurisprudence.

The early Kufan Hanafi jurist Ibrâhîm al-Nakha'î (d. 96/715-6) asserts that the public has misinterpreted the Prophet's statement that drinks "that intoxicate in large quantities are forbidden in small quantities" (i.e., the 'large/small' tradition)." Ibrahim explains that the Prophet meant to forbid intoxication rather than intoxicants.

The prominent Maliki jurist Ibn Rushd al-Jadd (d. 520/1126) states that "Khamr is that which intoxicates and overwhelms the intellect". There is a controversial and disputed narration, wherein the Prophet instructs Abu Musa to "drink but do not become Intoxicated". (Ibn Rushd al-Hafid, Bidaya, 2:914)

It is also well known that the famous Muslim philosopher and physician Ibn Sina (Avicenna) would often drink wine. He acknowledged the health benefits of drinking wine in moderation.

It is often claimed that Ottoman sultan-caliph Abdülhamid II would occasionally and privately savor a glass of cognac at his doctors’ orders.

A few years ago, a prominent Qatar-based Muslim scholar, Yousuf Al Qaradawi declared:

“An alcohol volume of up to 5/1000 or 0.5% in a drink has no significance in making it haram [prohibited]. It is a very small quantity, especially if it results from natural fermentation and is not manufactured."

Considering the totality of facts and arguments, I would say that the strict level of taboo and prohibition that today Islamic scholars have imposed upon the Muslims was not always the case historically.

Let me know what you guys think.

Please refer to:

  1. 'Angels Tapping at the Wine-shop's Door: A History of Alcohol in the Islamic World' by Rudi Matthee.

  2. Haider, N. (2013). Contesting intoxication: Early juristic debates over the lawfulness of alcoholic beverages. Islamic L. & Soc'y, 20, 48.

  3. 'The Odyssey of Ibn Battuta: Uncommon Tales of a Medieval Adventurer', by David Waines


r/progressive_islam • • Aug 31 '24

Opinion 🤔 I respect progressive Islam, and I respect the knowledgeable people who are progressive Muslims but…

1 Upvotes

I feel like the majority of the so called “progressive Muslims” take this route just so they can justify their weak faith.

Help me out here if you think I’m wrong.


r/progressive_islam • • Sep 28 '22

Opinion 🤔 As an Iranian Muslim, more and more I feel that in today's political climate, wearing a hijab is callous, selfish, and insensitive to those women who are forced to wear it against their will.

12 Upvotes

I posted this in another "Muslim" subreddit. I was quickly bombarded by comments asking me to quote "scholars" to back up my opinion and was banned from the subreddit for calling for civility. I am glad I found this subreddit, because it seems every Muslim community on reddit is full of angry, vicious, individuals who have no idea how to interact with other human beings

As we all know, it is important to be sensitive to the suffering of our fellow human beings. If you haven't kept up with the news, in my beloved Iran women are literally being beaten to death by religious police for not adhering to their proscribed dress code, which includes wearing a hijab. One can say, that this is a failing of the government of the Islamic Republic of Iran--which it is--but when the hijab has transformed from a show of modesty to a form of oppression, it is I feel our duty as Muslims to be cognizant of this oppression and think about how we are expressing ourselves.

Many Muslims express dislike and even hatred for Israel for their treatment of the Palestinian people. Why? Not because their suffering affects us directly, but because we are taught to be aware of empathetic towards the suffering of others, especially our brothers in sisters in faith. So why is a hijab any different?

More and more, when I see a woman wearing a hijab, I want to ask them if they realize there are 100s of millions of women around the world who are being forced to wear it against their will, and if the suffering of those women means nothing to them. I want to ask them if they, by continuing to wear a hijab, are expressing their support for such an institution? Or if they are doing it for purely personal reasons? I'm not dense--I'm well aware 99% are doing it for the latter. But then where does one distinguish between self-piety, and selfishness? Is an article of clothing--which is not mandatory in Islam as long as one remains modest in appearance--more important than the suffering of your fellow human being? How can one look at the picture of a dead Mahsa Amini and not feel anything? That this article of clothing, a hijab, has become more important in the eyes of many "Muslims" than the life of a beautiful young girl? How can one continue to support such an institution, regardless of whether or not one personally has the choice?

I leave you with the famous excepert, Bani Adam by Sa'adi, one of great Iranian and Muslim poets:

بنی‌آدم اعضای یک دیگرند
که در آفرينش ز یک گوهرند
چو عضوى به‌درد آورَد روزگار
دگر عضوها را نمانَد قرار
تو کز محنت دیگران بی‌غمی

"Adam's children are limbs of one body
That in creation are made of one gem.
When life and time hurt a limb,
Other limbs will not be at ease.
You who are not sad for the suffering of others,
Do not deserve to be called human."

r/progressive_islam • • Jun 25 '25

Rant/Vent 🤬 rant over some atheists on this sub

0 Upvotes

I have been on this sub for few weeks and already read many upsetting posts from atheist persons.

So I want to give my think piece.

I find such arrogance in the idea that nothing matters, we should all be free from religion, it's man made to control the masses, you must be brainwashed, religion only appeals to the poor and uneducated, how can you believe in something you have no proof of, if there is a God why is he so cruel blahblah.

To me, this is parroting a very capitalist, individualist, racist occidental rooted ideology. And to see and hear descendants of migrants agree with this break my heart.

You will never be free from religion. There is no place on this Earth that wasn't influenced by religion. Dignity, humility, forgiveness, charity, justice, equality within humankind, ... all the things you call "good morals" come from religion. It's not something you were born with, you were taught how to behave the same way your parents were. Not to kill, rape, steal, curse, lie,... all religious commandments. The laws you are following are religiously based, the government you are fearing in case of punishment is religiously based, the court you call for when in trouble is religiously based, the idolization for people in power is religiously based. You are not escaping religion whether you believe in Paradise or not.

To spit on religion is to spit on the beauty that came with it. Architecture, literature, philosophy, science, the people who contributed to all of this were not religious because they had to. They had true love and faith in God, regardless of the religion they followed. So many highly intelligent thinkers were religious. To say rich people are mostly not religious and most educated people are rich, … confirmation bias. Purely west propaganda, not taking into account colonization, wars, soft power, education system being destroyed by the government in place.

If religion is man made and shouldn’t have existed, why call for a community, to protect yourself from being drunk, smoking and killing your lungs, avoiding meat that can contain parasites, to not commit adultery, to wash yourself regularly, not be in debts and all the other things I already mentioned. HUGE pivoting moments were religious revelations, helped so much with our social evolution.

You could never claim religions are like cults, where one person abuses others. God is not even a person and we are told not to only feel love and respect for Him, but for humans as well.

All the structures abusing children, guilt tripping, gaining lots of money,… they’re all anti religious by essence. Corruption can be found in religious or non religious sectors.

God is not cruel and He isn’t human. Doesn’t think like one. So there’s no point in holding Him to human standards.

We have many interpretations because there is no test with given answers, we were made with good and bad sides because there is no test with only one answer. Choices, free will, there are gifts, allowing us to learn and do better. Yes it is sad to see people dying or birthed in sickness or poverty. But would you blame your teacher for giving everyone the same test although we don’t have the same capacities or time management? If you ask them to re evaluate your grades based on whatever was going on in your life, he might give you extra points but you won’t pass the test anyway if that’s not enough. What separates the human teacher from God is being the most merciful, the wisest and the one who knows the absolute truth. How can you hate that idea?

There are so much more things to say, but I’ve already written to much. I don’t care for atheism, if you don’t believe in God so be it. If you want to criticize a person jeopardizing religion to oppress others then do it. But being anti-religious or coming on this sub-Reddit, made for/by Muslims, to be patronizing is useless.


r/progressive_islam • • Aug 03 '26

Opinion 🤔 I really don’t understand the “you don’t need Hadiths to pray/prayer was passed down via tradition”, from some users in this subreddit and r/Quraniyoon.

0 Upvotes

Never understood it AT ALL. This claim that "you don't need hadith to pray.” is crazy to me.

Yes, it's true that most Muslims don't physically have a hadith book open when they perform salah. We usually learn to pray from our parents, our local mosque, a teacher, or nowadays from videos online.

But that's missing the point.

The question should not be "Where did you personally learn to pray?" The two questions should be:

"If all hadith and inherited practice disappeared tomorrow, could someone reconstruct the five daily prayers from the Qur'an alone?"

“How do we verify that the communal practice being passed down is actually the practice of the Messenger of Allah (SAWW), rather than a later development? 

The Qur'an repeatedly commands believers to establish the prayer:

However, the Qur'an does not provide a complete practical manual for performing salah. It does not explicitly tell us:

  • How many rak'ahs each obligatory prayer contains.

  • What is recited in every position.

  • The wording of the opening takbīr.

  • The tashahhud.

  • The taslīm ending the prayer.

  • Many other practical details that every Muslim performs daily.

If the Qur'an alone were intended to be a complete instruction manual for the mechanics of prayer, then what would prevent someone from claiming that standing, bowing, and prostrating while simply repeating “Astaghfirullāh" throughout each position counts as a valid ṣalāh?

The Qur'an certainly tells us to stand, bow and prostrate, but it doesn't specify what must be said in each position or the sequence in the level of detail Muslims actually practise.

This is precisely where the Sunnah comes in.

The Qur'an itself instructs Muslims to obey and follow the Messenger:

Imam Ja’far as-Sadiq (AS) himself said:

The Prophet (SAWW) himself said:

That instruction only makes sense if his method of prayer was meant to be preserved and transmitted.

Likewise, during the Farewell Pilgrimage according to Sunni ahadith he said:

Again, the Prophet did not simply leave people with the Qur'an and expect every ritual detail to be independently derived. Every Messenger had to teach his Sunnah to his loyal companions.

This is why hadith matter.

It's not because Muslims recite hadith during prayer.

It's because we as Muslims (or the vast majority of this Ummah) believe hadith preserve how the Prophet (SAWW) implemented the Qur'anic command to establish prayer.

When someone teaches a new Muslim how to pray today, they're ultimately teaching a form of prayer whose words and actions are traced back through reports describing the Prophet's practice whether that is the opening takbīr, the recitation, the bowing, the prostration, the tashahhud, or the taslīm.

Without that transmitted Prophetic practice, there would be no objective way to distinguish between the prayer taught by the Messenger (SAWW) and any number of sincere but invented methods.

The Qur'an commands us to establish prayer.

The Sunnah explains how the Messenger established it.

;
Once again, if we do not need hadith to pray, could one just say astaghfirullah x3 in qiyam, ruku, juloos and sujud. And then call it a day and that is salah?