r/programming • • Jul 17 '22

Create decentralized applications with JavaScript, HTML and CSS

https://gridnet.org/wpp/index.php/2022/07/12/create-ui-dapps-right-now-developer-guide/
122 Upvotes

159 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/0s_and_1s Jul 18 '22 edited Jul 18 '22

Let’s be clear, I can still host a website on your decentralised network and still use Google Analytics. You’re talking about privacy but you’re not going to do anything to enforce I’m not scraping the users details or siphoning off their data and further you’re forcing users to use Chrome the same company you mention above as selling our privacy.

The same Andreessen Horowitz that invested in Facebook? Lol I’m sure he’s investing in blockchain to undo his bad karma /s

-3

u/rafalsk Jul 18 '22

Hint: those interested further in this very topic may want to follow conversation (with same person over here).

Yet again, you may choose to incorporate any code you wish into your app, including Google Analytics.

You need to keep in mind though, that the app review process (which is decentralized) would certainly not assign a high rating to your app.

It would mostly likely assign a SCAM label, instead.

Then, it is up to users whether they want to use your app, with such a label.

Thank you for your comment and awaiting further questions.

3

u/0s_and_1s Jul 18 '22

You said your review process is optional, a manual process and no guarantee it will catch anything as you can’t guarantee the experience of the user doing the review, it’s anonymous after all but even so like I said it’s optional so I can use whatever tracking I like and bypass the review process altogether and then I’m on the store forever right?

If google is so bad for user privacy why do you force users to use only chrome?

1

u/rafalsk Jul 18 '22
  1. The review process not only is optional. Developers would need to pay to have the app reviewed, so there is an incentive for reviewers to carry out the work of reviewing the applications.

  2. how would the fact that of incorporate Google Analytics be supposed to bypass a review process would you kindly explain? The reviewer has access to your entire code package, hosted on the decentralized state-machine. Should your app reference external code, that would also be tacken into account.

  3. We do not assume reviewers to be perfect. Nor Apple nor Microsoft rely on such an assumption.

If google is so bad for user privacy why do you force users to use only chrome?

Yet again, we do not force anyone to do anything.

We just happen to be delivering best decentralized technology to developers, for free.

We employ a steady deployment process to assure best user experience and we chose Chromium engine as the first step since 1) it is open source 2) it offers best functionality coverage on the market (of web-browsers).

2

u/0s_and_1s Jul 18 '22

You pay the first time or for every update? So I create a 50k line code change how much will the user get paid? Just because someone gets money doesn’t mean they will do the job competently, it’s anonymous review after all. If all I did was tick approve and say yes it’s all good what are the repercussions? What if I missed something are you going to take my payment away? Of course not because theirs nothing you can do. Whether I spend two days looking at it or five minutes I’ll get paid the same so the incentive is for me to just approve and get my money

1

u/rafalsk Jul 18 '22

You pay the first time or for every update?

For every update, you want your app to wield the 'reviewed' label.

Just because someone gets money doesn’t mean they will do the job competently

of course, same with Apple, same with Google.

it’s anonymous review after all.

It is anonymous but each review is assigned to an identity, which has 'real' assets assigned. One would want to make a proper review.

If all I did was tick approve and say yes it’s all good what are the repercussions?

If your review score falls out too far away from a median of all of the reviews, your voting power would suffer, also your payment might not be released at all.

What if I missed something are you going to take my payment away?

yes. in short. proportionally to how far away from a median your score manages to fall.

Of course not because theirs nothing you can do.

Can you please explain?

Whether I spend two days looking at it or five minutes I’ll get paid the same so the incentive is for me to just approve and get my money

Yet again, kindly do not arrive at false assumptions to back your claims.

In the end, we all learn each and every day.

Looking forward to hearing back from you.

2

u/0s_and_1s Jul 18 '22

Is my assumption wrong? Will a user get paid more if it’s a bigger than than a one liner? Will they get paid per review or how many lines of code? The incentive if it’s the same cost per review regardless of size is to bunch all my code together right? This isn’t hard to understand. Do you have any commercial experience in the real world at all?

1

u/rafalsk Jul 18 '22

Will a user get paid more if it’s a bigger than than a one liner?

Then it is up to reviewers whether they agree to work for the fee you've proposed.

Reviewers may then choose to use any code-diffing utility to assess the particular case.

Do you have any commercial experience in the real world at all?

How is the question relevant?

→ More replies (0)