r/programming • u/tenbits • Jun 14 '20
GitHub to replace "master", "whitelist", "blacklist", and others with alternative terms to avoid slavery references
https://www.zdnet.com/article/github-to-replace-master-with-alternative-term-to-avoid-slavery-references/[removed] — view removed post
765
1.7k
u/_default_username Jun 14 '20
black engineers are paid significantly less than their white counterparts.
GitHub: we're removing the term master branch.
Thanks, brand.
562
Jun 15 '20
so much easier than actually doing something
61
u/zzzthelastuser Jun 15 '20
yeah, shit like this in fact contra productive as it kinda ridicules the real reasons for the protests.
Pay everyone equally based on their work instead of skin or gender for example. I doubt [brand] likes that idea though.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (4)72
u/ButItMightJustWork Jun 15 '20
Also this change can be seen by the public thus its a nice PR move.
→ More replies (3)279
u/rudedogg Jun 15 '20
GitHub: Also, we're keeping the ICE contract.
105
u/_default_username Jun 15 '20
Apparently Latino developers are the most underpaid demographic back in this study.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)43
u/empire314 Jun 15 '20
Its the same as this
https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/newsfeed/001/858/258/3bd.jpg
80
49
u/Endless-Edgar Jun 15 '20
black engineers are paid significantly less than their white counterparts.
Is that true? What are the stats on it?
→ More replies (34)→ More replies (27)139
u/cheekysauce Jun 15 '20
No one has ever been able to answer this for me.
Let's posit two things
there are groups of equally qualified and competent people, be it women, people of color, whatever distinction you like, and they are systemically paid less, and
businesses will seek to maximise profit, and should seek to hire an equivalent resource in terms of qualifications and experience, at the lowest possible cost.
If both of these are true, where are these businesses that are full of this cheap, underrepresented, equally qualified labor? If I was a business owner and I could hire underrepresented workers with the same output and at less cost, I'd be over the moon. They simply don't exist!
Either
a. there isn't a pay gap between groups, and businesses are hiring the best people for the job at market rates based on skills and experience, as they should be, or
b. businesses across the board are wasting money on equally valuable but more expensive labor to perpetuate racism and social prejudices
Which is it?
→ More replies (88)79
u/Skychronicles Jun 15 '20 edited Jun 15 '20
The hiring process is not completely rational
The study where you pick black names and white names and put them on the same curriculum and get a much lower callback rate for black people wouldn't make sense in a completely rational and profit driven hiring process.
https://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/minorities-who-whiten-job-resumes-get-more-interviews
https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/35823/1/584702035.pdf
One aspect of your reasoning I didn't touch is that for 2) to be true you actually would have to codify in some way that minorities should get paid less(not only happen to be paid less) which I think would be a PR and legal nightmare.
EDIT: pretty funny but here's an article from the Fed today: https://www.morningstar.com/news/dow-jones/202006142771/feds-kaplan-says-systemic-racism-holding-economy-back
There's a better article from the wall street journal but it's paywalled.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/feds-kaplan-says-systemic-racism-holding-economy-back-11592163431→ More replies (9)
705
u/mindbleach Jun 15 '20
Oh, come on. All computer terminology is stolen. It is necessarily divorced from its origins. We don't treat "avatars" as disrespectful to Hindu mythology, because that's not what the word means in this context.
This isn't even "master" versus "slave." It's a master copy. The derivatives are clones. So far as I know the word comes via archivists. It is knowledge passed from master to students. It refers to mastery of a profession or technique - kung fu, not KKK. (Though coincidentally, both have dragons.)
122
Jun 15 '20
In Spanish too. Maestro/Esclavo. The proper word for owner is "amo". Maestro has the context of teacher/or someone who mastered a skill or technique.
→ More replies (13)→ More replies (21)103
Jun 15 '20
Also, a lot of "woke" Americans don't realize a lot of words in Romances had their meaning a bit separate from the original Latin meaning.
Sinistra meant evilish/suspicious, but it also mean left (as in the position).
Or celda in Spanish. It means cell/room, but as the one in a jail. Also it means "slot", as probably means "cell" in English too. WIll they ban "cell" too?
→ More replies (2)
429
u/theLorknessMonster Jun 15 '20
Imagine how much developer time this will cost and then imagine if they had donated that money to a worthy cause.
205
Jun 15 '20
Dude imagine developer time worldwide to fix all the problems this will cause.
For example - any automation script that has
git push origin masterwill probably not be doing the right thing anymore for new repos.→ More replies (17)19
→ More replies (7)7
u/Rein215 Jun 15 '20
Imagine if they actually helped minorities, like pushing popular repositories that contain a front-end to increase accessibility for screen-readers.
→ More replies (1)
111
Jun 15 '20
My grandfather and his father were poor farmers in North India. They were regularly beaten by the British to grow indigo which ruined our lands. So I am not indifferent to the plight of slavery. I also suffered racism from bullies for being from a different state* when I went to school. I am not indifferent to racism. I fucking hate it.
However, I absolutely think is completely pointless. If somehow we assume that this did make an actual difference, I would be happily inconvenienced and make those changes.
But that is a big assumption to make.
I cannot understand why is anyone offended by this terminology.
It doesn't solve racism or the problem of qualified immunity.
Pretending racism/oppression doesn't exist by changing a few words here and there does nothing for no one. People have cited the reason that this term is rooted in privilege and oppression. So does by changing the word, does the privilege and oppression of those individuals vanish? Or does this mean that the people who use this word while writing scripts are privileged? If so, how? And assuming that they are, how will it remove that?
4)Who decides what words are offensive? Clearly there is no consensus amongst the people, unlike other words that are almost always used in a racist context. The lady cites anecdotal records as a good enough reason to change git, so without a clear vote by a large sample of people, you cannot claim to be the voice of the people.
5) On the other hand, you have the logistical issue of changing git fundamentally, I can safely say many are going to be against which the lady doesn't consider.
6) If I claim the word git offends me and get a small minority of people to support me, should git be removed?
7) Github hasn't stopped its partnership with ICE, so there is that.
However, I beg you, people, to keep the conversation civil and not harass anyone for their different opinions.
PS: (Not relevant to the whole message)
I am from a state called Bihar in India and I suffered a lot of ridicule when we moved to another state.
→ More replies (3)14
u/gossamerspectre Jun 15 '20
Actually in British English "git" is offensive. It is basically synonymous with "prick"
11
1.0k
u/LowerQuartile Jun 14 '20
What the hell does "whitelist" and "blacklist" have to do with slavery?
489
u/superherowithnopower Jun 14 '20
Nothing, whatsoever. "Black" meaning "bad" is from the 14th Century, and "blacklist" a 17th Century development based on the meaning "black" had had for 300 years by that point. "Black Bart," to give an even more recent use (19th Century), was not an outlaw of African descent, but was an Englishman.
Whitelist is just the inverse of a blacklist.
→ More replies (38)550
u/game-of-throwaways Jun 15 '20 edited Jun 15 '20
"Black" meaning "bad" goes back much much further, to the Persian empire as well as Confucianism (see for example Yin and Yang). It has nothing to do with skin color, just with the presence or absence of light. Darkness versus light. Night versus day. Children are afraid of the dark, and that has nothing to do with skin color. In the Oddysey (8th century BC) black was associated with death. In Sanskrit, the words for "black" and "death" are the same. To claim that the black/white duality is primarily about skin color is absurd.
In the academic "paper" - it's not a peer-reviewed paper just a commentary - that calls blacklist/whitelist racist terms, which OP's article links to, the only other link that they give between the term blacklist and racism is that the term originated around 1610, which happens to be somewhere in the (multiple-century) time period of mass enslavement and forced deportation of Africans. That's it, that's the only link between blacklist and racism.
Regardless of its origins, I think when the vast majority of people hear or read the term "blacklist", there is little association with the color black, and zero association with the skin color. It's just a term that people use as a whole, similar to how "breakfast" is made up of the words "break" and "fast" but nobody thinks of the word "breakfast" in this way.
→ More replies (20)391
Jun 14 '20
Probably a non-techie came across the terms and didn’t understand their meaning.
→ More replies (11)212
233
39
u/vantharion Jun 15 '20
Microsoft has internally discouraged the use of whitelist vs blacklist for a while now. I'm not surprised to see Github make this change.
→ More replies (5)60
→ More replies (148)15
u/acacia-club-road Jun 14 '20
They'll also need to check words in the music recording industry where master and slave finished products are available.
29
u/dermacol999 Jun 15 '20
Lmao cant believe it is real, sounds like a authright satire
Swear to god stupid shit like this makes people not support these movements
13
Jun 15 '20
You will be forced to support it or you will be fired. The establishment is pushing out this woke software update you must all run in order to function in reality - its a new religion.
→ More replies (2)
234
Jun 14 '20
so how do we call white hats and black hats now? what will happen to red-black trees?
163
76
45
u/green_meklar Jun 15 '20
what will happen to red-black trees?
They're now indigenous-american-african-american trees.
11
→ More replies (4)5
679
Jun 14 '20
LoOk wE'rE HeLpInG
184
Jun 15 '20 edited Jun 15 '20
Here at
$CORPORATIONwe really care about$CAUSE, so we did$TOKENGESTURE.33
33
u/AverageDegenerate Jun 15 '20
Here’s why you should feel $GOODEMOTION towards us at $FAMOUSCOMPANY for bringing about $SUPERFICIALCHANGE.
→ More replies (1)29
→ More replies (2)17
u/BackmarkerLife Jun 15 '20
I thought MS was done with adopt, extend, extinguish?
→ More replies (2)19
547
u/z1win Jun 14 '20
So next we need to remove the term Masters degree from all the universities as well...
At the same time, we should get rid of the letter k since there is little need for it.
96
u/lolwutpear Jun 15 '20
Anyone who has a master's degree needs to be blacklisted immediately like the racist scum that they are.
Oh no, did I say- AAAAHHHhhhhhhhh
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (16)112
Jun 14 '20
I don't like the old-fashioned term "master", either, but I kept it to avoid confusing my slaves. If GitHub introduces a new terminology that gets adopted, it would be great.
→ More replies (7)28
42
u/fufufang Jun 15 '20
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blacklisting#Origins_of_the_term
The English dramatist Philip Massinger used the phrase "black list" in his 1639 tragedy The Unnatural Combat.[3]
After the Restoration of the English monarchy brought Charles II of England to the throne in 1660, a list of regicides named those to be punished for the execution of his father.[4] The state papers of Charles II say "If any innocent soul be found in this black list, let him not be offended at me, but consider whether some mistaken principle or interest may not have misled him to vote".[5] In a 1676 history of the events leading up to the Restoration, James Heath (a supporter of Charles II) alleged that Parliament had passed an Act requiring the sale of estates, "And into this black list the Earl of Derby was now put, and other unfortunate Royalists".[6]
68
u/Jwosty Jun 15 '20 edited Jun 15 '20
I fail to understand how "whitelist" and "blacklist" are supporting racist concepts. Is it not drawn from color theory? In Western culture, we have other color connotations, like red meaning anger but also passion; green meaning life and virility; yellow meaning happiness and warmth; blue meaning sadness but also loyalty... and white meaning goodness and purity and black meaning death and power. Does this mean that anything using "red" in the terminology is somehow racist too because of the possible negative connotations and connections to race...? Or yellow? Or pick another color? Why do we have to keep automatically associating color terminology in words with race?
Was George Lucas racist when he used "the dark side" to represent evil? Was anyone of color actually oppressed by that symbolism?
Not to mention this doesn't really do much of anything for the actual cause in question in the grand scheme of things. Don't get me wrong, racism is bad, but what the heck does this whole word thing have to do with racism? First "master/slave", next "whitelist/blacklist", now "master branch...." (though I suppose there's more of an argument against "master/slave" than there is for the others) Where does it end? Pretty soon the list of forbidden words is going to outgrow the list of words we're allowed to use. A blacklist, if you will. It's a matter of time before someone comes up with a reason "main" is a racist word too.
9
503
387
u/MoreAlphabetSoup Jun 15 '20
Can we just start calling it dom/sub?
it's funny.
it's concise, less letters and syllables.
it makes you think of people clad in tight sexy leather outfits with slits to expose their genitals, which gives you a wide on or a half a chubby, depending on your gender.
it's clear, no one thinks the sub is driving the dom.
It doesn't offend anyone based on historical atrocities.
If it does offend doms, they can take it out on their subs, leading to juicier orgasms. If it offends subs, who fucking gives a fuck, they've been bad and need a spanking anyway.
It's 2020 why are we still talking about this? Crtl-f replace master with dom and slave with sub.
169
u/lolwutpear Jun 15 '20
Now you've been fired for sexual harassment instead of pseudo-racism.
→ More replies (2)45
u/MoreAlphabetSoup Jun 15 '20
Pseudo-sexual harassment, I can't get hard enough at work to properly sexually harass someone, I'm blowing way too much adderall.
→ More replies (1)46
→ More replies (8)6
37
184
u/Voidrith Jun 14 '20
who was even offended by it?
nobody.
Just another company wanting to look woke by solving a problem that doesn't exist
6
u/fukato Jun 15 '20
Someone on /r/factorio actually wants the dev to replace the "whitelist" and "blacklist" with something else. They do exist.
41
u/ISpendAllDayOnReddit Jun 15 '20
The company doesn't care either. There's just no one there willing to stand up to these mentally ill SJWs so companies let them do whatever they want.
11
Jun 15 '20
To be fair (barely) I've run my own company for a while, and customers can be a PITA and honestly it can be easier (as in cheaper/takes less time) to just do what they want than continue to push back.
→ More replies (8)0
Jun 15 '20
[deleted]
53
u/Martian_Maniac Jun 15 '20
So? People are offended about everything.. Especially SJWs. Cancel Culture.
→ More replies (2)13
Jun 15 '20
Plenty of white people anyways, meanwhile a number of Blacks commenting that this is absurd.
165
u/nayadelray Jun 14 '20
Where were you when the Cultural Revolution started? I was renaming my master branch on github #BLM
→ More replies (3)74
29
14
u/bless-you-mlud Jun 15 '20
I suppose "owner" and "chain" will be next. Best get rid of your cryptocurrency while you can!
28
46
Jun 15 '20
What a great move! In fact, why stop there?
No more Master's degree! Zelda's Master Sword should be renamed to Main Sword! All blackboards are now equalityboard! You no longer earn black belt, you earn race-neutral-color belt! McMaster University, how dare you hurt racial relation! Mastercard will now be renamed Maincard!
Whatever systemic racism exists in the US and beyond is not gonna be improved one little bit by this.
18
Jun 15 '20
You forgot to rename whiteboards.
→ More replies (1)28
u/currentlyatwork1234 Jun 15 '20 edited Jun 15 '20
They are called racistboards and you may not own one or you're a racist.
320
u/Caraes_Naur Jun 14 '20
This hyper-PC reactionism is stupid. These terms accurately and succinctly describe relational abstractions, not people.
Next they'll want to strip "owner" from OOP.
101
Jun 14 '20
What about getting rid of OOP altogether? /s
127
15
13
u/NilacTheGrim Jun 15 '20
OOP is full of terms that push the patriarchy's agenda. Inheritance & overriding are just two things the patriarchy does to further its power.
→ More replies (2)64
u/ChangingHats Jun 14 '20
Well don't forget they'd strip "object" and "oriented" and "programming" from OOP because we don't want to objectify the languages, nor the people who write them, we also don't want to commit micro-aggression against those who are "oriented" a certain way, and we certainly don't want to imply that we're *dictating* to a computer what it's GOING to do for us; we should be gently implying our intentions and asking politely if the computer would be willing to do something for us if and when it ever feels like it.
14
u/adscott1982 Jun 15 '20
I always ensure my computer gives consent before it gets fucked by my terrible code.
23
u/emanresuuu Jun 15 '20
They were able to bring this mess into the software development world. Ffs.
5
Jun 15 '20
Yes - because there is always that one guy that is a super asshole and demands very strict commenting structure - who decides this is his cause
23
u/reini_urban Jun 15 '20
As soon as racists and social justice warriors take over a project, it's time to leave. This happened to node, gnome, perl, and many others.
16
11
380
u/alblks Jun 14 '20
Master/slave are "racially-loaded terms" only in the US (as elsewhere there was a lot of slaves of the same race — including Africa, from where they were sold to the US), and now the whole world is to suck up to their fucking agenda...
I'd also propose to rename the color "white" to "oppressive color", and "black" to "impeccable color", to further reinforce the stupidity.
→ More replies (8)104
u/M___nek Jun 14 '20
It's really unfortunate that we (Europeans) are following US like they are our masters. Just take a look at BLM protests.
→ More replies (20)145
u/redalastor Jun 14 '20
It's really unfortunate that we (Europeans) are following US like they are our
mastersmains.FTFY
→ More replies (2)
61
u/haderp Jun 15 '20 edited Jun 15 '20
It’s much easier to make an empty political gesture to inconvenience your entire, mostly free tier users, rather than do something to end your paid relationship with a demonstrably racist organization (ICE).
Edit: parentheses abuse
10
Jun 15 '20
These are some of the most useless changes in the name of "equality", that really had no bearing on race to begin with.
10
Jun 15 '20
Luckily they didn't use unovigesimal instead of hexadecimal when creating CSS.
Otherwise "white" would be "#KKK".
8
10
u/elsif1 Jun 15 '20
It feels like there's a social incentive structure in place that rewards those who discover novel ways of being offended.
7
28
u/branchmain Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20
It's to the point that I feel like it would be fun to see how far this could be taken. I dunno but one or two of these words being banned is infuriating, but if it was like 10 or more I think it would become hilarious in its absurdity.
I'm thinking maybe a website with a list of all possibly insensitive terms and just tracking them as they are banned over time.
Given that we are now banning words without any connection to the reason they are being banned, I think it could be taken quite far into absurdity.
Would also be great to point out the hypocrisy of banning some words but not the rest of them.
"owner" as in "slave owner" would be the next target to have banned. Its wide-scale usage makes it an ideal candidate.
12
Jun 15 '20 edited Jun 15 '20
I'm thinking maybe a website with a list of all possibly insensitive terms and just tracking them as they are banned over time.
Put it on github for the lolz
Edit: you should add parent/child, I mean, some people had abusive parents, so that could be offensive to them.
→ More replies (2)7
u/ChallengingJamJars Jun 15 '20
Female/Male connectors. We could replace them with innies/outies.
→ More replies (1)
93
u/TheMagicBola Jun 15 '20
This is what happens when organizations dont have Black people to tell them they've missed the point. This is one of those things you never hear about from Black tech workers when we talk about racism within the industry.
But anything to make White people feel comfortable...
→ More replies (15)
19
Jun 15 '20
Slavery is abhorrent, but this, like master node and worker node, is a bit much.
→ More replies (1)
40
Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20
White noise.. Should I be offended? Male/Female plug? What is next?
→ More replies (4)
341
u/Luvax Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20
In the long run, this will hurt the entire movement. I would call myself neutral on the current situation in regards to BLM. I don't live in the US, I don't think I have anything do to with these problems. I don't care.
I never cared about skin color or anything of that sort. But if you make me work to replace these words, cause industry standards to change because of your political issues, than you got me as your enemy. If you think a blacklist is racist or the master/slave terminology is promoting slavery, you are the issue. Because up until people started to attack the very words I learned for my profession, I had no negative association with them. The people forcing these changes are the real racists. You might disagree with me, but I will not support your cause. You changed someone who was neutral towards your goals to actually hate your movement. Good job. I will continue to use these words out of spite. This is how you split a society.
Oh and I just want to add that I'm very well aware that different ethnicities don't support the push to cencor our language and most of this is carried out by a minority.
19
u/Krendrian Jun 15 '20
It's kind of like what happened to DnD orks.
They were cancelled, because literally no1, but the SJWs were associating them with black people
This is how you split a society.
Call me a conspiracy theorist, but I think this is intentonal, so that people focus on this nonsense instead of something way more important, or it simply makes it easier to control both groups
104
u/bioemerl Jun 14 '20
if you make me work to replace these words, cause industry standards to change because of your political issues, than you got me as your enemy.
Amen.
→ More replies (26)76
Jun 15 '20
have you actually SEEN people demanding these changes be made? because I haven't, and it's just a company trying to cash in on wokeness points.
→ More replies (4)29
u/gullman Jun 15 '20
That's why it's stupid.
This is just corporate bs. Nobody asked for this some moron in an office thought of it and nobody has been willing to tell him he's a moron.
→ More replies (1)
9
u/SushiAndWoW Jun 15 '20
Black people: "Please stop the police shooting us."
White people: "You're so right. In fact, let's do one better and purify technical terminology."
192
Jun 14 '20
George Orwell was right.
167
u/suhcoR Jun 14 '20
"Don’t you see that the whole aim of Newspeak is to narrow the range of thought? In the end we shall make thoughtcrime literally impossible, because there will be no words in which to express it." George Orwell, 1984
→ More replies (8)→ More replies (3)67
17
u/c-smile Jun 15 '20
Sigh...
Anecdote:
Very old Russian saying: "Noninvited guest is worse than Tatar" It was born at times of Tatar-Mongol Yoke (1237-1480). Since then TatarStan is part of Russia.
They said that someone from Communist Party approached Stalin with request to prohibit or replace the saying.
Stalin agreed and offered the change: "Noninvited guest is better than Tatar".
And the saying stayed the same in rather humorous connotation.
I believe any alternatives to "whitelist" "blacklist" will have this effect if not make situation even worse.
36
u/reddit-timewaste Jun 15 '20
They legit made these words race related if you think about it.
Blacklist was to do with British don't hire this worker books something or the other.
Whitelist? Well that's just the opposite of the color black, so it makes sense.
Master could just be "main" as in the master bedroom, not slave related.
→ More replies (5)
35
8
8
75
Jun 14 '20
Did Linus tell yet that they are idiots?
→ More replies (3)12
u/TiCL Jun 15 '20
Linus's daughter turned out to be huge SJW and he has been tamed.
→ More replies (1)
15
126
Jun 14 '20
This isn't what the protesters are demanding.
Replacing words can help, but it's probably a drop in the bucket, and could cause a short-term anti-reaction where people join the alt-right which would thus lead to even more racism.
What these companies need to do instead is boycot the militarization of the police and prisons. Boycot prison tech, boycot drug test tech, boycot surveillance tech...
We call China (rightfully) a dictatorship, but the US the has 7 times more prisoners per 100.000 people. That's a problem.
30
u/Godzoozles Jun 15 '20
Yes. Github renaming these branches are just meaningless woke affectations. This company contracts with ICE, ffs. Breaking those contracts would do far more good than just playing around with lexicon so that liberals can feel good about themselves as if they did something important.
→ More replies (11)32
u/icentalectro Jun 14 '20
I know this is completely besides the main point, but nit:
There's a difference between authoritarian and dictatorship. North Korea is a dictatorship. China is undoubtedly authoritarian but not a dictatorship for a few decades now, though the concern is that Xi may be dangerously close to the edge.
83
u/theChaosBeast Jun 14 '20
It's getting ridiculous...
Then we also should consider changing the terms string because that could be also women lingerie, flip flops because that's also a shoe exposing a lot of skin, gender every function and by default include every header so that nothing is excluded.
→ More replies (11)
7
u/g0_cubs_g0 Jun 15 '20
I had a QA class this quarter and our professor was so awkward about saying white box / black box testing. Each time he'd be like "white box....or glass box as some people call it"
Reminded me of the James Acaster bit where he talks about the speaker who's trying to not be sexist, "he....OR SHE!"
→ More replies (2)
7
38
26
u/madcaesar Jun 15 '20
Chess now will switch both sides to brown and racism will be defeated once and for all! Dusts off hands
→ More replies (3)
6
16
u/PapaJustifyyy Jun 15 '20 edited Jun 15 '20
The term slave has its origins in the word slav. The slavs, who inhabited a large part of Eastern Europe, were taken as slaves by the Muslims of Spain during the ninth century AD.
Will Github be replacing all Muslims in the company as well due to Islam’s historical link to the term?
Obviously I am not advocating for that to occur but if you deem the term to be offensive then surely the religion which practiced slavery, from which the term originated, has to be deemed offensive as well, along with anyone who continues to practice it.
You can deem both to be inoffensive, or both to be offensive, but not one or the other.
→ More replies (4)
11
65
u/C0R0NASMASH Jun 14 '20
This is a massive change and could potentially effect EVERY repository, every DevOps, every pipeline, a lot of scripts, and more. You can't just rename a branch?!
27
u/thelights0123 Jun 14 '20
Only the default for new stuff.
→ More replies (2)10
u/carrottread Jun 15 '20
Soon you'll see a lot of new "issues" demanding such rename on all popular repos.
→ More replies (2)18
u/makeitHD Jun 15 '20
master is the default name in Git, not just GitHub, so this would only cause a lot of confusion. What are they going to do, call everything main on the website when it's master in the repository itself?
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (1)4
u/andoriyu Jun 15 '20
Are you free to name your branches as you wish. It just won't name default branch "master" in documentation on how to push your first commit.
5
u/yoloman0805 Jun 15 '20
Man this is dumb. So what's next? Remove master - slave configuration term from mirco processors?
5
u/MilkTheSloth Jun 15 '20
So you're telling me, I've been protesting for the last few weeks and this is the outcome. Fuck off, this is stupid.
5
Jun 15 '20
Lol does black plague mean plague due to black people?
Bs US woke culture destroying stuff for everyone
5
5
u/I_LOVE_MONKAS Jun 15 '20
How is this going to help the current movement? If the only thing that you relate from "master", "whitelist-blacklist" is always about slavery and racism, then you're the real racist. This is the reason why people are not taking this whole movement seriously. As someone who's supporting the ongoing movement, this is just a bullshit that makes the moderates think that we are a joke.
5
u/ripam58566 Jun 15 '20
This is a bad idea. And Github is completely missing the point
This is an attack on language**, not racism.**
The term "Master" used in this context has nothing to do with racism.
This move is recieving pushback not becuase of racism, but because it is an attack on free speech.
Wait and see, the next this that will happen is that terms: "Masters Degree." "Master bedroom." "Record mastering." "Mastermind." "Mastering a skill" "Grillmaster5000" "Whitelist" "Blacklist"
Will be labeled as hatespeech.
And every one of you who comitted anything to your repositories that has any technical term that has words, but not meaning, in common with references to slavery wil be subject to scrutiny, and misplaced "Politically correct" attacks.
We can all hope that we will all laugh at the mistake that Github is making here, and that will be the end of it. But i think that we will see more of this kind of senseless virtue signalling from big companies instead of doing something that will result in real change.
20
4
4
u/qu4sar_ Jun 15 '20
Next thing you know, "Paint it, black" by The Rolling Stones is declared national anthem of the USA before of its symbolism to change the color of the red door (communism bad) to black (Black minorities good). Seriously what the hell GitHub
4
Jun 15 '20
Changing master branch to main branch will not solve racism issues. "Master branch" didn't cause any in the first place.
Dear companies: Stop wasting time on garbage like this.
4
u/gc_DataNerd Jun 15 '20
I am already having a panic attack at all the pipelines and scripts that are gonna break because of this. Do people not realize a word can have more than one context. This is complete lunacy and does absolutely no one good
4
Jun 15 '20
Please rename it to „mistress“ branch for all the feminazis. Also cracker list and African American list would be nice.
4
4
15
7
u/chet_atkins_ Jun 15 '20
Guess I’ll be a slave owner.
I’m not renaming my branches just because some precious tech hipster HR twat has pretended to be offended.
80
u/ColdFire75 Jun 14 '20
I’ll throw it out there.
Allow list and deny list make more sense and are more explicit than white list and black list.
We all know what a white list and a black list are, but for new users and people outside the industry, allow list and deny list seem better anyway.
26
u/corporaterebel Jun 15 '20 edited Jun 15 '20
Right up there with "rolling up the window", "dialing a phone" and shooting film footage on your phone.
Sure it makes sense to use more descriptive terms, but slang is what makes human language what it is... I'm not sure I want to talk, write, and speak like I'm creating a technical manual.
Heck, the majority of a printed paper is white (almost said "newspaper", but nobody knows what that is anymore) and the text is black...we should change that every other page.
THIS IS NOT A PROBLEM PEOPLE ARE DEMONSTRATING ABOUT. This is a useless sidetrack that is taking up valuable energy and talent that can be used for something more useful...
125
u/IceSentry Jun 15 '20
Blacklist and whitelist is used in pretty much every industry and everyone understands it.
54
u/LiveRealNow Jun 15 '20
Making up new word for concepts that are hundreds of years old and have words already does not make more sense than using the correct words.
12
46
u/Uristqwerty Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 15 '20
Compare these phrases: "Allow it", "Allowlist it", "Black it", "Blacklist it".
"Allow it" and "Allowlist it" have poor hamming distance (edit: with each other, and both being relevant in similar technical contexts, whereas "black it" doesn't make sense where "blacklist it" would), making them worse candidates for technical jargon where precise communication matters. This makes it inherently unsettling for some native speakers. Unless your internal association between "black", "white", and the trauma of sitting through high school history class is high enough to counterbalance the unease of muddled communication.
27
u/LiveRealNow Jun 15 '20
Blacklist predates the idea of modern technical jargon by many years.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (11)21
u/DocNefario Jun 15 '20
Deny and allow are both two syllables while black and white are both one. It's also nice that black and white are the same length, so blacklist and whitelist line up in monospaced fonts.
6
u/isamura Jun 15 '20
This is only going to increase confusion amongst developers, and nobody will be better for it. Now we’ll have two definitions that mean the same thing, depending on when the documentation or article was written.
6
u/rmrf_slash_dot Jun 15 '20
And the thousands upon thousands of tools that already exist using those terminologies.
Now, inertia is not typically a good argument against a good and necessary or even naturally evolving change.
This is none of those.
3
3
3
Jun 15 '20
This is so dumb. This weird woke cultural revolution never stops rolling. The nuts keep getting nuttier. No matter how much. This will all collapse into incoherence.
3
u/axilmar Jun 15 '20
This is entirely and utterly wrong, because it significantly increases the association of the word 'black' to negative contexts.
Black people (they are actually brown) are not gonna stop calling themselves black, but now using the term will not be allowed due to its negative connotations, thus making black people even more hurt.
9
9
5
Jun 15 '20
Ok, just my two cents: the 'master' default branch is a stupid name anyway, and it should be 'main' just like SVN. If people want to replace master/slave terms, I think that's perfectly fine. I personally prefer requester/completer anyway.
But "blacklist" is a slavery reference? Come on... However, IMHO they should eliminate Black Friday though, that thing is stupid.
→ More replies (3)
8
10
20
u/RevolutionaryCorps Jun 14 '20
I think the free folk that remain should dump this shitpiece of github and switch to any other equivalent alternative that's not implicating politics in every fucking aspect of the job.
This is extremely insane and crippling from an working pov.. we never had any problems with the Master-Slave notion in computer engineering however the USA government that is failing to lie to it's own population and always looking for dumber ways to drug the masses so that they don't claim their natural rights, this government will continue abusing the population by betraying the constitution which is the social contract between the different groups.
→ More replies (5)
4
5
2
u/runnriver Jun 15 '20
The master is whoever no longer clings to suffering.
To own a slave feels like suffering.
Yin and yang is black and white.
Microsoft owns Github. What will they do about that?
2
2
u/Imaginator127 Jun 15 '20
Lmao slavery stole the word “master” from scholars. Not the other way around.
2
2
2
2
Jun 15 '20
New repos will have a branch called "the big one" instead of "master", "whitelist" and "blacklist" to become "radlist" and "badlist"
2
u/frogking Jun 15 '20
As long as I can chose to NOT migrate to whatever new alternatives they chose, I don’t care.
Otherwise, there are some changes that have to be paid for by somebody.
2
2
233
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20
Won't removing the master branch cause problems with git tooling that might be dependent on a master branch always being available?