r/programming • u/alibix • May 18 '20
Microsoft: we were wrong about open source
https://www.theverge.com/2020/5/18/21262103/microsoft-open-source-linux-history-wrong-statement107
u/bigmoof May 18 '20
They weren’t wrong, they’ve made their fortunes by close sourcing...
82
u/apadin1 May 18 '20
Yeah this is quite a bit of "Monday Morning Quarterbacking". They've shifted their business model to cloud hosting and they own GitHub which is one of the largest open-source hosting sites, so of course they want to promote open-source now.
59
u/Somepotato May 18 '20
Which is fortunately a very consumer friendly way of doing it, they get their pockets lined, we get to continue to create, everyone's happy...except Richard Stallman, of course
12
May 18 '20
Stallman being happy would be a true miracle
-10
u/Somepotato May 18 '20
well defending epstein seems to make him happy
13
u/__j_random_hacker May 18 '20
He was defending Minsky, not Epstein. You can't even get that one basic detail right, even though one of his most fervent opponents makes a point of doing so.
If you actually read the email exchange that sparked all this, it becomes obvious that he was defending a recently deceased colleague from serious accusations that at the time appeared to be wholly unfounded.
But you won't do that, because you have already decided that he's A Terrible Person.
5
May 18 '20
Here is a link for more information on what Somepotato is talking about: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Stallman#Controversies
3
9
u/cowinabadplace May 18 '20
Fascinating how these things can mutate so much that now they're "defending Epstein". Good one.
→ More replies (2)23
u/caspper69 May 18 '20
Some people will never be happy unless everyone sees the world exactly as they do.
But no matter how intelligent a person may be, if they lack empathy, they will always be disappointed, because so few will share the totality of their vision.
Not everyone can be so fortunate as to have a cash-rich university subsidize their every whim, up to and including living as basically a homeless person in their facilities. Most of us have adult responsiblities, such as earning an income and supporting our families.
It is such a shame to be so gifted academically from a computer science perspective, yet be so blind to the reality of the common man he proclaims to wish to protect.
There's a kernel of truth in every saying.
Today's is "He can't see the forest through the trees."
Take care.
28
u/Kare11en May 18 '20
I am fond of another saying:
"The reasonable man adapts himself to the world: the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man."
-- George Bernard Shaw.
I say, with all the respect that I can, that Richard Stallman is a very unreasonable man.
2
u/caspper69 May 18 '20 edited May 19 '20
Thank you for the quote. I have to disagree with GBS here. This is not a zero-sum game, and progress is made through pragmatism, cooperation, and striving for excellence. Not in being a pedant. Open source, as a concept, and all of its various factions, is big enough to be just fine without RMS.
0
4
u/VegetableMonthToGo May 18 '20
Renting your entire digital life is not an improvement. SaaS, even if it's powered by Open Source technology, represents the loss of even more user rights and control. That's what Stallman objects to. He wants user rights, something that both closed source and SaaS prevent.
1
u/meneldal2 May 19 '20
He's not opposed to people making money with Open Source (for support for example).
0
May 18 '20
[deleted]
10
5
May 18 '20
Yeah you don't see them opening the code for GitHub.
10
u/Somepotato May 18 '20
Why would they? Hell why would they need to? Several viable alternatives exist (well several minus one as Atlassian keeps ruining everything they own)
32
u/Phrygue May 18 '20
Who cares about source code when you're selling services? So what if you have a LAMP stack, do you have a 10k server farm on a trunk line?
14
u/LetsGoHawks May 18 '20
Eventually they realized that FOSS wasn't nearly the threat they thought it was. And could in fact be quite helpful.
Yes, Linux kicked their ass in the server space, but that's about it.
Windows and Office are making oodles and gobs of money. SQL Server is still going strong, and that's unlikely to change anytime soon.
Meanwhile, they found an entirely new source of revenue selling Data Center services. And oh by the way.... look at all this wonderful Open Source stuff they can use in that space.
6
u/myringotomy May 18 '20
Open source also stopped them dead in their tracks to enter into the mobile space. That’s a massive loss.
5
u/falconfetus8 May 19 '20
No, it was their reputation that did that. Nobody wanted to have a Windows phone because...well, it's Windows! It reminds them of their work computer.
3
u/sihat May 19 '20 edited May 19 '20
From what I've read, Microsoft still makes money off Android.
https://www.howtogeek.com/183766/why-microsoft-makes-5-to-15-from-every-android-device-sold/
(They might have made more, if they had total control. Sure.)
6
7
19
u/complyue May 18 '20 edited May 18 '20
Once upon a time, people worship computers for what ever things it is designed to do, the users are willing to pay for the hardware and software, so you write code, compile it to computer programs, and sell them for great money. Users are your customers.
Years later, people hate computers for what they want a computer to do but it just unable at doing. Some ones / companies find a few ways for the computers to be useful to people, serving those functionalities over internet, attract users consuming the services free of charge, but push ads to them for great money. Users are your products, sold to advertisers who is your customers now.
You can no longer sell code because no one is willing to buy it anymore, and for your service to be more useful as well as less hated, you need massive man-hours, man-months or man-years to assess what functions are loved and what are hated, you want to hire that many people for the labor? Of course not, you just release your project to public, and SMEs and individuals may gather up to evolve it automatically, you just observe and pull good parts into your online services, for more effective ads casting thus greater money back.
8
u/ActuallyNot May 18 '20
Yeah, you were.
And your illegal activities against other operating systems and browsers.
And you're still wrong about paying tax.
7
11
u/OrsonEnders May 18 '20
There is a culture shift inside the company. Its now about what is the best tool for the job rather than some religious war of open vs closed.
I would not be surprised to see things that have been closed source for years start to open up.
34
u/AlstarsNinja May 18 '20
it wasnt about religious bs.... It was about establishing a monopoly(money)
5
u/RagingAnemone May 18 '20
Well, there still needs to be a cultural shift outside of the company. I still run into a lot of programmers who won't touch anything that isn't made by Microsoft. They're not interested in best of breed tools. They're comfortable in their little technological enclave and don't want the venture out of it.
2
u/DownvoteALot May 18 '20
And some farmers want to keep using rakes and shovels. How long will someone still be willing to hire them...
1
u/SaneMadHatter May 18 '20
Yeah, the folks you speak of are still involved in the "religious war" the OP of this subtread talked of.
1
u/Angeldust01 May 19 '20
I still run into a lot of programmers who won't touch anything that isn't made by Microsoft.
They're comfortable in their little technological enclave and don't want the venture out of it.
Not completely different from *nix fanatics, then?
1
u/RagingAnemone May 19 '20
Hard to say. I don't know any old school programmers from the Unix world. I know some mainframe guys but they use Windows now. All Linux programmers I know started with windows or Mac.
2
2
u/bartturner May 19 '20 edited May 19 '20
Ha! Like they wanted to go to open source. They were forced to because that is how their competitors are operating. If Microsoft really cared about open source they would end the patent trolling they continue to do extensively.
I think Microsoft is probably the worse software patent troll there is today? Who is worse? Definitely not Google or Facebook. Not how Amazon operates. Not really even Apple which is from the same era as Microsoft.
I believe Microsoft continues to be the worse software patent troll in history. But be curious if someone can come up with someone worse?
8
u/usecaseq May 18 '20
Basically they found a way to exploit/monetize the open source model so it’s cool now... Embrace and extend...
1
-5
u/wubrgess May 18 '20
Embrace
Extend
Extinguish
55
11
u/mindcandy May 18 '20
Has there been a single significant incidence of this from MS since Nadella took over?
-2
u/onan May 18 '20
Company cultures have inertia. Especially at the size of a company the size of Microsoft, that inertia can easily outlive the tenure even of every individual member.
So even if we're willing to grant that Microsoft's current behavior is ethical, trustworthy, and innovative, that is not sufficient evidence that they won't default back to their previous ways. (And, given their recent moves toward greater user surveillance, I'm certainly not willing to grant that.)
I think I'll be ready to trust Microsoft if they have been continuously clean for as much time as they were predatory, anti-competitive, and anti-technology. So if we generously count their good era as starting with Nadella, that means that they might be safe to trust by 2052.
-7
u/lambda-panda May 18 '20
That is like looking at the moon, and declaring that it does not move across the sky because it hasn't moved for the 5 minutes you stared at it.
8
u/JarateKing May 18 '20
Nadella has been CEO since 2014, and was vice president of their cloud division before then. We would have something by now.
The whole point of cloud services is that they take less effort (in theory) and less initial investment than managing the infrastructure yourself, and you do good in the cloud services industry by being the most developer-friendly and convenient. EEE does not work in that situation. They aren't following the same business model they were a few decades ago, and it stands to reason that they aren't going to approach it with the same strategies either.
15
u/Minimum_Fuel May 18 '20
How do you extinguish open source?
24
u/80286 May 18 '20 edited May 18 '20
I don't think there's benefit in extinguishing free/open source projects, but capturing them - getting rid of unwanted idealists and replacing them with corporate shills - to drive your own business and political interests is what can and has been attempted in the past few years.
1
4
u/JeddHampton May 18 '20
It's not extinguish the product but extinguish the user base. The explanation above shows how. After having the users grow dependent on a piece of software that is used with the open source product, the company forks into a way that the user base dependent on the company's piece of software must side with the company.
11
u/IAmARobot May 18 '20 edited May 18 '20
for a textbook example, see google and AOSP. The point of android was to get google's foot in the smartphone door by promoting open source so manufacturers could ship android phones and tantalisingly the user could update the os with cool shit that the community made. But the problem became apparent when google didn't update AOSP and instead updated their own apps, leaving manufacturers/hobbyists the progressively harder (over time) task of writing their own OS to do things that should somehow integrate with the rest of the internet/google ecosystem, or they can just give up and use the play store and google's apps. The death of an amazing open source project save for LineageOS/replicant, and even then you should see how hard it is to get their stuff working.
*I feel it's pertinent to mention that MS has their fingers in so many open source pies that this obviously wouldn't be their modus operandi for the gamut.
2
u/the_gnarts May 18 '20
for a textbook example, see google and AOSP.
Chrome with its LGPL’d core (KHTML) and proprietary plugins (EME) is another example in that vein.
1
u/VegetableMonthToGo May 18 '20
And in case you have to ask... The AOSP Project is Apache 2.0 licensed to there is no obligation on Google to play open card. If it was GPL licensed like the kernel, Google would not have been able to do some of these tricks.
3
u/lambda-panda May 18 '20
You don't extinguish open source itself, but by controlling various narratives, you can target and destroy various opensource software hosted on platforms they control...
-1
u/apadin1 May 18 '20
You do everything they do but more and better, so that no one uses the open source version. If you have no users, you have been effectively extinguished.
9
u/oblio- May 18 '20
Ok, follow-up question, what Open Source project can they extinguish in 2020 and after 2020? Keep in mind that almost any big Open Source project these days has at least 1 big corporate backer (Kubernetes => Google, Java => Oracle, IBM, ...).
What can Microsoft realistically kill now?
→ More replies (2)5
u/HaaYaargh May 18 '20
Please elaborate, I don't understand.
52
u/ipe369 May 18 '20
The wiki link the other person posted is good, but just to give you a quick example since I didn't really get it the first time I read through the wiki page:
MS want to kill some open source thing - let's say the apache web server, and replace it with their own server
Embrace:
MS develop a competing OSS web server, BUT allow it to run on linux and use apache config files - great! Now you can switch to the MS web server & not have to change your apache config, it all just works. Devs like using it b/c it's open source, which is also nice.
People slowly switch over to the MS alternative over apache, maybe it offers slightly better performance or better windows integration, maybe the company they work for just has a deal with MS
Extend:
MS adds some 'non-standard' extensions to the config files, which allow for customised behaviour. Users of the MS alternative now have access to a wider range of features
Apache doesn't support these extensions, either because it wants to stick to the original standard or doesn't have the development capacity to implement them all
Extinguish
People stop using apache because it doesn't support the extra stuff, and switch over entirely to MS
At this point MS don't need to support the open apache standard & are free to change it to use whatever they want to / close the MS source, because a viable OSS alternative is no longer available
50
u/lambdaq May 18 '20
that sums up Google Chrome pretty well. It's kinda the new IE.
7
u/apadin1 May 18 '20
Sort of, except Firefox is still extremely popular and probably will be for the next few years. So Chrome might dominate but it doesn't completely monopolize the browser market.
→ More replies (7)2
u/ipe369 May 18 '20
Yeah definitely, the idea that chrome kept up with constantly evolving web standards & caused IE to fall behind & get fucked is definitely pretty close - although, firefox is also still keeping up, & MS released Edge which has much more modern support, so it's not really a full monopoly like you'd want to achieve with EEE
14
u/bassmadrigal May 18 '20
Edge uses Chromium as a backend, which allows them "more modern support". Pretty much everything uses a Chromium base except for Firefox and its offshoots.
9
u/alantrick May 18 '20
everything uses a Chromium base
And Safari, which is in North American markets is one of the most common browsers because of iOS. Once upon a time, Safari and Chrome were both webkit based, but Chrome forked quite a while ago and is quite different at this point.
1
u/ipe369 May 18 '20
Oh i didn't actually know that, makes sense why edge was so surprisingly useable from the get-go lol
2
1
u/SmotherMeWithArmpits May 18 '20
I agree. Then acquiring github is sus. They're getting their hands into everything, fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, can't get fooled again.
-6
u/fortyonejb May 18 '20
Why are people still upvoting this nonsense?
2
u/VegetableMonthToGo May 18 '20
Because some have longer memory then you? Microsoft liked open source in the 90s too, with things like NetScape. See how that turned out.
0
u/fortyonejb May 18 '20
Thats right, things never change...
None of the people involved with Microsoft in the 90s are still there. Companies do change, or in your world does IBM still make desktop computers, and Nokia still makes rubber boots? I remember the 90s quite well and your smug attitude only proves you have no clue and should probably just keep your opinions to yourself.
2
2
-3
May 18 '20
Focusing on open source is good. Not putting ads in an expensive OS is better. Their philosophy is much more far away from open source spirit than 2001. I don’t believe them
58
May 18 '20
.NET Core, Xamarin, GitHub, WSL, HyperV, Typescript, etc. are all indicators to the contrary
31
u/Dlacreme May 18 '20 edited May 18 '20
Yeah. They are doing amazing. Visual Code, Microsoft Teams.. catching up with linux and open source allowed them to produce much better softwares.
2
u/BestKillerBot May 18 '20
GitHub is not open source, besides that Windows, MS SQL, Office, Active Directory, Visual Studio, Exchange, Sharepoint...
They did some new stuff (mostly smaller) as open source but the absolute majority of their offering is still closed source and nothing will change about that ...
33
u/ajr901 May 18 '20 edited May 18 '20
GitHub is not open source
You know that's not what he meant.
Github is the main watering hole for everything open source these days. A central hub for open source if you will.
In regards to everything else you listed: they're a corporation with a bottom line. You genuinely can't expect them to make 100% of their IP open source and free, can you? Why aren't we giving Apple any shit for their proprietary products? What about Google? How come facebook isn't open source? What about salesforce and oracle?
Take the things they do make open source and be grateful.
-10
u/BestKillerBot May 18 '20
You know that's not what he meant. Github is the main watering hole for everything open source these days. A central hub for open source if you will.
Right and it's pretty dangerous when such (closed source) central hub is tightly controlled by corporation like Microsoft.
Why aren't we giving Apple any shit for their proprietary products? What about Google? How come facebook isn't open source?
Because the topic is Microsoft and not Apple?
Besides that MS and some of its supporters are now trying to paint themselves as "open source champion" or similar and I think it's important to correct such false sentiments.
→ More replies (3)11
May 18 '20
some of its supporters are now trying to paint themselves as "open source champion"
No shit, when some people petty people can't see the big picture (open source as mainstream, real support and work to show for it) wouldn't accept anything from complete dissolution of Microsoft for them to be less angry.
You can dislike a billion dollar company and still appreciate positive steps that have a global impact.
→ More replies (4)8
May 18 '20
It may not be open source, but it's a free platform with free tooling that a large chunk of open source libraries rely on. It doesn't have to be open sourced in order to support open source initiatives
4
u/BestKillerBot May 18 '20
MS did not pay $8 billion for GitHub to serve the community. Their strategic plan is probably to channel people into Azure.
I mean it's OK for me since it's relatively easy to switch to another provider. But let's not get confused about motivations ...
6
May 18 '20
I didn't say that's why they did it, but the fact of the matter is they bought it and have since made it even better, and if you think that doesn't support the community, you're blind. Motivations aside, GitHub is still supporting the open source community
-2
u/oblio- May 18 '20
I think Windows, being infrastructure, could realistically be Open Sourced, on a longer time frame, say, 5-10 years.
Especially since they can't keep up with Linux.
The user facing apps will never be Open Sourced, they'll basically end up with what Apple is doing.
8
u/peakzorro May 18 '20
As someone who uses Windows 10, Ubuntu Linux, and macOS on a daily basis, I can confidently say that Linux has trouble keeping up with Windows, especially in usability and driver support.
For security and servers, I 100% agree with you.
→ More replies (1)4
u/myringotomy May 18 '20
You make it sound like Microsoft is writing all those drivers.
1
u/peakzorro May 19 '20
Microsoft writes many base implementations of drivers, and provides the framework and certification structures to make sure their devices are compliant. Did they write them all? Not a chance. Do they make it a priority that their OS is compatible with as much hardware on the market as possible? Absolutely.
4
u/myringotomy May 19 '20
Linux does the same thing. It just that some hardware manufacturers don't write drivers for it. In most of those cases the community writes drivers themselves.
1
u/the_gnarts May 18 '20
HyperV
MS released the source to that? I’d appreciate a link because my google fu didn’t produce any.
2
May 19 '20
No, but they do make use of it free and have pretty good documentation. My point is MS provides a plethora of free and open source tools that makes the open source community better, and the original comment I replied to is moronic for saying MS now is just as bad or worse than in 2001.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (19)-8
u/manghoti May 18 '20
Yah they changed tactics to owning standards and .net was a big one, endlessly blasting weird api updates to keep other platforms out of date, and trying to control the market that way.
They, and this very article, continue to push "Open Source" Instead of... you know... FLOSS. Let's pretend THAT term never existed it was ALWAYS open source what made you think otherwise?
So they release a platform that pushes that ideal, but it doesn't work out so they buy out the rooted competitor instead. Looking forward to the extensions there.
Just. Why are you pinning so many hopes to this company? You could invest your love elsewhere you know? Far less likely to be hurt in the future.
12
u/SirPsychoMantis May 18 '20
They have some good open source projects, so I use them. Why does it have to be LOVE or HATE?
8
May 18 '20
Because GNU Zealotry is a religion.
2
u/myringotomy May 18 '20
So is Microsoft worship and you see a lot more of the latter on this subreddit.
1
May 19 '20
I never found anyone who "worships" Microsoft, like a GNU Zealot starts foaming at the mention of non-viral open-source licences...
Not counting Xbox squeakers, of course.
2
u/myringotomy May 19 '20
I never found anyone who "worships" Microsoft,
I see them on this subreddit every day. They start foaming at the mouth anytime you mention the GPL or Linux. They attack you viciously if you say anything negative about Microsoft corporation.
They worship anything made by Microsoft and are 100% convinced that there is no better language than C# and Typescript and nothing better than windows ever and nothing even comes close to visual studio.
They are fucking nutcases. People who live their entire lives in the technology stack of one corporation and attack anybody who says anything negative about the corporation or any of their products.
Raving lunatics. I think they probably drool while typing their missives.
→ More replies (12)6
May 18 '20
Open source has nothing to do with ads.
However, in an open-source OS, you can change the software to remove the ads, and any other parts you don't like.
10
May 18 '20
You are absolutely right, but open source has something to do with transparency between the user and the software. Microsoft is not transparent. How Ms use our data is purposely not clear.
1
u/VegetableMonthToGo May 18 '20
That's why Microsoft likes 'Open Source' and not 'Free Software'. The first is a sensibly business decision which gives them the most while giving the least. The second is an actual ethical stance in software development. And in all open source talk that Microsoft does, their behaviour against their end users of totally devoid of ethics.
0
u/ObscureCulturalMeme May 18 '20
With every new release of Windows, hooks available to the end user have been removed. Even the patches to Windows 10 Pro have taken away options which were available in Windows 7, and can now only be had in Enterprise.
Find a way to do something on your own computer, Microsoft removes the registry key or the DLL. Want that control back, they ask? Fuck you, pay them.
I've never had a less open environment on my computer than the one currently pushed by this "open source friendly" corporation.
0
May 18 '20
[deleted]
-1
May 18 '20
Open source projects are not made to maximize revenues at all costs
0
May 18 '20
[deleted]
1
May 18 '20
How much do you pay for using Linux/Firefox/emacs ? What is the cost ? What do you give ?
2
1
u/ObscureCulturalMeme May 18 '20
How much did Microsoft pay for this advertisement fluff article?
3
u/ptoki May 19 '20
Nah, thats not actually interesting. The interesting part is the amount of fanboyism and community love for MS recently. How come the villain become hero just because they started using their "enemy" product.
The only good thing is they joined OIN but that does not mean they will be open and honest in the future.
1
1
1
u/thrallsius May 19 '20
and that's why they are trying to build a new monopoly service lock-in by buying Github :D
1
u/bitsofexplodedtits May 19 '20
This is another fluff/misleading/propaganda piece pretending that Microsoft has changed when it hasn't changed at all. They're the same as they've always been. They were about making money in the 80s, and they're about making money today. They found out that nickel and diming people on shitty cloud services was more profitable than selling software, so that's what they're doing.
We're talking about a company so tone deaf that even after over a decade of people shitting down their throats for destroying the Windows GUI, they can't just man up, admit they were wrong, and do another Windows 7 level release.
Just look at the Windows 10 2004 patch. It's literally all shit that no one wants. They keep trying to force feed their dumbass UI shit that no one wants. The only thing people want from Windows is for it to be faster, more efficient, and out of your way. They don't want an Xbox dashboard, they don't want UWP, they don't want all this stupid bullshit.
Microsoft blows.
1
u/gheesh May 18 '20
I'll believe them when they make significant open source contributions in areas where they are strong (i.e. desktop). To release minor products related to their own shitty cloud offering and saying they are now open source is pretty similar to big petrol companies investing in a small solar farm and calling themselves "green".
-1
May 18 '20 edited May 18 '20
MS -
"Our current direction means less $$$. So now we're reneging and joining everyone to survive, even though we tried to throw you guys wayside, despite innovation."
Edit: Fanboys gonna fan because the truth hurts when your $$$ is involved. I thought you guys were smart, pragmatic software guys? Guess not.
1
u/kanzenryu May 19 '20
Wouldn't it be nice to see some sort of actual apology for the things they said about open source projects and the people running them...
1
-12
u/manghoti May 18 '20
Microsoft in 10 years: We're extending open source!
*applause*
3
May 18 '20
Linux community in 10 years: We've added support for dual monitor.
*applause*
5
u/manghoti May 18 '20
Funny you mention that. Microsoft started an initiative of placing certified for windows X on every monitor that gets produced. Of course monitors are generic devices and the only objective of this campaign is to make customers doubt that other systems will work with it.
This campaign continues to this day.
... Because they love Linux.
And open source...
1
May 19 '20
Microsoft started an initiative of placing certified for windows X on every monitor that gets produced.
Can you source that? Google shows nothing. My hunch is you read somewhere on a GPL zealotry bbs and didn't bother to check if it was pure FUD, instead just accepted as truth because "M$ evil".
Because they love Linux.
And open source...
They could throw a poop party on top of Stallman's head, as far as I'm concerned. Actions and results matter, and the proof is in the pudding.
3
u/manghoti May 19 '20
sure
search "monitor box"
http://www.dollarshort.com/images/BandPics/Lighting%20Gear/14.13%20-%20Monitor%20Box.html
and can we talk about what you would imagine a "poop party" to be like?
1
May 19 '20
It's called ingredient branding, look it up. It's not illegal, I'm sure you'd feel the same with this, right? https://www.flickr.com/photos/kordite/819712100
2
u/manghoti May 19 '20
lmao it's not illegal?
Damn man, first it wasn't happening, now it's technically not illegal?
But lets move on from THAT hilarious repositioning of the goal posts.
I would have no issues with windows putting a sticker saying windows is running on a computer, just as I have no issues with ubuntu doing it. The issue I have is windows DELIBERATELY causing confusion by saying that a monitor even NEEDS to be certified to work with particular operating systems. It's not running windows, it has nothing to do with windows, microsoft was actively, and is actively, confusing customers to eliminate competition.
And yah, technically not illegal.
0
May 19 '20
[deleted]
2
May 19 '20
It's a joke from 5 years ago. I've watched plenty a Linux conferences, where the main issue spoken about... is how they can't get a projector to work on the conference.
-13
u/singularineet May 18 '20
They say MS <3 Open Source but that's a typo, they actually <====3 Open Source.
-2
u/ptoki May 19 '20 edited May 19 '20
Thats a false logic twist.
MS was NEVER an OSS enemy. They love programmers. They love people making software running on THEIR platform. They dont care if the coders sell it or give it for free. They are/were happy that the user NEEDED Windows to run the software.
They HATED Linux. Not OSS. Dont confuse those two! They hated competition. They hated the situation when someone could create java app and run it not on THEIR platform. That was the reason of their attempts of breaking java compatibility, invention of .net and few more.
They did not change a bit. They will try to get dominance, embrace linux, attract people to their platform and then break compatibility making you vendor locked.
Mark my words.
Edit: If you dont believe me just switch linux to open office. And compare attitudes towards the two.
3
u/sphinx80 May 19 '20
MS was NEVER an OSS enemy.
You must be young, or misremembering. They literally called open source "cancer" and did everything they could to discredit it.
0
u/ptoki May 19 '20 edited May 19 '20
You must be younger than me.
https://www.theregister.co.uk/2001/06/02/ballmer_linux_is_a_cancer/
There is actually explanation that he was thinking "linux", saying "open source" but the real issue was GNU (and linux as a competitor).
It was linux. Please read what I wrote. MS was NEVER OSS enemy. NEVER. They hate linux and GNU related to it. But not open source as an ideology. AFAIK they never pursued any OSS other than linux. Maybe OpenOffice but AFAIR not directly.
0
May 18 '20
[deleted]
280
May 18 '20
This is basically it. Microsoft didn't just wake up and randomly start loving Open Source, it just makes financial sense to do what they're doing now, given their current business model. It's all about the Benjamins, baby!
136
u/jl2352 May 18 '20
There has also been a cultural change in how businesses see software.
I remember during my internship the team I was in bought about 100 licenses for WinRaR. At the time I said they could just use 7-Zip. It was blackballed because ... it was free. Literally the fact it was free meant it would never be considered. Paid software was just seen as superior and more reputable due to a tonne of presumptions.
That still exists today. Not to the same prelevance. Today using free is considered.
77
u/master5o1 May 18 '20
With a lot of things, when you pay for something it gives you someone to blame if that thing goes wrong.
0
16
u/doctorcrimson May 19 '20 edited May 19 '20
To be fair the early versions of 7zip sucked and a lot of open source software has support or updates cut off at random.
Even worse is when modernization of open source starts and the company working on it suddenly runs out of money so you get a less stable release than before with the new features you require and no option to use an updated version of the old suite/client/UI.
If somebody made that WinRar decision today I would call them stupid, though.
4
u/Angeldust01 May 19 '20
bought about 100 licenses for WinRaR
Greatest business day for Winrar, ever.
9
u/ptoki May 19 '20
Actually the explanation is even simpler.
Ignorance. When given WinRaR and 7Zip it takes literally 2-3 months of setting it for a limited number of people/users and checking if there are any hard problems with it.
If back in time someone decided that they cant use 7zip "because" then that was just ignorance. No need to call it any different.
There is also other side of this story. Cost of WinRar per user is small. If the user wastes more than hour of learning 7zip then almost all of the profit is lost. At least for about a year or two (when you might need to renew support to get more updates - if needed).
Today the challenge is different. Lots of stuff is free now. But the commercial free comes with vendor lock-in.
If you are not ignorant you can avoid the big problem which this makes. Yet a ton of PMs dont see a reason to go with terraform instead of straight aws, azure, google cloud solutions.
Ignorance, ignorance everywhere.
2
u/pdp10 May 19 '20
Install them side-by-side. Instrument systems to see how often each is used.
Debian Linux has a "popularity contest" that does something like that. You can use that as a model, or you can do something like write a wrapper script that adds some explicit logging.
→ More replies (13)1
u/MrEllis May 19 '20
I've never heard of that service. What is the advantage of Terraform over strait aws/gcs/azure?
4
u/ptoki May 19 '20
Its kind of abstraction layer.
Instead of coding AWS api or google api you code in terraform api and it will translate the calls and will manage all the underlying vendor services.
Its still possible that it will flop but there is a chance that you will be able to leverage all the profits of multiple cloud providers.
Im not an expert on this but thats the way people can make their infrastructure more bulletproof.
3
May 19 '20
Terraform allows you to create stuff regardless of the cloud backend, so you can deploy to azure, AWS, gcp, all from Terraform
12
u/badtux99 May 19 '20
Theoretically.
Reality is that you're going to have to do a lot of modification of your Terraform recipes to move anything between clouds.
Still better than a complete rewrite to something entirely new.
5
May 19 '20
Exactly. Terraform still tightly couples a module's implementation to the cloud vendor it was implemented for. Your Terraform for defining IAM roles WILL NOT WORK IN AZURE. FULL STOP.
That being said, the advantages around using Terraform are countless. Let's compare it to AWS's equivalent: cloudformation. With cloudformation, you have to define everything for your infrastructure in a single file which relates to a single stack. If you want to logically organize your infrastructure, you gotta make separate cloudformation stacks with separate definitions. Need to reference a resource from your IAM stack in your Lambda stack. Global variables. AWS Account wide string based global variables. Good luck refactoring that.
Let's say I want to define some infrastructure which directly competes with AWS. Say I want to setup some monitors in DataDog becuause my enterprise cut a sweet deal with their data aggregation services. Terraform: no problem, there is a module for that; you can define you app's infrastructure in the same language as your app's monitoring. AWS: yeeeeaaaaa you know what, I'm gonna need you to define those resources in a way which enriches AWS' bottom dollar; no outsiders allowed!
Hey I want to use this infrastructure as code tool to see what the heck will be changed in the infrastructure when I change this variable name. Cloudformation: OK I will tell you what resources will change, but I will barely tell you anything about what actually will change in that resource Terraform: I will change this variable from state X to Y. Additionally this is a update-in-place change which means I will not destroy this resource to perform that change.
Let's say I want to setup a database with a configuration where there is a single master instance and several read-slaves. AWS: yea you know what go ahead and duplicate all of your database definitions; make as much code to define the read slaves as it takes to define the single master instance. Terraform: there are tools which exist to reduce code duplication. You can make 1 piece of code define all of your read slaves.
Terraform is vastly superior tool when compared to equivalent solutions like cloudformation. But let's please stick to the facts when discussing this engineering tool, and not let ourselves buy into the whole: write once run everyone BS that everyone is selling. That just is not representative of the reality of the tool, but should not discourage the discussion about the relative pros and cons of each tool.
Please if I have misconstrued any facts I would like to see some evidence about this so I can intelligently engineer solutions in the future.
Source: in the software engineering trenches 9-5 for a decade or so
→ More replies (5)2
u/pdp10 May 19 '20
At the time I said they could just use 7-Zip.
Earlier than your case, we once had a small panic about the licensing of WinZip. It must have been raised by one of our VARs or something, because by a week later when another team had tracked down an open-source replacement, the concern was already over.
Paid software was just seen as superior and more reputable due to a tonne of presumptions.
In the early days, the "open source movement" spent a considerable time distinguishing itself from shareware and freeware.
Then there's also the old descriptive: "reassuringly expensive".
→ More replies (2)1
u/audion00ba May 19 '20
Paying is arguably better business, assuming support is included where support means SLA with hard deadlines (which I have not seen any vendor do, other than "engineer on site within X hours/days").
69
u/quentech May 18 '20
Microsoft didn't just wake up and randomly start loving Open Source
You're right, Microsoft didn't just wake up and randomly start loving open source.
They've been moving towards it for more than a decade (on Codeplex), before Azure was a thing.
And it was what, 6 or 7 years ago they moved to GitHub and announced .Net Core would be fully open source, when Azure was just a few years old.
60
u/nemec May 18 '20
I'd argue that this is primarily why MS is betting on Open Source today. It didn't have to be this way, just look at Oracle.
It's a consequence of the right people being promoted into positions of power. Scott Guthrie, the EVP of Cloud (Azure), pushed to have the old ASP.NET MVC open sourced back in 2009 (originally under their own "Microsoft Public License", but now MIT I think). In 2014, they open sourced their brand new compiler on Github under the Apache license.
And since then, they've continued to push OSS not, I imagine, because of some top-down mandate, but because they're hired the right people who see its benefits (and, of course, see how those benefits can be used to make the company money)
35
u/jl2352 May 18 '20
I'd add TypeScript to that. At the time, Microsoft announcing that their new language will be open source from the start was really big news. It was very major. TypeScript proved that working in the open is fine. I expect this gave confidence to the rest of the company.
It's not surprising they tried experimenting with open source with with a brand new code base. For a reduced risk.
If TypeScript had of been a failure, then it may well have delayed other projects moving to open source.
8
u/radol May 18 '20
More money and free feedback to them, better free/cheap tools and technologies for us, I'm fine with that
6
u/falconfetus8 May 19 '20
And you know what? This is a good thing. It means that their interests are now, for the time being, aligned with ours.
1
u/ArmoredPancake May 19 '20
it just makes financial sense to do what they're doing now, given their current business model. It's all about the Benjamins, baby!
Shocking news!
0
May 19 '20
[deleted]
1
u/Full-Spectral May 19 '20
FOSS is not really a sensible business model since the software (in cases like MS or Google and such) exists purely to either get people to use your cloud services or to let you sell your users as your product. There's nothing about that that is good for us as end users. I can't believe people can't see that. It's completely undoing the personal computer revolution pretty much and moving us back to the mainframe world. It creates a situation where these companies have no obligations to their users because they aren't selling software. They sell a service or they sell you to other people.
Now if they were making their actual living on the FOSS, that wold be another thing. But they aren't. It's like giving out free crack samples. The people who get them feel good but they don't realize that it's not in their best interests long term.
39
7
u/Alhoshka May 19 '20
Not really a "tl;dr" as much as what the article should have been about. As is, the article itself is 5-6 year old news, and pretty bland/anodyne to boot. With a single sentence, you were able to provide more value.
I guess people are only upvoting the article because they like the fact that MS is supporting open source.
2
u/Full-Spectral May 19 '20
Yolde, exactly. And the sad thing is, people actually think this is a good thing because all they see if free software. But it's all just part of moving us back to the old mainframe in a glass room and not having any control over our own software. Just like Google, you give stuff away because the software isn't your product, your users are your product.
And even less funny is what this move is ultimately going to do to jobs as it becomes harder and harder for companies to actually sell a product. That will just allow big companies with vast back end infrastructure to kill smaller companies who can't compete because the need to make actual software and sell it.
None of this is a good thing, and I shake my head at all of the people who are lauding this move by MS. Honestly I don't even know if MS WANTED to do it, but even if they didn't they probably couldn't NOT do it at this point.
Of course people being without morals and stealing everything they can get their hands on didn't help either. if you only sell services or your users, then you can't be stolen from.
0
0
May 18 '20
[deleted]
9
u/scuzzy987 May 19 '20
Not over Bill's dead body
2
u/IceSentry May 20 '20
I'm pretty sure the issue is licensing more than bill gates. I see no reason why modern day bill gates wouldn't want windows to be open source.
2
u/Charles_Sangels May 19 '20
This would be the real "money where your mouth is" proof of this marketing strategy.
0
0
321
u/caspper69 May 18 '20
I feel like people are always missing context & time/place with everything, and maybe that's just me getting older.
The software industry was a very different place back then. Even the people writing Linux and posting all over Slashdot missed the point at the time. Look no further than the fights over compression formats, UNIX (et al, which took DECADES to resolve), look & feel (mac and windows)... The list really does go on and on.
It was the wild west. People sued for everything. And everyone stole each other's code. That's why no one will open anything old. I'm talking industry, not end users or hobbyists.
It's just very hard to relate to that mindset unless you grew up in it, the constant fighting and squabbles, and the massive amounts of money that was being generated. Microsoft's reaction and (over) reaction to open source should have come as no surprise to anyone. People who made it through that era sort of had a PTSD over all of the IP and litigation shenanigans.
It's always the idealists that grow up to become the PHB's, then you get what you (sort of) wanted. And then another group comes up and tells you you're doing that wrong. I don't think this is Microsoft attempting to stay relevant, I think this is the people that comprise Microsoft being open source friendly, or at least agnostic. They cut their teeth in a different era.
Wash. Rinse. Repeat.