r/programming • • Jan 07 '20

Adobe will finally kill Flash in 2020.

https://www.ghacks.net/2017/07/25/adobe-retires-flash-in-december-2020/
819 Upvotes

197 comments sorted by

223

u/militantcookie Jan 07 '20

2017 article?

133

u/ozjd Jan 07 '20

I upvoted this not because the article is actually from 2017 (I hadn't seen it yet), but because it feels like Flash should have been killed off a long time ago.

62

u/kopczak1995 Jan 07 '20

Funny thing is... It will be never killed in corpo. There are still apps somewhere which require nasty IE because it's the only browser still supporting flash -.-

54

u/AmericasNo1Aerosol Jan 07 '20

Note that Chrome still supports Flash (in that Flash come built-in to the browser), but its disabled by default. We have a vendor at work who's admin interface STILL requires Flash even in the most recent version. ಠ_ಠ

34

u/13steinj Jan 07 '20

Many, many textbooks, even now, require Flash. Wonder how that'll turn out, honestly.

47

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

They'll make you buy the latest edition, of course.

7

u/Dick_in_owl Jan 07 '20

VMware also

11

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

Not anymore. vCenter now has a shiny new HTML5 interface, and runs wonderfully (with the exception of a "double-key press" bug in the remote on Firefox) in all browsers!

8

u/magondrago Jan 07 '20

wait what? VMware requires Flash? WHY?

7

u/Dick_in_owl Jan 07 '20

The vmware vcloud

2

u/t1m1d Jan 07 '20

It has an HTML version which is now the default. Seems to function pretty well.

2

u/root88 Jan 07 '20

All they should need to do is import their projects from Flash into Adobe Animate and then they can render to HTML5/JS/Canvas apps instead of a SWF. I'm not sure how well that works, but that was the idea.

2

u/13steinj Jan 07 '20

I highly doubt Adobe expected Flash to be used for such a massively sized and scoped project such as textbooks and online homework systems. It probably won't be a "click and done" deal.

2

u/josefx Jan 07 '20

It worked rather well for python3. /s

0

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

[deleted]

18

u/Urtehnoes Jan 07 '20

I guess they like to gamble in more ways than one

6

u/EnderMB Jan 07 '20

Flash is still heavily used in retail display machines.

A few years ago I worked with a consultant developer that worked heavily in two niches - Salesforce and Flash. He'd travel around the UK maintaining and adding features to retail-based Flash applications, and when the work wasn't available he'd work on Salesforce implementations. A few of us pressed him on Flash work at the pub, and he said that many of them were still going strong, and would do so for years to come.

He never explicitly told me how much he made, but we knew he made a ton from the Salesforce work, and several times that for every Flash gig he picked up. He also owned a house in central London, so things were obviously going well for him.

3

u/joelhardi Jan 07 '20

Adobe has already announced that Harman, a Samsung subsidiary, is taking over support and development of Adobe AIR, which will surely live on for a while for stuff like kiosks, slot machines and whatever embedded/smart/IoT devices are still using AIR. They're also supporting Windows, Android, MacOS so things like legacy enterprise and mobile apps can also persist into at least 2021 without turning into zombies.

15

u/Eirenarch Jan 07 '20

These dates mean nothing. What do you think will happen someone will go around all the servers and delete all flash content and also make sure to uninstall it from all the browsers?

34

u/Kyudoxp Jan 07 '20

No need to uninstall anything, every major browser will remove flash compatibility by december this year (chrome, firefox, edge and ie) so any flash content you find in the web would require either some plugin, outdated browsers or some software able to run flash.

39

u/brtt3000 Jan 07 '20

This means some pour souls will just have to login to some old-ass VM everyday to use the legacy enterprise apps.

16

u/Poyeyo Jan 07 '20

This already happens with some Java plugins to pay taxes. It is problematic for the users and for the IT people that have to make it work.

18

u/bigben01985 Jan 07 '20

What's a pour soul? The ghost of a watering can?

3

u/Vespira21 Jan 07 '20

Man, these "poor souls" will hopefully won't have to connect to a VM to fun flash, they only need to use shitty plugins or have 2 different browsers on their desktop.

-14

u/Eirenarch Jan 07 '20

So again this date doesn't mean anything as they could remove it or not remove it at their own schedule anyway. Hell, iOS never added it (which is what actually killed Flash)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AnEnigmaticBug Jan 07 '20

It didn’t help it though

1

u/Eirenarch Jan 07 '20

Of course it did (in the larger sense, of course you can claim that Flash is alive today). If it did we'd be using Flash today just like we were before iOS. It also killed Silverlight.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/ferk Jan 07 '20 edited Jan 07 '20

Not just mobile, ARM support for flash is horrible in general.

Most likely this was the biggest reason iOS and Android didn't include it, not the other way around. Flash died under its own weight.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

Uh Android (on ARM) totally supported flash. Was it an amazing experience? No, certainly not. Did it work well enough for flash video players which is what 90% of users wanted from it? Yep.

2

u/davesidious Jan 07 '20

You don't seem to be disagreeing - the person to whom you responded was saying the ARM support was poor, not nonexistent.

19

u/derpderp3200 Jan 07 '20

As insecure as Flash is, HTML5 honestly makes for far worse user experiences in my experience. It uses vastly more resources, there's audio or framerate glitches more often, it cannot just be blocked as easily, you cannot try to constrain its resource usage anyhow else either.

35

u/dnkndnts Jan 07 '20

Content creation was vastly superior in Flash too. Non-coders could easily create interactive interfaces in a more-or-less WYSIWYG editor.

10

u/MjrK Jan 07 '20

There still are plenty of animation/game webdev tools that are WYSIWYG... Play Canvas, Unity, and Adobe Animate are good examples.

20

u/st33d Jan 07 '20

I work with these tools. They’re shit compared to Flash.

I know because I made Flash games for 5 years and mobile games in Unity for 5 years.

10

u/FINDarkside Jan 07 '20

Isn't Adobe Animate pretty much the same program you used to create flash programns, but just rebranded? So I don't see how content creation on flash was superior if you can still use the same program but simply select html5 as target.

15

u/st33d Jan 07 '20

Flash didn’t execute all of its code in actionscript. Some of the methods used features of the player running a C++ speeds and only slowed down by passing the data up to the player.

Searching an array and bitmap manipulation are two examples. These ran so fast that most devs would copypixels straight from memory to screen because it was blindingly fast. This is a huge issue with the current swathe of Javascript based Flash alternatives, because the canvas tag cannot compete with the speed that Flash altered bitmaps.

Thus most Flash content is impossible to translate to HTML5. It uses incompatible code, and approaches problems in a completely different way.

13

u/BandwagonHopOn Jan 07 '20

I invite you to try to make, in HTML5, any content with heavy audio and animation synchronization while also retaining interactivity. Games are one example, but a more important one is eLearning.

Developers have to constrain themselves in a way that was never an issue in Flash and still won't get the same performance and polish of a Flash presentation. And that's with programmers doing tricks to try to wrestle to keep the different parts of the browser in line. Synching audio to canvas animation is by itself frustrating.

Using JS to render content to canvas is simply not as efficient as a VM built expressly to deliver interactive, multimedia content. I've had to watch everyone - writers, animators, designers, programmers - deal with the headache of the switch over the past decade. It's been very disheartening.

4

u/FierceDeity_ Jan 08 '20

This, completely. I scrolled down to find some sanity in this assembly. Everyone wishes death upon Flash but we still havent gotten an alternative that's actually good. Somehow all people remember flash for is video...

Don't get me wrong, I would say my goodbyes to Flash if there was an equivalent thing now, but there isn't, so far.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

So you're saying the solution is... Java?

1

u/robotnikman Jan 07 '20

Arn't there already webapps which do this?

7

u/mobiliakas1 Jan 07 '20 edited Jan 07 '20

This might be true on Windows, but on Linux flash was always a problem: between old versions, audio issues with oss/alsa/pulseaudio transition or software audio mixing and video tearing. Right now with HTML5 things are still not perfect (most browsers don't support hardware acceleration for video decode) but much better than it was before with flash player. Plus you are not limited to x86.

2

u/FierceDeity_ Jan 08 '20

Flash isn't only for playing video files, somehow that's all people remember it for??

1

u/mobiliakas1 Jan 08 '20

I can't speak of others, but video was my only use case for flash.

1

u/FierceDeity_ Jan 08 '20

Well many people player games in browsers and flash was the king on that for a long time, and it would still be especially for amateur made games

24

u/SanityInAnarchy Jan 07 '20

Almost everything you said is the exact opposite of my experience.

Flash was easier to block, because usually you wouldn't lose anything by blocking it, and if you did, there was usually an obvious rectangle to show you what broke. With HTML5, it's still easy to just turn off JavaScript, and it breaks less than you'd think, but it still breaks stuff. And there were other advantages -- Flash games were the indie scene before it moved to Steam, and I don't think it has ever been as easy to get into game development and get your game in front of a ton of people as it was with Flash portals.

But if HTML5 uses more resources, that's probably a function of sites that are actually maintained also getting more bloated over time. Back when Flash was huge and disabling it saved a ton of resources, even something as simple as video playback was a thousand times faster using anything but Flash -- not just HTML5, but plain old <object> tags embedding Windows Media Player or whatever.

Flash also wasn't terribly accessible, was good at zooming everything proportionately and terrible at reflowing to the display size you actually had, and just chugged doing pretty much anything at higher resolutions. It technically had cross-platform support, but that was pretty poor, too -- towards the end, out of all the weird browsers people like to use on Linux, only Chrome supported Flash.

And since it was proprietary, only Adobe could fix any of that, and they were incredibly slow. Flash alone probably held browsers back from going 64-bit for years...

For once, I'm glad Steve Jobs was an asshole and shut them out of iOS long enough to cripple them on mobile. That was probably the beginning of the end -- not the sluggish performance, not the instability, certainly not the security nightmare, we'd probably still be stuck with it if it got a foothold on our phones.

8

u/patssle Jan 07 '20

For once, I'm glad Steve Jobs was an asshole and shut them out of iOS long enough to cripple them on mobile.

Except there was no replacement ready - HTML5 wasn't universally natively supported. 3rd party solutions like JWPlayer were needed to serve both Flash and HTML5.

2

u/SanityInAnarchy Jan 08 '20

That's just it -- thanks to Apple, HTML5 was on even footing with Flash, which also was no longer universally supported. So you had to do both, you couldn't just be like "HTML5 would be nice, but we have to support Flash anyway, and then why bother also doing HTML5?"

Which was annoying as a dev, but great as a user -- every now and then, a site got their detection backwards, and did Flash-with-a-fallback-to-HTML5 instead of the other way around. But there was a long, glorious period where simply turning Flash off in about:plugins made everything faster, and forced a bunch of sites to fall back (forward?) to HTML5.


Also, why did people even bother with JWPlayer? That's really only relevant for video, at which point... why not just give people the video:

<video controls width="720" height="480">
  <source src="/your/video.mp4" type="video/mp4">
  <source src="/your/video.ogv" type="video/ogg">
  <object width="720" height="480" data="/your/video/player.swf" ...>
    <!-- Heck, why not add Windows Media Player if they're old enough? -->
    <embed src="/your/video.avi" ...>
  </object>
</video>

No JavaScript needed, all browers at the time supported (even Firefox and their refusal to use MP4), and the browser's default HTML5 controls are IMO way better than the JWPlayer ones. I guess JWPlayer made a decent Flash player that I could drop into the above?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

Sad but true.

3

u/Jonne Jan 07 '20

I don't think I've seen it used in years, I'm pretty sure it's not installed on most of my machines. Still good news.

1

u/BloodLints Jan 07 '20

feels like Flash should have been killed off a long time ago.

Exactly. I thought they already did it tbh

2

u/agumonkey Jan 07 '20

reviving the dead to talk about killing

-7

u/penguin_digital Jan 07 '20

2017 article?

Seems incorrect. I can recall a few articles posted here about this topic roughly 3 months ago but hadn't seen anything before then.

It's old news but not 2017 old.

12

u/ferk Jan 07 '20

The article is from 2017. That's when Adobe decided to give flash 3 years then kill it.

Of course during the last 3 years there have been articles reminding about it, but the decision was taken in 2017.

62

u/AwesomeBantha Jan 07 '20

I recently picked up this beauty and can't wait to give it away at a white elephant party

6

u/match451 Jan 07 '20

I love the opossum. Play dead!

103

u/suhcoR Jan 07 '20

Why don't they open-source it?

95

u/calumbria Jan 07 '20

Already exists, things like OpenFL is common for gamedev. Dicey Dungeons on steam is built on HAXE with desktop flash.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

[deleted]

50

u/mx-chronos Jan 07 '20

It's not open source but the player has been available as a standalone EXE forever - just grab the Projector download for your OS and it can open any SWF file you've got onhand. Not a perfect solution for larger games that might be looking to load external libraries or depend on browser features, but it goes a long way for archival purposes.

40

u/Crestwave Jan 07 '20

Not a perfect solution for larger games that might be looking to load external libraries or depend on browser features, but it goes a long way for archival purposes.

The Flashpoint project aims to solve this, automatially handling things in the background of its launcher.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

[deleted]

1

u/Crestwave Jan 08 '20

Logs could help. I think I usually have to wait until the downloads are done then relaunch it unless my internet is fast. I exclusively use the Infinity version, and pretty much all games I've tried worked, and I'm on Linux, which is unsupported.

4

u/DownvoteALot Jan 07 '20

That's not open source though. Licensing may be a problem. And this means no porting to future platforms.

10

u/tigger0jk Jan 07 '20

ruffle is an open source emulator currently in development that newgrounds is planning on using

25

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

There's been a long history of different people at different times asking Macromedia and then Adobe to opensource the player.

My conclusion is that there actually is no reason. What Adobe claimed the last time they commented on this issue was that the player uses some proprietary tech (most notably, MP3 codec) that they are not at liberty to open (since it's not theirs, they have bought the license only). But, really, if they wanted to, there would've been a way around it, same way as Firefox can load proprietary video / audio codecs, if the user have them already installed.

Adobe managers were just shitheads: either too greedy, or too lazy / indecisive to do anything about it. They were too afraid to give anything away, even if it was obviously in their own interest. Here's my story of trying to get them to opensource, or just to even allow me to "clean-room" reproduce one of their "products" when they ditched Flex.

So, in order to compile any SWF with Flex compiler you need a special SWC (that's similar to object file in Linux or DLL in MS Windows). This SWC is "special" because it contains the definitions of Flash Player built-in functions, variables etc. Think about it as C headers / Java interfaces. SWC is simply a ZIP file with an XML containing names of functions in a library with their signatures / namespaces. So, understanding it is really easy. The format of SWC was never officially "opened", but, honestly, it's just a ZIP'd XML... On top of it, Adobe made the API public. So, one could, quite realistically, never open the SWC, and yet build the copy that would work just the same.

Knowing all this, I asked Adobe / Apache Flex maintainers if they wanted / would allow this SWC to be open-sourced / replicated. Adobe never honored this request, and required anyone who wanted to use Apache Flex to download the SWC from their site. Apache Flex maintainers, scared by the recent Oracle vs Google case would not rewrite the SWC...


Bottom line: greed and stupidity are the reason why Flash Player failed / was not open-sourced.

8

u/kshep92 Jan 07 '20

Flex

Ah yes, I have so many fond memories working with this platform and FlexBuilder was a dream. I never did get into Flash animation itself, but Flex had so much potential. If it had been managed better I think it might have saved us from the JavaScript hell we now face for web dev.

5

u/spacechimp Jan 07 '20

Flex really was a decade ahead of its time.

Angular now scratches that itch for me. TypeScript is practically the same language as ActionScript due to ECMA standard -- so creating components with HTML and TS feels very much like MXML and AS. There's still a lot of BS involved in JavaScript dev, but the Angular tooling hides a lot of it pretty well.

2

u/kshep92 Jan 07 '20

Not meaning to stray too far off-topic but Angular broke my heart with the release of V2. I absolutely loved working with 1.x (even with that damn $scope) but 2.x just seemed so complicated and bloated and the template syntax for bindings is weird too.

I will agree, though, that TS hides plenty of the JS BS but the trouble starts (for me) when you try to use legacy libraries or new browser APIs that don't have type support.

1

u/spacechimp Jan 07 '20

If you are able, I recommend looking at it again for what it is (a new framework) rather than comparing it to what came before. It's often just different, and not really more complicated -- and when it is, it's only to offer much more useful functionality.

The DefinitelyTyped repo is huge. It's not often that I can't typings for a library. When that does happen, the lib is still useable (it's still just JavaScript, after all), but that's a hint that the library is unsupported and there are likely better options elsewhere (like AngularJS itself).

Not sure what new browser APIs you mean. Angular internally emulates some stuff that isn't even fully baked by the W3C yet, like shadow DOM. There is also a polyfills.ts file where you can turn on/off a couple of dozen suggested polyfills for old/new stuff, or add your own.

1

u/kshep92 Jan 08 '20

All good advice, but I've found a new home with Vue for the moment and it's working out OK. Although, I'd still give Angular another look at a later point; I think I just need a new perspective on it and try to understand it a little more.

Not sure what new browser APIs you mean. Angular internally emulates some stuff that isn't even fully baked by the W3C yet, like shadow DOM

I was actually talking about TypeScript itself in this instance. I found myself having to create interfaces far too often just so the compiler would shut up.

1

u/strothjs Jan 09 '20

Unfortunately, Vue isn't as TypeScript friendly as either React or Angular. The next version of Vue is in development and one of their goals is improving the ergonomics.

→ More replies (0)

20

u/SlinkyAvenger Jan 07 '20

Greed and stupidity? More like who - out of anyone in the development chain - would want to allocate resources to refactoring decades old code on life support to decouple licensed dependencies?

How would you feel if you were a developer assigned to that? You'd probably freshen up your resume with a quickness.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

Did you read what I wrote?

I actually volunteered to do the open-sourcing part on my free time, without pay. What the fuck are you talking about?

25

u/SlinkyAvenger Jan 07 '20

Yeah I read what you wrote but you can't tell your licensee "hey I gave your code to some rando volunteer so they can remove it but it's totally cool." so I ignored that bullshit to focus on how companies actually work.

-11

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20 edited Jan 07 '20

Well, what you write is indeed bullshit... and you are very focused on it, that's true.

The code was always there. Anyone who wanted to have LAME's codecs had just to, idk, stretch their hand, and they would get it. Showing their code to someone wasn't ever a real problem.

Flash Player was decompiled multiple times by multiple people / organizations. Many had the original sources, or some version of them (Google and Microsoft, beside other smaller companies, had the sources). If Adobe realized earlier that the player is going to tank because they wouldn't get up their asses and put some effort into open-sourcing it, I bet the story would've been different. Penny-crunching combined with ultimate stupidity is what failed this project. The typical corporate "not my job", combined with managers of the player project all seeing it as a stepping stone for their next promotion is what did it in.

The Player itself wasn't a big project. I don't believe there were ever more than 10 people working on it, but, essential stuff was more like 3-4 people. AS compiler, for example, was written by one person, rendering and sound playback was, again, just one person. In terms of human resource cost, it was negligible. Having one less manager for a month would have saved enough money to do the work necessary to open-source it.

4

u/BCMM Jan 07 '20 edited Jan 07 '20

The code was always there. Anyone who wanted to have LAME's codecs had just to, idk, stretch their hand, and they would get it. Showing their code to someone wasn't ever a real problem.

LAME is open-source. The mp3 implementation they used for Flash almost certainly is not. I think the concern is the copyright on the mp3 decoder they licenced from somebody else, not the (expired) patent on the mp3 format. It doesn't matter if the whole world now knows how to make an mp3 decoder - a specific mp3 decoder is still protected by copyright. Even if this protection isn't really useful to anybody, it's still the way the law works.

Modifying the (ancient and no doubt extraordinarily messy) Flash codebase to use LAME would require non-trivial effort. It is very likely that this work would have to be done within Adobe, because their licence agreement with some third party does not permit them to show you the codebase in its current form.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

LAME become open-source very recently. They weren't open-source when this question was meaningful.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/jl2352 Jan 07 '20

really, if they wanted to, there would've been a way around it,

From Adobe's point of view, it's not if they can or cannot. It's why bother? They are the ones footing the bill and taking on the liability if it's wrong (i.e. law suits).

  • Why pay for the lawyers to audit and work out what work needs to be done to avoid legal headaches?

  • Why pay developers to rip out propriety code for new code that does the same?

  • Why do this to open source a player for a technology no one really uses anymore?

If there aren't good answers for those questions then it's a bit silly to say 'they are greedy shitheads'. Why are they paying for this instead of building new stuff?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Why pay?

Because ROI. Adobe was struggling to monetize Flash Player. Their strategy for monetization was outright retarded. They targeted large enterprise development shops for things like intranet consoles (think VMWare portal, for example). And what they wanted to sell to them is the license for Flash Builder (the Eclipse plugin they were developing). They completely missed the indie games developers, for example. Turned out that large enterprise shops are very crappy contributers: they never helped Adobe with developing its open-source products, essentially they send their reps to demand more and more new features with ever decreasing marginal utility. And so Adobe was adding half-baked features, often in contradiction to each other, instead of focusing on the quality of the product.

What they could have done differently is, for example, organize a platform for indie game developers similar to Google Play / App Store. Or, concentrate on developing few products that used Flash Player (they had crappy video conferencing software that did that, but they never invested enough effort into it). Or, they could've concentrated on FMS (Flash Media Server) that did video streaming that required Flash Player to play it. That was a huge thing at one point, and then Adobe mismanaged it into oblivion...

1

u/jl2352 Jan 08 '20

Your post is rewriting what they could or should have done. Not what will happen. I don't think any of your ideas will come to fruition today.

Why should they pay for the development to open source it today? I don't think they would get any return on investment.

Btw I'm actually in favour of it being open sourced. It's just from Adobe's perspective they are the ones footing the bill. It is rude to expect them to do for no real reason at all.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Today is too late to do anything with Flash. The ship has already sailed.

We are talking about the events from 2011 more or less, that's when it made sense to open-source Flash Player or related technologies.

-1

u/shevy-ruby Jan 07 '20

uses some proprietary tech (most notably, MP3 codec) that they are not at liberty to open (since it's not theirs, they have bought the license only).

That is a cop-out.

This part could easily be replaced with free, permissible open source code.

Adobe does not open source it because THEY DO NOT WANT TO.

A wonderful example why even the BSD/MIT style model would fail.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

[deleted]

4

u/Dwedit Jan 07 '20

That package is literally Adobe's player (32-bit ActiveX Version), plus a small player app which embeds that ActiveX control.

Perhaps you'll still be able to use Microsoft Internet Explorer to run Flash with that installed.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

Of course they did. Classic Newgrounds :)

10

u/robmcm Jan 07 '20

Contains proprietary code like video codecs etc. All that pain HTML has been going though agreeing on standards was solved in flash by Adobe taking the hit, unfortunately they can’t open source these solutions and the VM is pointless without them.

5

u/jadbox Jan 07 '20

^ this is the right answer (from an ex-flash eng)

5

u/robmcm Jan 07 '20

I’m still partly responsible for a legacy ~1m loc flex code base... 😳 😂

6

u/kmeisthax Jan 07 '20

The funny part is, Adobe actually did open-source a lot of the platform's developer tools. Hell, at one point they were trying to retool AVM2 (AS3 VM) to work as an ES4 VM for Firefox. I'd probably say the things holding back Adobe just dumping the player source on Apache (like they did Flex) is:

  1. Specific proprietary dependencies in Flash Player

  2. Proprietary content decryption technologies (RTMPE) which would need to be removed

  3. A general lack of willingness to invest time or money in the Player

That last one is kind of important. There's a point in time when Adobe said, "Flash Player isn't worth improving because we don't make money off of it". Personally, I'd put that point in time as the whole "premium features" fiasco. For those who aren't aware: Adobe planned to fund the development of AS4 and significant Flash Player improvements by gating Stage3D and Domain Memory behind a completely new revenue share licensing model. It failed spectacularly, and the resulting fallout generated more FUD than a million thoughts on Flash ever could.

There was a point in time where I think Adobe genuinely believed they were writing web standards that they could charge for. When they realized that they couldn't actually monetize the Player like they wanted, they pivoted the entire product away from that. Why develop your own browser plugin when Google is happy to just add those capabilities you need to the web itself? The end result is that the Player is some discontinued technology nobody at the company cares about, which just so happens to be ensnaring a good chunk of old Internet content.

If you're looking for a Free Software implementation of Flash, there are a couple of parallel re-implementations. During the "let's be Web Premium" era of Flash, Adobe actually published some specifications, and there were people in the Free Software community reverse engineering the SWF format before that. I'm partial to Ruffle, mainly because I'm one of the developers on it, though it's still missing a lot of functionality. There's also a few other reimplementations out there, though if I remember correctly only Lightspark is currently still being maintained and that's AVM2 only.

2

u/suhcoR Jan 08 '20

Very informative, thanks.

9

u/milnak Jan 07 '20

Likely because the code is too embarrassingly bad to open source.

-4

u/shevy-ruby Jan 07 '20

No, this makes no sense - a lot of existing code sucks.

Adobe does not release the code because they hate people becoming less dependent on them.

2

u/milnak Jan 07 '20

How does your reply make more sense? They're killing flash so they don't keep or add customers solely based on flash being open source or not.

1

u/Igoory Jan 07 '20

They have fear to someone do a better job than them.

1

u/adrianmonk Jan 07 '20

I'd kind of rather they didn't. In my opinion, the web is better if web pages use standard web technologies instead of ones based on browser plugins. If Flash were open-sourced, it could give it new life.

Maybe the momentum had already shifted enough, though, so that Flash isn't coming back even if it's open source.

-1

u/suhcoR Jan 07 '20

So what? It's a free market. People vote with their feet.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

[deleted]

4

u/suhcoR Jan 07 '20

They could still release the code they wrote and maybe the headers of external libraries. Should'nt be too much work to replace them with open source libraries with a thin adapter.

41

u/jack-tzl Jan 07 '20

gprime/albinoblacksheep/newgrounds.

All dusts in the wind man

54

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

Flashpoint is an archival project of old flash games and animations. The full package is about 253 GB extracted. According to their docs, they have about 36k games and 2.3k animations so far.

https://bluemaxima.org/flashpoint/

27

u/WTFwhatthehell Jan 07 '20

How did they deal with the thousands of games that were domain-locked?

"Is this running on newgrounds? no? throw an error!"

Ah I see, it looks like they run it in a container that always tells it it's running on the source site.

2

u/TSPhoenix Jan 08 '20

Seems like it is still changing your system proxy in order to achieve this which is far from ideal. Hopefully they find a method that's a bit cleaner and doesn't make me stick their software inside its own VM.

1

u/jack-tzl Jan 07 '20

Amazing!

1

u/endgamedos Jan 07 '20

That's a fantastic start. Couldn't find any animutations though - I hope someone digs them up.

8

u/Equal_Entrepreneur Jan 07 '20

Newgrounds seems to be doing pretty well for itself.

9

u/jack-tzl Jan 07 '20

Kongregate will lose many games

6

u/philh Jan 07 '20 edited Jan 07 '20

I have a handful of flash games up there from like 2010-2012. When they finally stop working, I'll be curious to see how much ad revenue I earned. My over/under is $2.

Most or all of them I wrote in Haxe, so I wonder if I could compile them to a different target now. I couldn't at the time because I was using a library that didn't support it, but maybe it does now.

2

u/jack-tzl Jan 07 '20

Wasm/canvas?

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

This is gutting but lets face it 95% of games on there are trash idle games

32

u/el_supreme_duderino Jan 07 '20

They’ve already killed my desire to have any adobe products whatsoever on my computer, so no big whoop.

-3

u/Timoman6 Jan 07 '20

Flash was one of the few good things from adobe

24

u/TheWabbitSeason Jan 07 '20

Because they didn't create it. Macromedia did.

8

u/Timoman6 Jan 07 '20

Ah, that makes much more sense

9

u/st33d Jan 07 '20

Flash was one of the few good things from Macromedia.

Then Adobe buried it with their shitty attitude.

11

u/p2mc Jan 07 '20

I became to dislike Flash Player, but I still love Flash program where i can make 2D animations and such.

Is Flash program also deprecated?

16

u/CasseroleOfChaos Jan 07 '20

Flash is now known as Adobe Animate and yes it still will be supported.

1

u/Il-_-I Feb 06 '20

im sorry u had to deal with that asshole reply

-5

u/TheGift_RGB Jan 07 '20

The other user asked "Is Flash program also deprecated?" but your reply starts with "yes", which primes me to expect you to say it will be deprecated, but then you go on to say "it will still be supported" [= NOT deprecated].

Why would you ever write a sentence in this awful way? Just to annoy people and make them waste their time?

9

u/Ikkepop Jan 07 '20

Bye bye z0r.de, yee shall be sorely missed :(

3

u/Muxas Jan 07 '20

oh shit i forgot about that gem of a website, i hope they can save it somehow

1

u/FierceDeity_ Jan 08 '20

http://www.pown.it/ was another one of the same kind. Too bad it's dead

31

u/imhotap Jan 07 '20

Yeah I was among those who couldn't get rid of Flash fast enough in 2010 or so, believing in "web standards" and that HTML5 would replace it. But looking at the mess that is the web stack today, I think that we just exchanged one set of technology (Adobe's) with another one (Google's). Flash enabled so many creators/non-devs to do edutainment and casual gaming apps, many of them unique, that we should've based interactive web apps on a standardized version of Flash (an API actually designed for it), and leave HTML+CSS alone for actual document-oriented web apps.

6

u/beginner_ Jan 07 '20

The security concerns are valid and it's not only flash that got ditched, it's NPAPI that they ditched which includes java applets. I also kind of hated on flash and java applets but now looking back I'm not so sure.

At work we had this one plugin (NPAPI based or activex on IE) that was crucial for us. The vendor only just this year managed to ship a usable javascript replacement meaning we had to keep a lot of apps on IE which was annoying. Here the security came with a huge price in usability namely what took forever to get to work was copy&paste into and out of that plugin. Before it just worked it needs 2 client-side installs: a local program and a chrome add-on (which must be user-installed and can't be pushed according to IT). So usability with ditching NPAPI for sure got a lot worse.

17

u/KillianDrake Jan 07 '20

Yeah the current landscape is absolutely garbage and like you said, locked out many casual devs and creators. We needed a single package system which combined a web safe compiled language, content system and a vector-based UI system which could run outside of the context of the browser but within a sandboxed system protected from the OS. Flash and Silverlight fit all of those things.

HTML sucks, Javascript sucks, having hundreds of random files to build a website sucks, nodejs infesting the client-side is the worst thing to happen to web development in the history of the world. I can't see how anyone thinks this is better than downloading a single file which provides everything needed to run an immersive app.

3

u/FierceDeity_ Jan 08 '20

Fuck yes nodejs and npm made everything worse (lol node_modules), the frameworks are all bloated as fuck, reddit new design runs slow as ASS... It's all fucked... And powered by Google.

5

u/bedrooms-ds Jan 07 '20

I like that idea. Why did W3C thought we should build app UIs with a text document markup language...

15

u/imhotap Jan 07 '20

Not sure W3C is to blame for killing Flash (they just acknowledged XHTML2 was a failure and accepted WHATWG's HTML5 at the time). Back in 2009, HTML5 rocks! was all the rage, and Apple not allowing Flash on iOS wasn't exactly helpful. In the beginning, it wasn't preceived as Google's sinister master plan to own the web but got support by lots of parties in the name of "open web standards". The idea of retargetting markup languages + JavaScript + browsers as universal UI was pervasive everywhere in the 2010's, and still is, regardless of the existence of much saner alternatives.

1

u/bedrooms-ds Jan 07 '20

Fair point

2

u/jl2352 Jan 08 '20

Why did W3C thought we should build app UIs with a text document markup language...

They didn't. They actually had very different ideas on how the web should go.

The reality was that people were building UIs for the browser. That's what developers wanted to do. WHATWYG then pushed through standards that made developers lives easier.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

You can have a browser without Flash but you can't have a browser without HTML+CSS+Javsacript (or the backend VM with WASM). By moving the functionality of Flash into the existing stack there is one technology stack with one attack surface.

The useful thing about open standards is they last longer than the company that drove them. Mosaic then Netscape then IE then (almost) FF then Chrome have all been the 1,000 lb Gorillas driving standards at one point. When something comes to replace Chrome it doesn't have to hope that Google keeps updating the Google Player to be able to support websites from that time.

1

u/FierceDeity_ Jan 08 '20

Chrome is almost the Google Player nowadays. Blink, Chromium, all it's based on is Google, Google, Google.

1

u/Uberhipster Jan 08 '20

cannot upvote this enough. so agree with this

the coolest thing about Flash was the authoring tool which allowed non-technical people to create and publish to the web animated and interactive experiences

the gripes about Flash player as a security problem and non-indexible-by-search-engines were valid but the gripes about Flash authoring tool being cumbersome for development were totally pointless

then MS tried to marry the approach with XAML/Silverlight except the authoring tool UX was a complete abortion for non-technical people thereby missing the whole point of the authoring tool; so instead of putting peanut-butter into chocolate they did the complete inverse and introduced all the drawbacks of Flash without any of the benefits

tl;dr; what HTML5/canvas/SVG is lacking is a (good UX) authoring tool which will give the Flash-like authoring and publishing experience to non-technical people

0

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

[deleted]

5

u/spacechimp Jan 07 '20

As you point out, those are "newer" features, so you can't always count on a browser supporting them and must plan accordingly.

The beauty of Flash was that it was a consistent engine. If your browser supported plugins, you would get the same experience (for good or bad) on any machine. No complaints from marketing about "the app doesn't look like the artist's comp on the client's machine with IE6!" HTML still can't do synchronized animation as well as Flash did 20 years ago, and JavaScript is a duct-taped mess -- but that's all we're left with.

Additionally, the Flash desktop software allowed many non-programmers an easy introduction to animation and interactive programming. This again could be both good and bad: It created a golden age of great original web content, but allowed for the easy creation of crap content as well.

15

u/pjmlp Jan 07 '20

To all celebrating Flash death, it is pretty much alive.

https://www.adobe.com/products/animate.html

And then there is https://docs.unity3d.com/Manual/webgl.html and similar.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

I think people are celebrating the death of the Flash plugin not the death of the content creation tool. See comments such as https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/el2w1b/adobe_will_finally_kill_flash_in_2020/fdgaygr/

1

u/Nobody_1707 Jan 08 '20

Flash in this context specifically means .swf and the VMs needed to run them.

1

u/pjmlp Jan 08 '20

I bet Adobe can eventually release a SWF to WASM compiler, given that Flash supports AOT compilation to native code anyway, it would be only a matter of adding another backend.

4

u/WarpedDiamond Jan 07 '20

Pro tip, you'll still be able to load anything flash with Internet Explorer 11. Yes, this sucks, but I'm in the boat where we're using Oracle software for another 2 years, and it needs flash.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

1

u/ProgramTheWorld Jan 07 '20

RIP Flash. Flash was literally what got me into programming and eventually my career.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

And Chrom{e,ium} with the PepperFlash plugin. Slackware 14.2 has it under the AlienBob repo, by installing Chromium you'll get a set of packages with the browser, the player and the Widevine plugin.

15

u/theineffablebob Jan 07 '20

I love Flash

26

u/Zardotab Jan 07 '20 edited Jan 07 '20

Designers loved the control of placement. None of that unpredictable inconsistent "auto flow" of HTML layouts. (Bootstrap is gonna focking turn me grey. Oh, I am grey already.) Unfortunately the Flash player grew too complicated too maintain well, inviting hackers galore. Java applets suffered a similar fate. If your plug-in tries to be a full virtual OS, you will relive history and become history.

41

u/caspervonb Jan 07 '20

> If your plug-in tries to be a full virtual OS, you will relive history.

Which is what browsers are trying to be now.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

I can‘t wait till all the react bullshit dies. Why does any program need 10 seconds to start nowadays.

7

u/DrudgeBreitbart Jan 07 '20

React done right does not suffer those problems.

12

u/dominic_failure Jan 07 '20

A damned shame nobody* does it right then.

  • nobody that matters, at least.

/s

5

u/arkaodubz Jan 07 '20

what are you talking about, my static marketing site definitely needs react and a colossal redux store

1

u/Zardotab Jan 07 '20

If it requires rocket science to do basic common CRUD or (what should be) simple UI's, something is wrong with our standards, or lack of. Why is the learning curve 100x what VB classic was yet we don't get 100x the features/benefits. I don't even think it's 2x. More like 1.2x.

3

u/IceSentry Jan 07 '20

It doesn't require rocket science, the problem is managers forcing ads and tracking scripts on developers.

0

u/Zardotab Jan 07 '20

Capitalism runs off of slimy marketing, for good or bad.

1

u/IceSentry Jan 07 '20

If your website takes 10s to start you have a much bigger problem than react.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

Not even talking about websites… every program from text editors to browsers is nowadays built on some shitty js framework

0

u/IceSentry Jan 07 '20

Electron uses browsers not the other way around and vscode proved that its possible to make an application with more than enough performance for most use cases this way. And as I said, this isn't a react thing in that case it's an electron issue.

2

u/FierceDeity_ Jan 08 '20

It's kind of sad that only one application was able to prove that and somehow most others are fully incapable of doing it.

Something is wrong here when everyone needs to take the ONE app that does it right as an example to defend all the rest.

Oh yeah you can write very clean gui applications with assembly, too bad only like 0.5% of developers are capable of pulling off such a feat. But the technology isn't bad!

1

u/IceSentry Jan 08 '20

Vscode is just an easy example. There are other good examples, but it's the only electron app I actually use. There's also discord which is decent, except a slow startup.

I've been working on a basic electron app for visualizing robots made with ros. There's as not been any performance issues related to electron. It isn't that hard. It's just that companies make electron app because it's cheaper and there are more devs that "know" javascript so we end up with shitty electron apps in those situations.

2

u/FierceDeity_ Jan 08 '20

I would argue that Electron is still like fitting a square into a circular hole... I mean, so is everything application focused made for html and js. As an aside, lately I had discord start up into a rectangular box saying 504 Bad Gateway (came from cloudflare) lol

Hm, actually Electron reminds me quite a lot of what Xerox wanted to do in the 80s with GUIs. They basically used PostScript (pdf is based on postscript for example) as the language for Gui Elements, a language meant for printed pages. It actually looked cool even tho your typical GUIs looked like, well, printed paper with buttons.

Just like almost everything calling itself app in the html5 space looks like hypertext on steroids.

A lot of my gripe is that for most of these apps, the user isnt really an important piece anymore. The user gets whatever gui the gui designer thought would be cool, with it's own design and own usability. Kind of gone are the times where the OS would have some kind of UI standard and programs would follow it. Now, electron apps in particular look native nowhere and are alien rectangular boxes everywhere. Hell, things like gtk allowed the user to specify if ok or cancel comes first in a dialog. But hey, dialogs are only css fake now. Also colors like if you had some vision problems. It took a long time for html5 thingies to actually follow system settings for colors. Its all gone because of the no-alternatives self-reinvention of web programmers into desktop programmers by refusing to learn more technologies. I also liked having multiple or detachable windows in chat programs, but that isnt cool enough for the world anymore.

Sorry for the rambling but we just lost so much on the way to have devs feel better and cost less to develop software for companies because since you can now fulfill every role (from db to admin (devops), from front to backend dev) you became so much more replaceable to companies.

1

u/LinAGKar Jan 07 '20

You can use absolute positioning in CSS as well, if you don't want the layout to adapt.

3

u/Zardotab Jan 07 '20

I and others have found inconsistencies across browser versions, vendors, and OS settings, such as under user DPI variations. DOM/CSS is not intended to be used with absolute positioning and thus is not carefully vetted/debugged/documented for such.

Note that if absolute positioning worked well on the client side, the server could do much of the adapting (UI flow) calculations. Thus, lack of client-side auto-flow (device size adaption) is not necessarily the same as coding or designing via absolute positioning. But at least Flash gave the option of a designer using absolute positioning. With DOM/CSS you don't even have that option because browsers don't really support absolute positioning, per above.

Web standards limit where we can locate our positioning abstractions. SVG was partly intended to solve that, but then you have to "invent" your own form controls, such as drop-down boxes. Position systems and UI controls should be orthogonal issues. The web standards "did it wrong".

3

u/lowbeat Jan 07 '20

Oh great, can't wait for all the support tickets on how to start Flex application and why it isn't working anymore.

8

u/shevy-ruby Jan 07 '20

Hmmm.

While everyone is on the HTML5-video hype train, it should be pointed out that many old flash-applications do NOT have a full equivalent in HTML5. So effectively mankind lost software that was working very well.

I can think of some games and some animations that disappeared. Isn't it strange how innovation tends to kill parts of what has worked before?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

What can not be accomplished with JS that flash was able to do?

12

u/wrecklord0 Jan 07 '20

Anything can be implemented in anything, it's a matter of ease of use and efficiency. An animator without decades of programming experience could do amazing things in flash, they can't in JS.

6

u/Dwedit Jan 07 '20

High-performance vector animation with synchronized sound, which is what Flash was exclusively used for before version 6.

SVG rendering in browsers is still not as high performance as Flash Player 4's ability to render vector graphics.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

High-performance vector animatio

Not at bigger scales.

3

u/adrianmonk Jan 07 '20

I had to read it twice, but I think the key word is that they do not have equivalents, not that they could not have equivalents.

1

u/Bergasms Jan 07 '20

What can not be accomplished with writing assembly that js was meant to do?

1

u/Saithir Jan 07 '20

Weren't there efforts to save or archive these?

https://bluemaxima.org/flashpoint/ for example.

1

u/Igoory Jan 07 '20

There is some work being done to rewrite flash open-source in html5 (by fans) so I think It will not be lost

4

u/spidermonkey12345 Jan 07 '20

Where were u wen flash die?

2

u/shield1123 Jan 07 '20

I will be crossing my fingers that our rewritten app is at feature parity and is as serviceable to our users as our flash app 😬

5

u/StrangelyBrown Jan 07 '20

Have to catch him first

3

u/Saithir Jan 07 '20

Good. And like 15 years too late.

2

u/DoctorStephenStark Jan 07 '20

What Professor Zoom couldn't do, Adobe will do!!

2

u/PM_ME_UR__RECIPES Jan 07 '20

So is there any plan for some kind of third-party flash interpreter or something? I like to go back and play old flash games every now and then, and I don't want to have to hunt down some old version of a browser with flash support to play them in the future.

4

u/tigger0jk Jan 07 '20

Yeah, newgrounds is planning on using ruffle

3

u/cleeder Jan 07 '20

Seems like they have a long way to go based on the ReadMe

2

u/MCShoveled Jan 07 '20

I thought Steve Jobs did that in 2007.

1

u/nikibobi Jan 07 '20

Unless something happens and the timeline changes

1

u/Zach_Attakk Jan 07 '20 edited Jan 07 '20

Well there goes our tax returns...

Context: Our online tax returns load a document in an embedded Flash player that you then have to complete and submit When Chrome auto-blocks it I have to allow and refresh the page. I need to do this once or twice a month for company tax.

1

u/shield1123 Jan 07 '20 edited Jan 07 '20

I work for a company where our main product was written in action script (for good reason at the time). We're hurriedly working toward redoing it in html5/js

We're on track, but it would be awesome if this article said 2021

1

u/r2bl3nd Jan 07 '20

It's still alive?

1

u/seven_seven Jan 07 '20

Does that mean browsers will stop allowing it as a plugin?

1

u/socratesTwo Jan 07 '20

It's like if I went to a graveyard, dug up a casket, pried it open, shot the remains of whoever in the head, and then got charged with murder. Adobe, good of you to do this, but really, Flash has been dead for a long, long time.

1

u/KamikazeHamster Jan 07 '20

Is there anything like it now? I know HTML5 is supposed to be the replacement, but does it have the tooling that made Flash easy to code/animate? Is there some HTML5 tool that does tweening and whatever other functionality EASILY available?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

DC gonna be pissed

1

u/nmatff Jan 07 '20

Thank god, fucking finally.

1

u/Gravybadger Jan 07 '20

Twenty years too late.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20

It will be like finding our that the guy at my grandmother's shops died.

1

u/DuncanIdahos5thClone Jan 07 '20

Sorry, Flash still exist?

1

u/ElliotsRebirth Jan 07 '20

Excellent! Death to Flash!

1

u/HR_Paperstacks_402 Jan 07 '20

Chrome has been annoying the fuck out of us with notifications when you launch for a long time now.