r/programming • u/magenta_placenta • Sep 20 '19
'Everyone Should Have a Moral Code' Says Developer Who Deleted Code Sold to ICE - Seth Vargo wrote code used in a platform called Chef. When he learned ICE was a customer, he wrestled with ICE using code he had personally written
https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/mbm3xn/chef-sugar-author-deletes-code-sold-to-ice-immigration-customs-enforcement45
u/Hrothen Sep 20 '19
It's funny to watch people react to this, as if Open Source wasn't a political movement in the first place.
6
u/schneems Sep 20 '19
Yup, half the comments in here trying to re-define open source to be about what ideals they've placed on the people's code they use while ignoring the ideals of the creators.
0
Sep 20 '19
[deleted]
3
u/snowe2010 Sep 20 '19
that's definitely not it, else you wouldn't have at all. it would just be OSS or not-OSS. But of course there are licenses and restrictions, and they do dictate what you can and can't do with the software.
32
Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
As the years pile on, of being subject to the unreasonable demands of end users, the more exceptions I start finding in my moral code.
27
u/ScientificBeastMode Sep 20 '19
Maybe you should catch those exceptions and handle them?
15
4
u/guygizmo Sep 20 '19
Whenever my moral code throws exceptions, I try using another valid moral code until I find one that works.
def resolve_moral_quandary(situation): solutions = [] methods = [find_solution_using_categorical_imperatives, find_utilitiarian_solution, find_solution_using_virtue_ethics, find_solution_by_doing_unto_others_as_i_would_have_others_do_unto_me] for resolution_method in methods: try: solutions.append(resolution_method(situation)) except MoralityError: pass if len(solutions) == 0: raise MoralityError('What the hell should I do?') return solutions1
u/myringotomy Sep 20 '19
That's a horrible thing. Literally your morals are for sale.
Basically you are saying you have no morals and will do anything for money.
1
Sep 20 '19
I'd personally draw the line at selling peoples personal information to ad agencies. But I can't speak for everyone.
2
u/myringotomy Sep 20 '19
Are you sure you would draw that line? What if a customer demanded it and offered you a fat contract?
→ More replies (3)
32
Sep 20 '19
I don't understand what the idealized end goal of this philosophy is. What organization is going to rely on software that may have support unilaterally removed simply because a third party decides to use the same software and piss off a contributor? What is your response if a CIO points to this as an argument against adopting an open source tool?
13
u/azhtabeula Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
You would ask the developer for a modified license like IBM did for JSLint.
2
u/schneems Sep 20 '19
What is your response if a CIO points to this as an argument against adopting an open source tool?
I think that's exactly what this developer would want. They would want other organizations to question to use Chef or not based in partly because of his actions. This was an act of protest. I can't claim to know the motivations, you'll have to ask the protestor.
What organization is going to rely on software that may have support
An organization that keeps a healthy working dialog with that community and who is responsive to their needs. The fact that this wasn't handled privately via Chef and the author is a failure on Chef's part. You protest when you're not being heard. If you truly hear your vital contributors then you shouldn't have much to worry about.
-21
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Your response should be, "you planning on doing any evil shit? Working with any evil companies? If not, then you probably don't need to worry about those uppity developers and their damned ethics"
28
Sep 20 '19
But it's not you. It's some other random user of the software. He didn't brake it for ICE, he broke it for everyone.
3
u/free_chalupas Sep 20 '19
This is, imo, analogous to supporting workers participating in a strike even if it temporarily inconveniences you. We all benefit in the long run from a world where software isn't used to support evil.
-16
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Well, maybe everyone who got broken should give a damn who they're in business with.
12
Sep 20 '19
They aren't in business with ICE.
-1
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Chef is
5
Sep 20 '19
So you want to ghettoize software to where every user audits the user base of every tool they adopt and demand that objectionable users be expunged? This is a terrifying hellscape you are describing.
→ More replies (1)6
u/sheepsy Sep 20 '19
So you're saying my non-US company, which has nothing to do with politics, should be hurt by this change too?
4
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Sure. Consider taking this opportunity to reconsider your Chef support.
4
u/sheepsy Sep 20 '19
The person who, somewhere else in this thread, said that this is a step back for open source was right. All this does is make open source flaky and scary in the minds of most people.
And I say this as a total supporter of the movement to bring light to what's going on with the kids in cages.
→ More replies (2)6
u/schneems Sep 20 '19
What I am hearing from these people is that not only are they entitled to my free work forever, they demand that I provide that work with no opinions or ideals. As long as I’m a loyal OSS lapdog they will love me, but if my protest inconveniences them for a second then they turn.
Choosing OSS is a politics decision, choosing to work on OSS is a political decision. They shouldn’t be surprised when it turns out there are political consequences to working with those that commit atrocities.
2
Sep 20 '19
Yep. What you’re seeing is the angry parasites that demand we release code but never upset their delicate sensibilities.
You’re not allowed to be outraged at having your shit be used by monsters because ... trollish bad faith reasons. Gotta remind you this is the same subreddit that thought Stallman’s pro-CP writings and Minsky defense was A-OK. So it shouldn’t be that surprising.
Same subreddit also went “Well James Damore has a point about women being less capable in composing software”, if we’re gonna dig up the previous times /r/Programming went full redcap.
5
u/ScientificBeastMode Sep 20 '19
That’s not how open source works. Anyone company or individual in the world could be using some open source tool to do ordinary business things. And none of them are even slightly related to each other in any way. If I download and use free software, I’m not “in business with” all the other random entities who happened to do the same.
-1
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Participating in the ecosystem of a tool is business. That's why Chef runs as a OSS tool. They only get money from enterprise agreements, but still get a huge amount of value from a broad community of OSS clients.
1
u/ScientificBeastMode Sep 21 '19
Sure, but I could start a company whose sole mission is to murder innocent children, and then start using & patronizing Webpack. That doesn’t mean every other company that uses Webpack is somehow “in business with me”.
→ More replies (3)0
Sep 20 '19
[deleted]
2
u/TikiTDO Sep 20 '19
It's still important to understand where the line of responsibility starts and ends.
This wasn't a person that actively worked to seek out ICE, and offer services to them.
This is someone that put up some openly available software, which was used in conjunction with another piece of openly available software, which was managed by an organization, which has a person cross-employed in another organization that appears to have had a support contract with an IT department inside a government institution which is also home to another department that manages a facilities where some heartless assholes did some horrible things. That's about as close a relation as your father's brother's nephew's cousin's former room mate.
So where does the chain of responsibility end?
Should I also feel morally responsible because I sometimes purchase things from an organization that pays taxes in the US, a portion of which may be used to fund ICE? That seems like a much more direct relation, but I'm not sure if that means I'm morally obligated to stop submitting PRs to open source projects. The authors of some of those projects might even be US citizens, which means they directly pay those taxes.
0
Sep 20 '19
[deleted]
2
u/TikiTDO Sep 20 '19
It's a big deal because it raises a lot of good questions about moral responsibility that programmers have to the world.
This one person clearly felt they had this responsibility, but is that a normal reaction? Is this something that we as a profession should strive for, or should we look at this as an outlier? If it is desireable, at what point should we consider it to be a moral responsibility to act? At what point should we consider it immoral not to act?
I don't care about chef, or chef sugar, or any of these libraries. I've written my own library to manage the infrastructure for my clients, and that library is under my control, and not beholden to much of anyone. In other words, I'm not going to be bothered by the annoyance this might cause people I've never met, nor do I care whether this guy takes down his code. I'm interested in the effects this might have on the field in which I work, and I'm hardly the only one that thinks this way.
A few people in this thread seem to be of the opinion that this topic isn't up for discussion, because this is purely one person's decision. However, this person is still someone representing our field in the media, and the acceptable lines of behavior is something we will need to figure out eventually. I don't feel the need to avoid such a discussion just because I'm not directly related to this matter, and you clearly feel the same way given the passionate way with which you respond.
-2
61
Sep 20 '19
His "moral code" is counter to the entire philosophy of OSS. You can either believe in open source, or you can believe that you should be able to unilaterally decide who can use your software.
52
u/Hrothen Sep 20 '19
I disagree, he pulled his repository. Anyone currently using the code would still have it, and full legal rights to modify and keep using it. The fact that chef apparently did not have their own fork and was just pulling from github is their problem.
6
u/ifonefox Sep 20 '19
They have one now. Git makes it pretty easy to clone a repo. https://github.com/chef/chef-sugar
27
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
He didn't break any OSS philosophies. That's why he pulled the code wholesale. It's not OSS now.
An actual breach of OSS principles would've been to re-license it to say "everyone except ICE gets to use this"
8
u/schneems Sep 20 '19
That would still have been in the spirit of free software, which does place requirements on end users.
5
u/brtt3000 Sep 20 '19
And even then it is debatable what that breach of OSS principles is worth. Does it matter? It is software. With a licence.
2
u/schneems Sep 20 '19
Does it matter?
It mattered to that developer who did this. It mattered to the thousands of people talking about this on the internet now.
Did it stop ICE, no. What does a protest need to accomplish to be considered effective? You'll have to ask the protester.
1
u/DavidsWorkAccount Sep 20 '19
An actual breach of OSS principles would've been to re-license it to say "everyone except ICE gets to use this"
From my understanding, that's what he's wanted to do.
1
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Uhhh well then your understanding is wrong. He is no longer hosting the software, for anyone.
3
u/schneems Sep 20 '19
Would have been the same effect, they still could have gone to an older copy of the software without that provision, forked it and still maintained it.
-6
u/Richandler Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
'No one except himself,' is no different. Also super narcissistic.
7
12
u/schneems Sep 20 '19
Hey, major OSS contributor here. Ever heard of the GPL? It is literally a demand on the users for how they can use your software.
Being pro OSS is about sharing, it’s about community. It’s not about letting everyone walk all over your personal set of ethics no matter what.
What do you maintain? What do you contribute to? How many hours, how many years of your life have you given to open source? How do you want someone else telling you what you can and cannot do with that time?
→ More replies (1)-2
Sep 20 '19
The GPL and OSS are not the same thing at all. If you were active in discussions during the 1990s you already know this.
OSS diverges from GPL on this exact issue.
1
u/schneems Sep 20 '19
Christ. I KNEW this was coming. Of course, I know it's not GNU-oss (best read with sarcastically mocking sounds). Your username is extremely appropriate for this conversation.
1
Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19
I'm flattered by everything about this.
By the way, since you KNEW this was coming, did you want to take any time to clarify what you said? Because it seems like you KNEW your comment was basically confusing two issues that you KNEW you were confusing.
It would be really great if you'd explain what you actually mean by community, if you say you are "pro OSS".
After all, you are a major OSS contributor. Contributor. You are a contributor, a major one.
What do your major contributions mean to you, and what stance do you take on your influence on the downstream?
I mean, c'mon, we've got a perplexing set of propositions here.
You are a major contributor
Being pro OSS is about sharing, it's about community
It's not about letting everyone walk all over your personal set of ethics no matter what
What's your payout, walk me through it. Is it about swagger on Reddit in 2019, is that the payout? What's going on for you, why are you such a major contributor?
I'd like to know the man behind the curtain. I'll level with you, I think you have a conflict in your value system, something known as cognitive dissonance.
I think you are suffering the following confusion: that your contributions, thrown into the bucket, have earned you a place at the table. On that score, you're partly right. Further, that your time spent on those contributions has earned you the right to rescind your contributions. And on that score you're sorely mistaken.
Software can't be taken back. Sorry. You might have written scads of code, inspired by a beautiful vision of great social progress. Time well spent, gather your wood. None of the other villagers are beholden to you for your largesse.
So it goes.
You will defend your record by claiming that you have helped X developers to write, reason about, and deploy many Y lines of code. You were contributing, after all. But now you want to defend your major contributions against those who might -- for reasons nobody except those persons understand -- use it for their own orthogonal purposes.
This suggests that you were not -- may never have been -- a contributor.
It calls into question your understanding of community. Is it only of like-minded people? That is an enclave.
You will have to grow into a larger understanding of what your engagement with technology means. No other options exist. How large is your community?
Had you, at some point, understood the fundamental conflict between GNU and OSS, you might have resolved your cognitive dissonance long ago. GNU was meant to protect the programmer against indemnity, and to foster a legal environment where software contributions were protected from proprietors. That was an achievable goal, but the larger community preferred to make money (and pump professional reputations).
I want to know your idea of community, because apparently you haven't the slightest idea how powerless you are.
If you were around during the 1990s for this conversation, and you didn't support the idea of The Largest, Broadest Community for socializing protected legal rights for programmers, then huh.
If so, then you fucking deserve to have every line of code you ever wrote stolen from you and abused for every malign purpose that your value system abhors. If you just wanted to be a bigshot in social software and comfort yourself you were helping people to get beginner code onto cloud platforms, then whatever.
19
u/free_chalupas Sep 20 '19
If OSS implies that you have to support all of the users of your code, no matter how kinds of atrocities they commit, then maybe that's a problem with OSS and not with Seth Vargo.
17
u/IMovedYourCheese Sep 20 '19
You don't have to "support" anyone. The code is out there, that's it.
→ More replies (6)13
u/free_chalupas Sep 20 '19
Without getting into semantics about "supporting", he found out that his code was being used for something he found morally abhorrent and decided to do his best to prevent that. I don't see what's unreasonable about that.
2
u/IMovedYourCheese Sep 20 '19
The problem with that line of thinking is that now if I publish an open source library, am I implicitly supporting all its users? Is the onus on me to do gatekeeping and keep unwanted actors away?
6
u/Prowler8513 Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
Yes, in the sense that we're all responsible for what we cause, even indirectly, or under good intentions. Most of us choose to ignore this. This person didn't. Good on him.
2
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Is the onus on me to do gatekeeping and keep unwanted actors away?
There's a reasonable middle-ground to be struck. Seth didn't do sniffing around to find this transgression, a government watchdog dug it up and posted it on Twitter, where he happened to see that.
I think it's extremely reasonable to not bother actively sleuthing, but to react when information is presented to you.
1
u/free_chalupas Sep 20 '19
There are obviously limits on how far this goes, but this guy's code was core to a project being used by an agency whose conduct he finds morally objectionable. This is not "I wrote an npm library that's 10 steps removed from the CIA" it's "I wrote a facial recognition library that the Chinese government is using to track Uighur dissidents".
→ More replies (1)0
u/mewloz Sep 20 '19
if I publish an open source library, am I implicitly supporting all its users?
No. And that means you can delete your public repo when you want.
Is the onus on me to do gatekeeping and keep unwanted actors away?
Neither. But you can try to do it if you want to.
0
u/KevinCarbonara Sep 20 '19
If OSS implies that you have to support all of the users
WAY off topic already.
1
u/_Oisin Sep 20 '19
I believe in general that OSS is good and a good idea. I think the world would be a better place if every company opened their code base.
The thing is we don't live in utopia where code is open and the government is just. We live in a hellhole where someone pulled code so that it wouldn't be used by a government institution that imprisons children.
I respect someone for the desire to resist a force that imprisons children far more than someone that would turn a blind eye in the name of OSS.
Will what he did make any difference? No, but fuck ICE anyway.
3
u/nfrankel Sep 20 '19
And OSS is also the fact it had absolutely 0 effect because Chef already provides their own repo. It cuts both ways...
16
u/Rival67 Sep 20 '19
This is an exercise in futility. You can't control the morality of users who use any product be it software or physical tool.
26
9
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
It's not about the users. It's about Seth. It's his code.
11
u/Atheuz Sep 20 '19
Subject to the terms and conditions of this License, each Contributor hereby grants to You a perpetual, worldwide, non-exclusive, no-charge, royalty-free, irrevocable copyright license to reproduce, prepare Derivative Works of, publicly display, publicly perform, sublicense, and distribute the Work and such Derivative Works in Source or Object form
7
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Yep. That's the license. What's your point?
-2
u/Atheuz Sep 20 '19
You made it sound like he could control his code, which given the license he can't really do. Or more accurately he can't prevent anyone from copying his code and using that moving forward. He cannot legally prevent anyone from using the code or creating a fork of it, so this seems like a symbolic demonstrative gesture.
13
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
No, because now his name isn't in the mud anymore.
I don't get why you people have such a hard time processing the idea that someone might have ethics
3
u/eikenberry Sep 20 '19
so this seems like a symbolic demonstrative gesture.
It is exactly that. He wanted to make the statement that he wouldn't support it anymore and that's just what he did. He never made the claim that they couldn't use it.
1
u/electricenergy Sep 20 '19
But they didn't fork it. If they did they wouldn't even have this problem.
4
1
Sep 20 '19
Sounds about right. No clause of "Original contributor must keep his own copy accessible and keep contributing indefinitely." He pulled only what he was sharing because he doesn't feel like it.
It's still open source, still can be distributed, used and people can still make new versions.
2
2
u/free_chalupas Sep 20 '19
You can however try to influence companies who sign huge contracts with government agencies that put children in cages
1
19
u/ThrowRA000123 Sep 20 '19
"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing."
That CEO is one huge shithead. It doesn't matter that "his work with ICE began during a previous administration." Glad the developer deleted the code.
29
Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
"While I understand that many of you and many of our community members would prefer we had no business relationship with DHS-ICE, I have made a principled decision, with the support of the Chef executive team, to work with the institutions of our government, regardless of whether or not we personally agree with their various policies,
This is basically “We’ll support the government no matter what monstrous actions it does”.
I don’t have to remind my fellow programmers of the Red Scare, WW2 et al to point out that really horrible things happened at behest of a lawfully elected government deciding to indulge in torture, arbitrary detention (and later murder).
We’re not powerless - we can refuse to enrich, employ, support such people. You’re part of the public, and the government rules at the consent of the public - you have a voice!
4
u/ThrowRA000123 Sep 20 '19
Not to mention "principled" means "acting in accordance with morality and showing recognition of right and wrong."
So their morals are to support an organization like ICE. Wow.
8
u/deja-roo Sep 20 '19
Wow. I couldn't even make it through that article. Getting a headache from rolling my eyes so many times.
3
5
u/TheSimkin Sep 20 '19
If i make a hammer and someone uses it as a murder weapon, I have no moral obligation to stop making hammers, or to recall all the hammers I have made. Nearly everything can be used for good or for evil. Freedom of speech and free software does not imply no evil will come from it. I feel that he was stupid to delete this code, especially considering copies of it exist and at best it will inconvenience everyone who used it while stopping nobody from performing any evil acts.
26
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Of course you don't have an obligation. The ACLU didn't sue Seth to take down his code.
He wanted to.
How dare people have principles!
9
u/IMovedYourCheese Sep 20 '19
You personally may not have a moral obligation. Some other developer may realize that they do have one. That's how morals work.
1
u/jaehoony Sep 21 '19
You missed the point by a long shot. You may not have moral obligation but you do have the right to stop making the hammers and this guy exercised that right.
0
-3
Sep 20 '19
But if you sign a contract to supply a murder org with hammers and they use those hammers to commit murders, you are kinda partly responsible.
0
5
Sep 20 '19
Sounds like a lot of melodrama and histrionics, not to mention grandstanding, considering they're still using the platform and that all they are is an immigration law enforcement agency. We're supposed to be rational as developers... right?
20
u/azhtabeula Sep 20 '19
There is a limit to how rational you can be, though the limit is a lot higher if you use doubles instead of floats.
34
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
You're right, people should only do things if they can alter the course of history single-handedly in the process. Also, personal morals are irrelevant. You should only do things if it makes me feel better.
→ More replies (1)-7
Sep 20 '19
Where is the morality in trying to undermine the immigration law of your country and undermining the welfare of your fellow citizens and countrymen in the process? This isn't a cut and dry question and it's annoying that this article (and guy) want to pretend it is. Should be especially relevant for us and the whole debacle with H1B and wage suppression in our industry.
4
u/Erog_La Sep 20 '19
Where is the morality
How about not supporting an organisation that locks children in cages?
I love how Americans are so keen to equate not supporting whatever awful human rights violations as being a traitor.
→ More replies (1)9
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Where is the morality in trying to undermine the immigration law of your country and undermining the welfare of your fellow citizens and countrymen in the process?
You can't possibly be this dense. C'mon. Try harder kid.
→ More replies (8)6
u/Madsy9 Sep 20 '19
Rational? Sure. But rationality without at least some empathy and solidarity is dangerous. Being empathetic towards others and caring about ethics isn't the same as being irrational. Rationality can guide us in finding answers, a moral compass decides the goals.
2
Sep 20 '19
I am empathetic, I also believe in law and order, and no amount of pathos based, hysterical arguments are going to change that. I don't trust those who willingly deceive and a lot of the recent narrative about ICE has been just that. They aren't doing anything that they haven't been doing for the past 20 years, if you take issue with the law focus on changing that.
•
u/ketralnis Sep 20 '19
Please keep submissions on topic and of high quality.
Just because it has a computer in it doesn't make it programming. If there is no code in your link, it probably doesn't belong here.
1
2
u/netbioserror Sep 20 '19
So moral code is explicitly "progressive" and opposes immigration law enforcement? I sincerely hope this board isn't full of political hacks as blatant as this guy. We'd have to shut down every open-source project.
8
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Being against child-concentration-camps isn't really a "progressive" thing. It's a "not shitbag" thing.
0
u/netbioserror Sep 21 '19
“Concentration camps”? Are people on this board so stupid as to buy the shit spewing from the mouths of kleptocratic hackjobs?
Detaining foreign nationals present on our soil without our consent and in violation of our laws until the soonest such time that they can be deported, with beds and supplies (in spite of best efforts to boycott their provision), is hardly working them to death mining in frozen slave camps out in Siberia or pushing them into rooms to be massacred in batches via horrendous poison gas death.
Doesn’t help that after a month, Flores consent decree requires their release. If you want to know why the detainment centers are overcrowded, that’s why. They have a free ticket into the US if they wait for a month in detainment.
1
0
Sep 20 '19
[deleted]
8
u/babblingbree Sep 20 '19
They were immoral when Obama used them as well. That doesn't really go counter to anything happening here.
6
7
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
What's your point?
0
Sep 20 '19
[deleted]
→ More replies (3)4
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
sigh you really have no clue what's going on down there, huh?
→ More replies (8)5
u/takeonme864 Sep 20 '19
ICE has done a lot of bad stuff and isnt held accountable
https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-citizens-ice-20180427-htmlstory.html2
Sep 20 '19
what government agency hasn't?
3
u/takeonme864 Sep 20 '19
supreme court hasnt really tortured anyone recently
1
Sep 20 '19
they're responsible for what a lot of the other agencies have done by their ridiculous interpretation of the Commerce Clause back in the day
-2
u/Richandler Sep 20 '19
ICE has done 0.01% terrible stuff that makes the headlines of copyrighted, closed source, profit-making journalism.
3
Sep 20 '19
A lot less actually. Considering how much headlines have been created over the course of history you would have to nuke a country or several off the map to make 0.01%
2
u/ThrowRA000123 Sep 20 '19
If "progessive" means not keeping kids in cages, then yes.
0
Sep 20 '19
[deleted]
3
u/ThrowRA000123 Sep 20 '19
Well the Economist did estimate that if everyone that wanted to move, were allowed to move global GDP would double.
Regardless of what our border policy should be, I don't see how denying them medical treatment such as vaccines, equates to shooting kids as human shields.
0
Sep 20 '19
[deleted]
1
u/ThrowRA000123 Sep 20 '19
Well in the US, the top 1% have more wealth than the bottom 90%. Sounds to me like there's enough to go around. However, since we live in Trump's America, fuck em' because they're brown right?
0
Sep 20 '19
[deleted]
1
u/ThrowRA000123 Sep 23 '19
Except BIll Gates is a horrible example. He did come from a well off family, but still contributed to the world via Microsoft in huge ways. He also has said he should be paying more in taxes. He obviously doesn't take your stance that he "earned it, so he can keep it". A better example would probably be the Walton family that inherited the Wal-Mart fortune. Do they deserve to live like Kings and Queen while there are millions of people barely making it by or even scrounging through the garbage? They were born into enormous wealth. I guess god decided they deserved that wealth more than starving children, right?
→ More replies (3)2
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Yes, we should let in all 7 billion people
You know, when you open with blatantly stupid arguments like that, it really devalues everything that comes after it.
0
1
0
u/_Oisin Sep 20 '19
Me reading your comment feels like my brain having a compilation error. Do you fucking think ICE is just?
1
u/Lenin321 Sep 21 '19
I’m not gonna comment on the article, but I’m gonna say this: I think ICE is doing a good job and is essential for deporting illegals. Otherwise this country would be overrun
-2
u/naftoligug Sep 20 '19
Does it matter what the moral code is?
8
Sep 20 '19
"Don't knowingly write code for people who put children in cages" seems like a good start to me.
0
Sep 20 '19
[deleted]
2
-3
Sep 20 '19
I think you're being pedantic. They aren't writing code "for" people who happen to use their code any more than the inventor of the internal combustion engine was inventing that "for" military dictatorships' tanks.
Fine, "Don't do business with people who put children in cages, or work for companies that do."
4
u/TikiTDO Sep 20 '19
ICE is serving their site over SSL, and are probably using Linux to do so. So the previous guy's question still stands.
2
Sep 20 '19
And if the OpenSSL developers collectively decide to halt work because of ICE, what will you say then?
It’s the authors decision to work or not work.
It is not yours.
If you’re oh so smart, take up the slack.
But your litigation of whether or not an author has control over their own copyrighted works, along with their decision to work or not work on a product, is absurd. You don’t have that right for other people - only yourself.
1
u/TikiTDO Sep 20 '19
What does it matter what I would say in that situation?
You'd have a core system securing billions of computers all over the planet falling apart at the seams. Such a move would effectively kill open source as a viable strategy for software development as no one would be able to trust any major open source project for fear that someone might decide it's used the wrong way by the wrong people, and immediately decide to take it offline. This would send us into a world of corporate ownership of code the likes of which you can't even imagine, and then you'd be the one crying about the good old days when you could just openly share knowledge.
It's not a question of who controls work. That topic was literally never brought up until you went your tirade, nor do you know my position on this topic (given that I did not say anything related to it). This entire discussion is more of an exploration of the limits of reasonable behavior for people this profession as it affects personal morality.
Instead of engaging in that discussion you managed to go from a hypothetical question attempting to understand where a reasonable intersection point of morality and professionalism is, to telling me to pick up the slack for OpenSSL terminating development because I'm "oh so smart." All the while making a bunch of statements that are not even remotely related to any point I made. That is far more absurd than the question I posed.
0
-1
0
Sep 20 '19
[deleted]
1
u/naftoligug Oct 02 '19
To be clear I'm just being a little pedantic and philosophical here, not trying to make any particular point.
But doesn't your statement,
Yes, if its a liberal moral code, it is praise worthy.
presuppose a moral code that supports liberal values? If you grew up with a different moral code you wouldn't say that, but yours would still be "a moral code."
1
u/naftoligug Oct 02 '19
Actually it just occurred to me that "moral code" can mean two different things, I think it usually is taken as short for "a code of morality" (or of morals). But it can also mean "a code that is moral" (i.e. a set of protocols that conform to morality). I was assuming the title meant the first way, which is why I was pointing out that that's too vague.
-20
u/sanity Sep 20 '19
So he vandalized an open source project he contributed to because an organization he disagrees with politically used that project?
20
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
He wrote it. He can do whatever he likes with it.
6
u/thfuran Sep 20 '19
He wrote it and then granted an irrevocable license for others to freely use it.
25
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Yep. I'm sure it's still running on ICE's servers. What's your point?
1
Sep 20 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
14
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Don't be ridiculous, he wouldn't have done it if it were useless. . Seth can now say he doesn't participate in child concentration camps. It might not matter to you, but I'm sure it improves the quality of his sleep.
→ More replies (17)9
u/ThrowRA000123 Sep 20 '19
He never promised to keep it available forever. If they have the code, they can still run it.
2
u/allhaillordreddit Sep 20 '19
...and?
→ More replies (6)9
Sep 20 '19
You apparently are a slave once you open source, according to the unreasoning demands of parent comment, and must never upset your “customer” because the customer thinks they’re always right. /s
10
u/babblingbree Sep 20 '19
An organization he disagrees with morally and ethically *
2
u/free_chalupas Sep 20 '19
but how will we have a Fair and Balanced conversation about this without phrasing like he disagrees with their stance on tax policy
→ More replies (1)-7
u/queenkid1 Sep 20 '19
Still doesn't justify the vandalism.
let's say you work at a glass-making factory, making planes of glass. One day, you notice a political party has built a building using the glass from your factory. Enraged, you go around the neighbourhood smashing all glass panes from that factory, because you don't like that one person using it. Unless it's apart of your contract that you can break the glass at any time (which is a great business strategy), then it's vandalism. Whether you made the pane or not, you made that pane knowing it could be shipped to anywhere. You didn't make them sign a contract saying that their use was dependent on whether they agree with you politically. You just gave the glass to anyone who wants it. Doesn't make it okay to vandalise it later when you change your mind.
2
u/babblingbree Sep 20 '19
Software isn't like glass, and pulling an open source repo is not like "vandalizing" other people's property. You're drawing an analogy that sounds worse to make your case.
0
u/queenkid1 Sep 20 '19
pulling an open source repo is not like "vandalizing" other people's property.
How is it not? You distributed it with a clear open source license, unless it says you can revoke it whenever you please, you can't. Licenses are made to set a clear relation between contributor and users. If you don't add a clause that says "you must agree with me politically" then you can't revoke access to all your users because of it. Most open source licenses say that you must provide source code to those users, that's the whole point of open source.
So by all means, disagree. Do whatever you can to stop them. But don't be an asshole and do it after the fact, write a clear license to accomplish your goals.
1
u/babblingbree Sep 20 '19
The dev can't go back and change his initial decision about licensing. His choices in the present are either to pull the repo for everyone, or continue allowing his repo to be used for work he finds morally objectionable. Of the two decisions, i think it's perfectly reasonable to think of the first one as less of an asshole move.
→ More replies (3)15
u/ThrowRA000123 Sep 20 '19
disagrees with politically
Really? Would you stand by if a grown man was hurting a child just because you only "disagree with him"?
-12
u/thfuran Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
Would you smash every window in that man's neighborhood with a brick wrapped in a flyer telling everyone how much you don't like him?
13
u/jrhoffa Sep 20 '19
Is that what's happening?
13
Sep 20 '19
Notice how that person flew into a rage by phrasing it as the developer attacking open source.
The open source the developer in question authored.
Sometimes I’ve worried about entitled users and dismissed it as a non issue, yet here we are seeing exactly that entitlement and spin doctoring. Lol
-2
u/queenkid1 Sep 20 '19
The open source the developer in question authored.
What license was it distributed under? Did it say "I can revoke your use and the use of EVERYONE at any time, because of one person who uses it"?
If there is no clause like that, then it doesn't matter who authored it, deleting it is harmful to the entire idea of open source.
If the Linux Kernel dissappeared off of the face of the earth tomorrow, because "China uses Linux, and we don't want them to" do you think that would be good for open source? It's harmful to the entire idea of a license, if you choose to revoke it at any moment, for everyone, because you don't like ONE person using it.
So by all means, have a moral code. But put that in your license. Because otherwise, you're breaking an agreement you signed. Is honesty and responsibility apart of your moral code?
→ More replies (23)-1
u/queenkid1 Sep 20 '19
He deleted the code for everyone, not just ICE. It wasn't a targeted attack, he took down lots of Chef customers. So yes, I understand why they're making that analogy.
If you worked for a company who used open source software, and suddenly it disappeared one day, through no fault of your own, because the author removed it for political purposes, that's a shitty situation.
2
u/jrhoffa Sep 20 '19
I'm not understanding what is his obligation to these people. He has not destroyed anything that is their property; they should still be able to use their own copies of everything.
If anyone's production code relied on externally hosted dependencies, that's a different (and major) engineering problem.
1
u/queenkid1 Sep 20 '19
they should still be able to use their own copies of everything.
There are lots of open source licenses that they open source code will always be available. That's the point of open source, so people can contribute to it publicly.
that's a different (and major) engineering problem.
That's on Chef. This guy submitted code to be apart of the project, they implemented that code in their software they gave to clients, and he magically revoked their license to use it after the fact, with no notice. He attacked all their users who had a valid license, not just ICE.
→ More replies (5)6
Sep 20 '19
That's such a sad way to see it...
9
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
Convenient tho, if you're a redcap and need a way to rationalize yourself into sleeping at night
-2
Sep 20 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
0
Sep 20 '19
It’s not inaccurate, but it fails to acknowledge the nuance. It’s like saying no one should protest, because it inconveniences people.
1
Sep 21 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
1
Sep 21 '19
We agree on this then! But I don’t think what was done is simply vandalizing, and that’s the point.
1
-3
u/Isvara Sep 20 '19
He has neither the right nor the ability to prevent anyone from using his code. That is the nature of open source. All he's really done is cause the URL and the maintainer to change. So since ICE are likely to continue using it anyway, perhaps a better move would have been to relicense it with a clause that limits its use by "bad" actors. That way, they wouldn't be able to use any improvements to the official project, and would have to implement them themselves if they wanted them.
5
u/tevert Sep 20 '19
I don't think you really understand what he did or why he did it...
0
0
-15
u/reinaldo866 Sep 20 '19
So woke! So brave!, now all he needs to do is to destroy the US nuclear arsenal or give the nuclear codes to the Chinese Communist Party, because historically evil white pigs stole and appropriated the gun powder! -SJW & Alphabets
0
-1
u/suid Sep 20 '19
I see the same "philosophy" in the actions of hyper-passionate and shallow-thinking "activists" everywhere.
Here, for example, in the deeply (politically) blue SF Bay area, you see "activists" who think along the lines of "if I'm feeling passionate about something, everyone else should, too, so I'll just go and block a freeway".
Bitch - as a life-long Democratic voter, I'm not going to be "more energized" to follow whatever the fuck you believe in; I'm just going to curse you and whatever cause you're foaming at the mouth about.
Screwing over a large user community because you want to make a big breast-beating-in-public gesture ("virtue signaling") is the best way to turn me away from whatever you believe in, even if I was sympathetic to your cause before..
-1
-13
-9
u/exorxor Sep 20 '19
Is Vice owned by Google? Who the fuck cares about a random developer?
Which person within vice.com thought it was a good idea to publish this?
I am not going to read the article.
4
2
u/crazazy Sep 20 '19
Vice isn't known for their high quality journalism. A good example of that would be their anti corporate spin on r/sbubby
-2
u/skulgnome Sep 20 '19
rms calls this "censorship envy". It's entirely without irony that the story is run in VICE.
72
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
Regardless of the politics, if your system goes down (as they say in the article) just because some third party decides to pull their project from github, your system kind of sucks.