r/programming • u/veridicus • May 27 '10
Analyst reports that Visual Studio will support native Mac OS development, and will be announced by Steve Ballmer at WWDC
http://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/stories/2010/05/24/daily79.html66
May 27 '10
In other news, analysts say monkeys might fly out of their collective butts.
Color me skeptical.
16
u/cosmo7 May 27 '10
Previous Apple decisions that people were skeptical about:
Macintosh
Alliance with IBM
Switching to PowerPC
MacOS / OS X transtition
Switching to Intel
4
u/wafflesburger May 27 '10
Why were people skeptical of switching to Intel? It seems to me like there was no real choice..
19
u/ronnoch May 27 '10
2
u/wafflesburger May 27 '10
I don't even mean in hindsight though.
2
u/cp5184 May 27 '10
The pentium 4 was utter crap, nobody knew that core was half decent, and core 2 was 20% better then half decent.
Plus IBM was literally days away from releasing a laptop suitable version of the 64 bit G5, and it was utterly retarded of Apple to support non AMD64 chips. They would have saved themselves tons of trouble moving to x86-64 instead of moving first to x86 and then to x86-64.
5
u/hortont424 May 27 '10
Plus IBM was literally days away from releasing a laptop suitable version of the 64 bit G5
for like 2 years...
1
u/cp5184 May 27 '10
The 11W dual core 970FX was released July 7 '05. The first intel Mac came out Jan 10 '06.
2
u/ZachPruckowski May 27 '10
I think his point is that IBM had been promising G5 laptops were "a few months away" since the introduction of the G5. Ditto on "3GHz within a year!", which didn't happen. So Apple decided they couldn't rely on IBM to keep up with Intel with desktop and especially laptop processors.
1
u/cp5184 May 27 '10
And Intel had been promising that the P4 wasn't utter shit since before november 20 AD 2000, but it was utter total shit from that day to october '05, and until the last one was sold. It was expensive, hot, wasted energy, and had terrible performance.
At the block level, it's very difficult to distinguish the Intel Core from the PowerPC G4.
→ More replies (0)2
u/yasth May 27 '10
Everybody who kept up with things knew the core was the alpha and the omega, because it was based on the Pentium M line, and that was murdering things left and right. I know for a fact that entire corporations threw out their deployment schedule just to get cores instead of pentium 4s.
2
u/cp5184 May 27 '10
core was no faster the it's AMD counterparts. Core 2 came out about a year later and was much larger, with more instruction units, 64 bit mode, and had a 20% performance advantage.
Any corporation that switched immediately to core would have had more pie in their face then Bill Gates (who literally got a pie to the face).
1
u/yasth May 27 '10
Core was a fair bit better than the AMD counterparts, especially if you are working with one of the big OEMs which were just not competitive selling AMD.
→ More replies (3)3
May 27 '10
Because people used to believe...
Backwards compatiblity above all else
Usable VMs are decades away
3
u/mbuckbee May 27 '10
I think people were skeptical because it went against the general Apple manufacturing trend of owning/controlling the entirety of their intellectual property.
8
u/trianglenose May 27 '10
Apple did not own the IP behind PowerPC and neither Motorola or IBM were willing to let Apple dictate processor design.
Apple was not a big enough customer to get Motorola to push the G4 chips to be powerful enough for modern computers (like, a faster than 166Mhz front side bus) since Motorola sold PowerPC chips mainly for embedded systems which do not demand the same kind of power.
IBM was never willing to invest the capital necessary to make the G5 smaller and cooler so Apple could put it into a PowerBook because Apple was the only customer for it, and not a big enough one.
So the switch to Intel did not impact the amount of technology they owned or controlled.
1
u/mbuckbee May 27 '10
I think maybe I should have said "product lines" instead of "intellectual property" as I think it derailed the point I was trying to make, which was that Apple is zealous about control.
Your point that Apple wasn't a big enough customer get Motorola to do what they wanted is really interesting because switching to Intel put them into a position of even less leverage. I'm not saying it wasn't the right decision, I'm just saying that it was not part of their ideal playbook.
1
u/s73v3r May 27 '10
Maybe, but Intel was already doing what they wanted. Plus, they had to be a customer of some size, as they were able to get some of the Intel chips first, and be the ones to debut them.
1
May 28 '10
Your point that Apple wasn't a big enough customer get Motorola to do what they wanted is really interesting because switching to Intel put them into a position of even less leverage.
Not too sure about that. I suspect that Apple got a very good deal; they're the only major Intel customer who isn't required to use the Intel Inside branding, and they have tended to get certain new chips and chipsets before everyone else.
-1
u/_Tyler_Durden_ May 27 '10
Apple never owned nor controlled the PPC.
The only thing Apple had slight control over in the PPC mac days were their motherboards, and chipsets. The CPUs, graphics chips, etherenet, drives, etc... were off the shelf like everyone else.
Apple, manufactures very little actually.
The intel switch was expected by everyone in the industry with an iota of common sense. There was absolutely no value proposition left for the PPC on the desktop. The only ones in denial is the weird hardcore Mac fans, who are obsessed with their computers... but who, ironically as it may be, know very little or nothing at all about computers themselves. I can't think of a sadder existence...
4
u/gecko May 27 '10
Just before the transition, I thought it couldn't happen, and I don't feel as if I know nothing about computers.
Common sense at the time was that PowerPC could not be decently emulated on an Intel chip. Combined with the fact that (let's be honest) the x86 architecture is flat-out disgusting compared to POWER and its derivatives, and the fact that a lot of people assumed that an adoption of x86 also meant an adoption, willing or not, of allowing Mac OS X to run on off-the-shelf PCs, and I think there was a decent mix of reasons to doubt and reasons to want to doubt.
At this point in time, I think the Intel transition will effectively prove to have been temporary; ARM-based chips clearly seem to be the future of Apple's existence. And here, they really can "fully" dictate the design of the chip, due to the mix-n-match licensing process of ARM SoCs.
1
u/Podspi May 27 '10
Combined with the fact that (let's be honest) the x86 architecture is flat-out disgusting compared to POWER and its derivatives.
Say what you will about x86, performance of x86 derivatives are fantastic. They're cheap to produce, and power efficient.
adoption of x86 also meant an adoption, willing or not, of allowing Mac OS X to run on off-the-shelf PCs
This is more or less the case. Heh.
I don't think ARM is apple's future. ARM doesn't have the performance characteristics x86 processors do, and Apple does not have the skill or resources to compete in the high-performance CPU market. (Hell, unless Bulldozer amazes, I will have to conclude the same thing about AMD too)
1
u/joshuag May 27 '10
but who, ironically as it may be, know very little or nothing at all about computers themselves. I can't think of a sadder existence...
That's quite a leap that you've made there, Mr. Durden.
1
u/ggggbabybabybaby May 27 '10
I think a lot of people misunderstood a rumored Intel switch to mean Mac OS X would suddenly become an OS you could install anywhere instead of only on machines blessed with an Apple logo.
I remember around that time I was still praying for the rumored portable G5 that wouldn't endanger my crotch.
1
May 27 '10
I remember around that time I was still praying for the rumored portable G5 that wouldn't endanger my crotch.
Funnily enough, IBM introduced a G5 for portable computers a couple of weeks after the Intel announcement...
3
u/specialk16 May 27 '10
Not only that, but this really isn't a big deal. MS is still the biggest 3rd party dev for Apple.
I mean, it's ok to like Apple and all but some people just take things a bit too far when they decide to blindly hate other companies, even when their cult leader has even said that MS doesn't need to fail for Apple to succeed.
17
May 27 '10
Nothing brings people together faster than collective hate of the Other.
2
5
u/cosmo7 May 27 '10
I remember Jobs saying that.
From Apple's point of view, the biggest expansion they can now make would be into the corporate space. That would be much easier in alliance with Microsoft.
2
u/specialk16 May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10
True. I for one think, if the rumors of VS coming to OS X are true, it will be great for devs that want a unix environment but need MS tools. I for one still depend on an XP VM in Linux but this would really make me consider getting a Mac.
Plus, Apple is also moving on to the mobile space, I wouldn't be surprised if they begin to prioritize their iPhone OS on top of OSX.
I think it would be fun if they take it on a personal level, like if Jobs says something like "I know people will be surprised about this.." or "I know you guys wont like this at first..." "...but here is Steve Balmer!"
And then Steve Balmer makes the now classic developers, developers, developers joke.
6
u/captainjon May 27 '10
While I would love to have VS on OS X instead of using X Code, but the rumours you speak of are the reverse. VS for Windows will allow one to code in Objective-C for OS X, iPhone, iPod, iPad and it will (cross)-compile code to the above mentioned products.
1
0
u/cp5184 May 27 '10
Whoah! Wait a minute! You're saying that Microsoft makes Microsoft office? Who'd believe THAT?
1
0
3
1
u/planetbeing May 27 '10
Am I the only who instantly throws out whatever statement is being made as false if it is claimed that it was made by an "analyst"?
-1
u/insomniac84 May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10
What is the issue? They want people to use visual studio for development. Adding iphone makes sense. The OSX support was probably something that just went with it.
They make much more from a license for visual studio or office than they do for a copy of windows.
This is actually very smart. Since it will destroy the need for OSX just to develop for the iphone. It breaks apple's small little closed circle. And helps sell visual studio because people can make their windows mobile apps in it and their iphone versions.
0
May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10
The issue is Apple is fanatical about maintaining control of the development environment. Microsoft is fanatical about platform lock in, and is currenlly building their own phone OS.
It is possible Apple has strong armed Microsoft into going along with a deal that allows them total control, and Microsoft thinks iPhone OS is a big enough threat they have to play nice with them, but I'll believe it when I see it..
4
u/insomniac84 May 27 '10
Microsoft is fanatical about platform lock in
By Microsoft you mean apple, right?
Microsoft is fanatical about platform lock in, and is currenlly building their own phone OS.
Microsoft has had windows mobile for like 15 years. They are just making a new version of their phone OS that doesn't have separate mobile frameworks. Now the mobile phones will have the same frameworks as the desktop.
1
May 27 '10 edited May 28 '10
You are correct of course. I mean a phone OS that doesn't completely suck and can probably compete in today's market.
Android, Palm's WebOS, iPhone OS, and BlackberryOS all beat the crap out of any previous version of Windows Mobile. Heck, even classic Palm OS was (is?) better..
1
u/insomniac84 May 28 '10
Windows mobile beats it out hands down. Why? The business apps. Now for consumers, it sucks. Even when someone has a business phone, they still take it home and use it outside of work. This is microsoft's mistake. Not catering to the regular stupid person. Most people on reddit would be fine with a windows mobile phone and like it. But people who don't know how to turn on a computer won't.
1
May 27 '10
Microsoft is fanatical about platform lock in By Microsoft you mean apple, right?
You jest. If Windows and Office did not lock people in, there would be no money for Microsoft to make.
-1
u/insomniac84 May 27 '10
I don't see how windows locks you in. Use something else if you want to.
Office has a mac version. So again, no lock-in.
Integration and ease is what microsoft is selling. Everything works together better if you use all of their stuff. Email, office, OS, etc.
Apple takes it further with hardware locking, peripheral locking, online store locking, browser locking, etc.
4
u/s73v3r May 27 '10
Office has a mac version. So again, no lock-in.
Except a lock-in to MS Office.
0
u/insomniac84 May 28 '10
So you consider open office to be a locked-in app by being on all platforms? Really? Multi-platform to you is locked-in?
1
-1
u/kleopatra6tilde9 May 27 '10
How old are you?
-1
u/insomniac84 May 27 '10
I was born before 2008, I have lived in a world without an iphone and I don't praise apple. Unlike you.
3
u/kleopatra6tilde9 May 27 '10
MS used windows 95 to kill other office suits because the other player were programming for os/2, the official successor of win 3.1.1. Since then, Office is the only alternative if you want to get the job done (Try OpenOffice with a huge spreadsheet).
The Mac Version has no propper VisualBasic support (not verified, I just read it somewhere).
2
u/insomniac84 May 28 '10
Lol, microsoft killed os/2 by existing. What an evil thing to do. Win the market by being better. Tsk, tsk. You are too much of a fan boy to understand common sense.
1
u/jussij May 27 '10
If you want to know what killed OS/2 it was IBM and not Microsoft.
The story goes that IBM had OS/2.0 ready to go 2 years before Windows 95 but because it neded a 386 to run, they delayed it's release.
Two years later out comes Windows 95 which also loved the now common 386 chips and it made OS/2 1.3 look like crap. Out came OS/2 2.0 a few months later but by then noboby cared.
1
-1
May 27 '10
In the past Microsoft was focused on the Windows tax. Everything had to either promote, or at least not harm, the sell of Windows.
Now that the desktop OS is becoming less important, Microsoft is looking to have the Windows and .NET brands everywhere. This was a major focus of the last two PDCs.
So while I have my doubts, I can see this happening as the natural next step for Visual Studio and .NET.
1
May 27 '10
You can use .NET on OS X now with Mono. It's amazing.
-10
u/cp5184 May 27 '10
It's like java but crippled. Microsoft. You will be assimilated.
want to make a fuss because you want to make me out as saying .net is crippled and not that mono on os x is crippled? go fuck yourselves.
2
0
4
u/mycall May 27 '10
The market value of Microsoft has fallen by more than half since Ballmer took over as CEO from Bill Gates, dropping from $556 billion to $219 billion as of the close of stocks on Wednesday.
Didn't Microsoft pay there stockholders tons of their capital a few years ago? I'm wondering how that affects their valuation today.
2
u/_Tyler_Durden_ May 27 '10
Dividends and market caps are two different things.
One (Dividends) are real, or at least as real as something based on a fictitious thing such as money/capital is likely to get. Where as market cap is completely fictitious...
4
u/Keyframe May 27 '10
Not really.
http://twitter.com/Microsoft/status/14850981422
Microsoft: Steve Ballmer not speaking at Apple Dev Conf. Nor appearing on Dancing with the Stars. Nor riding in the Belmont. Just FYI.
7
u/mschaef May 27 '10
They've done this before, back in the mid 1990's:
http://groups.google.com/group/comp.os.ms-windows.programmer.misc/msg/e21babf1761aec0f?hl=en
One of the reasons Word 6 for the Macintosh was such a disaster is that Microsoft took the Windows version and used a portability layer to migrate it to the Macintosh. (Prior to that, it had been purely native.) Microsoft briefly took the portability layer, packaged it up with a version of Visual C++ (with an appropriate toolchain) and sold it as a Macintosh development platform. The selling point was what you'd expect: transparent portability of Windows applications over to the Mac. Ironically enough, this is one of the experiences that likely has Jobs worrying about iPhone development platforms and portability layers.
6
u/ehnus May 27 '10
iTunes for Windows is another example of disastrous results of using application compatibility layers.
3
u/mschaef May 27 '10
Agreed... to the point I almost mentioned it myself.
if you want a 80-90% fidelity application, a portability layer is a good way to achieve it. (Not that 80-90% can't be good enough for the vast majority of applications.)
11
6
1
May 27 '10
MP3 players and other assorted handheld gadgetry aside, microsoft and apple aren't really competitors on the computer front anymore since so many people install windows on the computers they buy from apple, even if just to do a handful of things. Additionally, these people are all paying the full price for windows, unlike the people that buy an HP or Dell and are hardly paying MS a dime.
9
u/veridicus May 27 '10
The OEM price (the so-called "Windows tax") is $25 to $50 per machine. Hardly "hardly paying MS a dime".
2
u/jordan0day May 27 '10
I'm not sure if you're complaining about the extra $25 or $50 a machine potentially costs, or if you're just pointing out that MS makes money when you buy an HP or Dell.
While I completely think you should be able to buy a machine from an OEM sans-OS, the $25 to $50 on a reasonably priced desktop or laptop goes pretty much unnoticed. At least for the typical consumer.
For large purchases buying a lot of machines, well yeah, that adds up. They probably have their own ways of finagling cost savings, though.
3
0
May 27 '10
[deleted]
2
u/Ziggamorph May 27 '10
They aren't really direct competitors. Apple sells computers, Microsoft sells operating system licenses. Apple more directly competes with Dell, HP etc.
-1
u/sugar_man May 27 '10
Increasingly Apple is a company focused on selling its Brand as a distribution mechanism.
-1
u/insomniac84 May 27 '10
How is it bullshit? People who buy macs can run windows on it and would do so. Some companies probably bought macs to get access to xcode and iphone development, but employees would still be booting to windows for other work.
0
u/coob May 27 '10
People who buy macs can run windows on it
is not the same as
so many people install windows on the computers they buy from apple
0
2
2
u/DAVYWAVY May 27 '10
By some amazing coincidence Steve Ballmer will be delivering a speech at exactly the same time and on exactly the same day for 7minutes at Microsoft's Teched convention.
Can he Ballmer be in two places at the same time? I dont think so.
1
u/vestige May 27 '10
Bob Muglia is giving the Keynote at TechEd
1
u/DAVYWAVY May 27 '10
That was in 2007 wasnt it?
http://www.osnews.com/story/18088/Report:_Microsofts_TechEd_2007
1
u/vestige May 27 '10
http://northamerica.msteched.com says he is the keynote speaker at TechEd North America 2010. According to http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/exec/bobmuglia/?tab=speeches he also did 1999, 2000, 2007, and 2008. I wouldn't be surprised if he has done others since he runs the Server and Tools Business division at Microsoft.
1
u/DAVYWAVY May 27 '10
thanks for the links, I didnt see that all I saw was this on the agenda which was this;
http://northamerica.msteched.com/navigatingteched#keynote
which stated
Tech·Ed kicks-off with a 90 minute Keynote Session presented by one or more Microsoft executives
That to me sounds like that it is not unlikely that there will be more than one exec speaking, and since Ballmer loves developers it wouldnt be unlikely he would be one of the other speakers.
1
u/vestige May 27 '10
Front page bottom left under "Keynote Speaker Bob Muglia"
1
u/DAVYWAVY May 27 '10
Yeah saw that in your link, the site does say the keynote will be presented by one or more speakers so it might not just be Bob
4
May 27 '10
So Visual Studio adds Objective C compatibility, or it is allowed to compile .NET to Obj. C?
7
May 27 '10
Could just be C++ support in VS too.
Because C++ is a valid language for iPad etc.
If they went .NET to Obj C, that would be a big thumb of the nose to Adobe
7
May 27 '10
You can't really do much of anything with just C++, since most of the APIs are exposed through Objective-C.
1
May 27 '10
Ah, good to know
7
May 27 '10
In theory you can use the C functions that expose the inner workings of the Objective-C runtime to call things from C++, but that is not really recommended if you're planning on staying sane.
10
u/heroofhyr May 27 '10
Fortunately, the strict C/C++ programmers on Windows have already lost their sanity from years of MFC and COM. The adjustment period will be brief and painless.
1
2
u/BonzoESC May 27 '10
You wouldn't compile to ObjC; Mac applications are just (architecture-specific) binaries:
> file /Applications/Safari.app/Contents/MacOS/Safari /Applications/Safari.app/Contents/MacOS/Safari: Mach-O universal binary with 2 architectures /Applications/Safari.app/Contents/MacOS/Safari (for architecture i386): Mach-O executable i386 /Applications/Safari.app/Contents/MacOS/Safari (for architecture x86_64): Mach-O 64-bit executable x86_64 > file /Applications/GitX.app/Contents/MacOS/GitX /Applications/GitX.app/Contents/MacOS/GitX: Mach-O universal binary with 2 architectures /Applications/GitX.app/Contents/MacOS/GitX (for architecture ppc7400): Mach-O executable ppc /Applications/GitX.app/Contents/MacOS/GitX (for architecture i386): Mach-O executable i386The XCode stack is just gcc, which supports C, C++, and ObjC (including mixed C++ and ObjC files).
1
u/cp5184 May 27 '10
All the libraries you're going to use are going to be obj-c I assume. I know you can use some libraries with non native languages but I don't know the specifics.
2
u/BonzoESC May 27 '10
ObjC (.m) files can call C without issue, and ObjC++ (.mm) files can call C++ without issue. I suspect C++ files can call into C++ functions in an ObjC++ file, which can then call into ObjC functions.
0
u/player2 May 27 '10
Well, not precisely. There are customizations Apple has made to GCC to play with the custom linker in use on the iPhone, which isn't open source.
1
u/BonzoESC May 27 '10
Well you can still use the customized gcc to work with the linker, or learn from the code to implement it in your own iPhone-targeting compiler. If Apple's gcc modifications aren't public, they're in GPL trouble.
0
May 27 '10
[deleted]
1
u/player2 May 27 '10
I should have specified the dynamic loader, which has measurbly different behavior.
3
u/repster May 27 '10
Followed by an instant announcement by Apple disallowing development of Mac applications using third party tools...
2
u/TheHodge May 27 '10
TBH I can see another announcement, the complete removal of Google from the iPhone and replacement with Bing - maps, email everything that was G is Bing/Microsoft
1
2
u/apullin May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10
Hrm... I wonder if this means there'll be a port of the .NET framework to Darwin and iPhone? Or are they actually targeting BSD/Cocoa/Aqua natively? And I guess if they're going to support iPhone, they'll have an ARM compiler in there somewhere...
edit: wow, downvoted, awesome... it's a perfectly chromulent question. If part of it's misguided, maybe saying why so would be helpful...
1
u/geon May 28 '10
The .NET framework is already working on both OSX and iPhone OS, in the form of Mono.
But since sections 3.1.3 forbids it's use, I wouldn't count on iPhone support.
If they want a piece of the iPhone cake, they'd need to support the native Cocoa touch API. It would probably be a C++ version, though, since it wouldn't make much sense to build a whole Objective C compiler just to make it work.
2
u/conmulligan May 27 '10
This will never, ever happen.
0
May 27 '10
It already has. Sivlerlight runs out of the browser on the Mac and is created using Visual Studio. All thats missing for round one is a OS X style packager.
3
u/conmulligan May 27 '10
That's not native Mac OS development, it's not even close.
-2
May 27 '10
Allow me to restate my position.
All thats missing for round one is a OS X style packager and a wrapper around the native GUI toolkit so that it.
3
1
1
u/FirstDivision May 27 '10
I don't see why so many people think that this could absolutely never happen. It's already possible with monotouch (although I'll admit that I haven't tried it yet.)...
1
u/DVSBSTD May 27 '10
If I could use WPF and .NET on the Mac too, I'd be in heaven! Sadly, that's very unlikely to happen either way.
3
u/stacks85 May 27 '10
Use Silverlight, like the new Seesmic Desktop: http://d.seesmic.com/sdp/sd2/install.html
1
u/DVSBSTD May 27 '10
I hadn't seen that before! Very interesting how they made it an out of browser only app!
2
u/insomniac84 May 27 '10
You can, just boot to windows.
This is microsoft's answer to that. Why buy the 1.5k mac when the 500 dollar windows machine can make OSX apps as well as all the windows apps you already make.
1
u/thunderballfists May 27 '10
OR you could buy a mac mini for $599 and get XCode for free.
2
u/sugar_man May 27 '10
Yeah but you have just spend $599 on a box that you may have little other use for. Depending on your requirements it is fair to say that some people are paying $599 for XCode and getting a Mac Mini for free.
0
u/_Tyler_Durden_ May 27 '10
Or you can pay $500 for the basic VS license, and get a VS cardboard box for free.
3
0
u/insomniac84 May 27 '10
Sounds like xcode is 599 then. And when you already have a PC, why would you want to do that? Also what are the specs of the mac mini? If they are worse than a good 599 laptop or desktop, you are fucking over your other development needs by buying a slow machine instead of a faster one for the money.
Honestly the real solution is to just buy a good PC and use an OSX vmware image for the bullshit iphone crap. Then move to visual studio when it gets the support. It would be stupid to waste money on over priced hardware.
3
u/thunderballfists May 27 '10
OSX vmware image
So you going to pay $129 for OSX?
for the bullshit iphone crap.
Can't wait to see the great software is going to come out of that attitude.
When it came time to refresh our development machines we picked MacBook Pros and haven't been happier.
→ More replies (1)3
u/_Tyler_Durden_ May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10
Sounds like some of you think Visual Studio is free and comes included with windows. Which is not.
The cheapest commercial license of VS will easily cost the same as the mac mini.
With apple you have to waste money on the HW, with Microsoft you have to waste money on the SW (neither windows nor VS licenses are free). It is a matter of what is your choice of poison... in the end setting up an OSX/iPhone or a Windows/VS development system will run you about the same cost.
0
u/insomniac84 May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10
The cheapest commercial license of VS will easily cost the same as the mac mini.
Ouch, you don't seem to get it. The free version of VS allows you to use it for commercial reasons. That is why it is so good. If a business has a small project to do they can hire a temp worker or an intern and that person can use the free visual studio to make them an app.
Paying for it is not done to enable commercial use. Paying for it is to get extra features that the free version does not have.
neither windows nor VS licenses are free
Both pretty much are. You buy hardware and get windows with it. The hardware is cheaper than building it yourself or paying extra for the linux option. Thus the windows is free if you buy your PCs from dell, hp, acer, toshiba, etc.
With OSX you pay more for crappier hardware and their OS. You cannot claim the OS is free, since equal hardware on the PC side is a lot cheaper. Something is making that mac cost more.
1
u/ThwompThwomp May 27 '10
So I've heard the biggest hang to porting apps from windows was the use of the Visual Studio libraries and compilers. Some of its intricacies are a bit non-standard and break when compiling in gcc. Is this a move that will speed/ease the porting of apps?
1
u/jordan0day May 27 '10
The rumor around this that has intrigued me most is the one of an "official" .NET release for OS X. If I remember correctly, there was an article a little while back (right around all the 3.3.1 outcry, I believe) where the author speculated that Apple was positioning itself to be able to rapidly switch the underlying hardware while keeping all the apps running correctly. A VM-based solution like .NET would make that even easier. Probably ain't going to happen, but how cool would it be if it did?
1
u/lolomfgkthxbai May 27 '10
The enemy of my enemy is my friend. Certainly, these companies are no friend of Google.
1
1
1
1
u/Kyderdog May 27 '10
MacBasic comes to the finally comes to OS X?
(1987 reference, from how Apple Saved Microsoft)
1
u/badsectoracula May 27 '10
From the article
The market value of Microsoft has fallen by more than half since Ballmer took over as CEO from Bill Gates, dropping from $556 billion to $219 billion as of the close of stocks on Wednesday. Apple's market cap, meanwhile, has shot from $15.6 billion to $221 billion in that time. But the software giant still leads Apple in profit and revenue. Its net income between January and March was $4.01 billion on revenue of $14.50 billion, a time when Apple posted $3.07 billion in profit on $13.50 billion in revenue.
Ι didn't knew Apple was so big!
1
1
u/ropers May 27 '10
I really hate news about future news.
The pursuit of scoops has gone way over the top.
Wake me when it actually happens, and if and when there's actual news to report. Until such time, please do not disturb.
1
u/bartman279 May 27 '10
Steve Ballmer not speaking at Apple Dev Conf. Nor appearing on Dancing with the Stars. Nor riding in the Belmont. Just FYI.
via twitter - http://twitter.com/Microsoft/status/14850981422
1
May 27 '10
This is a rumor, most likely false. In any event, wouldn't this be against the new developer's agreement with Apple?
1
0
u/smakusdod May 27 '10
HOLY FUCKING SHIT if this is legit. I don't care about ipad/iphone just yet, this is a major step for MS and Apple as well.
0
u/m-p-3 May 27 '10
Visual Studio support native Mac OS development
Apple update their EULA to restrict developers to their tools
...
PROFIT!
/s
-3
May 27 '10
finally, they will get some decent dev tools for OSX
3
May 27 '10
actually, all things considered, it's probably mostly going to be a port of .net for it. They already did this with silver-light, the rest of .NET would be a breeze.
http://www.apple.com/downloads/macosx/development_tools/silverlight.html
3
u/jordan0day May 27 '10
I don't know that it would be "a breeze", there's still a lot of parts of .NET that are basically thin wrappers around Win32 stuff. That said, IF .NET was "officially" ported to OS X (and iPhone/iPad), I think it would be pretty darn awesome. Mono is great, but corporate IT folks are really scared of open source stuff, for some reason.
2
May 27 '10
That's all safely contained in System.Windows and Microsoft namespaces. It wouldn't be hard to change a few things to wrap the Coacoa framework.
If using WPF on the other hand, it uses a completely different rendering engine than win32 apps. Seeing as silverlight is already available, the hard work is mostly done.
0
May 27 '10
Seeing as silverlight is already available, the hard work is mostly done.
WPF is built on top of Direct3D, they would have to port to OpenGL.
0
May 27 '10
I wouldn't say it's trivial, but It's not exactly hard either... Remember THEY ALREADY HAVE SILVERLIGHT FOR THE MAC which is essentially the UI layer. SILVERLIGHT IS NOT RENDERED BY THE BROWSER. I don't see what's so hard about this....
1
u/Tyekanik May 27 '10
Could they fork Mono and build on that? That would atleast cover most of the core OS parts.
1
u/jordan0day May 27 '10
Yeah, ideally they would do that. I'm still not sure if Mono is something that MS really encourages, or just tolerates, or somewhere in between.
1
May 27 '10
I think it's fine, until you start using the Win32 forms. Just use Mono and Qt or GTK and I don't think they really care.
0
u/Tjunkie May 27 '10
Microsoft just tweeted that it was a rumor and Steve Ballmer won't be attending WWDC or Dancing with the Star. LOL
0
u/marlinspike May 27 '10
Hey, your title isn't supported by the article it links to! If you've seen this written somewhere else, please link to that instead.
-4
u/tluyben2 May 27 '10
Microsoft has a LOT of Apple stock. And making dev tools for Mac gives MS clients they normally wouldn't have. Makes perfect sense.
3
u/acatnamedbacon May 27 '10
Microsoft does not have any Apple Stock.
2
u/gschizas May 27 '10
May it has some. But the 10% (or at least I think it was 10%) of Apple stock is long gone, yes.
1
u/tluyben2 May 27 '10
It was 10% which is a lot. Where you see that it was sold?
1
u/gschizas May 27 '10
I don't remember, it was quite a long time ago. I think the question came up in reddit and there were facts and figures and links and tigers (oh my), but it was indeed too long ago.
I guess you could find out by searching for MSFT and AAPL portfolios...
1
1
u/tluyben2 May 27 '10
Sources? Mine are a-plenty (from 1997); I cannot find any references to it being sold at all.
-8
u/IOnlyPostInROT13 May 27 '10
Jnfa'g gur Ovt Oebgure Nccyr nq qverpgrq ng VOZ naq abg Zvpebfbsg? Bgure guna gung, V'z tynq Ivfhny Fghqvb jvyy fhccbeg qrirybcvat sbe gur vSnzvyl qrivprf.
5
u/veridicus May 27 '10
The commercial wasn't exactly aimed at IBM: "Let's see - an all-powerful entity blathering on about Unification of Thoughts to an army of soulless drones, only to be brought down by a plucky, Apple-esque underdog. So Big Brother, the villain from Apple's '1984' Mac ad, represented IBM, right? According to the ad's creators, that's not exactly the case. The original concept was to show the fight for the control of computer technology as a struggle of the few against the many, says TBWA/Chiat/Day's Lee Clow. Apple wanted the Mac to symbolize the idea of empowerment, with the ad showcasing the Mac as a tool for combating conformity and asserting originality. What better way to do that than have a striking blonde athlete take a sledghammer to the face of that ultimate symbol of conformity, Big Brother?" - Wikipedia
2
May 27 '10
combating conformity and asserting originality
I can't stop laughing when I read that fragment and think about the state of apple today, or rather the state of their users
2
May 27 '10
The irony has imploded on the hipsters and now threatens us all.
1
u/econnerd May 27 '10
Actually, all that has happened is supply of irony has outstripped demand of hipsters. Let the free market (of fashion) sort out an equilibrium. We must not inject bailout (more hipsters) into the market( fashion) or bad incentives (apple's irony) will be rewarded.
2
May 27 '10
With all the people like you blathering about how Mac users are sheeple, a minority, and generally morons, you'd think you'd realize that it's actually against the grain to own a Mac and takes a bit of independence to deal with the hypocritical BS from Windows users.
The only credit I can give you is the iPhone/iPad app store and approval process, since that's about as Big Brother as you can get.
1
May 27 '10
Depends on the context you are in.
In my current job, you would definitely be a minority if you owned a mac laptop. BUT if you own an IPod/IPad/IPhone you would NOT be in the minority.
Walk through the office of our manufacturing company and you'll see tons of ipods, and iphones. (I don't know anyone who owns an IPad yet.)
I know several people who have no real knowledge of computers who own IPods and IPhones. Heck, my 60 year old mom owned an IPod. She wasn't a hippie, power-to-the-people type mom's either. Just a typical suburban mom.
I've been around of several circles of friends who could be described as your typical MacBook & Starbucks group. Far from being counter-culture or anti-assimilation.
I have no problem with apple. If you want an IPod, MacBook Air, whatever, go for it, it's your money. Plus, in the end, it's just a material object. I tend to not differentiate myself and "combat conformity" by my possessions. But the idea that giving a company that made $3B last QUARTER so that you can have the same cool device as your friends, is somehow combating conformity is humorous. Might have been their goal w/ the Big Brother commercial, but they've since changed.
1
May 27 '10
I guess I don't think of iPad and iPod owners as users, those seem like just little gizmos to me, but when I think about it as you put it, it saddens me to think that all those stupid hipsters are making us Mac users look bad simply because of the umbrella company.
PS Sorry to think you were one of those people that posts ignorant crap about Mac users.
1
May 27 '10
Not a big deal... And as I thought about the post while typing it, I realized at the time the commercial was quite accurate... Apple's (and later Macs) were hobbyists computers -- even more so than my 8088 clone :)
But I don't think that's the case anymore.
1
u/IOnlyPostInROT13 May 27 '10
V fgvyy guvax vg jnf n fgno ng VOZ. Jnf Nccyr nsenvq bs ZF-QBF va 1984?
3
u/econnerd May 27 '10
I secured your communication in double rot13:
Wasn't the Big Brother Apple ad directed at IBM and not Microsoft? Other than that, I'm glad Visual Studio will support developing for the iFamily devices.
No one will be able to break this encryption.
-1
u/IOnlyPostInROT13 May 27 '10
Tbqqza lbh, lbh qnza Fpevcg Xvqqvr naq lbhe xvqqvr unpxf!
2
u/econnerd May 27 '10
What? Not impressed with my double rot 13. fine. I'll quadruple it!
Goddmn you, you damn Script Kiddie and your kiddie hacks!
Crack that one, Mr. Alan Turing.
1
u/mycall May 27 '10
Do you have a facebook plugin for firefox? I could get my friends to use it and stay strongly encrypted ;-)
0
May 27 '10
[deleted]
1
u/IOnlyPostInROT13 May 27 '10
[Warning! This post is encrypted with Double-ROT13 for extra security] You betcha'!
-2
u/sbrown123 May 27 '10
I think they should focus on getting MSOffice ports for Mac to release at the same time as the Windows release. I just don't see MS selling many copies of VS on the Mac....
5
May 27 '10
You've got that backwards - The rumor isn't that VS is coming out for the Mac, it's that VS is going to be able to compile OS X native binaries.
-1
u/sbrown123 May 27 '10
I doubt that would happen. Apple would have to let Microsoft distribute Apple libraries. And testing the binaries would require some form of virtualization of the Apple OS in Windows. Porting VS to Mac would be better in the long run.
4
May 27 '10
I really can't envision Mac developers giving up XCode in favor Visual Studio.
2
u/atrich May 27 '10
IB is nice, but XCode as an IDE blows, in my opinion. (Caveat: only used it for iPhone development.)
1
May 27 '10
I would, I absolutely hate XCode and VS 2010 is pretty useful. That said, I can't see this happening either, not with MS shipping a phone themselves later this year and it's hard to believe that MS would have been able to keep something like this quiet.
1
u/daviangel May 27 '10
Can't believe people would fall for this. I mean VS2010 doesn't even have support for XNA or DirectX "officially" yet and we are supposed to believe they have time for supporting Apple's stuff! Geez!
1
u/sbrown123 May 27 '10
Me neither. This is why I said I don't see MS selling many copies of VS on the Mac. But it is possible developers who are writing apps for both platforms could develop on a Mac if VS, and associated libraries, were ported. MonoDevelop already does this.
0
0
May 27 '10
[deleted]
1
u/mackstann May 27 '10
That's all they know how to do.
1
u/jordan0day May 27 '10
I don't know that it's "all they know how to do", but there is a fairly common saying about Microsoft: They always seem to start about 50 yards behind in the race, but they tend to run twice as fast.
0
u/_Tyler_Durden_ May 27 '10
That only works for them when it comes to bully small companies out of emerging fields/markets.
0
May 27 '10
[deleted]
8
→ More replies (2)4
u/s73v3r May 27 '10
You already can do that. Maybe if you actually looked into things instead of posting flamebait, you'd know that.
18
57
u/scmccart May 27 '10
Nope, "Steve Ballmer not speaking at Apple Dev Conf. Nor appearing on Dancing with the Stars. Nor riding in the Belmont. Just FYI." - Microsoft's twitter account, http://twitter.com/Microsoft/status/14850981422