r/programming • u/mongreldog • Sep 25 '18
Linux developers threaten to pull “kill switch” over Code of Conduct implications
https://lulz.com/linux-devs-threaten-killswitch-coc-controversy-1252/13
u/Agent_03 Sep 25 '18
I find this hilarious because the code of conduct basically boils down to "don't be a jerk: no doxing, personal harassment, or trolling."
Nothing in the Code of Conduct says you can't be brutally blunt in code reviews if someone has contributed a patch to critical kernel code and done a half-ass job of it.
And yet, people see it as "the end of meritocracy" and "SJWs destroying Linux." Is it really that hard to tell someone "this patch is full of bugs and WTFs" without resorting to slurs and personal attacks? Even Linus has apologized for his behavior and is working to change it because he simply did not realize the impact it has on people.
5
Sep 26 '18
To me it's more of who said it, rather than what it says. Sage Sharp and Coralie Ada Ehmke are political activists and this CoC will only generate more drama and friction within the community.
3
u/Agent_03 Sep 26 '18
Eh, there's always going to be someone trying to start drama in any community of a certain size. Occasionally they're right about something, but acknowledging that doesn't mean the community as a whole is suddenly going to embrace them.
2
Sep 26 '18
Nothing in the Code of Conduct says you can't be brutally blunt in code reviews if someone has contributed a patch to critical kernel code and done a half-ass job of it.
I wouldn't say that:
Examples of unacceptable behavior by participants include: Trolling, insulting/derogatory comments, and personal or political attacks
The old CoC is much closer to your interpretation.
The linux community is angry because of two reasons:
someone mentioned the original CoC - which's controversial
the ones pushing the CoC already violated multiple parts of the CoC - they called one of the core developers a "rape apologist" and insulted the community in various ways
And yet, people see it as "the end of meritocracy"
and "SJWs destroying Linux."
They're thinking about this and the racist/sexists insults towards the linux community.
1
-16
Sep 25 '18
basically boils down to
If this were day 1, you could be forgiven for thinking that. But this is year N. We've had N-1 years of this shit already, and all you're advertising with this ability to summarize the CoC is some manner of obliviousness.
10
u/Agent_03 Sep 25 '18
Actually, it's more that I've been a contributor and maintainer in a large open source project for years now and little changed when a code of conduct was implemented.
Most of us care more about building and improving something useful via code contribution and review, and by logging tickets. People that want to see everything as a personal attack will continue to see everything as a personal attack, and people that are obnoxious remain obnoxious (but stay away from crossing the line to personal attacks). As far as I know, the only person who was ejected due to the CoC was a (likely bot) that went in and randomly vandalized a bunch of tickets by changing their statuses -- and they would have been ejected pre-CoC as well.
Never underestimate the power of people who just want to get shit done! :-)
-8
Sep 25 '18
[They didn't come for my project.]
Cool story. Have you heard that Ts'o is a rape apologist? Have you heard that Linus is making way too much money from the Linux Foundation? Would you be A) pleasantly surprised--what an obvious way to benefit the community, or B) unpleasantly surprised--looks like the LF is serving the aims of others, rather than its own stated purposes now, or C) not surprised at all--this is year N after all, if the LF suddenly started spending lots of money on 'Women Kernel Hackers' outreach type programs?
2
10
u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '18
I do not think that this is possible since it would undermine all projects based on a permissive licence.
I couldn't care any less what random people say - it's important what the courts say. And so far I have not seen a single decisive case where permissive licences could retroactively be invalidated.
Copyright does not mean that forked software would become invalid at any moment in time lateron. That would completely kill ALL permissive licences in an instant - all you would need is to get the original copyright holder(s) to state that they will invalidate the licences. But this was not part of the licence originally so why should it suddenly became "active" out of nowhere?
I highly doubt that this would be a valid procedure.
7
u/Xelbair Sep 25 '18
unlikely? yeah i agree.
impossible? i am not so sure.
GPL3 explicitly states that it transfers rights, while linux is under GPL2 without that clause.
0
Sep 25 '18
[deleted]
2
u/lelanthran Sep 25 '18
I highly doubt any judge in their right mind would set a precedent like this.
Are these the same judges that slowly ratified a 12-year copyright duration to a 144-year copyright duration using precedents?
Are these the same judges that rubber-stamped the DMCA in which non-infringing material can be taken down without penalty for those lying under oath?
I wouldn't trust a judge to to make a sensible call. Not that I think that they always make nonesensical judgements, but we have plenty of examples where the courts have made clearly stupid judgements.
5
u/SemaphoreBingo Sep 25 '18
Are these the same judges that slowly ratified
Doubtful, as that would have been the legislature not the judiciary.
1
u/Xelbair Sep 25 '18
and how this contradicts anything i said?
it is very unlikely(as i said), but who knows - supposedly(article mentions that) there is already a precedent in USA.
1
u/backelie Sep 25 '18
So no guarantees.
1
u/AntiProtonBoy Sep 25 '18
Practically nothing ever is. All you can do is legal risk assessments and see whether the odds are in your favour.
1
u/backelie Sep 25 '18
since it would undermine all projects based on a permissive licence.
A permissive license gives the licensee the right to slap a difference license on it, including an unrevokable license.
Eg, anything released under a permissive license and then forked/relabelled/dual-licensed under GPL3 can't be revoked, and BSD/MIT could release new unrevokable license versions (which, unlike GPL, would be automatically backwards compatible).-2
u/warlockface Sep 25 '18
It could cost a lot of money defending various actions. In a plethora pf jurisdictions. Vs the value of the CoC, which is precisely what?
1
2
u/lelanthran Sep 25 '18
They don't need to "kill switch" existing code. They just need to fork and go their own way with the kernel.
Considering that the CoC was voted in with 6-5 vote, I wouldn't be placing any bets on which kernel becomes the new mainline kernel.
It could go either way.
4
5
1
Sep 25 '18
Already posted yesterday: https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/9idpyr/linux_developers_threaten_to_pull_kill_switch/
2
Sep 26 '18
And the day before that and the day before that and the day before that. I've seen this lulz article at least 4 times already.
-7
u/donegerWild Sep 25 '18
I love all people but seriously, these so called "leaders" of the LGBTWhatever communities need to STFU and focus on doing actual work instead of complaining about every little travesty in the name of morality. There is no end to the victim narrative and I am so tired of seeing the world descend into tribalism by the hands of these ideologues. I feel like we are all going insane! Please grow the f*** up.
2
u/mungojelly Sep 26 '18
don't use "insane" as an insult, that's harmful to mentally ill people
don't use "tribalism" as an insult, that's harmful to people who actually belong to tribes
maybe you don't like people saying to be nice because you're not
0
u/QuicklyStarfish Sep 25 '18
Okay
2
u/donegerWild Sep 25 '18
yeah okay my comment had a certain amount of pent-up angst baked in, should have left that out.
-4
u/Cuddlefluff_Grim Sep 25 '18
It's interesting that /r/Linux and /r/Programming seems to focus entirely on what GPLv2 permits and not, and not the bigger social impact of the revised code of conduct.
3
Sep 25 '18 edited Sep 25 '18
What do you expect? It's a threat to hold Linux hostage. Even if the threat isn't very credible it's still a perversion of everything the GPL stands for. That's the part of this story that's going to stick in FOSS programmers' craw, not the faux-outrage and conspiracy theories.
0
u/Cuddlefluff_Grim Sep 26 '18
faux-outrage and conspiracy theories.
I'm happy that you apparently have never encountered or seen the effects of professional victims. These types of people are a direct threat to any group they manage to infiltrate, and in this instance people with certain tendencies towards imaginary drama have been given power to expunge anyone for any reason without "trial" so to speak.
I think it's worrying that people seem to take the position against the actual code contributors, on the side of people who get places simply by displacing anyone that calls them out for the frauds that they are.
2
Sep 26 '18
professional victims
Who's paying them?
These types of people are a direct threat to any group they manage to infiltrate
For example?
and in this instance people with certain tendencies towards imaginary drama have been given power to expunge anyone for any reason without "trial" so to speak.
Which people, exactly? Who gave them power and why? What does it mean to "expunge" a person?
I think it's worrying that people seem to take the position against the actual code contributors
Who's taking that position?
on the side of people who get places simply by displacing anyone that calls them out for the frauds that they are.
Which people, exactly?
-1
u/Cuddlefluff_Grim Sep 27 '18 edited Sep 27 '18
Have you been living under a rock for the past 5 years?
Edit : ok, how about these two relevant examples in our industry https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/47ksmz/what_is_going_on_with_github/
https://techcrunch.com/2013/03/21/a-dongle-joke-that-spiraled-way-out-of-control/There are plenty more examples where groups eventually dissolve because certain individuals are apparently only around to stir up drama and make accusations towards others, and portray themselves as victims. These people are real and they are causing very real damage.
2
Sep 27 '18
Playhaven and Github are private corporations with closed-source products. Also, for the record, the Playhaven incident is six years old.
-1
u/Cuddlefluff_Grim Sep 27 '18
You believe that the dynamics of a closed-source project is dynamic and ever-evolving, but an open source one is fixed?
You admit I'm right, you agree that it happens - you just simply choose to dismiss it.
When core developers drop off from open source projects, they tend to die out fairly quickly. There is not an infinite amount of people who wants to spend their time working on Linux for free, and especially not if they are under continuous suspicion of being some sort of -ist and anything they ever say or have ever said anywhere will be used against them at any given opportunity. It's social terrorism disguised as cultural progression.
2
Sep 27 '18
No, don't be stupid. I'm only pointing out that the examples you cite don't support the argument you put forward. You want us to believe that CoC's lead to the dissolution of open source projects, but you can't point to any examples of that happening. The examples you did come up with aren't even open source projects, and didn't lead to dissolution anyway.
When core developers drop off from open source projects, they tend to die out fairly quickly.
Sure. But it's literally never happened because of a CoC.
There is not an infinite amount of people who wants to spend their time working on Linux for free
That's always been the case. I'm not sure why you think it's different now.
and especially not if they are under continuous suspicion of being some sort of -ist and anything they ever say or have ever said anywhere will be used against them at any given opportunity
They aren't.
It's social terrorism disguised as cultural progression.
Oh, so you're just a troll. Noted.
0
u/Cuddlefluff_Grim Sep 28 '18
You have not refuted anything I have said, you haven't even made an attempt.
You're a classic brick wall. It's a nice tactic - just dismiss anything the other party says and end on the note of calling them a troll. It's flawless and of course the pillar of intellectual conversation.
Keep in mind that I don't have to convince you of anything. There is no gain in it for me. You can be a brick wall, or you can actually have something insightful to say, it's up to you. I don't care, and I don't feel like wasting my time on people who just say "nuh-uh" instead of actually taking an active part in a conversation.
2
Sep 28 '18
I don't have to refute it. You're the one making the claim that there is a terrorist conspiracy to infiltrate open source projects to impose codes of conduct, and that this causes core contributors to drop off and projects to die. The onus is on you to prove it; presumably you made sure you could before you made the claim so it shouldn't be hard.
→ More replies (0)-4
u/warlockface Sep 25 '18 edited Sep 25 '18
Yes, there's certainly a negative social impact to consider with stirring up divides by pushing superficial identity above all else. A world where those who pretend to be or are brainwashed to be the most easily offended rule the roost. Yay the future!
19
u/webauteur Sep 25 '18
I'm going to switch to the Bro Linux fork because my computer will not run non-binary code.