r/programming • u/vitorgrs • Oct 24 '17
Next Visual Studio Code update will bring blue icon back
https://code.visualstudio.com/blogs/2017/10/24/theicon415
u/Saiing Oct 24 '17 edited Oct 24 '17
I think the VSCode Team have been a benchmark for how big corporations should work with the community pretty much from day one. From producing probably the best free, lightweight, cross platform code editor out there, to regular as clockwork updates and now a humorous, detailed and humble response to something that (despite being somewhat trivial) a lot of companies would have either ignored or put out some lame PR speak statement about.
Kudos to everyone involved in that team, and fair play to Microsoft for not being heavy handed about this.
17
80
u/xster Oct 25 '17
Ya seriously. The degree of transparency was shocking. Definitely not your Steve Ballmer Microsoft.
13
u/DownvoteALot Oct 25 '17
Not your Steve Ballmer dev team*
The Windows execs are still just as bad as they were, if not worse. Let's not forget that.
10
25
Oct 25 '17
Windows development has never been even close to being as open as today. Nobody says it's perfect but for such behemoth it's plenty transparent.
→ More replies (4)-24
u/VodkaHaze Oct 25 '17
lightweight
VS code is many things, lightweight is not one of them
55
u/Wartz Oct 25 '17
Compared to your average IDE, it is very lightweight.
-21
u/roddds Oct 25 '17 edited Oct 25 '17
And compared to your average text editor, it runs like a sloth high on pot.
Edit: the fanboy squad is on the hunt today. VSCode is a text editor, not an IDE. Read this, knuckleheads.
12
4
7
4
0
Oct 25 '17
[deleted]
12
Oct 25 '17
I thought VSCode was the editor and Visual Studio was the IDE.
5
u/ormula Oct 25 '17
What do you need in an application to make it count as an ide? Compilation, intellisense, debugging tools, stack trace? It has all of that. Visual studio has more, of course.
→ More replies (1)18
→ More replies (17)0
Oct 25 '17
Well I wouldn't exactly call it "lightweight", but it definitely suprised me how well it is doing
516
u/aniforprez Oct 24 '17
I really didn't care whether the icon looked blue or orange or whatever. It was functional, unique and I would maybe look at it once a day or so. I thought the people complaining were either a bunch of pedantic, nitpicky idiots or dumbasses looking to participate in a meme thread.
It's great to see the VSCode team taking the mountain of unnecessary feedback and do something constructive with it and be so transparent about it. The icons look great in blue.
264
u/pataoAoC Oct 24 '17
My troll side is tempted to start a support movement for the orange icon
114
16
u/Serei Oct 25 '17
...am I the only one who specifically likes it better orange? The blue is harder to see against the dark gray background in the macOS version; the orange stands out a lot better. And having the same color as Sublime isn't a bad thing; they're similar in functionality so having them look similar is nice.
6
u/Kaligraphic Oct 25 '17
I also like the orange better. I have regular Visual Studio installed as well, and I feel like with the orange it's easier to see immediately which is which in my taskbar.
→ More replies (2)1
u/DukeHarris Oct 25 '17
And having the same color as Sublime isn't a bad thing; they're similar in functionality so having them look similar is nice.
It is really not nice. Having both editors open at the same time, it is super hard to quickly find the correct window in the task bar.
Just look at this: https://imgur.com/a/EjIuh
I spent so much time yesterday looking for that VSCode window, thinking I must have closed it accidentally because orange==sublime
→ More replies (3)16
24
21
Oct 25 '17
I am too. I don’t see why there is such interest in bringing back blue. Should we wait until they release the old color and then revolt or should we start now?
43
13
u/sruckus Oct 25 '17
I didn’t have a strong opinion but the change was jarring for me. I keep looking for Code wondering where it is even on my taskbar. I just got used to the blue. Glad it’s coming back.
→ More replies (2)5
u/vplatt Oct 25 '17
Ditto. I actually don't care what color it is, but it confused my muscle memory. You don't change stuff like that (as in: main entry point) without some warning and a damn good reason.
1
Oct 25 '17
Orange was really jarring at first and I didn't like it. Now I'm used to it but still prefer blue. Oh well.
→ More replies (1)3
2
3
1
1
1
u/walesmd Oct 25 '17
I actually like the orange icon. It stands out as I'm Cmd+Tab'ing through things.
I was sad thinking of all the time and energy spent on that post that could have been spent elsewhere.
21
15
u/PartyByMyself Oct 24 '17
You can change the icon as well, takes like 60 seconds to do so yourself.
3
8
u/aazav Oct 25 '17
You need to suffer with the rest of us who use Xcode.
13
u/aniforprez Oct 25 '17
Man that thing is such a fucking train wreck. It really needs to cook in the oven for much longer to be an acceptable editor. As an IDE for iOS applications it's functional but I'd rather write code in VSCode than xcode
48
u/aazav Oct 25 '17
Apple just sucks ass with their release process. It's exactly as you say. This needs to be tested better before it ships, because we developers feel like their fucking beta team!
It's a god damn waste of our time and of our money. And they want us to take MORE OF OUR TIME to report what doesn't work.
Well, I don't HAVE IT, because when Xcode doesn't work, I don't magically get extra free time to report bugs that should have been caught and fixed before the product released.
And Apple's idiotic color scheme of glaring blue against 100% white sucks ASS, along with the need to animate everything in the FUCKING DEVELOPER TOOL. Jesus fuck, let us turn that shit off. Stop trying to entertain the developers! Just show us shit as fast as you can and make it look nice. If you have to animate part of the UI, GIVE US A SWITCH TO TURN THAT SHIT OFF.
It kills me that clicking a disclosure triangle on the left hand project inspector rolls down or rolls up the content of the item. Just SHOW THE FUCKING FILES INSTANTLY.
Apple has become the joke that Windows users said it was in 2001.
Thank you. I needed to vent.
18
u/aniforprez Oct 25 '17
You're... welcome... That seems to have come from a dark place
23
u/aazav Oct 25 '17 edited Oct 25 '17
That seems to have come from a dark place
Dealing with the simple "how to open a git repo" now in Xcode 9. The release notes mention that they changed things, but not how to actually do the task. Lots of misleading text and iconography on the Clone page. I hate these people.
They could have at least added text that said Clone Repository or Clone Repo…. There's a magnifying glass implying that I can search for a repo when I can't and text that tells me to add a GitHub account, which is meaningless.
Meanwhile, I have added my Mac OS server URL to the servers in Preferences which has my Git repos on the server so I can log in with my standard info. This is ignored.
I hate these people.
From the release notes:
• Source Control. All new source control navigator and integrated support for GitHub accounts to quickly browse repositories and push them to the cloud.
Nowhere does it explain HOW to get to this and how it is intended to work. "Look we changed things! Guess how it works!" Bastards.
15
5
u/jugalator Oct 25 '17 edited Oct 25 '17
It's crazy to me how Apple with the budget of a fucking nation can't properly QA control an IDE for stability as well as UX. :| One that is essential to their mobile platform, in turn their most essential platform bar none. It's weird because Apple ought to be eating their own dogfood with Xcode as well, like Microsoft has done with Visual Studio. Xcode ought to be market leading, something developers dream of working with and hate working on competing platforms after having used it.
It has to be an organizational issue where they either don't even realize the problem (unlikely), how to best solve it, or how to communicate it with management, or bureaucracy leading to glacial decisions even if they realize the problem (I know at least Microsoft of old had this problem). A human rather than a financial issue.
→ More replies (1)1
u/atrich Oct 25 '17
I use XCode, Visual Studio (both the full product and VS Code) and Android studio weekly, if not daily. They're all fucking terrible. But XCode is somehow still worse than all the others.
→ More replies (1)3
u/vplatt Oct 25 '17
This gives me sympathy towards all the developers who stick to the command line + vi/m or *macs for everything. I mean they kind of assume the developer experience is going to suck so they've already gone all survivalist on it. I wonder if they even notice how bad Apple is at this sort of thing. It's got to be one of the few reasons so many apps still get produced for mobile, much less iOS.
1
14
Oct 24 '17
I like the orange icon. I like that it stands out clearly from the other Visual Studio products, which I use most of every day.
2
Oct 25 '17
I really don't care either. It took me all of an afternoon to adjust to it. Tabbing between windows was confusing the first few times until I retrained myself to recognize the orange.
I think the icons have looked great in all iterations.
1
1
Oct 25 '17
I thought the orange was ok. It's just a color. I don't understand what all the fuss was about. Blue is ok too.
→ More replies (22)1
59
u/stesch Oct 25 '17
Dear Visual Studio Code developers: Your product's biggest problem is the icon. You can be proud.
36
1
u/VoiceActorForHire Oct 31 '17 edited Jan 21 '24
compare connect sort summer agonizing oil one long fanatical desert
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
19
u/RelaxReddit Oct 25 '17
People are creatures of habit. That’s why they react to change in such a negative way. They’re used to using something in a certain way and any change upsets the natural order of things. So they push back. They complain. They demand that you revert to the way things were.
People often respond before they give a change a fair chance. Sometimes that initial negative reaction is more of a primal response. That’s why you’ll sometimes hear things like, “It’s the worst thing I’ve ever seen.” No, it’s not. It’s a minor change. Come on.
83
u/maths222 Oct 24 '17
I'm just appreciative that in reverting this change, they thought to take my issue here into account: https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/35672
I feel like in apps that aren't designed with accessibility in mind, color often winds up conveying significant information that gets lost to those of us who are colorblind, which is almost 5% of the population. In practice, designing for screen reader users requires significant development commitment and doesn't even make sense for a lot of apps, but there is no reason that almost all apps cannot be accessible to the colorblind (obviously not those which as part of their purpose/function require color)
31
u/CSMastermind Oct 25 '17
Any UI at Microsoft, company wide, is supposed to be checked for usability by colorblind people (or at least that's how it was 5 years ago).
9
1
u/tragicshark Oct 25 '17
I was also having a hard time distinguishing these. It isn't quite so bad on my desktop with a dark blue-gray backdrop but on light backgrounds like in my titlebars it is very difficult to distinguish.
61
17
Oct 25 '17
Been using VS code for about a year, basically every day. Switching between applications I must click that icon minimum 20 times a day. They literally spent 365 days training me to click the blue icon when I want VS code. Then they sneakily swapped it to see if I would notice. It's sort of a cruel psychological experiment. On the surface the color issue seems silly, but it does actually take mental effort to unlearn something like that when it's become so automatic.
11
u/ricas07 Oct 25 '17
I didn’t pay attention to the backlash, and had no problem with the orange color... but I did find myself looking for he icon in my dock and skipping right over it.
5
31
u/xxxdarrenxxx Oct 24 '17 edited Oct 24 '17
If all jeans would become orange instead of blue people would probably complain as well though, even though it's equally relevant, or irrelevant if you will.
I like both Icons, but blue as a color in general is seen by many people as a very neutral color.
19
u/xxxdarrenxxx Oct 24 '17 edited Oct 24 '17
I wanted to add that under graphic designers, color contrast is a very serious thing. Color palettes are often made in a pseudo algorithmic way and do require a belief off balance for many.
It's hard to say in this particular case if just a slight hue difference would have made it natural enough to not bother people, or if it really is because off the base orange-ey.
Firefox and VLC player are orange.. I like them orange.
Reddit has blue for names and bright orange to pop out when you upvote a post.
Black for post text, but the options for the post in grey to push it back as it's less significant.
4
1
Oct 25 '17
Aside from the first iterations, the Visual Studio icon has always been blue. It's like if the Facebook icon became orange: not really a meaningful change per se, but it creates a lot of confusion to people who are accustomed to the cemented blue icon. It slightly disrupts your muscle memory, because you always have to do a double check.
Even then, I'd wager that anyone would get over it in a couple of weeks or so if they didn't get disproportionately butthurt about it.
2
0
13
u/IMovedYourCheese Oct 25 '17
What I'm really getting out of this otherwise insignificant fiasco is that VS Code is a great product made by a small, independent team at Microsoft, and more involvement by corporate upper management coming in with words like "broader product family" and "corporate guidelines" is eventually going to ruin it. Hope they all learn something from this.
1
94
u/svgwrk Oct 24 '17
Goddamn crybabies. I like the orange one.
121
9
Oct 24 '17
I do too. It was visually differentiating from some of my other icons that I keep pinned.
4
u/btgeekboy Oct 25 '17
For me, it looks way too much like the Sublime Text 3 logo that sits right next to it in my dock.
1
0
Oct 25 '17
[deleted]
11
u/greenwizard88 Oct 25 '17
It's very similar to the Sublime icon, too.
1
u/MEaster Oct 25 '17
Microsoft have been using that infinity shape since VS 2012 version. All they did here was lop off one side.
→ More replies (2)2
Oct 25 '17
I had the same problem my dude.
I can't believe people are complaining about being orange.
Holy shit.
0
Oct 25 '17
[deleted]
4
u/TarMil Oct 25 '17
They didn't say "I prefer orange", they said "I like orange". It's possible to like several things, you know.
49
7
9
Oct 24 '17
I didn't really notice the orange icon until this post, but I do now agree that they should switch back. For Linux users (such as myself), it doesn't fit in with a dark theme or the blues and greys that most apps have their icons set to.
6
3
3
u/Elegia Oct 25 '17
1616 upvotes at the time of writing. Clearly this is what we as developers really care about /s
(Not that I don't think the blue icon looks better).
3
u/whozurdaddy Oct 25 '17
Undoubtably 30+ "designers" spent hundreds of thousands of dollars and wasted countless hours, coming up with an icon color change.
Design people make me crazy. Once, I was in a meeting where they were discussing for an hour, how the color black on the screen wasnt "black enough". yeah... 0x000000 wasnt "black enough".
9
u/LukeLC Oct 24 '17
Yes, please. The particular shade of orange they chose for the update is just gross, like it came out of someone's ear. It's a small thing, but the return to blue is most welcome.
0
17
u/jakdak Oct 24 '17
I cannot imagine caring enough to submit a support ticket on the color of the icon.
7
u/adamcw Oct 25 '17
Then you aren’t colorblind. Congrats. (I am not either, I am just pointing out UI color is not a trivial matter.)
11
Oct 25 '17
Perhaps not the color, but there are some pretty crappy icons on some pretty well known projects that I think should be redesigned.
3
2
u/Hambeggar Oct 25 '17
For example, VLC.
2
Oct 25 '17
If I were a decent graphic designer, I'd totally dedicate a couple hours each week to improve icons for various software projects, such as VLC. I'm sure plenty of FOSS projects would accept a redesign, they just don't have the manpower or skillset to do so.
On a separate note, I think it's really interesting that this spawned a huge blog post where they iterated on designs over and over until they just ended up with essentially the Visual Studio icon, but with the back part missing to make it a fish instead of an infinity symbol. I find that kind of funny.
7
6
Oct 25 '17
Include both icons in the install directory and a short note on how to change the icon used on the github page. Problem solved?
4
u/theoldboy Oct 25 '17
Way too sensible. If people carried on like that we'd have to go back to arguing about tabs vs spaces.
7
7
u/JB-from-ATL Oct 25 '17
I'm really glad they changed it back to blue. I know it seems minor but brands changing colors is really annoying.
10
2
u/Stoppablemurph Oct 25 '17
Yeah but.. I kinda like the orange icon.. can't we just pick which one we want? I know windows at least had supported multiple icon options for like a million years. I'm sure it's possible on Mac and Linux too..
2
u/gtkm17 Oct 25 '17
I have to say that Visual Studio Code is really a wonderful text editor, with a very active community for plugins development.
2
u/zxc223 Oct 25 '17
If this is the biggest issue people have with VSC then they're doing a good job.
4
5
u/UsingYourWifi Oct 24 '17
A very minor thing but one I appreciate. The orange icon makes it easy to confuse with Sublime. More than a few times I've opened the wrong one.
3
u/CrudeTheFrood Oct 25 '17
Honestly I thought this was a Halloween thing. You know, because pumpkins and stuff.
2
3
3
Oct 25 '17
Is this seriously news? You are programmers. You should know how easy it is to change the icon of something.
3
3
u/ZiggyTheHamster Oct 25 '17
My beef with the new icon is the stupid fucking ribbon. Why are they using the bottom and right third of the icon to draw a right angle?
2
2
u/Katana314 Oct 25 '17
Funny to think that blue and orange have become the new replacement for "blue and red" in online competitive games. Wonder if this means there's more people rooting for blue teams there too.
2
2
2
2
Oct 24 '17
I personally had no problems with the orange icon - quite the opposite: There exist applications that reduce the bluelight of the display (such as f.lux or now also an integrated option in Windows 10). When there was a color change from blue to orange in the Visual Studio Code GUI, I personally thought that the development team took such an argument to reduce blue (programmers love nightshifts ;-) ) as one reason for the color change.
What I did not like with the orange icon is that a lot of existing elements in the Visual Studio Code GUI were still in blue (an ugly contrast with the new orange icon), such as the message whether new updates are available or not. I don't know whether these would look good in orange, too. If they do, I can immediately accept that Microsoft want to change the color change of VS Code to remove blue to make programming nighshifts more comfortable. But until "all blue is removed" the GUI simply looked ugly.
TLDR: When Microsoft changed the icon to orange, a lot blue elements were left in the VS Code GUI, which looks ugly. Nevertheless I can see good reasons (remove bluelight for programming nightshifts) why if the color scheme change is completed, it will potentially be better than the original blue scheme - and thus I am looking forward to an orange scheme.
1
1
u/anything_but Oct 25 '17
What concerns me more than the color of the logo is that I am not able to click away that Cookie warning. Is that a thing now?
1
1
1
u/Andrew_Radford Oct 25 '17
Microsoft have learned from the UPPER CASE MENUS IN VISUAL STUDIO fiasco.
1
u/mbrezu Oct 25 '17
This is all very refreshing. How about we turn back to rather unimportant issues, such as macro recording support? :-D
1
u/jugalator Oct 25 '17
I liked orange because I'm somehow less confused about it when running it alongside Visual Studio. Despite VS being purple. Oh well, not a huge issue. And for that reason, I'm surprised an issue was even raised for it.
1
u/Dave3of5 Oct 25 '17
Hurrah !
Now how long will it be until someone creates a issue to put it back to the orange icon amirite?
1
1
u/entrasonics Oct 25 '17
I actually enjoyed the new color and am a bit disappointed that it’s going back to blue
1
u/argumentnull Oct 25 '17
I was having sleepless nights because of the orange icon. Now that I know it is going to be changed, I can sleep well. great!
1
1
Oct 25 '17
Yes! Wow.
I have been opening VSCode mistakenly when I reach for Sublime at the moment.
Atom - Green VSCode - Blue Sublime - Orange JetBrains Webstorm, et. al - Black
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/bitwize Oct 26 '17
I for one am glad... that orange icon was literally the worst thing to happen since they colored Sonic's arms blue.
0
u/bloodguard Oct 24 '17
Kind of amazed that there are people in the world with so much free time that they can pitch a fit about an icon.
1
u/Anon_Logic Oct 25 '17
How do I keep not blue. Blue is an awful color. Nearly everything they produce is a blue icon. Windows 10 logo is blue.
Here, let's play a game. Put Microsoft product icons on the desktop, clear the names and squint your eye, now double click on the blue icon... what did you launch? IE\Edge? Powershell? Outlook? Word? Skype? OneDrive?
At least with orange you had a 50/50 shot (since Powerpoint is orange as well).
2
u/8igg7e5 Oct 25 '17
And Visual Fox Pro (yes I sadly need this installed at the moment)
1
u/Kirides Oct 25 '17
I feel you.
(Coder for a company that keeps extending a FoxPro application since 1999, when it was initially 'released')
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/euclid047 Oct 25 '17
I would rather them spend more time improving the IDE than dick around with the icon.
1
Oct 25 '17
I loved the old pycharm icon. Then they went all businessy with the logo.
1
u/murpium Oct 25 '17
Yeah I wish JetBrains cared as much as Microsoft. And I never thought I'd say that.
1
1
0
-5
u/bsterling604 Oct 24 '17
seriously, people need to stop wasting peoples time with shit like complaining about a god damn icon. Been using VS for 12 years, and couldn't give a rats ass what the icon looks like.
i feel dumber for having looked at a subreddit where this topic gets upvoted. thanks reddit, never fails.
0
u/webauteur Oct 24 '17
Why not just give users a choice of icons? You can change the icon when multiple icons are contained in an exe or dll file.
-2
-4
u/not_feeling_it Oct 25 '17
MS has always struggled with branding. Related: "Visual Studio Code" is possibly the worst product name I can think of. How about just "CodeStudio"?
0
u/PM_ME_YOUR_HIGHFIVE Oct 25 '17
Remember when IG changed their logo and everyone hated it? Or when Google changed it? Now nobody cares...The same thing happened with vscode.
"It really looks bad" is not a helpful feedback, even with 1424 likes.
I like the story and the article, but these people will be there in the comments at every new feature.
0
u/oxydaemon Oct 25 '17
Just as I was getting used to the new icon change... ah well. Why can't they just let us choose which one to show. That would be nice.
-17
Oct 24 '17
Why the fuck is there a cringy Monty Python reference to give an "analogy" on how they made the change?
255
u/cwg999 Oct 24 '17
Meanwhile,
https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1171252
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DHhTq9vUwAInh0C.jpg
Just kidding, this was a while back.