r/programming • • Sep 01 '17

Reddit's main code is no longer open-source.

/r/changelog/comments/6xfyfg/an_update_on_the_state_of_the_redditreddit_and/
15.3k Upvotes

846 comments sorted by

5.2k

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17

back in 2008, Reddit Inc was a ragtag organization1 and the future of the company was very uncertain. We wanted to make sure the community could keep the site alive should the company go under and making the code available was the logical thing to do

Translation: We needed you guys back then. We don't now.

The rest of it seems like a combination of technical hurdles that don't seem particularly compelling (they don't need to have secret new feature branches in their public repo) and some that don't make any sense (how does a move away from a monolithic repo into microservices change anything?) and some that are comical (our shit's so complicated to deploy and use that you can't use it anyway)

It's sad that their development processes have effectively resulted in administrative reasons they can't do it. I remember them doing shenanigans like using their single-point-of-failure production RabbitMQ server to run the untested April fools thing this year (r/place) and in doing so almost brought everything down. So I'm not surprised that there doesn't seem to be much maturity in the operations and development processes over there.

To be fair though, the reddit codebase always had a reputation for being such a pain that it wasn't really useful for much. Thankfully, their more niche open source contributions, while not particularly polished and documented, might end up being more useful than the original reddit repo. I know I've been meaning to look into the Websocket one.

981

u/onebit Sep 01 '17

I guess they dont know they could make a private repo and update origin after the feature is done.

7

u/eclectro Sep 01 '17

My guess is that they do know that, but won't do it for reasons.

4

u/largenocream Sep 02 '17

That's pretty much what was done for a number of years. Changesets were cherry-picked into the public repo after ensuring a rollback or fixup wouldn't be needed.

2

u/salgat Sep 02 '17

I think they don't want to have to deal with the overhead of either filtering out what they merge back into the origin or dealing with merge conflicts down the road.

2

u/marian1 Sep 02 '17

The linked thread says that is the old practice that they moved away from.

→ More replies (273)

61

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

and some that are comical (our shit's so complicated to deploy and use that you can't use it anyway)

To be fair, I've more than once tried to build something on Ubuntu, given up, and subscribed to a 3rd party PPA. Most packages do build, but there's a few that are just a nightmare.

Reddit could fix that, but I guess it's all time and money, and it might be optimised for their infra anyway. Although they could open source it and allow someone else to fix it...

→ More replies (5)

66

u/adrianmonk Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 02 '17

they don't need to have secret new feature branches in their public repo

They don't, but there is a trade-off here. Long-lived branches are harder to merge. Open source contributors can't merge a branch they don't have access to. That means someone internal has to choose between (1) making it a priority to merge open source contributions into the feature branch (and dealing with the risks or inconveniences that entails) and (2) dealing with a harder merge later on.

That's probably doable, but it's not a fictitious difficulty.

17

u/p7r Sep 02 '17

git rebase is your friend.

If you have a feature branch, it's your responsibility to regularly rebase (daily, ideally) from master and keep it mergeable. Simple.

34

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

That's fine until you have two long lived feature branches. The first to get merged causes hundreds of conflicts in the other. Can be very painful.

→ More replies (7)

76

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Just curious, are there are any companies that have moved to a microservice architecture that are open sourced? It does seem like it would be a lot harder to manage.

75

u/ccb621 Sep 02 '17

We have at edX (https://github.com/edx). In addition to our LMS, we have forums, credentials, ecommerce, a marketing site, and course catalog services.

The systems have some dependencies, but are mostly meant to operate and be deployed independently.

3

u/BeelzenefTV Sep 03 '17

You guys are awesome!

→ More replies (3)

25

u/tornato7 Sep 01 '17

Check out https://stackshare.io/. It'll tell you what tech stacks different companies are using.

67

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I can't think of anyone. Someone below mentioned Netflix: they FOSS a lot of tools but not their main services. Sounds like this is what Reddit is gonna do.

44

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17

I think Netflix is a good example of one that open sources many of their components.

As for one where the whole product is open source and microservice based, I'm not sure. I'm sure others might have an example in mind. Some quick Googling showed a few like Travis CI. In general, I don't feel like the (sometimes dubious) organizational benefits from microservice architectures are a good fit for FOSS development. They tend to be better with strong centralized policies, leadership, etc., spreading work out to many teams. Things like having good CI, testing, etc. practices are all very important. The ones I've found Googling around have all been similar to Travis CI and Reddit insofar as they are a public facing open source repo of an industry developed tool (using hosted as a service), so frankly I don't see this as a compelling reason to can all plans to keep reddit itself FOSS.

Orchestrating it with tooling like Kubernetes would make it much easier to manage, but it looks like reddit's has a lot of homegrown code to glue it together.

31

u/FlyingBishop Sep 01 '17

Yeah, I don't think Netflix is any more open source than Reddit is after this change. Probably less, since their more monolithic bits were never open source.

7

u/fc_newbro Sep 02 '17

The value of Netflix Open Source was never in the "here is all our code for running a video service", but rather in seeing their approach to developing robust, low latency, fault tolerant systems. Their approaches don't line up with the requirements of every project, but what they have developed it very useful within the ecosystem of their projects for a wide variety of situations. There is alot to be learned by looking at what they have produced.

Having said that, there is a clear rewrite/new approaches theme that has been running through their projects for the last few years. The move from stable code bases to extensive rewrites using different programming styles, e.g. Functional Java and the RxJava libraries, that may not fit with many projects. Also their fairly disjointed updates and how it lags behind their production system clearly won't work for everyone and honestly shouldn't be expected.

However, having said all of that, there are a ton of valuable painfully learned lessons that can be taken from what they have released and can be of benefit to many large scale internet projects.

20

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Can you think of a SaaS product you've worked on where the product code wasn't intimately coupled to the automation code and deployment platforms? I certainly can't.

Netflix releases their tools as open source (and they have some pretty cool stuff) but they do not FOSS their product.

15

u/Nyefan Sep 01 '17

Yes. Everything we're building in docker+kubernetes these days. The application code could be entirely open source without any issues so long as our yamls are stored separately and managed by Jenkins. Api base paths are managed by kubedns and linkerd, so we don't even have to do that ourselves anymore. Granted, only a few dozen of our services have been ported from Netflix so far (for testing purposes), but we are just finishing up auditing our first production readiness test of the environment, and everything looks good.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/RovingSandninja Sep 02 '17

Out of curiosity - why do you think the benefits of microservice architectures are sometimes dubious?

12

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

It places way higher demands on the competence of the developers and ops people to avoid catastrophic failures. Poor choices in where to draw service boundaries can make dealing with problems inherent to distributed systems even worse.

Ultimately, it's often a YAGNI situation. I don't think there's any reason whatsoever to do something like reddit as microservices.

It's wonderful at matching organizational decoupling with technical decoupling, even allowing radically different cultures and language preferences to coexist peacefully. I just don't see that being necessary for something like reddit.

2

u/geerlingguy Sep 02 '17

Elastic, to some extent - ELK stack and related components are all open sourced.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/Semi-Hemi-Demigod Sep 02 '17

Popularity leads to money. Money leads to lawyers. Lawyers lead to suffering...

103

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Generally speaking, microservices architectures are (for better or worse) pretty closely coupled with their automation code and thus the platforms they run on. It's already difficult to get that stuff running in prod (staging too if you've got some cash): getting it set up so you can ship the whole thing to contributors is super difficult and it has diminishing returns. You're not just shipping code, you're shipping container orchestration configs, database configs, load balancing logic, and a bunch of other shit that isn't portable.

It's one thing to have the code for the services available; if your contributors can't run it, it's not really open source. And having it out there in a broken state is worse than not having it at all.

Reddit is SaaS and I don't know anyone who's been very successful at open-sourcing their MSA SaaS product.

20

u/meltingdiamond Sep 02 '17

And having it out there in a broken state is worse than not having it at all.

I disagree, broken code can still give a leg up when you really need it.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

docker+kubernetes

they wouldn't even need to maintain the yamls, I'm sure the community would and then they could use whatever deployment structure they wanted.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

34

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

To be fair though, the reddit codebase always had a reputation for being such a pain that it wasn't really useful for much.

Ive never seen another web site crash as much as reddit. To this day it still crashes with some regularity.

inb4 "but lots of users"

reddit has big boy corporate financial backing and has been around for ~10+ yrs

reddit goes down more than someone w/low self esteem.

→ More replies (5)

17

u/Spider_pig448 Sep 02 '17

how does a move away from a monolithic repo into microservices change anything?

Sounds like someone's never worked in a monolithic repo.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Monolithic in this case is vs. service based. I'm not talking about the Windows repo here.

2

u/orbjuice Sep 02 '17

If you work in .NET, it's all you will ever work in.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Volt Sep 02 '17

The repo is just where the code is. You can still use it to deploy multiple services.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

To the guy that read the whole article, you da real MVP. Enjoyed the summary and agree.

2

u/ruinercollector Sep 02 '17

Their biggest problem seems to always have been that the people there want to believe that they are an innovative tech company solving huge complex problems, when really they are a pretty basic internet forum that succeeded on timing and a culture that they have since abandoned.

Scale is their would-be technical problem, but for something like this, it's a problem that's been solved for quite a few years now by better and smarter companies.

So their devs get bored, and they overengineer or needlessly shift technologies around, usually breaking things and pissing off their userbase.

3

u/FyreWulff Sep 02 '17

They've been slowly closing up their walled garden as they got more successful. It's a shame, but what can you do.

3

u/ex_CEO Sep 02 '17

What do you expect from the company that has CEO who secretly edits messages of other people.

3

u/saddestmaninworld Sep 02 '17

Translation: We needed you guys back then. We don't now.

Remember something called Digg?

7

u/farsightxr20 Sep 02 '17

You mean that platform that was never open source in the first place?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (42)

404

u/paranoidinfidel Sep 02 '17

I snagged a copy of the closed source:

print("all of our servers are busy right now")

print("please try again in a minute")

print("(error code: 503)")

18

u/stesch Sep 02 '17

Oh, updated to Python 3?

18

u/mishugashu Sep 02 '17

That is also valid python2 code.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

[deleted]

2

u/BeelzenefTV Sep 03 '17

its a core piece of code, vital!

923

u/Arancaytar Sep 01 '17

If I read it right, it's not so much that it's "no longer" open source, but hasn't been truly open for a while now and they're just giving up on maintaining the open version.

Because of the above, our internal development, production and “feature” branches have been moving further and further from the “canonical” state of the open source repository. Such balkanization means that merges are getting increasingly difficult, especially as the company grows and more developers are touching the code more frequently.

So in effect, they made a private fork of their own code and it's now diverged to the point where they can't feasibly maintain both.

It's sad but I suppose inevitable when your business model involves using your code rather than giving it to other people and selling support. Any users of your code are not potential customers but competitors.

However, since their source apparently remains available under a semi-free copyleft license (CPAL), maybe there will be a community-maintained fork of some kind.

244

u/WhoTookPlasticJesus Sep 01 '17

It's sad but I suppose inevitable when your business model involves using your code rather than giving it to other people and selling support. Any users of your code are not potential customers but competitors.

It's not often that I say this, but Facebook has the exact right attitude about this: open-source anything that's not a part of your core product. Sure, you give back to the community which is nice and all and you may reap rewards from pull requests here-and-there. But a side benefit is that you're creating a new pool of future employees already familiar with your internal technology. I mean, imagine React was closed-sourced. It would be a nightmare to ramp-up new front-end devs.

27

u/sminja Sep 02 '17

It sounds like Reddit is going to be using a similar model:

We believe in open source, and want to make sure that our contributions are both useful and meaningful. We will continue to open source tools that are of use to engineers everywhere

Much of the core of Reddit is based on open source technologies (Postgres, python, memcached, Cassanda to name a few!) and we will continue to contribute to projects we use and modify (like gunicorn, pycassa, and pylibmc). We recently contributed a performance improvement to styled-components, the framework we use for styling the redesign, which was picked up by brcast and glamorous. We also have some more upcoming perf patches!

5

u/adisbladis Sep 02 '17

Except Facebook has a very strange attitude towards patents so I'm not sure if they are a great example.

→ More replies (8)

15

u/temp409840984 Sep 02 '17

It's sad but I suppose inevitable when your business model involves using your code rather than giving it to other people and selling support. Any users of your code are not potential customers but competitors.

You'd think so, but there are a bunch of for-profit businesses that do just fine open-sourcing their core code. It's the community effect. Everybody's here. Even a truly superior product to reddit basically can't compete at this point, unless reddit does something to severely piss off the community, which given this announcement I expect is coming.

24

u/tornato7 Sep 01 '17

Yeah, I think we should still be thankful Reddit gave the open source community as much as they did. I can't think of any other tech companies that open source so much of their code, so this is pretty much to be expected.

30

u/Viper007Bond Sep 02 '17

A large portion of WordPress.com is open-source, including the entire custom JavaScript-based front end: https://developer.wordpress.com/calypso/

Lots more at https://github.com/Automattic

Disclaimer: I'm an employee.

19

u/tornato7 Sep 02 '17

Haha I didn't even realize WordPress was a business rather than an open-sourced framework. That's great though!

How do you guys make money? Do you guys get anything from like WPEngine?

21

u/enkideridu Sep 02 '17

WordPress VIP charges Enterprise users quite a bit of money for managed hosting

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Viper007Bond Sep 02 '17

WordPress itself is a framework owned by no-one.

The main founder started a for-profit (Automattic) which runs the SAAS WordPress.com. It's a freemium service where a percentage of users buy paid upgrades (such as a custom domain) and that pays for the service as a whole.

We also have paid employees whose entire job is to contribute back to the open-source WordPress project.

4

u/EUmpCDgZPYWJ9x2X Sep 02 '17

Depends what you call a tech company. There's centOS, nginx, owncloud/nextcloud and firefox.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/johokie Sep 02 '17

... Red Hat

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

[deleted]

14

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Isn't voat a fork of reddit? I know they're not exactly doing good things with the code, but it's the biggest example I know of

6

u/BlckJesus Sep 02 '17

I only just learned about voat. Jesus christ that place is a cesspool...

8

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Voat's bigger on free speech so every community that Reddit has banned has run over there so it's not a classy place.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/phySi0 Sep 02 '17

AVfM runs their own deployment called SocFreeSpeech.

→ More replies (4)

74

u/tech_tuna Sep 02 '17

It would be funny if Oracle acquired reddit.

58

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17 edited Sep 02 '17

It'd be ironic if Digg merged with Reddit, and funny if Oracle bought the result.

48

u/_my_name_is_earl_ Sep 02 '17

And then Google just swallows up the entire company, merging it with Google Plus.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

But how will Ellison pay for his sailboats? Or would he have Reddit charge user name/moderator licenses like Oracle charges for cores?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Well, that's one way to kill it

92

u/kallari_is_my_jam Sep 01 '17

I'm no expert when it comes to code architecture and large codebases but it seems to me like their codebase is horribly organized with over a decade worth of code being written without any major cleanup being done. There is no way to understand how all these pieces fit together cuz there are no meaningful comments in most of the files. How do you even keep developing on this codebase as it's such a mess. Is this a shit codebase or am I simply too negative?

52

u/tms10000 Sep 02 '17

How do you even keep developing on this codebase as it's such a mess.

People who have been developing this mountain of shitty code either:

  1. have been there such a long time, they hold the map to most of it in their head.

  2. take a really long time to get familiar with it with the reluctant help of people who fall in category #1, and eventually they drift to #1 themselves.

30

u/NOX_QS Sep 02 '17 edited Sep 02 '17

3 Don't have a work ethic and feel about wading through spaghetti code and taking weeks on a feature that should take hours roughly the same as working at a gas station: "Eh, it pays the bills" / just a job

4 Have a huge work ethic and great sense of architecture but after working with #3 for a while and trying to make changes either turns into #1 or #3 or quits the system in protest

4

u/Niek_pas Sep 02 '17

I think 3 is more of a societal issue then an individual issue though. It's too easy to blame "lazy programmers" with "no work ethic" but when you have a 9-5 and a mortgage to pay it's hard not to be in that category.

39

u/iamonlyoneman Sep 02 '17

Other people who seem to know what they are talking about tend to agree that the code is shitty

16

u/kallari_is_my_jam Sep 02 '17

Apparently they think so themselves as they're going to be rewriting the whole thing using a modern tech stack. Also partitioning the monolith into services I assume. The reason why they decided to make this new codebase closed source is most likely because they secured 200 million dollars in funding mostly for this and they don't want to give away the "new" project for free.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/plonce Sep 02 '17

You're not too negative. What happens when you start a project like Reddit is that:

  • What you start making and what you end up making are vastly different

  • The infrastructure buckles under its own weight as it was never designed to handle the load

  • It ends up with more patchwork fixes than you can possibly imagine and new features become cumbersome to add

  • The real-world realities of law, business, tech and art all have conflicting objectives; balance and compromise is required everywhere for the overall project to succeed. Side-note: this is why you see techies often distilling it down to comments like "hey moran just quazlinate the databases over a frickle wire with a Unix blort" ... it's because they only see the details of their profession and speak as though the other realities of business don't exist.

28

u/random8847 Sep 02 '17 edited Feb 20 '24

I love the smell of fresh bread.

137

u/ccfreak2k Sep 01 '17 edited Aug 01 '24

worm different engine license sort mighty agonizing grandiose seed marry

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

19

u/tabarra Sep 02 '17

And the "Source Code" on the site-wide footer.

79

u/yawkat Sep 01 '17

I guess it's not that different from before. Many of the anti-spam measures were already known to be closed source and in the end there was no way to verify what's running on the servers anyway.

41

u/zsaleeba Sep 02 '17 edited Sep 02 '17

I’m speculating that closing their source code is the result of this recent ruling about ownership of content on social network sites. After all if your source code is already open and then it turns out you don’t even own your site content what unique assets do you actually have? reddit has always argued that they own a license to their user’s submissions but if this ruling weakens that argument then they probably have to take some steps to mollify their investors.

Edit: for accuracy

36

u/Ghi102 Sep 02 '17 edited Sep 05 '17

What makes Reddit useful to investors is not the content of the site, only it's big user base. What money could Reddit get from the users' posts and comments? Not much. Having millions of eyeballs on an ad webpage + semi-regular donations? There's the value.

Plus open-source doesn't mean that you don't own the code, you still do. It's just theoretically possible for someone to run his own instance, fork the code and modify it. The code in Reddit's repo is still owned by Reddit.

2

u/Iamonreddit Sep 02 '17

What money could Reddit get from the users' posts and comments?

Welcome to the world of data mining. By tracking what your users post, comment, up/down vote and spend time engaging with you can build up profiles of what is popular right now for certain demographics. Sure you may think your user account is anonymous but - data mining to the rescue again - you can easily build up profiles based entirely on subs, votes, language patterns, etc based on profiles where you do know demographic info.

This is why Gmail has always been free, reading all those emails generates a lot of money.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/haragoshi Sep 02 '17

Open source doesn't mean you don't own the source code. It means you offer a license to other people for free if they meet certain conditions specified by that license. All open source must offer a license of some sort or it's effectively useless. Generally they fall under MIT license, GPL, GPG, etc. each license limits what you can or can't do with the source code.

Breaking terms of the license amounts to piracy and opens you up to a lawsuit.

→ More replies (1)

302

u/shevegen Sep 01 '17

Awww ... it'll no longer be the same.

Now they join the forces of evil.

93

u/copyrightisbroke Sep 01 '17

45

u/port53 Sep 01 '17

Can't wait to get my cut of this funding!

34

u/Works_of_memercy Sep 01 '17

Reddit notes anyone? LOL.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

[deleted]

→ More replies (4)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

you'll get nothing and like it.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/eclectro Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17

Now they join the forces of evil.

I'd say google is now officially in the doing evil business. So, what's in store for reddit??

7

u/mnilailt Sep 01 '17

Its actually a bit disheartening

0

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

[deleted]

80

u/IronSpekkio Sep 01 '17

confirmed. site was indeed spez'd long ago. sad!

41

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

When are we gonna go like digg migration 3.0 and forge the new Reddit and Make The Internet Great Again!

122

u/Rhamni Sep 01 '17

They tried that with Voat, but sadly the first groups to migrate in high numbers were /r/fatpeoplehate and extra+ racists. So... now anyone contemplating going there has to factor in that it has like four times the concentration of user based awfulness that reddit has. Even with reddit having more admin based awfulness and Voat paying more attention to what features users want (like displaying number of up and downvotes), Voat just isn't very appealing in comparison. Now sure, if everyone moved there the current loonies would be drowned out and it would have the same concentration of good and bad as reddit does but with better admins and features, but it's hard to get there. So basically, now we need a new new alternative.

→ More replies (65)
→ More replies (6)

19

u/ScrewAttackThis Sep 02 '17

Is t_d still jerking over that?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (12)

244

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

"we're doing some shady shit that we don't want public"

43

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

"I'm deleting my account and not coming back"

→ More replies (1)

56

u/iamonlyoneman Sep 02 '17

But they never did anything to cause people do doubt the site was administered with anything but a fair and even hand for all subreddits!

 

/s obviously?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/IamTheFreshmaker Sep 02 '17

Ad reinjection code?

34

u/haltingpoint Sep 02 '17

The ads won't be the bad part. The user tracking, analytics, and third party data brokers that they will share your data with in the future will be the bad stuff. Ads just leverage that data to serve an image or video.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/ScrewAttackThis Sep 02 '17

You understand Reddit hasn't been fully open source for a long time, right?

7

u/NorthBlizzard Sep 02 '17

They know everyone would leave if it was discovered there are more bots than people.

11

u/pocky00 Sep 02 '17

I don't support their decision but how exactly would that be discovered by being open-sourced?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/GetOutOfBox Sep 02 '17

After them trying to subvert their own algorithms by creating a duplicate front-page in the form of /r/popular, I guarantee you we will see further attempts to stifle "alternative communities" on here.

It's unbelievable how censorship loving modern-day reddit is, and how sad it is that it has turned into the very corporate shell like site that Digg did.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

15

u/Phobos15 Sep 01 '17

So are they going to have problems in the future, since they took in code from outside devs? They can't close source that code.

Won't that limit reddit from ever selling their platform to others? If they distribute anything, they would have to open source it.

35

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

They leave it on GitHub forever, the end. It's available there.

11

u/jedberg Sep 02 '17

They can't close source that code.

Sure they can. Read section 6 of the license. Reddit is allowed to change the license terms at any time. You may continue to use the code under the current license, but they get to use it under any license they want.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/redldr1 Sep 01 '17

So long and thanks for all the fish code

14

u/yorickpeterse Sep 02 '17

Open-source makes it hard for us to develop some features "in the clear" (like our recent video launch) without leaking our plans too far in advance.

This works just fine for GitLab. The few times we have to keep something secret (e.g. security fixes) we develop the feature on a private GitLab instance, then merge it into the main (and public) repository once it's ready to go.

7

u/Rugby11 Sep 02 '17

Oh no.....

115

u/GetOutOfBox Sep 02 '17

This combined with all of the censorship scandals and corporate shilling has finally convinced me that Reddit has gone full circle and pulled a Digg. They've sold out.

Time to do what we did when Digg stopped giving a shit about it's fanbase.

36

u/IceColdFresh Sep 02 '17

Migrate to Fark?

16

u/AnnoysTheGoys Sep 02 '17

Drew just spilled his beer all over the servers in anticipation.

10

u/Lacotte Sep 02 '17

I've heard Digg references like 3 times over the past 5 years. But Fark? holy shit!! haven't heard that name in 10+ years or something.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Fark's the same, if not worse.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/duckvimes_ Sep 02 '17

"Censorship scandals"? I think you're exaggerating just a wee bit.

27

u/skinnytrees Sep 02 '17

Generally speaking the CEO of a company that is "valued at 1.8 billion" (if true anyways) should not be going on to the political forums his company hosts and start editing without marking that the comments were edited the political posts from users

In fact I cant imagine something worse the CEO of reddit could do outside blowing up the headquarters, stealing money, or working with outside company to ruin reddit

→ More replies (12)

57

u/DanAtkinson Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 02 '17

If that means that they realise that they fucked up with the reddit app and the mobile site, then I'm all for it. /s

They've wasted time and effort on an experience that is inferior and frankly poor for a company of reddit's stature.

Also, they complain of the realities of being open source when they have 100 developers. Like having 100 developers is a huge deal. I work with companies many times larger who manage OSS, contributions and PRs without much effort. So, for reddit to turn around and moan about the effort required to balance between their private, proprietary code and their public OSS code shines a light on how bloated their codebase has become.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

82

u/stshine Sep 01 '17

So sad that Aaron Swartz can't rest in peace.

53

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

At least he didn't have to see reddit, a 12 year old site become a fucking corporation and not even have a rich text editor or fucking preview option when writing posts and comments. In the last 5 years reddit hasn't received any significant update that improves the experience for the end-user directly. I wrote about it at some length here https://www.reddit.com/r/changelog/comments/6xfyfg/an_update_on_the_state_of_the_redditreddit_and/dmg4c9x/?context=3

Yes, Aaron was a freedom advocate but I'm sure he knew the whole point of it was that open-source led to higher quality software. I'm sure he'd feel the same way as me looking at reddit as a major project, making major money (at least at keeping itself afloat) and not receiving a fucking update to basic functionalities in 5 years.

Aaron was a programmer first and an advocate second. From that point of view, he'd look at reddit and think "welp, that's a dead project, it's going nowhere fast". May he RIP.

9

u/femanonette Sep 02 '17

In the last 5 years reddit hasn't received any significant update that improves the experience for the end-user directly

This 'report' button for comments now is absolute trash. If I wanted to use Facebook, I'd go use Facebook.

2

u/stshine Sep 02 '17

Well, sadly maybe not that dead since so many people are attached to it.

→ More replies (1)

52

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Reddit also use to be a place where people's discussion was based on votes rather than the biases of their admins and advertisers.

5

u/_my_name_is_earl_ Sep 02 '17

It'd be pretty sweet if reddit went decentralized early one. Or at least a more free open source model.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/thefreecat Sep 02 '17

So...fork?

63

u/sizlack Sep 01 '17

So many comments seem to think this is some indicator that they've turned evil. If they have, it's unrelated to this change. How useful was it ever that the codebase was open source? Did anyone ever stand up their own clone of reddit and run it on the open internet? It seems impractical to maintain a codebase like this in the open, and from what I've heard they're doing a major rewrite, which would make it even more complicated. If no one uses it, why maintain it?

40

u/sourcecodesurgeon Sep 02 '17

I wanted to stand up an internal clone of Reddit for my company to use as an internal discussion board alternative to email. Unfortunately, their licensing is too restrictive for me to do so anyway. So for me at least, Reddit being open source made no difference.

7

u/CowboyBoats Sep 02 '17

What were the licensing terms that were a deal-breaker for your plan?

27

u/sourcecodesurgeon Sep 02 '17

The CPAL license had some issue that wasn't compatible. I'm not a lawyer, I just don't do what the lawyers tell me not to do.

2

u/jhasse Sep 06 '17

Unfortunately, their licensing is too restrictive for me to do so anyway.

Check out https://gitlab.com/edgyemma/raddit-app, it's licensed under the awesome zlib License.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/sageDieu Sep 02 '17

They've been undeniably evil for a while now we just don't have anywhere better to go

6

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

This cements it.

Do you remember all the edits made when the whole "Fuck /u/spez" thing went on? Or the amount of code devoted towards neutralizing one community?

6

u/_my_name_is_earl_ Sep 02 '17

Or the amount of code devoted towards neutralizing one community?

Did that code ever make it into the open source version? To my knowledge, the open source version of reddit was missing a ton of core features.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/artgo Sep 02 '17

If no one uses it, why maintain it?

That's how I see it. People want a huge monolithic site under one ownership/admins, and for years the code was barely used to setup alternate sites. A huge amount of the code has to be concerned with the massive volume. As text BBS systems go, reedit has always had fine featured and worked well enough. It's the massive size of the community and activity that's got to dominate all their technical decisions.

→ More replies (14)

36

u/nakilon Sep 01 '17

Reddit code is a pure shit. Move along.

23

u/bdcp Sep 02 '17

But I can't leave...

14

u/tech_tuna Sep 02 '17

Exactly, I've been complaining about reddit for well over a decade but no true successor has materialized. . .

→ More replies (1)

3

u/fernandotakai Sep 02 '17

the "thing" code is just.. i mean. i don't know why someone would do something like that.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '17

What's a good reddit alternative?

2

u/interiot Sep 04 '17

https://raddit.me is FOSS, non-profit and incredibly pro-privacy.

Otherwise there's /r/RedditAlternatives/.

24

u/dixncox Sep 02 '17

ITT Non programmers talking about things they know nothing about

13

u/andrewguenther Sep 02 '17

It is a sensible move. The Reddit repository hasn't been representative of the live site for multiple years now.

Baseplate and mcsauna are both really awesome projects and represent a much more meaningful contribution to open source than having the entire site in a monolithic repo. These are people someone can actually use and build off of.

If you try and say that having the entire site open source is "transparent" and want to spew conspiracy theories about how "now they're going to make evil admin tools!" then please tell me how you've verified that Reddit's servers are running the exact code in that repository. I'll wait...

9

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Fuck contributing to open source projects that are run by companies is the moral of this story as usual. Reddit is worth nearly 2 billion now, will the open source contributors who poured their hard work and time be compensated monetarily /u/spez? Of course they won't. Instead they will get some bullshit badge or other worthless png trinket.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Zamicol Sep 01 '17

It's time for something else.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

20

u/iamonlyoneman Sep 02 '17

Feel free to start it up then.

10

u/Zamicol Sep 02 '17

Will do.

There's one run by some OpenBSD dudes:

https://lobste.rs/

And there is always hacker news.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Valerokai Sep 02 '17

ITT: People pretending to know what open source is to push a narrative

29

u/keizersuze Sep 02 '17

Yeah no shit

"we're totally not censoring certain topics and promoting others to acheive our PC/Orwellian social engineering agenda"

Can we see the code then?

"No..."

13

u/TwoFiveOnes Sep 02 '17

PC/Orwellian social engineering agenda

Dude you're in your own head. I disagree with reddit being closed source but this spin people are giving it is just whack job nonsense

2

u/keizersuze Sep 03 '17

Ok, I guess it's also my imagination that google was filtering news/search results in Clinton's favour during the election and youtube isn't targetting conservative channels for demonitization. Reddit's just another name in a list of companies trying to control what people are allowed to hear.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Wouldn't they just use that code in their own private version and not update the repo?

10

u/andrewguenther Sep 02 '17

There's no room for your sense here.

8

u/moon- Sep 02 '17

Looks like /r/the_donald is leaking again...

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/xereeto Sep 02 '17

who the fuck gilded this

4

u/SupersonicSpitfire Sep 02 '17

This is the beginning of the decline of Reddit.

8

u/Sandvicheater Sep 02 '17

Lets face it when you get to the top (in Reddit's case one of the most visited sites on the web) you tend to guard your coca-cola secret recipe religiously. Microsoft, Apple, Facebook, Google, etc.

30

u/HumpingJack Sep 02 '17

Meh the code isn't anything special. Reddit's substantial userbase is what makes the site valuable, and that is hard to surplant with just another clone even if it was technically superior. First mover advantage.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/artgo Sep 02 '17

I agree, this is all about the user base size. They aren't about BBS text software any more, they are about being a massive and highly active website / a household name brand. The branding forces and "cash in forces" will far outweigh the technology choices.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Their secret sauce is not so much their code, but their ability to force a narrative on people.

6

u/AVhammerslammer Sep 02 '17

Welp...unzips dick...back to 4chan.

8

u/bthorne725 Sep 02 '17

If you have a zipper on your dick, you need to see a doctor. Immediately.

2

u/_The-Big-Giant-Head_ Sep 02 '17

So all the coders that wrote and contributed for free to make reddit what it is now just helped making a handful of people millionaires.

2

u/santiagojuan Sep 04 '17

A knifed in the memory of Aaron Swartz, this is my last appearance at Reddit.

8

u/smb3d Sep 02 '17

How does this honestly affect anyone? Are you guys auditing the source code to make sure they aren't pulling a fast one with the upvote algo? Serious question though...

12

u/_my_name_is_earl_ Sep 02 '17

Their open source code has always been different than their production code. A lot of missing features. Also, the licensing of their code was very, very restrictive where there is virtually no one using it for their projects.

But going back to your initial question, assuming that reddit included everything in their open source version, yes there would be people auditing the source code from all over the world. If you check out a project like Linux on Github, you can see a ton of activity and many pull requests (code suggestions) from all sorts of people.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Booty_Bumping Sep 02 '17

This affects the frontend aswell. The one last officially supported software to access reddit with free software (reddit-mobile for web and mobile) is now gone.

3

u/l7jtt Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17

/u/VanToch mentioned something that I want to ask about.

If a source tarball is released after closed-source deployment of releases, does it still count as open-source?

14

u/yawkat Sep 01 '17

Usually, open-source refers to the license of the source code, so if that source tarball is licensed under an open source license, the project would be open source. A collaborative development model is not necessary for OSS, though it is of course used for almost all OSS.

9

u/coderanger Sep 01 '17

One major counter-example being the Postfix mail server. The author doesn't believe in source control, at least as a public thing. So he just cuts releases as snapshots of his local tree and that's that. Bug reports are still via email and patches involve sending him a diff via email.

5

u/Bibifrog Sep 02 '17

Bug reports are still via email and patches involve sending him a diff via email.

Well, Linux is mostly developed by sending mails too; of course then come git, but probably most of the content starts as mail. So it being the first channel of communication does not prevent from publishing using source control. Git has been specially designed to allow that kind of flow, (github workflows are an abomination in Linus' eyes in that they regress to pre-git source control systems in the decentralized flow aspect). I don't know if the Postfix author has tested git, but it would be shame if he only doesn't believe in source control for publishing because of bad experience with e.g. subversion.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Open source requires the code, and a license to modify and redistribute. A source tarball should still satisfy the code requirement.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/mrtexe Sep 02 '17

I think we'll look back and see this as a turning point in how Reddit's once vast empire of market share and mind share began to disappear.

4

u/Nrdrsr Sep 02 '17

It is riddled with so much custom code for censorship now so it's understandably difficult to maintain a version that is actually open.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

that was all then...

thanks reddit, I've learnt some good things here, and maybe I'll keep reading some things without an account.

36

u/jokes_on_you Sep 01 '17

Lol was that seriously the only reason you had an account? My guess is you just created one, left this comment, then deleted it immediately.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/B-Knight Sep 02 '17

"The government are hiding some more shady shit into our code and we can't let you guys see it."

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

"So they are no more than common mortals! Now, too, they will tread under foot all the rights of Man, indulge only their ambition; now they will think themselves superior to all men, become tyrants!" - paraphrasing Beethoven

2

u/CODESIGN2 Sep 02 '17

:shrug: Oh noes... how else will someone ever write a forum now that every forum is closed source /s

2

u/humanysta Sep 02 '17

I have no problem with this.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Oh Aaron, if only you were around to see this mess...

2

u/hoseja Sep 02 '17

Slowly. Gently. This is how it goes to the shitter.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Is that why i see ads at the top of posts now?

2

u/Harvinator06 Sep 02 '17

Shit, it's the damn digg bar again. Just not as real yet.

1

u/elgamonal Sep 02 '17

Oh Lord! We will be forever lost without that amazing search feature.

1

u/Philluminati Sep 02 '17

There's two types of open source.

The good kind and the throw shit over the fence kind two months later. They should do the later because it's still better than nothing. The community can patch long standing bugs at least.

1

u/Strawupboater Sep 02 '17

No!!! How will I destroy Reddit now?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Adiós bots!

1

u/curioussav Sep 02 '17

Silly and not relevant at all

1

u/studiosi Sep 04 '17

Someone up for forking both repos and continue development without Reddit itself?

1

u/Thecrawsome Sep 04 '17

Reddit has turned into 2009 Digg. I smell a migration to a new platform. Not voat though...

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '17

The difference in using Reddit is that you can choose whatever filter bubble you want from time to time. I openly read extreme right wing posts just as much as their counterpart. Every large subreddit is a circlejerk, the key is not to be unconsciously part of it.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

From idiots like me …… thank you Jesus ! From a Luciferian.

1

u/I_The_People Sep 02 '17

This is 2017, everything you are fed by easily accessible sources is biased and has an agenda behind it. Trust nothing but your humanity, it is all we have in common. Times may seem dark, but take heart for this is our finest hour. The bullshit that is tainting our perception of reality is becoming unbearable and nothing will stop the tide of basic human resistance. Those in charge are not intelligent enough to keep up the act much longer, nobody is.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

Why the hell is this not in /r/blog?