r/programming • u/thecodeboss • Jul 28 '16
My Interviews with Amazon
https://thesocietea.org/2016/07/my-interviews-with-amazon/14
Jul 28 '16
recently interviewed with them for a Senior Software Development Manager role and was unsuccessful.
Most irritating thing was the 3 weeks of elapsed time from 1st telephone interview to confirmation of a date for the second interview, followed by a further 10 days for a decision which included no feedback.
Even though I have asked for feedback no one replies.
It was a worthwhile experience as the preparation for the full day has been valuable for other roles - and if I had succeeded I would not complain - but they are certainly arrogant and entitled in their approach. So much so, that I am a little bit glad I did not get the role.
2
u/BigMax Jul 28 '16
That can be frustrating, I had a very long process with a company once. Had a quick chat with a recruiter, then a long gap, another screen with the recruiter, then a long gap, then a phone screen, then a long gap, then a phone interview, then a long gap, then finally in person interviews. Days to weeks in between each contact.
Did get the job in the end which is good. Turns out the people there are great, but the one person they had coordinating the interviews was just lazy and a bit flaky, so it always took a long time.
17
u/brandf Jul 28 '16
He may have dodged a bullet. I live in Seattle. Amazon has a reputations for being a revolving door. Fueled by unhappy, overworked, demoralized developers. I would imagine some folks thrive there, but I've heard so many horror stories...
0
Jul 28 '16
[deleted]
1
u/XxNerdKillerxX Jul 29 '16
The stocking vesting's legality should be questioned. It only entices the employee to be harassed so that they leave before they can collect it. When I worked there, I saw people have very bizarre run-ins with their managers. Would enter a room a meeting with someone, and I would see them just get berated right in front of me in the most intentionally demeaning way. I would see other people emotionally shaken up and later tell me half jokingly that their manager was just done shouting at them.
6
u/sjapps Jul 28 '16
I don't understand why he did not reveal the actual number? A "low" six figure seems way off from 170-200k. That's almost insulting...
4
u/TheAnimus Jul 28 '16
I was told that I would hear back within the next week about whether I made it to the next interview. This part was pretty crazy to me, because it wasn’t even a full hour before I heard back from the Amazon hiring manager saying that I had passed the interview
This is them managing expectations, if you hadn't passed with flying colours it might not have been such a quick decision.
7
u/hireThisMarine Jul 28 '16
My phone interview with Amazon (drone stuff) was the best interview I've ever had. I didn't get the job but I learned more from what was essentially 80 minutes of paired programming than I did in half a semester of class.
1
Jul 28 '16
I interviewed at Google a couple months ago and it was a lot of fun, tech interviewer was very friendly and a pleasure to bounce ideas off of. Mildly annoyed that I didn't make it further though, since I ended up with a more efficient solution than the one he was trying to steer me towards.
1
u/hireThisMarine Jul 28 '16
I can sympathize with that. I had an interview at an infamous government agency and I was told that I was the only candidate to ever answer a certain question correctly; received a "Thanks-But-No-Thanks" e-mail less than 24 hours later.
3
u/cryptdemon Jul 28 '16
I interviewed with amazon about 4 years ago. I used it as a 2-day mini vacation to hop around seattle a bit. The questions aren't particularly hard. It's basic data structures and algorithms from college for most of the questions. They basically have some optimized solution in mind that they will slowly lead you to if you start off with a solution that isn't the best.
I was told by one of the engineers there that 3 phone interviews means that one of the interviewers was on the fence about you, or that there was at least some disagreement. So they send the third one in there to decide. I had 3.
Most of the questions are the type where you have to have seen something similar in the past or else you're just not going to get it because it's the type of stuff nobody could easily come up with in a 40 minute stress-packed interview. But if you've seen it before, it's easy enough. I remember I had questions about bit shifting, hash tables, linked lists and some sorting algorithms. The only one I wasn't familiar with at the time was topological sort, which I completely bombed.
Lots of white board coding. Some of the interviewers expected your whiteboard code to be flawless, while others were fine with whatever pseudo code you throw up there. They want you to talk them through your thought process, which was the hardest part to me. I don't think out loud.
Ultimately didn't get the job, but it was an interesting experience. One of the better code interviews I've done. A lot of places like to focus on bullshit logic puzzles, but Amazon kept it all CS fundamentals.
2
u/skydivingdutch Jul 28 '16
2k in stock is really bad for this industry. It's not unheard of to join a large company and get 200k of stock (vesting over 4 years) as part of sign on.
2
u/vaskemaskine Jul 28 '16
A friend of mine who had been a sales engineer at both Microsoft and Oracle over the years recently took a position with a big data analytics startup in London.
Aside from the £130k basic salary, they offered him 750k in options vesting over 4 years. He managed to negotiate them up 2x to 1.5m.
Sadly, 3 months after joining, they sold out and all he got was 5 weeks tax free farewell pay.
1
u/slaya45 Jul 28 '16
Cool article. I like how seemingly little coding you had to do besides the second phone call; everything else seemed really casual.
-80
u/look_behind_youuu Jul 28 '16
Here's a list of lies you told:
You say your current salary is roughly $50k(half of the 6 figure offer) at your current job, but you requested a salary from the Amazon recruiter of $170k-200k
You claim they gave you a low six figure offer, but the coding questions you answered are for an entry level position (eg. how to identify classes in JavaScript)
Conclusion: You might have got an offer as a junior web developer for probably $50k, or you didn't get an offer at all. Your logic doesn't make sense that you got a 100k+ offer (double your current wage) and you turned it down because of "housing prices". You could easily rent a nice place dtown Seattle for $2k/mnth.
End result: You're a liar
41
u/thecodeboss Jul 28 '16
You're being pretty rude - but I don't know if there's anything going on in your life that's making things tough for you, so I won't judge. I do hope you don't take it out on others, though.
To address your statements:
Yes, I requested a salary 3x what I was currently making. You got very close to my current salary at that time (I made a little more). Like I said, I wasn't expecting the recruiter to accept that amount - but it wasn't an unimaginable amount for me to uproot my family to move to Seattle.
There were many onsite interview questions in addition to the ones I remembered - I just can't remember them well enough to talk about them. Of the ones I mentioned - the whole point of these questions is for the interviewer to continue asking deeper questions and change things up for you. Also, keep in mind this is an interview. I don't have Google or any other sources. I can't even look up common APIs of tools. The questions are kept simpler for that reason - so you can talk about them. You don't even have to get them 100% right - the whole point is to just talk through your mindset.
I wish the best for you my friend.
15
u/aghman Jul 28 '16
As a developer working in Seattle I can say that 100k for a senior position is a crappy salary and wouldn't go very far. You'd end up living way north or way south and spend all your time commuting. All in all, a good decision I think. Thanks for the great write up, it was enlightening.
-43
u/look_behind_youuu Jul 28 '16
If your story is true:
You would be making more than DOUBLE your current wage NET of your housing costs
You'd be working for one of the largest, most respected companies in the world
To turn down an offer like that would be absurd. Either you're lying about the wage or you never got an offer.
9
u/Aeolun Jul 28 '16
Unless you are going to be in a really senior position or in a very specific sector, you would definitely be able to answer the generic questions and be accepted (including getting a 120k offer, they just don't go lower). 90% of the candidates probably won't even know the answer. If you're a nice person on top of that, well, that's a bonus.
Based on the way you are speaking, you probably wouldn't qualify for the nice person quantifier.
10
u/Rofl-Cakes Jul 28 '16
Well it's ok because I'm the president of Amazon and I would of fired him anyways. It was a good call on his part.
2
-4
5
u/uber_neutrino Jul 28 '16
Says the guy who is apparently jealous. hint: the gigantic chip on your should is preventing you from being successful. Get therapy.
8
u/fdar Jul 28 '16
You might have got an offer as a junior web developer for probably $50k, or you didn't get an offer at all.
I have no experience from Amazon specifically, but top tech companies do make 6 figure offers to even new college grads with no experience (except maybe some internships).
6
3
2
0
Jul 28 '16
[deleted]
13
u/TheAnimus Jul 28 '16
No, his mum only charges him that much for the basement. He has his own door and everything.
-27
u/look_behind_youuu Jul 28 '16
Can you do math bro? He says the cost of rent would be double. That would be likely an extra $1000/mnth x 12. So he's saying $12k/yr is the reason why he didn't accept the offer of $100k+ bonus. His bonus alone would cover the increase in housing cost.
This guys a total liar
12
u/XxNerdKillerxX Jul 28 '16
By math, you mean personal finances? I think he just did them, and decided not to live there. What would you know about his personal financial situation...? I think it is pretty obvious that living in downtown Seattle would be quite more expensive and would need a major pay grade bump. Everyone has different abilities to make money in different places. For example, I am lucky enough to WFH fulltime. I make a lot more money WFH in a low cost area with an office in a high paying area. It would take me about $170k/year as well to move to downtown Seattle, but only because I would come close to breaking even to my current net savings. That includes their no state income tax.
You keep saying a nice place in downtown Seattle is 2k/month. No... A crappy or sub-par place would be, compared to how large/nice of a house he has now.
4
u/charminggeek Jul 28 '16
Double his rent to downsize his living situation and move away from family. For a home comparable to the one he's got in OKC, he'd be looking at 3500-4k/month. And you can't put a price on living near family.
0
Jul 28 '16
[deleted]
9
u/BigMax Jul 28 '16
Lots of established companies have switched to this. Partly because once a company is established, they generally won't see huge upticks in stock, so you can get options that don't really appreciate much, or even become worthless.
With a stock grant, they just give you some stock directly (often over a period of time). So they'll say "your bonus this year is 1000 shares of stock, given to you at 25% a year for the next four years."
That way you'll be guaranteed to get something since it's actual shares, not options, and you're still rewarded more if the stock goes up, since those shares could be worth more if the stock goes up over the next 4 years.
2
u/badasimo Jul 28 '16
Plus you can get dividends if that company pays them
3
u/jeffbarge Jul 28 '16
Only if you hold the stock after it vests. I get an annual RSU package, always vesting @ 25%/year. What that means is that the number of shares I'll receive each year is set, but I don't own them yet, so I don't receive any dividends until they vest. So if I hold them, sure I get the dividends. I don't want to have significant amounts of money tied up in a single investment though (especially my employer), so I typically sell shortly after vesting.
1
u/SMORKIN_LABBIT Jul 28 '16
Pretty standard is a 4 year vest with a 1 year cliff. You vest 100% over four years it takes 1 year for 25% to vest and then you start vesting a portion monthly after 1 year. This can be negotiated lower but 4 and 1 is standard.
1
1
Jul 28 '16
Ive been offered 4x the options to the RSU. I Always take the RSUs but if theres a big swing you can make money off the options but its risky.
1
0
Jul 28 '16
[deleted]
25
u/emiller42 Jul 28 '16
Keep in mind a couple things:
The initial recruiter typically has zero say in the offer presented, and it's entirely possible that what OP initially asked for was within the range of possible compensation for the position. I doubt the recruiter lied, they just gave an optimistic answer with the information they had at the time.
Companies often think about total compensation instead of just salary. They have some method of quantifying all the perks they provide and it's entirely possible that offered salary + stock options + other forms of compensation resulted in a number in the ballpark of what OP asked.
It's a negotiation. If OP starts with $170k, you know the first offer is going to be under that.
14
u/Nilzor Jul 28 '16
It's a negotiation
This. If OP had said "You know I really want this job but financially I just can't do it for (whatever he was offered), however for $190k I'll take the job and be the most passionate employee you've got" - then he'd probably gotten an offer for 170k and accepted it. But as he said, the biggest deal was family, not money.
0
Jul 28 '16
[deleted]
20
Jul 28 '16
It also helps to give some specific, number,, like 171,536 a year. That gives the impression your salary request was a well thought out and calculated number.
No it absolutely doesn't. As a hiring manager, if some clown told me a number that specific I'd literally laugh at them.
1
u/g0cean3 Jul 28 '16
No it makes you seem ridiculous and petty. At that point say 171k but realistically just round it to the 5s...
7
u/XxNerdKillerxX Jul 28 '16 edited Jul 28 '16
I doubt the recruiter lied, they just gave an optimistic answer with the information they had at the time.
Right, he's not lying. He's just answering optimistically, in his best interests. The point of lying is to gain something from it, not to just tell tall tales. I think the recruiter benefited from saying "yeah 170k is something we can work with" and was deceitful as well. They should have just been more honest (but yes, it is a negotiation and they don't want to divulge their max offer). So either way, their recruiter is insanely incompetent with regards to bringing someone in who wanted $170k, and wasting everyones time.
Amazon's bonus is a hefty part of their salary, true. Maybe the OP should total this better for us. I don't think he mentioned the bonus amount, just the stock options.
2
u/Droi Jul 28 '16
You're absolutely wrong and shouldn't defend practices like these.
If the recruiter can't guarantee the final offer will be in the range OP asked they should specifically say that beforehand.
Total compensation elements were mentioned in the post and it wasn't anywhere near the amount OP asked.
This was not a negotiation. OP specifically said this is a big move and this is the amount he would require in order to consider going through with the process - take it or leave it. The recruiter confirmed it is in the range of the position. The process of agreeing on a minimum offer is then complete - yes it's not official and you shouldn't get a mortgage based on it. But it's still very shitty and unprofessional to go back on the agreement. In most cases you've wasted both the candidate's time AND so many Amazon employees' time - it's bad for everyone.
1
u/SMORKIN_LABBIT Jul 28 '16
I work in tech.....more in product and technical consulting like sales engineering so not directly as an engineer. I always tell the recruiter like 20K higher than I already make plus my bonus (also inflated) and for the last three jobs when the recruiter said we can work in that range they ALWAYS came back and offered above what I said I was currently making. I'm not sure how OP positioned in negotiation but usually they pay someone more to leave a job. Unless OP was unemployed in which case he doesn't have as much leverage.
8
u/phurtive Jul 28 '16
How do you get out of doing all day interviews? They all want to do this.
9
u/XxNerdKillerxX Jul 28 '16
There is a large demand for developers. Surely someone out there is hiring who doesn't want me for an entire day.
In the past, what has worked for me:
Friends/networking. Phone interview was all that was needed, wasn't even technical just a formality with HR.
Contracting versus full-time. I don't typically stay at companies that long anyway. All that was needed was 1 technical interview. Studying for data structures helps to knock it out of the park.
Places on the east coast only want me there for up to 1.5 hours for fulltime positions.
Smaller companies, if you must interview on the west coast for fulltime. They may have 4-5 interviews but they are much better at knocking it out in a few hours and being less bureaucratic about it (taking an entire day). Probably because their entire team has to interview you so they all have to take turns, and they want to reunite and get back to work sooner. Whereas at a larger company, I think you have to wait on each person from different teams to show up on a scheduled time.
It's when I go to the west coast, where the tech companies are, that they want all-day interviews. So I avoid that now.
4
u/uber_neutrino Jul 28 '16
There is a large demand for developers. Surely someone out there is hiring who doesn't want me for an entire day.
I quite doing all day interviews a while ago. It just wastes everyones time. On the flip side with less time the applicant needs to quickly show their skills.
2
u/phurtive Jul 28 '16
Hmm good info.
I had a friend referral for a job, went in for a "quick" interview, lasted 6 hours. Then didn't get the job.
At one job, we had a candidate once who said he could only come in for 2 hours. We still interviewed him. I think I'll try that strategy.
2
u/yesman_85 Jul 28 '16
Don't work at a massive tech firm. There are plenty of startups or smaller companies that need development too.
3
u/yetanothernerd Jul 28 '16
There are definitely senior engineers who get offers that big at Amazon. (Not in just base salary, but in total cash compensation: base + signing bonus + RSUs). His was lower. Doesn't mean they were lying.
One possible reason is leveling. The loop may have decided to make him an offer at a less senior level. (Note: at Amazon, "senior" actually means senior, like top 10%. And "principal" is pretty rare, like top 2%.)
Another possibility is that he negotiated badly. Maybe he divulged that he made peanuts in OKC, and whoever put the offer together offered him peanuts + 20%, thinking most people will take a 20% raise.
1
u/thaen Jul 28 '16
This is the correct answer. I personally know people who were hired as senior engineers with starting total compensation in the 250k range. His offer makes it sound like he was interviewed at one level and offered at a level down.
1
u/XxNerdKillerxX Jul 28 '16
Curious, when moving from small town to big town, how do you negotiate a fair salary? It seems to me that, divulging your salary in that case is a really bad idea. So far what I say is that I make X per year. Then I hint out that X is a combination of my salary + freelance projects. And that If I go to work for them, I will only be able to work fulltime.
2
u/yetanothernerd Jul 28 '16
I won't claim to be an expert negotiator. But what works for me is to negotiate from a position of strength. I never need their job; I can always get another one. And I have enough savings to live for a long time without a job if necessary. So, regardless of how they come up with their offer, I always have the ability to turn it down.
3
u/uber_neutrino Jul 28 '16
To me it's a flat out lie because they simply had no intention of offering him that salary.
Amazon is well known for playing games with this. For example it's typical of them to bump up the first year using a signing bonus that vests over time.
Bullet dodged. Although Seattle is a very nice place to live...
2
u/yetanothernerd Jul 28 '16
Amazon offers typically include a signing bonus in the first year or two, but RSUs that ramp up over time. So in year one, lots of signing bonus, little stock. Year two, a bit less signing bonus, bit more stock. Year three and four, no signing bonus, much more stock. The total package goes up slowly over time, but the composition changes. (Of course, it's possible to get raises on top of the original offer.)
1
u/uber_neutrino Jul 28 '16
Point being they try and spread your yearly comp over time to get you to stick around.
For example the signing bonus typically has to be repaid if you leave before vesting.
Personally I'm not really sure why someone would want to work at Amazon right now when there is so much other more interesting opportunity around.
1
u/yetanothernerd Jul 28 '16
Yes, they are absolutely trying to get people to stick around.
Whether any signing bonus has to be repaid depends on whether you got the whole thing up front (as is common for new grads), or whether you got it spread out over your paychecks (as is common for experienced hires). If you got 2 years of signing bonus up front and leave before 2 years, you have to pay a prorated amount (not all) of it back. If you're getting it month-by-month, you don't have to give anything back.
Amazon does a lot of interesting stuff, and pays well. (They pay particularly well right now, because the stock has spiked from ~$300 to ~$740 over the last 18 months, meaning that all those sign-on RSUs are accidentally worth more than twice as much as expected. Whether that will continue over time, nobody knows, but it's been very good for current employees.) Finally, they have a pretty honest business model: sell things to customers for money. (Contrast with a couple of the Big 4 whose business model involves giving away free stuff and mining their users' personal information for sale to advertisers.)
1
u/uber_neutrino Jul 28 '16
Yes, they are absolutely trying to get people to stick around.
So people need to take this into account when accepting the job. They could get stuck with a debt to Amazon they can't repay in a job they don't like.
Whether any signing bonus has to be repaid depends on whether you got the whole thing up front (as is common for new grads), or whether you got it spread out over your paychecks (as is common for experienced hires). If you got 2 years of signing bonus up front and leave before 2 years, you have to pay a prorated amount (not all) of it back. If you're getting it month-by-month, you don't have to give anything back.
Sure. A month-to-month signing bonus isn't a bonus though, it's a fucking joke. It's basically a temporary salary boost. They are playing psych games. It's bullshit.
Amazon does a lot of interesting stuff, and pays well.
They pay ok, but certainly aren't near top of market. Their work environment is also subpar. Compared to the other big guys they are cheapos.
(They pay particularly well right now, because the stock has spiked from ~$300 to ~$740 over the last 18 months, meaning that all those sign-on RSUs are accidentally worth more than twice as much as expected. Whether that will continue over time, nobody knows, but it's been very good for current employees.)
Not saying they aren't successful, but I don't need to work there to invest a portion of my salary in Amazon stock.
Finally, they have a pretty honest business model: sell things to customers for money. (Contrast with a couple of the Big 4 whose business model involves giving away free stuff and mining their users' personal information for sale to advertisers.)
Yeah, they are great for customers. I buy a shitton of stuff from them.
However, to characterize companies like Google as not being honest is itself dishonest.
Anyway I don't have a horse in this game, I'm coming at this completely from the angle of being a software engineer looking for a job. Amazon might make a nice resume piece but you are basically working at the walmart of tech. There is just so much opportunity out there...
1
u/yetanothernerd Jul 28 '16
Signing bonus dollars aren't complete bullshit; they spend the same as salary dollars. Of course I'd rather have $50k/year more salary than a $50k signing bonus, because salary is recurring and a signing bonus is once. But they're not going to give you that, for the same reason. So, in more realistic terms, I'd rather have a $50k cash signing bonus than the real alternative, another $50k in RSUs.
I agree that paying new hires signing bonuses up front is a trap for some -- if they spend it all then they might feel that staying in a job they don't like is their only option. Of course they can take a different offer, or, if Amazon is the best offer even without the signing bonus, just stick the signing bonus in the bank until it's vested.
I'm being completely honest that I find the Google / Facebook business model gross, because the majority of the users are not really the customers and so get treated like shit at the expense of the advertisers who are the real customers. I personally would take an Amazon/Apple offer over an equal Google/Facebook offer for that reason. (Microsoft is kind of in the middle.) Other people don't really care, and would go for Google/Facebook because of the nicer perks. That's fine.
1
u/uber_neutrino Jul 28 '16
Signing bonus dollars aren't complete bullshit; they spend the same as salary dollars. Of course I'd rather have $50k/year more salary than a $50k signing bonus, because salary is recurring and a signing bonus is once. But they're not going to give you that, for the same reason. So, in more realistic terms, I'd rather have a $50k cash signing bonus than the real alternative, another $50k in RSUs.
If it's a real signing bonus then it's not going to vest over time. Anything else is a trick at best.
I agree that paying new hires signing bonuses up front is a trap for some -- if they spend it all then they might feel that staying in a job they don't like is their only option. Of course they can take a different offer, or, if Amazon is the best offer even without the signing bonus, just stick the signing bonus in the bank until it's vested.
If it's their only option then it's simple. Take what you can get. It doesn't mean amazon isn't playing HR games here.
I'm being completely honest that I find the Google / Facebook business model gross, because the majority of the users are not really the customers and so get treated like shit at the expense of the advertisers who are the real customers.
That's fantastic but it's not really the issue we are talking about here. Being a customer and an employee are just... different.
I personally would take an Amazon/Apple offer over an equal Google/Facebook offer for that reason.
I wouldn't take any of them personally, working for other people is lamzor; )
1
u/XxNerdKillerxX Jul 29 '16
cough Garupa sucks cough
They have a lot of new development work in Java/etc with regards to porting their old Garupa work. But sadly, this goes to the more senior developers who stick around. Newbies/contractors are often assigned the less interesting work. The last tasks to be picked.
1
u/XxNerdKillerxX Jul 29 '16
When I worked there, they had a social media type app on their intranet. So like if you want to message someone you could easily see their "page" and how long they worked there. Was very rare to see anyone at the 4 year mark. That's pretty typical with tech companies though. Developers get bored of solving the same problems and also want raises.
2
u/robertbieber Jul 28 '16
Eh, it's not necessarily a lie. Generally if you're getting an offer from a company it's not a simple yes/no decision, they'll want you to a certain degree. Interview performance might not just be the difference between getting an offer or not, but the difference between them wanting you at 170 vs wanting you at 130. I'm sure Amazon has engineers on the payroll making well north of 200, so it's likely that 170 could have been completely possible if they'd wanted the author badly enough
2
Jul 28 '16
It is strange to me that they did not mention trying to negotiate at all. If someone told me a number initially, I would definitely bring that up.
21
u/thecodeboss Jul 28 '16
OP here. If you subscribe to /r/compsci and/or /r/javascript - you may have seen this in the last week or two. Those subreddits really seemed to like this post - so I thought I might give it a shot in the big kahuna of them all - /r/programming. I hope you guys like it too.
I know this topic has probably been posted many times - or at least something similar, but I still want to share my experiences with interviewing, being offered a job, and eventually turning down said offer with Amazon.
This one goes out to all of you in a similar position who are interviewing, and want to know step-by-step someone else's full experience. And even if you're not actively interviewing with a tech giant (or anyone, for that matter) - I hope it still benefits you somehow.