r/programming • • May 11 '16

Github changes pricing structure - per user charge with unlimited repos

https://github.com/blog/2164-introducing-unlimited-private-repositories
295 Upvotes

240 comments sorted by

View all comments

172

u/Athas May 11 '16

I'm a member of a Github organisation with 63 members and 20 private repositories. As far as I can see, this changes our yearly cost from $600 to $6564.

53

u/Braxo May 11 '16

My organization went the opposite way, we're on the Fermium plan which is $855 per month (600 repos).

We have 8 people. So our new costs would be $152

$10,260 down to $1,824

15

u/cbigsby May 11 '16 edited May 11 '16

We have ~240 people and ~330 repos on the Holmium plan which is $650/month (up to 450 repos). With the new model it'll go to $2,160/month. Luckily they're saying that we don't have to move for at least a year.

You can't win 'em all; it does make sense for larger organizations to subsidize the smaller ones.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '16

[deleted]

9

u/pxtang May 11 '16

Yeah, but GitHub has a familiar and popular UI.

But to add onto your point, does anyone know if it would be cheaper to run a Git server on AWS or Google compared to private GitHub or Bitbucket repos?

9

u/wrosecrans May 11 '16

Depends on the scale. For a single user, no. Running an EC2 instance 24x7 is more expensive than the $7/mo. For ~10 users the infrastructure in EC2 is probably cheaper than Github. For large organisations, you need to scale up to multiple servers and such and I'm not sure exactly where the crossover points would lie.

That said, the several people working 24x7 to fix it and keep it updated, and make sure it's working are going to cost you many orders of magnitude more than the EC2 infrastructure. That's the real benefit of using a service like Github, moreso than CPU time or disk space.

7

u/kushangaza May 11 '16

But EC2 really isn't the right service for running a single git server. For that job a VPS is cheaper and more powerful, and available at many providers for less than $7/mo. As you scale up, a bigger VPS or a small dedicated server is probably still the better option.

There are great use cases for EC2. I don't think this is one of them.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/levir May 11 '16

As far as I can tell the cheapest option on Github is $7/month.

At Digital Ocean the cheapest server is $5/month, and it should be more than good enough to run a typical git server.

4

u/vanrysss May 11 '16

You could try https://gogs.io/ on a digital ocean droplet and probably get by for $20/mo depending on your needs.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ThatOnePerson May 11 '16

Gogs and GitLab are two popular self-hosted GitHub clones. They might not be 100% as nice as GitLab, but they work. GitLab even has a built in Mattermost (open-source Slack clone) if you want that too.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/cbigsby May 11 '16

We use it for a lot more than just Git. We do all our pull requests on there, it hosts wikis and documentation for projects, permission management on repos, and a couple other things. Plus, it's just a nice UI for Git.

We could roll our own hosted Git, but we don't have any knowledge on what's required to host 300+ repos, and switching away from Github would be a pretty big, expensive shift.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/yesman_85 May 11 '16

We have a 5 man team and 70 repo's. So BB was the only way to go before, now GH is finally a player again.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '16

[deleted]

6

u/0drew0 May 11 '16

$10/member/year is a fucking steal

It's not $10 per member per year. It's $108/member/year (after the first 5 users at $25/month). The new plans are priced at $9/month/user.

In /u/Athas's case, it's $25/month for the first 5 users, then $522/month for the remaining 58 users, for a total of $6,564 for the year.

(25 * 12) + ( (58 * 9) * 12 ) = $6,564

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '16

[deleted]

3

u/0drew0 May 11 '16

Oh yeah, definitely. Fair point :)

43

u/kn4rf May 11 '16

Time to switch to bitbucket I guess. You get unlimited private repos and up to 100 users for 100$ a month (or unlimited users for 200$). Not sure why you ever used Github for your private organisation, their pricing have always been shit.

19

u/[deleted] May 11 '16

If you want a wiki, you need Confluence, too. If you want an issue tracker, you need Jira, too. Bitbucket is cheaper because Atlassian's offerings are more segmented. If you're a small organization looking for an all in one solution, Github is probably still better. If you're a large organization, I'd agree, but I really wonder how many large organizations aren't already using Atlassian products.

I've used both offerings before. Jira kicks Github's issue tracker out of the water, but for a company under 50 people, Github's issue tracker gets the job done. Source control and PRs are very similar. I like Github PRs a bit better, but that's just personal preference.

I'd suspect that the majority of Github's customers are smaller companies, and that this price change isn't as substantial as many people are claiming here.

21

u/gauauu May 11 '16

if you want a wiki, you need Confluence, too. If you want an issue tracker, you need Jira, too

This is misleading and not entirely true.

It depends on what you want out of your wiki and issue tracker. Bitbucket has a simple wiki and issue tracker built-in for each repository. They aren't as full-featured as Confluence and Jira, but you don't necessarily need those other tools just to get a wiki and issue tracker.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '16

True, but there's a niche between vanilla Bitbucket and the full Atlassian suite that Github fits nicely into, IMO.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

12

u/MrDOS May 11 '16

No it doesn't.

We want everyone to have a plan with unlimited private repositories, but don’t worry—you are welcome to stay on your current plan while you evaluate the new cost structure and understand how to best manage your organization members and their private repository access.

→ More replies (6)

26

u/dsk May 11 '16 edited May 11 '16

It's a big price jump but $600/year for 63 users is insanely cheap. This new pricing model better reflects the current market for cloud services.

For example we use kiln (+fogbugz), intellij webstorm, and office 365, and this new pricing is pretty much inline with those services.

12

u/Dark_Crystal May 11 '16

Eh, not really. 63 users with ~20 private repos that are <50MB each is a pittance for hosting and traffic. But 10 users with a single 500GB private repo would cost a lot more to host and in traffic. And you don't really get much with Github, git itself is free, the site features are not terribly complicated/robust.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/rydan May 11 '16

Too bad I guess though you aren't required to switch. I'm a GitHub organization with 10 repos but I've been deleting repos so I don't have to pay double for one or two more. My costs just stayed the same and I can actually things done now. Planning to have 30 - 40 repos in the next few months. Github is finally a great value for the money.

→ More replies (11)