r/programming • • Oct 29 '25

[ Removed by moderator ]

/r/programming/comments/1oj28yn/removed_by_moderator/

[removed] — view removed post

0 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

•

u/programming-ModTeam Oct 29 '25

This post was removed for violating the "/r/programming is not a support forum" rule. Please see the side-bar for details.

4

u/z19970615 Oct 29 '25

I think the problem is: The answer of stackoverflow is not as good as before since 3 years ago. Sometimes the better solution would be discarded or you can't answer for the answered one, but the existing answer is not good enough.

-6

u/Senior_Note_6956 Oct 29 '25

Stackoverflow is a big star in my eyes, but like Apple, it has been beaten in the AI race and is no longer developing any AI. Stackoverflow has also fallen behind in AI technology, and we haven't found a solution for how we can proactively use AI on our site. For example, the first ChatGPT-3 models generated responses by crawling Stackoverflow, but now they are pulling all the data from Reddit. For this very reason, Reddit sued companies like OpenAI, Perplexity

Link what I found on LinkedIn:
https://cemkoyluoglu.codes/tech-news/reddit-sues-perplexity-for-using-its-content-without-permission-for-ai-training

4

u/roscoelee Oct 29 '25

Where do you think Generative AI would get its answers from if SO went away?

-1

u/Senior_Note_6956 Oct 29 '25

Ofc Github... AI models are already scanning GitHub, Ai models aren't looking at the SO side anymore 

1

u/Senior_Note_6956 Oct 29 '25

For exp: Grokipedia is citing reddit as a source

https://x.com/_thomasip/status/1983122673094840580

2

u/lelanthran Oct 29 '25

Ofc Github... AI models are already scanning GitHub, Ai models aren't looking at the SO side anymore

I suggest you try training an LLM; use HuggingFace or something.

Github can be used as input data to train the LLM to output code, but you still need input data in the form of "question -> answer" to train it to actually answer questions (even if self-generated questions generated from deep reasoning).

That's how "probability of generating the next token in a sequence" works, after all.

20

u/flyers25 Oct 29 '25

A world where nobody needs to know how to write code has been “10 years away” for the past 50 years.

2

u/chris-antoinette Oct 29 '25

100% this. It's like self-driving cars - the point at which an autonomous technology becomes commercially viable is the point at which you know who to sue when it goes wrong. Which is why we're going to need human oversight for a good while yet.

1

u/roscoelee Oct 29 '25

I’ve always wondered that. If an autonomous car was in an accident, the car company should absolutely be on the hook for any damages shouldn’t they?

1

u/lelanthran Oct 29 '25

May I introduce you to the legally binding phrase "Terms and Conditions Apply"

The T&C almost certainly contains something that, when translated from legalese, means exactly this: The car will drive itself for hours, days, weeks or years on end. However, at any given point in time, the driver must be ready to take over with less than 100ms notice. If the driver does not react within 100ms, they are liable.

1

u/roscoelee Oct 29 '25

Is that the actual T&C for self-driving cars? I feel like most people interested in a self-driving car would be ignoring the expectation that they respond within 1/10th of a second.

1

u/lelanthran Oct 29 '25

Is that the actual T&C for self-driving cars?

When translated from legalese, probably. The actual clause is going to be more along the lines of "Driver must be ready to take over at any time".

1

u/_pupil_ Oct 29 '25

So what you’re saying is… we just need to teach the LLMs to use Visual Programming and we’ll finally  have AGI?

(AGI defined as the ability to get boxes and arrows to do what we want without having to specify exactly what that is, or fully what boxes and arrows are, and also make the stop sign red into firetruck red when those error squiggles come up and also fix all the errors forever…)

12

u/roscoelee Oct 29 '25

I’ve gone the other way. When Generative AI first was coming out I started using it, but I’m finding it less and less effective and not comparable to community help.

3

u/jc-from-sin Oct 29 '25

ITT, op doesn't know what "officially" means

1

u/TheBlueArsedFly Oct 29 '25

Ironically, that's not now ITT is supposed to be used. 

3

u/s-mores Oct 29 '25

Oh look, more AI hallucination.

1

u/TheBlueArsedFly Oct 29 '25

The funny thing is the AI hallucinations are significantly less likely, and easier to correct for, than a bad answer on stackoverflow. As well as that, the AI. Response is real-time, far more nuanced, less opinionated and more balanced than most of the stuff on stackoverflow.

It's lazy rhetoric on reddit to make comments about hallucinations in response to AI discussions. It's not really that clever and it's not 2023 anymore so it's not as much of a problem as you might think it is. You would do well to pull your head out of your ass. 

1

u/Full-Spectral Oct 29 '25

The problem though is that, LLMs provide no discussion, no second opinions (whether you might thing they are rude or whatever.) Just spit out something like some kind of oracle and people believe it. Technical discussion sites provide discussion, rebuttal, nuance and so forth, which is very important.

1

u/TheBlueArsedFly Oct 29 '25

Second opinion? Yes they do. You don't know what you're talking about. You're speaking through your biases rather than any semblance of fact or meaningful experience. You're literally the problem with human-based discussion. 

1

u/Full-Spectral Oct 29 '25

I'm talking about an actual person who can respond to your question and then others who can respond to that, and debate the finer issues of the question, ask you questions based on their expertise, who you can message perhaps with a query, where you can go look at their post history and reputation to get a feel for their competency, etc...

1

u/roscoelee Oct 29 '25

And we need to stop given these models credit by calling it a hallucination. It’s just giving a wrong answer, or being a shitty product. Saying it is hallucinating is giving it too much credit.

3

u/PkmnSayse Oct 29 '25

SOCorp has been actively ignoring their meta community at this point for years and everyone is getting tired of it. They announce “experiments”, get downvoted to oblivion, ignore any feedback that comes in more than 48 hours after the announcement, and then 2 weeks later announce the experiment was a success because of a pointless metric so it’s like talking to a wall.

2

u/JuanAG Oct 29 '25

The fact that you can trust LLMs says all, when you start needing real knowledge you will understand how wrong you are thinking this

And i hope it happens soon, for your own good or you will be the ones that will be replaced by the "IA" everyone talks

0

u/mallardtheduck Oct 29 '25

StackOverflow is still sometimes useful, but it's full of out-of-date information. You really have to pay attention to dates. Sometimes there's a more up-to-date answer under the "accepted" answer, but there often is not. It's a shame their platform doesn't have any mechanism for mitigating this, not to mention the moderation culture that is very happy to kill your question for being a "duplicate" of some similar question from a decade ago with "solutions" that no longer work.

Once the AI hype calms down, we'll see what the future of coding looks like. IMHO, use of LLMs is pretty bad for beginners, since they end up throwing together generated code that they don't have the ability to understand and cannot maintain long-term, maybe ending up with a program that "works", but often contains bugs and flaws that an experienced developer would never allow. It feeds "Dunning-Kruger" type misassesment of their skills. For more experienced folks, it can be useful for prototyping, automating away repetitive tasks, finding the right areas in large codebases, etc. I'll eat my proverbial hat if "no one will write code in 10 years' time".