r/programming • u/GhostalMedia • Jun 09 '23
Apollo dev posts backend code to Git to disprove Reddit’s claims of scrapping and inefficiency
https://github.com/christianselig/apollo-backend189
u/TiredPanda69 Jun 09 '23
This is just the natural development of capitalist platforms. Are we really surprised?
The holy grail of useful massive public platforms is underground, its fringe and it only lasts for their infancy.
Once they come to surface privatized, they necessarily become a way for its owners to make money. That's how capital works. And it ruins platforms.
Don't pretend it isn't like this. It happens to all but the incredibly strong and willing individuals or organizations.
It starts off as a question of securing income: "well put ads", then as it grows: "there are offers to buy metadata", "our advertisers want certain content to be toned down". It happens to most. It's a tendency.
I dont like it, but I expect it to continue happening to most platforms that come to light in our economic system.
This is platform development under capitalism.
75
u/GhostalMedia Jun 09 '23
There is one exception, decentralized and distributed systems. Example, email / SMTP.
This is arguably why federated social networks are an interesting idea.
60
u/uuuuuuuaaaaaaa Jun 09 '23
Even email is suffering from Google’s monopolization. If you send from a self-hosted domain (or anything that’s not gmail, really), you’re likely to get send to spam folder of 90% of recipients (again, gmail)
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (11)8
u/TiredPanda69 Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
Yes, exactly
I do believe these are the future of the peoples internet.
Yet some of these standards are still manipulated by big interests through their managing organizations. And that can be staved off by users controlling versioning. But it very quickly becomes a problem of hardware.
That's a big set back for us as people. Controlling what the hardware does is the next step in freeing computing
41
u/GoodBoiAuto Jun 09 '23
"Enshittification"
Be a good site to users, lure in as many users as possible.
Then be a good site to advertisers, lure in as many as possible.
Then once you have as close to a monopoly as feasible over both groups, cut costs and reap the profit until the platform collapses.
Entire departments revolve around ensuring the final stage lasts for as long as possible. But once it has started, it's inevitable. No stakeholder wants to hear that this quarter will be less profitable than last, even if it means a better platform.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (16)11
u/Spider_pig448 Jun 09 '23
Capitalism is what has enabled it to exist for the last 10 years at least, so we got something. The alternative I guess would be a government run project like this that was closed to 3rd parties from the start and likely a significantly worse product the entire time, for much higher development costs.
→ More replies (3)
1.5k
Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
686
271
u/ZeroThePenguin Jun 09 '23
I'm sure it will go incredibly smoothly what with all of the negative comments being removed and only approved dick sucking posts are allowed to stay up
90
26
u/Gangsir Jun 09 '23
I'm excited for either outcome. Either it's a massive meme of everyone shitting on him, or it's a display of how low he's willing to stoop, correcting everyone's comments to praise.
Will be an internet historic event, to be sure.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (8)9
33
11
u/jack0rias Jun 09 '23
You know that little pig looking fucker will cancel the AMA.
→ More replies (9)5
→ More replies (45)3
u/driverofracecars Jun 09 '23
I doubt he even shows up. It will be an intern answering questions for him.
7.7k
u/FyreWulff Jun 09 '23
I was honestly both creeped out and disappointed at Reddit admins for trying to: 1) falsely insinuate Apollo was abusing the API 2) falsely claim Apollo was extorting them and 3) trying to go for "Apollo is programmed bad" as a desperation attempt to appeal to nerds to turn people to their side.
2.3k
u/FC37 Jun 09 '23
When I read the article, it was legitimately hard for me to understand how Reddit's execs could have even interpreted those comments as "extortion." I still don't understand how someone's mind can jump to that from the comments that were made.
3.3k
u/timeshifter_ Jun 09 '23
Victim complex. We're talking about /u/spez here, known for silently editing comments he doesn't like. Reddit has done exactly what they said they wouldn't do, on a time scale they said they wouldn't do it in, and are attempting to deflect their obvious stupidity onto the most widely known third-party dev. Reddit is going to absolutely trash their value before they even hit IPO. They've rejected endless opportunities to make their own app suck less, and instead they've tripled down on the suck, and gone out of their way to make the main website suck for the benefit of literally nobody. They're basically just asking to be killed off at this point, and given that the entire site's moderation is done by volunteers using primarily third-party tools... the community will be only too happy to oblige.
→ More replies (460)1.5k
451
Jun 09 '23
Read further. That actually happened in a prior call at the end of May. It was immediately addressed and reddit acknowledged the misunderstanding and apologized for it. They already had that conversation and knew it wasn't a threat. Spez repeating it today was intentional malice.
Unfortunately for them, the Apollo dev recorded all the calls, and in his big post already brought the receipts.
→ More replies (72)335
u/kazza789 Jun 09 '23
When I read the article, it was legitimately hard for me to understand how Reddit's execs could have even interpreted those comments as "extortion." I still don't understand how someone's mind can jump to that from the comments that were made.
Yeah - the idea of acquiring a downstream service is incredibly normal in the world of business. I can't understand at all how they would think of that discussion topic as making a threat.
And then, in context as well, it was clear what was being said. They were saying "your pricing suggests that Apollo is worth $20M. If that's true, then shouldn't you be willing to buy it for $10M?". Where the implication was obviously that they're not going to buy it for $10M and therefore the pricing is ridiculous.
→ More replies (42)101
49
u/go_ninja_go Jun 09 '23
Honestly, when I read the transcript, I could see how the reddit rep initially misinterpreted it. The dev clarified though and the rep immediately apologized. To me, it sounds like reddit recorded the call as well and is grasping at anything to twist the narrative.
→ More replies (13)→ More replies (63)48
u/tsammons Jun 09 '23
They also sent out market research to advertisers, 15 minute questionnaire (more like 25) for a $100 Amazon gift card. That was mid April; nothing received. I don't see Reddit doing the right thing anymore at this time unless it's aligned with maximizing their short-term IPO valuation.
→ More replies (2)789
u/cat_prophecy Jun 09 '23
If Apollo is “coded poorly” what does that say about the dumpster fire that is the official app? Jesus Christ these people have some fucking cheek.
154
Jun 09 '23
It is amazing the size of stones people will throw while living in glass houses.
→ More replies (4)101
Jun 09 '23 edited Jul 10 '23
special sulky melodic crawl fade touch jar sugar boast berserk -- mass edited with redact.dev
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (35)31
Jun 09 '23
I think it's the API that's poorly optimised - forcing apps to code "poorly" and make 10x more requests than any other platform - it's not poor, because it's only way to get shit to work
→ More replies (4)142
7
u/killeronthecorner Jun 09 '23
Apollo is programmed bad
This is really only judgable relative to another client.
Seeing as Reddit is making the claim, the only way to resolve it is for them to release the entire source code for both native Reddit apps.
I await the release of the source code which I'm sure will be objectively superior
/s
11
u/boonhet Jun 09 '23
trying to go for "Apollo is programmed bad"
Yeah it's a bold claim from the company behind the official reddit app and the new reddit website and the reddit video player...
→ More replies (1)8
u/SooooooMeta Jun 09 '23
After over a decade on this site all told, it’s so disappointing to see what a piece of shit company has turned out to be. Was it always bad or another instance of “you either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain”
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (123)7
u/SabMayHaiBC Jun 09 '23
The best part is the mods don't get paid for this shit. They're shitty individuals normally.
7
u/Starslip Jun 09 '23
But we're not talking about mods...we're talking about admins, i.e. reddit's paid employees
→ More replies (1)
2.2k
u/ForShotgun Jun 09 '23
Inefficiency lmao, have they seen their own app? Feels like an awkward piece of shit compared to Apollo. Also they could have just discussed it if they really cared about API efficiency, but we all know they just want to monetize to IPO, as soon as possible and they don't care if they have to burn the site down to do it. AMA's are already worthless, how did that monetization go? Because that's what this shitshow is going to look like
666
u/LiberContrarion Jun 09 '23
Feels like an awkward piece of shit compared to Apollo.
Not just feels like -- is.
→ More replies (4)244
u/--xx Jun 09 '23
i used the official app for 2minutes and I found a bug.
The touch area for the “Home” drop-down at the top is the entire button, until u visit a subreddit. now u can only trigger the drop-down via the tiny little arrow.
that’s within two minutes playing around w the official app… wtf is this spaghetti code
→ More replies (13)262
u/absentmindedjwc Jun 09 '23
From recordings Apollo dev has of calls with Reddit execs, the reason wasn't API efficiency, they want to be able to flood people with stupid He Gets Us ads.
45
u/Spitfire1900 Jun 09 '23
From the interview with snazzy labs, Christian mentioned that the APIs for ads aren’t even available if Apollo wanted to add them. on top of that a number of third-party apps reached out to Reddit about making it available in order to avoid all this.
174
u/Inquisitive_idiot Jun 09 '23
Yeah when I read that the dude “had the receipts” my interest was peaked 🤨…
… and then he started stating that Canada is one-party consent…
…and was like 😮 🤡 this gonna be good 😈
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (8)14
u/Starslip Jun 09 '23
And from data he pulled of the official app's API requests, reddit sure as fuck has no place to talk about efficiency anyway. 156 api calls in 3 minutes of usage of the official app and they want to blame apollo for being inefficient? fuck outta here
171
Jun 09 '23
They privately said they wanted to monetize opportunity cost, not server costs (per Apollo). Then they openly bash the efficiency and basically say everything (except NSFW) should get cached externally.
Ridiculous.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (27)130
Jun 09 '23
but we all know they just want to monetize to IPO
yes, but not from the API. With those prices they clearly just wanted 3rd party apps to go away. Then they'll give exceptions to the ones they want to allow.. which they already have.
The outright lies and dishonest tactics only validate that any "negotiations" with the TPA devs was entirely in bad faith, as their real goal was to push them out.
→ More replies (2)100
u/mobileuseratwork Jun 09 '23
Yep.
Some MBA clown would have sat down and tried to fudge the numbers to make them look way better than they are
"Oh if you clowns somehow move all the 3rd party API traffic into the official app, then the advertising and user data tracking revenue will go up by 20% and make the company another $1billion". So just turn that off somehow and you will get 100% of those users
Um fucking no.
Content creator %s will drop.
Moderation quality will drop, causing subreddits to expire and user participation will drop
Repost, scam, tshirt sellers, spammers and banned user posts will skyrocket exponentially. User participation will drop off a cliff.
→ More replies (34)
1.5k
u/Xanza Jun 09 '23
Don't worry /u/spez It's going to be really easy to afford the bills when everybody stops fucking using Reddit because you guys are turning into a bunch of money hungry fucks that forget where you came from.
✌️✌️✌️
→ More replies (28)513
u/absentmindedjwc Jun 09 '23
Spez doesn't care, he just wants to cash out in the IPO.
→ More replies (128)20
u/qdatk Jun 09 '23
I don't get why he doesn't just cash out in the IPO without making a dumpster fire first. Surely a website where the entire userbase isn't in revolt would be worth more?
→ More replies (15)
747
u/0x1f606 Jun 09 '23
Shoutout to the git commit message of "things".
460
u/Artillect Jun 09 '23
I'm a big fan of "reduce account updates" followed immediately by "but for real this time" lol
→ More replies (4)214
u/XoXFaby Jun 09 '23
I've definitely done this.
"fixed thing"
"actually fixed thing"
"actually actually fixed thing for real this time"→ More replies (27)215
Jun 09 '23
30
102
u/Mxfrj Jun 09 '23
That’s actually Reddit terminology
… they keep a Thing Table and a Data Table. Everything in Reddit is a Thing: users, links, comments, subreddits, awards, etc. Things keep common attribute like up/down votes, a type, and creation date. The Data table has three columns: thing id, key, value...
→ More replies (4)69
u/Neocrasher Jun 09 '23
Man, if only programming had an existing term to describe objects...
→ More replies (11)140
u/noobsc2 Jun 09 '23
b585906 "did thing" 385d06 "fix thing" af59f6 "thing working now" c585e06 "fix thing" b5f90a "thing really working this time" b5a59d6 "disable thing"→ More replies (4)12
10
u/dbbost Jun 09 '23
For projects where one person is writing 99% of the code we are all guilty of using "update stuff" for every single commit message
→ More replies (8)9
367
u/redcoatwright Jun 09 '23
They know what they're doing, 100% they want to kill off 3rd party apps to get add revenue and user data.
The reason they won't reverse the decision is this is the intended outcome and honestly they don't care if a couple 100k people leave reddit over it.
150
u/useablelobster2 Jun 09 '23
It's more a question of who this forces to leave, and what they bring to the website.
Getting rid of third party apps is selecting for the older and most invested users. We have been here for years, and we clearly shopped around for the best experience. All they are going to be left with is the new users.
Imagine the eternal September, but instead of just lots of new people joining, all the grey hairs piss off for greener pastures at the same time.
This website is DEAD.
→ More replies (10)104
u/Xarthys Jun 09 '23
It won't matter much imho, because most of the content in popular (aka profitable) subs is already bot-driven reposts, with very little OC.
So from a casual user's perspective, not much would change, as most people just read the feeds, where all the ads are anyways.
The lack of quality content might be more visible when diving into comments, but even then that can be easily masked by reddit deploying their own ChatGPT-supported bot army to keep things interesting.
At the end of the day, it probably won't even make a dent, as any humans providing quality content will be replaced by some automated content generation. And most users being here for the rage bait and all that probably won't even notice?
It's the smaller communities who will suffer the most imho, especially tech focused, because those have the most power users.
Moderation, including spam/scam could become a bigger issue though, however maybe reddit already has volunteers waiting to take open positions, once the old brigade has either deleted their accounts or been replaced after going dark too long.
Admins can take over any sub at any point, so it wouldn't suprise me either if communities go back to normal, simply because those who made them private no longer are in control.
My point being that reddit is going to change drastically, giving much more control to site admins over basically every aspect, including what type of content is going to be around.
We will probably see much more censorship and sanitation attempts, combined with major SFW ad-friendly spaces that will be mostly reddit's internal bot network curating content aggressively to create the desired engagement and metrics.
Everything that is being done now is about making profits. You can't really control millions of humans, but you can do so with millions of bots.
Wild thoughts, I know, but I do believe reddit wants to turn into a dedicated money printer, and the only way to achieve this is to change the entire platform, including the way content is being generated.
I think we are about to witness a major transition from news aggregation/discussion to fully automated content farm.
→ More replies (25)→ More replies (17)16
Jun 09 '23
Might not be a ton of people, but the ones that bounce are gonna be the ones that mod /r/Seahawks, /r/Vinyl, /r/mechanicalkeyboards and countless other communities from sports to nerd shit. And for real if they go public all the NSFW subs are gonna get banned and that’s a fuck ton of people that won’t ever use Reddit again.
→ More replies (3)
588
u/dacjames Jun 09 '23
Instead of making up technical bullshit, what Reddit should do is structure their API access deals as a profit sharing agreement where third party apps like Apollo pay Reddit a percentage of their ad revenue after some threshold.
I think reddit has the right to monetize the site however they want, which they can't do with third party apps. They want 100% of that revenue but what they don't realize is that a large percentage of users will quit before they switch off their preferred app. It would be better to capture 30% of those users than to jeopardize the entire site trying to cut out the developers who acquired many of these users in the first place.
352
u/Toast42 Jun 09 '23 edited Jul 05 '23
So long and thanks for all the fish
38
→ More replies (5)66
u/Inquisitive_idiot Jun 09 '23
Yeah… ”Fool me once…”
Who in Sam Hill over there thought kicking developers to the curve through attrition - after Twitter just self-emollated themselves in public a few months ago doing the same damn thing - wouldn’t be noticed for what it was.
Instead of lying / misrepresentation / trying to kick developers out through attrition, they should have been straight with folks and said we’re cutting everyone off and licked their wounds.
And if they intended to keep the api access, make it palatable to both 3rd party developers looking for modern integrations and investors looking for user data mining and monetization.
Instead what they achieved is to insult absolutely everybody.
→ More replies (15)21
u/cedear Jun 09 '23
All spez and other stockholders care about at this point is getting the IPO money so they can bail.
→ More replies (8)11
u/aksdb Jun 09 '23
If this really was about revenue lost due to apps not displaying ads, they could have locked API access behind Reddit Premium. That would have still affected the user base, but with far less impact and in a far more comprehensible way.
→ More replies (57)7
u/Kwpolska Jun 09 '23
Or they could make API access a Reddit Premium feature. While not everyone would be happy, it would be a fair way to get paid for the API without bothering the developers too much. (And they could have some free tier for the API that would allow for basic usage / trying out a third-party client.)
117
u/EshuMarneedi Jun 09 '23
While they wax poetic bullshit about how "inefficient" Apollo is, let's just admire how absolutely abysmal their official app is. It's slow, it doesn't work right half the time, and it's a terrible user experience. Why don't they fix that? Oh right, it's because they're so focused on putting a shitton of ads and trackers in it to sell user data and make maximum profit. "But that's business, not inefficiency!"
13
u/appleparkfive Jun 09 '23
They think they can just do whatever they want, obviously. That people will stick around no matter what. They see people like Netflix pulling shit and people sticking around.
But there's one problem there. The content on Netflix is media that is delivered to the user. For Reddit, the content IS the user's input. We all make the content.
I'm really curious to see if this is going to be a Digg rehash, where another site comes along and just takes over. If there's a similar site that has a good ToS against things like hate speech (so it doesn't turn into a Voat kind of place), it could very well attract a ton of people away from Reddit.
155
u/WolfgangSho Jun 09 '23
I'm calling it now:
u/spez will be the sacrificial lamb.
They will walk back a bit of the API changes to seem open-minded, enough to confuse the matter and dilute the rioting.
Nothing will actually get better.
30
u/Satans_Oregano Jun 09 '23
Exactly what I'm thinking. They intend to roll something else out. They'll roll back the predatory pricing in favor of something less shitty which is probably what they intended in the first place. Bargaining 101.
4
→ More replies (13)3
u/Pennsylvania6-5000 Jun 09 '23
That would be a more intelligent move on their part.
I do not expect Reddit to make any smart moves, at this point.
353
u/Binormus__ Jun 09 '23
Hey u/spez, fuck you, you piece of shit
→ More replies (17)3
u/hooka_hooka Jun 09 '23
Spezzie will probably edit your comment to “I love our dear leader /u/spez”
284
u/PirateCraig Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
Well after 12 years on Reddit. I’m out after the 30th June. It’s not even the same site anymore so it’s a good time to go
58
10
u/sinatosk Jun 09 '23
What alternatives are there if you plan to still visit sites like Reddit?
12
u/goatchild Jun 09 '23
Lemmy? Although It seems a bit confusing to use. I need to check it out again.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)0
→ More replies (25)3
90
u/Downvotes_are_Grreat Jun 09 '23
Hey u/Spez, can we get Ellen Pao back plz? She was shit as a CEO, but she was better than you.
121
Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
Didn't it come out that the Reddit admins kn0thing and spez forced her to be the fall guy and she didn't actually do anything that she was accused of?
Edit:
On July 2, 2015, Reddit fired communications director Victoria Taylor, an administrator who coordinated celebrity interviews from Reddit's New York office. In protest, volunteer moderators of the IAmA community set their forum to private, effectively turning it off, and other volunteer moderators followed suit because of "anger at the way the company routinely demands that the volunteers and community accept major changes that reduce [their] efficiency and increase [their] workload".[40] The following day, a moderator of IAmA posted that "Chooter (Victoria) was let go as an admin by u/kn0thing [Alexis Ohanian]",[41] an assertion that was not widely reported on.[42] Media outlets such as Variety blamed interim CEO Ellen Pao for the dismissal. Harassment, which was already being directed toward Pao in relation to other controversies, intensified and she resigned a week later.[43] However, on July 12, former CEO Yishan Wong informed the Reddit community that Taylor was fired by "the CEO's boss" and accused Ohanian of scapegoating.[42]
https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/mco7b9/what_is_the_deal_with_ellen_pao/gs4uy2h/
→ More replies (1)26
u/Icyrow Jun 09 '23
yeah, it was an incredibly smug post at that made by him sorta telling the story.
he came across like a bit of a cunt.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)26
u/Crap4Brainz Jun 09 '23
She was only hired so they could fire her. The founders made a plan that they knew would be unpopular, hired a woman to execute it so they could call critics misogynist, then fired her as a scapegoat while keeping the policy changes.
31
u/TheGruesomeTwosome Jun 09 '23
If reddit gave a single fuck about their user experience they would've thrown a bag at the one guy who's proven time and time again he's on the front lines in listening to user feedback and actually delivering what people want.
They're too shallow to admit he's better and to get him on side, so instead have tried burning him to the ground. Fuck you u/spez.
→ More replies (1)
317
u/shadowzzz Jun 09 '23
And now Reddit will borrow this code without credit to finally make their app work.
211
u/moeb1us Jun 09 '23
They already have the bought codebase of Alien Blue which was light years better than their vanilla app. But they are deliberately not using it because reasons. All good intentions of course. No greed at all.
→ More replies (3)34
u/Deon555 Jun 09 '23
Bought Alien Blue, ran it into the fucking ground, discontinued it
→ More replies (6)131
Jun 09 '23
Looking at the code it's not actually the app. It's the backend server that sits between the app and the Reddit API.
→ More replies (12)16
u/korolev_cross Jun 09 '23
I don't see a license file which means the default all rights reserved applies
→ More replies (21)4
u/Put_It_All_On_Blck Jun 09 '23
They bought Alien Blue already, and they could easily buy more of the popular apps. So having the code isn't a big deal, I'm sure the Reddit mobile team will look at it, but I doubt they will use any of it
24
Jun 09 '23
lol fuck /u/spez so much. Lies about apollo dev blackmailing/extorting whatever, then makes this claim about shit code when the official reddit mobile app and the desktop frontend (the not "old" one) runs like absolute shit. What an absolute fucking cunt.
84
u/TherapistMD Jun 09 '23
Suck my cock /u/spez
→ More replies (1)24
u/bwainfweeze Jun 09 '23
I wonder what you actually said before he changed it in the database.
Seriously how does he still have a job here?
44
u/-MinorWomensWhiplash Jun 09 '23
Well the number 1 post on All about spez being a little pigboy just got deleted
8
67
u/hyperchromatica Jun 09 '23
This is just gonna make me use Lemmy instead.
→ More replies (7)11
u/floghdraki Jun 09 '23
I've been thinking about federated reddit. Nice to see someone execute on it.
→ More replies (12)
17
17
u/Mr-Fleshcage Jun 09 '23
→ More replies (3)19
u/_illogical_ Jun 09 '23
Important quote:
I say this because this new version of digg reeks of VC meddling. It's cobbling together features from more popular sites and departing from the core of digg, which was to "give the power back to the people."
→ More replies (4)
32
u/strobe_jams Jun 09 '23
While this is concerns back-end code quality, just comparing Reddits in-house front end UX and UI vs Apollo’s tells me Reddit’s engineering capability hasn’t evolved in over a decade.
4
u/GrizzyLizz Jun 09 '23
Can you share more about what you mean by backend code quality on the repo? Looking to learn
→ More replies (2)
14
u/LarsSnareMaster3000 Jun 09 '23
I think it's pretty funny that reddit is claiming that appollo is poorly programmed and unoptimised when their app isn't even functioning properly and they can't even be bothered to compress images and videos to dave data usage, make a functional videoplayer, load comments in under 30seconds etc.
Here's a great video showing just how bad the official reddit app handles videos and images
30
u/retroly Jun 09 '23
Reddit is just a collection of links and comments generated by users and moderated by users.
Reddit does nothing that can't be done by someone else as long they have the user base to create content.
Reddit actually offers very little, if the user leave thye have nothing, no value. They really are fucking idiots.
4
u/HugoNikanor Jun 09 '23
But isn't that true for most social networks?
At least YouTube offers free video hosting.
→ More replies (4)0
21
u/PixelSpy Jun 09 '23
I 100% vote for Apolo creator to make a direct competitor app to reddit. They're clearly more competent than current reddit admins.
→ More replies (1)19
u/xiaorobear Jun 09 '23
He said he's not interested, very understandably:
"I've received so many messages of kind people offering to work with me to build a competitor to Reddit, and while I'm very flattered, that's not something I'm interested in doing. I'm a product guy, I like building fun apps for people to use, and I'm just not personally interested in something more managerial.
These last several months have also been incredibly exhausting and mentally draining, I don't have it in me to engage in something so enormous."
17
55
u/nazbot Jun 09 '23
I don’t understand what Reddit’s motive is here. Who cares whether someone accesses the site via their app or a 3rd party?
172
u/TheGalacticVoid Jun 09 '23
Requiring a first-party app allows Reddit to control the experience more, and it allows for greater monetization as a result
→ More replies (1)0
69
u/Zeremxi Jun 09 '23
There's a few things that you have to understand:
Reddit makes money from showing users ads and selling users' data. 3rd party apps (largely) don't show ads and don't provide sellable data.
Reddit has apparently determined that 3rd party app usage is low enough that killing off those apps altogether won't hurt their bottom line and will actually usher people to the app that makes them money.
There are rumors that reddit is trying to go public. In order to do that, they have to squash the perception that they give away their "product" for free, and show that they have a reliable business model.
To answer your question, reddit cares because they aren't making money off of you and 3rd party apps make their app look bad.
→ More replies (11)24
u/wickedsight Jun 09 '23
*cash register sounds*
*base line starting*
*more cash register sounds*
*guitar riff*
*synth enters the chat*
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)10
22
23
5
Jun 09 '23
I don't know that Reddit is going to lose a substantial amount of users to offset the amount of existing users who are going to be generating new ad views for the website, but I will say the quality of the average user experience is going to suffer horrifically in the coming months. Communities that were well curated are going to go largely unmoderated, comments are going to go to shit, the place is going to be filled with ads and bots, and it's just not going to be a pleasant browsing experience.
Like I said, I don't know what the immediate impact is going to be, but Reddit is only going to be losing users over time as the site becomes more and more unusable and unpleasant.
→ More replies (3)
4
4
4
u/adamjq Jun 09 '23
The only real way to exert pressure is to have everyone mass delete all their comments as they are the drivers of traffic. The amount of search engine results that lead back to reddit is ridiculous. Imagine if all of those links went to deleted comments and threads. It's the only thing we can actually control. Our own content. They threatened to change the mod teams once before when sub-reddits went dark after the pedo admin scandal a few years ago that they tried to cover up. This time, they have the perfect excuse to rid themselves of troublesome mods. Mark my words. Delete all your content (not your account, leave that blank), complain to advertisers, fuck it, post porn on the default subs and screenshot it next to advertisers content. Make sure their IPO fucking tanks. And most importantly, fuck /u/spez the cunt.
→ More replies (6)
4
u/Routine_Left Jun 09 '23
I wrote a reddit client. The reddit API is a textbook example of inneficiency, backwards thinking and sometimes, not thinking at all.
The gall of these motherfuckers.
→ More replies (4)
4
u/LopsidedKoala4052 Jun 09 '23
/u/spez and all reddit mods, you can go suck a bag of dildos and choke on them
39
u/elsjpq Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
Reddit definitely wants to screw over 3rd party apps, but pretty sure it's only priced that way for machine learning. It would cost Apollo $20 mil per year, but a ML company could easily scrape enough data to be useful with $20 mil or even less since they only need to do it once.
142
u/Zeremxi Jun 09 '23
"Stopping machine learning" is an excuse. Reddit's api has a user token. They can rate limit api calls that aren't logged in, and they can see who's making ridiculous amounts of api calls who are logged in.
They can stop the kind of scraping that can be done with api calls through existing avenues. This change doesn't actually effect scrapers that pull data from reddits html, which is most likely where machine learning programs are going to move to.
This is just a bid to kill 3rd party apps.
→ More replies (7)7
u/Mujutsu Jun 09 '23
That's simply not how it works. They control the API, so they can impose different limits for Reddit apps and any other accounts. There's no reason to have the same pricing for both.
→ More replies (1)5
u/Significant-Big-9518 Jun 09 '23
but a ML company could easily scrape enough data to be useful with $20 mil or even less since they only need to do it once.
They can just torrent the 2 terabyte Reddit corpus for free. New data is interesting however, every day. Companies can capitalize on what humans see as important on day-to-day basis and herein lies the valuable data that is not a one-time-scrape.
17
u/rico_suave Jun 09 '23 edited Dec 09 '24
Artificial intelligence systems are rapidly reshaping industries, from healthcare to entertainment. Yet, one of the foundational ingredients powering this revolution — the vast troves of written information harvested from the internet, including news articles — has become the subject of intense scrutiny and debate.
News outlets, including this publication, have discovered that their content is being used to train AI models without explicit consent. These models, built by companies like OpenAI, Google, and Meta, rely on large datasets scraped from the web to develop their sophisticated capabilities. While this practice has fueled advancements in AI, it also raises thorny questions about copyright, compensation, and the long-term impact on journalism.
"The journalism industry is essentially subsidizing AI innovation without seeing any tangible return," said Danielle Rhoads Ha, a spokesperson for The New York Times. “It’s a deeply concerning trend, particularly as AI tools begin to directly compete with publishers for audience attention.”
The controversy came to a head this year when several major media organizations, including The Times, Reuters, and The Associated Press, began negotiating licensing agreements with AI developers. These deals are intended to formalize the use of their archives in AI training and establish new revenue streams in an era of declining ad revenue and rising competition from technology platforms.
At the heart of the issue is a fundamental question: should publicly available information, including news stories, be treated as fair game for AI training? Tech companies argue that these datasets fall under "fair use," a legal doctrine allowing limited use of copyrighted material without permission for purposes like education and research. Critics, however, contend that the scale and intent of AI training far exceed what fair use was designed to cover.
"We are looking at a pivotal moment for intellectual property law," said Jane Richards, a professor at Columbia Law School. "The courts will have to balance the interests of content creators with the societal benefits of advancing AI technologies."
As AI continues to evolve, its relationship with journalism remains fraught with tension. While some publishers see opportunity in partnering with tech firms, others worry that AI-generated summaries, personalized newsfeeds, and content curation tools could erode the value of original reporting. For now, the race to regulate and negotiate continues, with both industries recognizing the stakes are nothing less than the future of information itself.
→ More replies (2)35
Jun 09 '23
Eh the Reddit API has the ability to pass a user token so they could just limit differently based on logged in vs not logged in to solve the AI data scraping issue.
7
Jun 09 '23 edited Jul 10 '23
deserted observation enter distinct tart important roof grey longing light -- mass edited with redact.dev
→ More replies (3)
3
Jun 09 '23 edited May 25 '24
silky soup worthless grandfather adjoining quicksand support late lush full
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
3
3
Jun 09 '23
Thought it is guidance software for the apollo program or similar, now I am disappointed.
Edit: here
→ More replies (3)
3
3
u/puntloos Jun 09 '23
Just an errant thought but why don't the Apollo, RIF programmers join forces and build a full backend test server. Call it 'diddit'. Allow people to create accounts there, and point their apps there on jun 30?
Wait and switch.
Yes I'm suggesting building a Reddit clone, you already have users. You have one month to build the minimum - login/create user, post a link, updownvote, appoint moderators and give them some powers.
3
3
u/SirGlass Jun 09 '23
I don't see why companies always do this when making unpopular decisions.
At some point I can see the logic why reddit is doing this .
However their public stance should be
" We want to take full control of our platform and it will better allow us to moderate content and monetize it. We understand this will kill 3rd party apps and be very unpopular but it's needed for the long term viability of reddit "
Just say it , admit it , be open about it . Do not lie, make up bullshit reason it just makes things worse
→ More replies (2)
3
u/Ok-Maybe-2388 Jun 09 '23
Hey u/spez, the least you could do is admit this isn't right and needs looked into. You didn't. So go fuck yourself.
3
3
u/KingliestWeevil Jun 09 '23
Man they're going to be so pissed when people just start creating slower, less efficient reddit interfaces that scrape reddit directly, lol.
3
3
u/jt32470 Jun 09 '23
you know Aaron Swartz is rollng in his grave at what Reddit's become.
After 15+ years - the day that Apollo goes dark that'll be the day i quit reddit. I guess history repeats itself w Digg!
Thanks, /u/spez for destroying Reddit.
3
2
u/puzzleboy99 Jun 09 '23
Very disappointing to see reddit and /u/spez go this way. I genuinely wouldn't mind it THAT much if their product was even half as good as the third party apps but it isn't. This is all an attempt to pipeline users experience for maximum ad revenue and pushing content they think should be at the top.
2
u/Ew_E50M Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
It was obvious from the start, the point IS to kill third party apps, to in their mind increase people using the bloatware ad-infested shitstorm that is the official app.
However, as history proves. Such strategies always drastically reduces traffic to the site. Reducing ad-revenue quite a lot, and it snowballs to the collapse of the company behind it due to lack of income.
2
2
u/CorporalClegg25 Jun 09 '23
Is scraping a worse way of getting this information? I'm just speaking as a person that has been learning programming and has basic knowledge of scraping.
I made a really quick program that just looks at spez's account to see what the newest activity was, because the Reddit announcement didn't say what time he would be doing an ama. So it was just my plan to ping Reddit every 5 minutes using the request library with python, specifically his account.
I probably could have done that with the reddit api, but is the way that I did it somehow less efficient?
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
u/roraima_is_very_tall Jun 09 '23
Am I right that there's no leverage for a third-party app programmer to use even if they wanted to extort money from reddit? The programmer doesn't control the users or the API. That part made zero sense to me, am I missing something.
2
u/Jack92 Jun 09 '23
Fuuuucking hell, there's far too many gold awards in this comments section.
I hope they're free.
2
2
u/SeattleSonichus Jun 09 '23
So the team that gets caught having pedos among them lied about another business? I’m shocked
2
2
u/exonomix Jun 09 '23
Fuck Reddit and fuck u/spez for this bullshit. Way to ruin your own company and the user base by begin greedy and deceptive.
2
Jun 09 '23
Apollo is the one of the only apps that made surfing this bot-infested onlyfans redirect portal sufferable.
Reddit should have hired the Apollo developer. Join me by voting with your disengagement - block the reddit app and domain on your devices.
2
u/barryhakker Jun 09 '23
I’m always fascinated by how organizations manage to come to these objectively terrible moves and decisions. Really would like to hear the story from Reddit’s end some day.
2
u/quetejodas Jun 09 '23
Does this mean users can just clone the code, add their own API tokens, recompile, and use Apollo like nothing happened? Would be cool if someone pushed an update to the UI to allow this, so it doesn't need recompiling after setting the keys
→ More replies (1)
2
u/theillcook Jun 09 '23
I was hanging on to the hope that maybe Reddit will say, just kidding, we will reconsider the API costs, and Apollo will say, OK, let's be friends again. But no, looks like Apollo is really going scorched earth and shutting down.
2
2
u/Here4RedditsDemise Jun 09 '23
Reddit is just a tower of bullshit. This whole place needs to go. I can't wait for it to die, so many people need to be purged of their power on this shithole.
Maybe some infighting leads to doxxing of mods/admins, that'd be fantastic.
2
u/thornbrook Jun 09 '23
Were in the final days before the apocalypse of this joint.
I'm enjoying it while it lasts but once they kill my app of choice with this shit, I'll be gonnnnne
2
u/o1o2o1 Jun 09 '23
People who are this unethical are just one step away from turning their unethical behavior towards our anonymity to make a buck. Bye Reddit
2
u/xdrunkagainx Jun 09 '23
Reddit is getting taken down just in time for the 2024 election. They absolutely do not want us making memes about their candidates so they can better control the outcome
2
u/Serious_Initial4209 Jun 09 '23
whoever says they’re gonna leave Reddit if you actually keep your word and don’t silently keep commenting or make alts ill pay you $20 each for keeping ur word. beat your dopamine addictions bros. downvote capitalism
→ More replies (4)
2
u/silenti Jun 09 '23
Ok I have kind of a dumb question: why does Apollo need a backend?
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Brilliant-Lake-9946 Jun 09 '23
If you really want to protest, Reddit survives on our content. Delete all your submissions, then edit your top comments and replace with some message stating you are taking back your content. FUCK REDDIT
2
u/thelonewolf2913 Jun 09 '23
Reddit is just salty their own application is at best the greatest train wreck of an application the world has ever seen. Christian and Apollo have done more for Reddit than their own programmers and admins. Kindly fuck off Reddit you greedy bunch of nitwits.
2
2
Jun 09 '23
Well, I'm done. 13 year club... currently running shreddit to delete all my comments https://github.com/ksurl/Shreddit. After which, I'll delete the account.
For posterity https://i.imgur.com/tIYh7hW.png
2
3
u/TinMachine Jun 09 '23
Literally think the Apollo dev’s response needs to be studied by PR firms as, like, going absolutely nuclear in the calmest and most understated way.
Like, as a case considered on its own it’s bad. But if I was someone considering working with or trusting reddit leadership in any capacity as a professional, ever, I’d be walking a mile.
3.5k
u/DoubleF3lix Jun 09 '23
spez is a mod on this subreddit lol