r/programmer • • Sep 06 '26

Question Is AI gonna replace programmers?

Hi. I'm Dylan.

I'm currently a junior dev. Ive spent 2 years learning abt programming, writing code and interested on bulding systems.

Ive got to admit that im very scared of all this AI thing and how it's progressing.

Ive seen it make horrible videos back in 2022. Now sometimes i can't even tell if a video is AI or if it isn't.

Yeah, code written by ai isn't the best. But, with the passing of time, it gets even better and better.

Yeah, we as programmers CURRENTLY do analysis, requerimients and all that ai can't currently replace us.

But what are we gonna when ai becomes able to do all that? For me, it seems like a very possible escenario. You can even see the difference of what AI can do if you compare the current models to the models we had 6 months ago. I think it's becoming unstoppable and i really fear it takes our (or my) job away.

Yes, I'm very frustrated. All this time dedicated to it... Makes me sad. This is more like venting I guess, but I seriously need to know, from y'all, how y'all see this. I need to know if it's time to let go of this passion I had with this career, and start on something else where Claude Code can't reach me and replace me.

0 Upvotes

89 comments sorted by

19

u/BeauloTSM C# Sep 06 '26

The chances of it happening are slim. The chances of companies trying are higher

2

u/AdRecent7021 Sep 06 '26

This. LLMs with task agents have gotten pretty good, but they're unpredictable and have no actual intuition-based reasoning. They mimic intellect, but do not possess one. Outside of basic scaffolding and tech demos, they fall apart quickly. There are certain tasks they're very good at... or at least helpful, but tech companies are trying to shove them into everything, which isn't going to work out. In the end, lots of people will lose money and jobs, and some will make unimaginable fortunes. Don't stress over it too much, this cycle has been going on since the begging of human kind.

2

u/nicolas_06 Sep 07 '26

I can tell you that if well steered by a senior dev, they are incredibly capable.

2

u/AdRecent7021 Sep 07 '26

I used to setup inference pipelines for some of the frontier models you've never even heard of (got really bored though). I am not convinced yet.

1

u/nicolas_06 Sep 07 '26

That job description can match many stuff. To me it look like an operator job but it could be also a research job. Maybe doing this is very similar to maintaining and adding features to a big codebase, the most common stuff in software dev but to me it's unclear said like that.

All in all I manage it just fine personally, so I know it possible. it's pretty recent (1-2 year max and it much better now) and it tend to work well only for people with lot of XP and maybe honestly 10-20% of developers, other tend to be unproductive with AI.

2

u/AdRecent7021 Sep 07 '26

lol, okay. You do you.

10

u/Rich-Engineer2670 Sep 06 '26

No -- because programming isn't about the code....

Programming is understanding how to break down a task into somethign the computer can execute, regarldes of language or framework. Sure, AI may give us new tools, but you still have to know what to ask for.

1

u/Away_Advisor3460 Sep 06 '26

Programming is understanding how to break down a task into somethign the computer can execute

I have to note that there is a specific field of AI (i.e. automated planning and scheduling) dedicated into doing just that, in a deterministic way, of course. It's been difficult to apply in a programming paradigm because the domain is so complex and ergo hard to specify.

They have, as I understand it, also been training the LLM type AI with reward functions that, well, reward it for taking an interative approach. So there is a motion to try and replace humans in the middle part of the loop, and abstract the task specification further and further away from the technical detail - part of that abstract seeming to be from using agents to abstract tasks a bit like in an HTN graph.

I don't know whether it'll replace us or not. But the intent is definitely there.

1

u/mossiv Sep 06 '26

I whole heartedly agree. We are using it extensively in work. A lot of us haven’t even hand written a line ourselves in about 4 months. But there’s a few that vibe prompt and haven’t got a grasp at all on how much Claude is over reaching, over engineering, slopping, you name it. These are devs that were “ok” but under a proper agile framework delivered. Now that everything is faster paced and there’s no product owner holding their hands (we still have product, but they are busy solving other problems) they are failing to adapt in this newer world. Others are now shining that they have to work more autonomously but not be disruptive.

It’s going to change our space for sure. And maybe “programmers” will disappear but I think “SWE” or whatever new variation of roles that get created will be in quite high demand.

There’s a couple of chaps I work with who are on AI prototypes and they can deal with 6 or 7 worktree sessions. These guys are going to fly.

1

u/Rich-Engineer2670 Sep 07 '26

Strangely enough, I see Willie Wonka's Umpa Lumpas' dancing around as the AI agents. No one ever asks how they do what they do, or what comes out of the chocolate vat.

I suspect we will see code do more of the work -- but that's what compilers are doing right now right? I CAN write assembly code, I USED to write a lot of hardware assembly code, but then, this thing called C took over. Is that any different?

1

u/davidbasil Sep 07 '26

why do you think AI can't do that?

1

u/Rich-Engineer2670 Sep 07 '26 edited Sep 07 '26

Let me explain it with a real world example I did -- and I can tell you AI can't do this.... because software engineering isn't about code, anymore than Starbucks is about cofee. They just sell it.

Your assignment:

A hospital wants to imprve surgical outcomes which use anesthesia. They also want ot reduce labor costs.

That's it, that's all you get. Now, forget AI, write your solution on paper. AI can't help you becuase:

  • Does the AI understand neurology, puminology, cardiology, a collection of nasty drugs, and how we do it in surgery?

  • Does the AI understand why computers and neuroology can have a strained relatioship? Do you understand the physics

You need to. It won't work without it.

Or the DEA... they want a way to scan substances they find within in hour to figure ouf what those substances were? How do youi do it because that's all the DEA is giving you.

I had to understand what was being done, not the code. Once we had the structure, someone else code write it if they had to.

If your job is following step-by-step processes that can be written down, AI won't replace your job -- it already has. You just don't know it yet. The problem isn't the computers, or the software -- it's the meat bags who don't know what they want, what they're willing to comp[romise on, they want it immediately, and for free. I don't think AI can solve that.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/nicolas_06 Sep 07 '26

The industry average is that a software engineer spend about 30% of his time coding (before AI). Even if coding become instantaneous, you only gained 30%.

1

u/Kwabi Sep 07 '26

Even then, you only convert the time you code into time you write markdown files and prompts and do code review for the output.

I don't know how other devs actually increase their output with AI; by the time I explained in detail what I want with which structure, I'd be faster if I just wrote it myself.

Not to mention that reading and properly understanding code takes longer than writing it.

1

u/nicolas_06 Sep 07 '26

The catch is that you had to write specs anyway. Not necessarily the same person but at company level it was here.

Also from experience, Maybe I'll research what I need to do, understand it and all. This is long. Then I write it down and maybe it's like a few hours, like say half a day. Then the AI generate 1-2 week of coding in half an hour or less. Then I spend another half a day to 1 day fix what the AI did. So it's still significantly faster.

What I understand is that right now while I managed to it on most use case, be it new apps, prototype or legacy code with millions line of code, my understanding is that maybe 10-20% of developers manage it.

For the moment the majority do not manage it. So maybe you gain say 20% on 20% of the devs and that's basically a 4% gain.

Maybe over time we manage to get a 30-50% gain on 50% of dev. That would still be only a 15-25% gain and it will take a few years.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Rich-Engineer2670 Sep 06 '26

Well, the scary part is now I'm actually hearing people talk about "managing your agentic workforce". Are we giving AI workers rights now? We don't even give that to people.

1

u/ThatRedDerg Sep 06 '26

Yes and no. It’s one of those situations where it lowers the bar of entry to create a basic app, but the skill set required to maintain an enterprise-level codebase is practically unchanged.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ThatRedDerg Sep 06 '26

I agree in theory, but you have to remember very few improvements are being made to the underlying technology. All the ‘improvements’ we’ve been seeing are largely due to throwing more compute/training data at it, and/or tweaking base prompts to make better use of any extra compute.

But the amount of compute required to see any improvement is exponentially scaling, so we’re seeing increasingly decreasing returns.

And that’s ignoring that even the current amount of compute required isn’t economically sustainable.

If they end up making concrete improvements to the technology to make it significantly more efficient, or create something more efficient to replace the generative pre-transformer, then I’ll take back what I’ve said. It’s just that the current trajectory of things isn’t signalling anything to me about complete replacement.

1

u/nicolas_06 Sep 07 '26

For the moment, that's the reverse, the bar to entry tend to be higher because it's mostly senior dev that manage to steer AI well. The juniors that were doing pure coding under the supervision of a senior tend to lose their job. But the AI can't do a senior job, at least for now.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/nicolas_06 Sep 07 '26

They need to be technical if you want the application to actual work. And even if they are not technical, they need to be able to move between high level requirements and small details and be able to write great specifications.

Such skills are surprisedly uncommon.

5

u/Own_Nail_2999 Sep 06 '26

AI is nothing more than yet another tech bro product. And they are insufferably vocal about it. You'll be fine once companies start getting it.

3

u/a_prieto12359 Sep 06 '26

The reality is that the sector is in decline and in freefall. It would be a lie to say that things will get better or much worse, although nobody can know for sure.

I want to be optimistic and think that we'll fall a little further, but then we'll have a small rebound to position ourselves as a profession where you're either extremely good or you earn very little (I think that's a slightly more realistic scenario).

If you can study medicine or electrical engineering, do it.

2

u/USToffee Sep 06 '26

They will be replaced too. One doctor will still be needed to sign off on the work of AI but that’s about it

1

u/Kwabi Sep 06 '26

Yes in the sense that companies will use AI as a reason to increase workloads on existing programmers, thus reducing the number of overall jobs.

No in the sense that the profession will remain in some shape or form.

I worry about juniors, though. It was already difficult to get companies to invest in the next generation instead of just leeching on existing expertise. The opportunities for young people will become even rarer, which means that we won't get lots of seniors to properly utilize or create new technology anymore.

That's probably an unfortunate reality for most if not all branches of work, not just programming. Nobody wants to pay you and AI promises to replace every job in the future.

Sorry your life got screwed by automation and unchecked capitalism.

1

u/NotTheJason Sep 06 '26

Is ai going to replace some programmers? Yes. Will it replace all programmers? About the same time it replaces everyone else.

1

u/peanutbutterdrummer Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

Is AI gonna replace programmers?

Short-term answer is no, long-term answer is yes.

The role of "programmer" is changing and hand-coding is most likely becoming obsolete (although people will still do it for fun or in niche roles).

This in turn may lower the barrler of entry for what a "programmer" is - however the job will still require a holistic knowledge of logical thinking for systems architecture and planning.

With more coding potentially being done by less people, companies will either keep their existing workforce capacity and scale up production, or cut back and maintain the production they already have.

Sooner or later though, demand for programmers to build new apps and systems may lessen as models become increasingly adept at generating the software users need on-the-fly at the push of a button.

That's pretty much the endgame I think.

1

u/Charming_You_25 Sep 06 '26

You gotta move up the elevator. I’ve been programming for 14 years and this year stopped looking at code. The volume is even too high to read full PRs (though choice areas are good). But you still need to understand your codebase and best practices, and knowing the language can help you describe what you want and understand what’s going on once long running tasks start talking machine. Coding by hand is kinda like knitting; you can make a choice piece but it takes too long if you’re trying to build a blue Jean factory.

You can request flowcharts of different areas of your codebase so you can direct it better. I definitely wouldn’t safe programming is useless or will become useless.. but it’s changing quickly.

2

u/Away_Advisor3460 Sep 06 '26

I'm sort of a luddite with this stuff because I feel threatened by it, I guess (and also because I put 5 years into studying a different kind of AI and sort of resent how it's been pushed to the wayside). But it seems inevitable that AI will at least have a similar sort of impact as languages and compilers - i.e. just like the latter pushed devs away from working in assembly, LLM code generation will further abstract responsibility into the design space.

1

u/Charming_You_25 Sep 06 '26

Right, you should try building some side projects in the different kind of AI. Domain knowledge is huge and things come together fast.

1

u/MarkoKrulc Sep 06 '26

Nope. Programmers became supercharged developers with AI. Nothing is impossible, everything is doable.

1

u/MannToots Sep 06 '26

Until the ai can read my mind for my intent I doubt it

1

u/effectivescarequotes Sep 06 '26

No. My guess is it's just going to raise the level of abstraction at which we work. You're not going to make your sales team stop and prompt Ai when they need a tool. That would distract from the time they have to sell things. You can pretty much play that game with every aspect of a business.

The other piece of it is writing code was never the bottleneck. It's all the stuff surounding it. Ai can help with some of those tasks, but not all of them. And at least on my team, AI is letting us tackle some of the less exciting tech debt problems that have been kicked down the road for years. So there's a chance that because it allows dev teams to be more productive, businesses will ask us to do more.

1

u/USToffee Sep 06 '26

Yeah, we as programmers CURRENTLY do analysis, requerimients and all that ai can't currently replace us.

Unfortunately it can. What there is currently is a trust issue and it’s still justified.

And there probably always will be but the days of code monkeys is over

1

u/izahariev96 Sep 06 '26

no, but it shifts the type of work programmers do

1

u/Independent_Pitch598 Sep 06 '26

Very probably yes, better to move to arch or tech lead

1

u/SplendidPunkinButter Sep 06 '26

Short answer: Absolutely not

Long answer: No, but plenty of companies will be happy shipping shitty vibe coded McSoftware anyway. It will suck, but as long as it sells the business idiots won’t care.

1

u/hulkish Sep 06 '26

Already is replacing programmers

1

u/TheUmgawa Sep 06 '26

Well, the world is gonna need a hundred percent fewer “coders.” Programmers are a different story, but if an AI can churn out the same code as a junior developer and ask a hundred percent fewer stupid questions per day, then it makes good sense to spend money on tokens instead of humans. But, for that to happen, the programmers need a good sense of logic and structure, and they have to be able to read (or at least test) the output.

And then it becomes a matter of hiring programmers who will minimize token usage while maximizing quality output. It’s just a numbers game, but everything in business is a numbers game. Part of my job is automating manufacturing. If it’s cheaper to automate a task over the expected lifetime of the automation tool, I automate the task. Otherwise, a human continues to do the job until the next time I evaluate it. Humans have this annoying tendency to ask for more money every year, so if the price of automation goes down or remains flat, eventually those lines will cross and it gets automated. So, why would programming, or any other industry, be any different?

1

u/the_millenial_falcon Sep 06 '26

If it gets good enough to fully replace software engineers then it won’t be long before it’s good to enough to replace most if not all knowledge workers.

1

u/2MysteriouslyBizarre Sep 06 '26

You guys keep asking this, its been answered thousands of times already, no, it wont replace all programmers, yes, we will have less programmers than we have now, yes, most industries will have the same issue not just tech, no, there wont be enough jobs created to absorb them all, try your best to be the best at what you do, keep a close eye on your community since we will have some pretty bad times ahead, if you’re not confident enough in your technical abilities become a teacher, Ai legally can’t replace those, if you want to get into a more resilient area in tech get into data center/critical infrastructure networking or Ml research

1

u/Mr_Willkins Sep 06 '26

Jevon's paradox says otherwise

1

u/2MysteriouslyBizarre Sep 06 '26

Sorry Im not familiar, could you elaborate?

1

u/Mr_Willkins Sep 06 '26

1

u/2MysteriouslyBizarre Sep 06 '26

Oh okay, I see, but even so, say you now develop 100 times as much software, but an engineer can be 200x as productiveas before, you still end up with half the devs

1

u/Anonymity6584 Sep 06 '26

You still need someone to preview and overlook what ai spits out, they do have random tendency to hallusinate stuff up.

God forbid you ever have to fix some vibecoded project after its viber has changed jobs already...

1

u/ThatRedDerg Sep 06 '26

Not anytime soon, but companies are desperately trying.

While, in theory, LLMs are capable of creating applications, there are major caveats. It is only really possible with applications that are common in its training data (ie websites), and they often end up poorly unoptimized and poorly designed.

This is just cause an ‘autonomous agent’ really boils down to a loop that goes like “while project != prompt, generate more stuff.”

Furthermore, not much has been done to develop the technology other than throwing more compute/guardrails/robust base prompts, so these caveats aren’t likely going anywhere soon.

I personally think this whole thing is just an attempt to de-skill most workers. Be sure to keep up with things, keep being competent without needing an LLM, and I’m sure you’ll never be unemployable.

1

u/Original_Speed6200 Sep 06 '26

I’m in the middle of a massive project I’m working on using AI. There’s just no way for it to understand the preferences of a human. It keeps making the wrong decisions over and over again. And as the requirements get more complicated it breaks down and starts making mistakes. Yes it can generate a lot of code but that has just moved the goalpost on number of lines of code moved per day, not a grand awareness (yet). Even if it did have awareness the humans still have their own preferences.

1

u/Snackatttack Sep 06 '26

yes, its replacing as we speak. code written by AI is often really good if not better than human code. can be bloated, but overall its pretty good.

1

u/Rav_3d Sep 06 '26

Yes, AI will write practically all code. No, it won't replace software engineers.

1

u/normantas Sep 06 '26

Curent tech no. I would even disagree coding is solved. You got now have an automated draft generator and boilerplate copy pasting + better lookup.

1

u/Silver-Ad-8595 Sep 06 '26

Just the lazy ones

1

u/common_king Sep 06 '26

It’s going to displace programmers

1

u/Mizetings Sep 06 '26

All programmers no. It’s very good at programming because the rules are rigid. Entry level and low-mid level roles are already disappearing.

It’ll never replace all programmers. At least not for a while. It’s more akin to an evolution in programming. Like going from Assembly to compilers. You still need programmers to design the inputs and polish the code.

1

u/oddlyamused Sep 06 '26

We are the best at using the ai

1

u/yuehuang Sep 06 '26

Yes. AI will replace programmers and coders. They won't replace software engineers. Focus on the engineer part instead of the coding part.

1

u/Rriazu Sep 06 '26

learn engineering and problem solving over programming - programming is a means to an end.

1

u/Common_Ad_6362 Sep 07 '26

Companies will replace old developers who can't use LLMs with new developers who can. Sound engineering and product design principles and solid reasoning skills will trump knowledge of a specific language. This is already happening, a lot of people who are posting to Reddit about it are -way behind-. The best devs I know are now making high six figure salaries managing about a dozen LLMs at a time in proprietary harnesses. LLMs are genies. How you wish is very important. They never get tired. They still need you to be the architect.

1

u/uceenk Sep 07 '26

better treat programmer as side skill, so if main skill need software or website you can just create it with Agentic AI

the future of programming is not good tbh, companies reduce team left and right (an app that usually created / mantainer by 6 people now can only be done with 2 people)

1

u/nicolas_06 Sep 07 '26 edited Sep 07 '26

20 years of professional XP here. Title go by lead principal software engineer.

Even if nobody code anymore, it isn't like all the work to make and maintain software and automation in general would disappear.

I think you knowing how to program and how to do great software and understanding how computers work is still extremely valuable. You also understanding and steering AI has lot of value too.

If you are passionate about the job, have the intuition about it and can be among the top 10-20% best in the field, I think you'll do just fine. If you don't want to use AI or if you are only average or worse and the task is boring or complex to you, I think you should review your priorities. And I mean if that's how it is, it is how it is. No shame.

You can also start like that and try to move to an adjacent job. Team leader, project manager, tester... Cyber security. There many field around that might not be impacted as harshly or that would let you move later to another domain.

1

u/mfi12 Sep 07 '26

If all you do is "coding", then yes, you have high chance being replaced.

1

u/Flashy-Whereas-3234 Sep 07 '26

AI can replace programmers, it's unlikely to replace engineers.

Consider this in the world of construction; if robots come in and can lay bricks and pour concrete and put up drywall, what do the humans do? The humans get promoted to foreman, they oversee, guide, rectify, problem solved, hell they can design and architect.

This is where you should learn fundamentals, architecture and system design, but learning language syntax and tool chains can take more of a backseat. You will still be exceptional if you specialise in a particular language, but it is less necessary for you to dedicate significant chunks of your education towards it.

Even if AI starts to eat system design (and it can), a CTO isn't going to manage a cabal of agents and be on call for incidents. A successful company has room for headcount and delegation, so some engineering jobs will still exist, even if they have a heavier dedication to product instead of code.

And, there's always a hold-outs, who don't like AI, trust AI, or can afford AI.

1

u/Danknoodle420 Sep 07 '26

Now, no. Later, probably.

1

u/raven2cz Sep 07 '26

Hi Dylan. you do not need to be afraid at all. Quite the opposite, you will have much more work, and it will be more demanding.

You are forgetting one essential fact: we will start creating far more complex systems with AI, services, and completely new customer requirements. today’s applications, as they exist now, will no longer be needed.

Take Astra, for example. The demo shows how it can use current applications. In a few years, we will all laugh at that and wonder what kind of nonsense it was, because when you think about it, it is completly stupid. Why would you need a UI there, and why would you switch between applications at all? do you see what I mean? And now imagine this on a massive scale for large companies and services.

Have you seen any sci-fi movie? That is basically where we need to get. Did you see in those movies that IT engineers were not needed? as a developer, you will always make a good living, because we have always had to learn something new every year, whether languages, systems, and now AI.

1

u/reddituserrr20 Sep 15 '26

What about a fresher? I am unable to study because of these all negativity what we should do? Change our carrier paths? So which carrier is ai proof? We should do Masters (m tech) feels unreasonable

And ai is evolving from my first year of btech to this date that no one wants to hire a fresher .

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

Yes. All you now need is a couple architects who know the subject and Claude.

0

u/PipePressurePanic Sep 06 '26

it doesn't even need to do analysis. It's enough that it can do the code monkey part of development and 80% of developers lose their jobs .

0

u/Taght Sep 06 '26

It will replace everyone in the end, but we're not there yet. We still have couple years ahead.

1

u/falconetpt Sep 06 '26

With LLM you surely won’t do anything material 😂

Or you will have basically software engineers earning 10M dollars a year, this comes from someone who programs in assembly and C mainly but I contributed a great load to things like Java SDKs and such things, my salary is skyrocketing more and more especially now, the skillset for specific tasks are the same and less and less people know how to do it, and there is barely any good training data for those

Maybe it will replace what we call code monkeys or noodle programmers, which were never needed in the first place, companies just went to look for cheap labour and ended up with loads of people that can’t do shit, the best example is WhatsApp’s tech team, a highly effective team vs a company like google, which is full of bloat and people doing jack shit ahah

0

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[deleted]

1

u/davidbasil Sep 07 '26

Then explain how previous automations and high level languages (python, html) employed more devs than before

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Hooper022 Sep 07 '26

Best answer. Everyone likes to pretend they know what's going to happen. My best advice as a senior dev is the be adaptable, make connections, and hope for the best. Change is scary but it can open doors just as much as it can shut them.