“Sex is for procreation” the bitter forced birther screamed. I’m sure we’ve all seen this and rolled our eyes. This idea that sex is naturally for reproduction only and thus a woman must carry a fetus to term because she decided to have sex. This is obviously stupid, but after having two very annoying conversations about this I wanted to figure out why this is incorrect. Read these conversations if you want to blow your brains out lol
Side note, does anyone else feel like people who say “The natural purpose of sex is reproduction” are just terrible in bed. Like if somebody told me “the natural purpose of food is nutrients” I know the meal they’re about to cook me is going to be bland, boring, uncreative, and I’m not going to enjoy it.
First, there is no singular purpose to a complex act. To say that there is ignores the incredible complexity of life. Many things happen when two people have consensual sex. The most common one (if they're doing it right) is pleasure. In the cases we're talking about, this is both the goal and the expected outcome. An unintended and unlikely possible result (assuming proper protection) is pregnancy. There is no basis for saying it is somehow automatically more legitimate a result of protected, consensual sex, especially when the sex is specifically performed in a method designed to make pregnancy not happen.
Let’s address this natural purpose idea. I’ve never seen any evidence that procreation is the “natural” or “biological” purpose of sex. I’m not ever sure where this idea of natural comes from. Nature isn’t some person or entity that decides things for humans. I would say the most natural thing of all is human beings' intelligence and ability to change the world around us to fit our needs. While there is no evidence that sex is naturally for procreation, there is quite a bit of evidence to the contrary.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I think this is going to get kind of long so I apologize.
Point 1: People who cannot get pregnant still feel sexually aroused and still engage in sex. This includes infertile men and women, women who have gone through menopause, women who have not menstruated yet, and pregnant women. If sex was biologically for the sole function of reproduction, none of those groups would become sexually aroused or have sex. Especially pregnant women.
Point 2: Homosexuality is found naturally in human beings. There is no way for a same-sex couple to reproduce through sex, and yet they still have sex and experience arousal. This wouldn’t make sense if sex was solely for reproduction. How can the sole purpose of sex be for reproduction if homosexuality occurs naturally in humans?
Point 3: The different ways we have sex. There is no reproductive benefit to anal and oral sex, and yet humans are naturally inclined to carry out those actions. Making out, holding hands, kissing, grinding on each other, manual stimulation- some of these are found in the animal kingdom and some aren’t. But kissing during sex certainly doesn’t increase the chances of reproduction. Even the things we are aroused by during sex don’t increase reproduction chances- having your hair pulled, being spanked, dirty talk, having your nipples licked and played with, having sex in missionary vs the more common positions found in nature. We don’t naturally seek these things out because the increase our chances of reproduction, we seek these things out because they are enjoyable. What about having sex and stopping before the man reaches completion. This happens with humans, but it shouldn't happen based on the "function of sex is reproduction" theory. Starting sex and ending before the man ejaculates doesn't make any sense from a reproductive standpoint. The male penis should enter the vagina, swell and become locked inside until ejaculation.
Point 4: Estrous. Let’s look at how cats reproduce compared to how humans reproduce. Cats, like most animals, go through estrous or heat. Estrous the main reproductive cycle of other species females. When the female is ready for reproduction they give off pheromones and physical signs, so the male knows they are ready for reproduction. Human women do not go through heat. If reproduction was the sole biological purpose of sex in humans, why don’t humans go through heat? Why don’t human men KNOW a woman is able to procreate at this time. Seems kind of weird that purpose of sex is procreation and yet men are just guessing at when women can actually get pregnant. Animals will also typically have a breeding season because this is when they can get pregnant. Something else conspicuously missing from human beings.
Point 5: Let’s talk about ovulation. Cats, like many animals, are induced ovulators. Which means that the act of breeding stimulates the release of eggs from the ovaries. Cats literally need to engage in the physical act of coitus to release eggs. They need to have sex to even be capable of pregnancy. If the cat doesn’t mate, no eggs will be released. Ovulation is very different for human women. A woman is born with a set number of eggs and those eggs are released every month, no matter if she had sex or not. What a waste of eggs. Ovulation is a very short window and a man can’t tell when a woman ovulates, a woman can’t even tell when she ovulates (unless she tracks her cycle.) If sex is for the sole biological purpose of reproduction, why is human sex done mostly outside of the fertile window? Women should feel no arousal outside of her ovulation period and a man should not feel arousal nor have sex with a woman outside of her ovulation period. The fact that ovulation in humans has no relation to sex shows that reproduction is not the main function of sex. Ovulation is such a tiny window that most intercourse humans have takes place OUTSIDE of the fertilization window. If the natural purpose of sex was reproduction, than it would not make sense to have sex when the female was infertile. It would instead make sense to have sex only when the female was fertile. And in most mammals, that is the case — sex occurs almost exclusively when the female is in estrus or heat. Why would human evolution discard the arrangement of mating only when the female was most likely to be fertile, if the primary natural purpose of human sex was reproduction?
Point 6: Sex is incredibly inefficient. If human sex were to exist solely for reproduction than it would be the most inefficient method of reproduction there is. Women are only ovulating between 7%-15% of their lives, and most of the time sex does not end in a pregnancy. Even if conception/fertilization happens, most of those end in miscarriage. Plus, humans can only have one egg (not including twins) fertilized at a time. Cats can have multiple eggs fertilized my multiple male cats in one pregnancy. Once human women are pregnant, they can’t get pregnant anymore. The best way to produce offspring is asexual reproduction. If the natural purpose of humans was to reproduce, we would reproduce through asexual division.
Point 7: Clearly, the biological function of sex is not just for reproduction, and sex has some other natural/biological purposes. The female orgasm is a big one! The female orgasm is not related to procreation at all. If the natural purpose of sex was reproduction only, the female orgasm would tie into procreation. One natural reason for sex is a desire for physical pleasure. Another is the human desire for connection and intimacy. Humans are naturally social animals and sex is naturally part of the social exchange. Sex is also about bonding. Having sex releases oxytocin. Oxytocin is the hormone that helps maintain healthy interpersonal relationships. When it is released during orgasm, it begins creating an emotional bond. Having sex also naturally releases endorphins. Endorphins make you feel calm, relaxed, and secure. Humans are always seeking security and sex helps us achieve this. Humans also have sex because it has some natural health benefits. It’s a cardiovascular activity that is good for your heart and burns calories. It naturally improves your immune system and relieves stress.
Ultimately, we need to look at how sex looks like in most of the animal kingdom and look at how sex looks for humans. Would sex look the way it does if it was intended only for reproduction. I think it’s pretty clear that the concept that “sex is for procreation” is incorrect and is just a forced birther talking point.
Here are some biological purposes for humans to have sex: procreation, orgasms, pleasure, bonding, connections, fun, health, exercise, to maintain a healthy relationship, intimacy, and desire to connect socially with others. Forced birthers don't like sex, for whatever reason. They don't like the idea that sex can be for many different functions and people have sex for many different reasons. They try to push this idea that "sex is for making babies." Nope! Humans are complex and amazing beings, and sex is for whatever we decide it's for.