r/probabilitytheory • • May 09 '26

[Discussion] The Birthday Paradox. In a group of just 23 people, there is a 50.7% chance that at least two people share the same birthday, and this probability rises to over 99% with 57 people.

0 Upvotes

r/probabilitytheory • • Sep 19 '26

[Education] Monty Hall Problem

1 Upvotes

I was solving the Monty Hall problem recently, and when I couldn't find a mathematical solution that I was satisfied with, I searched around quite a bit.

Then I remembered the way I used to solve these kinds of problems in undergrad: law of total probability.

So I would like to present my solution

P[win] = P[win | car is behind D1] * P[car is behind D1] + P[win | car is behind D2] * P[car is behind D2] + P[win | car is behind D3] * P[car is behind D3]
Suppose you choose door D2

Case : - No switch

P[win | Car is behind D1] = 0 , similarly P[win | Car is behind D3] = 0
P[win | car is behind D2] = 1 , P[car is behind Di] = 1/3 for i = 1, 2, 3

therefore P[win] = 1/3

Case :- Switch

P[win | Car is behind D1] = 1 , similarly P[win | Car is behind D3] = 1 (because which ever door monty opens, you would select the door having car)
P[win | car is behind D2] = 0 , P[car is behind Di] = 1/3 for i = 1, 2, 3

therefore P[win] = 2/3


r/probabilitytheory • • Aug 27 '26

[Education] Guys! I have a problem

0 Upvotes

I want to start learning probability from scratch (my major)...but I don't know how and I need advice to get started.


r/probabilitytheory • • Jul 28 '26

[Discussion] The Gender Ratio Trap, Part 3 — every family is guaranteed to end up with more girls

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/probabilitytheory • • Jul 15 '25

[Discussion] What are the chances ?

0 Upvotes

r/probabilitytheory • • 29d ago

[Research] If an event has exactly 0% probability but can still happen, does continuous probability really represent physical reality?

0 Upvotes

I've been studying probability theory, particularly continuous probability density functions, and I came across something that I mathematically understand but still find logically and physically counterintuitive.

In a continuous uniform distribution, say a random variable (X) between 0 and 10, or for example a robot in a line of 10 m , i don't know where he is but i know he is within the 10 m yet the probability of any exact distance value is zero:

[
P(X=5)=0
]

This is because probability is calculated by integrating the density over an interval, and a single point has zero width, meaning zero area under the curve.

I understand the mathematics behind this. I also understand the distinction between countable and uncountable infinity, and how an interval can have a positive measure even though every individual point has measure zero.

My problem isn't with the mathematics, but with its representation of physical reality.

If something has exactly 0% probability yet physically occurs, shouldn't that suggest the model might not perfectly describe reality?

We can't still say weather the universe is fundamentally continuous or discrete. But if space has some smallest resolution, wouldn't that change how we assign probabilities to exact positions?

I'm struggling to reconcile that with physical intuition.

So my question is: Is continuous probability merely a useful mathematical approximation of physical reality, or is there a deeper reason why zero-probability events can physically occur without contradicting the model?


r/probabilitytheory • • Oct 19 '24

[Education] Probability of your existence

Post image
1 Upvotes

After listening to a discussion about life and how lucky we are to even exist, I wondered what the exact probability of our existence was. The following was quite shocking so I thought I'd share it with you.

Here's the odds of you even existing The probability of your existence is 1 in 102,685,000. 10 followed by almost 2.7 million zeros. Your existence has required the unbroken stretch of survival and reproduction of all your ancestors, reaching back 4 billion years to single-celled organisms. It requires your parents meeting and reproducing to create your singular set of genes (the odds of that alone are 1 in 400 quadrillion). That probability is the same as if you handed out 2 million dice, each die with one trillion sides… then rolled those 2 million dice and had them all land on 439,505,270,846. https://www.sciencealert.com/what-is-the-likelihood-that-you-exist


r/probabilitytheory • • Oct 04 '18

0.000154% chance of drawing a royal flush and i do so in consecutive days. Only $5, per, to break even on each ticket. Asinine!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/probabilitytheory • • Dec 14 '19

Variance is not linear, but is standard deviation.

0 Upvotes

From what I can see, variance is not linear because we square everything (as a way to not end up with 0 based on linearity of expectation). So all constants also need to be squared. Would I be correct in saying that standard deviation is linear then?


r/probabilitytheory • • May 20 '20

Is the normal distribution quite possibly the Michael Jordan of probability distributions?

0 Upvotes

r/probabilitytheory • • Jun 25 '14

I want to know if I'm more likely to get bitten by Luis Suarez than I am by a shark.

0 Upvotes

Not sure this is the right place to ask, but would anyone care to let me know the various probabilities of things happening to me:

Getting bitten by a shark Getting hit by lightning Winning the lottery Getting hit by a meteor Getting bitten by Uruguayan cannibal-footballer Luis Suarez


r/probabilitytheory • • May 18 '20

Suggestions to learn probability theory from SCRATCH

0 Upvotes

This semester i had a probability course, which i did not attend at all. Due to coronavirus my textbook has not arrived yet. Can anyone recommend any book or video courses to catch up with the curriculum?

P.S. 1 no khan academy please.

P.S. 2 i am willing to pay for any book.


r/probabilitytheory • • May 22 '20

Interesting Probability Problem : try solving

0 Upvotes

Two different integers are selected at random from first 99 integers from 1 to 99. What is the probability that their sum is divisible by 5?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uIpj8wMSinM&t=199s


r/probabilitytheory • • Mar 07 '19

Discrete Random Variable X; Find x such that the Probability P[X=k] =co...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/probabilitytheory • • Aug 22 '20

An interesting probability problem

0 Upvotes

Bag A has 4 black balls and 3 white balls. Bag B has 2 black balls and 4 white balls. A ball is drawn at random from bag A and placed in bag B and then two balls are drawn at random from bag B. What is the probability that both balls drawn from bag B are of the same color?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lXQ3JMnMoUo&t=47s


r/probabilitytheory • • Sep 22 '26

[Education] I built an interactive Monty Hall simulator — pick a door, stay or switch, and watch 1,000 games prove the math

0 Upvotes

Made this after seeing how many people still don't believe switching wins 2/3 of the time. You play it yourself (pick a door, host opens a goat door, stay or switch), then there's a button to instantly simulate 1,000 games and watch the win rates converge live. https://claude.ai/artifact/99ytxqwB7ydNqCL22FhcSp Happy to hear if the explanation/visualization could be clearer.


r/probabilitytheory • • Mar 13 '14

Probability and Statistics Question.

0 Upvotes

The probability that a randomly selected 40-year old male will live to be 41 years old is 0.9970. What is the probability that at least one of four randomly selected 40-year old males will not live to be 41 years old?

(without replacement)

Thank you in advance!


r/probabilitytheory • • May 10 '20

Bernoulli trials

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/probabilitytheory • • Aug 18 '22

[Discussion] If probability is useful why isn't in all industries?

0 Upvotes

I'm studying probability nowadays and I don't understand why is not used in the process of making movies for example.

If you know how high a probability is of this and that why not just do the movie and win money.

Theorically you don't need much money and can multiply it. Are there some problems in probability that I don't understand and make things harder to calculate?


r/probabilitytheory • • Aug 21 '26

[Education] I Got Distracted and Tried to Derive Probability from Expectation

1 Upvotes

First of all, that's not an anime title. 😆

Some time ago, while reading Axler's linear algebra book, I got distracted (as always happens to me) and started thinking about probability from a slightly different perspective.

Since probability theory can be developed from expectations, I wondered how far I could get by starting with expectations and deriving the usual probability framework from them.

So I wrote down my attempt.

https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22030704

I'd be interested to hear what you think about the derivation, especially if you spot any mistakes or gaps.

Edit: I probably should've been clearer about this 😅 I wasn't trying to claim that this is a new way of developing probability. I already knew that probability can be derived from expectations, but I wasn't familiar with the details, so I decided to try working out the derivation myself. I'm mainly posting it because I'd be interested to see how my derivation compares with existing treatments and whether I've made any mistakes or missed anything.


r/probabilitytheory • • Jul 22 '26

[Discussion] Monty Hall, the never ending story

0 Upvotes

A lot of the confusion and misunderstandings and paradoxes around the Monty-Hall-Discussion arise from the different interpretations of the game with either a "knowing host" or an "ignorant host". Some people do that math based on an ignorant host, some assume the host knows. But today, I want to propose a method that we can actually use to *test* the host's knowledge.

This is my setup:

You are only ever brought into the TV studio when there has been one door reserved for you (randomly of course) and one door opened and showing a goat. Thats what you see, and you play this setup 100 times. And I believe you can determine whether the host knew where the car was or not.

Here is how: If you play the "stay"-strategy, you would expect to win 33% of the games. but this will only happen if you see all the games. If the host accidentely reveals the car, the game is aborted and you will never see it. In this case (Monty does not know) you will observe that your win-rate is 50%. And then you know that there were games you never saw.

I have written a Javascript simulation for this, and it seems to work. I also asked AI for a comment, and it confirmed my approach. Nevertheless I find it wiered that it works. Or am I missing something?


r/probabilitytheory • • Aug 13 '26

[Education] Probability 0 ~ impossible!???

8 Upvotes

What is the meaning of a probability of 0? For example, consider the set (0,1) and let x be in (0,1). What is the probability of picking that x? The answer is 0. But if the probability of randomly picking x from the set (0,1) is 0, does that mean it's impossible to pick that number?

There is another similar example, if you throw a dart at a 2D plane, the probability that the dart lands on a specific point on that plane is 0. That implies it can't happen, but it actually did happen, it landed on a point! So what does it mean, exactly?


r/probabilitytheory • • Jun 25 '18

Will probability catch up in insurance market?

0 Upvotes

I will explain a weird theory I have. I believe it is completely inaccurate, but I want to know why. Tossing a coin reaches 0.5 probability given enough number of flips. For example, probability of heads for first 100 experimental flips, might be 0.55, but it slowly converges to 0.5 as we progress to “enough” no.of flips.

Similarly, in the insurance industry, let’s say probability of a car being in an accident in a given year is found to be P. Does that mean that, if you are not in an accident this year, you are more likely to be in an accident the following year or the year after? Does that mean your insurance costs should be going up based in this factor with your experience even though they might be going down due to some other factors? Is that how it works?

Are my questions too dumb?


r/probabilitytheory • • Mar 20 '23

[Discussion] ChatGPT creating an interesting formula

0 Upvotes

I have always been interested in probability theory and chance. When I became interested in gambling, I began to actively explore it from the side of chance and calculation. I came up with the idea that, based on the mathematical expectation, it is possible to calculate the outcome of a certain number of games. For example, according to the mathematical expectation, in roulette, red and black colors should roll about an equal number of times. But when does that mathematical expectation come into play? My research on this question stalled a few years ago when I learned about the law of large numbers, which states that the average "gradually approaches" the mathematical expectation as the number of tries increases. Such a general and imprecise definition frustrated me, because any gambler's dream is to one day get his 94.74% (return to player percentage in american roulette) of the money spent. When does this day come? Today I came to an answer. I asked Bing AI, which is a version of ChatGPT 4 a question: how do I know after how many tries a certain experiment the mathematical expectation will come? And he gave me an answer that amazed me:

To estimate after how many repetitions the mathematical expectation should approximately come, you can use the law of large numbers. This law states that as the number of independent trials increases, the sample mean tends to the mathematical expectation.

However, this law does not accurately answer your question because it does not account for random deviations from the mathematical expectation. In order to account for these deviations and get a more accurate estimate of the number of repetitions, you must use the central limit theorem. This theorem allows you to calculate the probability that the sample mean will differ from the mathematical expectation by no more than a given amount (error).

For example, if we want to know how many times we need to repeat an experiment (one number bet) on American Roulette (with an expectation of -0.0526) so that the sample mean is close to the mathematical expectation with a probability of 95% and an error of 0.005, we can use the following formula:

n ≥ (z)²(p)(1-p)(d-p)/ε²,

where n is the number of attempts, z is the coefficient of normal distribution for a given confidence probability (for example, for 95% it is 1.96), p is the probability of success in one attempt, d is the payout ratio for success (for example, for a one number bet it is 35), ε is the precision of the mathematical expectation estimate.

In American roulette there are 38 numbers, of which only one corresponds to your bet on one number. Therefore p = 1/38 ≈ 0.0263. The value of d, the payout ratio for success, is 35:1. The value of ε is the precision of the mathematical expectation estimation - equals 0.005 (0.5%). The z-value of the normal distribution coefficient for a given confidence level is equal to 1.96 for 95%.

Substituting these values into your formula, I get:

n ≥ (1.96)²(0.0263)(1-0.0263)(35-0.0263)/0.005²,

n ≥ 137624 (approximately).

This means that you have to make at least 137624 attempts to get close to the mathematical expectation with 0.5% accuracy and 95% probability.

In other words, it means that after 10,662 roulette games you'll get back your theoretical 94.74% ±0.5% RTP with a 95% probability. Isn't that awesome? Personally, I'm amazed by this formula.

It turns out that it is possible and very easy to calculate the expectation, using this formula, in addition we can set the probability of occurrence for this number of attempts and the possible error. The incredible thing was that I could not find any source for this formula or where Bing AI could get it from. Further in the dialogue, Bing clarified that this formula is not particularly popular and falls under the experimental mathematics section. It is possible that this formula is incorrect and completely made up by Bing. I am very interested in the opinions of educated mathematicians. I hope this formula will help someone. It would be interesting to hear what you guys think about it.