r/privacy • • Nov 24 '25

software Signal REFUSE TO PATCH "Design Flaw" that tracks EVERYTHING you do!

0 Upvotes

Unfortunatelly, i cannot send the link to yt video because of this subreddit antispam. I will post the research paper later.

According to that paper, it is possible for anyone to trick your phone with signal app to respond with message meaning "delivered".

The latency of that message could be used to determine the state of your device (locked, unlocked, signal app open/closed), manufacturer of your device, if you are on wifi/cellular etc.

These informations could be obtained by literally anyone, as long as they know your phone number/are able to send you message o signal.

The vulnerability is part of Signal protocol, meaning that fixing this design flaw would probably cause breaking of backwards compatibility. So its probably not gonna be fixed.

For me, personally, its time to switch to another app, that does not require phone number at all.


r/privacy • • Jan 23 '20

Apple's Privacy myth needs to end

237 Upvotes

It’s pretty clear that many members of this community have very little understanding of privacy, falling victim to mainstream media’s depiction of it and the world in general—the very power system(s) they're trying to combat. The belief in Apple as privacy-oriented is one such illusion. So before starting I highly suggest people educate themselves on media and propaganda (I’ll happily provide book recommendations) to develop a more critical framework. A good introduction is this documentary.

A rough summary is that mainstream media are huge corporations whose profit-making comes not from readers/viewers or paid subscribers, but advertisers. This means there’s two important institutional constraints on media ideology: that of their owners and of their buyers. Both inherently determine their values and the kind of content they make. Corporate media are businesses selling products (us, consumers) to other businesses. What kind of ideology and picture of the world do you think you’re getting from that?

The rest of this post is written under the assumption that this sub is informed enough to view Apple as nothing more than “the lesser of evils”. A perspective I will argue is still misguided.

1. USER IDENTIFICATION:

Outside the ones shared by all competing products in the industry, there are additional ways to identify you in specifically Apple products.

  1. iOS subliminally and constantly collects sensitive data and links it to hardware identifiers almost guaranteed to link to a real identity.

  2. iOS forces users to activate devices which sets up a remote UUID-linked (also collecting registration IP) database for a given device with Apple’s services.

  3. iOS and iOS-based coprocessors force the regular sending of incredibly sensitive metadata to Apple for the mere ability to use the device for questionable and unknown reasons.

2.1. PRIVACY POLICY IN PRACTICE IN REGARDS TO THE AUTHORITIES:

Apple is subject to the FISA Amendments Act of 2009, and PRISM is an example of that law in practice, which they are a part of.

As public disclosure of cooperation with authorities have been allowed in in limited degrees in recent years, we’ve seen examples like Apple admitting to complying with 90% of government requests of accessing thousands of user files every year; FBI openly praised them for providing "ample assistance". It therefore came as no surprise when a recent leak revealed that the company purposefully kept their phones less secure to make access easier for the authorities. Despite all this, Apple is still most associated with the FBI encryption dispute in 2015, which has been a huge PR success for them.

The latter case, which was completely fraudulent, is still widely circulated and frequently brought up as a demonstration of the company's integrity. In reality it was a demonstration, like the general theme of much else in this post, of successful media propaganda. Apple (or even FBI) aren’t able to fool professional and well-educated journalists of NYT, WP, etc--they rely on the media's conformity through misrepresentation of the available facts, as well as accessible and well-known critique. It all happens quite "freely", due to the institutional constraints mentioned in the second paragraph of this post.

Apple have outlined how they give virtually everything relevant on iCloud to the authorities. As the CEO of ElcomSot, a security company that revealed iCloud was uploading data to Apple servers without users knowing, said: "The takeaway really is don't ever used iCloud". Apple having the encryption keys to iCloud as well as other parts of your iPhone completely invalidates the point of E2EE, and might explain why/how NSA mines data directly from their servers.

The company's respect for privacy is no better outside the US. We know that they oblige and assist authoritarian governments like China in installing firewalls to block citizens' access to encrypted tools like social media apps. They’re actively undermining people’s security and privacy from violent regimes for the sake of profit.

2.2. PRIVACY POLICY IN PRACTICE IN REGARDS TO THE PRIVATE INDUSTRY.

Apple sells certificates to third-party developers that allow them to track users—third-party developers are allowed to collect data on iOS. Facebook's privacy scandal (interestingly, Apple themselves were one of the main partners buying data from Facebook) involved iOS users as well due to the mentioned tracking. Tim Cook reacted to the scandal with another publicity stunt by superficially punishing Facebook. A real response, like removing Facebook from the App Store or removing their ability to track you, did not happen.

The company attacks Google and Facebook's intrusion on users' privacy, yet are enabling them and other businesses in doing so on their products. They even use Google as Safari's default search provider—making 12 billion USD in 2019 alone from this deal.

If they really cared about privacy they would deny the ability of privacy-invasive apps to collect any user date. They don't because these apps' importance in keeping their products' platform popular and therefore profitable.

3. THE LACK OF OPEN SOURCE CODE.

Open source code, specifically those that have been audited, is for obvious reasons much safer than closed source ones. Even government agencies take it into account in choosing secure software for their members.

It is all the more important when the company in question surrenders data to state authorities, allows third-party developers to collect data, have weak security measures (sometimes on purpose) and havr had numerous suspicious activities discovered. Not to mention the fact that Apple's verification mechanism is designed in such a way that they have the ability to “silently send targeted malicious updates to devices matching specific unique ID criteria”. iOS is a textbook example of why closed source is bad.

Imagine if Huawei, on top of providing third-party developers the ability to track its users, admitted to giving the Chinese government access to user data (but only after it was caught doing so) and were continuously caught in suspicious activities (many involving Chinese authorities)—all on a completely closed source software platform. Would you take their claims of "security" and "privacy" seriously?

Many users (predominately Americans) already have a hard time trusting Huawei, despite 0 evidence of illegal data collection of users or claimed connections with the CCP. Users have bought into US government claims and mainstream media propaganda. At the same time they buy and congratulate Apple for their privacy-oriented approach. A perfect example of a system of indoctrination.

4. ALTERNATIVES.

Here are some reasonable steps with descending order in how effective they are, that provide you with Android-based alternatives superior to iOS in privacy and security:

1: Disable Google tracking and services in settings (the little that they make available to you) and use F-Droid instead of Play Store. Notwithstanding the lack of privacy in many ways, it's a good starting point.

-At this point your privacy from private companies is a bit better than on iOS.

1.5: Some OEMs, like Huawei, simplify and help users uninstall Google apps and services. Huawei’s current products (like Mate Pro 30) also come without all that, due to the current trade war. The phones still come with Huawei bloat and their ad-based data mining, but it’s nowhere as bad as Google and easier to evade.

-At this point your privacy from private companies is better than on iOS.

2: Root your device (an easy task) and uninstall all Google apps and services, as well as anything else, completely.

-At this point your privacy from both government and private companies is better than on iOS.

3: Install Custom ROMs that allow the same as 2, have even more open software for examination and also include enhanced privacy features in the system (or you can get these as third-party apps). Some, like LineageOS, also provide UI, performance and update cycles superior to almost all the main Android OSes (One UI, MIUI, EMUI, LG UI, etc.)

-At this point your privacy from both government and private companies is significantly better than on iOS.

4: GrapheneOS. It provides an exceptional level of privacy and security that has been praised by Snowden himself. It runs a stock Android setup with the same pros as LOS above, making it very well from a non-privacy perspective as well. If you want a user-friendly and highly privacy-related platform without having to do a lot of tinkering and manual management, this is the ROM for you.

-At this point your privacy from both government and private companies is tremendously better than on iOS.

5. SUMMARY: IPHONES ARE NOT THE BEST ALTERNATIVE FOR DATA PRIVACY.

iPhones give no additional security and privacy from the government over Android phones. They only do in limited conditions that are inconsequential to this sub. It's not better out of the box, nor is it the minute you want to improve your privacy and security beyond what you get out of the box (where iOS is terrible). It is not the "lesser of evils"— a myth that needs to die.

Additionally, positioning themselves as a beacon of privacy make them even more dangerous, as they become a honeypot for people in severe need of privacy. This has profound consequences in authoritarian societies for journalists, demonstrators and other dissidents. COINTELPRO has shown how ugly it can get in free societies as well.

If Apple's software and ecosystem is more important to you than increased security on even some of the best UX alternatives on Android (LOS, GrapheneOS, etc), then at least admit to this hard truth and move on. Spreading misinformation undermines the privacy of others, and doing that to serve your confirmation bias is disingenuous and honestly deplorable.


r/privacy • • Sep 11 '19

Misleading title Firefox about to break privacy for all users

43 Upvotes

Warning: if you are a firefox user and you upgrade to the latest version, Firefox will send all DNS requests to cloudflare. Cloudflare is then able to track every DNS request of yours. While it is possible to opt out, this "feature" will be enabled by default. Read more about this on https://ungleich.ch/en-us/cms/blog/2019/09/11/turn-off-doh-firefox/.


r/privacy • • Sep 01 '14

Say hello to men who hate the NSA but love invading the privacy of women

Thumbnail
theverge.com
0 Upvotes

r/privacy • • Apr 17 '17

Google Hire would lay bare your entire search history for employers

Thumbnail
news.com.au
12 Upvotes

r/privacy • • Jul 04 '26

discussion Stuff I ask chatgpt gets recommended to me on reddit

0 Upvotes

This happened more than once. I ask Chatgpt about a specific topic that I have never been interested in before, then it gets recommended to me on my reddit home page with a post from a subreddit about that specific topic.

For a long time I ignored it, mostly because I thought I was imagining it. But it's getting really unnerving.

When I asked chatgpt about it, it tried to gaslight me into believing I was imagining it by saying stuff like: "Once something is on your mind, you notice it more. Psychologists call this the frequency illusion or Baader-Meinhof effect."

I searched through the app settings but I couldn't find anything to stop this or turn this off.

I know other companies like google used to (and still) do this too, like showing you ads based on your search history. But it felt less creepy back then.


r/privacy • • Mar 23 '26

question Is Proton drive safe to store nudes in?

0 Upvotes

Just wondering looking for something free


r/privacy • • Sep 28 '23

discussion Websites do LISTEN to you, and will feed you targetd advertisments based on that.

1 Upvotes

storage write muscle dynamic layer cow cassette counter round curtain


r/privacy • • Jan 28 '25

data breach DeepSeek’s Popular AI App Is Explicitly Sending US Data to China

0 Upvotes

Amid ongoing fears over TikTok, Chinese generative AI platform DeepSeek says it’s sending heaps of US user data straight to its home country, potentially setting the stage for greater scrutiny.


r/privacy • • Sep 26 '25

question my friend managed to find out the name of my bluetooth headphones

8 Upvotes

hi guys, i was talking with her on discord, i never talked with her on voice chat, i never sent a voice message anywhere EVERR, i never told anyone ever no matter what site or app it is the name of my bluetooth headphones or my model or anything related to it, the name is literally just a random mash of 17 letters and numbers, it cant be a guess
i had no accounts of any other social media connected to my discord account
i never clicked any links that she sent

im on windows 11 pro btw using the desktop app

how did she manage to find that out?


r/privacy • • Nov 01 '24

discussion Why Privacy?

0 Upvotes

I know this sounds stupid. But I'll explain why I'm asking.

I saw someone on here order a maxed out M4 Max MacbookPro and he said he's getting it as he needs the computing power to run LLMs locally.

I fully get the concept of privacy. Everyone has the right to share what they want to and don't want to.

But also for simple data, nothing incredibly personal, who cares?

For example when my phone or watch asks me if it can track me/what I look at for whatever reason, if it'll give me a better UX or better data tracking for health etc, why not?
Running an LLM locally probably has benefits other than privacy, but having to buy the computing power to do so just for privacy? Not sure how beneficial this is.

Again, not here saying people are overreacting, I'm asking for other reasons as to why you're keeping simple things private.


r/privacy • • Mar 04 '25

discussion With current Trump administration on the US, how endangered are we all with our info and data?

0 Upvotes

With the current US government, how endangered are we all (including people outside of the US that use US based services from companies like Google, Microsoft, etc)?

Given the latest news, and Us pulling itself further away from Nato and their allies, are people from Europe under microscope by the US if they use US based services?


r/privacy • • Jul 09 '24

question Uncensored search engine

1 Upvotes

Do they exist?


r/privacy • • Jul 03 '24

question Just found out that my son (11) uses Instagram without my knowledge and permission

173 Upvotes

So, as a result, I contacted the privacy department of Meta for the deletion of the account and all the data that has been collected on it but as an answer, they told me that I have to provide them three different official documents that indicate:

1)Me as a legal authority over my kid,

2) My ID where my name and surname are visible

3) My son's ID where his name, surname and birthday are visible.

How is this even legal in European Union ? I just wanted to make a complaint and demanded the deletion of data that has been illegally collected and now they ask for even more data to prove my situation as a parent. I do not want my data anything to do with Meta, except I use whatsapp which in mandatory if you are in EU. So, should I look for a lawyer which will cost me a lot of money or just send our IDs and other private information to Meta to get it over with ? I am not concerned about my data as much as I do about my son's data and all the bullshit he has been exposed to, through Instagram reels.

Waiting to hear your advices.


r/privacy • • Jun 24 '18

Speculative. Very. After taking $50 Million monies, Signal app shortly thereafter gets rid of passcodes in favor of fingerprints for security....

17 Upvotes

But fingerprints lack the Constitutional protected rights and are not implicated by the 4th amendment.... The fact that the Signal developer (Moxie) abruptly removed a core functionality of Signal that has existed since its inception merely months after taking $50 million dollars from a source related or connected to Facebook, while I suppose it COULD be a coincidence... but there is reasonable doubt that something else might be going on...

http://archive.is/55NnJ


r/privacy • • Jan 04 '24

news 32 Sask. students outed as transgender due to Edsby glitch: privacy commissioner

Thumbnail
saskatoon.ctvnews.ca
2 Upvotes

r/privacy • • Mar 10 '24

news I know this has probably been asked before: but why should o care about privacy?

0 Upvotes

I’m an 18 year old male, use google, use chrome. Uses everything everyone here would run from. I just can’t understand why I personally care about privacy? I’ve wanted to care, truly. I tried switching software, browsers, etc but I just become Inconvenienced and switch right back. I understand the importance of privacy however, and I will support everyone’s right to privacy. However me personally, I do not see why I should care for myself, I want to know how I could make myself care. I want to care. But I find myself like “eh I really could care less of google knew what shoes I liked and gave me an ad for it” I just fail to recognize why that should be scary or noteworthy. Help.


r/privacy • • Jun 15 '24

news Elon Musk threatens to ban iPhones over OpenAI integration

5 Upvotes

Elon Musk threatened to ban Apple iPhones from his companies Monday, calling the tech giant’s new deal with OpenAI a security risk and escalating his long-running feuds with both companies.

In a series of posts on his social-media platform X, the former Twitter, the Tesla TSLA, -2.44% chief executive expressed doubts that OpenAI would protect Apple users’ security and privacy. “Apple has no clue what’s actually going on once they hand your data over to OpenAI. They’re selling you down the river,” Musk claimed.

Apple did not immediately respond to MarketWatch’s request for comment.

Apple’s stock AAPL, -0.82% shot up 6.2% in midday trading on Tuesday, putting it on track for a record close. It was also headed for the biggest one-day gain since it ran up 8.9% on Nov. 10, 2022.

Earlier in the day, Apple unveiled its long-awaited artificial-intelligence strategy at its Worldwide Developers Conference, which included featuring OpenAI’s ChatGPT in its latest iPhones. Apple said users will control when ChatGPT is used, and will need to give their permission before any data is shared.

“If Apple integrates OpenAI at the OS level, then Apple devices will be banned at my companies. That is an unacceptable security violation,” Musk said.

Tesla did not respond to a request for comment.

It was unclear how exactly Apple’s ChatGPT integration would work, or how likely Musk is to follow through with his threat.

Musk has been feuding with Apple and its CEO, Tim Cook, since last year, after Apple stopped advertising on X after Musk endorsed an antisemitic conspiracy theory and some Apple ads were placed alongside pro-Nazi content.

He’s also been feuding with OpenAI, a company he co-founded and later left. Musk started his own AI company, xAI, which he hopes will be a competitor to OpenAI. Musk sued OpenAI in March, claiming it put profits over humanity. OpenAI claimed Musk supported its for-profit plans but wanted to control the company.

Original Source


r/privacy • • Jul 28 '21

The last refuge of the criminal: Encrypted smartphones

Thumbnail
politico.eu
0 Upvotes

r/privacy • • Feb 01 '24

software Email is not private, stop falling for marketing

0 Upvotes

People often ask here “what’s the best email service” when they’re starting out. Here’s the truth, companies and 99.9% of people you email will not be using the same system, so your email is no more private on Proton or Skiff or whoever else has fancy marketing than it is on Outlook or Gmail.


r/privacy • • Jan 10 '25

data breach Why Face ID Isn't As Secure As You Think

1 Upvotes

Face ID seems convenient and secure, but here’s the catch: your face is public. Unlike a PIN code or password, your face is always visible and can’t be changed.

From my experience working with sensitive data, I’ve seen cases where biometrics were exploited in unexpected ways. For example, using 3D replicas or even under physical coercion, attackers could bypass Face (Touch) ID.

If you value privacy, switching to a PIN code might be a safer choice—it requires your active consent and stays hidden from the world.

Biometric systems promise security at the cost of privacy. Do you think they’re worth the trade-off, or should we focus on traditional access methods?


r/privacy • • Jun 12 '24

news Elon Musk claims Apple's new AI tools are a privacy risk. How much of a concern are they?

Thumbnail
cbc.ca
0 Upvotes

r/privacy • • Sep 09 '22

discussion My dentist uses gmail. Ouch

2 Upvotes

I have noticed that my dentist uses gmail in their business.

My xrays, my teeth, everything at Big Brother's plain sight.

Privacy-conscious people suffer twice nowadays.


r/privacy • • Dec 31 '22

news Learning to Self-Manage Abortions Is Key in a Post-“Roe” Society

Thumbnail
truthout.org
1 Upvotes