r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Oct 12 '26

Why?

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

I found this PCB at work today. It is from a Gas Monitor, and seems to be from the mid-90s.
Why would you route the traces like this? Is there any advantage? Or was there just no other way back then?
Another manufacturer from the same era uses straight traces, but always 90° bends.
It goes against almost everything I was told. And I was just curious about it.


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Feb 12 '25

Wow, it is IMMENSELY satisfying when you designed and assembled it yourself

Thumbnail
gallery
662 Upvotes

My first time doing SMT. Hopefully the .5mm pitched QFNs soldered right. There isn't exactly an x-ray in my garage.

Also hot plate worked wonderfully. $40 shipped from the US via Ali. Great purchase.


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Jul 13 '25

What type of PCB design is this?

Thumbnail
gallery
548 Upvotes

Came across these interesting PCBs which are used on Aspides and wanted to ask if this kind of trace routing has a name or this type of design? What would be the advantages and downsides to this layout? Thank you


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Jun 16 '25

vendor didnt add inner layers, boards bricked, refusing to give replacement or full refund

Post image
497 Upvotes

I ordered several hundred dollars of PCBAs from a certain Popular Chinese Vendor whose name starts with J.

Upon receiving it, the board was visibly incorrectly built. This was a minor rev of a previously successful board, and it was immediately obvious that the PCB was missing all plane layers. The board is translucent when held up to a light.

Popular Chinese Vendor whose name starts with J admitted fault:

Dear Customer, Thank you for providing the correct order number. Upon investigation, we found that due to an error on our engineer's part, the inner layer negative film was not converted to positive, resulting in a lack of copper on the inner layers. We have reported this issue to the relevant department and will ensure closer attention to this process in the future.

However, they refuse to provide working PCBAs or adequately refund the value of the boards:

As your order includes SMT assembly, a remake is not supported in our system due to component-related constraints. Additionally, compensation for SMT components is typically not provided, as their cost can exceed that of the boards themselves. To avoid further waste, would you consider salvaging the components for reuse?

I don’t care that the component value exceeds the cost of the board—they were purchased as a package deal, and they failed to provide PCBAs built to print. Salvaging components—ie doing a bunch of rework labor to make their mistake right—is absolutely absurd. Especially when most of the components are power FETs attached to decent sized copper pours, making rework difficult.


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Sep 11 '25

EMS allowed me to be there for our proto production!

Thumbnail
gallery
453 Upvotes

We're working on a 10Gb router design and the company that does our pick and place was kind enough to let me not only be there while they were working on our boards but also take pictures and record videos.


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Oct 14 '25

[Review Request] I redesigned my 3D printer board to be 38% smaller.

Thumbnail
gallery
446 Upvotes

Previous post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/PrintedCircuitBoard/comments/1kb9bv9/review_request_a_robust_3d_printer_control_board/

The previous design works perfectly so I'm mostly interested to hear opinions on the denser layout used here.


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Apr 30 '25

[Review Request] A Robust 3D Printer Control Board

Thumbnail
gallery
425 Upvotes

r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Sep 26 '26

Review request for an all-in-one drone ESC, flight controller and video using ESP32 P4

Thumbnail
gallery
408 Upvotes

Hello folks,

This is my first PCB of this complexity and density for a quadcopter, so I would be very grateful for any remarks on the schematics or layout, especially on the motor phase drivers, MIPI-CSI and 2.4/5 GHz RF parts.

Overview

The board is 40x40 mm and meant for 2-3S (7-13 V) battery operation. The main MCU is an ESP32 P4, which controls the motor ESCs, sensors, and a Raspberry Pi-compatible camera. It's connected via SDIO to an ESP32 C5 for 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz Wi-Fi, which has a U.FL connector for an external antenna.

There are 4 ESCs on board with an STM32G071 MCU and DRV8328 each. They will run AM32 and I hope to get ~15 A continuous power draw per motor, though this is not a strict requirement. The MOSFETs are JMSL0302AU with ~3 mOhm RDS(on) at 100 degrees Celsius. Planning on 24 kHz switching frequency, at least initially.

3.3 V power is supplied by a TPS62933 buck, by my calculations it should be able to supply ~2.3 A continuously with the inductor I chose, while the avionics current draw should peak at 1.5 A at most. A TPS2121 power mux routes either USB 5V or +BAT to the buck's supply, with USB having priority if present.

In terms of sensors, there's an LSM6DSR IMU, LIS2MDL magnetometer, LPS22HB barometer, VL53L1X ToF sensor all connected on the same I2C channel, and a PMW3901MB optical flow sensor using SPI.

Layer stackup

The board is 1.2 mm thick and has 1 oz outer copper, 0.5 oz inner copper. I could afford thicker copper, but I hope to get away with this. Vias are filled and capped, surface finish is ENIG.

  • L1: Mixed

  • L2: GND

  • L3: 3V3 plane + some signals

  • L4: BAT plane + some signals

  • L5: GND

  • L6: Mixed

Notes

Sorry if the layer images are color vomit, I tried to make it a bit more readable at a glance. Yellow is low voltage power supply, purple denotes impedance-controlled signals (MIPI-CSI at the top, USB and 2.4/5 GHz RF at the bottom right). Trace widths and distances were calculated according to the JLCPCB impedance calculator, but especially in the case of MIPI it was hard to keep proper spacing. USB will only be used for debugging and flashing the P4, so I am not too worried about it.

Passives are rated 10 V X7R for low-voltage nets and 25 V X7R on battery voltage nets (except for C0G caps in the range of pF of course).

The 3V3 plane is heavily perforated in order to keep the VBAT plane as whole as possible between the half bridges and the battery connector.

I'm aware that the 0201 resistors between some motor pads and close to the mounting holes will probably be inconvenient, but I really couldn't fit them anywhere else.

KiCad project files, Gerbers and BOM: https://github.com/anticitizn/p4eregrine

Direct link to schematic PDF if images are hard to read: https://github.com/anticitizn/p4eregrine/raw/refs/heads/master/docs/p4eregrine_rev_a.pdf

Thank you in advance!


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Dec 23 '23

Review Request: High power BLDC Controller

Thumbnail
gallery
348 Upvotes

r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Jul 17 '26

[Review request] nRF54LM20B + PAW3950 (USB High Speed + 16 MHz SPI)

Thumbnail
gallery
325 Upvotes

Hi folks. Just finished an initial board design, would love some sanity check from the community.

The board has 2 power inputs: USB and external battery input (up to 5.5V), which are then OR'ed and bucked into ~1.9V.

Stackup is SIG/GND+PWR/SIG/SIG/GND/SIG. USB HS on the bottom layer, ~280 mm, matched to 90 Ohm differential impedance, with a solid uninterrupted ground above.

I need PAW3950 to work at the maximum possible 16 MHz, MISO/MOSI/CLK are lenght matched as well, just in case.

Non-coplanar 50 Ohm feedline for the antenna, because there isn't much sense to introduce a coplanar waveguide this short (I believe). Technically the via fence makes it a CPW anyways, but it's far from the trace.

The antenna itself is from Infineon reference guide: infineon.com/assets/row/public/documents/cross-divisions/42/infineon-an91445-antenna-design-and-rf-layout-guidelines-applicationnotes-en.pdf

nRF54LM20B doesn't have a reference design for the QFN52 yet, so hopefully their other one works here too.

My primary concerns are:

  1. The board will be 0.8 mm in thickness for the wiggly parts to be bendable. Should I worry about the antenna ground plane vias acting as mouse bites?

  2. Should I perhaps try to fit the buck converter closer to the power consumers? I have a 47 uF bulk cap there, but I'm still worrying about that large inductive power trace.

  3. I used 4x49.9 Ohm resistors for the USB impedance matching, just for BOM optimization reasons. The MCU technically expects 200 Ohm, I don't think it would be an issue though?

  4. The nRFs aren't available for assembly in my fab yet; I indent to get the boards assembled without these, and then solder them down manually with a tiny hot table of mine. Any nuances I'm missing here?

High resolution images of the layout: https://postimg.cc/gallery/QD86jHG

Schematic PDF: https://efog.tech/storage/sch.pdf

Thanks in advance!

P.S. Please don't mind ugly squiggly lines, I will fix them lol.


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Nov 22 '24

Just finished my first PCB, how did i do

Thumbnail
gallery
307 Upvotes

Just finished my pcb for my automated greenhouse, did i make any mistakes?


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Apr 26 '26

[Review Request] 1kW SMPS for lab bench power supply

Thumbnail
gallery
301 Upvotes

Reposted from r/AskElectronics because I think the revised design fits better in this subreddit.

This is my 1kW half-bridge SMPS design. My goal is to create a cost effective, simple, and robust SMPS board for lab bench power supply builds. The full details on this project is available in my previous post over on r/AskElectronics and this design implements the improvements people have suggested for my design. The improvements include:

  1. Major layout changes that actually make sense for a longitudinal cooling ( u/machineintel, u/BmanGorilla, u/BVirtual, u/mariushm).

  2. The new layout now significantly shortens the secondary power path, can handle higher current, and doesn’t require a wire jumper.

  3. Improved board density and 8% reduction in form-factor.

  4. 2x 225 DC blocking capacitors to better handle the high current demand.

  5. Multi-pin config for the capacitors to improve adaptability with various capacitor leg types/spacing.

  6. Refined component selection and better on-board documentation silkscreen.

  7. Re-routed high dv/dt loop on different layers and coupled with ground plane to minimise EMI radiation ( u/VEC7OR).

  8. Added electrically-connected mechanical mounting (M3 screws) to the heatsinks for better mechanical support and to reduce EMI radiation ( u/machineintel).

  9. Added a film capacitor across VBUS close to the N-MOS half-bridge to decouple the high dv/dt loop from the electrolytics ( u/machineintel).

  10. Implemented a single snubber across the low side switch for simplicity and increased its maximum thermal dissipation to 6W ( u/machineintel).

  11. Added a GND return terminal on the main transformer for the faraday shield that reduces HF noise capacitively coupled to the secondary side ( u/machineintel).

  12. Added another M3 mechanical mounting for the board close to the ETD49 cores and the heatsinks for better mechanical support ( u/Keefe1933).

  13. Maxed out the spec for the 1210 X7R MLCCs ( u/flyingsaxophone).

The full resolution media is available here.

This project is to be open-sourced once I finalise the design and ensure everything works properly. I plan to make a few YouTube videos about it and I welcome any PCB sponsorship for this project, feel free to DM me.

If you have any questions about this design, let me know and I'll try to answer them. Thank you and have a good day.


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Jun 21 '25

So happy it worked and looks beautiful to me

Thumbnail
gallery
295 Upvotes

r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Apr 01 '26

[Review Request] FOC & Six-Step ESC - 6S 64kHz 12.5A (First PCB)

Thumbnail
gallery
281 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I've been working for the past 2 months on a ESC board for a quadcopter drone. This is my first PCB so I would really appreciate to get some feedback !

To give you an overview, this board features an STM32G474 as the MCU, six CSD18540Q5B MOSFETs, three 2EDL8024 gate drivers, and three HoBB1216-5W-0.5mR-1% Kelvin shunts along with other supporting components. It is designed to support both six-step commutation and sensorless field-oriented control. The board v1.0 targets operation on a 6S battery at up to 64kHz, with current ratings of 12.5A (@continuous), 20A (@seconds), and 50A (@spike).

It can be powered either from the battery or from an external 3V3 source to run only the MCU. It is designed to be used alongside the Shirley FC board, as both projects are developed together.

All source files and exports (schematics, renders, and soon firmware) are available here alonside the project documentation: https://github.com/Bare-Metal-Foundry/Kururugi-ESC, and the sizing sheet can be found here if you are curious.

I wanted to have a small board that fits easily on a drone (24x38mm), so the layout is very compact. I used a 6 layer stack with SIG | GND | PWR(VBAT) | SIG | GND | SIG.

Any kind of feedback is welcome, especially regarding layout and routing, as I have no prior PCB design experience.

Thank you very much 😁 !

[EDIT] Bom can be found here.
[EDIT] PDF for the schematic can be found here Schematic PDF

------------

Some notes:

  1. What are these net colors? I’m colorblind, so I’m using a custom color scheme that works better for me.

  2. Why not 8 layers? I think I’m approaching the point where 8 layers could help and would make sense to shild the n°3 SIG plane, but I started with 6 and it seems sufficient for now.

  3. Firmware compatibility? The firmware will be custom bare-metal C++, so there are no pinout constraints.

  4. STM32G474/components are overkill? Yes, but this is not a production board, so cost is not a concern and it will be fun to play with the G474 h/w features

  5. What about the large VBAT trace/plane to PH1 on C.In3 and C.B? The VBAT PWR plane is heavily perforated by vias, so these added copper paths are intended to reduce resistance along the VBAT path to the MOSFETs. The trace placement is also far from sensitive components, so EMI should remain acceptable.

  6. Why not only sense on two phases and not three? Three-phase sensing is implemented for evaluation purposes. The goal is to compare it against two-phase sensing. V2.0 revision may simplify the design.

  7. How did you choose your via size and count? I estimated about 0.7A per 0.2mm via for a 20°C rise, which led me to use ~30 vias on the hot paths to ensure proper work at 20A@seconds.

  8. The GNDing? Grounding was one of the hardest parts. I decided not to split ground with net ties, and instead focused on keeping return paths as low-impedance and low-resistance as possible. Hopefully that’s enough to avoid major ground bounce on the MCU side.

  9. [EDIT] How do you amplify the shunt reading? I use the internal STM32 OpAmps. This also allows me to reduce the impedance seen by the internals ADC and have faster sampling time, as stated here.

  10. [EDIT] How will you mount it? I will use either a custom 3D mount or a sketchy solution (my beloved zipties!).


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • May 04 '25

Stop using 1117 regulators in new designs

275 Upvotes

The LM1117, AMS1117, or any other 1117 is probably a terrible choice for any new design you're considering. Pick any of the thousands of cheap modern linear regulators instead, such as the TLV767. Here's 5 reasons why:

  1. Capacitor requirements:

The LM1117 specifies a minimum output capacitor ESR of 0.3 ohms, this is much higher than any common ceramic capacitor. If you try to use a ceramic capacitor without adding a resistor you will see instability. Compare this to the TLV767 with a minimum ESR of 2 mohms, well above what you'll see on any reasonable choice of ceramic capacitor. The need for a resistor increases both the cost and size of your product and it's something that's easy to forget which could lead to having to scrap your entire first batch.

2. Minimum load current:

The adjustable version of the LM1117 has a minimum load current of 5 mA, this makes the LM1117 a poor choice for almost any sort of battery operated device. Most modern linear regulators handle any minimum load currents internally and don't come anywhere close to 5 mA.

3. Quiescent current:

Every version of the LM1117 has a maximum quiescent current of 10 mA, this again makes the LM1117 a poor choice for battery operated devices. The quiescent current of the TLV767 has a maximum of 95 uA, making it over 100 times more efficient.

4. Missing specifications:

Most 1117's have absolutely terrible datasheets that are missing even the most essential details, such as the ESR requirements for the output capacitor (the AMS1117 that everyone seems to use is one example of this). The LM1117 is slightly better, but even there we're missing important details, such as the PSRR at anything other than 120 Hz.

5. No soft-start:

The LM1117 lacks any sort of soft-start which can lead to all sorts of problems in both the input and output side. Exactly what these problems are depends on your circuit, but they can all be avoided by just getting a modern LDO with soft-start.


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Jan 22 '24

Does anyone know how these cartonish renders are created?

Post image
271 Upvotes

Is it possible to do it from Kicad for example?


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Apr 03 '25

For USA, TRUMP will be ending duty-free "de minimis" for low-value imports from China & Hong Kong on May 2, 2025

266 Upvotes

If you live in USA, the following will affect you...

If you order from AliExpress / LCSC / JLCPCB / PCBway / and more, "de minimis" changes will affect you!!

If you order tariff'ed components from Mouser / Digikey / and more, new import tariffs will affect you!!

List of new tariff for each country...

I guarantee there will be lots of price-shocked electronics hobbyists after May 2.


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Aug 14 '26

[REVIEW REQUEST] Programmable capacitor bank for piezo energy harvesting experiments

Thumbnail
gallery
257 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Two friends of mine wanted to do their final high-school research project (PWS for the Dutch folks) on piezoelectric energy harvesting and the possibility of using the generated energy for real-world applications. I told them numerous times that the amount of energy generated by piezo elements is exceptionally low, but they still wanted to research the piezo effect

Their main goal is to investigate how much energy piezo elements can generate and compare different elements to see how properties such as diameter, excitation frequency, impedance, and capacitance influence the harvested energy. To give them a way to measure this, I decided to design a PCB for them.

The main measurement method uses a programmable capacitor bank. By measuring the voltage increase, they can calculate the stored energy. Making the capacitance programmable also allows them to analyse which capacitance is optimal for charge transfer and storage. By using both MLCCs and electrolytic capacitors, they can also analyse differences in leakage current.

Since they also wanted to learn how to use an oscilloscope, I added a parallel load resistor to the capacitor bank. This can be used to measure energy delivered to a resistive load, as well as to discharge the capacitor bank. With no capacitors connected, the same setup can also be used to measure the losses of the full-bridge rectifier.

The ADC has a VREF​ of 2.048 V, so a resistor divider scales the maximum 10 V input down to 2.032 V. We don't intend to charge the capacitors beyond 8 V. A MOSFET disconnects the ADC and resistor divider when they're not being measured to prevent continuously draining the capacitor bank.

The goal was to provide as many research possibilities as possible while keeping the cost relatively low. I know there are dedicated piezo energy-harvesting ICs, but they are relatively expensive and would give the students less opportunity to experiment with the individual components.

The PCB is 40mm in diameter to fit in a custom designed case with a load cell to be able to apply a constant bending force to the piezo elements. The case will also support the extending connectors.

Are there any problems or potential improvements you can see with this PCB or measurement approach?

All feedback is greatly appreciated!

P.S. Any recommendations for a budget-friendly buffer op-amp would also be appreciated.


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Jul 08 '25 I’ll Drink to That

Felt cute, might reflash later

Thumbnail
gallery
256 Upvotes

Just wanted to say thanks to all the wonderful people on this subreddit doing the reviews. My board turned out great!


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Jan 25 '24

Review results: High power BLDC controller

Thumbnail
gallery
255 Upvotes

r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Jan 28 '24

PCB Color Palette

Thumbnail
gallery
253 Upvotes

r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • May 27 '25

Thanks for the reviews! Icepi Zero came back perfectly!

Thumbnail
gallery
246 Upvotes

Thanks everyone for the reviews! ( https://www.reddit.com/r/PrintedCircuitBoard/comments/1k7v7yk/review_request_ecp5_development_board/ )

My Icepi Zeros came, and they look amazing! Plus no problems found first try! (Except the leds are a bit bright but I can live with it ;p)

If anyone wants to check out the final sources it's open sources on github: https://github.com/cheyao/icepi-zero


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Jul 13 '26

[PCB Review] STM32L496ZGT6 based GSE board LoRa RS485 CAN

Thumbnail
gallery
240 Upvotes

Note: I've omitted some sheets in the post because there are too many (25 total), I've attached a link to where you can see all 25 sheets + layout. 😄

This is the main board for my team's ground support equipment system for a hybrid rocket, and may support a future liquid rocket. It is placed near the rocket, so it's called "Pad Side". Passes ERC & DRC.

6 layers: Signal - GND - PWR - Signal - GND - Signal. 1oz outer and 0.5oz inner. ENIG.

Dimensions are 145mm x 200mm

Purpose:

  • Control a separate valve power board.

  • Ingest pressure transducer, load cell, and thermocouple data.

  • Communicate with other electronics near or in the rocket with CAN bus.

  • Ignite the rocket's engine with a 12V igniter system, 15A max power path.

  • Save data to an SD card.

  • Communicate with the team over RS-485 and/or LoRa.

  • Communicate with an "interface" daughter board via a backplane connector to control additional LEDs and user input on the pad side.

Some Features:

  • Input power muxing between barrel jack or XT-60 connector.

  • TVS protection on most connectors (exceptions are debug headers and backplane connector).

  • Support for 4-pin or 3-pin pressure transducers.

  • Piezo buffer for simple audio status indication.

  • I2S connector for external audio control.

  • Load switch control for 3.3V & 5V power to SD card, Radio, and interface board.

  • USB-C 2.0 & SWD interface with STM32.

Some Notes

  • Mostly single-sided component placement to reduce assembly house cost.

  • Most if not all resistors and capacitors are the "basic" type in JLCPCB stock to further reduce cost.

    • As such, some resistors are combined in series to avoid using extended values for things like OVLO/UVLO and feedback setting.

  • LoRa RF shield is a placeholder and likely won't be used unless RF issues are encountered.


r/PrintedCircuitBoard • • Apr 09 '21

The perfect PCB reflow plate

Post image
236 Upvotes