r/preppers • u/Melodic-Conflict6405 • Apr 09 '22
The Gray Man is overhyped. Also a critique of prepper culture.
Perhaps this is an unpopular opinion but when things are a push come to shove, no amount of work for some people can't be gray.
Take one of my siblings, 6'3, skinny, and white in a predominantly black neighborhood. No amount of trying to be gray is going to allow him to be "gray" because he just is too tall and skinny and the wrong race and will always stand out. So instead of wasting any energy into something that is flat out pointless, to just go the other route and be obvious.
This brings me to my next point of what others have claimed is "good opsec" to me is just obscene opsec. Don't talk to strangers at the store, don't share any information... if you don't share any information with strangers then one can't grow but also others won't grow and if others do grow that is less trouble in your local level and thus less trouble for your group. You risk other people showing up who are starving and desperate... (Oh no.... it is called leverage them... I want those people who say they are just going to show up to my house to show up because they will get leveraged and put to work and yes, their children will be fed but they may have to clear up problems I have been having in my AO)
Bugging out: When looking at the Ukraine War, it took about two weeks in an shtf scenario for this to happen. The weak joined with the strong as those who were willing to commit violence. The weak fled and became a refugee or the weak became fertilizer. So in two weeks, you were either fertilizer, a combatant or a refugee. Being a refugee is not a good thing. You need to be able to spend time at your bug out location to get to know the locals so that you can trade and know who is who. But that means well failing to be gray somewhere or both places as the dude you are trying to portray in both areas is rarely around during certain months which also can lead to people drawing attention. (Yes, if you are in the city, you have to bug out but that should have already been done by now)
Community size: If you are prepping only for you and your immediate family. Well sorry to say this but you are a loot box. The prepper who is preparing to take in a community who has months of supplies for 50 people will take that "tacticool prepper" to help augment the firepower of the rest of the people showing up. What about things called "Acceptable Casualties" ? A minimum size of any prepper mag needs to be at least 20 or so adults. Teens in some areas can work in a pinch. You need some to watch kids, cook, clean, forage, barter, and protect, to name a few. You will get sick or others will get sick and so others need to be able to pull that weight. So yeah, acceptable losses comes to mind. If you lose 5 out of your 20 then things start breaking down and then it is easier for others to take advantage of that group.
So when the prepper who has 50 people under his belt show up knocking, yeah, the solo family prepper may get 8-10 of them if they did something head on. But now they can use your supplies to augment their own but also take in more people who were starving and thus will be loyal to the one who puts food on the table for their starving kids. The ones who are willing to do violence to others first initially are almost always the ones who set the agenda of how society will be shaped (remember all government is just force)
So chances are when the warlord or "marauder" comes knocking on my door and I haven't gotten enough people who well didn't prep in time. My goal is simple. "Negotiate to Fall in Line." This way both groups are improved and my family is now more safe not less safe.
I think the early focus on bugging out to the wilderness and being a lone wolf crowd hurt the community as mags are necessary and later a true community must form. The early settlers had two wagons minimum worth of stuff when they traveled, a bug out bag is not going to cut it. We should be now more than ever being looking to expand to add more people if possible and to take in more people who show up . Those people that show up with starving kids well the parents will be more loyal to you in the grid down scenario than any others as food is on the table for them. Sure there can be spies, but let them spy. If you are overwhelming to them it matters not since they will leave you alone or negotiate which is probably for the best as with negotiation people can all grow. if not then either fall in line or well the only other option other than running and becoming a refugee; is to be culled.
Also the people with 40-50 deep is going to check EVERY home, including the ones that "Look gray" so the idea that nothing can be in the home from the appearance that is a myth as it will be preppers who know better that are leading those groups. It is just like teaching all the kids about school shooter drills when almost all the school shooters are kids themselves so they know exactly what the response is and can plan accordingly. (A marauder and a homesteader are two different sides to the same preparedness coin. A prepper is just someone who is working towards homesteading. Both are being prepared and both are doing their best to shape society best to how they see it. Marauding isn't long term viable but the short term it can actually work to control your AO and expand your AOI.)
If your group of 100 is the only group within 20 miles of your main location then by default it is a win for your group. You can negotiate and trade with the groups who are 20-30 miles away and be able to slowly absorb new folks in who show up. The goal is to get to 300 or so to avoid drift.
I hope this post isn't against the rules, as it is just my opinion and critique. I've avoided name calling, I don't know anyone here, not looking for a fight though a dialogue is most welcoming. I'm not trolling. Yes, I am risking being down voted spam, but as a famous professor once said."In order to think, one must risk being offensive." And if the mod team feels this is unnecessary confrontation I apologize.