EDIT: for those that are down voting (apparently more than a third of the votes), i would love to know why. The point of this thread was not to be preachy or try to force an opinion on others, but to hear people's opinions. Let them be heard!
I was excited to hear that Shawn and Alan are going to revisit this topic with guests. I have encouraged my fiancé to re-read the Lord of the Rings for the first time since middle school, and we have been discussing it as she goes through. Given the state of things over the summer, race was an issue that we discussed. She commented on the problematic language that Shawn and Alan mentioned, things like slant eyed, swart, white-skins, and some of the ways in which the Easterlings and Haradrim are described.
Naturally, I tried to explain about how Tolkien was a medievalist, the time period in which it was written, etc. However, she brought up the point that I think we will hear about soon; that it is important to unpack these things from the context of the reader as well, not just from the author’s perspective (as we do with so many historical documents and other pieces of literature).
She proposed an interesting hypothetical:
She grew up writing fan-fic about another fantasy setting, and remarked that it was not uncommon for people to re-write the race of characters. When asked how I thought people would react if someone made a movie version in which Aragorn was black, I admit I was stumped. I used the argument that much of Tolkien’s work is considered canonical, and that there can really only be so much artistic liberty with the appearance of a character (imagine Gandalf with no beard and a Mohawk for example).
I recall in early episodes Shawn and Alan discussing the three rules someone proposed about changing the medium of a story (book to film) and how to make changes. They were essentially: 1) is it essential for the change in medium 2) does it change the core message of the story 3) I can’t remember this one and would love for someone to help out.
I had to ask myself; is the race (using the word the way it is used in current United States) so intrinsic to a character in the Lord of the Rings, that it is unacceptable to portray them as anything but white (thinking specifically of the Fellowship). Could there be a black elf? Could a dwarf be Asian? Again, this is in the specific context of there being a new movie/tv show, but could certainly be applied to fan art.
Looking at the suggestions about changing a book to a film, the notion of having a Black Aragorn does not change the core message of the story for me, but I have to wonder, would it for other readers?
Not looking to ‘solve a problem’ or get a definitive answer, but just to inspire general conversation.