r/prancingponypod • • Jan 16 '22

I'm sorry I just can't take it anymore

1 Upvotes

I used to really like this podcast and just tried to get past the annoying voice acting. But the gollum voice... Lads i love ye but it's just too much. I can't listen anymore sorry.


r/prancingponypod • • Feb 28 '26

I’ve been falling (through Moria) for thirty minutes- Ep 156

0 Upvotes

I just started listening last year, first with The Hobbit episodes, now with the LOTR ones. I’m up to the point where the Fellowship is in Moria and they stop to rest next to the three passages. Merry and Pippin are about to rush into the guard room before Gandalf tells them to wait. As we find out there’s a huge hole in the floor and the guys talk about how terrifying it would be to fall long enough and far enough to know you’re falling and not know when you’re going to hit bottom. I have to say I’m disappointed in the podcast at this point. Out of all the jokes and references the podcast has made they DON’t reference Loki’s “I’ve been falling for 30 minutes!” line. Seems like a total missed opportunity


r/prancingponypod • • Nov 25 '19

(OC) How much is IN that letter anyway?!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/prancingponypod • • Jun 16 '24

Real life LOTR?

0 Upvotes

I'm sorry if this has been asked before but I was scrolling across tiktok randomly and read a comment on how the siege of Gondor was actually referring to the siege of Vienna and the Osman empire when the winged riders of Poland came to the aid of Austria and turned the tide.

I know almost nothing against that history and am now completely floored...


r/prancingponypod • • Dec 21 '20

A discussion on Tolkien and Racism

78 Upvotes

EDIT: for those that are down voting (apparently more than a third of the votes), i would love to know why. The point of this thread was not to be preachy or try to force an opinion on others, but to hear people's opinions. Let them be heard!

I was excited to hear that Shawn and Alan are going to revisit this topic with guests. I have encouraged my fiancé to re-read the Lord of the Rings for the first time since middle school, and we have been discussing it as she goes through. Given the state of things over the summer, race was an issue that we discussed. She commented on the problematic language that Shawn and Alan mentioned, things like slant eyed, swart, white-skins, and some of the ways in which the Easterlings and Haradrim are described.

Naturally, I tried to explain about how Tolkien was a medievalist, the time period in which it was written, etc. However, she brought up the point that I think we will hear about soon; that it is important to unpack these things from the context of the reader as well, not just from the author’s perspective (as we do with so many historical documents and other pieces of literature).

She proposed an interesting hypothetical:

She grew up writing fan-fic about another fantasy setting, and remarked that it was not uncommon for people to re-write the race of characters. When asked how I thought people would react if someone made a movie version in which Aragorn was black, I admit I was stumped. I used the argument that much of Tolkien’s work is considered canonical, and that there can really only be so much artistic liberty with the appearance of a character (imagine Gandalf with no beard and a Mohawk for example).

I recall in early episodes Shawn and Alan discussing the three rules someone proposed about changing the medium of a story (book to film) and how to make changes. They were essentially: 1) is it essential for the change in medium 2) does it change the core message of the story 3) I can’t remember this one and would love for someone to help out.

I had to ask myself; is the race (using the word the way it is used in current United States) so intrinsic to a character in the Lord of the Rings, that it is unacceptable to portray them as anything but white (thinking specifically of the Fellowship). Could there be a black elf? Could a dwarf be Asian? Again, this is in the specific context of there being a new movie/tv show, but could certainly be applied to fan art.

Looking at the suggestions about changing a book to a film, the notion of having a Black Aragorn does not change the core message of the story for me, but I have to wonder, would it for other readers?

Not looking to ‘solve a problem’ or get a definitive answer, but just to inspire general conversation.


r/prancingponypod • • May 01 '20

Alliance

0 Upvotes

I come on behalf of r/OhnakaGang and r/ShadowCollective. We are starting a string of star wars alliances and I feel that it would be cool to expand and have a lotr sub join us as well. I feel an alliance could benefit not only our subs but yours as well. What say you


r/prancingponypod • • Jan 15 '20

Ep. 150 Elrond joke went too far

0 Upvotes

So on episode 150, PPP was making fun of Elrond for saying that he can't help Frodo and the Fellowship but saying that he would be a bad doctor you forgot one thing,

Elrond is a Doctor
and that he heald Frodo from the knife wound.

but going with the joke;

Elrond: soo, you were stabbed by a Morgul knife. I don't know if you'll live, I will try to help you, but I might not be able to save you.


r/prancingponypod • • May 18 '26

Pangea theory

0 Upvotes

I you think since Morea is at the north western point of middle earth that middle earth was sort of like Pangea


r/prancingponypod • • Sep 30 '21

Ancalagon WAS that big

16 Upvotes

I don’t remember the exact episode number, but when Alan and Shawn talked about Ëarendil slaying Ancalagon the Black, they really made an exhaustive effort to downplay the size of the dragon.

IIRC, they made Thangorodrim seem more like some piles of rubble instead of massive mountains. It is said that they were three gigantic volcanoes and the mightiest of the towers of Middle-Earth. If a dragon fell on them and they were broken in his ruin, it only makes sense that the dragon was absolutely massive and may be as big as some of the fanart makes him out to be.

I was always confused at their diminutive vision of Thangorodrim and Ancalagon.


r/prancingponypod • • Jul 13 '25

Does it get better?

21 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm starting the podcast for the first time, and I've made it up to episode 12 (All in the Family). Does the humor ever improve? I love the Tolkien talk but the jokes feel like a boomer uncle at Thanksgiving sometimes. Other times they're just a little dad-jokey, but gods help me the "hurr durr millennials" is just so played out.

Does it stay like this?


r/prancingponypod • • Jan 14 '22

How would YOU change the ranger class in D&D?

4 Upvotes

This is potentially off-topic but bear with me. I wanted to ask how this community would address the ranger class in D&D 5e and I specifically want to ask here because

  1. Alan and Shawn play D&D

  2. I think the discussion might benefit from some of the ranger's origins which I understand to be LotR's Aragorn.

I'd like to compare what I see as the ranger's struggles to the barbarian who seems to have little to do with the actual Conan the Barbarian, who is largely described as a thief/fighter multiclass. But instead of trying to be a rogue/fighter, the barb has found a home in being the class that fights harder, not smarter.

I think it would benefit D&D if it embraced the same for the ranger. I say this because in LotR, the ranger isn't even a class, it's more of a race of the Numenorians and that is NOT going to work in D&D. My question then is: would you like to see the ranger just dump the LotR influence and instead try to be something that's "ranger" in name only?


r/prancingponypod • • Jun 17 '22

A Parler ad?

52 Upvotes

Listened today and the first ad was for Parler. I know the hosts don't pick and choose the ads but I feel uncomfortable supporting a podcast that advertises for a social media space best known for magnifying misinformation about vaccines and election integrity, and providing a bullhorn for known white supremacists and insurrectionists.

I'm not gonna stop listening to the podcast yet, but it just made me feel some cognitive dissonance and I felt the need to express that here.

I doubt The Professor would approve.


r/prancingponypod • • May 26 '26

the 4th Age

0 Upvotes

who thinks there should be a 4th age movie


r/prancingponypod • • Dec 30 '19

Bad Pic but here's my LOTR collection, really proud of it!

Post image
51 Upvotes

r/prancingponypod • • Oct 04 '25

Has this podcast done a breakdown of the Rings of Power show?

4 Upvotes

I can find a smattering of pre-release discussion from early-mid 2022, but then after the show actually released in September 2022, I can't find a single mention of it...searching this sub brings up nothing, and reading the titles/descriptions of the podcast episodes around that time comes up empty. Searched their YT and I found one S2 preview discussion. I found one post about a watch party on FB but I can't find an easy way to find that except scrolling for ages.

But surely an event as big as two seasons of Rings of Power for people this steeped in Tolkien lore and LOTR love would be all over it covering it episode by episode and breaking it down, right? Are they only posted exclusively somewhere I'm not checking (Apple Podcast, Spotify, YT)?


r/prancingponypod • • Nov 06 '21

General Discussion Scrubbing the tub in November isn't pleasant, any way you look at it. BUT...! Some Johnston's Fluid Beef will cure the chills!

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/prancingponypod • • Feb 14 '22

Locally inserted ads

8 Upvotes

I just listened to an add on the PPP on Spotify promoting gambling and it left me with a bad taste in my mouth.

I am a long time listener if your amazing show, and while I fully respect the need for locally inserted adds, I think the podcast could benefit from from being a bit more selective with these adds, I know that many other podcasts I listen to do this.


r/prancingponypod • • Mar 10 '21

Balrog wings

8 Upvotes

I'm a first time reader and before getting into The Fellowship of the Ring I was already aware of the discussion on whether the Balrog in Khazad-Dûm has wings.

When I finally got to that chapter, I was confused as to why there is such a discussion, since there is an explicit reference to the Balrog's wings:

"The Balrog made no answer. The fire in it seemed to die, but the darkness grew. It stepped forward slowly on to the bridge, and suddenly it drew itself up to a great height, and its wings were spread from wall to wall*; but still Gandalf could be seen, glimmering in the gloom; he seemed small, and altogether alone: grey and bent, like a wizened tree before the onset of a storm"*

Am I missing something? Or is the discussion about ALL Balrogs (and not this especific one)?


r/prancingponypod • • Dec 08 '21

Shawn and Alan’s Sméagol/Gollum voice

5 Upvotes

I wish they would have come up with their own, new take on the voice of Sméagol, instead of seemingly trying to replicate Andy Serkis’ Sméagol.

Iirc, all Tolkien gives us in regards to hints is that Sméagol hissed and Gandalf said that he talked with snarls. The high pitch, squeaky voice done by Serkis is certainly iconic and how most of us think of Sméagol, but I would have liked to hear a new and fresh take on the voice.

Edit: spelling


r/prancingponypod • • Jun 06 '23

Favorite day of Tolkien Times?

5 Upvotes

What's been your favorite so far?

33 votes, Jun 08 '23
3 Mailbag Monday
4 Tolkien Tuesday
11 Word Nerd Wednesday
2 Third Age Thursday
4 Fandom Friday
9 Silmarillion Saturday

r/prancingponypod • • Jun 06 '23

Favorite day of Tolkien Times?

0 Upvotes

What's been your favorite so far?

10 votes, Jun 08 '23
0 Mailbag Monday
0 Tolkien Tuesday
3 Word Nerd Wednesday
0 Third Age Thursday
0 Fandom Friday
7 Silmarillion Saturday

r/prancingponypod • • Jun 08 '26

the ppp

0 Upvotes

it just aint the sane dynamic without steve


r/prancingponypod • • Oct 14 '21

Fëanor did nothing wrong

Post image
66 Upvotes

r/prancingponypod • • Apr 23 '21

If Middle-earth was set in the Star Wars universe

28 Upvotes

What would the names of the characters lightsabers be?


r/prancingponypod • • Nov 05 '25

Cutting Aldarion some slack

6 Upvotes

I felt bad for the guy, so I wrote a post. https://www.idiosophy.com/2025/11/in-defense-of-aldarion/