r/powdermage • • Jan 30 '24

F Vlora

0 Upvotes

Re-reading the first Powder Mage trilogy and find myself hating Vlora even more the second time around. Honestly I'm not sure what Brian was smoking making her a Main POV in the second trilogy.

It's pretty infuriating because I like Two-Shot, Tamas and Kaa-pol so damn much as characters wich makes me want to continue listening but want to throw my phone (audiobook) every time Vlora appears.

Anyone feels the same?


r/powdermage • • Nov 10 '24

Vlora is a bitch

0 Upvotes

I'm a little into the second book, and I read return to honor. I absolutely despise vlora's character. The stupid bitch doesn't think about Taniel at all, and he thinks about him too much. Reading return to honor just made me angry. Also, Ka-poel is actually a good person. Anyone else hate her that much or is it just me? No spoilers please


r/powdermage • • Sep 28 '24

Started reading the first book, something that bothers me...

0 Upvotes

Will the theme of "oh I know exactly what you want to know, but go talk with that other character for no apparent reason" continue? I'm only at around a third of the first book but It seems like half the story so far could have advanced faster if the characters were just saying the stuff they know and not send them down a goose chase.


r/powdermage • • Apr 13 '22

Am i the only one who can't stand Poel ? (spoilers all) Spoiler

5 Upvotes

This isn't about her character as a whole, more her role in the story. We don't really know her Motivations or viewpoint, she's with Taniel because she just kinda tagged along, but still solves basically all problems in the series. It just kind of annoyed me, because she seemed more like a plot device then a character and I'd be more interested in characters whose arks were actually part of to do the solving.


r/powdermage • • Sep 07 '24

Is Adro based on Mordor ?

4 Upvotes

Just seen a map of Mordor after listening to the powdermage audiobooks and realised there are some uncanny similarities.

Both countries are encircled by high mountains, with a few well guarded mountain passes

Both feature large inland seas

Both are highly industrialised compared to their immediate neighbours

I think i’m right in saying the author was one of BrandoSando’s students who’s mistborn series was inspired by “what if frodo/sam had kept the ring for himself”. What if the powdermage series is inspired by “LOTR from Modors perspective”? 🤔


r/powdermage • • May 04 '21

Entice a skeptic like me into reading

5 Upvotes

Okay so I’m going to be honest, I was only interested at first because of the beautiful covers, especially Promise’s.

But now I want to actually ask about getting into it. WITHOUT SPOILERS, what are the reasons I should get into it? The multiple nations storyline gives me the impression of Song of Ice and Fire which I love, I also love genre bending as it keeps things fresh. But I want more to entice me!

Also, if I decide to read, what reading order should I follow? Chrono, realease, or is there a first timer?


r/powdermage • • Sep 28 '18

Will Taniel end up with Vlora?

1 Upvotes

Am I the only one who still desperately wants Taniel and Vlora to end up together in the end?


r/powdermage • • Aug 24 '26

What on gods green earth is a dragoon??

6 Upvotes

No seriously it bothers me every read. And there is not a single description in the book. Someone put me out my misery


r/powdermage • • Jul 06 '20

Should’ve posted this here.

Thumbnail self.fantasy
3 Upvotes

r/powdermage • • Dec 22 '23

Does it get better after book 1?

0 Upvotes

book 1 was okay. How is the rest of the series compared to the first book. Is the first one the weakest or best?


r/powdermage • • Aug 08 '24

First time reader questions

2 Upvotes

So reading the first few chapters of "Promise of Blood" and it seems fairly barbaric. Does this series maintain this tone throughout all the books? Namely, I was put off by Taniel instigating the mass rapes of noble daughters by redirecting the riots, and the very first scene from a woman's perspective she was about to be raped herself.

So is this a consistent pattern that I should be leery of or is it all over after this?

-Edit- Thanks to the comments here I put the introduction aside and kept on listening to the audiobooks. I've thoroughly enjoyed this series and found myself invested! I'm now starting on "Sins of Empire" after wrapping up the original trilogy and I look forward to the rest.

My only quip aside from the previously mentioned SA was how Investigator Adamant always dug up the clues moments before they would have revealed themselves to everyone anyway with the exception maybe one or two cases. Despite that his story as well as Nila's were my favorite arcs to listen to.


r/powdermage • • Apr 25 '20

Nila and vlora. One of the greatest things ever

7 Upvotes

r/powdermage • • Aug 10 '17

Reading "Sins of Empire" (Brian McClellan) but find it hard to find motivation to finish it. [Heavy spoilers] Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I read and liked the Blackpowder Mage trilogy a whole lot, so I was excited to pick this "fourth" one up. I'm roughly 70% into the book, I think? A lot has happened, but...

Dang, I just can't seem to give a damn about any of it. I've spent the last hour or so trying to collect my thoughts on the matter, and I'll try to put them into words here. I'm sorry if it's a bit of a rant, I've really tried to condense it. Believe me!


  • Vlora

I think the biggest glaring issue for me is Vlora. She's supposed to be this hardened General that has been through decades of battle, countless campaigns yet she regularly reverts to an emotional teenager and throws tantrums when things don't go her way. I had expected her to evolve into a more cunning, calculating person. Instead, her decisions are driven by random impulse.

She has spent 10+ years with Olem as lover and partner, yet she can't get over Taniel Goody-two shoes. When Vlora meets him, she just becomes so... childish. I feel sorry for Olem.

The fleet shows up, and she assumes the mantle of defender of Fortrasta. Why? There's no reason to. You've already been paid, and generously. You've got no stake in this fight- none at all. What's more, your men are tired and want home. Third, you're going to defend a city in which a large part of the population hates you and regularly murders your troops (this is before she finds out about the godstone). '

If that wasn't enough, she has just arrested Lindet. What's the long term plan here? You arrested the one who pays you. Your last 'ally'. Now a chunk of the population and the government wants you dead. This isn't viable, in the slightest. You think the Blackhats will obey you? "I don't want to get involved politics" she says and then fucking dives straight into it.

She's not compelling in the slightest because she doesn't feel like a real person to me. Note that I'm fine with flawed characters, of course! That's what I like! But her character doesn't make sense to me. It was fine when she was a minor player in the trilogy, where her main trait was "I'm Taniels ex, grr, people are mad I cheated on him!". It's a pity to see she really hasn't developed further than that.

  • Styke

Styke was interesting for a while because he was a has-been with flaws and doubts. Turns out he's not though, and he never suffers any consequences for his rash actions. What's the point of building up the Dragonmen throughout the book if this old cripple can take one out 1 on 1? He even goes to challenge that freaking Commander, gets his ass beat...

only to be shipped back to the camp, which he promptly escapes from again. So I guess that mattered nothing. His old friend the smith survives too, so that didn't matter either. All the Mad Lancers are back and they're all happy to see him after 20 years despite them (and their loved ones/lifes works) getting trashed due to his inability to keep his nose out of others business.

What's the point of his knack anyway? It never comes into play in any real sense as far as I can tell. Might as well skip it entirely, or build the plot a bit more around it (like Addamat!) or give him a different knack.

  • Taniel and Kapoel

Taniel and Kapoel are back, and they're just as untouchable/invincible as ever. I thought Tempo was a fascinating new character, mysterious and everything! Turns out it's just Taniel, the cardboard cutout of a classic gary stu protagonist. He was probably my least favorite character in the prior books due to how good he is at everything and his constant complaining. What's cooler than killing one mythical Dragonman, you say? Well, killing two without breaking a sweat. Goodness how cool he is. These Dragonmen sure are scary. Of course, Kapoel is there with her deux ex magic that is so good no other magic can measure up to it. The stakes are high!

  • Michael Bravis

Was one of my favorite characters for a good amount into the book because I thought he was there to add ambivalence to the Blackhats, show the reader that it's not all black and white. Put someone on the side of the 'bad' guys to give their perspective, and eventually have him clash with the other characters of the book in a game of cat and mouse!

Nah, turns out he actually hates the Blackhats and he has a hidden persona he can hide so well it completely disappears, only to be brought out when convenient! So much for that dynamic. But wait, maybe his many years as a Blackhat has given him second thoughts? Maybe he has come to see their side of things, to see their worth? Maybe reverting back to hid old self isn't as easy as taking off a ha-

Oh. Wait. It is. Blackhat persona of half a decade instantly discarded with minimal fuzz. But wait! He's discovered to be a traitor, and his own reckless behaviour might just have gotten his mother killed...! No, she lives and she's overjoyed. No consequences there either, nothing to drive a character. He's just some vague revolutionary.


There's... so much more that bothers me, so many seeming plotholes or leaps of logic that I just can't wrap my head around. Like when Taniel tells Bravis "Fidelis Jes probably didn't tell anyone you're a spy, you're good to go!". Why wouldn't he? To "save face"? Uh, all Fidelis has to say is "I promoted him to let expose his true motivaitons" and presto, it's not a blunder but a clever plan. "Fidelis has more important things to do", Taniel says thereafter. "Not chasing you!". But Taniel, Fidelis things Bravis is a spy for the enemy fleet, he HAS to be a top target?

Ah fuck. I wrote a lot. It felt great to get it off my shoulders, even if no one bothers to read it all. I'm just so surprised and disappointed in this installment because I went into it with high hopes, and it turns out that it's a book with no stakes, nothing at risk, with a plot that is driven by shortsighted, narrow logical leaps by blundering main characters.

Does it get better? Is there some twist, or some other happening that ties it all together at the end? Or does it continue in the same, stumbling fashion?


r/powdermage • • Jan 18 '22

Powder Mage live action casting

9 Upvotes

My coworker and I are reading through the series together (I'm on Wrath of Empire and he's on The Autumn Republic) and we've been spending some of the workday today trying to come up with casting we'd like to see if the series does get the live action adaptation. So far we have:

Tamas - Ron Perlman

Taniel - Brenton Thwaites (Dick Grayson on Titans)

Vlora - Keira Knightley

Mihali - Jack Black

Lord Claremont - Ethan Hawke

SouSmith - Rory McCann (The Hound on GoT)

Olem - I always picture him as Davos from GoT, but Liam Cunningham is way too old, so I'm not sure. But he'd be perfect if he was 30 years younger.

That's all we've got so far, but it's a fun and ongoing game, so I'm sure we'll think of more. Not sure if this has been discussed before (it probably has), but if anyone has other casting ideas, we'd love to hear them!


r/powdermage • • Jan 07 '22

Is this really a hard magic system? and does the series improve with it?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/powdermage • • Aug 05 '20

Inspiration for the idea of powder mages revealed

2 Upvotes

r/powdermage • • Mar 19 '26

Not a fan of this line from Nila’s POV Spoiler

0 Upvotes

“Only he could match someone like Field Marshal Tamas in strategic maneuvering”

Doesn’t sound like the thoughts of a commoner washerwoman.


r/powdermage • • Feb 18 '15

Just finished TAR, did he kick up the amount of women?

0 Upvotes

So I just finished, loved the book, but I got this feeling that there were a lot more women. I always had the feeling that egalitarianism in the army and such was a relatively new thing in universe, and I could swear they had mentioned women being rare before, but it seems that whenever they mentioned a character in the army this book it was a new woman.

I don't know, I don't want to say I mind it, but I was very confused and it got a bit distracting because I suddenly had to reevaluate the setting. Am I just seeing things?


r/powdermage • • Mar 13 '17

Vlora ?

1 Upvotes

Vlora has no honor. She thinks only in the short term and has been tricked many times. I do not believe she is a good leader, she care more about her her image then doing the right thing.


r/powdermage • • Nov 13 '20

Question/s about tactics and strategy

12 Upvotes

Ok, I don’t wanna come off as unduly hating on the powder mage books. Personally I am not the biggest fan of the books, but they have their moments now and then. But I had a question about Tamas’ strategy in The Crimson Campaign when he fought the Cavalry under Beon Je Ipille (I think that’s his name). Why. In the name of God. Did he not just form Square? For context, I read The Shadow Campaigns series by Django Wexler which is now one of my favourite book series I have ever read, I am studying history at university, and am also a huge history nerd in general, especially for the Napoleonic Era. So in the Crimson Campaign, Tamas is with the Seventh and Ninth Brigades, he has a couple powder mages, and whatever handful of Cavalry he had after he got seperated outside of Budwiel (Its been awhile since I’ve read it so apologies if I get anything wrong). Say, 10 000 soldiers. Iirc, he was facing something like 13-15 000 Kez cavalry who were pursuing them. He comes up with some big convoluted plan instead of going the obvious route of having his men form squares to repel any charges. Tamas is supposed to be a military genius, yet he doesn’t go for the most basic anti-cavalry (for lack of a better word) tactic of the time. The entire time I read this part I was thinking “Form square! FORM SQUARE!” But he doesn’t. For those who don’t know, square formation was used to repel cavalry charges. When a unit was threatened by mounted enemies, they would form a square with fixed bayonets, and present a ring of steel and musket-fire to the enemy that was mostly impenetrable. No horse is going to charge home against a wall of bristling bayonets. That’s how Wellington beat Marshal Ney’s charge/s at Waterloo. To compare to a moment in the Shadow Campaigns (SPOILERS for the Shadow Campaigns): Winter Ihernglass and her company of raw recruits are scouting when they see a horde of Redeemer cavalry rushing towards them. Despite not being trained in forming company square, Winter gets some of her men to form up, and they survive the attack, as the main force passes them by and gets slaughtered by the main Vordanai force (also in square formation btw). My point is, if newly promoted sergeant Winter Ihernglass, with basically a half-company of terrified, green recruits can stand off thousands of screaming mounted fanatics, Tamas should be able to with two of the best brigades in the most advanced and disciplined army in The Nine. Just have the Adran brigades march forward, all calm and collected. And then when the Kez see they are unprepared and make to charge, form square in the required time. The Adrans are supposed to be incredible soldiers so they should be able to form up pretty fast. This brings me to another point, a counter argument might be that, “oh well the Kez cavalry could just circle around them and pick them off from afar”. No they couldn’t. The Kez cavalry would mostly be armed with carbines, if they had firearms at all. And carbines have a much shorter effective range than muskets or rifles (I say “or” because McLellan seems to use Muskets and Rifles interchangeably for some reason). So the Adrans would outrange the Kez if they did this. Tamas is a military genius, supposedly, but he makes a lot of nonsensical decisions. No offence to the book, but a lot of the tactics and war stuff really isn’t that good: During the Crimson Campaign after the retreat from Budwiel, the ultra disciplined Adrans can’t hold a fortified position against the mindless, stupid horde of Kez? And they also seem to only build one earthwork at a time too, matching the pace of the Kez assaults. Later in the next book at Neds Creek the Adrans send in cavalry at the start? Why? Cavalry charges are supposed to be a coup de grâce. And why were the Wings of Adom so scared when they think the adran lancers are going to attack them? They’re in a fortified camp, I’m sure they’ll be safe against a cavalry charge. Back to the crimson campaign, The Adrans are defending Budwiel? It’s a medieval wall, good luck, better dig some trenches or something, the Kez artillery should reduce that to rubble in a matter of hours (sorcery could explain a lot of things I suppose, but still). Wardens have existed for a while now, why is their no hard counter for them? Why does Taniel, when he is hunkered behind the earthworks in the Crimson campaign grimly state “volley fire” when the Kez are attacking as if it’s some special trick. It’s the main tactic of the time! In the first book, when they talk about fighting the royalists, why do they talk about “shelling”? Shrapnel and explosive “shells” weren’t invented yet iirc. Most of all, why does McLellan talk about rifles and muskets and use those two words interchangeably? Ok, that’s my two cents, if anyone wants to discuss this that would be great. If I’m wrong about anything feel free to correct me. I don’t want to sound too mean about this series, I really enjoyed certain parts of the books.


r/powdermage • • Dec 01 '25

Ben Styke Casting

9 Upvotes

How do we feel about Dolph Lundgren playing a live action Ben Styke? Quite a bit older than Ben, but the age could play into Ben’s broken and scarred look.

Square jawed and gruff looking I think he fits the look pretty well. Matches the imposing height too.


r/powdermage • • Nov 01 '22

not wearing gloves. Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Why doesn't the launderess not wear gloves? It would point her out as a privileged and would keep her ability to touch the else without gloves a secret.

I'm surprised this wasn't even mentioned so far.


r/powdermage • • Feb 17 '24

No comeuppance Spoiler

7 Upvotes

I love the powder mage books but the series has a few plot lines that aren't completely taken to a "satisfactory end" and some serious lack of comeuppance.

Without spoiling to much, everything from major antagonists to traitors kinda just get away with it. Don't get me wrong I'm not saying that this ruining the story or anything it always has the cover of more important stuff is going down, but it still feels a bit unfulfilling.


r/powdermage • • May 22 '25

Half way through Crimson Campaign &…

18 Upvotes

Be NICE to Vlora, Tamas! Ass.

Edit: Let my girl have some FUN!