Many of us are wondering this. Between the poll going on, and the debate about X11, things are heated, and surely lots of us are wondering what potential effects this could have on the supply/demand for our coin. In the next few paragraphs, I aim to provide some insight as to the most likely outcomes if we stay scrypt, the the most likely outcome if we fork.
If we stay scrypt: This would obviously be the most convenient thing to do, and the easiest in the short term. However, if we do this, we must be sure to account for the fact that our gpu's will be forced to compete against the asic network.
Look at it like this: Very few people have bought asics for the purpose of mining potcoin and holding for the long run. Must of the people who bought asic have one thing on their mind: Return on investment. And I'll be honest, if I pre ordered an asic, I would be thinking the same way, no shame on asic owners for wanting ROI ASAP. Short term return on investment means mining whichever coin is currently most profitable, and then immediately dumping for bitcoin, and then trading for U.S. dollars.
Ok, so it's understood we have ASIC owners mining and dumping for short term return on investment, and that this will increase exponentially. How does this affect our coin?
WITH A WAVE OF ASIC POWER ON OUR COIN, THERE WILL BE A WAVE OF COINS BEING DUMPED BY ASIC MINERS WHO NEED SHORT TERM RETURN ON INVESTMENT. This will constitute an increase in supply, but there will not be an increase in demand to match it (Just because people started mining more of a certain coin, doesn't necessarily mean that people will want to BUY more too...) Thus, the price will have to lower in order to reach equilibrium price. Wealth will be taken out of potcoin, and moved back into bitcoin.
Here is my assessment of what will happen to the price if we switch to X11:
First, one must reasonably estimate the percentage of ASIC power which is on the scrypt network. Given that it is a known fact that scrypt asic companies are "testing" their scrypt asics to death before dumping them on the market for a high price (which was prepaid 6 months before, when the diff was 1/8 of what it is now, lol, suckers), we can reasonably assume ASIC makes up a large portion of the scrypt network. This information, coupled with the fact that the network difficulty has recently been increasing at an insane exponential rate, I have come to the conservative estimate that ASIC power makes up 40% of the scrypt network.
Ok: Cool, there is a lot of asic power mining and dumping our coin. What does that mean for us?
This means that if we switch to X11, we as GPU miners and CPU miners can take back the network which was once in our control, the control of the people. Marijuana legalization is modeled after fairness and decentralization, and putting power back into the hands of the masses, verses the hands of the few. Our coin should follow suit.
Ok, get to the point, what does this mean for the price of the coin?
While some of us here are into potcoin for the short term, most of us here are not pump and dumpers, and most of us are holding long term. If we eliminate ASIC power from the network, most of the coins mined will go to the hands of the holders, not the dumpers. Furthermore, without ASIC power in the network, we will mine fewer coins everyday. Pursuant to the point I made previously: JUST BECAUSE WE ARE MINING FEWER COINS, DOES NOT MEAN FEWER PEOPLE WILL WANT TO BUY THEM. The demand will be the same, but the amount of coins being produced will be lesser, so in order for equilibrium price to be reached, the price must RAISE.
So not only would the price raise, but our coin would become more rare as well, and it would be more fairly distributed because people will be able to mine it on standard computers, and there won't be ASIC's interfering with our supply/demand curve because they need to get ROI.