all reviews @ substack, link in bio!
The Earth Is Not a Cold Dead Place
Explosions In the Sky (2003)
I’ll just say it: this is probably going to be a pretty short review. It’s less about how good the music is, but more about the nature of it. Explosions In the Sky, almost infamously, feature very little unique instruments. Their cast features drums, bass, and several guitars, but rarely any more. Their soundscapes revolve around densely layered and textured guitar melodies, not necessarily the instrumentation that we see from other post-rock acts like Godspeed You! Black Emperor and Swans. And because so much of my reviews are talking about lyrics and talking about instrumentation, naturally there’ll be less to say about The Earth Is Not a Cold Dead Place. Despite its simplicity, though, it earned its place amongst the post-rock greats, commonly cited as post-rock royalty, and one of the pioneering records of the genre.
There seems to be two sides of the post-rock fanbase. The first side are the normal people, the people who realize that not everyone can make an album like Godspeed You! Black Emperor. They accept everything on the wide range of post-rock, because it’s such a unique genre. Every approach to it is interesting in its own way. The other side are the elitists. They believe that there’s a “right way” to approach the genre. They hear albums like Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas to Heaven, Spiderland, and Laughing Stock, and believe that those albums do post-rock correctly. That there are no other valid approaches to the genre. And yes, those albums are incredible. There’s no understatement the impact they had on music as a whole. But to disregard the vast majority of a genre for taking a different approach is ridiculous.
What I find great about this album is its emotion, and how much it’s able to do with so little. It’s able to paint such vivid imagery between its titles and how the music sounds. It’s difficult to make a song evoke a specific emotion, without having any lyrics or unique instrumentation. Yet, every single song on The Earth Is Not a Cold Dead Place evokes a different emotion. Between the awakening sensation on “First Breath After Coma,” to the triumphant, hopeful e-bows on “Your Hand in Mine,” this album is a full journey.
“First Breath After Coma” begins with a single, ringing guitar. It’s accompanied by a bass drum, giving a heartbeat-like rhythm. When the bass and other guitars come in, it creates such a unique soundscape. All the melodic elements throughout The Earth Is Not a Cold Dead Place reside in the guitars, so naturally the guitarwork here is immaculate. Even just the ringing guitar from the beginning continues into the main song, giving an incredible textural bonus. I’m also a sucker for the guitar texture in this whole album, it’s so clean and smooth. Honestly, this song feels exactly as advertised; a first breath after a coma. It’s a refreshing, awakening song that feels like watching the sunrise on a cold summer morning.
I do believe there is some criticism to be had of the drumming on the whole album. Most of their drum beats sound pretty similar, especially with the repeating drumrolls and the heavy snare drum sounds. But I don’t think that’s really a big enough issue for me to take away from the songs individually. The snare rolls work in each of the songs, they just get a little worn out after listening to the entire album.
Regardless, “First Breath After Coma” takes a pretty big turn after the first half. It uses a much more bass-driven beat, with mostly atmospheric guitars and sleigh bells. This section of the song is even more atmospheric than the last. If the first half of the song was waking from the coma, this half is settling back into your life. I wonder what it’d feel like to jump back into my life after missing years of it. Catching up on everything that’s changed, what all my friends have been doing for all this time. When the distorted guitars come in, it introduces a little bit of another element. An anger, of sorts, of missing so much time. You’re grateful you woke up at all, but you could’ve just… not been in a coma.
“The Only Moment We Were Alone” is a ten-minute epic. It’s a pretty common thing to start with a droning guitar at the start. But the layers that are added to the song soon after make all the difference. The little riff that the high guitar plays, in addition to the wavering lower guitar is such a nice contrast. And when the song moves, everything moves in tandem. Explosions In the Sky must be such a great band to play in. Everyone is locked in the same groove, and everyone knows and plays off one another. It seems like a great band dynamic. When the rest of the drums come in, the song transforms completely. It keeps the same cast of instruments, but sounds completely different. The lush cymbals and snare drums add so much to the groove.
Thematically, “The Only Moment We Were Alone” is as hopeful as it gets. It makes me picture two young lovers, finally finding the time in the day where they can be together uninterrupted. They share the same night sky, looking at the stars together. It’s funny how even the most mundane tasks can become the highlight of your day, depending on who you do it with. Spending time with your partner beats doing drugs every single time. Now, doing drugs with your partner? Now we’re talking (I’m joking, I’ve never had a partner nor have I done drugs).
The Earth Is Not a Cold Dead Place sort of kickstarted a whole new phase in post-rock. People usually divide the genre into different “waves,” with Talk Talk, Slint, and Swans pioneering the first wave, followed by Godspeed You! Black Emperor and Sigur Rós, and eventually leading to Explosions and the Sky and everyone else. They initially popularized the “crescendocore” subgenre, which is the part of post-rock that the elitists hate. Of course, there’s a lot of bad crescendocore. There are artists who literally just increase the volume for the epic moments, and diminuendo for softer, more intimate moments. Explosions in the Sky is not one of them. Their buildups, while not as layered and intricate as Godspeed, for instance, are incredible. Besides, I don’t think anyone else on Earth can do what Godspeed does.
“The Only Moment We Were Alone” transitions directly into the next track, “Six Days At the Bottom of the Ocean.” The album takes a bit of a darker turn here. While the first two tracks were full of hope and truly beautiful moments, “Six Days At the Bottom of the Ocean” feels anxious and dark. A dam that’s ready to break at any moment. The repetitive, droning guitars build tension seamlessly, until the whole thing’s ready to fall apart. As the song explodes into its “chorus,” the cymbals and the drums in general do an amazing job at getting the point across.
“Six Days At the Bottom of the Ocean” was written in response to the Kursk submarine disaster. The Kursk was a Russian submarine that sank in an accident, resulting in over a hundred deaths across the entire submarine. This song perfectly gets across the claustrophobic and quiet panic that the survivors of the initial explosion must’ve felt. To be trapped hundreds of feet underwater, resting on the ocean floor in an already delicate piece of technology. It portrays the little sliver of hope that everyone can’t help but feeling when faced with the worst of circumstances. Unfortunately for the crew of the Kursk, that hope was to no avail.
“Your Hand In Mine” is the most well known song on the album. It offers a hopeful, triumphant ending to The Earth Is Not a Cold Dead Place. In fact, I believe it’s a direct response to the album’s title. The Earth isn’t a cold, dead place, because I’m here with you.
The song itself features a delicately and intricately woven cast of guitars. There’s only so much you can do with a guitar (it’s a lot, have you listened to shoegaze?). But when you combine two, there’s so much more you can do. “Your Hand in Mine” features the interweaving of several guitars, much like the interweaving of two people’s lives. Once they learn how to love each other, both of their lives become so much more.
I think the song feels like climbing up every mountain in your path. Every challenge the world throws at you, you respond with a solution. You feel like you could climb Mount Everest. And one day, you’ll look back on all that you’ve done. Everything you’ve accomplished in your eighty years of life. You turn around, looking down at the mountain you’ve summited. And remarkably, through all that, you did it together. With the person that matters to you more than the universe. It’s the beautiful part of life. Just don’t give up before you get there.
First Breath After Coma: 87/100
The Only Moment We Were Alone: 84/100
Six Days At the Bottom of the Ocean: 88/100
Memorial: 79/100
Your Hand In Mine: 91/100
Overall: 82/100