743
u/genericmario
2d ago
•
i like the fogginess of the before. that gets lost in the high contrast of the afterย
106
37
u/Even-Assist6414 2d ago
As an Australian, the pre feels authentic like waking at 6am on a foggy morning. I can feel the cold of the water in the air and know it'll start steaming off the grass when the sun rises. The post feels like a bush fire and makes me very nervous, not in a way that I want to keep looking.
My question is, why not correct the horizon line first?
6
u/eienOwO 2d ago
The vertical posts suggest it is horizontal, it's a hill...
2
u/Even-Assist6414 2d ago
Ah you're right. In which case that's a nice tension that caught me off guard. To the point I'm trying to correct it.ย
2
u/Lilien_de 2d ago
Don't give up so quickly, my first and lasting impression is also that the photo is crooked. ๐
0
u/Lilien_de 2d ago
I would use the taller masts as a reference, and they tell a different story, on top of that, the rear tree also looks crooked.
1
u/eienOwO 2d ago
If you zoom in the trees to align with your screen edge they're all vertical, likewise draw a guide in Photoshop etc.
OP feel free to wade in to solve our conundrum :)
0
u/Lilien_de 1d ago
I live in a part of the world where strong winds from a prevailing direction are common, so trees here often grow crooked, and I donโt really trust them to help frame a photo. To me, itโs more likely that the workers who installed the utility poles for the power lines werenโt drunk at the time. ๐
3
4
1
u/mongini12 1d ago
in fact, I'd even double down on the haze and make it even a tiny bit stronger, add a vignette and try to improve the blue of the sky and add some blue on the ground for perfect color contrast...
132
45
45
u/JustGr8Ful 2d ago
The original version needs very little if anything. The processed version is overdone. It is your photo, and whatever way you want to view it is your choice, but please straighten the horizon. Great shot!
304
108
u/WolfRelic 2d ago
Before was way better
4
u/WolfRelic 2d ago
I'd crop it to get rid of some of the left side, and the pole, and only lightly retouch
23
u/zuulbe 2d ago
-3
u/sub_doesnt_exist_bot 2d ago
The subreddit r/shittyher does not exist.
Did you mean?:
r/shittyHDR (subscribers: 67,914)
r/ShittyPoetry (restricted, subscribers: 19,285)
r/ShittyHeroinBot (subscribers: 145)
r/shittyarma (subscribers: 27)
Consider creating a new subreddit r/shittyher.
๐ค ๐๐ท๐ธ๐ ๐ฒ๐พ๐ผ๐ผ๐ด๐ฝ๐ ๐๐ฐ๐ ๐๐๐ธ๐๐๐ด๐ฝ ๐ฑ๐ ๐ฐ ๐ฑ๐พ๐. ๐ฑ๐ด๐ด๐ฟ ๐ฑ๐พ๐พ๐ฟ ๐ค
18
u/TheKingMonkey 2d ago
Before looks like a nice foggy winter morning.
After looks like what Sarah Connor was worried would happen on August 29th 1997.
35
u/angedefensif
2d ago
edited 2d ago
•
So I looked at your other edits, OP. It seems like you think post processing is just โMORE CONTRASTโ and thatโs just not the right way of going about it.
Some photos can use more contrast and some donโt. Stop applying the same filter to every photo.
In this case, your overdone contrast completely killed the atmospheric, almost pastel like warmth and haziness of the original pic.
Holy crap talk about a downgrade.
16
15
15
u/strouze 2d ago
Have you ever tried to print a picture you edited? Those vibrant colours look like they won't translate well to non self illuminating surfaces. I usually grade for paper print to prevent me from going "overboard" also editing a picture on multiple days helps to reach a state of post "post" clarity before your post.
I think loosing the fog and increasing the contrast so much is taking something away from the picture that made it unique in the first place. I'm talking about the mood introduced by the lack of contrast due to the fog.
If your goal was to increase clarity and contrast to the scene then you achieved it. If it was your intention I'd like to hear why to get a better understanding of your vision.
4
u/GayRacoon69 2d ago edited 2d ago
100% agree with taking a few days to edit. Even just taking a break for like an hour can help
It's way too tempting to keep trying to improve your photo but you reach a point where you stop seeing your edits as "improvements" and the modified version becomes the base image you're editing. You just become so used to the edited version that at some point you're not editing the photo you took; you're just editing an edit of that. I think it's really important to take a step back and keep looking at the original photo. I like to focus on what drew me to that photo in the first place and do as little as possible to highlight whatever it is in the photo that drew my interest. When you're editing an edit you can't really do that. You just keep adding "improvements" because you want to keep working on it. The original photo gets lost. And it's very easy for those "improvements" to stack until they themselves are what draws your attention instead of whatever it is that made you want to take that photo in the first place
As for how this applies to this photo:
I think the interesting things about the before are mostly the slight fog and the path leading you towards the sun. The after hides the fog and makes the path too dark. The path no longer draws your eye in towards the hazy sunset. When I look at the after I just see a sunset and then notice the path. The bright sunset draws all your attention and the dark ground becomes almost secondary rather than an integral part of the photo
3
1
u/theyseemeeggroll 2d ago
Newbie here, how do you grade for print, please?
2
u/strouze 2d ago
Look for soft proofing and icc profiles in light room
https://www.saal-digital.eu/service/professional-zone/softproof-and-icc-profile/
And only pay somone to print your pictures that offers you workflow instructions icc profiles and similar things
Last but not least getting a spyder or a similar device to calibrate your monitor is important. While it is not only about the colour accuracy I think the biggest improvement is setting the monitor brightness correctly. You don't need to buy an expensive monitor that enables hardware calibration but 150ish dollar/euros to enable software calibration is a good investment if you think about how much money you pay for lenses and or other equipment.
1
2
u/SedentorySensor77 1d ago
The easy way is to test print. Small proof prints. Then change to correct/taste.
41
14
36
12
6
5
u/Bresson91 2d ago
If the first one was before, you nailed it... Then ruined it with over processing. Number one is great! Number two, destined for the trash.
5
u/dadarknight 2d ago
Is it just me, or does every other person prefer the original? I love the mist, which has been taken away, and the sky looks so artificial.
5
5
4
4
4
6
u/No-Explorer-4381 2d ago
This takes me back to 2010 Instagram photos of sunsets with the saturation turned up and temperature too ๐คฃ
1
3
u/dexhamster 2d ago
Yeah no. Good base photo but WAY overtuned in the edit. I would crop and maybe increase contrast by like 5-10% with curves but thats it.
3
3
3
u/dadarknight 2d ago
The original picture is stunning, and probably all it needed was just some foreground enhancement, then leave the rest alone.
3
3
u/RennieAsh 2d ago
I edited this to how I would usually fiddle with photos. Mainly to replicate what I think I saw in the moment. In this case it's just using past sunset sunrise experiences. Sorry it's a "video" since there's no image option here
I do sometimes like to bump up the colours heaps. In this case, the dehaze positive introduces new colours that aren't so enticing; so in this photo it's actually -16
2
7
u/ShovelKing3 2d ago
Looks ai in the fix to me. Itโs got a cool intensity but I like fogginess in the before.
7
u/Illustrious_Win_481 2d ago
*sigh*
Always the case with this sub, unfortunately. The after is always overcooked, oversaturated, overly contrasty, overly warm. Idk what kind of screens y'all are editing these on.
1
2
u/Historical-Brick-823 2d ago edited 2d ago
So much detail gets lost on the edit. If I was editing this shot I would be looking to enhance the fog slightly, by making the fog a little whiter/brighter and adding blue/cool saturation to the road. And straighten the horizon. Thats it. Itโs a great shot, it doesnโt need heavy handed editing ๐
2
u/mzzchief 2d ago
Love all the soft hazy pastels of the first photo. It gives a very peaceful dreamy feeling. The charm of this photo is in all those delicate subtle colors.
Second photo โฆ all that is gone. Itโs just an ordinary sunset. Darkened earth under a garish sky.
2
2
2
2
2
u/ModernAtomX 2d ago
Instead of whining that I don't like it like everyone else in this thread, I'm going to explain my perception of the technical pros and cons of this photo.
The foreground is ignored in favor of the far more impressive sunset. This is generally not great with respect to the fundamental principles of photography. You should try to have a foreground, midground and background if possible. This could be fixed with cropping the photo to remove the foreground to great effect, or, the colors of the edit could be changed to re-include the foreground
The rolloff of the saturation seems good, but it is not going to be loved by this type of crowd specifically because it resembles noob level slider maxing. The halo in the sky does exist in the original photo, but it does have color banding artifacts in the edit. This specifically is a bad mistake and should tell you that the edit needs to change in some way to reduce the color artifacting at the top of the image. This type of look and effect is also commonly caused by overdoing the dehazer, so if you're doing that, don't.
I went ahead and made an edit trying to replicate the dramatic look you're going for, but keeping it a little calmer: https://imgur.com/a/zwkJh28
Tldr: keep the foreground or crop it out. Color banding is a bad mistake. And everyone in this sub whines and offers very little, so don't let it get you down.
1
u/yoovi4u2 2d ago
Where is the colour banding that you're talking about, in the edit ? The blownout portion of the cloud ?
1
u/ModernAtomX 2d ago
Good question. I actually think you're right that it's not color banding, but I was talking about the green band artifact caused between the fog layer and the sky.
I'm not sure what you'd call other than messed up
2
1
u/Appropriate_Canary26 2d ago
I really like the before. The after is something Iโll scroll past.
The only edit needed is a slight rotation to straighten the horizon, and maybe subtly recover some highlights in the cloud.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Leicaleica1959 2d ago
Correct the horizon on the first one then leave it alone. The second is totally over the top, way too much contrast and saturation, no shadow detail left, completely lost the mood of the original, which I really like.
1
u/No-Sir1833 2d ago
You crushed the atmospherics with a contrast slider. Use the original and crop some of the road out of the foreground.
1
1
1
1
u/Icharectus 2d ago edited 2d ago
I am noticing other comments saying that the original looks better and should be kept the way it is, however, I disagree. The original photo although good, it currently a bit too uniform and is lacking depth. I would bring out the contrast in the trees ever so slightly in the background to give a sense of layered depth. (Make them slightly darker to match the fence)ย This will also connect the leading lines of the already dark fences along the road significantly improving the visual flow and composition in the process.ย
(Just don't do it to the extent in the original post-procress)ย
1
u/FatRufus 2d ago
Nooooooooo no no no no no. Before looks a million times better. I work HARD to get fog like that. I set my alarm, I read the weather reports, I setup and take shots every few minutes as the fog morphs and changes before my eyes so I can find the absolute best moment. You sir had that all in the palm of your hand and just pissed it away
1
u/jUST_rUSH 2d ago
I love my dark contrasty edits, but the original had so much going for it that's lost here. Even if you wanna go heavy handed, I think you should lean into what it has to begin with.
1
u/Photo_Jedi 2d ago
A little too much. The before seems beautiful with the pastels. I think a subtle adjustment to the contrast and a slight increase to the vibrance.
1
u/Realistic_Article812 2d ago
The before has a beautiful feeling, which you've then completely discarded with the after
1
u/idk_what_to_put_lmao 2d ago
I like that the colours are more saturated in the edit, but it's overblown and oversharpened
1
1
1
u/Natwanda 2d ago
To be honest I really love both. Where was this taken, and around what time? Gorgeous.
1
u/i_sing_anyway 2d ago
I really like the before. You could slightly increase contrast or slightly drop blacks if you want it to pop a bit more, but you just put dehaze to 100, huh?
1
1
u/UneditedReddited 2d ago
It looks good but what you should do is take a screenshot of the 'after' and then edit the screenshot and turn the saturation up to 100. And then do that 2-3 more times. And it'll really pop.
1
u/theparrotofdoom 2d ago
Oooooooof. Roll everything back 50% mate. This oneโs been In The oven too long.
You had a solid base exposure and solid scene. You donโt need to go so heavy on the settings. Your job is to make slight changes to draw the eye.
1
u/mummerlimn 2d ago
The before is far better, should lean more into that. The edited photo is..not good.
1
u/alexproshak 2d ago
You lost some details on the ground of the field, but you got a complete new feel
1
u/No_Bus_474 2d ago
Any expert, could you guys please do your magic and make it look better. The after image looks way too processed
The scenery is beautiful tho
1
u/Potential_Ad6288 2d ago
Am I the only one who thinks the poster has put the images in the wrong order and the first pic is the after?
1
u/gitarzan 2d ago
I prefer before. Much more realistic. After has too much of a Thomas Kincade look to it.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Alarmed-Intention-22 2d ago
My only comment is you have lost the foreground and fog in concentrating on the sky. Maybe a horizontal ND filter darkening as you hit the sky to bring it back.
The sky pops which is great, but the track leads to this.
1
u/ItemSweet7607 2d ago
I think both are good. Before the light is softer. After it looks like a movie scene. The light is deeper, more emotional.
1
1
u/East_Pie_3825 2d ago
Pros: This edit makes me feel like Iโve taken psilocybin. Cons: I havenโt actually eaten any psilocybin. Moral: Please send psilocybin.
1
1
u/MoistCumin 2d ago
You turned a sunrise into a sunset. In that sense, objectively I think it's not a good edit. The fog and the grey frost/dew on the grass are valuable details imo. But it's not a completely bad edit either, I just would've gone in a different direction if I were you.
1
1
1
u/TemporaryElk5202 2d ago
I prefer the before. By a lot.
The after looks like an amateur playing with lightroom for the first time. Not trying to be rude.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Odd-Heart7904 2d ago
both great but... the first looks like a classic foggy morning, the other looks like its at sunset... they are completely different pictures.
1
u/RennieAsh 2d ago
I've seen this road and the tree with the sun near it posted months earlier somewhere on Reddit
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Broer2612 2d ago
The first is way better. Less is best, ....and start with cropping - that can make the image a lot stronger.
1
1
1
u/Due_Cauliflower_7786 1d ago
ngl the after looks like it got hit with the clarity slider a few too many times. the fog in the before was actually doing something for the shot. i'd ease up on the contrast and let that mood breathe a little. not every photo needs to look like an hdr tutorial.
1
1
u/a_rogue_planet 1d ago
This was overcooked quite badly. Highlights and shadows present in the first image are lost and blown out after the deep fry. I've created sunrise images like the first one and they come out as beautiful prints. It's what the thing mostly looked like. Isn't good in that it doesn't look real or taken with a good camera.
1
u/sunplaysbass 1d ago
The before is a beautiful shot. The added contrast took it from sunrise with fog I understand to sunset with possible smoke. No offense. I think the colors are nice in the aftern especially the magenta but and highlighting that sun rays up top. The deeper orange zone is approaching โthatโs aiโ though. So much natural โdataโ in the lower contrast original to utilize.
1
u/Lowkeylowthreadcount 1d ago
Look like AI in the final edit. Thereโs a happy medium thatโs less contrasty that would accentuate the fog
1
u/canyonsinc 1d ago
Aside from the "cooked" comments I'd say it's kind of a weird shadow mask in the foreground, it doesn't make sense with the sun pointing right at it.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/SedentorySensor77 1d ago
I like the foggy unprocessed more. Sure a very little contrast and saturation, but youโve basically removed the atmosphere imo. Itโs a nice shot :)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/piddydafoo 23h ago
Crop out the telephone pole. The 2nd one is a little intense, but quite striking.
1
1
1
0
0
-3
u/Jenneon_ 2d ago
I disagree with the other comments, I like the edit. The colors are giving movie poster to me. The only thing I personally "miss" is a subject, it feels like a background to me
-1
0
3
2
1
u/srpntmage 1d ago
Way, way better before. You murdered a good photo.
One of the hardest things to learn in processing is when you have gone too far. You went too far, and then went a few extra miles.


274
u/FlecktarnSWE 2d ago
I don't say this often, but I really prefer the before this time.