11
u/fak1t Jul 08 '25 edited Jul 08 '25
I would suggest you to use BW and a diferent crop to intensive the sillouette/shadows.
8
Jul 08 '25
You need to light your subject. You can't just expect the light to appear.
I see a lot of this on this subreddit, but there seems to be some basic misunderstanding. You can't just expect the light to appear in post.
You need to paint your subject with light. Light the parts you want to show, either with natural or artificial lights. If using natural light...face them towards the light.
8
6
4
u/00365 Jul 08 '25
Both are just bad photos. Chuck 'em and start again. You've made the focus an empty wall while the woman is heavily shadowed. She's not a silhouette, she's just pushed out of light.
My eye is on the archway, and there isn't really any story or message here. Just an overshadowed woman holding cheerleader pom poms in an arch. It doesn't stir anything within me.
1
u/Fotomaker01 Jul 09 '25
All the attention goes to the funky blue wall in the foreground with the After. And, the poor girl lost the details she had in the Before.
5
4
u/AllMySmallThings Jul 08 '25 edited Jul 08 '25
If the after is the one with the person that is darker in shadows I like the before. You should mask the person and increase the exposure to show a bit more of them. At the moment they are very obscured.
2
2
u/Aurongel Jul 08 '25
Some fill light would’ve been preferable if you were going for a non-impressionist look that highlights the subject. With what you have here, the most straightforward option would be to lean into the silhouette itself and really emphasize the lighting contrast of the photo.
Making it black and white might help if you’re into that sorta look but I would start by brightening the region behind the subject and dimming the edges of the frame. The foreground brick wall for example (camera left) can be easily darkened to draw the viewer’s eye in toward the frame-within-a-frame that the subject occupies.
Good work, this is only my opinion but I hope it helps 🙂
1
1


68
u/SilentSpr Jul 08 '25
Is the back wall the actual subject and not the person posing in frame? If not, then the lighting change is just conflicting. You should be drawing attention to your subjects by lighting them better via masking and increasing exposure