r/porterrobinson • • Jun 30 '25

DISCUSSION An old Porter fan struggles to embrace the new...

0 Upvotes

This is my first time posting in this subreddit(I generally don't post in any subreddits. As an introvert, I tend to try and keep to myself online, and also have often disliked social media overall.)

So what better way to start off posting than with contentious takes and possible heavy convo about serious mental health issues? I am sure nothing will go wrong here! Its possible this will just get buried and nobody will see it and that's okay too. Its possible that I will get a few "Cool story bros" or an updoot or whatever. It is also possible that the community here will nuke me from orbit for posting cringe and, while I would prefer to not be destroyed for what I have to say; whatever will be, will be. But I hope people would at least try to hear me out here before making a decision.

TW: SUICIDAL IDEATION

I guess I will frontload the contention to get it out of the way. I didn't like 'Smile!', like at all. And I honestly feel bad about it because Porter's music was once a key feature in my life, for better or for worse. And it seems like a lot of people really like it and find it special. I want to like it. I want to be able to appreciate all of his music, because at one point in my life, I DID appreciate all of his music. I still think he is creative and talented and can't imagine yucking him, his music, or anyone's yum for that matter. But nothing on Smile hits my ear right, save for a few moments on Russian Roulette that are ultimately ruined for me by the Meta humor outro of the song. It just doesn't seem to resonate with me. It could be that the hyper pop influence is not my jam and maybe the audio clips take me out of it as well. The other part of this is that I have still not been able to get into Nurture. Now before I get dumped into the garbage shoot by everyone here; I don't have a negative opinion of Nurture! I simply haven't been able to listen to it yet for mental health reasons. I am working through a pretty rough portion of my life and have been for some years now, and I am not sure I am ready to really take that plunge just yet.

In theory, a lot of what people are saying about Smile really resonates with me. I appreciate artists reinventing their aesthetic or their sound, even if the end result is something I like less than their previous work. And I appreciate when an artist is authentic to how they feel as well as shows a willingness to explore uncomfortable feelings and topics and to do so in a thoughtful way, as well as embracing the vulnerability that comes with opening up about difficult struggles. Part of my dislike for social media overall is that it seems to rob a good number of people of empathy. It seems to make a lot of us more cynical and mean-spirited to the point where we see genuine vulnerability and heartfelt emotional expression as cringe. If you hate my opinion of Smile, that is totally valid and, I don't blame you as I am also not very fond of my opinion of Smile. But in the spirit of Smile, I have some vulnerability of my own to explain my perspective...

When Worlds first came out, it was a big thing for me. It was at a time where I was experiencing a lot of big moments for the first time in my life.(First time living on my own in a big city, first time truly falling in love, first long-term romantic relationship, first apartment together, first time forming a static friend group, etc.) It seemed like things were really moving in a positive direction for me. Since high school, I enjoyed EDM, but Worlds showed me something that most EDM had been missing for me: Heart & Soul. (Also as an aside: the use of sounfonts and Vocaloid felt pretty unique to mainstream EDM at the time. Also I got into writing music as a hobby in high school with 'Guitar Pro", tablature software with sheet music, and it used the same midi/soundfont instruments you hear throughout Worlds.) Needless to say I was blown away by Worlds. It felt paradigm altering in how big and emotional it was (even when it was using these simple MIDI instruments it was so emotionally moving.) It showed me possibilities with electronic music that I never thought I would hear as well as ignited a lifelong love of music production and sound design in me. Then after that, Madeon's album 'Adventure' released(I had familiarity with Madeon from his Pop Culture mashup.) Both albums felt like the next turn of where EDM was going to go and that, along with where my life was, felt positive and bright. Throughout my life I have struggled with my mental health, so to go from the consistent lows of what was my normal life to such soaring highs was a pleasant change of pace to say the least. I would listen to both albums all the way through regularly and often paired them together like a great food/wine pairing. I considered Adventure to be more technical in its execution; but Worlds was my sentimental fave. I went to the Worlds tour and even saw Porter's mini Worlds tours when he would perform at EDM festivals in my city(Once even going just for him). I got my first love into both Madeon & Porter as well and she loved them both as much as I did. We shared that love as a big part of our relationship(I even went with her when she got a tattoo of Porter's iconic logo to remind her of us). So, naturally, we both were very excited when it was teased that they were collabing together as we both loved the story of their friendship together about as much as we loved their music. We attended the Shelter tour together, which is still to this day, the most amazing live performance I have ever experienced and, for years after, if I put on the final part of that tour on Youtube or Soundcloud, I would cry when Hugo sung the Shelter reprise. Especially as it transitions into Language with "I'll Be Okay" it is just so beautiful and a core memory. I still have the Shelter tour shirt and even the shirt featuring Rin that came out when Shelter dropped(Will post pictures of them if anyone wants.) I was so excited to see the seismic shift in EDM and what that possibly meant for the genre as well as music overall. Despite everything happening in the world at the time, I felt like there was a lot to be positive about overall and even when I didn't feel so positive, I always had our love, the music, and the world we built together.

This is where it gets rough. My first love had been going through some major personal life events that I will not be going into detail about here. It seemed to have brought us together as I supported her the best I could throughout those events and the aftermath of them. During that time, we seemed to have grown closer as a result of our love and support. Then, in 2018, things got rough for me in return. My parents went through a gray divorce. Surprisingly, even though I was an adult, it hit me harder than I thought it would. After that, pretty much the remainder of the 10 worst moments of my life happened in a fairly short period of time(2019-2022). The one that hurt the most happening in 2019: I lost that first major relationship with my first love in a twist of betrayal that blindsided me and ultimately ended not just our relationship, but our friendship as well. It left me feeling stunned initially, followed by feeling broken, hopeless and grief-stricken. My depression had been gaining ground on me the prior couple of years and now it took a dark turn. I started thinking about not living anymore. I started contemplating how I might carry that out. Fortunately, after a short period of time, I started to realize the path I was starting down and that it was even taking up my thoughts more than the thoughts about the love I had lost. I also remember being told by someone close to me that "suicide doesn't end the pain, it just creates more of it to go around, especially with those closest to you." I ended up calling a suicide hotline one morning at 2am and after that, I attempted to move in a more positive/healthy direction. Unfortunately that would prove to be short-lived as the breakup was the start of a domino effect of hardships in my life. It was right around that time that everything with COVID-19 happened. I then proceeded to have the remainder of the 10 worst events of my life hit me over the next 3 years. They happened in rapid succession and it was difficult to for me to cope with all of the loss I suffered. Its difficult to even fully express how it felt for life to deal repeated back-to-back blows without a chance to recover let alone even begin to process as it all piled up. So when Porter teased the singles from his upcoming Nurture album, desperate for some return to normalcy and a reprieve from the suffering that seemed to just keep coming, I tried listening to them and I just broke down when I did. It did not help me in those moments due to all of the pain that I was experiencing. To be clear: I didn't and still don't put that on him. This was tied to my feelings of my life and my relationship. Of course, I would later find out the story behind his departure from his previous style due to the mental health struggles he was going through. Regardless, I couldn't find solace in it anymore. I couldn't find comfort in any of it. It felt like everything I loved had disappeared from my life and that I was helpless to stop it. So I locked it away, along with the other music that, over the years, had meant so much to me. Eventually I ended up moving out of state and across the country as all of my reasons for remaining were gone and I was left with little more than painful reminders of the better timeline of my life that was never to be. I have now been through about 5 years of therapy, and a big realization for me was that I didn't actually want to die. I just didnt want life to carry on as it was. I have since been attempting slowly recover my love of the music that once meant so much to me as well as find new love. I still can't listen to it all the way I used to(it comes in spurts and waves), and I am not ready yet for Nurture(I still havent been able to listen to Hollowheart either). Maybe I am just not ready for Smile as well. It just feels like the opposite of everything I hoped the future would be, everything I saw for my life. This life often has felt that way since 2016 with increasing frequency. I am sure a lot of people can relate to the world feeling like it wasn't what they hoped before things went from a Nightmare to living in Hell. Especially during that time frame. For those who found and continue to find Porter's music to be a source of comfort and joy in trying times, I am truly happy for you to have that, whatever it may mean to you. I too hope I can some day enjoy all that I used to and more. And maybe even find love again. Maybe some day that love and the music will surround me, and give life to a world that's our own once more.

TL;DR - I didn't like Smile, and haven't been able to get into Nurture due to years of grief and hardships. I loved Worlds and the time it came out in my life. I went through some truly bad times that left me broken and disconnected from a big part of my life and now I am slowly healing and making my way back to a place where I can get into Nurture and maybe even grow to appreciate Smile(maybe even love it?) as well as move forward in a more positive direction.

If you read all of this I appreciate it. Just know that it is not easy being open on the internet(Vulnerability?! In THIS Economy?!) Feel free to share your opinion, thoughts, or whatever you care to say. Make a stupid joke even...Just please PLEASE don't get into a flame war over any of Porter's music catalog. I didnt make this post only for people to rage and be toxic with me or one another. Life is brief and far too short to waste any amount of it hating on something we all love. Something this special should unite us, not drive us apart.

If this was a massive wall of text that you couldn't be bothered to read, that's fair. But I want to be able to make connections again with people over an artist that has made an indelible mark on my life and made me smile. Even if this doesn't accomplish that. Its a still a first big step. After all, what I have learned from people who love Smile! Is that: Sometimes in life, you have to take a risk and be vulnerable, even if it is not everyone's cup of tea.

Cheers, peace, and love.


r/porterrobinson • • Apr 29 '24

FEELS I'm... feeling conflicted about SMILE :D

1 Upvotes

I want to preface this by saying I’ve really enjoyed Cheerleader and Knock Yourself Out. They’re bombastic, infused with signature Porter hooks and melodies, and they’re really easy to listen to. He’s moved into a completely different space and killed it, once again proving his phenomenal talent as a musician. I’m also for the artistic direction Porter has headed in; Nurture was an introspective reflection on happiness and fulfilment, whereas SMILE is exploring the external aspects of Porter’s success. It feels like a very natural progression, and very Porter-esque for him to satirize with a character who can’t brush his teeth without the help of his team. I get it, and I like it

But that’s where the conflict comes in, because this version of Porter’s art feels so egregiously and aggressively pitted against the beautiful and poignant vulnerability he created with Nurture. I know that such a striking change is normal for Porter, and I don’t doubt that that this is an artistic and worthy calling he feels compelled to explore. But I don’t think anybody who was a pre-Worlds fan was actively offended by Worlds, and any pre-Nurture fans were actively offended by Nurture; they’re different, but not aggressively so. But now, we’ve gone from such beauty and honesty with ‘everything we need is already here’ to ‘Bitch I’m Taylor Swift’, and I can’t finish this sentence because the contrast speaks for itself

I imagine a lot of people are reading this are thinking ‘this person is way too emotionally invested and is exactly who Porter is talking about in Knock Yourself Out’, and you’re correct. I realize the deeeeep irony of everything I’m saying days after KYO’s release, and that Porter is doing absolutely nothing wrong and everything I’m feeling are my issues. But I’m one of the many, many people who owes so much to Nurture and Porter’s art. I will not say Nurture saved my life because I did that, but fuck, it was pivotal to the healing I’ve done, and it means so much to me. After reading this in a recent interview with Porter, I can’t help but feel lied to and kinda betrayed, like this thing that you took so much comfort from “wasn’t real”. And that hurts.

I am genuinely still looking forward to the album, and I trust Porter and his magnificent artistry, even if it’s taking shape in a way that is difficult to adjust to. But that’s where I’m at right now, because I’m struggling with that adjustment


r/porterrobinson • • Aug 22 '24

DISCUSSION Year of the Cup is the weakest song on the album

0 Upvotes

complete full knee innocent swim bike treatment plate spark mysterious

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact


r/porterrobinson • • Apr 10 '25

DISCUSSION Ranking the songs from Nurture and Smile! :D

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I don’t really like worlds so I didn’t rank it. Feel free to roast me


r/porterrobinson • • Mar 26 '24

DISCUSSION I'm beginning to hate Porter Robinson

0 Upvotes

Cheerleader has been out for like a week now. It’s so damn catchy. It’s a well written and produced song all around.

Separating the art from the artist, I’ve been a huge fan of his music since Spitfire, including Virtual Self. I didn’t really care to learn about who he is as a person for much of this obsession—since his instrumental music has historically done a lot of the talking. Going against the traditional bounds of EDM, I love his unique emphasis on atmosphere, Japanese-influenced aesthetic, and meticulous approach to production/composition on Worlds. During the pandemic, Nurture was a great, refreshing comeback record given the state of the world and his own struggles. Connecting over a general fascination for video games, nature, movies, TV shows and the creative process—these were all showcased through his instrumentals and stage visuals on both album cycles. After watching him perform live on his Nurture tour, I cannot think of another artist that blends their own songs in such a mellifluous way while still incorporating live instruments and making it feel like a concert instead of a dynamic-less rave.

But something I’ve picked up on throughout his interviews and how he presents himself through his music after the release of Nurture—this man is clearly full of himself. It seems like he wants to be a pop star so badly. The fact that him and his team used a clickbaity video just to announce that he finished his album is laughable. Like dude, just use the countdown to drop the first single and announce an upcoming album like normal bands/artists. As music lovers, we all know how many bands/artists love to tell media outlets that their music is “finished” well before it hits streaming services.

Regarding Cheerleader’s lyrics: ok, we get it dude, poor you for having a successful music career with obsessive parasocial fans. This whole “but I need her [the fanbase]” line is pretty cringey IMO. Like man, you have a seemingly very healthy relationship with your wife and family. You likely now have enough money to last you for the rest of your life. You’ve been showered with validation since you were a teenager. I am sure you are more than strong enough to have your own personal identity and happiness within your inner circle outside of your music career.

I think the video complements the song well, clearly taking influence from 2000s pop-punk/emo vibes. But, we get it Porter, you can play guitar now. It’s okay the show some love for the synths/keys— you know, the thing you mastered long ago that’s responsible for the catchy melody that makes the tune shine. At least play an actual acoustic guitar during the acoustic part for the love of god. There’s a clear shift from his persona compared to the Nurture videos—the make-up, boisterous hairstyle, direct eye contact with the camera—the man has low-key developed a new obsession over his appearance.

In his interview with Anthony Fantano, he quickly shifts from mentioning lyrical themes of mindfulness to unfullfilment from praise as an artist before landing with the statement “I hate the fact at any given moment I can look on Twitter and someone’s saying something about me.” How can he detest the praise yet continue to bathe in it over the last album cycle and in the new song? It's contradictory.

You're not The Beatles. At the end of the day you are your own person and you should make music for yourself. Any musicians out there reading this, please don’t base your identity around the loud minorities of the Internet and learn to not care so much about what others think. Stay humble out there.

TLDR: I'm autistic and got my dick stuck in the ceiling fan after listening to Cheerleader. I hate when DJs talk during their sets.


r/porterrobinson • • Mar 15 '24

DISCUSSION Unpopular opinion: I'm not vibing with the new snippet, but that's fine too

0 Upvotes

Don't get me wrong, the full song hasn't even released yet, but from all the hype I've seen surrounding the snippet I'm starting to get kinda worried that it might just not be the thing for me. I don't want this to be taken dramatically or to sound like the entitled fan Porter is probably talking about in the lyrics, but I didn't feel ready to say goodbye to Nurture so I hoped for a more natural departure from the style.

I've been listening to Porter's music since Language so I expected to feel at least some kind of nostalgia from the 2012-2013 throwback, but musically and aesthetically the new project feels too incoherent for my taste, maybe there's something I'm missing that I'll understand better when the full album releases, or perhaps it will just grow on me with time. The thing I liked the most about this release process was the original YouTube video, it set a very surreal and funny tone. The background music he used in there was the best thing we've heard so far but I'm not sure if it was teasing anything in particular given how chill and layed back it sounded.

I feel like this often tends to happen with the aesthetic revivals commonly seen on TikTok, usually from people that only have an indirect experience of various Internet eras, but I thought that in this case it would have been different coming from Porter. He's the same guy who put a lot of interest and research into authentic production techniquesfor stuff like Virtual Self. I wouldn't even mind if he leaned more into his 2008 Ekowraith side, like the joke FL studio tutorial for the new single or his own remix of Humansongs.

I don't particularly appreciate the influence from Wavedash either, their style is definitely unique and they have put out some bangers on WFT, but I feel like some of their tracks can be a little more of a miss... Including Dummo Loop and the Ekowraith collab, they're missing a certain flow in order to sound intentionally stuttery.

What I'm basically looking for is a way to rationalize my initial impression in order to feel a little more positively about it, but even if I won't that's also fine! I guess this initially happened with Nurture too as the singles he decides to put out are rarely the highlight of his albums for someone that appreciates his more instrumental stuff. In any case, I'm extremely happy for anything that Porter will ever put out and I'm glad he's genuinely expressing himself, even if it won't always be my cup of tea!


r/porterrobinson • • Aug 29 '24

DISCUSSION what song & what part?

Post image
1 Upvotes

for me, first thing that came to mind's "Thaw your hands now, put color in your cheeks" from Unfold 💚


r/porterrobinson • • Aug 23 '17

DISCUSSION Porter Robinson is the best EDM producer......Period

8 Upvotes

Porter Robinson is my favorite artist of all time and here is why. In the October of 2016 (when i was 14) i went to New Orleans Voodoo festival. I didn't listen to EDM that much at the time. One night i had no one particular to go and see so i went to Porters stage. I waited for the music to start having no idea who was about to play or what kind of music was on this stage. He came on stage and started. I was instantly hooked, the beats and the rhythm totally memorized me. I couldn't stop jumping up and down or waving my arms and hands to the music.It was almost like i could feel the energy in the crowd. I later found out that the artist who was supposed to be at that stage was canceled so the luck of me coming to a random stage for an artist who was filling in was amazing. After i left the festival Myself as a person changed, I had a completely new look on everything. To this day whenever i listen to Porter i get goosebumps all over me.


r/porterrobinson • • Sep 22 '21

DISCUSSION Unpopular opinion about second sky

3 Upvotes

Jai wolfs set wasn’t very good.


r/porterrobinson • • Jan 21 '25

DISCUSSION Porter Robinson’s brother is a rapist

0 Upvotes

I am sending this out to this subreddit to ask what to do. My girl’s friends are close friends with Porter Robinson and have been hit up by multiple girls telling them that Porter Robinson’s brother nick is a rapist and has assaulted them. They decided not to do anything just to KEEP THE PEACE within the friend group. And it’s sad that they have not brought this out in to the public. The victims want to protect any future victims of his brother and my girl’s friends did NOTHING.

I don’t care that I’m not close with them but I can just let it slip by. HE NEEDS TO BE REPREHENDED.

Just wanted to bring this out as a PSA, even though this might not get to anyone or even be shadow banned by reddit but I can’t keep being silent.


r/porterrobinson • • Feb 17 '24

NEW MUSIC Y'all heard of Air2Earth, aka, one of Porters most recent side projects/alias?

0 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LfDj-_tdzUw

Listen to this ID; amazing. Anyways, Air2Earth shows have been circulating around a bit, there’s one on ITunes, and yea. Happy listening. Peace.


r/porterrobinson • • Jan 16 '23

FUNNY I got porter played at a furry convention.

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/porterrobinson • • Apr 29 '21

DISCUSSION I am a huge porter fan, but this album ain’t it

1 Upvotes

Really disappointed. Something comforting & get your wish are great tracks, but everything else is so mediocre that I find myself moving on already.

I know this is destined to be downvoted into oblivion, but I am curious if anyone feels the same.

I saw porter at ezoo NY in 2018 and had a mind blown experience. Just a bit bummed about how this one turned our


r/porterrobinson • • Apr 23 '24

DISCUSSION porter robinson foreshadowing the taylor swift reference on one of his previous dj sets?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/porterrobinson • • Aug 28 '26

ART Happy release day :D

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/porterrobinson • • Sep 26 '24

FUNNY The world is not ready for this collab.

Thumbnail
x.com
0 Upvotes

r/porterrobinson • • Jul 28 '24

DISCUSSION why do so many people hate the new album?

0 Upvotes

it's so sad to see how much hate comments he's getting. you guys know that he's allowed to make any sort of music he wants, not every album is gonna sound the same. he's experimenting and trying new things and everyone just is calling his album mid and it's so sad since he worked so hard to get it released just for some people to say it's bad.


r/porterrobinson • • Jul 24 '25

FEELS I feel a little sorry for ‘Unfold’

0 Upvotes

Unfold is an absolutely beautiful song, capturing the duality of Nurture’s light and shade. I could very well envisage this being Nurture’s closer — even though the ending would feel different — due to its maturity and sense of perspective

But whenever I’m listening to Nurture, I can’t help but feel a little sorry for it because it gets completely overshadowed by Trying To Feel Alive. Every time Blossom finishes, I know Trying To Feel Alive is just around the corner and I end up skipping Unfold just to get there faster 😅 It may be because Trying To Feel Alive is just sublime and the perfect ending to Nurture, so it makes Unfold feel a little lesser than when listened to sequentially instead of independently? I think the two songs are thematically similar, but Trying To Feel Alive embodies the perspective, growth and maturity in a ‘better’ and more profound way


r/porterrobinson • • 11d ago

OPINION Does anyone else think there are quite a few underwhelming tracks on SMILE! :D plus+

22 Upvotes

While I like SMILE! :D, I find a lot of the tracks on this remix album lacklustre. The remixes for Perfect Pinterest Garden, Year of the Cup, and Is there really no Happiness (Frost Children) are great. However, songs like the first Knock Yourself Out, first Cheerleader, first Easier to Love You, and a few others just feel like uncreative, sped-up versions of the original songs with a different beat.


r/porterrobinson • • May 18 '25

DISCUSSION Black Fans of Porter

1 Upvotes

Went to the Chicago Concert last night (WAY better energy than the Nashville one last year), but I was disappointed to still see the low number of African American fans even in a bigger and more diverse city like Chicago. What are the demographics like throughout the fanbase as a whole?


r/porterrobinson • • Nov 18 '23

OPINION Would you guys go to my concert lineup?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/porterrobinson • • May 11 '25

DISCUSSION Is it just me or does Unison sound like something you'd hear in a Roblox tycoon game? Because that was what I thought when I first heard it

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/porterrobinson • • Aug 05 '24

FEELS ive seen a lot of people ranking the songs for each of the albums, so i did it too. (BIAS WARNING) Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/porterrobinson • • Jan 30 '25

DISCUSSION Add “up my ass” to the last Porter song you listened to

Post image
0 Upvotes