TLDR
My podcast just passed 400,000 downloads. (it's called This Was The Scene if you want to verify it's real)
That’s roughly 100,000 every two years. No viral moment. Just one episode a week, over and over.
Day one: 98 downloads
Interviews run 1.5 to 2 hours. Editing them takes 4 to 5 hours
I niched down it pretty far down (Late 90s/Early 2000s punk scene)
Best interviews are where you let the guest talk without interupting them with a thousand "Yeah"s every 5 seconds
Recording is the easy part
THE LONG READ
(Technically it crossed on September 10th, but I was busy editing the next episode so I’m just now telling you.)
Here’s how I went from wanting to do a 2-3 hour documentary about the Late 90s Jersey scene to putting out 450+ hours of content.
The documentary I didn’t want to “Kickstart”
I’ve always wanted to make a documentary about the late 90s/early 2000s New Jersey punk scene. That’s the scene I grew up and toured in with my band Lanemeyer. Then I did the math and figured these would be the things that would suck to purchase: cameras, gear, travel, a bunch of interviews. I’d have to raise about $20k. Yeah, no.
In 2018 I learned the technical side of podcasting because of the marketing podcast I did for drive80. I quickly got bored of doing it cause the topic sucked but then I thought of one that didn’t suck. And that would be the late 90s punk scene.
So I posted in the NJPP Facebook group and asked if anyone would listen to a podcast about that scene. About 40 people said yes. I took that as my validation for putting some time into this thing. I opened a text doc, made a list of 10 people to reach out to, and recorded 10 episodes. Somewhere around episode 10 I realized I had something.
I launched on March 22, 2018.
Day one: 98 downloads. More than double the people who said they’d listen. #winning
The numbers
That’s roughly 100,000 every two years. No viral moment. Just one episode a week, over and over.
Want to start a podcast? Here’s what I put into each episode
Find the guest. This is a mix of everything. I usually have give myself some space to think of bands, labels, producers, comps, DVDs, etc from back in the day and then check instagram to see if I can somehow contact them.
Reach out. I DM them on Instagram. Then I find an old post of theirs and leave a comment saying I just sent a message. That bumps my DM to the top of the pile. (Free pro tip. You welcome.)
Record it. I used Skype for years because it was free. Skype shut down, so now it’s Zoom at $16 a month. Every interview gets split into 2 audio tracks and saved in a couple of places so I never lose one.
Make the teaser. The week of I update my Photoshop templates for the Instagram and YouTube graphics, pull a clip from the full interview before I edit it, and drop it into my After Effects teaser template. That goes out on all my socials (ie. Instagram, Linkedin, Twitter, Facebook)
Edit. Interviews run 1.5 to 2 hours. Editing them takes 4 to 5 hours. After 8 years I can spot filler words and repeats just by looking at the waveform.
Build the episode. I use Adobe Premiere for this: The order of the audio goes... 24-second intro clip, my intro song which is from my old band Arcade Academy because I didn’t want to run into licensing issues, my personal intro to the episode which I record the day before (in case there’s news), audio clip to transition into the full episode, an ad read for my drive80 services that I put about 30 minutes into the episode, and then end it with the ending of the opening song which again is mine
Publish. Thursday I upload to Libsyn with show notes and tags, scheduled for 12am Friday so it has time to hit every app.
Launch day. Open all the tabs (Youtube, my website, Twitter, Facebook, Linkedin) swap the main video on YouTube to the current episode, turn on monetization (it’s not a lot, but it’s something), update the show’s episode page on my website, add the landing page to my LINKS page which I host on my website, AND THEN post the 1080x1080 show graphic on all the socials.
This is the repeatable process every week that I launch an episode.
I had to take a few breaks over the past 8.5 years
I’ve burned out a few times. The longest break was about 7 months in 2023.
However, during those 7 months I didn’t post a single new episode, and the show still pulled about 55 downloads a day. That’s almost 12,000 downloads while I didn’t do jack.
When I finally came back with HRVRD in November 2023, the show had its biggest day in about 9 months: 682 downloads.
Every time I take a break I grab 1 or 5 IPAs, open Instagram and just start messaging people to see if they’ll come on. Once that starts I get that fire going and it’s off to the races.
I despise posts with “What ____ life lesson taught me” Soooo, here’s what you COULD take away from all these words
Niche down as far as possible. Late 90s/early 2000s New Jersey punk is about as niche as it gets. Some people say “I’d never listen to that.” The ones who do binge it for weeks and months to catch up.
Shut up and listen. This is probably the best advice I can give to anyone that wants to interview people. Ask the question and let your guest talk. Don’t interrupt. Your guest is the show, not you.
Kill your filler words. Hearing yourself back for hours makes you pick your words better in an interview and in real life.
Stop saying “yeah” after every sentence. It’s annoying on a podcast and it’s annoying it makes me want to punch things.
Respect the time. If you want to start a podcast, go for it. Just know the recording is the easy part.
Guests become friends. A bunch of people I interviewed are now people I message all the time. That part I didn’t see coming.
Got podcast questions? Drop them in the comments.